ZEITGEIST, The Movie

Well, not to be overly re-railing or anything, but it would be interesting to talk further on the subject, but this thread may not be the best venue. While I have had some experiences that seem similar to what you've said (here and elsewhere), I think you have a different point-of-view that is interesting to read. The same applies to Nick as well.
 
Well, not to be overly re-railing or anything, but it would be interesting to talk further on the subject, but this thread may not be the best venue. While I have had some experiences that seem similar to what you've said (here and elsewhere), I think you have a different point-of-view that is interesting to read. The same applies to Nick as well.

What do you propose? GreNME forum? New thread? I am all ears. I think it is pertainent to this discussion to a degree, but only because there is overlap between the parties involved.

So...?
 
Well, as long as the mods don't mind we can continue on it here.

The main thing I would focus on with the drug interaction is what I already pointed out: we have evidence of it being used in rituals and rites, but not in any originating fashion. There's certainly reason to believe it was used as a form of medicinal, incantational, and celebrational fashion in religions, and in that there's not really any reason to hold an opinion otherwise (and plenty of reason to agree with it). However, the reality is that we don't actually know where religions in the esoteric sense come from, and in the practical sense they seem to be derived from various environmental and cultural factors of their time(s). In fact, the main consistencies between religion usually have to do with environmental factors and the social justifications for the beliefs. Our earliest known religions seemed focused on agrarian cycles (for planting or harvest) or hunting and migratory cycles. All of them had to do with a specific kind of understanding: how to live in the world and survive.

Now, many did this through ancestor worship-- the act of ritualized burial is indeed the first practice we know of that had religious overtones. It's not exactly clear where the concept of deities came from, but one likely school of thought concerns hero worship having individuals attain mythical proportions and later achieving the status of a god-like being. Since not all cultures have human-like deities, the hero worship didn't necessarily have to be just one of the people of that culture, naturally. Regardless of the accuracy in such a theory, it's clear these gods were initially the anthropomorphosis of natural phenomenon (human, animal, weather, earthly or celestial object). Obviously, these natural phenomenon were things local to the culture who worshipped such deities-- you don't see oceanic deities in land-locked hunter-gatherer or agrarian societies, and you don't see deified aspects of a non-native creature in a given area unless the culture is one that travels.

It's in this that the film (and its sources) actually drink a big flagon of fail. Sure, the stars were all relatively in the same basic location and configuration in ancient times around the world, but the biggest indicator to there not being a unified or even common derivative mythology about them is in how differently different cultures personified them. Sure, some of them (especially those within the same parts of the world) had similar personifications, but they weren't the same and their stories tended to be much different. The same applies to the stars. The most popular one in the zeitgeist movie, Sirius, is actually an example of one that was quite different to different cultures: the Egyptians had a different view of Sothis (Sirius) than most others because they actually built their calendar around it. The reason the star had significance in Egypt and not in, say, Jordan or mid-China, is because the rivers in those latter two didn't exhibit the same clockwork behavior that the Nile did when Sothis was at its predetermined location.

Anyhoo, what I'm trying to say is that it'd be rare to find someone who has actually done any degree of study to say that controlled substances haven't been used in some form or variation throughout many cultures in their religious observances, but it'd be difficult to find those who would agree that those substances play a significant role in those respective religions outside of ritual or common cultural (basically social use, like beer/wine today) through most of history. Heck, most of Jan's own image "proofs" on his website substantiate that, in that the images usually consist clearly of expressions of religious ritual with the cultural aspects (not just the shrooms, but the attire and general appearance) respective to the date and time in which they are produced. Joseph Smith (founder of the LDS faith) described Jesus and God (the father) as being pale white with blonde hair, but would you say that because he based it off some Christian historical precedent or the fact that he was of European descent?
 
I don't think anyone is saying that all religious writings are drug induced. I think, at least for me, that some of them must be, and that I wonder which of those in history have been.

Just like thinking up stuff could be a cause, or meditation, or Yoga...drugs are in there too. Like I said before, we haven't even touched upon other things like natural phenomena, psychotic states, or catastrophic events(thera?).

Hi TSE,

I think the religious or spiritual writings that last the test of time tend to relate to a deeper part of our awareness, below the surface. When you make self-awareness a focus, you become more and more aware of your trips and self-avoidance strategies, and you start to realise more and more who you are. When I read stuff in the Bible, a lot of it makes sense to me on a deeper level. It has a surface meaning, it has a deeper significance.

So, to me, there is this continuum of experience with the ever-present possibility of going deeper, of not continuing in a line, but taking a right-angle turn to look inside. It's not like the writings are created by drugs, just that drugs is one possibility to open up this channel. It's there anyway, but people overlook, distracted by the play going on around them. When you see this, when you experience it, you realise that drugs are not really significant here. Like I say, they just open up a channel that is anyway there, you were just too distracted to notice before.

Nick
 
Last edited:
Anyhoo, what I'm trying to say is that it'd be rare to find someone who has actually done any degree of study to say that controlled substances haven't been used in some form or variation throughout many cultures in their religious observances, but it'd be difficult to find those who would agree that those substances play a significant role in those respective religions outside of ritual or common cultural (basically social use, like beer/wine today) through most of history.

Thats about the safest explanation there is. No one truly does know for certain. Lets consider south american shamanism, particularly those groups that utilize ayahuasca. Those shamans will tell you that they learned everything they know about the natural world(give or take) by communing with the 'spirit of the vine'...or so I have read. There are certain depictions of Aztec gods speaking to humans via mushrooms.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aztec_entheogenic_complex

Literally "god mushroom"—compound of the words teo(tl) (god) and nanácatl (mushroom)—the Psilocybe genus of mushroom has a long history of use within Mesoamerica. The members of the Aztec upper class would often take teonanácatl at festivals and other large gatherings. According to Fernando Alvarado Tezozomoc, it was often a difficult task to procure mushrooms. They were quite costly as well as very difficult to locate, requiring all-night searches.

Both Fray Bernardino de Sahagún and Fray Toribio de Benavente Motolinia describe the use of the mushrooms. The Aztecs would drink chocolate and eat the mushrooms with honey. Those partaking in the mushroom ceremonies would fast before ingesting the sacrament. The act of taking mushrooms is known as monanacahuia, meaning to "mushroom oneself".

At the very first, mushrooms had been served...They ate no more food; they only drank chocolate during the night. And they ate the mushrooms with honey. When the mushrooms took effect on them, then they danced, then they wept. But some, while still in command of their senses, entered and sat there by the house on their seats; they did no more, but only sat there nodding.

Perhaps the best known uses of the mushrooms are among the feasts of Montezuma. At his coronation ceremony, many prisoners were sacrificed, had their flesh eaten, and their hearts removed. Those who were invited guests to the feast ate mushrooms, which Diego Durán describes as causing those who ate them to go insane and many to take their lives.

Regardless of what can be proven we know that people have used them, and we know that they produce certain results at certain volumes of consumption.

The highest level of intoxication involves:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychedelic_experience

Total loss of visual connection with reality. The senses cease to function in the normal way. Total loss of ego. Feelings of merging with space, other objects or the universe. Feelings of reaching to the beginning or the end of space and time. The loss of reality becomes so extreme that it defies explanation. Dream or movie like states, people have been reported seeing themselves in entirely different settings than their original setting. Many people experience religious phenomenon at this level. Often mentioned are an "all-powerful presence" or a "universal knowledge" which many equate to their idea of God or enlightenment. Earlier levels are relatively easy to describe in terms of measurable changes in perception and thought patterns. The only thing still reported to be working at a recognizable level, is the mind's voice of thought. Much is unknown about what a person actually experiences during this period, because most people actually come back explaining the experience as "inexplicable" or "uncommunicable". This effect can be produced in high doses of LSD, DXM and extremely high doses of psilocybin or with extremely high doses of the strongest extracts of salvia divinorum

Sounds an awful lot like a 'religious' experience to me, regardless of cultural interpretation or setting. The difference I perceive between naturally attained states of mind such as those Nick is describing and this is that this state of mind is attainable by any one at any time essentially, given the availability of certain substances. It can happen purely by accident in some cases without any pretense, although pretense only reinforces the idea.

I get what Nick is saying about the 'continuum' and the lack of need for a catalyst like drugs. I would be curious to know what Nick thinks about the origins of such knowledge in the first place though? Thats the hang up for me in this case. I cannot accept that humans just thought up meditation one day with the intent of attain higher consciousness. I have a pretty cynical view of humanity though, to be honest.

So, to me, there is this continuum of experience with the ever-present possibility of going deeper, of not continuing in a line, but taking a right-angle turn to look inside. It's not like the writings are created by drugs, just that drugs is one possibility to open up this channel. It's there anyway, but people overlook, distracted by the play going on around them.

This is exactly what I have been trying to say all along. I just think that the accidental discovery of a visionary substance is more likely to have occurred before the formation of serious modes of thought regarding inner exploration.
 
I also want to add that it appears to me we are talking about two different things here. The origins of 'religion' and the origins of 'spiritual thought'....maybe it would help to clarify if we seperated them into two different areas for this discussion.
 
I don't think it's that we're talking about two different things, it's that I don't think that I (at the least, as I'm only speaking for myself) haven't made clear that it isn't really being argued that people can't or haven't attributed religious experience to a hallucinogenic high before. It's that people have attributed many things to being a religious experience, and some of them every bit as intense and amazing as a hallucinogenic one. Personally, I could paint a whole weird and surreal tapestry about what I recall while I was in a coma-- most of what I remember likely happened close to my waking, according to the medicos-- and I can even say today that the experience left quite an impression on me. All I would have had to do is mix a little religious belief in there and presto: instant religious experience that most people can only dream of having. For the more tame examples you can look at many cultural rites of passage-- they're usually based in some form around a social lay-over from religious observances these days. For a more direct similarity, check out the various levels of fasting and sleep deprivation out there and the effects they have on the human mind. Depending on the state of consciousness of the individual, it isn't usually difficult to slip into that state of incredibly intense hallucinatory experience.

Think of it like a set of orchestral instruments: entheogens are just one of many instruments, and indeed while there are numerous versions of that type of instrument there are still more different instruments that make up the entire orchestra. That, in a metaphorical sense, is what I'm saying.
 
I get what Nick is saying about the 'continuum' and the lack of need for a catalyst like drugs. I would be curious to know what Nick thinks about the origins of such knowledge in the first place though? Thats the hang up for me in this case. I cannot accept that humans just thought up meditation one day with the intent of attain higher consciousness. I have a pretty cynical view of humanity though, to be honest.

The explanation is....dah, dah....we have fallen! Just as there is an outer, temporal axis - a horizontal, so there is also an inner, atemporal, vertical axis. It's awareness. I don't fully understand it, and I can't well explain it, but it's there. I experience it. To explore it is to move inward. Objectivity only really applies on the outer layer.

This is significant because TSE is, as I see it, seeking some temporal source for religion or spirituality - some start point, or means attribute origination. I feel fairly confident to state that we are not going to find it here. We are looking in the wrong place. To find the commencement it's needed to actually make the inner journey itself. This is part of it.

Relating to this discussion, having followed the whole entheogenic debate for years, it's interesting to me that there does seem now, more than ever, a willingness in formal scientific circles to examine the potential medical uses of banned substances. There's a good article in Sci Am's Mind magazine this month summing up the whole scene.

www.sciam.com/article.cfm?id=psychedelic-healing

Nick
 
Last edited:
It's that people have attributed many things to being a religious experience, and some of them every bit as intense and amazing as a hallucinogenic one.

Speaking of...I think I said something similar about seeing terminator 3...at least that was my inital reaction..."Dude, that was like a religious experience..." might have been my exact words...

but seriously...

I think I have agreed to this statement several times, perhaps I wasn't clear..I'm not even really sure what I was getting at any more...

This is significant because TSE is, as I see it, seeking some temporal source for religion or spirituality - some start point, or means attribute origination. I feel fairly confident to state that we are not going to find it here. We are looking in the wrong place. To find the commencement it's needed to actually make the inner journey itself. This is part of it.

Well, I am a bit dualistic when it comes to this. To invoke David Bohm a little...I feel that there is the Implicate order of 'TRUTH' so to speak, that humans potentially have access to that is becomes completely nonsensical when one tries to discuss it. Then there is the Explicate order of human created 'truth' that attempts to reflect the 'timeless knowledge' but never achieves the goal. It gets bogged down by it's own dogmatic weight. It pretends to be the truth when it's just a human approximation of 'truth' based on the perceptions by those that experienced it.

I have to do work now...be back later....
 
To finish my thoughts...

An analogy I use is this(apologies if you are not into audio editing):

Picture if you will a multi-track audio editing program(the Uni/Multiverse). In each track you see a wave shape(aspects of reality) representing the audio visually, and they are arranged in an order that is defined by certain parameters(natural laws).

We can observe the audio files(empiricism) and we deduce what we can by observing them(science). However, we cannot know what they contain without experiencing them through listening. No matter how much we look at the wave shapes we can only go so far. We know there is something thre because we can experience it, but all attempts to determine what it is have failed because you cannot perceive it without direct experience.

To me, this is representative of consciousness(and the All). You cannot see thought, but we can see the mechanisms that make it possible.

I know it may seem horribly convoluted...but thats the best way I know how to explain it in non-'religious' terms.

I am not seeking a temporal cause for the spiritual so much as wondering where the 'spiritual' (for lack of a better term) and temporal have collided to create aspects of human history if in fact such a thing has ever occurred.
 
Well, it's going to depend on the audio software you're using to perform the editing ( kidding ), but I understand your analogy.

I think the 'spiritual' thing you're looking for, and stick with me on this metaphor, isn't in any specific track to which it belongs. I think this is a common type of mistake in searching for the properties in spirituality as well as its more organized sibling, religion. As near as I can tell, on your multi-track set in the editor, the 'spiritual' is probably best described as a property, or the dissonance or harmony between two or more separate tracks and how they play on (or off of) one another. Sometimes they have coalesced into a track of their own-- which could be counted as a 'religion'-- but otherwise the harmonies and dischords between tracks are mostly properties that can apply across many different sections of the piece and aren't constrained by the qualities of any single track.

Of course, at this point I'd have to expand my version of the metaphor into one involving compositional writing for the music tracks as well, specifically into the realm of orchestral composition. Now, I've never written a whole orchestral piece myself (haven't even written a movement), but I've had experience in putting together a few dozen measures to understand some of the properties of such writing. With all the different types of instruments, each with different properties and qualities to them, playing together at different times and in different variations, the entirety of the song is clear. But if you were to take individual parts of the whole and listen to them separately, some of them would be recognizable and others would not be recognizable. Depending on the composition some of them might even seem like they don't even fit into the larger piece or are not even in the same key. When all of the sections are played together, the total piece is not necessarily greater than the sum of its parts but it definitely becomes clear how those parts work together in creating the piece as a whole.

Now, take that and multiply it by an order of magnitude (depending on the period in history, anywhere between a few hundred thousand to six billion)-- that's the point where we still have a decent metaphorical representation of 'humanity' in some unspecific generic sense. Lifetimes could be devoted to how different sections work together harmonically (or not) and how those qualities work and how they affect other sections. Heck, a lot of that is what tends to make up social and behavioral sciences today. From what I can tell regarding those two fields of study, there are regularly occurring trends or patterns-- a similar 'key', if you will-- but no really unified or recognizable equation ( A + B = C ) that can explain everything.

Well, unless '42' works for you. ;)

And... to bring it back around to the film (yeah, I know, I keep smacking the horse), that search for a working equation is what seems to drive people like the makers of zeitgeist, like Dorothy and Jan, and/or like plenty of other people-- and plenty more non-CT people than otherwise. Outside of conspiracy theory-ish ideas, though, I don't think I've ever read a thesis consisting of any single, unified systems at the heart of humanity, though.
 
Nick said:
This is significant because TSE is, as I see it, seeking some temporal source for religion or spirituality - some start point, or means attribute origination. I feel fairly confident to state that we are not going to find it here. We are looking in the wrong place. To find the commencement it's needed to actually make the inner journey itself. This is part of it.

Well, I am a bit dualistic when it comes to this. To invoke David Bohm a little...I feel that there is the Implicate order of 'TRUTH' so to speak, that humans potentially have access to that is becomes completely nonsensical when one tries to discuss it. Then there is the Explicate order of human created 'truth' that attempts to reflect the 'timeless knowledge' but never achieves the goal. It gets bogged down by it's own dogmatic weight. It pretends to be the truth when it's just a human approximation of 'truth' based on the perceptions by those that experienced it.

I read one of Bohm's books years back when I thought it would be cool to try and understand these things. To me he is simply trying to reconcile objective awareness with the reality of immediate communication or apparent direct connection - objectivity with non-duality. So, to me, this is not really what I'm talking about. I'm talking more of an inward journey, analogically at 90 degrees to the temporal experience. Implicate order in a non-dual reality means you can't observe it because there is no point that is outside of it to do any observing from, ergo the Tao that can be told is not the true Tao. This isn't the same. It's an inner realm.

Nick
 
I think the 'spiritual' thing you're looking for, and stick with me on this metaphor, isn't in any specific track to which it belongs.

I think you misunderstood what I was getting at....but that is to be expected since I hardly can keep track of what I mean myself when it comes to these matters.

I am not looking for a track. I am saying that the contents of the track are non-existant in the physical sense but still exist just the same. You can measure the amplitude of audio, perhaps some of the most beautiful awe inspiring sounds one can hear, but measuring only tells you how loud it is. You have to look inside the wave to hear it.

The example works better for consciousness I think. As in we can measure consciousness, but we cannot see thoughts...you dig?

The phsyical world is the embodiment of the 'spiritual' that we can perceive, like the wave shape in the audio editor...but looking at the wave shape only tells us about the wave shape. We are conscious though, and thought so to speak is like the contents of a song. You can't see audio or consciousness by measurement alone.

My feeling is that the universe as a continuum is just the representation of that inner unknowable thought that permeates everything.

...anyway...be back in a few with more explanation.
 
I read one of Bohm's books years back when I thought it would be cool to try and understand these things. To me he is simply trying to reconcile objective awareness with the reality of immediate communication or apparent direct connection - objectivity with non-duality. So, to me, this is not really what I'm talking about. I'm talking more of an inward journey, analogically at 90 degrees to the temporal experience. Implicate order in a non-dual reality means you can't observe it because there is no point that is outside of it to do any observing from, ergo the Tao that can be told is not the true Tao. This isn't the same. It's an inner realm.

Nick

When has it not been cool to try and understand these things??

My interpretation of what Bohm is saying is that there is no seperation between what we term 'spiritual' and the physical world. They are like an entwined fabric, constantly unfolding and enfolding upon itself through an infinite layer of implicate and explicate orders....

Here is a bohm quote from wiki:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Implicate_and_Explicate_Order
In the enfolded [or implicate] order, space and time are no longer the dominant factors determining the relationships of dependence or independence of different elements. Rather, an entirely different sort of basic connection of elements is possible, from which our ordinary notions of space and time, along with those of separately existent material particles, are abstracted as forms derived from the deeper order. These ordinary notions in fact appear in what is called the "explicate" or "unfolded" order, which is a special and distinguished form contained within the general totality of all the implicate orders (Bohm, 1980, p. xv).


I like the idea of a continuous amalgam of quantum information fluxing in and out with many perceivable levels contained with in it...all that will be or was in a bubbling instant.

This whole idea you speak of regarding some inner realm...it's not much different than what I have been describing(if at all). By the phrasing of your last few sentences it sounds as though you disagree with the notion on the grounds that it is not the same as the way you perceive it. Using terms like inner realm, and inward journey don't really reveal much to me unfortunately, but I feel that we are both discussing basically the same thing using different languages.

Perhaps you can elaborate?
 
Well, one problem I see with your explanation is the assumption about our ability to measure consciousness. We can't. We're only just barely beyond being able to guage it in a binary way (on, off), but measuring of levels of consciousness is still a subjective task.

Read my analogy again. I'm not just taking your analogy further, I'm translating the verbiage you used and took it a different direction with more metaphorical exposition. I'm saying that it's all subjective, and within that a lot of variables get factored in depending on the person's (or culture's) background, history, general education, and interaction with others.
 
Well, one problem I see with your explanation is the assumption about our ability to measure consciousness. We can't. We're only just barely beyond being able to guage it in a binary way (on, off), but measuring of levels of consciousness is still a subjective task.

I don't think I mean what you think I mean...or something. We can measure brain waves for instance, via EEG. We can see actions at the neuronal level. We can see the composition of a neuron. We can map out what we think is going on mechanistically, but there is still no way to 'see' and experience thought independent of the individual experiencing it. You can't sample thought. We can see orchestrated firings in a brain and know that that is what thought looks like on the outside the experience of thought is unique to the individual.

I like this quote:
"I have developed a link gate... complex enough to regulate the forces, the field energies surrounding us... these waves are all around us now... radio waves, television channels, x-rays, the sun... the entire electromagnetic flux... I have no actual power myself... by using my brain patterns as a sort of focusing device I'm able to direct electromagnetic field energy into a discreet feeling... It's as though my brain were a lens..."

- Donald Pleasance in the episode "The Man With The Power of The Outer Limits

Read my analogy again. I'm not just taking your analogy further, I'm translating the verbiage you used and took it a different direction with more metaphorical exposition. I'm saying that it's all subjective, and within that a lot of variables get factored in depending on the person's (or culture's) background, history, general education, and interaction with others.

I know...I thought thats what I was saying too...sorta. I am saying that there is a universal experience that is interpreted by the individual. The Wave analogy is just my way of explaining what I think is going on...Something on the surface with non-existant yet real contents.

No wonder people have religious wars....
 
Last edited:
I don't think I mean what you think I mean...or something. We can measure brain waves for instance, via EEG. We can see actions at the neuronal level. We can see the composition of a neuron. We can map out what we think is going on mechanistically, but there is still no way to 'see' and experience thought independent of the individual experiencing it. You can't sample thought. We orchestrated firings in a brain and know that that is what thought looks like on the outside the experience of thought is unique to the individual.

Oh, we can grab a whole lot of data, definitely. The problem we're at now is finding a useful way to quantify that data into something that defines what seems otherwise ephemeral. Down that road, in my opinion, lies the realm of things we like to think of as the Big Stuff (self, mind, imagination) and the Bigger-But-More-Esoteric Stuff (religion, imagination, etc). Those are the things that fuzzy logic and AI programming, by the way, strives to one day be able to duplicate (especially the self and imagination parts).


GreNME said:
Read my analogy again. I'm not just taking your analogy further, I'm translating the verbiage you used and took it a different direction with more metaphorical exposition. I'm saying that it's all subjective, and within that a lot of variables get factored in depending on the person's (or culture's) background, history, general education, and interaction with others.
I know...I thought thats what I was saying too. Damn...

Well, maybe we're both saying the same thing two different ways. :)

This is the trouble with esoteric topics, you know: there's never just one flavor.
 
Last edited:
Oh, we can grab a whole lot of data, definitely. The problem we're at now is finding a useful way to quantify that data into something that defines what seems otherwise ephemeral. Down that road, in my opinion, lies the realm of things we like to think of as the Big Stuff (self, mind, imagination) and the Bigger-But-More-Esoteric Stuff (religion, imagination, etc). Those are the things that fuzzy logic and AI programming, by the way, strives to one day be able to duplicate (especially the self and imagination parts).

I have been slowing hacking my way through the Philip K Dick catalog, and a lot of these things you mention are topics of his. You want to talk about a man with too much on his mind! Wow.

His Valis experience is of particular note because I definitely think in the context of this conversation it is a nice example of how a person can become wound up in all this...seeking an explanation for the irrational, or what seems irrational.

Behold!

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philip_k_dick

This is a quality explanation of the valis experience:
http://www.philipkdickfans.com/weirdo.htm
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom