ZEITGEIST, The Movie

Couldn't this divine or causal plane have been perceived to be the stars though? I mean, with no knowledge of astronomy as we think of it, the stars must have been a pretty awe inspiring sight. I could even go out on a limb and say the stars combined with whatever drugs these people were doing might have even been so awe inspiring as to cause the creation of a mythos such as this...who knows though, right? Personally, after reading about, and personally experiencing some of the 'mystery' regarding psychonautical affairs I would definitely say that some of that influenced the creation of mythos...but that just speculation from a biased POV.

Well, the ancients certainly figured astrology was important, I've no doubt. The seven planets they counted were understood to have a powerful influence on man's psyche, and the astrological signs also. But this isn't really the same as a causal archetype, a la the Bible's "Ha-Shamaim" [Gen 1:1]. The latter is more a realm of divine ideation from which our world constantly descends. Objects start out as ideas in the divine mind, and passing through a series of formative layers, eventually have the appearance of being solid. The stars and planets also.

I mean, there are crossovers, for sure, but the way Andrew portrayed things in this video I would consider quite biased, and unlikely to be representative of either an ancient or modern metaphysical interpretation of the Adam and Eve story. Perhaps he just sees everything as a conspiracy, maybe it's the only filter he can process information with. I don't know.

I think the drug links are overplayed a bit too. I've no doubt that people took stuff, but I have to say I find it a little patronising to be viewing these guys as staring in wonder at the stars while off their heads and creating some whole cosmology. Not to lay some trip on you! People like Socrates and Hermes Trismegistos were a long way ahead of where we are now in understanding our own subjective inner realm. A lot of awareness has been lost. I don't really want to start banging on about objectivity/subjectivity again but it does come back to this. If you don't appreciate the assumptions that the objective mindset is based upon, it's very very hard to grasp just what had been achieved 2000 years ago. People put it down to drugs or whatever, it's natural. But drugs don't do so much.

Nick
 
This film has now appeared in the 'Off Topic' forum of the Orbiter spaceflight simulator group in a thread entitled Looking at the world from a different perspective - A must see film

The person who posted the link used JAQ as his defense.

Yes, it's getting everywhere. People like the idea. I don't know what the Google Video counter is now as they don't seem to have it on the site anymore, but it's usually Top 3, and was getting a million plus views a month and rising last time I saw.

Nick
 
The thing is that it's unclear how widespread various recreational or religious drug use actually was, unless you take the word of Allegro. Unfortunately for Allegro, his theories have been much-repeated but not reproduced with independent study. It's too bad Jan and Andrew aren't endeavoring to try to bring that back through a peer-review, as I'd be interested (read: amused) to hear how it turns out.

Well, we have a idea at least:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entheogen#Entheogen-using_cultures

Prepare to be amused:
www.egodeath.com

Jan collaborates with the author of this site, and likes to name drop him quite a bit around the GM forum.

I think the drug links are overplayed a bit too. I've no doubt that people took stuff, but I have to say I find it a little patronising to be viewing these guys as staring in wonder at the stars while off their heads and creating some whole cosmology. Not to lay some trip on you!

Don't worry, there is no trip to be laid. However, how is that patronizing? I would say that it's hardly over played considering it is a fringe topic at best. In anycase, its all speculation about where idea's come from and how they perpetuate and there really is no way to prove or disprove much of anything. My statement is an oversimplification for clarity I suppose. There obviously are religous/philosophical idea's that have no root in entheogens, perhaps I should have demarcated and said 'peak experiences' which do bear a remarkable similarity across cultures.

so yeah...like...back to zeitgeist.

The relevance of ptolemaic astrology to Christian symbolism, though, is ambiguous at best, and otherwise superficial. Its intention was to draw as many systems into a unified model, which explains its logenvity... not unlike the Catholic Church, which is most likely why so many conspiracy theorists are so eager to link the two as related, considering the lasting success both had in the long run.

So, if I get you right...Ptolemy attempted to attach astrology to everything, and that is why we have a bunch of Christian symbolistic references tied to astrology like jesus pictured in a zodiac etc?
 
Last edited:
GreNME said:
The thing is that it's unclear how widespread various recreational or religious drug use actually was, unless you take the word of Allegro. Unfortunately for Allegro, his theories have been much-repeated but not reproduced with independent study. It's too bad Jan and Andrew aren't endeavoring to try to bring that back through a peer-review, as I'd be interested (read: amused) to hear how it turns out.
Well, we have a idea at least:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entheogen#Entheogen-using_cultures

Prepare to be amused:
www.egodeath.com

Jan collaborates with the author of this site, and likes to name drop him quite a bit around the GM forum.

Well, this is getting a bit off-topic and into the realm of Jan Irvin's repeating of Allegro, but the biggest fault I tend to find is not that there are plenty of examples of cultures using various drugs-- heck, I don't think there is a single one in all of human history that hasn't-- it is the causative manner in which Irvin (and his much-cited Allegro) tend to portray it. If nothing else, the Marsh Chapel experiment is a good example of how it doesn't take an actual working psychoactive to promote religious experiences (even the people who took the placebo reported allegedly 'profound' experiences). I know that experiment is often cited by Leary apologists as a success, but the only successful part of it is that the actual psychoactive drug used lasted longer than the placebo, whose physical effects wore off quickly.

Basically, on this topic, the most argument you're going to get from me is that Jan and others who argue similarly are putting the horse before the cart regarding the mechanism of the drug use, and nine times out of ten this type of argument is basically taking the form of a well-spoken and researched 'stoner apologetics' (as I call it). I don't see anything inherently evil, bad, or wrong about the intention, but the line of logic being purported (much like many religious apologetics) simply doesn't withstand scrutiny unless the scrutinizer actually wants it to. Though I hate over-reducing it, I usually come to the conclusion that it's a basic "preaching to the choir" line of thinking.

(In other words, I'm not trying to insult your average pot-smoker or shroom-taker who finds the topic interesting. I'm simply pointing out that the topic has consistently in scholarly circles come to the consenus that drug use is simply one of many mechanisms of religious cultures, not a religious originator nor necessarily a critical necessity for the 'true believer' in the religion)

Don't worry, there is no trip to be laid. However, how is that patronizing? I would say that it's hardly over played considering it is a fringe topic at best. In anycase, its all speculation about where idea's come from and how they perpetuate and there really is no way to prove or disprove much of anything. My statement is an oversimplification for clarity I suppose. There obviously are religous/philosophical idea's that have no root in entheogens, perhaps I should have demarcated and said 'peak experiences' which do bear a remarkable similarity across cultures.

The similarities there, though, are similar in the same way sales pitches and indoctrination are the same across cultures. :)

I think what Nick was trying to say, however, was that the heavy emphasis on the entheogen-centric arguments to the psychotropic or other drug use seems somewhat dismissive of the normal human element of imagination and ability to assemble intricate and detailed pictures in the mind's eye without the assistance of outside factors. Nick seems to be quite the humanist in this regard, and he has a great deal of confidence in the abilities of the human mind all by itself to paint the various milleaus of religious and mythological symbolism. In that regard, the type of thinking that drug use or some other outside factor played a part in that process seems to somewhat lessen or overshadow the natural capabilities of the unfettered and unfiltered mind.

