ZEITGEIST, The Movie

By "interpretational" do you mean that the translator may have read meaning into texts that really wasn't there when held up to the scrutiny of later study ? Or are there Egyptologists still out there defending the work of guys like Massey ?

I know i saw Stargate, but unfortunately I can't remember the movie at all. The Wiki entry on it reminded me that it did have a significant Egyptian component to it, and I can understand the appeal ancient Egypt has in popular culture. While we're 'fessing up to watching and liking cheesy movies, this is where I admit my wearing an Ankh after watching Logan's Run.

So given ancient Egypt's appeal and my assumption that most people who might watch and appreciate a movie like Zeitgeist are going to subscribe to a spirituality other than Christianity ( if they subscribe to a spiritual philosophy at all ) and are most likely still rebelling against *a Christian upbringing*...or...*our Christian society/culture* I can see where people might want the assertions in the movie to be true.

I agree with the analysis that part 1 was in the movie to set an *us vs them* tone given that ( at least in the US ) most of the power brokers, like past and present presidents subscribe to a Christian outlook. Thing is though, if the Jews are supposed to be behind the whole NWO thing, why didn't Zeitgeist attack Judaism instead of Christianity?

To politically sensitive, I suppose.
 
By "interpretational" do you mean that the translator may have read meaning into texts that really wasn't there when held up to the scrutiny of later study ? Or are there Egyptologists still out there defending the work of guys like Massey ?

I mean that they weren't doing a simple dissemination of the original heiroglyphs from one language to another. That alone has its difficulties, especially with heiroglyphs. Instead, they provided analyses of the texts, in the effort to translate the concepts and ideas, not simply the words which translators had many difficulties over the years determining contexts and even simple things like grammar. They were, essentially, doing the best they could with what they had in most cases (and, specifically, in Massey's case IMO). The trouble is where the perspective of the person attempting to frame these ancient text into an understandable descriptive or narrative piece of writing ends and the actual frame and context of the original ancient text begins. In many ways, authors like Massey were working on things which had very little frame of reference to work with in the first place. I think a lot of intellectual leeway is given to many of these early studies because of this, or because they made other contributions to Egyptology in general, which consists of many different fields of study beyond looking at texts.


I know i saw Stargate, but unfortunately I can't remember the movie at all. The Wiki entry on it reminded me that it did have a significant Egyptian component to it, and I can understand the appeal ancient Egypt has in popular culture. While we're 'fessing up to watching and liking cheesy movies, this is where I admit my wearing an Ankh after watching Logan's Run.

The cool thing with Stargate was how much they actually did their research. Sure, they didn't do their research for accuracy, but they didn't sound like idiots when using references and were actually building a fiction on top of pre-existing fringe theories, which gave them a lot of their research work in the form of books already written. I was also impressed with how they constantly integrated historic cultural aspects in small (though, once again, not always accurate) ways when they turned it into a series, first on Showtime and then on the SciFi Channel. The shows have diverged far away from their early stuff using historical references in weird ways, but I think that contributed to why I have been a fan of the show in the long run.


So given ancient Egypt's appeal and my assumption that most people who might watch and appreciate a movie like Zeitgeist are going to subscribe to a spirituality other than Christianity ( if they subscribe to a spiritual philosophy at all ) and are most likely still rebelling against *a Christian upbringing*...or...*our Christian society/culture* I can see where people might want the assertions in the movie to be true.

I think that was a heavy influence on the creators of the film, though I'm not sure about the intended audience. The films seems more to me like proselytizing their ideal after hearing about or reading some stuff that really struck them as feeling "true." Not unlike someone reading a book like Brave New World or Stranger in a Strange Land and coming away with a whole new worldview that they feel they just have to share with everyone who doesn't seem like they ever thought about it.


I agree with the analysis that part 1 was in the movie to set an *us vs them* tone given that ( at least in the US ) most of the power brokers, like past and present presidents subscribe to a Christian outlook. Thing is though, if the Jews are supposed to be behind the whole NWO thing, why didn't Zeitgeist attack Judaism instead of Christianity?

To politically sensitive, I suppose.

Christianity is the big kid on the block. It's like shooting at a target the size of a mountain... pretty hard to not hit something on it.
 
I mean that they weren't doing a simple dissemination of the original heiroglyphs from one language to another. That alone has its difficulties, especially with heiroglyphs. Instead, they provided analyses of the texts, in the effort to translate the concepts and ideas, not simply the words which translators had many difficulties over the years determining contexts and even simple things like grammar. They were, essentially, doing the best they could with what they had in most cases (and, specifically, in Massey's case IMO). The trouble is where the perspective of the person attempting to frame these ancient text into an understandable descriptive or narrative piece of writing ends and the actual frame and context of the original ancient text begins. In many ways, authors like Massey were working on things which had very little frame of reference to work with in the first place. I think a lot of intellectual leeway is given to many of these early studies because of this, or because they made other contributions to Egyptology in general, which consists of many different fields of study beyond looking at texts.

Is it also not the case that it's really very difficult to decide from the variety of papyri produced over such a long time just what it was the Egyptians actually did believe? Pantheism, polytheism, monotheism, I mean, is it actually clear? I've heard before that, over the timespan of the Egyptian dynasties, their core religious concepts and values altered considerably, through frequently the same mythological characters appear, just playing altered roles. Is this true?

GreNME said:
Productions like the Zeitgeist film, however, are intellectually sloppy and a better example of how a little bit of knowledge can be dangerous when the understanding of how to apply it is involved. It may very well be that the makers of the film honestly sought to "uncover" something with their sources, but many of the more contemporary sources should know better than to follow such narrow and exclusive schools of thought on subjects that are so broad and in many ways vague to begin with.

I don't see Zeitgeist like this at all. The film clearly has a major agenda to convince people and, given the low budget, does an exceptional job of this. It makes excellent use of the power of suggestion, it makes excellent use of the lack of hard evidence. On a propoganda level this movie should get an Oscar. It hammers anything coming out of Hollywood. It's been written by people who know how to convince, who've studied the art of persuasion. Really, on this level, it's absolutely top notch. It's still picking up 1,000,000 plus views a month on Google Video alone, and a lot of these are through email embedding, implying a lot of people watch it and say to their friends "you have to see this movie." It's been in the Top 3 on the Google Video chart for months.

Of course, it's not even attempting to directly uncover truth. It's CT propaganda par excellence.

Nick
 
Is it also not the case that it's really very difficult to decide from the variety of papyri produced over such a long time just what it was the Egyptians actually did believe? Pantheism, polytheism, monotheism, I mean, is it actually clear?

The Egyptians believed many things over many years. During most of that time, they were polytheists who had a list of gods that they worshipped in different degrees, usually with one god as represented by the pharaoh. This was never the same, and indeed the Egyptian religion saw changes over the course of the dynasties. There is one period of monotheism that we can tell from the history of Egypt, and that was during the time of Akhenaten.

So, the case itself is that there is no single solid all-encompassing "religion" for ancient Egypt. There doesn't even exist a word that I know of for the word "religion" in Egypt, not as we know of the word as an organized set of beliefs.


I've heard before that, over the timespan of the Egyptian dynasties, their core religious concepts and values altered considerably, through frequently the same mythological characters appear, just playing altered roles. Is this true?

It is what happened insofar as modern study can tell. There were even differences in who was worshipped between Upper and Lower Egypt at most given times. Once again, Akhenaten seems to be the single outlying period where there was an "Atenism" form of monotheistic worship.


I don't see Zeitgeist like this at all. The film clearly has a major agenda to convince people and, given the low budget, does an exceptional job of this. It makes excellent use of the power of suggestion, it makes excellent use of the lack of hard evidence. On a propoganda level this movie should get an Oscar. It hammers anything coming out of Hollywood. It's been written by people who know how to convince, who've studied the art of persuasion. Really, on this level, it's absolutely top notch. It's still picking up 1,000,000 plus views a month on Google Video alone, and a lot of these are through email embedding, implying a lot of people watch it and say to their friends "you have to see this movie." It's been in the Top 3 on the Google Video chart for months.

I think you give it more credit than it deserves. It goes over a lot of stuff very quickly and covers up its holes with flashy transitions. As the saying goes: "If you can't fight them off with facts then bury them in bulls***." It's effective in the same way that used car salemen are effective-- they tug on as much gullibility as they can grasp, then get in and get you out the door or on to the next subject before you have a chance to think about the pitch you were just given.

Ironically, that kind of technique is what turns quick converts away from Christianity later on when they begin doubting.


Of course, it's not even attempting to directly uncover truth. It's CT propaganda par excellence.

Well, it pretends to incover "truth" but does so with little basis in fact. So I guess I agree about the propaganda part.
 
I think you give it more credit than it deserves. It goes over a lot of stuff very quickly and covers up its holes with flashy transitions. As the saying goes: "If you can't fight them off with facts then bury them in bulls***." It's effective in the same way that used car salemen are effective-- they tug on as much gullibility as they can grasp, then get in and get you out the door or on to the next subject before you have a chance to think about the pitch you were just given.

Hi GreNME,

Thanks for your insights about Egyptian beliefs.

re: the movie, I would challenge any film-maker on the planet to create a movie on this budget level that can pull in 40,000+ views daily on Google Video. Really Speilberg, the Coen Bros anyone. Zeitgeist is a subtle masterpiece. It's sole objective, as I see it, is to pull people in and create groundswell for more debate. Like I said it's a propaganda movie par excellence.

Nick
 
I am 1 hour and 31 minutes in. This is the most unadulterated, pressure-packed barrel of bull[rule8] I have yet seen in my life.

Part One: Why the Jews and the Christians Are Evil
Part Two: Why 9/11 Was An Inside Job
Part Three: Why the International Bankers Have Been Getting Away With It For Centuries

All of our favorites are here. It moves from CT to CT so fast that a library would have be dedicated to debunking the whole thing. It's insidious.

ETA: OMG, they used a clip of Carl Sagan at the end! Sweet Sufferin' Jeebus.

So Jesus really walked on the water, turned water into wine, and rose from the dead? Great, this is the place for me to learn more about mythology.

The next thing I'll expect to hear is that the Virgin Mary was really a virgin!
 
So Jesus really walked on the water, turned water into wine, and rose from the dead? Great, this is the place for me to learn more about mythology.

The next thing I'll expect to hear is that the Virgin Mary was really a virgin!

Why did you quote boloboffin if your post didn't actually respond to anything he said in that quote? That didn't make any sense.
 
R U A Believer?

Why did you quote boloboffin if your post didn't actually respond to anything he said in that quote? That didn't make any sense.

Because bolobuffoon didn't respond to anything that was in Zeitgeist. There is nothing in the movie that says Christians or Jews are evil.

[But I'll admit the persecution of Galileo has never tickled my fancy]

The movie debunks several myths; Jesus was the son of God, Jesus was resurrected, and WTC 7 fell down because of an office fire.

Why don't you respond to anything in my quote?
 
Why don't you respond to anything in my quote?

Because you're trolling.

I tell you what: you give me a few of the points in the movie you think it broke wide open, and you and I can cover them one at a time.

I could always give you the same challenge I gave to thesyntaxera and ask you to show me which Egyptian text mentions Anup the Baptizer and where it's mentioned. Or if you want a different one, you can find for me the Egyptian text that tells of Horus dying and rising again in three days. Or, hey, you could simply just name for everyone here the alleged twelve disciples of Horus.

You see, the movie didn't prove any of that. It claimed it and used sources that can't prove it either. I can even point you to translations of the texts to give you a head start. You can not only show you aren't trolling, but you can also prove something that no one else has ever been able to prove using ancient Egypt as a source.
 
GreNME...I can see why there's be a considerable amount of slack granted to intrepretational researchers given the difficulty and complexity of deciphering hieroglyphics ( something I know nothing about ) especially if there were no established frames of reference. So Massey wasn't a bad guy then...just doing his best with maybe a smattering of desire for an interpretation he visualised as a non- Christian.

Nick...It is a good propaganda film, a little cheesy for my tastes but I did actually read 400+ posts in this thread before watching the movie over three days, I knew what to expect. I also found An Inconvenient Truth to be convincing too.

But they key here, IMO, is to identify it AS a propaganda film. Propaganda distributed by whom, I'm a little unsure of but I have a few suspects in mind. I really really hope this doesn't come down to mundane reasons....like attention seeking.

Ahhhh the joys of the internet. Reading a story and tracking, or at least trying to track down what really is and separate it out from what people want you to believe:)
 
GreNME...I can see why there's be a considerable amount of slack granted to intrepretational researchers given the difficulty and complexity of deciphering hieroglyphics ( something I know nothing about ) especially if there were no established frames of reference. So Massey wasn't a bad guy then...just doing his best with maybe a smattering of desire for an interpretation he visualised as a non- Christian.

Absolutely. I don't think he was being intellectually dishonest. He was a linguist. Just not for a language that the world knew very little about (and no one alive has heard spoken).
 
The movie debunks several myths; Jesus was the son of God, Jesus was resurrected, and WTC 7 fell down because of an office fire.

Why don't you respond to anything in my quote?

Hey Galileo,

I am a believer. However, I think Part 1 of the movie, whilst highly convincing for most who haven't studied this field, would I think really struggle to cut it with the more scholarly types. I think the makers would personally have been better off to drag all these mythoi back to the Hero's Journey, or Life/Purgation/Rebirth, something like this. It's harder for the viewer to take in but it is a lot stronger case than Sun worship.

Part 2 is just taken from LC mostly, I figure, and it's not so much my scene.

Part 3 I think is great but personally I would have put in a lot more info about the Breton Woods organisations, World Bank and IMF, as this can be presented in a way that is so strong it will have even ardent anti CTists struggling with their beliefs that there is no globalist hidden agenda in banking.

Still, it is a great movie and it excites me to see its figures on Google Vid.

Nick
 
Because you're trolling.

I tell you what: you give me a few of the points in the movie you think it broke wide open, and you and I can cover them one at a time.

I could always give you the same challenge I gave to thesyntaxera and ask you to show me which Egyptian text mentions Anup the Baptizer and where it's mentioned. Or if you want a different one, you can find for me the Egyptian text that tells of Horus dying and rising again in three days. Or, hey, you could simply just name for everyone here the alleged twelve disciples of Horus.

You see, the movie didn't prove any of that. It claimed it and used sources that can't prove it either. I can even point you to translations of the texts to give you a head start. You can not only show you aren't trolling, but you can also prove something that no one else has ever been able to prove using ancient Egypt as a source.

The major source for part one of the film is the classic work "the Golden Bough":

The Golden Bough
A Study in Magic and Religion
Sir James George Frazer
http://www.bartleby.com/196/
 
The major source for part one of the film is the classic work "the Golden Bough":

The Golden Bough
A Study in Magic and Religion
Sir James George Frazer
http://www.bartleby.com/196/

Yes, but that's not an Egyptian text. Which Egyptian text gave him and the other sources the information for this claim? If you had bothered to read my other posts, there are loads of freely-available online translations of ancient Egyptian texts. All you have to do is tell me which one it is, and we can go and check for ourselves.

The thing is, you (and Frazer, and Massey, and Zeitgeist, and other authors) can't give us this critical piece of information that would actually prove their claims.

So, go ahead and track down the Egyptian text that Frazer or Massey or anyone else you want to use actually drew this conclusion from, and then you and I can go look at the texts ourselves and see whether what they said is factual or not. It's really that easy.

Seriously, read the last seven or eight pages. I think I've given enough explanation to show I'm not simply ignorant about this subject. I'm perfectly willing to actually discuss the talking points with you, but only if you and I can both work from the same original sources. Either the Egyptians actually wrote down "Anup the Baptizer" or they didn't. Either the Egyptians wrote a story about Horus dying and rising again in three days or they didn't.

This is how history works. If there is evidence, then it's worth considering. If someone makes a claim without evidence, then they need to present evidence to support the claim. All you have to do is tell me where in anything we have from ancient Egypt this evidence is, and then we can both go look at it ourselves.

Is this agreeable to you?
 
Yes, but that's not an Egyptian text. Which Egyptian text gave him and the other sources the information for this claim? If you had bothered to read my other posts, there are loads of freely-available online translations of ancient Egyptian texts. All you have to do is tell me which one it is, and we can go and check for ourselves.

The thing is, you (and Frazer, and Massey, and Zeitgeist, and other authors) can't give us this critical piece of information that would actually prove their claims.

So, go ahead and track down the Egyptian text that Frazer or Massey or anyone else you want to use actually drew this conclusion from, and then you and I can go look at the texts ourselves and see whether what they said is factual or not. It's really that easy.

Seriously, read the last seven or eight pages. I think I've given enough explanation to show I'm not simply ignorant about this subject. I'm perfectly willing to actually discuss the talking points with you, but only if you and I can both work from the same original sources. Either the Egyptians actually wrote down "Anup the Baptizer" or they didn't. Either the Egyptians wrote a story about Horus dying and rising again in three days or they didn't.

This is how history works. If there is evidence, then it's worth considering. If someone makes a claim without evidence, then they need to present evidence to support the claim. All you have to do is tell me where in anything we have from ancient Egypt this evidence is, and then we can both go look at it ourselves.

Is this agreeable to you?

Here is the complete source page for Zeitgeist, part 1:

- BASIC SOURCES -

PART 1

* Special thanks to Acharya S for her consultation for this section*

Massey, Gerald - The Historic Jesus and the Mythical Christ, The Book Tree

Carpenter, Edward: Pagan and Christian Creeds: Their Origin and Meaning Book Tree, 1998

Acharya S - The Christ Conspiracy, Adventures Unlimited Press

Massey, Gerald - Ancient Egypt: Light of the World, Kessinger Publishing

Churchward, Albert -The Origin and Evolution of Religion, The Book Tree

Acharya S - Suns of God, Adventures Unlimited Press

Murdock, D.M. - Who was Jesus?, Steller House Publishing

Allegro, John - The Dead Sea Scrolls and the Christian Myth, Prometheus Books

Frazer, Sir James: The Golden Bough, Touchstone Pub., 1890

Maxwell, Tice, Snow - That Old Time Religion, The Book Tree

Rolleston, Frances: Mazzaroth, Rivingtons, Waterloo Place, 1862

Cumont, Franz: Astrology and Religion Among the Greeks and Romans Cosimo Classics 1912

King James Version, The Holy Bible, Holman

Fideler, David: Jesus Christ, Sun of God Quest Books, 1993

Berry, Gerald: Religions Of The World, Barnes & Noble Pub., 1965

Leedom, Tim C - The Book Your Church Doesn't Want You To Read, TS Books

Paine, Thomas - The Age of Reason

Wheless, Joseph: Forgery in Christianity: A Documented Record of the Foundations of the Christian Religion 1930

Remsburg, John E. - The Christ: A Critical Review and Analysis of the Evidence of His Existence, Prometheus Books

Massey, Gerald - Egyptian Book of the Dead and the Mysteries of Amenta, Kessinger Publishing

Irvin, Jan & Rutajit, Andrew - Astrotheology and Shamanism, The Book Tree

Doherty, Earl - The Jesus Puzzle: Did Christianity Begin with a Mythical Christ?, Age of Reason Pub.

Campbell, Joseph - Creative Mythology: The Masks of God, Penguin

Doane, T.W. - Bible Myths and Their Parallels in Other Religions, Health Research

Maxwell, Jordan: The Light of World (Film Series) IRES

Singh, Madanjeet: The Sun- Symbol of Power and Life, UNESCO, 1993

Flemming, Brian: The God Who Wasn't There (Film) 2005

The Naked Truth (Film) IRES

Jackson, John G. : Christianity Before Christ, American Atheist Press, 1985

http://zeitgeistmovie.com/sources.htm

The makers of Zeitgeist are not scholars who read ancient Egyptian texts, they are movie-makers working with the findings of legitimate scholars.

It is not the job of a movie-maker to go back and redo all the research over the past 100 years and re-invent the wheel.
 
Here is the complete source page for Zeitgeist, part 1:

http://zeitgeistmovie.com/sources.htm

I could give you just as many sources for every bit of information I have stated over the last seven or eight pages. However, I can also cite actual Egyptian text in my sources, which is better than Zeitgeist can claim.


The makers of Zeitgeist are not scholars who read ancient Egyptian texts, they are movie-makers working with the findings of legitimate scholars.

But not legitimate claims. I have stated over and over and over that you will not find support for the claims made in Part 1 in any scholarly group of Egyptologists. The only people who make these claims cannot support the claims with actual Egyptian source material.

It is not the job of a movie-maker to go back and redo all the research over the past 100 years and re-invent the wheel.

No, but it should be their job to be intellectually honest. They are not, because as I already pointed out the evidence they claim exists does not exist.

I can prove this to you. I can prove to you that the Egyptian texts I know of have no mention of those things. I can give you the web addresses to check for yourself. What you and none of those sources you claim can do is give a name for which Egyptian text supports their claim, nor the actual passages from that text support that claim.

I can show you my proof. You can't. You see, I've actually read a few of those 'sources' listed. How many have you read?
 
I could give you just as many sources for every bit of information I have stated over the last seven or eight pages. However, I can also cite actual Egyptian text in my sources, which is better than Zeitgeist can claim.




But not legitimate claims. I have stated over and over and over that you will not find support for the claims made in Part 1 in any scholarly group of Egyptologists. The only people who make these claims cannot support the claims with actual Egyptian source material.



No, but it should be their job to be intellectually honest. They are not, because as I already pointed out the evidence they claim exists does not exist.

I can prove this to you. I can prove to you that the Egyptian texts I know of have no mention of those things. I can give you the web addresses to check for yourself. What you and none of those sources you claim can do is give a name for which Egyptian text supports their claim, nor the actual passages from that text support that claim.

I can show you my proof. You can't. You see, I've actually read a few of those 'sources' listed. How many have you read?

I am not an Egyptoligist.

The parts of part 1 that I am informed about in the film were accurate. A few which come to mind are:

a) The birth of Moses and the birth of Sargon

b) The precession of equinoxes

c) The 12 tribes of Israel, the 12 signs of the Zodiac and the 12 disciples

d) The epic of Gilgamesh and Noah's ark

Even if the film go it wrong on one point, Horus, there were plenty of other facts regarding Christianity borrowing myths from prior pagan religions.

That's the point. The story of Jesus is mostly myth. He didn't rise from the dead to save us from our sins, his mother wasn't a virgin, and WTC 7 didn't fall from an office fire in the 7th floor window at 4:45 P.M.
 
The story of Jesus is mostly myth. He didn't rise from the dead to save us from our sins, his mother wasn't a virgin, and WTC 7 didn't fall from an office fire in the 7th floor window at 4:45 P.M.

Did anybody order a stundie?
 
The major source for part one of the film is the classic work "the Golden Bough":

The Golden Bough
A Study in Magic and Religion
Sir James George Frazer
http://www.bartleby.com/196/

I don't really think so, dude. The Golden Bough's a classic of the comparative mythos genre and a beautiful work. I haven't looked at it in a decade but from what I recall it's crucially different from Zeitgeist in 2 ways....

- it doesn't try to tie everything in to Sun worship
- it doesn't try and line up events the way the movie does

Zeitgeist does this highly convincing thing of lining up events and attributes from different mythologies back to back. It looks great, totally convincing. Trouble is, you're going to struggle to get that one past the scholars. Too much of it comes from sources who were real keen, one way or the other, to find links.

The list of source material they put on their site is also great but a lot of those guys ain't scholars neither.

Part 1 is a heavy over-simplification but it works for me because it gets people to look closer.

Nick
 
Well...I don't seem to be having to much success getting out of the Wikipedia as a source state of mind, but one thing the mighty Wiki seemed to stress is the personal agendas, bias, and lack of scholarly acceptance of the majority of those contributors listed above.

GreNME...now might be a good time to release those links that you have that show the lack of scholarly acceptance to the works of guys like Massey et al. I'm happy with Wiki, and I do notice terms like "books that attracted popular attention and scholarly derision."
when describing John Marco Allegro, one of the contributors.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom