GreNME said:
The thing is that it's unclear how widespread various recreational or religious drug use actually was, unless you take the word of Allegro. Unfortunately for Allegro, his theories have been much-repeated but not reproduced with independent study. It's too bad Jan and Andrew aren't endeavoring to try to bring that back through a peer-review, as I'd be interested (read: amused) to hear how it turns out.
Well, we have a idea at least:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entheogen#Entheogen-using_cultures
Prepare to be amused:
www.egodeath.com
Jan collaborates with the author of this site, and likes to name drop him quite a bit around the GM forum.
Well, this is getting a bit off-topic and into the realm of Jan Irvin's repeating of Allegro, but the biggest fault I tend to find is not that there are plenty of examples of cultures using various drugs-- heck, I don't think there is a single one in all of human history that
hasn't-- it is the causative manner in which Irvin (and his much-cited Allegro) tend to portray it. If nothing else, the Marsh Chapel experiment is a good example of how it doesn't take an actual working psychoactive to promote religious experiences (even the people who took the placebo reported allegedly 'profound' experiences). I know that experiment is often cited by Leary apologists as a success, but the only successful part of it is that the actual psychoactive drug used lasted longer than the placebo, whose physical effects wore off quickly.
Basically, on this topic, the most argument you're going to get from me is that Jan and others who argue similarly are putting the horse before the cart regarding the mechanism of the drug use, and nine times out of ten this type of argument is basically taking the form of a well-spoken and researched 'stoner apologetics' (as I call it). I don't see anything inherently evil, bad, or wrong about the intention, but the line of logic being purported (much like many religious apologetics) simply doesn't withstand scrutiny unless the scrutinizer actually
wants it to. Though I hate over-reducing it, I usually come to the conclusion that it's a basic "preaching to the choir" line of thinking.
(In other words, I'm not trying to insult your average pot-smoker or shroom-taker who finds the topic interesting. I'm simply pointing out that the topic has consistently in scholarly circles come to the consenus that drug use is simply one of many mechanisms of religious cultures, not a religious originator nor necessarily a critical necessity for the 'true believer' in the religion)
Don't worry, there is no trip to be laid. However, how is that patronizing? I would say that it's hardly over played considering it is a fringe topic at best. In anycase, its all speculation about where idea's come from and how they perpetuate and there really is no way to prove or disprove much of anything. My statement is an oversimplification for clarity I suppose. There obviously are religous/philosophical idea's that have no root in entheogens, perhaps I should have demarcated and said 'peak experiences' which do bear a remarkable similarity across cultures.
The similarities there, though, are similar in the same way sales pitches and indoctrination are the same across cultures.
I think what Nick was trying to say, however, was that the heavy emphasis on the entheogen-centric arguments to the psychotropic or other drug use seems somewhat dismissive of the normal human element of imagination and ability to assemble intricate and detailed pictures in the mind's eye without the assistance of outside factors. Nick seems to be quite the humanist in this regard, and he has a great deal of confidence in the abilities of the human mind all by itself to paint the various milleaus of religious and mythological symbolism. In that regard, the type of thinking that drug use or some other outside factor played a part in that process seems to somewhat lessen or overshadow the natural capabilities of the unfettered and unfiltered mind.
Then again, that's just the impression I get from what Nick said. He can correct me if I'm off on any part.
GreNME said:
The relevance of ptolemaic astrology to Christian symbolism, though, is ambiguous at best, and otherwise superficial. Its intention was to draw as many systems into a unified model, which explains its logenvity... not unlike the Catholic Church, which is most likely why so many conspiracy theorists are so eager to link the two as related, considering the lasting success both had in the long run.
So, if I get you right...Ptolemy attempted to attach astrology to everything, and that is why we have a bunch of Christian symbolistic references tied to astrology like jesus pictured in a zodiac etc?
No, I think I may have worded things a bit incorrectly there. Ptolemy, as far as I can tell, didn't try to link his astrological models to 'everything'. What it seems to me he attempted to accomplish was to provide a unified theory on astrology by incorporating the stuff that seemed to work from more than one astrological system. Later versions of astrology did the same thing, including modern astrology today, but most of them were based on the ptolemaic model because it was so inclusive.
The Catholic church (remember, "catholic" means "universal") tended to be inclusive as well, absorbing many different cultural backgrounds and each, while having separate cultural legends consistent with their pre-converted mythologies (Our Lady of Guadalupe is a decent example, though I like to use more obvious ones like those in Irish Catholicism), tended to be more inclusive as time went on also. Much like the ptolemaic astrological system, the Roman Catholic Church is both similar (hierarchically, systematically, pedagogically) and different (eschatologically, somewhat doctrinally) from its earliest versions of the unified church that emerged from the Nicene Council and prior to that time. Some certain schools of thought may have changed, but structurally, the Roman Catholic Church remains similar enough to its early versions that it would still likely be reconizable to someone from a thousand years ago.
That's essentially the basics of what I mean. The structural framework and inclusive longevity of both are what seem to be the underlying factors behind most conspiracy theorists connecting the two, whether they are connecting actual similarities or jumping ahead of themselves to claim connections that are centuries (or, in some cases, millenia) apart from each other-- the Southern Crux thing from the film is a good example. Astrology, much like other religious or spiritualist beliefs, is a series of reflections of the culture at that time-- a civilizational snapshot, if you will. I'm unsurprised to see imagery containing both not because they were necessarily connected, but that they were both around at the time. There are plenty of other cultural factors involved in a lot of religious imagery through the ages, and in fact some of them even made their way into regular religious dogma and practice-- prayer beads (the rosary, adopted from the Mid-East and borrowed most likely from Islam), the concept of the halo (thank Zoroaster for that), the process of canonization and sainthood (a way to promote religious philosophers and provide a vehicle for local legends), and plenty more. But these things are all mechanisms for the religious structure, not indicative of the origin or nature of the religion itself. This is easy to see in the sectarian divisions that exist throughout all sorts of religions: Christianity (Catholic, Orthodox, Protestant, 'Reformist', etc.), Islam (Sunni, Shia, Wahabi, Sikh, etc.), Hindu (literally dozens), Buddhist (Theravada, Eastern, etc.), and so on (including subdivisions in different sects). If tracing origins to these different religions were as easy as the Zeitgeist film or any of the list of would-be-'scholars' (Dorothy, Jan, Andrew, and so on) seem to posit, then any one of these religions would have settled the doctrinal debates centuries ago, or one of the many sects would be settling them today. At the very least, it would be more at the forefront of scholarly studies and not require the vehicle of conspiracy theories in order to gain some kind of traction.