Then again, that's just the impression I get from what Nick said. He can correct me if I'm off on any part.

GreNME said:
The relevance of ptolemaic astrology to Christian symbolism, though, is ambiguous at best, and otherwise superficial. Its intention was to draw as many systems into a unified model, which explains its logenvity... not unlike the Catholic Church, which is most likely why so many conspiracy theorists are so eager to link the two as related, considering the lasting success both had in the long run.
So, if I get you right...Ptolemy attempted to attach astrology to everything, and that is why we have a bunch of Christian symbolistic references tied to astrology like jesus pictured in a zodiac etc?

No, I think I may have worded things a bit incorrectly there. Ptolemy, as far as I can tell, didn't try to link his astrological models to 'everything'. What it seems to me he attempted to accomplish was to provide a unified theory on astrology by incorporating the stuff that seemed to work from more than one astrological system. Later versions of astrology did the same thing, including modern astrology today, but most of them were based on the ptolemaic model because it was so inclusive.

The Catholic church (remember, "catholic" means "universal") tended to be inclusive as well, absorbing many different cultural backgrounds and each, while having separate cultural legends consistent with their pre-converted mythologies (Our Lady of Guadalupe is a decent example, though I like to use more obvious ones like those in Irish Catholicism), tended to be more inclusive as time went on also. Much like the ptolemaic astrological system, the Roman Catholic Church is both similar (hierarchically, systematically, pedagogically) and different (eschatologically, somewhat doctrinally) from its earliest versions of the unified church that emerged from the Nicene Council and prior to that time. Some certain schools of thought may have changed, but structurally, the Roman Catholic Church remains similar enough to its early versions that it would still likely be reconizable to someone from a thousand years ago.

That's essentially the basics of what I mean. The structural framework and inclusive longevity of both are what seem to be the underlying factors behind most conspiracy theorists connecting the two, whether they are connecting actual similarities or jumping ahead of themselves to claim connections that are centuries (or, in some cases, millenia) apart from each other-- the Southern Crux thing from the film is a good example. Astrology, much like other religious or spiritualist beliefs, is a series of reflections of the culture at that time-- a civilizational snapshot, if you will. I'm unsurprised to see imagery containing both not because they were necessarily connected, but that they were both around at the time. There are plenty of other cultural factors involved in a lot of religious imagery through the ages, and in fact some of them even made their way into regular religious dogma and practice-- prayer beads (the rosary, adopted from the Mid-East and borrowed most likely from Islam), the concept of the halo (thank Zoroaster for that), the process of canonization and sainthood (a way to promote religious philosophers and provide a vehicle for local legends), and plenty more. But these things are all mechanisms for the religious structure, not indicative of the origin or nature of the religion itself. This is easy to see in the sectarian divisions that exist throughout all sorts of religions: Christianity (Catholic, Orthodox, Protestant, 'Reformist', etc.), Islam (Sunni, Shia, Wahabi, Sikh, etc.), Hindu (literally dozens), Buddhist (Theravada, Eastern, etc.), and so on (including subdivisions in different sects). If tracing origins to these different religions were as easy as the Zeitgeist film or any of the list of would-be-'scholars' (Dorothy, Jan, Andrew, and so on) seem to posit, then any one of these religions would have settled the doctrinal debates centuries ago, or one of the many sects would be settling them today. At the very least, it would be more at the forefront of scholarly studies and not require the vehicle of conspiracy theories in order to gain some kind of traction.
 
I think what Nick was trying to say, however, was that the heavy emphasis on the entheogen-centric arguments to the psychotropic or other drug use seems somewhat dismissive of the normal human element of imagination and ability to assemble intricate and detailed pictures in the mind's eye without the assistance of outside factors. Nick seems to be quite the humanist in this regard, and he has a great deal of confidence in the abilities of the human mind all by itself to paint the various milleaus of religious and mythological symbolism. In that regard, the type of thinking that drug use or some other outside factor played a part in that process seems to somewhat lessen or overshadow the natural capabilities of the unfettered and unfiltered mind.

Then again, that's just the impression I get from what Nick said. He can correct me if I'm off on any part.

Yes, I think you put it better than I could! Unless you've really experienced the power of meditation, or the intensity of self-inquiry, or the depth of spiritual work, I can imagine that it would seem quite reasonable to believe that it is needed to load up on tryptamines to get a religious experience. It's not. Just sit there and investigate the source of your own thoughts, experientially, for a few hours and you'll find all sorts of exciting stuff.

In the wake of the LSD ban in 1970, psychotherapist Stan Grof sought another way to open his patients up and let them release emotions and understand their unconscious. After some experimentation, he found that controlled breathing techniques were just as good as taking acid.

The development of the objective mindset in the West has created many amazing things, but one unfortunate ramification is that it has left a whole race of people with such rigid minds that they cannot even imagine who they really are and how much is inside of them. They assume you need drugs.

Nick
 
Last edited:
Yes, I think you put it better than I could! Unless you've really experienced the power of meditation, or the intensity of self-inquiry, or the depth of spiritual work, I can imagine that it would seem quite reasonable to believe that it is needed to load up on tryptamines to get a religious experience. It's not. Just sit there and investigate the source of your own thoughts, experientially, for a few hours and you'll find all sorts of exciting stuff.

In the wake of the LSD ban in 1970, psychotherapist Stan Grof sought another way to open his patients up and let them release emotions and understand their unconscious. After some experimentation, he found that controlled breathing techniques were just as good as taking acid.

The development of the objective mindset in the West has created many amazing things, but one unfortunate ramification is that it has left a whole race of people with such rigid minds that they cannot even imagine who they really are and how much is inside of them. They assume you need drugs.

Nick

Just really quickly off-topic: I know where you are coming from with this, though not necessarily from the religious perspective. I'd gotten myself banged up pretty good in an auto accident (road ice, embankment, the works) and was broken so bad I now have "after-market parts" installed (yeah, I'm a hoot in airports). Once I woke up from my coma (2.5 weeks later) I began working off the pain-med cocktail as quickly as possible using controlled breathing and relaxation of muscles to ease the tension that triggered the worst pains. I was out of the hospital by the end of the month and was completely off the morphine immediately, and was taking only asprin by the end of my first two weeks in home recovery. It kept my mind from being dulled and, interestingly enough, I knitted together in almost half the time that the docs all thought it would take for recovery. It's all mostly anecdotal (though I was told a doc mentioned my case at a seminar in Philly), but it's a decent anecdotal example of how eschewing reliance on any one thing-- in this case, pain-killer drugs-- can have potentially beneficial results. The only caveat I would include is that I made sure to have all of my concerns regarding weaning off the pain meds discussed thoroughly with my doctors, so that they would be aware in the case that any complications came up. I don't recommend being cavalier with your health to anyone, and have learned to trust medical professionals and defer to their judgment when my long-term health is concerned in most cases.

Anyhoo, that's the end of the derail, but I totally understand the concept behind the belief that our natural abilities are highly underestimated in most cases with regard to our creativity, coping ability, and general ingenuity, among other things.
 
I think what Nick was trying to say, however, was that the heavy emphasis on the entheogen-centric arguments to the psychotropic or other drug use seems somewhat dismissive of the normal human element of imagination and ability to assemble intricate and detailed pictures in the mind's eye without the assistance of outside factors. Nick seems to be quite the humanist in this regard, and he has a great deal of confidence in the abilities of the human mind all by itself to paint the various milleaus of religious and mythological symbolism. In that regard, the type of thinking that drug use or some other outside factor played a part in that process seems to somewhat lessen or overshadow the natural capabilities of the unfettered and unfiltered mind.

I would say that the idea of invoking the influence of psychedelic states is hardly dismissive of the capabilities of the human brain by itself. I would also say if anything it is a empirical method that demonstrates to the user how immensely powerfull the brain can be.

Logically speaking, what do you think occurred first...the accidental ingestion of a mind altering compound, or the mastery of the ego and self via meditation and various other mental exercises? The answer should be obvious.

Of course it seems to lessen or perhaps over shadow the capabilities of the mind, but only in the minds of those that feel one path is more valid than the other. The reality is, in my opinion, a combination of factors where no single one is more important or ultimately more influential. Perhaps when you get into small indigenous groups you could identify what methods they favored, but overall I feel that there is no one better or worse way of achieving the same states of mind. The difference is totally subjective.

Personally I do not share the same confidence that you percieve in Nick. For all the great things the mind is capable of, we are not nearly a bright enough species to fully make use of them in any way(yet), and to assume that at a time when we were relatively simple minded that we could attain such spiritual feats is to assume a lot, I feel anyway. Where the entheogenic experience is completely verifiable experience today, the claims of spiritual enlightenment from ages ago are not, especially when you remove the influence of chemicals in the brain from the picture. Regardless of ingestion/meditation it is still chemistry, in one you are altering your brain chemistry with a subtance, with the other you are training your mind to do it for you. It could just as easily be a delusional state brought on by the individual that wants it to happen.

Yes, I think you put it better than I could! Unless you've really experienced the power of meditation, or the intensity of self-inquiry, or the depth of spiritual work, I can imagine that it would seem quite reasonable to believe that it is needed to load up on tryptamines to get a religious experience. It's not. Just sit there and investigate the source of your own thoughts, experientially, for a few hours and you'll find all sorts of exciting stuff.

I can see where you are coming from, but I think I still disagree. Like I said before, which do you think occurred first? Did hunter gatherers in the prehistory of civilization have many hours with which to sit around and contemplate, or were they busy hunting and gathering? There is no doubt that there have been instances in history where people were able to take the time to develop things like Yoga, or Zen Buddhism, but what were they doing before that? I guess, as I have already stated it cannot be proven either way, but that doesn't call for one to overrule the other in terms of validty.

The development of the objective mindset in the West has created many amazing things, but one unfortunate ramification is that it has left a whole race of people with such rigid minds that they cannot even imagine who they really are and how much is inside of them. They assume you need drugs.

I don't believe this to be completely true. I do agree that the western mind has been stuck in it's 'objectivity', and that this has in the minds of many persons closed off the possibilities of internal investigation. However, to say they assume you need drugs to achieve that is a bit much. I would say it's more accurate to say that they assume you don't need anything, and that the idea of spiritual/mental development is foreign and fantasy for the most part, or that they assume due to religious conditioning that the only way to attain it is by following a dogmatic prescription for religious epiphany.

In the end I think everything regarding personal spiritual growth is inherently biased by the individual seeking it, and influenced by the cultural meme's present where they reside. Some cultures favor non-drug taking, and others do, and the results are arguably similar, although subject to interpretation by the experiencer.

My bottom line- You can inject a person with a small dose of DMT, or comsume psilocybin and induce some of the wildest and most reality challenging experiences filled with all manner of 'aliens and archetypes' that also interact with you on a personal level. These extremely powerful experiences, the contents of which are nearly universal in description(if one is to believe strassmans medical research) across all cultural boundries, carry with them extremely heavy spiritual overtones that are in turn interpreted against the participants belief system.

I am not offering that these experiences are the only means of attaining some level of spiritual development, I am offering that these experiences are verifiable whereas an individuals personal explorations of the self are not. They are also freely attainable whereas the process of meditation is a lengthy one. It is more likely to me that a person would accidently induce an experience like this via foraging vs inducing it via hours of meditation in days of old.

I am not saying either method is valid or invalid I am merely speaking about which of them I feel is likely to have catalyzed thought on the subject of spirituality first....and I haven't even touched on the possible influences of naturally occuring mental states that we would today consider illness. Working in the field of psychiatry I have witnessed self proclaimed messiahs and people who feel that aliens are controlling them from another dimension via some sort of Air Loom technology. It often makes me wonder if these 'distant controllers' were viewed as gods or angels before the discovery of magnetism and the development of technology.

...man what a digression....

How did we get on this subject anyway?
 
Last edited:
I would say that the idea of invoking the influence of psychedelic states is hardly dismissive of the capabilities of the human brain by itself. I would also say if anything it is a empirical method that demonstrates to the user how immensely powerfull the brain can be.

Except you're introducing an unnecessary factor for the desired result. Drugs have never been necessary for achieving a trance state. That's a mostly Western misconception. Still, a more in-depth discussion on this would probably belong in a different subforum, where the likelihood of a more varied breadth of responses could chime in.

Logically speaking, what do you think occurred first...the accidental ingestion of a mind altering compound, or the mastery of the ego and self via meditation and various other mental exercises? The answer should be obvious.

No, it shouldn't. In fact, it's a chicken-egg scenario that doesn't really logically fit the model for how either thing develops (or developed) historically.

Personally I do not share the same confidence that you percieve in Nick. For all the great things the mind is capable of, we are not nearly a bright enough species to fully make use of them in any way(yet), and to assume that at a time when we were relatively simple minded that we could attain such spiritual feats is to assume a lot, I feel anyway. Where the entheogenic experience is completely verifiable experience today, the claims of spiritual enlightenment from ages ago are not, especially when you remove the influence of chemicals in the brain from the picture. Regardless of ingestion/meditation it is still chemistry, in one you are altering your brain chemistry with a subtance, with the other you are training your mind to do it for you. It could just as easily be a delusional state brought on by the individual that wants it to happen.

I strongly suggest you read my little anecdote again. I'm not kidding when the doctors told me I wouldn't walk for quite a while and I was up walking and driving in less than half the time. The ability to make use of these strange behaviors of our mind-body relationships may not be fully quantified, but don't believe for a second that medical science isn't gaining a pretty good understanding of the connection something as simple as attitude and disposition can make in a healing process. However, what medical science fully admits is that the results vary depending on the person, and that not everything is going to be solved through sheer force of will.

I can see where you are coming from, but I think I still disagree. Like I said before, which do you think occurred first? Did hunter gatherers in the prehistory of civilization have many hours with which to sit around and contemplate, or were they busy hunting and gathering? There is no doubt that there have been instances in history where people were able to take the time to develop things like Yoga, or Zen Buddhism, but what were they doing before that? I guess, as I have already stated it cannot be proven either way, but that doesn't call for one to overrule the other in terms of validty.

It absolutely calls for such a thing. Ruling out certain things is how we narrow things down to valid probabilities. The chicken-egg scenario isn't valid because it's assuming motives and situations for which there are absolutely no evidences and tend to consider cultural behavior in the context of how things work today. Even those cultures we would call "primitive" that exist in todays world are so much more advanced than the peoples of 10,000 or 50,000 years ago that even they aren't a feasible comparison.

My bottom line- You can inject a person with a small dose of DMT, or comsume psilocybin and induce some of the wildest and most reality challenging experiences filled with all manner of 'aliens and archetypes' that also interact with you on a personal level. These extremely powerful experiences, the contents of which are nearly universal in description(if one is to believe strassmans medical research) across all cultural boundries, carry with them extremely heavy spiritual overtones that are in turn interpreted against the participants belief system.

I am not offering that these experiences are the only means of attaining some level of spiritual development, I am offering that these experiences are verifiable whereas an individuals personal explorations of the self are not. They are also freely attainable whereas the process of meditation is a lengthy one. It is more likely to me that a person would accidently induce an experience like this via foraging vs inducing it via hours of meditation in days of old.

I am not saying either method is valid or invalid I am merely speaking about which of them I feel is likely to have catalyzed thought on the subject of spirituality first....and I haven't even touched on the possible influences of naturally occuring mental states that we would today consider illness. Working in the field of psychiatry I have witnessed self proclaimed messiahs and people who feel that aliens are controlling them from another dimension via some sort of Air Loom technology. It often makes me wonder if these 'distant controllers' were viewed as gods or angels before the discovery of magnetism and the development of technology.

I'll reference again to the Marsh Chapel experiment, which was actually repeated a few years ago with even more controls in place and happened to yield exactly the same results: whether taking a placebo or a psychotropic, nearly everyone reported having similarly profound experiences despite the actual substance they ingested. If you want an example of a person, look up Benny Hinn. That guy (huckster) is so charasmatic that he gets people so worked up that those who are in wheelchairs from conditions that have made it too painful to stand are literally convinced to ignore their pain long enough to get up and move around on their feet. If you want a less religious example, try Derren Brown as someone who knows how to manipulate the power of suggestion and people with high susceptibility.

...man what a digression....

How did we get on this subject anyway?

As far as I can tell, bringing up Jan and Andrew started it. If you want, though, you can bring this separate topic up in the Gen Skepticism & Paranormal section and we could look more in-depth into it.
 
...



I'll reference again to the Marsh Chapel experiment, which was actually repeated a few years ago with even more controls in place and happened to yield exactly the same results: whether taking a placebo or a psychotropic, nearly everyone reported having similarly profound experiences despite the actual substance they ingested. ...

no.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marsh_Chapel_Experiment



http://64.233.169.104/search?q=cach...h+chapel+experiment&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=10&gl=us

"According to Pahnke, the experiment determined that "the persons who received psilocybin experienced to a greater extent than did the controls the phenomena described by our typology of mysticism" (Pahnke, 1963, p. 220).
 
I would say that the idea of invoking the influence of psychedelic states is hardly dismissive of the capabilities of the human brain by itself. I would also say if anything it is a empirical method that demonstrates to the user how immensely powerfull the brain can be.

Hi TSE,

It's not really the power of the mind that I'm talking about. It's the capacity to become aware of the mind, or to allow some diffusion into the egoic perspective. It's doesn't really make any difference how clever you are. Of course drugs can help here also, for sure. If I look specificially at Platonic thought, how it arose, and how it sought to enter early Christianity, it could be that drugs were involved. I think it's possible. I'd have to know more how the ideas of "ha-Shamaim" took shape.

Logically speaking, what do you think occurred first...the accidental ingestion of a mind altering compound, or the mastery of the ego and self via meditation and various other mental exercises? The answer should be obvious.

Hard to say, to be honest. People have spontaneous meditation or spiritual experiences. Happens all the time. I know because I'm the manager of a new age centre and people are always boring me rigid with them! In Genesis 5, Enoch famously "walked with God, and was not," making him the first enlightened being, according to Hebrew myth. It seems spontaneous. He didn't have to score any "manna" off Moses.


Personally I do not share the same confidence that you percieve in Nick. For all the great things the mind is capable of, we are not nearly a bright enough species to fully make use of them in any way(yet), and to assume that at a time when we were relatively simple minded that we could attain such spiritual feats is to assume a lot, I feel anyway. Where the entheogenic experience is completely verifiable experience today, the claims of spiritual enlightenment from ages ago are not, especially when you remove the influence of chemicals in the brain from the picture. Regardless of ingestion/meditation it is still chemistry, in one you are altering your brain chemistry with a subtance, with the other you are training your mind to do it for you. It could just as easily be a delusional state brought on by the individual that wants it to happen.

But this is the thing, it's not to do with intelligence. It's not to do with the capacity of the mind to process, to sort data, to imagine. It's more the ability of the mind to let go of these things.



My bottom line- You can inject a person with a small dose of DMT, or comsume psilocybin and induce some of the wildest and most reality challenging experiences filled with all manner of 'aliens and archetypes' that also interact with you on a personal level. These extremely powerful experiences, the contents of which are nearly universal in description(if one is to believe strassmans medical research) across all cultural boundries, carry with them extremely heavy spiritual overtones that are in turn interpreted against the participants belief system.

I am not offering that these experiences are the only means of attaining some level of spiritual development, I am offering that these experiences are verifiable whereas an individuals personal explorations of the self are not. They are also freely attainable whereas the process of meditation is a lengthy one. It is more likely to me that a person would accidently induce an experience like this via foraging vs inducing it via hours of meditation in days of old.

I've taken lsd, psilocybin, ibogaine, ayahuasca, ketamine, ecstasy, and no doubt more of same genre in my time. Not all at once, I hasten to add. And I've yet to see one alien. I feel a bit short-changed! I've read Strassman's book too. I still don't buy it that religious writings are necessarily drug-induced.

[eta, thinking back, I did see some weird beings on a 6 day iboga trip in the Cameroun years ago, but they weren't really aliens. To be honest, drugs ime really just show you yourself. When people don't want to look so much their minds often spin off into alternate realities. In psychological terms, aliens could be disowned aspects of the psyche]


...man what a digression....

How did we get on this subject anyway?

Probably something to do with Jan, still trying to justify being a stoner!

Nick
 
Last edited:

Yes.

I've looked for the actual numbers available on who took what in the experiment. The only noticable difference was in the length of time that the effects took place and the hallucinogenic qualities of the drug itself. Without working from the preconcieved conclusion that Pahnke and Leary were using, it's clear that the placebo showed that the only thing the psychotropic did was introduce hallucinations. Read the actual claims with a more discerning disposition and it becomes clear that the drugs didn't create the experiences, they only accentuated it for some (not all) of the participants.

"According to Pahnke, the experiment determined that "the persons who received psilocybin experienced to a greater extent than did the controls the phenomena described by our typology of mysticism" (Pahnke, 1963, p. 220).

Yes, but if you read the wording there it even admits that they all had an experience. That's what I've been pointing out. In fact, a minority percentage of the people who were given psilosybin in that experiment reported negative experiences, which was further reinforced by experiments and studies a few years ago using more control factors and more than one incident. One relevant abstract: "When administered under supportive conditions, psilocybin occasioned experiences similar to spontaneously occurring mystical experiences. The ability to occasion such experiences prospectively will allow rigorous scientific investigations of their causes and consequences." For people who have performed studies that aren't specifically trying to legitimize recreational drug use, these results aren't surprising: they are textbook programming techniques. Along with outright torture, these techniques have been used for a very long time for indoctrination and brainwashing.

The basic fact is that, using the Marsh Chapel experiment as the most notorioous example of such attempts to scientifically measure it, the results that came from the experiment were that everyone, including those who took the placebo, experienced something. If one looks at that ratio from the perspective of gauging efficacy of the drug itself to elicit a religious experience, then the efficacy rate seems almost nil in being able to create such an experience. If you want to talk about magnifying pliability and susceptibility along with causing hallucinations, that's fine, but you're not talking religion or even necessarily spirituality at that point.
 
I'm only interested in the gist of the Marsh Chapel experiment, which confirmed something obvious; namely, that psychedelic drugs have powerful effects on mental function for as long as they last, and many people have had what they consider to be a mystical experience from the drug.


the thing I objected to from your previous post:

GreNME:
"I'll reference again to the Marsh Chapel experiment, which was actually repeated a few years ago with even more controls in place and happened to yield exactly the same results: whether taking a placebo or a psychotropic, nearly everyone reported having similarly profound experiences despite the actual substance they ingested."

and:

Yes, but if you read the wording there it even admits that they all had an experience.


The people who got the nicotinic acid had some flushing and mild stomach discomfort, the people who took the psilocybin looked at the candles with awe. Yes, everyone had an experience.

In fact double blind tests like this are a joke (only in this sense) because it is completely obvious who got the hallucinogen and who didn't.

Personally speaking, when I've ingested psilocybin I've become an instant mystic for the duration. Then I return to crusty old atheism and nothing-newism.
source:
http://www.druglibrary.org/Schaffer/lsd/doblin.htm

"After about a half hour I got this burning sensation. It was more like indigestion than a burning sensation. And I said to T.B., "Do you feel anything?" And he said, "No, not yet." We kept asking, "Do you feel anything?" I said, "You know, I've got this burning sensation, and it's kind of uncomfortable." And T.B. said, "My God, I don't have it, you got the psilocybin, I don't have it." I thought, "Jeez, at least I was lucky in this trial. I'm sorry T.B. didn't get it, but I'm gonna' find out." I figured, with my luck, I'd probably get the sugar pill, or whatever it is. And I said to Y.M., "Do you feel anything?" No, he didn't feel anything. So I sat there, and I remember sitting there, and I thought, "Well, Leary told me to chart my course so I'm gonna' concentrate on that." And I kept concentrating and sitting there and all I did was get more indigestion and uncomfortable.
Nothing much more happened and within another 40 minutes, 45 minutes, everybody was really quiet and sitting there. Y.M. was sitting there and looking ahead, and all of the sudden T.B. says to me, "Those lights are unbelievable." And I said, "What lights?" He says, "Look at the candles." He says, "Can you believe that?" And I looked at the candles, and I thought, they look like candles." He says, "Can't you see something strange about them?" So I remember squinting and looking. I couldn't see anything strange. And he says, "You know it's just spectacular." And I looked at Y.M. and he was sitting there saying, "Yeah." And I thought, "They got it, I didn't."
 
I'm only interested in the gist of the Marsh Chapel experiment, which confirmed something obvious; namely, that psychedelic drugs have powerful effects on mental function for as long as they last, and many people have had what they consider to be a mystical experience from the drug.

I understand that's all you're interested in, but what is actually germane to the conversation are the multiple implications from the experiment, most notably that the drug wasn't actually necessary to have the mystical experience, only to accentuate it. This is relevant in the same way that a hypnotist can't actually suggest to someone to do something unless the inclination to be suggested or guided is already there. The results from the experiments of both Pahnke and Griffiths (the latter performed in 2006) display the obvious: that under suggestable conditions drugs can make people more suggestable. Shrouding the language in esoteric phrases like "mystical experiences" is somewhat misleading because in both experiments the experimenters make it clear that they are placing the subjects in a suggestible position (the first in a church, the second by specifically asking the participants to individually "look inward" and relate their experience).

The people who got the nicotinic acid had some flushing and mild stomach discomfort, the people who took the psilocybin looked at the candles with awe. Yes, everyone had an experience.

This is my point, though. Even in the first experiment that took place, all the participants considered their experience "profound" in some way. Trying to measure degrees, on the other hand, is mostly going to be subjective outside of the obvious hallucination symptoms.

In fact double blind tests like this are a joke (only in this sense) because it is completely obvious who got the hallucinogen and who didn't.

Actually, this is why I suggest the more recent experiment as better methodology. Pahnke and Leary were not only leading the students on in the experiment, but later interviews with the participants shows an obvious eagerness to please and be rewarded (with the drug). I can definitely see why it can be considered a joke by you in this regard

Personally speaking, when I've ingested psilocybin I've become an instant mystic for the duration. Then I return to crusty old atheism and nothing-newism.
source:
http://www.druglibrary.org/Schaffer/lsd/doblin.htm

"After about a half hour I got this burning sensation. It was more like indigestion than a burning sensation. And I said to T.B., "Do you feel anything?" And he said, "No, not yet." We kept asking, "Do you feel anything?" I said, "You know, I've got this burning sensation, and it's kind of uncomfortable." And T.B. said, "My God, I don't have it, you got the psilocybin, I don't have it." I thought, "Jeez, at least I was lucky in this trial. I'm sorry T.B. didn't get it, but I'm gonna' find out." I figured, with my luck, I'd probably get the sugar pill, or whatever it is. And I said to Y.M., "Do you feel anything?" No, he didn't feel anything. So I sat there, and I remember sitting there, and I thought, "Well, Leary told me to chart my course so I'm gonna' concentrate on that." And I kept concentrating and sitting there and all I did was get more indigestion and uncomfortable.
Nothing much more happened and within another 40 minutes, 45 minutes, everybody was really quiet and sitting there. Y.M. was sitting there and looking ahead, and all of the sudden T.B. says to me, "Those lights are unbelievable." And I said, "What lights?" He says, "Look at the candles." He says, "Can you believe that?" And I looked at the candles, and I thought, they look like candles." He says, "Can't you see something strange about them?" So I remember squinting and looking. I couldn't see anything strange. And he says, "You know it's just spectacular." And I looked at Y.M. and he was sitting there saying, "Yeah." And I thought, "They got it, I didn't."

Wait a second, are you sourcing that because that's your account, or because it's similar to your own experience in some way? Regardless, I think the following paragraph is more applicable to the overal conversation as pertains to the subject matter we're discussing as opposed to the obvious fact that hallucinogens can make you hallucinate: "Both the six-month and long-term follow-up questionnaire results support Pahnke's hypothesis that psilocybin, when taken in a religious setting by people who are religiously inclined, can facilitate experiences of varying degrees of depth that either are identical with, or indistinguishable from, those reported in the cross-cultural mystical literature. In addition, both the six-month and the long-term follow-up questionnaire results support Pahnke's hypothesis that the subjects who received psilocybin, more so than the controls, experienced substantial positive persisting effects in attitude and behavior."

I often wonder how the results would have differed if it had taken place in a good-old Pentacostal church instead of a more stoic chapel. I agree with you, calebprime, that the results of that study were unreliable and poorly performed in the context of what seems to have been the stated objectives for Pahnke, but I believe so because most studies trying to use some sort of methodology in churches rarely take into account the vast differences in dynamics between different types of churches of the same religion, let alone from different religions. I have a distinct feeling that a few college students on psilocybin listening to a Pentacostal (or even better, Southern Baptist) minister getting all fired up in his sermon would have quite a different experience than the ones in Marsh Chapel. :)
 
I often wonder how the results would have differed if it had taken place in a good-old Pentacostal church instead of a more stoic chapel.

Or what about in a doctors office?
http://www.rickstrassman.com/pages/dmt/chapter-summaries/

Or there is also the John Hopkins study:
Psilocybin can occasion mystical-type experiences having substantial and sustained personal
meaning and spiritual significance

http://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/Press_releases/2006/GriffithsPsilocybin.pdf

This is my point, though. Even in the first experiment that took place, all the participants considered their experience "profound" in some way. Trying to measure degrees, on the other hand, is mostly going to be subjective outside of the obvious hallucination symptoms.

Define 'profound' please.
 
Last edited:
I still don't buy it that religious writings are necessarily drug-induced.

I don't think anyone is saying that all religious writings are drug induced. I think, at least for me, that some of them must be, and that I wonder which of those in history have been.

Just like thinking up stuff could be a cause, or meditation, or Yoga...drugs are in there too. Like I said before, we haven't even touched upon other things like natural phenomena, psychotic states, or catastrophic events(thera?).

I can't really say I have seen 'aliens' in my inward adventures either. I have 'seen' the entire earth replaced with a globe shaped red grid, being overseen by a giant translucent statue of liberty looking down at me, at which time I noticed that I was in one of the squares of the grid as if I were a fuse that had burnt out. It was distressing, and felt like what I imagine death to be like. The giant figure pointed down to me and screamed in a manner not unlike an auditory hallucination that "I am not supposed to be here!"

I know, it sounds wack. But I couldn't make this stuff up.

There was another time(on the same substance) a friend and I were facing the western plaines watching a giant storm front move in. Just as the rolling clouds of lightening were about to pass I became transfixed on the front and in the chaos I could have sworn at the time the giant head of Zeus was traveling across Iowa with an arm outstretched for a split second. The next thing I remember I was stating..."I totally get greek mythology now"..

What does all that mean. Nothing. But it has certainly shaped how I view entheogen use in history.
 
Last edited:
GreNME said:
I often wonder how the results would have differed if it had taken place in a good-old Pentacostal church instead of a more stoic chapel.
Or what about in a doctors office?
http://www.rickstrassman.com/pages/dmt/chapter-summaries/

I don't think you understood what I meant by that statement. :)

Or there is also the John Hopkins study:
Psilocybin can occasion mystical-type experiences having substantial and sustained personal
meaning and spiritual significance

http://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/Press_releases/2006/GriffithsPsilocybin.pdf

You mean the one I've already referenced a few times so far myself? :)

GreNME said:
This is my point, though. Even in the first experiment that took place, all the participants considered their experience "profound" in some way. Trying to measure degrees, on the other hand, is mostly going to be subjective outside of the obvious hallucination symptoms.
Define 'profound' please.

No. I don't have to. You see, neither you nor I can be the judge of someone else's subjective experiences. To do so espouses bias that is not part of responsible scientific study.

I still don't buy it that religious writings are necessarily drug-induced.
I don't think anyone is saying that all religious writings are drug induced. I think, at least for me, that some of them must be, and that I wonder which of those in history have been.

The problem there, which I've been pointing out, is that there is actually zero way to be able to tell. Making guesses based on imagery that follows centuries and centuries after the first texts is not only an unreliable way to tell but is actually a backwards approach considering the known phenomenon of how stories (even non-mythological stories) tend to grow and become exaggerated over the course of even short periods of time.

Just like thinking up stuff could be a cause, or meditation, or Yoga...drugs are in there too. Like I said before, we haven't even touched upon other things like natural phenomena, psychotic states, or catastrophic events(thera?).

But things like the latter happen in regular frequencies, especially natural phenomenon, and in many cases happened in ways that obviously had cultural impacts on the people in the region. A very brief and highly paraphrased example: the Egyptians with the Nile River and the Mesopotamians with the Tigris and Euphrates Rivers. One of the most obvious reasons the Egyptian and Mesopotamian cultures had such different governmental structures-- the Egyptians tended toward a high amount of centralized control while the Mesopotamian civilizations were made of multiple cities (or city-states) that were constantly at odds with each other-- was the flooding of their respective rivers. The Nile flooded each year like clockwork, while the T & E happened at less discernable and inconsistent times. This had an obvious effect on the cultures because this was a food source, and as such the Egyptians could track their stores more efficiently and regularly while the Mesopotamian cities had to get what they could when it was available. One effect was in the governing bodies: like I said, Egyptians were centralized, consistent, and required few fortifications around their cities and borders, while Mesopotamian cities varied in the types of governing bodies they had and tended to have walls or towers up around their cities to keep out strangers. Another effect was the way their gods were anthropomorphized: Mesopotamian (Babylonian, Sumerian, Akkadian, etc.) gods tended to have figures and faces that displayed rage or invoked fear, while Egyptian gods were depicted as human, usually with features of the body or face that were not gruesome or invoking anger. Also, Egyptian leaders spoke for and as their religious god-heads, while Mesopotamian leaders usually did not and often deferred to a priesthood who would plead and bargain with their religious god-heads.

Yes, that's a rather textbook example of how it's obvious geographical and climatic history played a role in the civilizations and religions of two relatively close (in proximity) cultures, but it has become a textbook example because it so clearly illustrates how something like the timing of floods with the seasons can play a large role in how the people adjust to the world around them. This is something I constantly see missing in the writing of Jan & Andrew, of Dorothy M., of Allegro et. al, and especially within the movie Zeitgeist (the last of which seems to completely ignore such things).

I can't really say I have seen 'aliens' in my inward adventures either. I have 'seen' the entire earth replaced with a globe shaped red grid, being overseen by a giant translucent statue of liberty looking down at me, at which time I noticed that I was in one of the squares of the grid as if I were a fuse that had burnt out. It was distressing, and felt like what I imagine death to be like. The giant figure pointed down to me and screamed in a manner not unlike an auditory hallucination that "I am not supposed to be here!"

I know, it sounds wack. But I couldn't make this stuff up.

There was another time(on the same substance) a friend and I were facing the western plaines watching a giant storm front move in. Just as the rolling clouds of lightening were about to pass I became transfixed on the front and in the chaos I could have sworn at the time the giant head of Zeus was traveling across Iowa with an arm outstretched for a split second. The next thing I remember I was stating..."I totally get greek mythology now"..

What does all that mean. Nothing. But it has certainly shaped how I view entheogen use in history.

And it's certainly understandable how it would shape your view of such things. I don't necessarily dispute that your view has been shaped by those types of anecdotes. Quite the contrary: I think that your view being shaped by what you say is an honest and frank admission on your part that is refreshing to see explained. However, what I am countering with is that such a view is incomplete and is missing a lot of obvious factors (like explained in my textbook Egypt / Mesopotamia comparison) that not only obviously played a role throughout history, but did so consistently and in independently observable ways by different types of studies. The biggest hurdle for the drug-hypotheses has been the subjectivity of the myriad experiences despite the generalized symptoms of the effects of the drugs themselves. What makes historical comparative religion interesting across cultures and disciplines is that it tends to be inclusive of those many subjective experiences while simultaneously maintaining the ability to keep just outside of it in a universal and somewhat objective (to the believer, at least) fashion, but still manages to be traced to a bunch of other factors.

That, by the way, is how religions have managed for so long to avoid being broken down to simple psychoses, to simply the affects of moderate-to-heavy drug use, or to some kind of cultural machination to "control the masses" in some way. Sure, plenty of people attempt to reduce them down to such things and plenty of arguments accusing many religions of containing these symptoms exist, but in almost every case the religions themselves tend to still have facets within them that go beyond just those symptoms. That's actually why religions persist: because they are a cultural phenomenon that manages to stay just ahead of the sum of various parts of it. I'm not saying this justifies of validates any religion or its claims, just that it gets into the beginnings of why and how religion in general has persisted so much through the millenia.

To bring this back around to Zeitgeist: the failure to address the issue of religion in this regard is the biggest mistake in the argument the film tries to make, as well as the arguments made by many of its sources. Such arguments are a long-form rhetorical straw-man that makes a two-dimensional entity that they call 'religion' (or 'Christianity'), which they then knock down in short order by attacking one or two symptoms and claim that the whole kaboodle of what really makes up religion has been thereby debunked. Like I said before, it just isn't that simple.
 
I don't think you understood what I meant by that statement. :)

So what did you mean? I thought you were suggesting the outcomes would be different in different settings, hence the reference to a doctors office.

You mean the one I've already referenced a few times so far myself? :)

Forgive me for not recognizing. I thought you were strictly refering to the Leary experiment.

No. I don't have to. You see, neither you nor I can be the judge of someone else's subjective experiences. To do so espouses bias that is not part of responsible scientific study.

Regardless of bias, the contents of a entheogen induced experience are markedly different in sensation and content, and althought peoples interpretations of the experience will differ(your right there) the overall effects of the chemicals involved are very similar. Thats what the DMT book Strassman wrote is about. Speaking specifically of DMT the visual manifestations are almost uniform in many cases, with many people reporting nearly exacly the same 'creatures', although the type may vary from person to person. The contents of my experience are listed in that book also, with the exception that instead of a statue of liberty character, the guy saw a giant tribal goddess who said to him 'How dare you come here!'...

...and no I didn't read the book before the experience, but after.

The problem there, which I've been pointing out, is that there is actually zero way to be able to tell. Making guesses based on imagery that follows centuries and centuries after the first texts is not only an unreliable way to tell but is actually a backwards approach considering the known phenomenon of how stories (even non-mythological stories) tend to grow and become exaggerated over the course of even short periods of time.

I agree completely. Do you at least admit they could have played a role depending on the culture...I am not just talking about abrhamic religions either.

Yes, that's a rather textbook example of how it's obvious geographical and climatic history played a role in the civilizations and religions of two relatively close (in proximity) cultures, but it has become a textbook example because it so clearly illustrates how something like the timing of floods with the seasons can play a large role in how the people adjust to the world around them. This is something I constantly see missing in the writing of Jan & Andrew, of Dorothy M., of Allegro et. al, and especially within the movie Zeitgeist (the last of which seems to completely ignore such things).

It is bothersome. I think it has been brought up before, however with many at GM being so drug biased it's hard for such idea's to be taken seriously. I can't speak for acharya or zeitgeist.

And it's certainly understandable how it would shape your view of such things. I don't necessarily dispute that your view has been shaped by those types of anecdotes. Quite the contrary: I think that your view being shaped by what you say is an honest and frank admission on your part that is refreshing to see explained. However, what I am countering with is that such a view is incomplete and is missing a lot of obvious factors (like explained in my textbook Egypt / Mesopotamia comparison) that not only obviously played a role throughout history, but did so consistently and in independently observable ways by different types of studies. The biggest hurdle for the drug-hypotheses has been the subjectivity of the myriad experiences despite the generalized symptoms of the effects of the drugs themselves. What makes historical comparative religion interesting across cultures and disciplines is that it tends to be inclusive of those many subjective experiences while simultaneously maintaining the ability to keep just outside of it in a universal and somewhat objective (to the believer, at least) fashion, but still manages to be traced to a bunch of other factors.

Still in agreement. I'll repeat again, I am not offering that entheogens are the only factor to consider. Just one of many. I am glad you are refreshed!

To bring this back around to Zeitgeist: the failure to address the issue of religion in this regard is the biggest mistake in the argument the film tries to make, as well as the arguments made by many of its sources. Such arguments are a long-form rhetorical straw-man that makes a two-dimensional entity that they call 'religion' (or 'Christianity'), which they then knock down in short order by attacking one or two symptoms and claim that the whole kaboodle of what really makes up religion has been thereby debunked. Like I said before, it just isn't that simple.

no...it isn't.
 
Last edited:
So what did you mean? I thought you were suggesting the outcomes would be different in different settings, hence the reference to a doctors office.

No, the 'spiritual' environment is markedly different in a Pentacostal church than in a chapel. In fact, depending on the type and denomination of the church, I am more than willing to posit that you could come to a very close approximation of equal severity in experience for both the experimental and control group. It all has to do with factors outside of the known effects of the drug itself, regardless of the drug chosen. Trust me, I say this having seen behavior you would completely mistake for drug-induced coming from completely sober individuals. It's all about the proper environmental factors and the right person doing the guiding.

Forgive me for not recognizing. I thought you were strictly refering to the Leary experiment.

Nope. I referenced the Griffiths experiment in my first post mentioning the Leary (Pahnke) one, just not by name (of the observer) until a couple posts later.

Regardless of bias, the contents of a entheogen induced experience are markedly different in sensation and content, and althought peoples interpretations of the experience will differ(your right there) the overall effects of the chemicals involved are very similar. Thats what the DMT book Strassman wrote is about. Speaking specifically of DMT the visual manifestations are almost uniform in many cases, with many people reporting nearly exacly the same 'creatures', although the type may vary from person to person. The contents of my experience are listed in that book also, with the exception that instead of a statue of liberty character, the guy saw a giant tribal goddess who said to him 'How dare you come here!'...

For the similar creatures: do you know why so many people describe aliens in UFO stories as very similar in resemblance? If you understand how that phenomenon works, you'll be able to see how that phenomenon transfers to other stories. As for the statement that entheogen experiences are markedly different: all I can say is that such a claim is incredibly naive. I am absolutely sure that-- within the context of experience that has not been witness to the similarities-- conceiving of the possibility of very little difference, but there are lots of things that might fall outside of the conception of plenty of people's experience.

...and no I didn't read the book before the experience, but after.

You didn't have to. People weren't generally collaborating even a fraction of as much as they have been since the advent of the internet regarding UFO phenomenon, and yet they tended to be remarkably consistent as well. How did that happen? The answer for that applies here (beware... "psychotic" or "stupid" is not part of the answer).

I agree completely. Do you at least admit they could have played a role depending on the culture...I am not just talking about abrhamic religions either.

The difference that I think exists here is one of definition. Drug use obviously played a role in several cultures, but there are no evidences whatsoever pointing to them having a causative role in the creation of the religions or the myths. They were part of ritual and rite, not creation or necessarily dissemination/indoctrination (unless you are counting some more modern cults). So, yes, they seem to have often played a role, just not in any way resembling the way Irvin, Allegro, or others seemed to imply.

It is bothersome. I think it has been brought up before, however with many at GM being so drug biased it's hard for such idea's to be taken seriously. I can't speak for acharya or zeitgeist.

I understand your frustration. Bias is one of the hardest things to deal with when trying to look at something for as much qualitative and quantitative data as possible. As for Dorothy (acharya) or Peter (zeitgeist), I think their biases tend along different routes-- they don't seem as focused on the drug use.

Still in agreement. I'll repeat again, I am not offering that entheogens are the only factor to consider. Just one of many. I am glad you are refreshed!

I certainly didn't mean to imply anything condescending (just want to make that known). I mostly wanted to compliment you on your intellectual honesty. As for them being a "factor" (as you put it), the thing I'd be quick to point out is the question: "factor in what fashion?" A mental image of some peyote or mushroom leading to religious visions and then to myths and rituals is a whole different dynamic than religions and rituals stemming from environmental factors (like flood plains or climate) and then evidence of some substance used in the ritual. There's evidence of the latter, but no evidence of the former. That isn't to say there is evidence proving the former decisively false, but then we'd be getting into the "prove a negative" problem.

Quick aside: for a good read on how innocuous things seem to be factors in unrelated things, check out Jared Diamond's Guns, Germs, and Steel. It's one of the most impressive looks at such subjects I've read, though it doesn't deal specifically with religion (it deals with cultures). I think you'd like it.

GreNME said:
To bring this back around to Zeitgeist: the failure to address the issue of religion in this regard is the biggest mistake in the argument the film tries to make, as well as the arguments made by many of its sources. Such arguments are a long-form rhetorical straw-man that makes a two-dimensional entity that they call 'religion' (or 'Christianity'), which they then knock down in short order by attacking one or two symptoms and claim that the whole kaboodle of what really makes up religion has been thereby debunked. Like I said before, it just isn't that simple.
no...it isn't.

That's precisely the reason why I make it a point to clarify that I am arguing neither for nor against religion itself when covering this topic, by the way. It's a topic on which reams of books could be written and still only barely begin coming close to scratching the surface, and plenty of people are already diligently attempting to go that route. Personally, I think it's a cyclical battle-- like I explained on the GM forum about the prophets, the god-killers, and the religious sycophants-- and in trying to fight such a battle one is wantonly jumping into that cycle, whether intentionally or not. I also found that I'm not the first in voicing this opinion about Dorothy's work, as the introduction to The Christ Conspiracy has a mention of her being accused of similar behavior (her editor is mentioning some controversies from her work), which I found interesting. Considering the whole "the revolution is NOW" rhetoric coming from Peter (zeitgeist), he seems to be playing the role I described as prophet earlier, but the signs are there: these types of conspiracy theories tend to fall right into that cycle whether the creators want to or not.
 
No, the 'spiritual' environment is markedly different in a Pentacostal church than in a chapel. In fact, depending on the type and denomination of the church, I am more than willing to posit that you could come to a very close approximation of equal severity in experience for both the experimental and control group. It all has to do with factors outside of the known effects of the drug itself, regardless of the drug chosen. Trust me, I say this having seen behavior you would completely mistake for drug-induced coming from completely sober individuals. It's all about the proper environmental factors and the right person doing the guiding.

Yeah, I have been to a four square gospel church once. You ever see people speaking in tongues? It's hilarious...and unnerving at the same time.


For the similar creatures: do you know why so many people describe aliens in UFO stories as very similar in resemblance? If you understand how that phenomenon works, you'll be able to see how that phenomenon transfers to other stories. As for the statement that entheogen experiences are markedly different: all I can say is that such a claim is incredibly naive. I am absolutely sure that-- within the context of experience that has not been witness to the similarities-- conceiving of the possibility of very little difference, but there are lots of things that might fall outside of the conception of plenty of people's experience.

Naive or not, you are introducing a chemical that is very similar to serotonin into the blood via the stomach. Regardless of the logic of your statement this still holds true and as a result they are different. It seems you are telling me that they aren't different when by the very nature of our physiology they will ultimately be so. It's like saying asprin is the same as ibuprofen. Both are pain relievers but both act in two completely different ways.


The difference that I think exists here is one of definition. Drug use obviously played a role in several cultures, but there are no evidences whatsoever pointing to them having a causative role in the creation of the religions or the myths. They were part of ritual and rite, not creation or necessarily dissemination/indoctrination (unless you are counting some more modern cults). So, yes, they seem to have often played a role, just not in any way resembling the way Irvin, Allegro, or others seemed to imply.

Agreed.


I understand your frustration. Bias is one of the hardest things to deal with when trying to look at something for as much qualitative and quantitative data as possible. As for Dorothy (acharya) or Peter (zeitgeist), I think their biases tend along different routes-- they don't seem as focused on the drug use.

Nope, thats Jan's territory.



I certainly didn't mean to imply anything condescending (just want to make that known). I mostly wanted to compliment you on your intellectual honesty. As for them being a "factor" (as you put it), the thing I'd be quick to point out is the question: "factor in what fashion?" A mental image of some peyote or mushroom leading to religious visions and then to myths and rituals is a whole different dynamic than religions and rituals stemming from environmental factors (like flood plains or climate) and then evidence of some substance used in the ritual. There's evidence of the latter, but no evidence of the former. That isn't to say there is evidence proving the former decisively false, but then we'd be getting into the "prove a negative" problem.

No worries. In any fashion would be my answer. We can't deny that certain groups especially those in north, central, and south america utilize them even to this day. It would seem that to assume that entheogens didn't play a role in mythos creation would be just goofy.

Quick aside: for a good read on how innocuous things seem to be factors in unrelated things, check out Jared Diamond's Guns, Germs, and Steel. It's one of the most impressive looks at such subjects I've read, though it doesn't deal specifically with religion (it deals with cultures). I think you'd like it.

I own it, and read it several times. Fantastic book.



That's precisely the reason why I make it a point to clarify that I am arguing neither for nor against religion itself when covering this topic, by the way. It's a topic on which reams of books could be written and still only barely begin coming close to scratching the surface, and plenty of people are already diligently attempting to go that route. Personally, I think it's a cyclical battle-- like I explained on the GM forum about the prophets, the god-killers, and the religious sycophants-- and in trying to fight such a battle one is wantonly jumping into that cycle, whether intentionally or not. I also found that I'm not the first in voicing this opinion about Dorothy's work, as the introduction to The Christ Conspiracy has a mention of her being accused of similar behavior (her editor is mentioning some controversies from her work), which I found interesting. Considering the whole "the revolution is NOW" rhetoric coming from Peter (zeitgeist), he seems to be playing the role I described as prophet earlier, but the signs are there: these types of conspiracy theories tend to fall right into that cycle whether the creators want to or not.

Indeed. Thats the thing. These people honestly think the world is as they think it is and act accordingly. Then the ego becomes involved...and soon they have cemented themselves into a hole in the wall, afraid to entertain any other concepts.

More later perhaps....
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom