ZEITGEIST, The Movie

After thinking for a little while on this I am left to wonder about a few things. Namely, if you rule out the Murdoch/Irvin version of religious meme evolution what is left? Is there any weight to the ideas/concepts being presented, or is the overwhelming consensus of historical investigation opposed to the idea due to lack of evidence?

What is there evidence for in the first place? Is it as simple as parrallel evolution with a smattering of cultural borrowing?

I have been re-reading a nice although cheaply made book called "The Universe" and in the front is a lengthy discussion of the history of astronomy from the Babylonian/Egyptian era's to the present. What I find interesting about this situation in relation to that book is the apparent lack of consideration given to the history of astronomy and it's effects on human thought evolution.

As we discussed earlier in this thread(perhaps) there are many things being left out of the AS/JI version of events, like wars, natural disasters, and the individual interpretations of the stars themselves by the many cultures in question.

So...some questions...what is fact about this topic? What is well supported? Are there instances of co-evolution that are well supported? Or is this concept and idea a complete fiction?
 
It's going to depend on what you're asking about to get a detailed answer. The figurative waters of religious history is muddy in the first place, too steeped in legend and myth to really be able to peel back what is fact from what is fabrication that way. Further, it's too imprecise a practice to try to apply symbolic meanings across so many cultures that have developed through human development universally-- they just don't all translate the same.

Honestly, the core question with regard to the content used for the Zeitgeist film should probably be: is there really a need to "disprove" Christianity instead of disbelieving it and moving on?
 
After thinking for a little while on this I am left to wonder about a few things. Namely, if you rule out the Murdoch/Irvin version of religious meme evolution what is left? Is there any weight to the ideas/concepts being presented, or is the overwhelming consensus of historical investigation opposed to the idea due to lack of evidence?

What is there evidence for in the first place? Is it as simple as parrallel evolution with a smattering of cultural borrowing?

I have been re-reading a nice although cheaply made book called "The Universe" and in the front is a lengthy discussion of the history of astronomy from the Babylonian/Egyptian era's to the present. What I find interesting about this situation in relation to that book is the apparent lack of consideration given to the history of astronomy and it's effects on human thought evolution.

As we discussed earlier in this thread(perhaps) there are many things being left out of the AS/JI version of events, like wars, natural disasters, and the individual interpretations of the stars themselves by the many cultures in question.

So...some questions...what is fact about this topic? What is well supported? Are there instances of co-evolution that are well supported? Or is this concept and idea a complete fiction?

I think one could make a strong case that Christianity isn't anything new. It clearly very closely resembles the age-old life/purgation/rebirth Hero-myth from antiquity. Of course, as GreNME says, nothing is so certain this way back, but it still looks pretty strong to me.

The Zeitgeist contention is that there was an intent towards malice, if not in the actual construction of Christianity, then certainly at the Council of Nicaea some centuries later. This is a popular notion these days, but a good deal harder to substantiate, I think, and I think well worth keeping separate from the notion that Christianity is re-hashed mythology.

So, to me, I think it's good to distinguish between what can be well substantiated and what can't. Zeitgeist runs it all together a bit, in classic propagandist fashion.

I find it a bit of an brave choice of Irvin and Murdoch to try and "prove" their view at an academic level. They sure haven't picked an easy task for themselves. I think it's fair to say most academics will resist CT material strongly, and with so much "give and take" in the historical evidence, they'll simply demand proof, whereas were the conclusions less confrontational they might let it pass. I salute them for going for it though.

As for "parallel evolution" - at a psychological level, I think this could be happening a bit, but I don't find it so relevant.

Nick
 
Buddists don't believe Buddha was born of a virgin.. end of story (yes a very very very tiny minority held this belief based a dream story), but it's not a Buddist belief.

It's like saying Christ appeared to the native American indians after his resurrection. Christians don't believe that.

Zeitgeist the movie is complete rubbish full of twisted theories.
 
I think one could make a strong case that Christianity isn't anything new. It clearly very closely resembles the age-old life/purgation/rebirth Hero-myth from antiquity. Of course, as GreNME says, nothing is so certain this way back, but it still looks pretty strong to me.

Actually, it is that nothing is so cut-and-dried as some (including the film) try to make it out to be. The third part of the film (and many anti-fed conspiracy theorists) make the same mistake.

I find it a bit of an brave choice of Irvin and Murdoch to try and "prove" their view at an academic level. They sure haven't picked an easy task for themselves. I think it's fair to say most academics will resist CT material strongly, and with so much "give and take" in the historical evidence, they'll simply demand proof, whereas were the conclusions less confrontational they might let it pass. I salute them for going for it though.

I'm not sure I agree as much. They do seem to be trying to bring the subject to an academic level, but neither seem to display the qualities necessary to do it within their work. They tend to work backwards from a conclusion instead of forward with evidences, and in the process attempt to redefine terms that have gone through plenty of time getting worked out to begin with. Also, the more I read of both, especially Murdoch, I get the feeling that they have a specific axe to grind with the Roman Catholic Church in specific, Christianity second, and in a distant third any other religion (excepting Murdoch's multiple "articles" on her site advocating New Age type stuff).

As for "parallel evolution" - at a psychological level, I think this could be happening a bit, but I don't find it so relevant.

Hmmm, I don't know if I got my idea on that across quite as clearly as I'd hope. There isn't much doubt about instances of parallel evolution of civil and cultural traits-- languages, architecture techniques, even implements of war (from strategies to weapons)-- but naturally the world is quickly reaching a point where literally nowhere inhabited by people on this planet will not have some influences both direct and indirect from somewhere else. Most of the world is already like that. At the time of the dawn of Christianity, the Roman world was at least partially connected to several different cultural influences, which is why influences should not be ruled out completely. However, depending on which comparison is being made, influences might or might not come into play in determining the relationship, and in other cases parallel development might or might not come into play. As an example, there are natural influences that are noticable-- the Jews in terms of law and some beliefs, or the Roman in terms of eventual hierarchy and infrastructure. Groups who could be considered having developed in parallel (or near-parallel) to this early Christianity can also be observed: the Mithras worshippers or some Christian-like groups in Alexandria (Egypt). Of these groups, there were obviously a high likelihood of conversions between the beliefs (Paul mentions more than once groups that seem to resemble some mystery groups), and at least by the time of Tertullian there were also rivalries (he complains of Mithraites lampooning Christian observances in sacrelige), and it's pretty clear that by the time of the Nicene Council the 'universal' (which is what 'catholic' means) church decided to stamp out not only groups that were long rivals but even Christian sects that were deemed heretical.

When not trying to determine motives that are unclear or unproven, the facts show quite clearly that there were plenty of religious paradigms being used in similar (but not the same) fashion in many of the groups in those early centuries, and as such there was plenty of friction. This is why I call it parallel evolution, by the way: it in many ways mimics a more notable and significant precedent, and in some ways it could be called an observable case of 'religious darwinism'. The early (pre-historic) version of humans had a similar challenge, where they occupied the world at the same time as around two other similar species: the neandertals and a species called homo sapiens idaltu. These other two subspecies died out before historic times, but there are obvious signs that they competed with our ancestors (homo sapiens sapiens) who were still hunter-gatherers. We (Homo sapiens sapiens) out-bred, out-innovated, and out-smarted the others whose subspecies lines died off tens of thousands of years ago.

Does it sound familiar? It should-- it may as well be a description of a number of historic struggles between modern humans today, who continually vie for superiority and influence. We have whole systems in modern civilization dedicated to it: economics and politics to name two obvious ones. During those times tens of thousands of years ago, language slowly developed, while the beginnings of religion (burial of the dead) were already practiced in an irregular fashion. Since then, there has been this sort of 'religious darwinism' taking place in the same way that cultures usually rise and fall-- meaning to say it isn't always deliberate, it isn't always linear, and not everything is intrinsically related to one another even though some things may seem similar.

Well, at least that's my going hypothesis. It's not really groundbreaking and it isn't really well-written-out yet (hence my study and later plans to eventually submit to peer-review). Still, hopefully that sheds a little more light on what I'm talking about in terms of what the Zeitgeist film attempts to cover-- basically that I think it attempts to claim some uncovered secret where the studies of history, archaeology, and anthropology have significant evidence that the motives and circumstances paint quite a different picture than what the film tries to claim.
 
It's going to depend on what you're asking about to get a detailed answer. The figurative waters of religious history is muddy in the first place, too steeped in legend and myth to really be able to peel back what is fact from what is fabrication that way. Further, it's too imprecise a practice to try to apply symbolic meanings across so many cultures that have developed through human development universally-- they just don't all translate the same.

Honestly, the core question with regard to the content used for the Zeitgeist film should probably be: is there really a need to "disprove" Christianity instead of disbelieving it and moving on?

Hmm...specifics....

I guess for starters I wonder if there is any culture that has any history of solar worship that might have been borrowed from mythologically to "create" jesus. Sorry for lacking specificity, but at this point I am just curious to know what IS out there instead what is fabricated for the sake of books sales.

What is difficult for me in my postion of semi ignorance to rectify is the idea that very few if any cultural idea's transfered from the egyptian source. Surely there must have been some that did given the nature of history to unfold based on previous events...so I guess I am wondering what those may be???

What is frustrating me is that, looking over the information, you could literally assemble any myth figure you wanted out of the pantheon of egyptian deities. Saying that jesus was "created" out of an amalgamation of them is a non-falsifiable statement on it's face. None of the supplied correlations fit in any real sense....But! does that mean that there aren't meaningful correlations that are accurate and do in fact exist?

In regards to your "core" question (and this is a bit of digression from the topic at hand)...Trying to disprove a myth figure is a pointless exercise, and one that infringes on the cognitive liberties of others who want to believe in said myth figure. The world isn't going to fall apart because a bunch of people believe in Jesus. Yes, it does disturb other members of society who are having their personal rights mired by christian politics but given time people will become more educated and thus more accepting of non-christian idea's. I feel that the overwhelming majority of people are secular for the most part even if they have religious feelings..."disproving" something they cherish only serves to remove a certain amount of needed hope. We can't all be perfectly logical athiests. Some people need some 'thing' to believe in, otherwise the vast majority who are raised to seek authority for direction would become directionless and the ship of society would begin to list.

The revolution will not be televised, and it certainly won't happen over night so...athiests...take a pill and relax, your time will come. In the meantime support universal education benefits for our children so that they can grow to be something besides a follower of a religion or political party.

*digression over*


I find it a bit of an brave choice of Irvin and Murdoch to try and "prove" their view at an academic level. They sure haven't picked an easy task for themselves. I think it's fair to say most academics will resist CT material strongly, and with so much "give and take" in the historical evidence, they'll simply demand proof, whereas were the conclusions less confrontational they might let it pass. I salute them for going for it though.

I think the problem is there is nothing to prove in the first place. A lack of evidence is a lack of evidence. We are free to draw whatever conclusion we wish, but the bottom line is what are we drawing conclusions from?

Is the misinformation of millions of internet viewers(I know, I know, I was talking about how little of an impact this movie would make a dozen or so pages back...) worthy of a salute?

As for "parallel evolution" - at a psychological level, I think this could be happening a bit, but I don't find it so relevant.

What I was refering to was the parallel evolutions of cultures throughout history, as opposed to the linked evolution promoted by JI and AS.
 
Hmm...specifics....

I guess for starters I wonder if there is any culture that has any history of solar worship that might have been borrowed from mythologically to "create" jesus. Sorry for lacking specificity, but at this point I am just curious to know what IS out there instead what is fabricated for the sake of books sales.

Well, we'd first have to settle the dispute over the varying levels of possible historicity of Jesus to begin chomping at that question with a comfortable level of definitive assurance. The most common consensus is that there was probably a guy who existed whom the Jesus story is based on, but that a lot of the details have been expanded on and expanded on to create the mythological being we know of today. Even then, though, any answer is muddied because there isn't one single definitive version of that being, not even among various Christian sects (or denominations). Even though there is no conclusive evidence of a "guy named Jesus" (or Yeshua) to fit the original mold, there are literally dozens of possible (Jewish) candidates that we do know of who could have served as the initial template on which other stuff was added as time passed.

What is difficult for me in my postion of semi ignorance to rectify is the idea that very few if any cultural idea's transfered from the egyptian source. Surely there must have been some that did given the nature of history to unfold based on previous events...so I guess I am wondering what those may be???

By the turn of the first century CE Egypt did not resemble the Egypt of earlier antiquity. The more common language heard was Greek, almost all recorded myth literature had become a mixture of Greek with Egyptian names, and the nation itself had already been conquered and run by ethnically non-Egyptians for nearly 500 years. Semitic Bedoin people were migrating into the country, Greeks and Romans lived there and mingled with the population, and the people we normally think of as ancient Egyptians were slowly being bred out of existence (though not intentionally). Think about the Roman Empire during its decline, and change the original empire to one that highly centralized (moreso than Rome) and had an even more strict hierarchy.

Better yet: do you feel that casinos on Native American reservations are indicative of the culture of their respective tribes 100, 200, 400, or 800 years ago?

What is frustrating me is that, looking over the information, you could literally assemble any myth figure you wanted out of the pantheon of egyptian deities. Saying that jesus was "created" out of an amalgamation of them is a non-falsifiable statement on it's face. None of the supplied correlations fit in any real sense....But! does that mean that there aren't meaningful correlations that are accurate and do in fact exist?

Well, Horus was pretty much applicable to anything, which is probably why Frazer, then Massey, then Campbell, and so on liked using him. When Egyptians wanted to connect something of mankind to the divine, they'd invoke Horus (even in non-religious literature). So, I guess in that sense the way so many people are "Jesus this" and "Jesus that" when it comes to invoking their religious beliefs is a 'sort-of' meaningful correlation. :)

In regards to your "core" question (and this is a bit of digression from the topic at hand)...Trying to disprove a myth figure is a pointless exercise, and one that infringes on the cognitive liberties of others who want to believe in said myth figure. The world isn't going to fall apart because a bunch of people believe in Jesus. Yes, it does disturb other members of society who are having their personal rights mired by christian politics but given time people will become more educated and thus more accepting of non-christian idea's. I feel that the overwhelming majority of people are secular for the most part even if they have religious feelings..."disproving" something they cherish only serves to remove a certain amount of needed hope. We can't all be perfectly logical athiests. Some people need some 'thing' to believe in, otherwise the vast majority who are raised to seek authority for direction would become directionless and the ship of society would begin to list.

I agree for he most part. I also don't think it's a smack against atheists or a condemnation that people somehow need religion. Heck, human civilization has been in relatively high gear for only around 4,000 - 6,000 years (and of that the last 1,000 to 2,000 have seen huge changes), so in the grand scheme of things we're managing pretty well considering all that.
 
Buddists don't believe Buddha was born of a virgin.. end of story (yes a very very very tiny minority held this belief based a dream story), but it's not a Buddist belief.

It's like saying Christ appeared to the native American indians after his resurrection. Christians don't believe that.

There's a great deal more to suggest that Buddha did actually exist. There are whole books of teachings done by disciples for a start. Even though JC supposedly came along some centuries later, there's very little evidence he really existed. The gospels can easily be seen as simply allegorical tales created by spiritual adherents of the time.

Having a virgin birth is spiritual allegory.

Nick
 
Last edited:
Hmmm, I don't know if I got my idea on that across quite as clearly as I'd hope. There isn't much doubt about instances of parallel evolution of civil and cultural traits-- languages, architecture techniques, even implements of war (from strategies to weapons)-- but naturally the world is quickly reaching a point where literally nowhere inhabited by people on this planet will not have some influences both direct and indirect from somewhere else. Most of the world is already like that. At the time of the dawn of Christianity, the Roman world was at least partially connected to several different cultural influences, which is why influences should not be ruled out completely. However, depending on which comparison is being made, influences might or might not come into play in determining the relationship, and in other cases parallel development might or might not come into play.

Yes.

I think there are a couple of other points to also be considered here with regard to parallel evolution...

Firstly, as the human ego, on a group level, becomes more solid and consistent, so the needs that each ego projects outwards onto some "God" or "Messiah" figure will also become similarly consistent. Even across quite a significant cultural or physical divide, so similar human egos will inevitable seek to get the same needs met through their individual religious beliefs and practices. Thus the deities and saviour figures of quite separate peoples could well become remarkably similar.

Secondly, I think it's worth recognising that many metaphysical schools of thought, certainly including early Christianity, did themselves have philosophies relating to their own origination. Gnostics, and many other followers of mystical biblical interpretations, believe in the existence of a divine, causal, or spiritual realm, from which the world we experience is constantly in a state of "fall." This realm of divine archetype is the source of our world of duality, and it is the task of the spiritual aspirant to return to the pre-Fallen, paradisical state through personal endeavour. It was actually the controversy stirred up by this belief (actually this interpretation of Genesis) that caused all the embittered internal dramas that so befell early Christianity. Some followed it, some wanted a more literal interpretation of Genesis to be taught. At the Council of Nicaea, Christianity was finally set on the orthodox path and the notion of a realm of divine archetype was dropped, remaining only with the mystical Christians and neo-Platonists.

This last point is also the crux of Zeitgeist Pt1. History records a clear battle preceding Nicaea between opposing Christian ideologies. The aforementioned Epiphanius was one of the more virulent defenders of what became the orthodox position, and the radical Origen one of the early defenders of the mystical interpretation. The mystical interpretation lost, and modern-day Christianity, with its belief in absolute sin, the absolute existence of evil, and the need to seek salvation outside of the self was born. All Zeitgeist is really trying to do, if you ask me, is to integrate the early Christian mystics again.

Nick
 
Last edited:
Nick said:
find it a bit of an brave choice of Irvin and Murdoch to try and "prove" their view at an academic level. They sure haven't picked an easy task for themselves. I think it's fair to say most academics will resist CT material strongly, and with so much "give and take" in the historical evidence, they'll simply demand proof, whereas were the conclusions less confrontational they might let it pass. I salute them for going for it though.

I think the problem is there is nothing to prove in the first place. A lack of evidence is a lack of evidence. We are free to draw whatever conclusion we wish, but the bottom line is what are we drawing conclusions from?

Is the misinformation of millions of internet viewers(I know, I know, I was talking about how little of an impact this movie would make a dozen or so pages back...) worthy of a salute?

Well, to me, it's all just where you put your attention, and where people put their attention in the past. People are getting very interested in the subject of Christianity's origins. There's evidence of that everywhere, from Dan Brown to Peter Joseph.

There's very little authoritative history, if you ask me. The winner gets to write history, and that's how it stays until someone challenges it. DM and JI are doing this. More light gets shined on this phase of human history, more academics get involved. Sides and positions form. Arguments and debates take place. It's all good.

Nick
 
There's very little authoritative history, if you ask me. The winner gets to write history, and that's how it stays until someone challenges it. DM and JI are doing this. More light gets shined on this phase of human history, more academics get involved. Sides and positions form. Arguments and debates take place. It's all good.

Nick

Normally I would agree that having established norms challenged and revised is great for the discourse and the "great work" as you might say. However, there is a point where, regardless of personal persuasion, fact stands on it's own. I feel it is dishonest to claim ones conclusions as fact in the face of the murk that is the area of history we are talking about. Very little can be proven, and in a sense I guess it doesn't matter, because we are still talking about educated persons informed guesses, which are as subjective as Jan or Acharya. The difference as far as I can tell, and as GreNMe has pointed out, is that what we do know as fact doesn't coincide with what is being presented as fact.

All the informed speculation in the world doesn't mean anything if it's speculation that starts with a conclusion first. On top of that, Irvin and Acharya are wary of people questioning their methods and conclusions, which is the bedrock of investigation and exploration. If one cannot even question the premise of an idea without being attacked what does that say about the quality of the idea being discussed?

I wish I was more removed from the debate on this than I am, as it would be easy to chalk up the clashing of idea's as two opposing yet equal forces. Unfortunately I am all too familiar with the ZT side of this debate and as the onion layers peel back the more I feel duped. Not by the idea itself, but by the people selling it...it's boils down to an agenda driven commercial for an idea that doesn't have enough wieght to stand on it's own...it has to rely on persons like myself who take for granted the percieved intentions of others...or in other words, I was stupid.

That is not to say that I am not open to the idea's being expressed, or that I think Irvin and Acharya are actively deceiving people, on the contrary, they are so in love with the paradigm of their creation that they cannot escape what RAW calls the "reality tunnel" of their situation. They are invested in it and will defend it forever, to it's metaphorical death.

Even though there is no conclusive evidence of a "guy named Jesus" (or Yeshua) to fit the original mold, there are literally dozens of possible (Jewish) candidates that we do know of who could have served as the initial template on which other stuff was added as time passed.

Do you have any info on these people? Any books to read on the subject?

GreNME- As an aside, how do you think Jan is able to coincide his idea's of the "mushroom cult" origins of christianity, with the egyptian origins that we are debating?
 
Last edited:
GreNME said:
Even though there is no conclusive evidence of a "guy named Jesus" (or Yeshua) to fit the original mold, there are literally dozens of possible (Jewish) candidates that we do know of who could have served as the initial template on which other stuff was added as time passed.
Do you have any info on these people? Any books to read on the subject?

You can start with "failed Jewish moshiach" on Google, and you'll find some notable names like Simon Magus and lesser ones like Athronges. I'm not sure there are any definitive lists of the lives of all the would-have-beens. Jewish sources have a list of names of notable ones, and the list goes as far back as the time of Alexander the Great (I don't trust the Wiki article actually naming Alexander) all the way into the seventeenth century. Josephus even mentiones that there were more than one coulda-been.

GreNME- As an aside, how do you think Jan is able to coincide his idea's of the "mushroom cult" origins of christianity, with the egyptian origins that we are debating?

By smoking copius amounts of weed.

Look, Jan really wants John Allegro and Timothy Leary to be "right" in all this. It makes people like him feel justified and more self-righteous. Allegro was a talented translator, but took the train to crazyville and only came back to here (the real world) for a couple visits after that. Leary was... well, his notoriety precedes itself (turn on, tune in, drop out).
 
Normally I would agree that having established norms challenged and revised is great for the discourse and the "great work" as you might say. However, there is a point where, regardless of personal persuasion, fact stands on it's own. I feel it is dishonest to claim ones conclusions as fact in the face of the murk that is the area of history we are talking about. Very little can be proven, and in a sense I guess it doesn't matter, because we are still talking about educated persons informed guesses, which are as subjective as Jan or Acharya. The difference as far as I can tell, and as GreNMe has pointed out, is that what we do know as fact doesn't coincide with what is being presented as fact.

Hi TSE,

Well, I haven't yet seen that the case could be so strongly presented as to say "that what we do know as fact doesn't coincide with what is being presented as fact." I'm sure there are quite a few errors in the movie, but I haven't seen sufficient enough fact to really undermine the basic premise that the Jesus story was a retelling of an age-old astrotheological myth. If someone can demonstrate that Jesus lived, or that there's another basis to the story then great.

It seems to me that the Bible clearly does go on about the stars considerably. The heavens declare the glory of god, Psalm 19..... the stars in their courses battled against Sisera, Judges 5 - these and many other Biblical quotes are understood metaphysically to reveal the dominion of the astrological signs over human personality and human error, over the microcosm and macrocosm.

I also agree that Jan and S don't make out so strong a case in reality as it appears in the movie.

All the informed speculation in the world doesn't mean anything if it's speculation that starts with a conclusion first. On top of that, Irvin and Acharya are wary of people questioning their methods and conclusions, which is the bedrock of investigation and exploration. If one cannot even question the premise of an idea without being attacked what does that say about the quality of the idea being discussed?

Undeniably true. Though, with regard to attacking, I think it's good to appreciate that these kinds of interpretations of Christian scripture have been attacked since early CE. Read about Origen or Philo, for example. People taking on the task of putting these interpretations out have a history of being attacked. They defend themselves as they can.


GreNME- As an aside, how do you think Jan is able to coincide his idea's of the "mushroom cult" origins of christianity, with the egyptian origins that we are debating?

Good question. Though parts of the Bible have been reasonably seen as relating to drug use, notably Exodus 16. And the Greek drink Kykeon, used in religious rituals, was reputedly hallucinogenic.

Nick
 
Hi TSE,

Well, I haven't yet seen that the case could be so strongly presented as to say "that what we do know as fact doesn't coincide with what is being presented as fact." I'm sure there are quite a few errors in the movie, but I haven't seen sufficient enough fact to really undermine the basic premise that the Jesus story was a retelling of an age-old astrotheological myth. If someone can demonstrate that Jesus lived, or that there's another basis to the story then great.

If the movie presented the idea as a premise and not cold fact I guess I wouldn't have a problem. It doesn't though. As GreNME points out, it could have been an actual guy who ended up getting mythology attached to him as the legend grew? Either way, there isn't enough info to declare anything as fact.

It seems to me that the Bible clearly does go on about the stars considerably. The heavens declare the glory of god, Psalm 19..... the stars in their courses battled against Sisera, Judges 5 - these and many other Biblical quotes are understood metaphysically to reveal the dominion of the astrological signs over human personality and human error, over the microcosm and macrocosm.

Sure. Jan and Andy put out a short video that I posted to this thread earlier that compares gnostic cosmology to actual zodiac events, it's interesting, but I cannot attest to it's accuracy.

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=3129789386576750896

Good question. Though parts of the Bible have been reasonably seen as relating to drug use, notably Exodus 16. And the Greek drink Kykeon, used in religious rituals, was reputedly hallucinogenic.

For sure. I just wonder how he puts the two together.

By smoking copius amounts of weed, as GreNME thinks?

Look, Jan really wants John Allegro and Timothy Leary to be "right" in all this. It makes people like him feel justified and more self-righteous. Allegro was a talented translator, but took the train to crazyville and only came back to here (the real world) for a couple visits after that. Leary was... well, his notoriety precedes itself (turn on, tune in, drop out).

I think Jan wants to be the bastard child of Leary and Allegro. Although, I don't think he is as big of a supporter of Leary as he is of Mckenna. Maybe if the they had a three way?? In any case, this is the big thing that turns me off about all this...the Fing self-righteousness.
 
Last edited:
Hey, I also wanted to make sure to qualify that I don't think smoking weed makes someone a conspiracy theorist, either. I know plenty of people, some of them quite smart, who enjoy a toke every now and then. The difference, and you named it quite accurately, is the self-righteousness about it. To Jan, it is all about that whole concept as a cultural statement. Like I said to you before (maybe in e-mail), Jan and anyone else who gets totally belligerent over this may be a decent person otherwise, but when the subject strays to this they increasingly become closed-minded, aggressive, and venomous toward dissenting views. Dorothy has this character trait as well.

In fact, a lot of people have this character trait, and the only thing that usually differs is the subject that sets them off. That should be recognized as something that makes them just as human as you and me, not something to denigrate them about. After all, behaving badly about something is usually sufficient for the person to dig their own hole without help. :)
 
Hey, I also wanted to make sure to qualify that I don't think smoking weed makes someone a conspiracy theorist, either. I know plenty of people, some of them quite smart, who enjoy a toke every now and then. The difference, and you named it quite accurately, is the self-righteousness about it. To Jan, it is all about that whole concept as a cultural statement. Like I said to you before (maybe in e-mail), Jan and anyone else who gets totally belligerent over this may be a decent person otherwise, but when the subject strays to this they increasingly become closed-minded, aggressive, and venomous toward dissenting views. Dorothy has this character trait as well.

In fact, a lot of people have this character trait, and the only thing that usually differs is the subject that sets them off. That should be recognized as something that makes them just as human as you and me, not something to denigrate them about. After all, behaving badly about something is usually sufficient for the person to dig their own hole without help. :)


You and your impeccable logic. Politics seems to be the arena in which most people conduct themselves in such a way. People mistake their bias for logic constantly...especially on the internet where being called out on it might take days to unfold.

Did you watch the posted video they made to link Gnostic Texts to Constellations? If so, what did you think?
 
Sure. Jan and Andy put out a short video that I posted to this thread earlier that compares gnostic cosmology to actual zodiac events, it's interesting, but I cannot attest to it's accuracy.

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=3129789386576750896

Hi TSE,

Thanks for the link. I don't know about it's astrological or astronomical accuracy, I'm afraid. Though I'm sure someone else could evaluate this as it seems fairly specific.

I wouldn't agree with Andrew's interpretation of the Adam and Eve story though. In the age when Genesis was written, people believed in a divine or causal plane of existence from which our world constantly descends. Adam and Eve are born in this paradisical realm but descend into dualistic consciousness through the symbolic act of eating the fruit of the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil. Each child goes undergoes the same "descent" as the infant ego develops and the sense of relative selfhood emerges.

I would agree, however, that the way the story is interpreted as being "Eve's fault," and ergo all women's fault, is grossly unfair. It's the theological basis for misogyny. Women should sue the church for misrepresentation and blemishing of character, if you ask me.

Nick
 
Last edited:
You and your impeccable logic. Politics seems to be the arena in which most people conduct themselves in such a way. People mistake their bias for logic constantly...especially on the internet where being called out on it might take days to unfold.

Oh, I'm sure I'm plenty 'peccable' on plenty of occassions, I just don't bother trying to hide behind it any more. I'm not afraid of admitting that I've allowed myself to get unhinged and that it's gotten ugly and made me look stupid. Instead, now I work on the "not looking stupid" thing. :)

Did you watch the posted video they made to link Gnostic Texts to Constellations? If so, what did you think?

Not yet, but since you mention it again I can probably check it out.


By the way: I figure I'll start by announcing in this thread first, until such time I have it populated with enough content to plug it with its own thread. I've gotten the first part of my 'project' up and running and am now commencing on transferring the truckload of varied and fragmented data I have in a bunch of different formats into one, big, huge-mungous standardized wiki-like format.

http://ct.grenme.com

Honestly, though, it's nowhere even close to being populated enough with information to be useful in referencing to other sources right now, so please keep that in mind and don't begin linking it willy-nilly at a bunch of places. I currently have a page up on Zeitgeist Part I (that is incomplete), a page up on the Horus-Jesus stuff (that is incomplete), and a page up on the Federal Reserve itself, not the tax stuff or the "international bankers" stuff (that is, of course, incomplete). I spent a good portion of the weekend adding content, collected from my books in digital and print format libraries as well as my growing list of links, but I've only just barely begun (considering the amount of stuff I've been saving up). Unlike the PDF I linked way, way back in the pages, I plan on actually using citations galore and fleshing out what I was previously going on from memory, which means it should be more accurate and deal with things in a more contextual manner. The reason I bring this up, though, is because I know exactly how much work this is going to be and I want to keep focusing on things that actually come up as debate points and relevant contentions on the subject matter. I'm not asking anyone to help me actually write any of this stuff, because I think that would be not only presumptuous of me but also lazy on my part (hey, this was my idea to install and try to execute, so I should lay in my own bed), but suggestions and criticisms are totally welcome.

I'm mentioning it in this thread because, for the time being, it is going to focus on Zeitgeist-related topics and tangental information or discussion material stemming from the film. In other words, the claims made in Zeitgeist, the claims made in its sources (like Dorothy's and Jan's work), and arguments made by the sources since the film came out (like Dorothy's recent e-book) are all going to be fair game, while the latest ranting from Alex Jones or whatever new chemtrail video pops up on YouTube is currently not in the queue. So, in that sense, it is still a Zeitgest-related project for me.

Oh, and registrations are turned off on it except by me. I might add voluteers for refining it later, but first and foremost I don't want it to become a wiki-war battleground (this forum or my own site is good enough for public debate).

Let me know what you think.


ETA: I just watched the video, and I find it pretty ridiculous. The whole "Lady of Guadalupe" thing is from the sixteenth century, for crying out loud! That means the Book of Revelation had already been written for fifteen hundred years, and the speculations and wild ideas about what John of Patmos' trippy vision must mean had made its way around Christian circles for a millenia and a half. There's no mystery as to why the imagery is similar: it doesn't take a genius to use apocolyptic imagery that exists in what was probably the only religion Juan Diego knew at the time. Conflating two completely different periods of history in order to come to some foregone conclusion seems to be a bad habit of Jan's that he really should work on.
 
Last edited:
ETA: I just watched the video, and I find it pretty ridiculous. The whole "Lady of Guadalupe" thing is from the sixteenth century, for crying out loud! That means the Book of Revelation had already been written for fifteen hundred years, and the speculations and wild ideas about what John of Patmos' trippy vision must mean had made its way around Christian circles for a millenia and a half. There's no mystery as to why the imagery is similar: it doesn't take a genius to use apocolyptic imagery that exists in what was probably the only religion Juan Diego knew at the time. Conflating two completely different periods of history in order to come to some foregone conclusion seems to be a bad habit of Jan's that he really should work on.

Please aid my sleep deprived mind for a moment would you? I am not following your line of thinking here too well...or something just doesn't make sense in the video...

It appeared to me that the video was referring to there being a correlation between the constellations on the 25th of December, the Gnostic Texts, and the Christian bible(particularly revelation), and 'Our lady of Light'.

So far so good?

To me it appears you are saying that invoking the 'Lady of Guadalupe' as a connection symbolically is pointless because the two only have a connection at a symbolic level given that the revelation story had already been kicking around for a 1500 years or so.

Am I close?

What I am curious about is how accurate it is to compare astrological symbols that are derived from a western zodiac to the stories they retell in the video? Is it possible that astrology of that time period could have influenced the writing of those stories?

I took a minute to read back through on wiki the summaries regarding the various histories of the different forms of astrology and the result seems to point in the direction of a sort of borrowed progression of star knowledge that starts with Babylon and leads into Egypt, culminating with the Greeks and Ptolemy. Ptolemy however was not born until at least 83CE and didn't write his astrological treatises until much later.

So I guess what I am saying is...although a case could be made that his astrological writings might have influenced the later gnostic and biblical writings, the symbols used to tell it didn't exist until he created them? I am not totally certain of my knowledge regarding the history of astrology, but if the western zodiac that we think of didn't exist until 'after jesus' so to speak how could it have influenced the creation of jesus?

It would appear to me that the story of jesus took on these traits after all these new greek astrological idea's came into bloom...if thats even the case at all....Aaaannd!...who knows how long it took for jesus to absorb those traits mythologically...? I kind of wish I knew more concrete info about the actual people who wrote the Gnostic Gospels as it would be most helpful right about now.


A tiny example:
http://www-spof.gsfc.nasa.gov/stargaze/Sjewcale.htm

That link provides an explanation of how the Jews were using the zodiac to create a calender of sorts(notice no jesus in the center of the zodiac).

I wouldn't agree with Andrew's interpretation of the Adam and Eve story though. In the age when Genesis was written, people believed in a divine or causal plane of existence from which our world constantly descends. Adam and Eve are born in this paradisical realm but descend into dualistic consciousness through the symbolic act of eating the fruit of the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil. Each child goes undergoes the same "descent" as the infant ego develops and the sense of relative selfhood emerges.

Couldn't this divine or causal plane have been perceived to be the stars though? I mean, with no knowledge of astronomy as we think of it, the stars must have been a pretty awe inspiring sight. I could even go out on a limb and say the stars combined with whatever drugs these people were doing might have even been so awe inspiring as to cause the creation of a mythos such as this...who knows though, right? Personally, after reading about, and personally experiencing some of the 'mystery' regarding psychonautical affairs I would definitely say that some of that influenced the creation of mythos...but that just speculation from a biased POV.


GreNME- I like the site. I like that it is wiki format especially...it makes navigation so easy some times. I was just talking about the need for a comprehensive CT site on a different thread here...looks like you were reading my mind....◊◊◊◊ where's the tin foil.
 
Please aid my sleep deprived mind for a moment would you? I am not following your line of thinking here too well...or something just doesn't make sense in the video...

It appeared to me that the video was referring to there being a correlation between the constellations on the 25th of December, the Gnostic Texts, and the Christian bible(particularly revelation), and 'Our lady of Light'.

So far so good?
Near as I can tell, yes.

To me it appears you are saying that invoking the 'Lady of Guadalupe' as a connection symbolically is pointless because the two only have a connection at a symbolic level given that the revelation story had already been kicking around for a 1500 years or so.

Am I close?

Pretty close. It wasn't a symbolic level, though, like Jan and Andrew seem to be claiming. It was a literalist interpretation taken directly from the imagery on the Apocalypse. Unlike some fundie-lit today (like the Left Behind series) that try to transpose symbolic meanings to things like the dragon or the whore of Babylon or the mark of the beast or the antichrist him(or it)self, Our Lady of Guadalupe takes it literally. There's no mystery there, nothing to try to figure out: it may as well have been a snapshot of the mind of whoever made the image. Pleas note, though, that I'm not going to bother getting into an argument of the veracity of the alleged miracle of the cloth-- if someone believes it, good on them and they are welcome to it, and the same goes for those who feel otherwise. The point I'm getting at is that the imagery was plainly and clearly a mosaic from the Book of Revelation, and a pretty darned literalist one at that. Trying to claim that one thing means this and the other thing means that is, well, no different than the writers of the Left Behind series or the fundementalist doom-sayers who accuse the Catholic Church, the EU, France, America, and pretty much whatever else they don't like as being the bad stuff from the story of the Apocalypse. It gets into exactly the kind of behavior that gives the heavy impression, whether intentional or not, of trying to create a new spirituality or belief system.

What I am curious about is how accurate it is to compare astrological symbols that are derived from a western zodiac to the stories they retell in the video? Is it possible that astrology of that time period could have influenced the writing of those stories?

Which astrology? This is one thing that the likes of Jan and Dorothy keep coming back to in a misleading fashion. There was no "astrology" in any unified sense, not even in the ones based on the Greek or Roman schools (of which there were several of their own). Ever hear the phrase "ask five people a question, get six answers back" used? As far as I can tell, astrology, spiritualism (the communion with ghosts and the like), and demonology/spiritology were all like that. Further, this was in Mexico, pretty far away from the provincial trappings of the Euro-minority traditions, so the likelihood is much higher that some indigenous influences would be present than European (I mean, they turned the story of Quetzacoatl into a Christ-like myth pretty quick).

I took a minute to read back through on wiki the summaries regarding the various histories of the different forms of astrology and the result seems to point in the direction of a sort of borrowed progression of star knowledge that starts with Babylon and leads into Egypt, culminating with the Greeks and Ptolemy. Ptolemy however was not born until at least 83CE and didn't write his astrological treatises until much later.

So I guess what I am saying is...although a case could be made that his astrological writings might have influenced the later gnostic and biblical writings, the symbols used to tell it didn't exist until he created them? I am not totally certain of my knowledge regarding the history of astrology, but if the western zodiac that we think of didn't exist until 'after jesus' so to speak how could it have influenced the creation of jesus?

The Western zodiac as we know it today didn't exist as a whole until about the 19th Century. However, bits and pieces of it go back way further, even to the pre-Hellenistic Mediterrainian and Mid-Eastern regions, as well as up to those of the northern (eventually the Nordic) lands. However, yes, the Ptolemaic chart of Claudius that we recognize today didn't come into fashion until well after Christianity had begun, and was often used to unify conflicting Greek and Roman charts.

The relevance of ptolemaic astrology to Christian symbolism, though, is ambiguous at best, and otherwise superficial. Its intention was to draw as many systems into a unified model, which explains its logenvity... not unlike the Catholic Church, which is most likely why so many conspiracy theorists are so eager to link the two as related, considering the lasting success both had in the long run.

It would appear to me that the story of jesus took on these traits after all these new greek astrological idea's came into bloom...if thats even the case at all....Aaaannd!...who knows how long it took for jesus to absorb those traits mythologically...? I kind of wish I knew more concrete info about the actual people who wrote the Gnostic Gospels as it would be most helpful right about now.

A tiny example:
http://www-spof.gsfc.nasa.gov/stargaze/Sjewcale.htm

That link provides an explanation of how the Jews were using the zodiac to create a calender of sorts(notice no jesus in the center of the zodiac).

They were using a zodiac, not the zodiac. Additionally, by the time of the Romans the Jews were split into more than one group (the Samarians are featured in the Bible as apostate, and there were others), several of them highly Hellenized, so it would be difficult (actually, close to ridiculous) to define any one of them as definitive in the influence according to Greek systems. There were varied levels of accepted Hellenization, though it does seem that, by the time of Paul, the Christian story was more popular among the Hellenized Jews than the traditionalists. That time would have had to have been around the time of the first 'official' gospel (Mark), and by that time there seemed to already be quite a bit of established mythology to the story.

Of course, other than the gnostic paths the conspiracy theorists love to quote Justin Martyr, whose signature argument seemed to be "see? we're not much different than you guys!" History shows how effective that attempt of his to legitimize Christianity turned out. ;)

Couldn't this divine or causal plane have been perceived to be the stars though? I mean, with no knowledge of astronomy as we think of it, the stars must have been a pretty awe inspiring sight. I could even go out on a limb and say the stars combined with whatever drugs these people were doing might have even been so awe inspiring as to cause the creation of a mythos such as this...who knows though, right? Personally, after reading about, and personally experiencing some of the 'mystery' regarding psychonautical affairs I would definitely say that some of that influenced the creation of mythos...but that just speculation from a biased POV.

The thing is that it's unclear how widespread various recreational or religious drug use actually was, unless you take the word of Allegro. Unfortunately for Allegro, his theories have been much-repeated but not reproduced with independent study. It's too bad Jan and Andrew aren't endeavoring to try to bring that back through a peer-review, as I'd be interested (read: amused) to hear how it turns out.

GreNME- I like the site. I like that it is wiki format especially...it makes navigation so easy some times. I was just talking about the need for a comprehensive CT site on a different thread here...looks like you were reading my mind....◊◊◊◊ where's the tin foil.

Yeah, this is the project I was talking about before, I was just looking for an effective medium and decided on a wiki because of its flexibility. Once I figure out how far I want to take it I might get it a root website of its own, at which point I imagine it'll grow rather quickly. I just need to figure out more of the technical structure underneath it and how to make sure that additions/subtractions and such will be peer-voted in order to ensure as little defacement as possible. My only complaint with this software is the lack of a unified control panel, but since it's free I guess I can't complain. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom