Near as I can tell, yes.
To me it appears you are saying that invoking the 'Lady of Guadalupe' as a connection symbolically is pointless because the two only have a connection at a symbolic level given that the revelation story had already been kicking around for a 1500 years or so.
Am I close?
Pretty close. It wasn't a symbolic level, though, like Jan and Andrew seem to be claiming. It was a literalist interpretation taken directly from the imagery on the Apocalypse. Unlike some fundie-lit today (like the
Left Behind series) that try to transpose symbolic meanings to things like the dragon or the whore of Babylon or the mark of the beast or the antichrist him(or it)self, Our Lady of Guadalupe takes it literally. There's no mystery there, nothing to try to figure out: it may as well have been a snapshot of the mind of whoever made the image. Pleas note, though, that I'm not going to bother getting into an argument of the veracity of the alleged miracle of the cloth-- if someone believes it, good on them and they are welcome to it, and the same goes for those who feel otherwise. The point I'm getting at is that the imagery was plainly and clearly a mosaic from the Book of Revelation, and a pretty darned literalist one at that. Trying to claim that one thing means this and the other thing means that is, well, no different than the writers of the
Left Behind series or the fundementalist doom-sayers who accuse the Catholic Church, the EU, France, America, and pretty much whatever else they don't like as being the bad stuff from the story of the Apocalypse. It gets into exactly the kind of behavior that gives the heavy impression, whether intentional or not, of trying to create a new spirituality or belief system.
What I am curious about is how accurate it is to compare astrological symbols that are derived from a western zodiac to the stories they retell in the video? Is it possible that astrology of that time period could have influenced the writing of those stories?
Which astrology? This is one thing that the likes of Jan and Dorothy keep coming back to in a misleading fashion. There was no "astrology" in any unified sense, not even in the ones based on the Greek or Roman schools (of which there were several of their own). Ever hear the phrase "ask five people a question, get six answers back" used? As far as I can tell, astrology, spiritualism (the communion with ghosts and the like), and demonology/spiritology were all like that. Further, this was in Mexico, pretty far away from the provincial trappings of the Euro-minority traditions, so the likelihood is much higher that some indigenous influences would be present than European (I mean, they turned the story of Quetzacoatl into a Christ-like myth pretty quick).
I took a minute to read back through on wiki the summaries regarding the various histories of the different forms of astrology and the result seems to point in the direction of a sort of borrowed progression of star knowledge that starts with Babylon and leads into Egypt, culminating with the Greeks and Ptolemy. Ptolemy however was not born until at least 83CE and didn't write his astrological treatises until much later.
So I guess what I am saying is...although a case could be made that his astrological writings might have influenced the later gnostic and biblical writings, the symbols used to tell it didn't exist until he created them? I am not totally certain of my knowledge regarding the history of astrology, but if the western zodiac that we think of didn't exist until 'after jesus' so to speak how could it have influenced the creation of jesus?
The Western zodiac as we know it today didn't exist as a whole until about the 19th Century. However, bits and pieces of it go back way further, even to the pre-Hellenistic Mediterrainian and Mid-Eastern regions, as well as up to those of the northern (eventually the Nordic) lands. However, yes, the Ptolemaic chart of Claudius that we recognize today didn't come into fashion until well after Christianity had begun, and was often used to unify conflicting Greek and Roman charts.
The relevance of ptolemaic astrology to Christian symbolism, though, is ambiguous at best, and otherwise superficial. Its
intention was to draw as many systems into a unified model, which explains its logenvity... not unlike the Catholic Church, which is most likely why so many conspiracy theorists are so eager to link the two as related, considering the lasting success both had in the long run.
It would appear to me that the story of jesus took on these traits after all these new greek astrological idea's came into bloom...if thats even the case at all....Aaaannd!...who knows how long it took for jesus to absorb those traits mythologically...? I kind of wish I knew more concrete info about the actual people who wrote the Gnostic Gospels as it would be most helpful right about now.
A tiny example:
http://www-spof.gsfc.nasa.gov/stargaze/Sjewcale.htm
That link provides an explanation of how the Jews were using the zodiac to create a calender of sorts(notice no jesus in the center of the zodiac).
They were using
a zodiac, not
the zodiac. Additionally, by the time of the Romans the Jews were split into more than one group (the Samarians are featured in the Bible as apostate, and there were others), several of them highly Hellenized, so it would be difficult (actually, close to ridiculous) to define any one of them as definitive in the influence according to Greek systems. There were varied levels of accepted Hellenization, though it does seem that, by the time of Paul, the Christian story was more popular among the Hellenized Jews than the traditionalists. That time would have had to have been around the time of the first 'official' gospel (Mark), and by that time there seemed to already be quite a bit of established mythology to the story.
Of course, other than the gnostic paths the conspiracy theorists love to quote Justin Martyr, whose signature argument seemed to be "see? we're not much different than you guys!" History shows how effective that attempt of his to legitimize Christianity turned out.
Couldn't this divine or causal plane have been perceived to be the stars though? I mean, with no knowledge of astronomy as we think of it, the stars must have been a pretty awe inspiring sight. I could even go out on a limb and say the stars combined with whatever drugs these people were doing might have even been so awe inspiring as to cause the creation of a mythos such as this...who knows though, right? Personally, after reading about, and personally experiencing some of the 'mystery' regarding psychonautical affairs I would definitely say that some of that influenced the creation of mythos...but that just speculation from a biased POV.
The thing is that it's unclear how widespread various recreational or religious drug use actually
was, unless you take the word of Allegro. Unfortunately for Allegro, his theories have been much-repeated but not reproduced with independent study. It's too bad Jan and Andrew aren't endeavoring to try to bring that back through a peer-review, as I'd be interested (read: amused) to hear how it turns out.
GreNME- I like the site. I like that it is wiki format especially...it makes navigation so easy some times. I was just talking about the need for a comprehensive CT site on a different thread here...looks like you were reading my mind....◊◊◊◊ where's the tin foil.
Yeah, this is the project I was talking about before, I was just looking for an effective medium and decided on a wiki because of its flexibility. Once I figure out how far I want to take it I might get it a root website of its own, at which point I imagine it'll grow rather quickly. I just need to figure out more of the technical structure underneath it and how to make sure that additions/subtractions and such will be peer-voted in order to ensure as little defacement as possible. My only complaint with this software is the lack of a unified control panel, but since it's free I guess I can't complain.