Zohran Mamdani

Meh. Distinction without meaning here. They're active within the Democratic party, and have the fairly clearly stated intent to drive positions and shift the entire Dem platform to their views.

MAGA also isn't a party, but that doesn't stop anyone at all from conflating them with the entirety of the Republican party.
The difference is that MAGA took control of the Republican party under Trump.

The same isn't the case for the DSA.
 
The point bears repeating: The two people in this thread wringing their hands over the possible takeover of the Democratic Party by the DSA (for reference, next year there will be a total of 8 DSA members in the House out of 255+ Democrats and 0 DSA members in the Senate), have little or nothing to say about the total MAGA takeover of the Republican Party that is currently destroying the country.
 
What difference does it make that the DSA wants to replace the Democratic Party? These are just labels. Policy positions vary from person to person and from time to time.

There was a time the Republican party was fiscally conservative and for small businesses. MAGA has turned it into culture wars, crony capitalism, hedge funds, investment banks and tech billionaires.
 
Seems to be updated about as frequently as it was. They just moved the news and statements sections off the main page, for whatever reason.

Oh, good. I was wondering what happened, why I could find anything.

It turns out that all I needed to do is delete the history catch in my browser and that got everything working again.
 
Serious question: Why should anyone take seriously a person who spends more time worrying about what DSA might do than what MAGA is currently doing?
A person can hold two thoughts at once. I can think that MAGA is bad and the DSA is bad. MAGA is worse now because they have more power. If the DSA gets power and MAGA loses power, the DSA will be worse than MAGA.

Should anyone takes some seriously who can't understand that two things can both be true?
 
Meh. Distinction without meaning here. They're active within the Democratic party, and have the fairly clearly stated intent to drive positions and shift the entire Dem platform to their views.
No, it's a meaningful distinction. The DSA candidates in New York don't run against Republicans, they run against moderate/establishment Democrats.

MAGA also isn't a party, but that doesn't stop anyone at all from conflating them with the entirety of the Republican party.
Unless I do that (and I don't), this is immaterial.

You're giving yourself license to treat the DSA as monolithic while complaining that people treat political organizations as monolithic. It's just incoherent. You're trying to socialize error, when you should instead be attempting to eliminate it.
 
Last edited:
A person can hold two thoughts at once. I can think that MAGA is bad and the DSA is bad. MAGA is worse now because they have more power. If the DSA gets power and MAGA loses power, the DSA will be worse than MAGA.

Should anyone takes some seriously who can't understand that two things can both be true?
Why... would DSA be worse?
 
ahhell would not be able to distinguish an early Trump rally speech to the nascent MAGA community from one from Bernie Sanders -
what MAGA movement claims is its agenda is almost entirely in line with a more socialist agenda:
- restricting the power of Big Business, forcing them to sell shares to the government
- dictating prices on drugs, electricity, insurance premiums
- demanding that companies reduce their commitments overseas and bring jobs back to the US
- government check for everyone
- more populist influence in Washington, fight Special Interests; Trump also praises Unions (granted, if they support him)
- no avoidable wars

etc.

The only difference is that DSA wants all that for All Americans, not just those that fit the desired ethnicity.
 
Last edited:
ahhell would not be able to distinguish an early Trump rally speech to the nascent MAGA community from one from Bernie Sanders -
what MAGA movement claims is its agenda is almost entirely in line with a more socialist agenda:
- restricting the power of Big Business, forcing them to sell shares to the government
- dictating prices on drugs, electricity, insurance premiums
- demanding that companies reduce their commitments overseas and bring jobs back to the US
- government check for everyone
- more populist influence in Washington, fight Special Interests; Trump also praises Unions (granted, if they support him)
- no avoidable wars

etc.

The only difference is that DSA wants all that for All Americans, not just those that fit the desired ethnicity.
I don't object much to any of that the programs of the DSA and MAGA aren't that different. I'm sure there will be less obvious corruption if the DSA actually gain significant power. The goals are bad necessarily but the means needed to get there are that the goals will not be achieved by those means.

The DSA National Political Committee, as near to an national authority as anything they have is about have selfdescribed Marxists. Aside from the long history of failure that marxists governments have, there is also the long history of death, mostly by famine but also deliberate murder.

The DSA would be worse
if they have power and MAGA doesn't.
MAGA has power so they are worse. MAGA intent is mostly worse but the results will mostly be the same. More poverty and more authoritarian government. The good thing is that having so many Marxists among them, they'll all turn on each other at some point.

ETA: I will also say that now, MAGA is back on its heals, Trump can do a lot of damage in the next two years, but MAGA is pretty much done. I expect a lot of MAGA voters will start voting for DSA and DSA adjacent candidates. The DSA seems to be gaining ground, which I find concerning.
 
Last edited:
A person can hold two thoughts at once. I can think that MAGA is bad and the DSA is bad. MAGA is worse now because they have more power. If the DSA gets power and MAGA loses power, the DSA will be worse than MAGA.

Should anyone takes some seriously who can't understand that two things can both be true?

If you were criticizing the MAGA cabal that runs this county for the overwhelming amount of damage they have done proportional to the amount of hand-wringing you have done in this thread about a tiny faction of the Democratic Party that has no real power, you might have a point.

Sorry, but this "Sure Trump and MAGA are bad, but let me tell you about the left..." bothsides horse ◊◊◊◊ is beyond tired.
 
Last edited:
I don't object much to any of that the programs of the DSA and MAGA aren't that different. I'm sure there will be less obvious corruption if the DSA actually gain significant power. The goals are bad necessarily but the means needed to get there are that the goals will not be achieved by those means.

The DSA National Political Committee, as near to an national authority as anything they have is about have selfdescribed Marxists. Aside from the long history of failure that marxists governments have, there is also the long history of death, mostly by famine but also deliberate murder.

The DSA would be worse
if they have power and MAGA doesn't.
MAGA has power so they are worse. MAGA intent is mostly worse but the results will mostly be the same. More poverty and more authoritarian government. The good thing is that having so many Marxists among them, they'll all turn on each other at some point.

ETA: I will also say that now, MAGA is back on its heals, Trump can do a lot of damage in the next two years, but MAGA is pretty much done. I expect a lot of MAGA voters will start voting for DSA and DSA adjacent candidates. The DSA seems to be gaining ground, which I find concerning.

In which we gloss over how absolutely disastrous Republicans have been and currently are for this country and move directly to an imagined future in which Democrats will be worse.
 
What difference does it make that the DSA wants to replace the Democratic Party? These are just labels. Policy positions vary from person to person and from time to time.

There was a time the Republican party was fiscally conservative and for small businesses. MAGA has turned it into culture wars, crony capitalism, hedge funds, investment banks and tech billionaires.
Would consider comparing and contrasting your two paragraphs above? And perhaps consider reviewing my prior post regarding bias?
 
No, it's a meaningful distinction.
Why is it a meaningful distinction that DSA isn't technically a party?
The DSA candidates in New York don't run against Republicans, they run against moderate/establishment Democrats.
Well... other than the ones that ran against Republicans I guess? And the ones from other states who won seats?
Unless I do that (and I don't), this is immaterial.

You're giving yourself license to treat the DSA as monolithic while complaining that people treat political organizations as monolithic. It's just incoherent. You're trying to socialize error, when you should instead be attempting to eliminate it.
I think it's as reasonable of me to have issues with the DSA program as it is for all of us to have issues with Project 2025. I have issues with the policies, and with the people pushing those policies.

What I haven't done is to decide that ALL democrats are aspiring communists because SOME of them are DSA. I am concerned about the influence that DSA will have within the Democratic party.

It's crazy, I know, but I continue to be opposed to communism and all of the efforts to usher in communism by a different name. Consistency is just so inconvenient.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom