ZEITGEIST, The Movie

GreNME...thanks for the list of books and websites, that's a pretty impressive wealth of information. Enough to keep me busy for..well, years actually.

I am curious about your putting together a debunking because so far, I've been under the impression that it was only possible to "debunk" this Christian/Egyptian topic through years of study and then subscribing to the " this is the least possible, but not impossible" school of thought.

Where do you figure Anup the Baptiser originally came from ? Did Massey just make it up ? Translate something no one else has gotten around to translating, yet ? Or read something that no one else has read to say the same thing ?

Nick...I like this whole debunking thing simply for the sport of it. That, and I really really don't like being lied to and I have a natural knee jerk reaction that when I suspect someone is making something up, I like to see for myself. Unfortunately, this whole Egypt/Christian thing is both beyond my scope of immediate knowledge, and too complicated and esoteric for me to be able to post anything "meaningful" on the topic.
 
Where do you figure Anup the Baptiser originally came from ? Did Massey just make it up ? Translate something no one else has gotten around to translating, yet ? Or read something that no one else has read to say the same thing ?

Nick...I like this whole debunking thing simply for the sport of it. That, and I really really don't like being lied to and I have a natural knee jerk reaction that when I suspect someone is making something up, I like to see for myself. Unfortunately, this whole Egypt/Christian thing is both beyond my scope of immediate knowledge, and too complicated and esoteric for me to be able to post anything "meaningful" on the topic.

Stout,

I think it's pretty safe to say that no one really knows what the Egyptians believed, or if indeed it was even remotely coherent. There's evidence to show that they themselves changed beliefs at periods, even keeping the same mythological characters but with changed roles or interactions.

Can anyone demonstrate to a reasonable degree that Jesus was Horus? I very much doubt it.

I have knee-jerk reactions too, but I doubt the makers of Zeitgeist set out to deceive. People are ready for change...and that's how it is.

Nick
 
There's enough skeletons in the cupboards of the 3 institutions I mentioned to keep a legion of med students happy for aeons. These are not healthy organisations we're talking about here, doing their best to make the world a better place. Far from it. Let them take some **** and try and scrape it off. It also empowers positive elements within the same orgs to create positive change.

I think this is a worthy sentiment, and agreeable enough as far as I'm concerned. :)

Stout,

I think it's pretty safe to say that no one really knows what the Egyptians believed, or if indeed it was even remotely coherent. There's evidence to show that they themselves changed beliefs at periods, even keeping the same mythological characters but with changed roles or interactions.

Can anyone demonstrate to a reasonable degree that Jesus was Horus? I very much doubt it.

I have knee-jerk reactions too, but I doubt the makers of Zeitgeist set out to deceive. People are ready for change...and that's how it is.

I pretty much agree with this, as well. I don't think the makers of the film thought to themselves "hey, let's shove as many lies as we can together and see who catches it." Instead, I think it was an attempt to proselytize ideas, some of which have long since passed the realm of measuring up to real scrutiny (and things like the 9/11 stuff which are still current in our consciousness), and attempting to cram it all together in a shepherd's pie of conspiracy theory.
 
GreNME...thanks for the list of books and websites, that's a pretty impressive wealth of information. Enough to keep me busy for..well, years actually.

The books alone have kept me busy for years. I found the websites only over the recent couple of years. I've only scratched the surface of actual formal education on the subjects, though as time and finances allow I'll probably be doing that more as well. There's enough available in those resources, though, to keep you with stuff to read for a good, long while. It's even prompted me to begin learning some languages I wouldn't have thought of before (for example, you might want to learn Italian if you ever wish to read some of the oldest Arabic texts, because many are located in Italy).


I am curious about your putting together a debunking because so far, I've been under the impression that it was only possible to "debunk" this Christian/Egyptian topic through years of study and then subscribing to the " this is the least possible, but not impossible" school of thought.

Well, for me to really put together a "debunking" it would focus more on taking the talking points and working to place them into context, pointing out how the assertions that are made in the target of the "debunking" are missing the context and losing the actual translation of the ancient culture. This happens a lot when examining older cultures, as the most obvious error made is projecting modern contexts in places we don't understand. Since we understand so little about some aspects of these ancient cultures (without a lot of study), it's a common mistake.


Where do you figure Anup the Baptiser originally came from ? Did Massey just make it up ? Translate something no one else has gotten around to translating, yet ? Or read something that no one else has read to say the same thing ?

I haven't a really strong opinion on that, but as a quick guess I would wager he somehow got mixed signals on the personality and purpose of Anubis in his translations, and accidentally allowed some personal influence to leak into his translation.


Nick...I like this whole debunking thing simply for the sport of it. That, and I really really don't like being lied to and I have a natural knee jerk reaction that when I suspect someone is making something up, I like to see for myself. Unfortunately, this whole Egypt/Christian thing is both beyond my scope of immediate knowledge, and too complicated and esoteric for me to be able to post anything "meaningful" on the topic.

I think wanting to see for yourself is a worthwhile endeavor. It's certainly something I think more people should be encouraged to engage in. One of my pet peeves about a lot of the conspiracy theorist material out there is that they purport to tell people to "see it for yourself," but perform a load of prompting on the context ("look at it this way") and seem to always feed the information in an order fitting their own predetermined assumption. It's basically a variation of the way an illusionist makes people believe that a coin has disappeared from their hand or that a card magically transported to a location outside the deck. Added to the human predilection for seeing patterns in things and it's easy to paint a landscape of history as if it's all one long ongoing story being dictated in ways we wouldn't see unless we "woke up."
 
One of my pet peeves about a lot of the conspiracy theorist material out there is that they purport to tell people to "see it for yourself," but perform a load of prompting on the context ("look at it this way") and seem to always feed the information in an order fitting their own predetermined assumption.

I think that's a good point. The conspiracy theorists want you to see the world "their way" just as much as your parents, teachers, and governments wanted you to see it their way. Whichever way you cut it, it could be said that you end up being conditioned.

On the other hand you can also say that the process of allowing yourself to really and truly disbelieve everything that you've been taught, of itself, is liberating. And that from that position you can start to become the person you really want to be.

This latter position is more how I see Zeitgeist. I'm not so bothered about the so-called hard facts. The act of creating a believable challenge to the ridiculously rigid mindset that so many Westerners have developed over the last decades of itself is worthwhile.

To pick up on another good point GreNME raises above, we don't really know what our ancestors believed. We assume a lot. We can read the books, stones, or pictograms, but these things say little if anything about who these people really were, who they believed themselves to be, and how they regarded themselves in relation to the world around them or the world of myths.

GreNME said:
Added to the human predilection for seeing patterns in things and it's easy to paint a landscape of history as if it's all one long ongoing story being dictated in ways we wouldn't see unless we "woke up."

We look for new patterns when the old ones don't work. Facts are all very well, but if they don't create nourishment, people go elsewhere.

Nick
 
Last edited:
According to boloboffin in reference to part one, any critical observation on religion is a viscious Ad homen attack on the adherents. He is wrong. He must be a Apologist. This wasn't an attack on people, just a critique of religion.

Part one never said that Christians and Jews are evil. Its refering to the rulers if anything, not the masses.

Part 2 looks like bunk. I will let you know my take on Part 3.

Oh, and Dumbledore is gay. Deal with it.
 
According to boloboffin in reference to part one, any critical observation on religion is a viscious Ad homen attack on the adherents. He is wrong. He must be a Apologist. This wasn't an attack on people, just a critique of religion.

Boloboffin is not a religious apologist and nowhere does he say that a critical observation of religion is an ad hominem attack on religious adherents. He is right that Part 1 of Zeitgeist is an example of a dishonest critique of religion. It demonizes Christianity and Judaism by making them out to be vast conspiracies used by the elite to dominate the world. This kind of position is unsupported by scholarly research and obvious anti-intellectual bunk to anyone who has seriously studied the sociology of religion or the origins of Christianity and Judaism. If you want honest critique of religion read Sagan or Dawkins, not this conspiracist hokum.

Part one never said that Christians and Jews are evil. Its refering to the rulers if anything, not the masses.

Part 2 looks like bunk. I will let you know my take on Part 3.

It's all bunk.

Oh, and Dumbledore is gay. Deal with it.

I guess we'll also have to deal with the fact that you're a homophobe. Great.
 
According to boloboffin in reference to part one, any critical observation on religion is a viscious Ad homen attack on the adherents. He is wrong. He must be a Apologist.
Yep, he's a regular Bible-thumping Jesus freak. From post 11 in this thread:

I am an atheist, and my head pounded three holes into the drywall watching that nuttiness.

Any other posts from July that you need help with, priapus?
 
Y'all, what up with Zeitgeist tonight? I've been going round and round with someone over at DU about it, and now somebody's whacking on me here? If I were a conspiracy-minded fella...

Thanks for the setting straight, Slayhamlet and Gravy.
 
... He is right that Part 1 of Zeitgeist is an example of a dishonest critique of religion. It demonizes Christianity and Judaism by making them out to be vast conspiracies used by the elite to dominate the world.

Well, Christianity created demons, now it gets demonised. What goes around comes around.

This kind of position is unsupported by scholarly research and obvious anti-intellectual bunk to anyone who has seriously studied the sociology of religion or the origins of Christianity and Judaism.

Load of rubbish. Scholars don't know where Christianity comes from, how it developed, or if there was any motivation behind its development. It's all speculation. Zeitgeist's interpretation of the origins and motivations of Christianity are as good as anyone else's. Their exposition of Egyptian religious belief is pretty feeble though.

Nick
 
Last edited:
Load of rubbish. Scholars don't know where Christianity comes from, how it developed, or if there was any motivation behind its development. It's all speculation. Zeitgeist's interpretation of the origins and motivations of Christianity are as good as anyone else's. Their exposition of Egyptian religious belief is pretty feeble though.

Nick

That's not necessarily true. In fact, for the last fifty years archaeologists and scholars have done a pretty fine job of finding many of the origins of Christianity, including some branches that didn't make it past the Nicene Council. The difference is that, on the whole, these scholars don't couch all of their work in some "religion is a lie, Christianity is a fraud" message that Zeitgeist is so ham-handed about it's ridiculous.

Like I said before, I'm not religious, and I'm certainly no Christian apologist. However, there's a difference between actually searching for and studying the cultural and historical originations of Christianity or the Jesus story and the type of conspiracy-like misattribution of context, intent, and interpretation like Zeitgeist engages in.
 
Like I said before, I'm not religious, and I'm certainly no Christian apologist. However, there's a difference between actually searching for and studying the cultural and historical originations of Christianity or the Jesus story and the type of conspiracy-like misattribution of context, intent, and interpretation like Zeitgeist engages in.

I applaud wildly.
I don't mind people having a negative opinion of Christianity, but to beleive crap like Zeitgeist and The Da Vinci Code just because they are hostile to Christianity is a bad,bad,idea.
It's no better then a New Ager laughing at those stupid Christians while buying into magic crystals,astrology,psychic healing, etc. Nothing is gained,you have just exhanged one form of woo for another.
 
I applaud wildly.
I don't mind people having a negative opinion of Christianity, but to beleive crap like Zeitgeist and The Da Vinci Code just because they are hostile to Christianity is a bad,bad,idea.

Why is it "a bad, bad idea"? Please explain. I'm interested.

Cultures and believes get overthrown. It happens. Scientific method is relatively new, and I think it's great. But trying to apply empiric reasoning to demonstrate the validity of religous belief is nonsense. You're straight away back with psychology, back with self-examination, back with yourself and why you choose to believe what you do. It's confrontational to challenge your own beliefs and in my book it's good.

Please answer. Explain. Take a risk. Don't hide.

Nick
 
Why is it "a bad, bad idea"? Please explain. I'm interested.

Cultures and believes get overthrown. It happens. Scientific method is relatively new, and I think it's great. But trying to apply empiric reasoning to demonstrate the validity of religous belief is nonsense. You're straight away back with psychology, back with self-examination, back with yourself and why you choose to believe what you do. It's confrontational to challenge your own beliefs and in my book it's good.

Please answer. Explain. Take a risk. Don't hide.

Nick

Because it tends to become exactly what it appears to hate. Replacing one dogma for another is just trading a religion, and doing it out of anger usually can't sustain itself. It's not healthy, to boot.
 
Because it tends to become exactly what it appears to hate. Replacing one dogma for another is just trading a religion, and doing it out of anger usually can't sustain itself. It's not healthy, to boot.

That is only true if there is no rise in awareness. People are invariably drawn to CTs, as opposed to OTs, because they are attracted subconsciously. The pattern of organisation suggested by the CT makes more sense to them than the pattern suggested by the OT. The experience is that the CT seems to account better for events. If you can just become slightly aware of what it is that is causing you to become attracted to the CT then you have risen in awareness. From that expanded position you can create, if you're still attracted to, something better than the OT.

Nick
 
That is only true if there is no rise in awareness. People are invariably drawn to CTs, as opposed to OTs, because they are attracted subconsciously. The pattern of organisation suggested by the CT makes more sense to them than the pattern suggested by the OT. The experience is that the CT seems to account better for events. If you can just become slightly aware of what it is that is causing you to become attracted to the CT then you have risen in awareness. From that expanded position you can create, if you're still attracted to, something better than the OT.

The problem is that this dogma replacing the previous one is faced with even more blatant factual falsehoods and has more feet of clay.

I wouldn't call that raising "awareness" as much as I would call it "just another evangelism."
 
The problem is that this dogma replacing the previous one is faced with even more blatant factual falsehoods and has more feet of clay.

I wouldn't call that raising "awareness" as much as I would call it "just another evangelism."

Well, the proposed "dogma" has not yet replaced orthodox Christianity. When I mentioned awareness, I meant self-awareness. People are attracted subconsciously to CTs. In acting upon the attraction there are a multitude of opportunities for self-awareness to rise and one to become aware of that which is truly causing the anger of which you write.

BTW, can you tell me more of what you wrote here...

"That's not necessarily true. In fact, for the last fifty years archaeologists and scholars have done a pretty fine job of finding many of the origins of Christianity, including some branches that didn't make it past the Nicene Council. The difference is that, on the whole, these scholars don't couch all of their work in some "religion is a lie, Christianity is a fraud" message that Zeitgeist is so ham-handed about it's ridiculous."

Nick
 
Well, the proposed "dogma" has not yet replaced orthodox Christianity. When I mentioned awareness, I meant self-awareness. People are attracted subconsciously to CTs. In acting upon the attraction there are a multitude of opportunities for self-awareness to rise and one to become aware of that which is truly causing the anger of which you write.

Based on how memes like that progress, I wouldn't hold my breath. It's a little like passing a secret through 100 people and seeing how it turns out at the other end.


BTW, can you tell me more of what you wrote here...

"That's not necessarily true. In fact, for the last fifty years archaeologists and scholars have done a pretty fine job of finding many of the origins of Christianity, including some branches that didn't make it past the Nicene Council. The difference is that, on the whole, these scholars don't couch all of their work in some "religion is a lie, Christianity is a fraud" message that Zeitgeist is so ham-handed about it's ridiculous."

Nick

More discoveries have been found in the last fifty years regarding the earliest forms of Christianity-- from the Nag Hammadi to the Dead Sea Scrolls (though they don't contain Christian-specific stuff they contain much context), to a greater ability to forensically examine a lot of these artifacts long considered to be from that time (I think the latest report has the Turin shroud at about 3000 years old)-- than in much of the realm of history regarding the religion since the Middle Ages. Other age-old remnants of those early centuries are being re-examined, and loads of books on the subject abound these days. Usually, the more intellectually honest of these books are careful to not write their studies in terms of a decisive opinion one way or the other on How Things Were ™ regarding the subject, because they are exploring it in study and not attempting to present a new category of faith or dogma. The Zeitgeist film clearly does not fall under that category, which is a major gripe I have with it.
 
Hey Syntaxera,

I've now read an assortment of the so-called Zeitgeist Part 1 "debunkings" on the Net and they're all feeble as hell imo. People focus on the Horus-Jesus relationship and the fact that much of what was briefly believed by some writers has now lost credit. No one really looks at the vast number of other mythoi quoted and goes for comparison there.

Yeah I agree..If GrenME has done anything for me it has been to inspire a look around to see what others are saying, and I can't say that I am too impressed. Everyone seems to parrot the same things as you said..."it's been debunked"...but I haven't really found a single instance where debunking has truly occured. There aren't many scholarly articles out there that say emphatically that horus/jesus comparisons are bunk...what I have found is that the historical record is too complex, especially when you consider the many thousands upon thousands of years that is the back drop for what we are talking about. Thats why I argue from memetic evolution...because there is no clear case of borrowing, but as we all know, idea's get borrowed...you have the semitic culture in the middle of two giant imperial cultures...it just seems logical that folktales and traditions would rub off...I don't think there is any empirical way to judge how much and of what, but is it likely? I think so. I'm no egyptologist though.

Part 1 makes 2 principle claims -

1) that Jesus was a retelling of an age old mythological tale, not a real living person
2) that the Romans rehashed it to create religious vehicle for human control

Regarding 1, I'd say this can be pretty well held up, though the way the movie attempts to do so does over simplify things and over-rely on astrology.

Regarding 2, Christianity the religion did emerge at this time, that of Nicaea, and it is inevitably difficult to divine the motivations of those that create it.

Regarding the over dependance on astrology ...I did find this comparison between the gnostic story of creation and astrology interesting:
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=3129789386576750896
it's short...

As far as 2 is concerned...I think they genuinely thought it was the right thing to do...but with the added bonus of being a social control...maybe...who knows...perhaps we can get the vatican to let us in their repository and read the meeting minutes?
 
Last edited:
My thoughts...

I am not a supporter of swindlers, con artists, or the uneducated person that supports them. Additionally, I understand the scientific method and appreciate the concept of proof. Nevertheless, there are things in life, while although true, do not have much proof. Love is a very good example of this. Now while I do not condone the aspects of 9/11 conspiracy designed to promote illogical thought for profit, the fact that I am not only highly intelligent but also what I call “street smart” guides my belief that there is more to the official explanation.

Rather than focus on the buildings themselves and anything related to fires, eyewitness accounts, or angles of fall... I think its better to focus on the human aspect of it.

The movie brings up key points:
Was was the head of the 9/11 commission a close friend and professional associate of the people they were investigating?
Why are some of the hijackers still alive?
Why was the bin laden family not investigated?
Why would their be career IRS agents and Police officers who would resign after 20 years of service because they think something is very wrong... if nothing is wrong?

Something I remember Penn bringing up on ********:

“Isn't it a little naive to think that the government is capable of not only committing this heinous act but has the ability to cover it up? How could the government suppress and control hundreds of thousands of people into perpetuating such a conspiracy?” (this is not word for word but that was the general meaning behind his statements)

The problem with that philosophy is that it relies on the fact that hundreds of thousands of people would be needed... this is not the case.. only a handful of people in key positions would be needed.

I often hear that it's up to the people making “wild claims” to back up their standpoint. I do not believe that the idea of a few people with a lot of resources working together for their own benefit without acknowledgment of outside interference is beyond the realm of possibility. More than that, not only is it possible but its highly luckily... and thats whether you are looking at the simplest form of social interaction... the schoolyard... or the largest form... international politics.

My belief is that the government either knew of 9/11 and did not act on it or committed it themselves. In my mind arguing about minor details is not only a waste of time .. from both sides.. but it misses the overall point.

Randi and Penn are not great scientists... they aren't even scientists... they are magicians. Who was the greatest scientist to ever live? No, it was not Isaac Newton ... a lonely anti-social man who was consumed with details. It was Albert Einstein... a genius that was highly capable and excelled at most aspects of life. Einstein could party hard, Einstein was very good with women, Einstein was not afraid to physically defend himself or physically fight for peace, Einstein loved to be alone, he loved to follow the depths of his mind to the caves of genius. Einstein also understood something that most of the people here do not understand... it's something thats been repeated over and over again by a large number of geniuses:

“Imagination is more important than knowledge.” - Albert Einstein
“Imagination is more important than knowledge... imagination rules the world.” - Napoleon Bonaparte
“Creation is more important than knowledge.” - Julius Caesar

The bottom line is: every facet of society ... whether its business, a criminal gang, politics, whatever... is ultimately controlled by a handful of people... thats how a “chain of command” works. One guy directs orders to someone below ... who directs them to others.. who directs them to others.. etc. Like a pyramid.

Now people that lack any of this kind of power love to convince themselves that it doesn't exist. My viewpoint is this... go back to when you were in school... their were “cool kids” that could make one phone call and have 1000 people somewhere... and than their were kids that had no power whatsoever. Now no matter how smart that one kid with no power becomes... it means nothing compared to the collective intellect of the cool kids and their friends. In other words, if the lonely kid learns to build his own automobile lets say... the cool kid will just use his social ability to find ten guys who already know how to build an automobile and will instruct them to make him one thats even better.

Now most of the cool kids get used to their positions as leaders and never think about it. The people following the cool kids are simply followers... they don't understand enough to lead or don't want to lead and are quite content with following someone who appears to have their lives together. The lonely kid will do one of two things: lie to himself, give in to anger, claim he doesn't need people, and think that his weakness somehow makes him divine or noble or good. The other thing that lonely kid can do is say to himself ... I'm very very intelligent naturally.. now I haveto learn the skills I wasn't born with ... the ones that allow me to be “cool”. Why do these kids think he's “cool”. How can I be like that? Then they haveto work towards conquering their fears, humiliating themselves infront of people, etc. ... but if they want it enough and are committed enough they become more powerful than anyone else.

Thats why generally speaking... the person who suffers the most is the best at survival. Someone who isn't able to change every aspect of their reality.. isn't able to do anything.. simply hasn't suffered enough.

“God is subtle... but he isn't plain mean.” - Albert Einstein

I find that most of the people on this forum (including penn and randi) are usually rude and close minded towards people whom don't think like them. They only “debate” from a standpoint of being intellectually superior (majorly FALSE.) and a certainty that what they believe is correct above all others.

Being intelligent has absolutely nothing to do with memorizing trivia or what your interpreted IQ is. Thats why Einstein refused to take an IQ test.

I will cite an example of the rudeness of Penn and Randi: (note: I used to look up to these guys but as I got older I realized science [and the scientific method in particular] does not work very well as a lifestyle platform. To live your life by these “rules” will leave many aspects of life completely unexplored and will send your imagination to uninspired destinations filled with inglorious mediocrity.)

It was on Penn's radio show ... Randi had agreed to an interview by a christian radio host. Now the radio host was very friendly.. Randi was mostly rude and mostly repeated the same things over and over again and in my opinion was just plain insulting. If I had been interviewing him I would have ended it and asked him to leave.


Now, I am not religious. My personal philosophy is “There is a creator, there is life beyond death, there is such a thing as a soul or spirit.” If there is not such a thing as spirit ... then how is it that someone who physically should not be able to achieve something... environmentally nothing, absolutely nothing gave them a foundation on which to achieve what they have... and nonetheless are able to do so? Its in there soul.

As far as religion does... I agree... I am against zealots whom use the bible to control and brainwash people. I am against taking the bible literally. However, I think an intelligent person who also believes in the bible looks at them as stories... stories that while although flawed can keep a killer from killing again for example. Or keep the lonely waitress working in some distant rural cafe happy... give her hope when she loses an unborn child... in other words... is it really wrong for someone to take a story that isn't true and make it what they need it to be... for them? To better their lives or continue living?

Their isn't anything inherently wrong with that aspect of religion. While I do not need these stories to live my life (I'm a former atheist... but I now agree with Cris angel when he brilliantly said “for every great painting there exists an artist”) That sums it up for me. Science without philosophy (or more accurately the correct philosophy... and there is a correct philosphy... when more people follow it world peace and REAL space exploration will become a reality.) is moot. Live is about far more than figuring out that 1+1=2. :)

To be positive though, I do greatly admire Randi's ability to expose clear charlatans like Yuri Gellar or (i did not say and) people similar to Richard Hoagland.

I think to dismiss anything... even if there is some proof against it or for it .. doesn't matter.. to dismiss anything in totality from being possible is a gross misdirection in which to guide your mind. :)

“We still do not know one thousandth of one percent of what nature has revealed to us.” - Albert Einstein

Another important point: things have not changed to the point where we are some how more evolved than the Romans for example. The world is still run exactly the same... communication, transportation, and weapons technology are the only things that really exist that make this world any different than it was 200 years ago or 2000 years ago. Any real progress thats been made socially has always quickly been reversed: see Napoleon Bonaparte, Frederick II, the American Revolutionary War. ... the governments largely influenced by the above two names and the many popular colonial figures (especially Jefferson & Franklin) only made institutions that lasted in their original concepts for a very short time... twenty years is generous.

The most wealthy people in this world, especially ones whose relatives have all grown up in that environment or a very similar environment lack morals. They've always lacked morals. You can find countless quotes from many respected people throughout history in a diverse range of backgrounds whom can personally attest to their highly lacking morality.








I'm not saying our own government killed 3000 people or didn't kill 3000 people... I'm just saying its possible despite whatever evidence there is.

However claim its not only not possible but not likely is to deny:
1.)The ultra wealthy/powerful have a lot to gain by taking over not just more countries, but the entire world. (The ultra rich love the idea of the movie Dune for example... because it illustrates a.) the return of the ultra luxurious life of public nobility
b.) the complete control of everything by their very small society, especially money or products or control of the production and distribution of something needed. (like 'the spice')
c.) Its one of the only movies to depict space explorations future as a place dominated by similar trade, business, and ownership concepts... the few rich individuals I've meant have especially loved the idea of royal families controlling entire planets.
2.)Their exists technology thats capable of influencing public opinion more than any past time in history. Their exists technology that can be used to track, spy, record, and create out of thin air... information.
3.)The above ultra wealthy/powerful have access to and can easily afford to buy all of the above mentioned equipment/facilities/organizations/politicians/government groups/military personnel .. whatever.

These people are not evil... but you have to understand most of them have grown up always getting what they want, always being treated and taught that they are better than everyone else and are the only things that matter, and on top of that rarely (if ever) does one experience true suffering. Usually if they have... it has a lot to do with a loss of money and political influence... ie: they were relegated back to poverty and only then truly understood what reality is for most people.

Last Note: if you are someone that thinks there is only one “actual, real.. world” than how come one man can walk into a supermarket and not only come out with 5 numbers, but also bang a lady butcher in the meat room.. Then go home... drink a slurpy and play with his telescope ... then do some computer programming. Then getting calls from people wanting to party in atlantic city... he says yes but not now and tells them that he's busy... hangs up .. later on he gets high and picks them up, parties hard, and wakes up in Montreal.

Someone else's reality might be ... “I went to the field and studied ant farts. It was truly amazing. I collected 15 samples of micro farts and categorized them by not only species of ant but also texture.. moistness.. .. . looks around ... whispers to ant... “edibility” and licks it .. then goes home. Gets a call from his nephew in florida asking for money. Starts talking to him on about ant farts. The cousin hangs up. He scratches his balls privately when no one is watching and eats the worst tasting, most sugarless, uncreative, drab, alcoholic inspired... plain cereal he can find. Then he works for 8 hours at home, plays some tetris, and goes to bed.

Those are two very very different realities. I'm not saying one is wrong and the other is right... however in my opinion... the answer to to life to do with the following:

“A merger of modern technology with ancient wisdom on a mass scale.”

“A merger of scientific pursuit with self realization of your mental abilities.”


[Note: when I say the following... I don't mean paranormal stuff ... I mean your thoughts influence how you act... where your mind goes .. on what levels you are thinking. For example... if you are depressed... I don't care whats happened to you ... you DO have the power... to say to yourself “I am happy right now. I can feel the wind on my face, I can take in the sunset to its fullest beauty. You can then think of something happy and continue in that vain. It's actually possible to never be depressed ever again and to always feel good. Most people want to be around that before anything else. Few people are that way.

If you really want to change things.. on a large scale.. if you really want people to stop and listen to what you are saying, praise it, and adopt it into their own philosphies you haveto inspire them. You have to prove to them with other areas of your life that you understand all that they do AND more. You can't do that just by saying “I went to Yale... or I have this piece of paper here that says I am a DOCTOR! ... I am smarter than you god damnit! .. I'm an expert... you couldn't possibly understand it as good as me... let alone better...” Those kinds of attitudes happen because a person suffers and believes he can't do anything about it naturally.

Additionally, I think to automatically assume that paranormal philosphies (while I do not necessarily believe or practice them personally) are inherently wrong or idiotic.. or to dismiss it because it can't be proven and a lot of loons are mixed in trying to take peoples money with clearly delusional or fraudulent methods. All I'm saying is:

1.)We have no idea where people go when they die.
2.)We have no real idea about how our universe was really created... there is always another question behind any theory or answer currently available... which basically means we don't know. In the same way that classical physics was widely thought to be almost a completed science... but yet spawned an entirely different way of looking at it .. and within years was starting all over again. Or when the telephone was invented and the automobile.. those people thought they were highly advanced.... today we have computers and the Internet.. people think that means we are evolved. We aren't.

Also ... I can promise you that there is more to life by this train of logic:

“It makes no sense whatsoever that we would all live and our lives have become only what we could make them mean socially.” With that philosophy it essentially means that the few people out there who are say alcoholics... that never talk to anyone.. and spend all their time at home... and maybe drive a truck alone for work ... and never marry... that their lives were entirely for nothing. Thats not true.. one of them might have been a great poet.. or composed something that will be remembered.

If you want proof that science is not the most important thing... why is it no scientists are remembered anywhere near the scale of an artist? Instead of thinking you are right in this regard and that everyone else is wrong... just think about it more...

Julius Caesar for example is remembered everywhere. It's been thousands of years since he lived.. yet you can ask almost anyone, anywhere in the developed world (and beyond to some degree) who he was and they can tell you. Ask someone who John Law was and they will look at you with a blank expression on their face. Ask someone who Alexander the great was... they can tell you... ask someone who Nicolas Leblanc was and they will again look at you with a blank expression. The same can be said for Albert Einstein in my opinion.

Just because you think one way about something doesn't mean other people are thinking the same thing.
You can never really know what someone is truly thinking. Even if they tell you, they could theoretically all be lying... even if you observe them in some situation... what if they know its fake.. maybe they are very intuitive.. that might affect their reaction.. if you are testing one person he might go along and not know anything... try a more quality sample.. and your result can be greatly reversed.

Thanks for reading! Comments welcome.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom