ZEITGEIST, The Movie

This whole idea you speak of regarding some inner realm...it's not much different than what I have been describing(if at all). By the phrasing of your last few sentences it sounds as though you disagree with the notion on the grounds that it is not the same as the way you perceive it. Using terms like inner realm, and inward journey don't really reveal much to me unfortunately, but I feel that we are both discussing basically the same thing using different languages.

Perhaps you can elaborate?

Well, I could try but I think we're starting to really drift OT here. As a general rule, I think if Philip Dick starts showing up, it's time to re-focus!

Nick
 
Last edited:
Well, I could try but I think we're starting to really drift OT here. As a general rule, I think if Philip Dick starts showing up, it's time to re-focus!

Nick

Ha! Nice dodge. I believe this was a planned digression, so I wouldn't worry about going OT. We will get back to zeitgeist momentarily.
 
Yup. For a production that allegedly doesn't claim it's evangelizing the "truth" it sure does behave like it is.
 
Given the nature of the film, I would have assumed April 15 to be a more appropriate day.


(Waits for the inevitable April 1 joke.)

Truth be told, I'd imagine that February 29 would be the best day.

That way it'd only come up once every 4 years.
 

There is one college professor I know who I can almost guarantee is encouraging her students to see this tripe. She gushed over What the Bleep Do We Know? when it came out and offered extra credit to anyone who went to see it and brought their ticket stub to class.

This also blows out of the water my friend's argument that the makers of Zeitgeist aren't trying to profit from it.
 
That list made me sick to my stomach. Is there any historical precedent for the amount of disinformation the Trooth Movement is spreading? Did the village idiot EVER have a voice this loud?

In our ever emerging consumer-driven global marketplace it seems that truth and history become simply more commodities, to be bought and sold like anything else. Personally, I think it's good that the public now have more choice. I think this forum needs to get more used to the reality of free market dynamics.

Nick
 
Last edited:
There is one college professor I know who I can almost guarantee is encouraging her students to see this tripe. She gushed over What the Bleep Do We Know? when it came out and offered extra credit to anyone who went to see it and brought their ticket stub to class.

But objectivity is not truth. And science does not deal with the nature of reality, merely relationships between phenomena. You can't label something that is merely a viewpoint, or a consensual reality, truth, and expect it to just go on and on. It's unrealistic. There will inevitably be a point of challenge.

Nick
 
Last edited:
That's the funny thing about "truth" as a word, and why I try to avoid using the term when I can. It isn't always dependant upon fact, reality, independent verification, or even consistency. Conversely, it's not always exclusive of those things, but it doesn't depend on them either.
 
But objectivity is not truth. And science does not deal with the nature of reality, merely relationships between phenomena. You can't label something that is merely a viewpoint, or a consensual reality, truth, and expect it to just go on and on. It's unrealistic. There will inevitably be a point of challenge.

Nick

Did you quote the right post?
 
Did you quote the right post?

Hi Cisco,

I figure so. I mean I'm not like a collosal fan of "What the Bleep," "The Secret" or Zeitgeist, but I think they're all good movies fundamentally because they do all push people to look deeper at their preconceptions. This notion that some sceptics seem to carry around that scientists actually do understand what the hell is going on in reality - I think it's good to challenge that. They don't. They actually haven't got a clue.

Nick
 
Last edited:
Oh, I think that's overstating just a bit. Depending on the science, there are plenty out there who have at least a little bit more than a clue. Also, most scientists don't claim to have the wholeness of "truth" about things, often enough even with their own fields of study. This is quite common in the field of history, where I tend to study most, but there are plenty of other fields ranging from botany to astrophysics with scientists stating the same.
 
That's one thing I like about scientists, on the whole they're willing to admit they don't have the whole truth and are in the process of trying to determine it. I've always wondered, let's say, hypothetically, that a huge chunk of the Ross ice shelf falls off into the sea revealing a UFO with a copy of the manual "How to Colonize Alien Planets" inside on the kitchen table.

Who's going to have a harder time accepting this new truth, scientists or believers?
 
Hi Cisco,

I figure so. I mean I'm not like a collosal fan of "What the Bleep," "The Secret" or Zeitgeist, but I think they're all good movies fundamentally because they do all push people to look deeper at their preconceptions. This notion that some sceptics seem to carry around that scientists actually do understand what the hell is going on in reality - I think it's good to challenge that. They don't. They actually haven't got a clue.

Nick
If all these movies did was push people to look deeper at their preconceptions I'd be handing out fliers.

Unfortunately for your argument, that's not even close to all they do and you know it. Zeitgeist lies. It states known, demonstrated, verifiable lies as fact. That's not pushing people to look deeper at their preconceptions. That's pushing people to accept the author's preconceptions.

Science admits it doesn't have all the answers, but is looking for them with integrity. These people peddle fantasies for money or to further some agenda; usually both.
 
If all these movies did was push people to look deeper at their preconceptions I'd be handing out fliers.

Unfortunately for your argument, that's not even close to all they do and you know it. Zeitgeist lies. It states known, demonstrated, verifiable lies as fact. That's not pushing people to look deeper at their preconceptions. That's pushing people to accept the author's preconceptions.

Science admits it doesn't have all the answers, but is looking for them with integrity. These people peddle fantasies for money or to further some agenda; usually both.

Science has no clue about the nature of reality. It has looked. It has no clue. Science predicts relationships between observed phenomena. It tries to grasp the behaviour of reality. Zeitgeist is a propaganda movie. If I really believed in science and if I believed that objectivity was truth, then I would no doubt be appalled by Zeitgeist, and I would also probably feel sick to the stomach. But I don't. There's no real independent truth beyond subjective experience. It's utter fantasy. Zeitgeist moves energy. What the Bleep moves energy. The Secret moves energy. These movies create change. This is a far more powerful force that anything science can comprehend.

I've shown Zeitgeist to quite a few people. I don't see it as pushing them to believe Peter Joseph's view of the world. What I see is that people come away from it shaken, no longer so convinced in the version of events given to them by the recorded history they were bought up with. I can understand why someone would think that it's just one guy ramming his viewpoint down someone else's throat, but that's not my experience of what happens with it for the people I know.

Nick
 
Last edited:
That's one thing I like about scientists, on the whole they're willing to admit they don't have the whole truth and are in the process of trying to determine it. I've always wondered, let's say, hypothetically, that a huge chunk of the Ross ice shelf falls off into the sea revealing a UFO with a copy of the manual "How to Colonize Alien Planets" inside on the kitchen table.

Who's going to have a harder time accepting this new truth, scientists or believers?

Scientists are not looking for truth. Or, rather, if they are all they will discover if they're lucky is that they're looking in the wrong place. Objectivity is a filter. You place it over your awareness and the world looks one way. It doesn't really mean anything. Maybe for a while a few billion people all start looking the same way, and for a while it appears that this must be truth. But such a culture will always be vulnerable to the small boy in the crowd that can see that actually the emperor is not wearing anything, that none of it is actually based on anything substantial.

I like scientists. I like objectivity. But these things have nothing whatsoever to do with truth, and nothing whatsoever to do with the nature of reality.

Nick
 
Science has no clue about the nature of reality. It has looked. It has no clue. Science predicts relationships between observed phenomena. It tries to grasp the behaviour of reality. Zeitgeist is a propaganda movie. If I really believed in science and if I believed that objectivity was truth, then I would no doubt be appalled by Zeitgeist, and I would also probably feel sick to the stomach. But I don't. There's no real independent truth beyond subjective experience. It's utter fantasy. Zeitgeist moves energy. What the Bleep moves energy. The Secret moves energy. These movies create change. This is a far more powerful force that anything science can comprehend.

Nick

The bolded text, has in one fell swoop, explained why the truth movement cannot be reasoned with.

TAM:)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom