I'm pretty sure the question was about as specific as it needed to be.
If you really believe that to be the case, then you are incredibly ignorant. whole courses are taught on just parts of what are covered by your question, but you are demanding of me to sum it up for you. How many words would you like it summed up in, pray tell?
If you possess any information on the subject of mediterranean mystery schools and the influence they had on the creation of gnostic chrisitianity then why not just answer with that. Pretty simple really. You either do or you don't.
Which "mystery schools" are you talking about? This is what I mean by you being vague. You aren't even sure of what you're asking, but you're expecting me to explain everything to you in a single forum post. I possess a reasonable amount of information, and wonder of wonders I have been pointing you to books and links that actually have information coming from sources other than myself!
What is what? Specify what you want and we can start from there. So far you haven't even displayed enough understanding to focus your question, instead relying on vagaries like "mystery schools" that, despite being mysterious to
you doesn't mean there isn't any information out there. But first, you need to specify
which ones you're asking about.
And while your at it, what information do you have that supports your contention that no mediterranean or middle eastern religions had any effect on what would ultimately become chrisitianity, because some of us are still waiting to examine that.
Hello, straw man.
Now I know you're either being incredibly deliberately obtuse or you actually have no inkling of what you're talking about. I could
swear that I've actually been maintaining pretty reasonable influence by the Sumerians, Babylonians, Assyrians, and even some from Canaanites. I don't know if you're aware of this, but they're pretty darned "middle eastern" in the geographical sense of the phrase. You really need to check yourself before you say things that reflect poorly on your own lack of good faith on this matter. As a matter of fact, here is a quote of my own words way back on page 14, actually discussing some specific interests that the movie left out:
Some examples:
- Moses - What happened to Sargon? The comparison was standing right there in the faces of everyone, including the narrator, and the film just scoots right on past him with less than 20 seconds of exposure and goes on to try to connect Moses to Menes from Egypt and Manu from India. He was right there!
- Akhenaten - Without a doubt the number one, absolutely positive, sure-thing bet for someone who is doing a comparative religious study between Egypt and Judaism / Christianity would be with Akhenaten. This is the pharaoh who brought the first verifiably recorded evidence of a monotheistic religion in that whole region (from North Africa up to the Mediterranian). Even most of the scholars who reference Egypt as a major influence on Christianity use Akhenaten as their primary example! Why no mention of the obvious?
- Babylon - The Jews didn't get their calendar and their constellation symbols from the Greeks, they got them from Babylon. Babylon. Where the heck was Babylon in this whole film?
- Mithra - Get off the whole Jesus comparison attempts! The existing mythology surrounding Mithra tends to be more relationally comparable to stories involving Abraham, Moses, and David.
- Rome - I couldn't believe how little attention the film and narrator gave to Rome as a major influence on the formation of Christian theology in the liturgical sense. Sure, quoting Justin Martyr is all well and good, except they missed the context and Martyr had less of a contribution in merging Roman practices than, say Ireneaus, Ignatius, or (most of all)Constantine. Any of those alternatives would have been better examples. Information like the establishment of Christian churches in conjunction with Roman political governing buildings, and how the church simply had to step into an administrative role after the crumbling of Rome as an empire happened would have seemed to me to be directly in line with the case they were trying to make. That and things like it never appeared on the screen, though-- just a couple of weak quotes from Martyr.
You obviously have some bit of knowledge that informs your position, so why not share? I personally would really like to know how you decided on all this for yourself. Where did you get the information that debunks Nick's posted comparison chart? Why not let us examine the sources?
How many times to I have to repeat that I've been giving links all along? How many times do I have to point out that, in cases like the baptism stuff and similar things, that the onus is on the ones claiming that it exists to actually show where it exists? Jeez, man, I have listed for you a number of books and links, and the best you've come at me with is that you trust the movie and a bunch of wikipedia links, at least half of which have actually contradicted you when I pointed out other parts of the articles. If you're questioning my lack of sourcing, then you are in the negatives as far as providing a single reason why the outrageous defenses you are giving have a single shred of credibility.
Some references I have give so far, just to show how much of an outright liar you are:
- A Critical Examination of "Wordprinting" from BYU - an article discussing how similarities, especially using similarities in words from separate languages, does not link the languages and cultures in a causal relationship. The reasons why such claims are flawed are discussed in the link.
.
- Coincidental Similarities - a list of words collected by a linguist showing words that have similar meanings in languages that have absolutely no root relations. This displays how easy it is to make up fictitious claims based on unrelated similarities.
.
- Transfigured On The Holy Mountain: The Beginnings of Christianity - by Earl Doherty. A pretty good article on the subject matter, and well-written. Also, it leads to his supplementals, like...
.
- Josephus Unbound: Reopening the Josephus Question - also by Earl Doherty. A supplemental to the previous link, and one of 11 supplemental articles. I suggest them all for some interesting reading.
.
- Old Testament Life and Literature by Gerald Larue. This is an excellent resource.
.
- Constantine's Sword by James Carroll - this book focuses on Christian history as relating to the Jews as well as a great deal of historical examination on how Christianity developed through the centuries.
.
- The Gnostic Gospels by Elaine Pagels - this book is an examination of the gospels written by the Gnostics and their Hellenistic influences; and Beyond Belief by Elaine Pagels, where she compares the Gospel of Thomas to the Gospel of John, and examines how the first couple centuries of Christian philosophical debate established Jesus as a deity, eventually including the Gospel of John as canon and discarding the Gospel of Thomas.
.
- The Nag Hammadi Library - translation by James Robinson. Basically, a translation of what pretty much puts to rest earlier claims of direct Egyptian influence by Egyptologists from the 19th and early 20th century.
.
- Encyclopedia Mythica article on Horus - one of the most concise brief descriptions of the mythological Horus out there on the 'pedia' sites. A quote: "As the prototype of the earthly king, there were as many Horus gods as there were rulers of Egypt, if not more."
All of these are links I've given on previous pages (and not even
all of the links I provided). I gave you reference material to check out. And what was your response?
Whatever man, you don't even read them anyway.
I happen to have a copy of the NH by elaine pagels, but I wouldn't venture to interpret it too specifically as it seems there are many ways to digest it depending on whom I am talking to.
Whenever I tossed references your way, you either made a personal attack at me or you completely disregarded a source that has far more academic veracity than some internet movie. This is why I am calling you a liar. But if your best defense at my showing exactly how ridiculous these claims are is to attack my credibility, then I once again challenge you to bring your lady friend to this board, have her read exactly what I've been saying-- instead of getting it second-hand through your thesyntaxera-filter-- and ask her if the things I have been saying are, for the most part, credible.
How does the flat earth "theory" have any relevance to what he was asking?
You need to go look up the definition of "metaphor". I'm getting bored of doing your thinking for you in that regard.
When researching claims such as those about the origins of christianity you have to research the source of the claims and find out if those claims are based on sound research or not.
Or you could, you know, actually do research on history of the entire region in general-- one of my focuses-- and actually be able to recognize when claims are made that do not exist in any of the related study you've done of the other cultures.
You seem to be confidant in your dismissal of them without even researching them, which is only slightly less bogus than repeating the same two catch phrases of this thread over and over..."correllation does not = causation" and "never attribute malice where you can attribute stupidity"....If you have any rock solid proof beyond unreferenced rhetoric then spill it, or this dialog will never move forward. If you honestly have no idea if there could or could not have been any cross pollination of the egyptian culture onto those cultures that led to the creation of chrisitianity then please admit so and do us all a favor.
Oh baloney. I dare you to find me one
EGYPTIAN reference of Anup the Baptiser, for crying out loud. It doesn't exist. Check every exhibit description of every museum you want, check any current archaeological study projects you want. I dare you to find one credible reference to Anup the Baptizer that isn't just another one of these self-referencing wild claims. It doesn't exist.
Please don't take the time to attempt to sound witty and condescending in your next reply, just please, please, please answer the questions... it will be much appreciated.
Too late for that. You have gone past the point where you can take back some of the ridiculous assertions you've made. You seem perfectly willing to take these claims as reasonable enough to believe with barely passing self-referencing sources, and yet you've ignored every single suggestion for where you can actually look,
for yourself and with your own eyes, in places that can give you a better understanding of the cultures that this discussion covers. You have refused every suggestion of mine outright and practically taken the film as gospel. Your whole thesis up to this point is completely built on style over substance, and yet you don't want any criticism of the weak stance you've taken.
Nothing you have supplied thus far has invalidated the egyptian origin of christianity hypothesis, you have only picked apart the claims of the film which seem objectionable to you, because I assume you would have preferred them to offer an entire history lesson on the development of egyptian religion with archaeological evidence(which isn't likely to exist any way)to back up those claims of origin and cross contamination. Considering the intent of the video....
You're either lying or you think deliberately ignoring every contextual bit of information I've supplied. Either way, you're wrong and you don't even seem to know it.
Religion controls the masses, traumatizing events have been manipulated to better the power brokers, and power brokers control your life via the economy...
...I don't see why an expectation such as this even exists...
At this point, I honestly don't believe you have an understanding of what you just said outside of "religion controls stuff" or some equivalent.
I humbly await you answer.
You go to wikipedia and you find me some proof that "Anup the Baptizer" existed, and then we'll work on your "answers" one at a time.