ZEITGEIST, The Movie

I wouldn't necessarily call their doors "open," so to speak. With the Rosecrucians there are fees for attending or joining, and with the Masons there are contributions that are made.

I would quote them, from the Fama Fraternitatis (the first Rosicrucian manifesto) - "none of them should profess any other thing, than to cure the sick, and that gratis" (italics mine). These days they usually charge admin fees but I think they're generally not-for-profit orgs.

GreNME said:
Granted, neither of them are strictly social networks-- they both engage in some charity work or donation, for example-- but what I'm talking about is the main thrust of the membership nowadays.

Dear me, not even any coursework? Things are getting slack.


GreNME said:
As a matter of fact, one of the most common complaints I hear against them is their tendency to be considered clandestine and working behind the scenes. To someone who has investigated and at least considered joining one of them, I couldn't find any evidence of such. The Rosecrucians even have a lot of scheduled 'meetings' (more like speaking engagements on certain topics) listed online, if you find a location near you. Still, these groups have a mystique of being a 'secret society' and that mystique has served them well in the past. It's also served to build up a lot of distrust and animosity toward them. Some openly distrust them (look at all the CTs involving Masons), while others mimic them (I won't get into naming names, because it involves one or two religious groups and they take it very personally). To most people, though, they barely register.


I think your comments above are true. But if you're still interested in membership I'd recommend Builders of the Adytum (BOTA), based in LA. Dr Paul Foster Case (1884-1954), the founder was, behind the scenes, one of the central forces in the US Western Mystery Tradition (WMT). A good 15-20 years of coursework.

GreNME said:
Interestingly, much like the government, groups like the Rosecroix and Masons have the dual honor of being overestimated and underestimated nearly simultaneously when it comes to issues either applying to or sharing similarities with conspiracy theories.

Yes, CTists have, I believe, named the Masons the "political wing of Kabbalah." No, you can't have a good conspiracy theory without at least some passing reference in there.

Nick
 
I would quote them, from the Fama Fraternitatis (the first Rosicrucian manifesto) - "none of them should profess any other thing, than to cure the sick, and that gratis" (italics mine). These days they usually charge admin fees but I think they're generally not-for-profit orgs.

Those are some pretty hefty admin fees, if I recall correctly. :)

Dear me, not even any coursework? Things are getting slack.

Oh, no. The Rosecrucians, at least, offer plenty of 'coursework', I think. That's what all those scheduled engagements I mentioned are, I think. I'm sure 'coursework' fits more into the language of what they discuss, but I wasn't impressed enough to consider it that at the time.


I think your comments above are true. But if you're still interested in membership I'd recommend Builders of the Adytum (BOTA), based in LA. Dr Paul Foster Case (1884-1954), the founder was, behind the scenes, one of the central forces in the US Western Mystery Tradition (WMT). A good 15-20 years of coursework.

Thanks for the suggestion, and I'll save the name for possible correspondence, but I'm not too interested in actually acquiring any membership anywhere right now, and my studies tend to focus more on academic pursuits (that is, secondary to my career).


Yes, CTists have, I believe, named the Masons the "political wing of Kabbalah." No, you can't have a good conspiracy theory without at least some passing reference in there.

Indeed. Got to include some intrigue. :)
 
Nick. I just spent the past hour reading about Freemasons and about the only "weird" thing I can find about them ( apart from the CTs surrounding them ) is the requisite belief in a Supreme Being"

So if they want me to have faith is something greater than me and i entered their order with my preconceived notions of "how things are" wouldn't it stand to reason that I'd reject their ideas in defense of my own and quit the group ?
 
Once again, you're going to need to be way more specific in your question. There have been whole books-- and if you are interested, Elaine Pagels has one or two good ones on the gnostics-- on the subject you're asking about, so I need to know more of what you want to know before I could begin to give you a direct answer.

I'm pretty sure the question was about as specific as it needed to be. If you possess any information on the subject of mediterranean mystery schools and the influence they had on the creation of gnostic chrisitianity then why not just answer with that. Pretty simple really. You either do or you don't. If you do what is it? And while your at it, what information do you have that supports your contention that no mediterranean or middle eastern religions had any effect on what would ultimately become chrisitianity, because some of us are still waiting to examine that. You obviously have some bit of knowledge that informs your position, so why not share? I personally would really like to know how you decided on all this for yourself. Where did you get the information that debunks Nick's posted comparison chart? Why not let us examine the sources?

I disagree about it being a reasonable course. If someone makes a case for you that the Earth is flat and cites old and sometimes self-referencing sources, do you really believe that you are obligated to scour every one of those sources in order to adequately display to the person the proofs needed to show that the planet is, indeed, not flat?

How does the flat earth "theory" have any relevance to what he was asking? When researching claims such as those about the origins of christianity you have to research the source of the claims and find out if those claims are based on sound research or not. You seem to be confidant in your dismissal of them without even researching them, which is only slightly less bogus than repeating the same two catch phrases of this thread over and over..."correllation does not = causation" and "never attribute malice where you can attribute stupidity"....If you have any rock solid proof beyond unreferenced rhetoric then spill it, or this dialog will never move forward. If you honestly have no idea if there could or could not have been any cross pollination of the egyptian culture onto those cultures that led to the creation of chrisitianity then please admit so and do us all a favor.

and...

Please don't take the time to attempt to sound witty and condescending in your next reply, just please, please, please answer the questions... it will be much appreciated. Nothing you have supplied thus far has invalidated the egyptian origin of christianity hypothesis, you have only picked apart the claims of the film which seem objectionable to you, because I assume you would have preferred them to offer an entire history lesson on the development of egyptian religion with archaeological evidence(which isn't likely to exist any way)to back up those claims of origin and cross contamination. Considering the intent of the video....

Religion controls the masses, traumatizing events have been manipulated to better the power brokers, and power brokers control your life via the economy...

...I don't see why an expectation such as this even exists...

I humbly await you answer.
 
Nick. I just spent the past hour reading about Freemasons and about the only "weird" thing I can find about them ( apart from the CTs surrounding them ) is the requisite belief in a Supreme Being"

So if they want me to have faith is something greater than me and i entered their order with my preconceived notions of "how things are" wouldn't it stand to reason that I'd reject their ideas in defense of my own and quit the group ?

Don't really know, Stout. I never heard of the supreme being before. I don't think the masons much want people to join them. Maybe they headhunt a little, I don't really know. I never thought to try and join up.

I mean, on the surface of it, they do look pretty suspect. I can totally understand why David Icke used to go in such rages about them. There's this whole gang of society's most influential people. They're members of any esoteric order and prevented from giving out info about the order's activities with a vow of silence. I mean, it's ideal CT material.

There's a lot of masonic symbolism around the set-up of the USA, back in the day, so I've heard. Do they still have the all-seeing eye and capstone of the pyramid on dollar bills? Annuit Coeptis - Novus Ordo Seclorum, all that stuff. Isn't one of the more famous buildings at address 1313 somewhere or other? I mean, it's all Westernised Kabbalah.

Nick
 
I'm pretty sure the question was about as specific as it needed to be.

If you really believe that to be the case, then you are incredibly ignorant. whole courses are taught on just parts of what are covered by your question, but you are demanding of me to sum it up for you. How many words would you like it summed up in, pray tell?


If you possess any information on the subject of mediterranean mystery schools and the influence they had on the creation of gnostic chrisitianity then why not just answer with that. Pretty simple really. You either do or you don't.

Which "mystery schools" are you talking about? This is what I mean by you being vague. You aren't even sure of what you're asking, but you're expecting me to explain everything to you in a single forum post. I possess a reasonable amount of information, and wonder of wonders I have been pointing you to books and links that actually have information coming from sources other than myself!

If you do what is it?

What is what? Specify what you want and we can start from there. So far you haven't even displayed enough understanding to focus your question, instead relying on vagaries like "mystery schools" that, despite being mysterious to you doesn't mean there isn't any information out there. But first, you need to specify which ones you're asking about.


And while your at it, what information do you have that supports your contention that no mediterranean or middle eastern religions had any effect on what would ultimately become chrisitianity, because some of us are still waiting to examine that.

Hello, straw man.

Now I know you're either being incredibly deliberately obtuse or you actually have no inkling of what you're talking about. I could swear that I've actually been maintaining pretty reasonable influence by the Sumerians, Babylonians, Assyrians, and even some from Canaanites. I don't know if you're aware of this, but they're pretty darned "middle eastern" in the geographical sense of the phrase. You really need to check yourself before you say things that reflect poorly on your own lack of good faith on this matter. As a matter of fact, here is a quote of my own words way back on page 14, actually discussing some specific interests that the movie left out:
Some examples:
  1. Moses - What happened to Sargon? The comparison was standing right there in the faces of everyone, including the narrator, and the film just scoots right on past him with less than 20 seconds of exposure and goes on to try to connect Moses to Menes from Egypt and Manu from India. He was right there!
  2. Akhenaten - Without a doubt the number one, absolutely positive, sure-thing bet for someone who is doing a comparative religious study between Egypt and Judaism / Christianity would be with Akhenaten. This is the pharaoh who brought the first verifiably recorded evidence of a monotheistic religion in that whole region (from North Africa up to the Mediterranian). Even most of the scholars who reference Egypt as a major influence on Christianity use Akhenaten as their primary example! Why no mention of the obvious?
  3. Babylon - The Jews didn't get their calendar and their constellation symbols from the Greeks, they got them from Babylon. Babylon. Where the heck was Babylon in this whole film?
  4. Mithra - Get off the whole Jesus comparison attempts! The existing mythology surrounding Mithra tends to be more relationally comparable to stories involving Abraham, Moses, and David.
  5. Rome - I couldn't believe how little attention the film and narrator gave to Rome as a major influence on the formation of Christian theology in the liturgical sense. Sure, quoting Justin Martyr is all well and good, except they missed the context and Martyr had less of a contribution in merging Roman practices than, say Ireneaus, Ignatius, or (most of all)Constantine. Any of those alternatives would have been better examples. Information like the establishment of Christian churches in conjunction with Roman political governing buildings, and how the church simply had to step into an administrative role after the crumbling of Rome as an empire happened would have seemed to me to be directly in line with the case they were trying to make. That and things like it never appeared on the screen, though-- just a couple of weak quotes from Martyr.


You obviously have some bit of knowledge that informs your position, so why not share? I personally would really like to know how you decided on all this for yourself. Where did you get the information that debunks Nick's posted comparison chart? Why not let us examine the sources?

How many times to I have to repeat that I've been giving links all along? How many times do I have to point out that, in cases like the baptism stuff and similar things, that the onus is on the ones claiming that it exists to actually show where it exists? Jeez, man, I have listed for you a number of books and links, and the best you've come at me with is that you trust the movie and a bunch of wikipedia links, at least half of which have actually contradicted you when I pointed out other parts of the articles. If you're questioning my lack of sourcing, then you are in the negatives as far as providing a single reason why the outrageous defenses you are giving have a single shred of credibility.

Some references I have give so far, just to show how much of an outright liar you are:
  1. A Critical Examination of "Wordprinting" from BYU - an article discussing how similarities, especially using similarities in words from separate languages, does not link the languages and cultures in a causal relationship. The reasons why such claims are flawed are discussed in the link.
    .
  2. Coincidental Similarities - a list of words collected by a linguist showing words that have similar meanings in languages that have absolutely no root relations. This displays how easy it is to make up fictitious claims based on unrelated similarities.
    .
  3. Transfigured On The Holy Mountain: The Beginnings of Christianity - by Earl Doherty. A pretty good article on the subject matter, and well-written. Also, it leads to his supplementals, like...
    .
  4. Josephus Unbound: Reopening the Josephus Question - also by Earl Doherty. A supplemental to the previous link, and one of 11 supplemental articles. I suggest them all for some interesting reading.
    .
  5. Old Testament Life and Literature by Gerald Larue. This is an excellent resource.
    .
  6. Constantine's Sword by James Carroll - this book focuses on Christian history as relating to the Jews as well as a great deal of historical examination on how Christianity developed through the centuries.
    .
  7. The Gnostic Gospels by Elaine Pagels - this book is an examination of the gospels written by the Gnostics and their Hellenistic influences; and Beyond Belief by Elaine Pagels, where she compares the Gospel of Thomas to the Gospel of John, and examines how the first couple centuries of Christian philosophical debate established Jesus as a deity, eventually including the Gospel of John as canon and discarding the Gospel of Thomas.
    .
  8. The Nag Hammadi Library - translation by James Robinson. Basically, a translation of what pretty much puts to rest earlier claims of direct Egyptian influence by Egyptologists from the 19th and early 20th century.
    .
  9. Encyclopedia Mythica article on Horus - one of the most concise brief descriptions of the mythological Horus out there on the 'pedia' sites. A quote: "As the prototype of the earthly king, there were as many Horus gods as there were rulers of Egypt, if not more."


All of these are links I've given on previous pages (and not even all of the links I provided). I gave you reference material to check out. And what was your response?
Whatever man, you don't even read them anyway.
I happen to have a copy of the NH by elaine pagels, but I wouldn't venture to interpret it too specifically as it seems there are many ways to digest it depending on whom I am talking to.

Whenever I tossed references your way, you either made a personal attack at me or you completely disregarded a source that has far more academic veracity than some internet movie. This is why I am calling you a liar. But if your best defense at my showing exactly how ridiculous these claims are is to attack my credibility, then I once again challenge you to bring your lady friend to this board, have her read exactly what I've been saying-- instead of getting it second-hand through your thesyntaxera-filter-- and ask her if the things I have been saying are, for the most part, credible.


How does the flat earth "theory" have any relevance to what he was asking?

You need to go look up the definition of "metaphor". I'm getting bored of doing your thinking for you in that regard.


When researching claims such as those about the origins of christianity you have to research the source of the claims and find out if those claims are based on sound research or not.

Or you could, you know, actually do research on history of the entire region in general-- one of my focuses-- and actually be able to recognize when claims are made that do not exist in any of the related study you've done of the other cultures.


You seem to be confidant in your dismissal of them without even researching them, which is only slightly less bogus than repeating the same two catch phrases of this thread over and over..."correllation does not = causation" and "never attribute malice where you can attribute stupidity"....If you have any rock solid proof beyond unreferenced rhetoric then spill it, or this dialog will never move forward. If you honestly have no idea if there could or could not have been any cross pollination of the egyptian culture onto those cultures that led to the creation of chrisitianity then please admit so and do us all a favor.

Oh baloney. I dare you to find me one EGYPTIAN reference of Anup the Baptiser, for crying out loud. It doesn't exist. Check every exhibit description of every museum you want, check any current archaeological study projects you want. I dare you to find one credible reference to Anup the Baptizer that isn't just another one of these self-referencing wild claims. It doesn't exist.


Please don't take the time to attempt to sound witty and condescending in your next reply, just please, please, please answer the questions... it will be much appreciated.

Too late for that. You have gone past the point where you can take back some of the ridiculous assertions you've made. You seem perfectly willing to take these claims as reasonable enough to believe with barely passing self-referencing sources, and yet you've ignored every single suggestion for where you can actually look, for yourself and with your own eyes, in places that can give you a better understanding of the cultures that this discussion covers. You have refused every suggestion of mine outright and practically taken the film as gospel. Your whole thesis up to this point is completely built on style over substance, and yet you don't want any criticism of the weak stance you've taken.


Nothing you have supplied thus far has invalidated the egyptian origin of christianity hypothesis, you have only picked apart the claims of the film which seem objectionable to you, because I assume you would have preferred them to offer an entire history lesson on the development of egyptian religion with archaeological evidence(which isn't likely to exist any way)to back up those claims of origin and cross contamination. Considering the intent of the video....

You're either lying or you think deliberately ignoring every contextual bit of information I've supplied. Either way, you're wrong and you don't even seem to know it.


Religion controls the masses, traumatizing events have been manipulated to better the power brokers, and power brokers control your life via the economy...

...I don't see why an expectation such as this even exists...

At this point, I honestly don't believe you have an understanding of what you just said outside of "religion controls stuff" or some equivalent.


I humbly await you answer.

You go to wikipedia and you find me some proof that "Anup the Baptizer" existed, and then we'll work on your "answers" one at a time.
 
GreNME-
Thanks for all the exposition. I should have wagered money you wouldn't provide a single piece of evidence to back your claim...what you did provide was some links to resources that might be interesting reading....but to be fair, in no way invalidate the hypothesis in question. So, to summarize what you have provided...logical proofs in place of evidence, books by laypersons on subjects that don't even appear to be making a commentary on the possiblity of the validity of this theory, and a link to a book of mormon critique....In all that you state plainly that the NHL published by pagels, or the one translated by robinson clearly refutes the hypothesis. It is important to note that there is not one single peer reviewed academic paper in your sources that directly relates to what we are talking about here.

Since it would appear as though your whole argument stems from your personal opinion based on your unexpert analysis of lay persons literature, and translations of gnostic texts(which is akin to citing the bible as a accurate source) then what do you have but a half baked theory yourself?

Explain how the NHL discredits the theory. Summarize the information you have from other sources that discredits the theory? State exactly why you believe that this theory is false in a manner that doesn't involve you invoking weak logical arguments in place of evidence or at least provide some one elses research that will validate your position(because I have found none...and believe me I looked)...nothing you have lay on the table so far has done these things.
 
You can question my status as an "expert" all you want. Funny how you can't provide one single shred of evidence of Anup the Baptizer.

Like I said, if you can provide any shred of evidence of Anup the baptizer, we can begin to discuss evidence. I could hand to you a whole library on Egyptian mythology, all from source material, and I am perfectly willing to bet you $100 USD that you could not find a single Egyptian reference to Anup the Baptizer.

You are basically demanding I prove a negative, and you are demanding that I provide source material that state explicitly that these claims are false. By your ridiculous attempt at logic, I could claim that there is an invisible pink unicorn on my roof, and since you couldn't cite a single source that specifies precisely that there is no invisible pink unicorn on my roof, nothing you say can refute my claim. Good job, you just fell into the hole of tautology. :)
 
Last edited:
You can question my status as an "expert" all you want. Funny how you can't provide one single shred of evidence of Anup the Baptizer.

First and foremost, I never endorsed the Anup the Baptizer comparison, so you can quite assuming. But since you ask here is a link to a book on google that mentions it..it's a book by Gerald Massey that you refused to look into...

from Ancient Egypt light the light of the world
http://books.google.com/books?id=Pb...ts=ehUHlecszH&sig=U52vBGesf6xBnnihBpCqdIeia4s

here is the wiki article:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anup

So he is the enbalmer...and thats what massey calls him as well.

I think it is important to note that I am not trying to validate the claims of the film, but am trying to validate the hypothesis of egyptian influence on christianity.

Like I said, if you can provide any shred of evidence of Anup the baptizer, we can begin to discuss evidence.

There are two shreds directly above.

You are basically demanding I prove a negative, and you are demanding that I provide source material that state explicitly that these claims are false.

Gee, I wonder why. You are attempting to debunk something for the "benefit of the masses" and you haven't provided a single reason that any one should believe any thing you say. If you want to be taken seriously in your counter claims then please have something to back it up. There is literally tons of referenced information out there claiming similar things as the 1st part of this film...I can find none that state what you claim as historical truth, be it websites, peer reviewed articles, or cataloged book reviews from previous publications available from jstor.

By your ridiculous attempt at logic, I could claim that there is an invisible pink unicorn on my roof, and since you couldn't cite a single source that specifies precisely that there is no invisible pink unicorn on my roof, nothing you say can refute my claim. Good job, you just fell into the hole of tautology.

Well since we are not talking about pink unicorns on your roof, my postion falls into the acceptable range of expectation considering the "acceptable occasion" section of the negative proof explanation provided by wiki...allow me to remind you:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_proof
Appropriate occasions
In some cases a reversed burden of proof may be appropriate. This occurs when there are two competing explanations, and neither can be confirmed by observation. For example: when an empirical relationship has been observed, but the underlying mechanism is unknown, it may be reasonable to infer from the lack of conflicting evidence that the observed relationship is most likely causal. (see Inference to the Best Explanation)

Criteria for selecting the best explanation in this case could involve Occam's razor, which states that the best explanation tends to be the one requiring the least amount of additional assumptions. Such an explanation invokes the fewest intermediate factors while maintaining its predictive power; that is, its ability to explain current data and to predict future data.[1] However, according to the scientific method, the relationship is not formally proven in this instance, and to assert that it is so until disproven is fallacious.

In this case you need to prove that there is no way the egyptian mythologies couldn't have been transposed onto other cultures over time specifically the ones dealing with the origin of christianity. There is much info out there that supports the proposition of the film, and you claim to have information that contradicts those correlations. If you have it, then I fail to see why summarizing it is so difficult. If you are so well versed in the material then you should be able I would think to pop off a few paragraphs explaining why so that others can fact check you.

If we are "making an inference from the best explanation" using occams razor then I think it is more than fair to expect you to provide the source material that you claim invalidates the theory for our examination. If you can't then I suspect you are putting everyone on.
 
What part of "Egyptian" do you not understand? Funny how Gerald Massey's book isn't an Egyptian source. What is the name of the Egyptian source? You don't want to trust me for saying that no Egyptian text exists, but you'll trust him without verifying. Give me something to verify with. If you can name the text, we can probably find some images showing the heiroglyphs, and I can give you the names of books translating them properly, the names of the authors who did the translation, and the satisfaction of showing you how us people who actually study these things don't rely on Google and Wikipedia to do the thinking for us.


If you are trying to say "Anup" is basically the Egyptian god Anubis, though-- follow your own wikipedia links-- then thanks for proving my point for me yet again. :)
 
If we are "making an inference from the best explanation" using occams razor then I think it is more than fair to expect you to provide the source material that you claim invalidates the theory for our examination. If you can't then I suspect you are putting everyone on.

Occam's Razor does not include trying to make connections or comparing a god of the underworld in Egypt to the dude who baptised Jesus in Christianity. Occam's Razor is coming to the conclusion that the assumed connection of Anubis to John the Baptist is too much of a leap of faith, since no evidence exists to support it. You see, Occam's Razor looks to the simplest probability, the one with the least amount of steps, the most straightforward, not requiring any extra assumptions be made.

But you still have a chance to cite the Egyptian text. :)
 
I dunno...Gerald Massey looks pretty respectable to me. British Museum, Egyptologist, translated his own hieroglyphics and made the Christian Egyptian connection himself.

Were his findings proven to be in error ?
 
I dunno...Gerald Massey looks pretty respectable to me. British Museum, Egyptologist, translated his own hieroglyphics and made the Christian Egyptian connection himself.

Were his findings proven to be in error ?

I think I want thesyntaxera to come up with some names of Egyptian texts before I get into that. I mention Massey in my PDF of notes a few pages back, but I didn't go into details about his credentials. I knew Massey was who thesyntaxera was going to reference, because it's the one everyone cites (very few ever bother with Budge any more). However, none of them can reference the Egyptian text it allegedly came from because Massey isn't clear about it, the same as he is throughout that book with its references and "translations." I expect he'll come back with something like The Book of Gates or The Book of the Dead, both of which we will be able to go over together here in this thread with both contemporary accurate translations and actual images of the heiroglyphs. Since his Google search-- which pulls up that link he gave in the number four position for me when searching "Gerald Massey" and about ninth when searching "Anup the Baptizer"-- pulled up a copy of Massey's book with loads of missing pages, a more complete version can be found here (another of those self-referencing new-age-pretending-to-be-old-age sites).

The problem thesyntaxera is facing here is that he's attempting to argue with someone who's been studying this since before he ever got into middle school (he's in college now, I surmise this because he wouldn't have a JSTOR login unless he borrowed it from a friend). However, he wants full understanding right away, ostensibly to fall easily into his outstretched hands. Unfortunately, that's like someone who has never programmed before coming to a hacker and demanding to know how to hack before he even understands programming, or like someone who comes to a native speaker of Japanese and demanding to understand the language without ever learning even the basic words. So, I point him to materials to give him a beginning, which he summarily ignores. I haven't even gotten into the more complex Egyptian stuff yet, and he's already unwilling to actually consider that there are resources out there better than Wikipedia or Google for finding information about specific subjects. Since he doesn't want to hear any of it from me, I'm challenging him to do his own research, because at least then he's actively looking instead of assuming. Turning up Massey was the easy part, now he has to actually read Massey's writing and find the actual references.

I'm being as open as I can in explaining that it isn't possible to just spit out exactly the information on the general suject without context, and even his own personal friend explained that such subjects aren't going to fit into a simple non-contextual box. At this point, either he has to prove he really wants to find some information on the questions he asked or admit that he's really just disagreeing because he was convinced by the movie.
 
Would Massey be considered the first person to propose the link between Egypt and Christianity ? I realise now that it was Massey I was referring to when I mentioned I'd found a reference dated something like 1863.

I see now that Massey's been republished, in 2006. I wonder if that inspired the movie ?

Anyways I'm pretty wikipedia on this topic myself but I couldn't find anyone who preceded Massey, and you're saying that there's a problem with the actual source material Massey used in his research. ( the actual references ) ?

Can it really be that simple ?
 
Would Massey be considered the first person to propose the link between Egypt and Christianity ?
Oh, absolutely not. Claims that Christianity got its roots from Egypt date back to at least the 17th century, if I recall correctly. Masonic lore relies heavily on this, as a matter of fact.


I realise now that it was Massey I was referring to when I mentioned I'd found a reference dated something like 1863.

He was a pretty well-regarded linguist and poet, and was fairly prolific in his writing considering his other duties (he wrote a lot of non-Egyptology stuff).


I see now that Massey's been republished, in 2006. I wonder if that inspired the movie ?

I'm fairly certain he's a principle source. He's mentioned on their site in the list of references.


Anyways I'm pretty wikipedia on this topic myself but I couldn't find anyone who preceded Massey, and you're saying that there's a problem with the actual source material Massey used in his research. ( the actual references ) ?

Can it really be that simple ?

No, not really that simple. Massey was one of many early scholars to attempt to get early translations in after the Rosetta Stone was beginning to be copied (through various means, since there weren't many cameras and photocopiers didn't begin to appear for another 80 or so years. For quite a few years, many scholars worked alone and together to come up with definitive translations. Massey was one of many, though his work wasn't among the top of the field at the time. Subsequent publishings of his book have yielded much interest.
 
"Although the rude World herewith will be but little pleased, but rather smile and scoff thereat; also the Pride and Covetousness of the Learned is so great, it will not suffer them to agree together; but were they united, they might out of all those things which in this our Age God doth so richly bestow upon us, collect Librum Naturae, or a perfect Method of all Arts: but such is their opposition, that they still keep, and are loth to leave the old course, esteeming Porphiry, Aristotle, and Galen, yea and that which hath but a meer shew of learning, more then the clear and manifested Light and Truth; who if they were now living, with much joy would leave their erroneous Doctrines."

Egypt, btw, was seen, symbolically, as a place of darkness and psychic oppression, which is why Moses led the Israelites (Isis Ra El) out of there, and the Frater CRC, in the "Fama Fraternitatis," (part quoted above) did not hang out there too long. Egypt was the Theosophist's "Lower Astral", the realm of reinforced ego, where the novice spiritual aspirant was advised to not dally too long. Moses' journey from Egypt in the book of Exodus symbolises the flight from psychic oppression which the newly spiritually awakened individual may have to undertake. Some commentators claim that he used psychoactive drugs to sustain him on his flight, when his vision of God was low (Exodus 16), a practice which was no longer necessary when his vision was made permanent, as they Israelites crossed the River Jordan. It's a symbolic journey, depicting the awakening from the dream of the world, and the travel to spiritual maturity.

The Fama was also a major influence on Freemasonry. Its central character, the Jesus analogue, Frater CRC, has direct numerical links to the three mythological founders of the Masons.

Hiram Abiff, the "widow's son" of Freemasonry, has a value of 273 in Hebrew because Freemasonry, like Kabbalah, Gnosticism, Alchemy, and Rosicrucianism are all concerned (on one level) with effecting certain subtle bodily changes to bring about the full flowering the "all-seeing eye" or fully-evolved pineal gland. It is the number of the important Kabbalistic phrase "the stone the builders rejected" and this is significant because - the stone is a metaphor for the pineal, and because it is believed that this stone is confected as a result of subtle processes that take place between the intestinal agent chyme in the upper intestine, after the normal body-maintaining processes of metabolism have already taken place.

Ergo, likewise, Jesus is born of a virgin (Virgo is assigned to the stomach and upper intestine), in Beth-LeHem, the House of Bread, or stomach.

This stone is the Philsopher's Stone of Alchemy. Its value in Hebrew is 53, Ahben, and it is thus a contraction of the phrase Ab-Ben, father-son. This signifies that, when the stone is perfected, the individual is in a state of perfect union with God, as in "I and my father are one."

Nick
 
Israelites (Isis Ra El)

Oh my, I really hope you don't believe that is how the name is broken up. The name "Israel" is a Hellenization of the name "Yisra'el" in Hebrew, which is broken into yisra (or YSRA - yod, shin, reish, aleph) and the word for "god", which is el (used in reference to G-d in the texts, sometimes in as the root as in names like Elohaynu, El Shaddai and Elohim). It is the name given to Jacob, and it means "he who struggled with God" or "he who fought with God," which makes sense if you know the story of Jacob.


Egypt was the Theosophist's "Lower Astral", the realm of reinforced ego, where the novice spiritual aspirant was advised to not dally too long. Moses' journey from Egypt in the book of Exodus symbolises the flight from psychic oppression which the newly spiritually awakened individual may have to undertake. Some commentators claim that he used psychoactive drugs to sustain him on his flight, when his vision of God was low (Exodus 16), a practice which was no longer necessary when his vision was made permanent, as they Israelites crossed the River Jordan. It's a symbolic journey, depicting the awakening from the dream of the world, and the travel to spiritual maturity.

The Fama was also a major influence on Freemasonry. Its central character, the Jesus analogue, Frater CRC, has direct numerical links to the three mythological founders of the Masons.

Hiram Abiff, the "widow's son" of Freemasonry, has a value of 273 in Hebrew because Freemasonry, like Kabbalah, Gnosticism, Alchemy, and Rosicrucianism are all concerned (on one level) with effecting certain subtle bodily changes to bring about the full flowering the "all-seeing eye" or fully-evolved pineal gland. It is the number of the important Kabbalistic phrase "the stone the builders rejected" and this is significant because - the stone is a metaphor for the pineal, and because it is believed that this stone is confected as a result of subtle processes that take place between the intestinal agent chyme in the upper intestine, after the normal body-maintaining processes of metabolism have already taken place.

Ergo, likewise, Jesus is born of a virgin (Virgo is assigned to the stomach and upper intestine), in Beth-LeHem, the House of Bread, or stomach.

Not for nothing, but the stomach thing is a Greek thing, and there isn't any equivalent I know of concerning Mary ruling the stomach region. As for the upper intestine, considering there wasn't much understanding of anatomy at the turn of the millenium, I highly doubt that explanation's veracity. :)

As for the rest, it seems awfully judgmental and ethnocentric a view against Egypt, which kind of shows how much effort was put forth to cram the entirety of three millenia of Egyptian culture into the biblical story.


This stone is the Philsopher's Stone of Alchemy. Its value in Hebrew is 53, Ahben, and it is thus a contraction of the phrase Ab-Ben, father-son. This signifies that, when the stone is perfected, the individual is in a state of perfect union with God, as in "I and my father are one."

It was also the "seer stone" of Joseph Smith, who 'borrowed the concept from Freemasonry. However, those are all concepts that have roots in the dark ages, not Egyptian mythology. That is, I have never seen such references in Egyptian mythology. I'd be happy to see the connecting piece of Egyptian text from whence this is translated. :)
 
Not for nothing, but the stomach thing is a Greek thing, and there isn't any equivalent I know of concerning Mary ruling the stomach region. As for the upper intestine, considering there wasn't much understanding of anatomy at the turn of the millenium, I highly doubt that explanation's veracity. :)

Well, astrological signs are assigned to parts of the body. Pisces - feet; Capricorn - knees, Aries - face, etc, if I recall correctly. And Virgo is assiged to the stomach and upper intestines. Beth leHem is clearly the house of bread. Jesus represents the liberating or guiding principle that will lead the aspirant out of bondage to duality, just as Moses led the Israelites out of Egypt. The belief is that Jesus here represents a potentisation of life-energy that develops in the body, commencing with a process in the upper intestine.


GreNME said:
As for the rest, it seems awfully judgmental and ethnocentric a view against Egypt, which kind of shows how much effort was put forth to cram the entirety of three millenia of Egyptian culture into the biblical story.

Well, it's a symbolic story. Whether it is actually a judgment of the value of Egyptian rituals and belief I don't know.


GreNME said:
It was also the "seer stone" of Joseph Smith, who 'borrowed the concept from Freemasonry. However, those are all concepts that have roots in the dark ages, not Egyptian mythology.

Well, they're also present at the time of the Bible. Whether they can be tracked back to Egypt I have no idea. It's not so relevant to the actual point in the movie - that Jesus was a fiction, and Christianity the religion came along later.

Nick
 
I understand now. You were talking about the symbology of a specific belief (or set of beliefs). That makes sense.
 
It's been two days, thesyntaxera. Have you found the original source yet? Do you want me to give you the answer, or have you given up?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom