It's a propaganda movie. No doubt about it. What I like about it is that it pushes people to look deeper, to question stuff.
Except it doesn't do that. What it
does do, however, is provide blowhards like Jan Irvin-- who decided to ban me after I pointed out a few of his errors and asked him to openly admit them (which he kind of did)-- and DM Murdock chooses instead to insult or denigrate anyone who is critical of her work and encourages her fans to spam boards where discussions critical of her work are taking place (yes, I have proof).
That's what makes it valid to me.
Nick
Carl Sagan said it best:
“It seems to me what is called for is an exquisite balance between two conflicting needs: the most skeptical scrutiny of all hypotheses that are served up to us and at the same time a great openness to new ideas. If you are only skeptical, then no new ideas make it through to you. You never learn anything new. You become a crotchety old person convinced that nonsense is ruling the world. (There is, of course, much data to support you.)
On the other hand, if you are open to the point of gullibility and have not an ounce of skeptical sense in you, then you cannot distinguish useful ideas from the worthless ones. If all ideas have equal validity then you are lost, because then, it seems to me, no ideas have any validity at all.” – Carl Sagan, “The Burden of Skepticism,” Pasadena lecture, 1987
I bolded the important line in the quote, and I agree with Sagan completely in this regard.
Now, on to Jan's claim:
Jan Irvin said:
I found this yesterday while reading Christian Rätsch’s book, Pagan Christmas. When I found the quote, I checked to see if it had been sourced by others in this field regarding the fact of the similarities between Jesus and Horus. Other than Rätsch, it appears that the following quote from Epiphanius (circa C.E. 375) has only been used in a handful of other books in 150 years since its discovery in 1859.
This is "MAJOR DISCOVERY". We now have the PROOF, the SMOKING GUN, that the texts have been INTENTIONALLY MANIPULATED by the Christians to cover up the SIMILARITIES between HORUS and JESUS.
Except that he has to go all the way forward to the fourth century, where the Mithra and Christian cults had already coalesced into full religions in their own right and ignoring the three centuries of prior history that brought them to where they were at the time. Basically, as long as everyone ignores the three centuries prior, then it all seems to "make sense" in Jan's view.
Jan Irvin said:
From Christian Rätsch, Pagan Christmas, pg. 150-1.
“In 375 CE, Epiphanius, Biship of Constantia, described the pagan winter solstice feasts and mystery cults:
“This feast was celebrated by the Greeks (I mean the pagans) on December 25—the day called Saturnalia by the Romans, Kronia in Egypt, and Kykellia by the Alexandrians. On December 25, then, a cut happens that is also a turn; and it begins to grow. This is the day when the light becomes more (Vossen 1985, 72).”
I don't know why this bit of information keeps getting screwed up like this by people who claim to be actual scholars. Saturnalia was a festival that began around the middle of December (Wikipedia states around the 17th, but it wasn't always that specific day) and, in the later years went on for anywhere around 9 or 10 days and ending usually in the first few days of the solstice (before the 25th). Some of the rites from the Saturnalia celebrations made their way into the Deus Sol Invictus celebration, which in varying times throughout Roman history commemorated a number of different individuals (ranging from Mithras, Aurelian, Septimius Severus, and more). Basically, what both Jan and his source are getting incorrect here are the actual attributions to what Saturnalia was, as well as the corresponding dates.
Jan Irvin said:
In Egypt, Kykellia is called “the rite of Isis.” Like the smudging nights, this is a twelve-day feast. It begins with a torch procession in honor of the birth of Horus, the son of Isis: “The birth of the new sun is the intended meaning, and that was connected with the announcement of the sowing [of wheat] in the earth, freshly fertilized (with dung) and flooded by the Nile” (Vossen 1985, 72f). The sowing was done on December 27, during the feast celebrating the ascension of Horus to the throne. The meaning of the name Isis is equivalent to “Earth”.
An interesting claim, but take note that Jan's citation here is at the very least third-hand and doesn't actually name where in any Egyptian literature where this festival is mentioned. If Jan Irvin would be so kind as to name a single (or even several) Egyptian texts that mention it, instead of a 2006 book that is quoting a 1985 book (Vossen 1985), that would be great. I did a cursory search for the book by someone named Vossen in 1985, but not all archives from that year are complete and I did not find anything but some late-80's work by someone with the same last name who had published work in the realm of Computer Science (obviously not the same guy). If Jan actually has the book from whence he quotes, he should have no problem supplying the original sourcing instead of a quote of a citation that cites some unnamed Egyptian text. I'm not exactly calling the actual celebration that they are mentioning false, but the thing is that what they describe does not fit in with any information I have ever read on Egyptian celebrations during that time of year in antiquity.
Instead, what I know of are the celebrations surrounding the rise of Sothis, which meant that the priestly class would be notified and subsequently those who lived near the Nile would prepare for harvest-- the rise of Sothis (known as Sirius in western culture) meant the Nile was soon going to flood.
From the book
Letters from Ancient Egypt with translations by Edward F Wente and Edmund S Meltzer, from the 12th Dynasty (Senwosret III) (P. Berlin, 18-21) about Sothis (Sirius) it reads:
"It is the mayor and dean of the temple Nubkhaure who addresses the chief lector priest Pepyhotep:
"I am speaking in order for you to know that it is on the sixteenth day of the fourth month of the second season that the heliacal rising of Sothis (Sirius) will occur. May the attention of the priestly corps of the mortuary temple "Powerful is Senwosret (II), the deceased," of Anubis who is upon his mountain, and of Sobek be directed thereto. And have this letter entered into the journal of the temple."
Notice how they mention the timing? They are preparing their congregations for the harvest. Jan should be privy to this type of literature, since it was found in a university historical science journal and he should allegedly have access to such information. This is a direct quote from sourced Egyptian text (P. Berlin scroll, plate 18), not some third-hand esoteric paraphrasing. I can find references to names of places like Kehkeh or names of people like Kynebi, but none of the Egyptian literature I have on-hand has this 'Kykellia' being referenced, and I have numerous copies of different Egyptian texts ranging from letters to stories to religious documents. Unfortunately, the onus is on Jan Irvin to produce the source for this claim, or else it falls into the realm of unverifiable mistakes the like Wallis Budge is most notable for making.
Jan Irvin said:
Who is not familiar with the image of the Mary holding the baby Jesus? This classic tableau has found expression in countless examples of European art. This depiction of mother and child is not merely a sentimental evocation of motherhood, nor did it originate with the birth of Christ. It actually began with Egyptian pictures of Isis and Horus child, giving us yet another example of the mysteriously subtle interweaving of religious iconography and meaning in art from diverse cultures.”
~ Christian Rätsch, Ph.D.
The above discovery was verified last night by Acharya S, and was sent to other scholars as well. Not only have we re-discovered one of the largest COVER-UPS in academic history, but it also appears that because of Rätsch, Mead, Vossen, and my diligence, that the original name of the Egyptian celebration *MAY* have been re-discovered!
A mother holding a child is the proof? Talk about a ridiculous correlation! One may as well take any imagery of a mother and child and call it a proof. Once again, until the actual textual sources for this "original name" are given for independent verification, then there is no proof of anything.
Jan Irvin said:
The above quote I found is MISSING in ALL translations of Epiphanius EXCEPT the one quoted above by Rätsch, and the following:
Thrice-greatest Hermes: Studies in Hellenistic Theosophy and Gnosis
By Hermes, George Robert Stow Mead
Thrice-greatest Hermes: Studies in Hellenistic Theosophy and Gnosis
""And here it will be of interest to turn to a curious statement of Epiphanius; it is missing in all editions of this Father prior to that of Dindorf (Leipzig, 1859), which was based on the very early (tenth century) Codex Marcianus 125, all previous editions being printed from a severely censured and bowdlerized fourteenth century MS.
Epiphanius is stating that the true birthday of the Christ is the Feast of Epiphany, "at a distance of thirteen days from the increase of the light [i.e. December 25]; for it needs must have been that this should be a figure of our Lord Jesus Christ Himself and of His twelve disciples, who make up the thirteen days of the increase of the Light." The Feast of the Epiphany was a great day in Egypt, connected with the "Birth of the Aeon,"--a phase of the "Birth of Horus." For Epiphanius thus continues:
And here Jan (and apparently, his source as well) performs the good old switcheroo. You see, Epiphanius here is talking about the holiday that the Greek and Russian Orthodox churches celebrate
this very day as the birth of Christ, which is otherwise known as Advent. The switcheroo is where the claim that the "Birth of the Aeon" (a Greek word) and the claim that the "Birth of Horus" are somehow connected to this date. Unfortunately for Irvin and friends, Epiphanius does not name a date, and since he is speaking of the Eastern Orthodoxy observance, which is January the 6th, the claims being made connecting it to December 25th are off by 13 days... yet another of the many errors with dates that Jan and DM (Acharya) make with their faulty sourcing. Interestingly enough, DM Murdock (Acharya) should know better, since she claims to be able to read ancient Greek and speak Greek fluently-- this is a poor and utterly sloppy example of shoddy scholarship on both their parts. The Panarion by Epiphanius is a list of heresies he wrote to the heads of the church in Constantinople in the fourth century, long after ancient Egyptian religious practices had died out and well after the ethnic Egyptians had been practically bred out of existence by the influx of Greeks and Bedouin Arabs to the region under Roman rule. Even the language of the Egyptian tongue was practically lost by this time. Frankly, there is no evidence Epiphanius had any access to any information, secret or otherwise, connecting anything of ancient Egyptian religious practice to anything.
Jan Irvin said:
"How many other things in the past and present support and bear witness to this proposition, I mean the birth of Christ! [Notice how Epiphanius thinks that the similarities between Jesus and Horus actually support the Jesus story!] Indeed, the leaders of the idol-cults, filled with wiles to deceive the idol-worshippers who believe in them, in many places keep highest festival on this same night of Epiphany [=the Manifestation to Light], so that they whose hopes are in error may not seek the truth. For instance, at Alexandria, in the Koreion, as it is called--an immense temple, that is to say the Precinct of he Virgin--after they have kept all-night vigil with songs and music, chanting to their idol when the vigil is over at cock-crow, they descend with lights into an underground crypt, and carry up a wooden image lying naked on a litter, with the seal of a cross made in gold on its forehead, and on either hand two similar seals, and on either knee two others, all five seals being similarly made into gold. And they carry round the image itself, circumambulating seven times the innermost temple, to the accomplaniment of pipes, tabors and hymns, and with merry-making they carry it down again underground. And if they are asked the meaning of this mystery, they answer: 'To-day at this hour the Maiden (Kore), that is, the Virgin, gave birth to the Aeon.'"
Once again, Epiphanius wouldn't have known anything about ancient Egyptian practices regarding Horus. He would only have known of the various Romanesque cults who were vying for legitimacy at the time after Constantine's legitimizing of Christianity, where many of the various cults were adopting either Christian rituals or Mithraic rituals, since those two were the 'strongest' politically (Christianity in connection to Constantine and his legitimization, Mithras because it remained popular among the soldier classes).
Jan Irvin said:
He further adds that at Petra, in Arabia, where, among other places, this mystery was also performed, the Son of the Virgin is called by a name meaning the "Alone-begotten of the Lord."
That "Son of the Virgin" would be the Jesus story. Why Jan or anyone else thinks otherwise is beyond me, but considering the proximity to Judea and the nearly 400 years the story had time to spread, this should be no surprise considering what I said above about the mystery cults attempting to gain legitimacy.
Jan Irvin said:
Here, then, at Alexandria, in every probability the very environment of our treatise, we have a famous mystery-rite, solemnized in the Temple of the Virgin, who gives birth to a Son, the Aeon. This, we shall not be rash in assuming, signifies not only the birth of the new year, but also still more profound mysteries, when we remember the words of the Naassene Document quoted above: "For such a man is the Virgin, big with child, conceiving and bearing a Son,--not psychic, not fleshly [nor, we may add, temporal], but a blessed Aeon of Aeons"--that is, an Eternity of Eternities, an immortal God." [...]
Wow. That's such a fragmented and mixed-up mistranslation of more than one source that I'm not even sure where to begin. Instead, I'll simply continue to point out that if a list of heretical practices from a church 'leader' from the fourth century is the best these guys can come up with for their claims that Christianity is tied to religions like ancient Egypt, then they are already proving how little they know of Egyptian history in the first place, how little they actually bother looking at source material (both Egyptian, Greek, and Latin, among others), and how they continue to fail to provide any actual proof from any source material and instead rely on questionable paraphrasing in an out-of-context manner without providing any concrete evidence to back up their claims.
Jan Irvin said:
With the similarities between Horus and Jesus officially PROVEN, the attacks on Zeitgeist (and our own work) are now assuredly false.
Still playing the victim, I see. Apparently, pointing out where the claims are based on false pretenses, incorrect translations, misquoting, and other sundry errors is tantamount to attacks in Jan and DM Murdock's mind. That's the wind-up, and here's the pitch:
Jan Irvin said:
Further research on these topics, placing the research in the historical context as I recommended previously in a thread on our website, is to be found in the new, official release of the Zeitgeist Companion by Acharya S. that was released last week. The Companion Guide to ZEITGEIST, Part 1
Yep. "Buy my stuff to know more." My only question is: why not provide it for free if it's so important?
Jan Irvin said:
In other words: please spam boards across the internet with this posting.