ZEITGEIST, The Movie

Well...I don't seem to be having to much success getting out of the Wikipedia as a source state of mind, but one thing the mighty Wiki seemed to stress is the personal agendas, bias, and lack of scholarly acceptance of the majority of those contributors listed above.

GreNME...now might be a good time to release those links that you have that show the lack of scholarly acceptance to the works of guys like Massey et al. I'm happy with Wiki, and I do notice terms like "books that attracted popular attention and scholarly derision."
when describing John Marco Allegro, one of the contributors.

I mean, Allegro had the guts to write The Sacred Mushroom and The Cross (Jesus was a magic mushroom, basically). I didn't read it but I think it's an excellent subject for a book. But...realistically, you're grossly unlikely to get much scholarly approval for having written this. And it's not going to do your other books much good either when it comes to scholarly review either.

Nick
 
Oh, yea...mushroom philosophies. Those are good for a giggle ( I read about your Africa trip ) but in the cold light of day I find what was sooo apparent and deeply moving was, on reflection, rather silly.

So if most everything I read, and I've spent hours reading online, points to the Jesus myth hypothesis being a fringe-y, alternative, not generally accepted anymore, where's the evidence? kind of, well, hypothesis. Then why are people so keen to want to believe in this relationship?

Is Zeitgeist some sort of trap for truthers? I mean, if you're willing to believe in the 9/11 part, and since we all hate paying taxes, lend credence to the Bank part, doesn't that kind of put you between a rock and a hard place when it comes to thinking critically about Part 1 ? You sort of have to accept and defend it...in the name of truth.

While I'm here....What, exactly does the word "woo" mean?
 
I am not an Egyptoligist.

Neither were many of the film's sources, and yet the film makes it a central theme that Jesus was built on the template of Horus.


The parts of part 1 that I am informed about in the film were accurate. A few which come to mind are:

a) The birth of Moses and the birth of Sargon

I've pointed out already that the film didn't go into near enough detail on this. Instead, it tries to connect Jesus and all of the Josephs into some Egyptian mold.


b) The precession of equinoxes

You mean the ones that are not actually in line with the zodiac, right?

c) The 12 tribes of Israel, the 12 signs of the Zodiac and the 12 disciples

The zodiac the film uses was created after Christianity started. Go ahead and look up Ptolmey.


d) The epic of Gilgamesh and Noah's ark

Once again, barely mentioned and instead the film tries to point out the hundreds of others. Here's a hint: floods happened in places near large bodies of water. The glaring difference between the Jewish and Babylonian deluge myths are the former was monotheistic and the latter polytheistic. Other than that, yeah, since they came from just about the same people there should be some striking similarities.


Even if the film go it wrong on one point, Horus, there were plenty of other facts regarding Christianity borrowing myths from prior pagan religions.

The film used Horus as it's main point. Horus and Egypt are practically mentioned more than Jesus and Christianity, respectively. You know where the webstite is, you know there's a transcript, do word searches yourself.

As for the "borrowing" stuff, you are getting the verbiage wrong. It was less "borrowing" or "stealing" and was more "absorbing." That's what religions do. What is more historically striking is how a large civilization like the Egyptians managed to not pass on at least parts of their religious mythology to someone.


That's the point. The story of Jesus is mostly myth. He didn't rise from the dead to save us from our sins, his mother wasn't a virgin, and WTC 7 didn't fall from an office fire in the 7th floor window at 4:45 P.M.

Those statements practically imply just as much of a leap of faith as believing in a religion. Religion isn't science, it's mythology. Attempts like this film to treat it like a science have as much faulty logic in them as they accuse the religions of having. I'm not even religious (I'm agnostic) and this film is so intellectually dishonest it sounds like preaching.
 
Well...I don't seem to be having to much success getting out of the Wikipedia as a source state of mind, but one thing the mighty Wiki seemed to stress is the personal agendas, bias, and lack of scholarly acceptance of the majority of those contributors listed above.

Wikipedia isn't in and of itself a decent place to start. They cite a lot of sources that you can follow and actually find more information.

GreNME...now might be a good time to release those links that you have that show the lack of scholarly acceptance to the works of guys like Massey et al. I'm happy with Wiki, and I do notice terms like "books that attracted popular attention and scholarly derision."
when describing John Marco Allegro, one of the contributors.

I think you're going about it wrong. You're looking for books to verify a polemicist premise. You won't find scholarly material that way (outside of philosophy). I don't have a list of sources that say "here is why Massey was wrong, here is why Budge was wrong," and so on. Instead, the method is to find the subject they covered, find the list of available material out there. Take a look at them. See what trends exist as far as schools of thought. Read. Look for more material. Compare the trends. Read. Take notes. Read more.

There's a lot of reading involved. :)

I can give you lists of books and links that can introduce you to Egyptology, ancient Mesopotamia, some topical religious history. Even though there might be some that exist, I wouldn't point you to material that claims so-and-so in specific was wrong. Be sure to note that even while arguing about the quotes made from Massey's own text, I'm not trying to discredit him but instead pointing to the actual source material. As far as I am concerned, true scholarly work in history can withstand not only scrutiny of the scholar's arguments, but evaluation of their sources. Otherwise we simply get into the trap many lit-crit students fall into where they are referencing people who referenced people who referenced people (you get the point). There are authors who can be considered to have created some works that can be looked at as fully citable and as 'decisive' as academia allows (which means not absolute). Massey is not one of those individuals, and if nothing else that should be one of the main reasons to not consider him an "original" source.
 
It just seems, that with this issue I can't escape the Wiki, occasionally it directs me to Amazondotcom but it seems very reluctant to let me leave.

OOooo I have an idea for a new conspiracy theory...wiki, subliminal advertising, maybe some invisible malicious software, the NWO...Think It"ll fly ? :D

It just seems to make the task at hand more difficult, convincing those who want the Christian/Egyptian connection to be true, without a specific source at hand to cite saying "your source is wrong" I understand what's going on here, the tack of going for the original source material, the uncertainty factor , and the hesitancy to want to discredit a respected individual(s). I've just never seen this tack used before.

Usually, I find it's a case of "my link trumps your link because......" style of discussion, with bonus opinions thrown into the mix. Or, better yet, your fact's are really only opinions in disguise, so it's will be very interesting to watch this thread continue to play out.

Haven't any other Egyptologists worked on the exact same material as Massey ( I'm just harping on him, because he seems like the major player ) and come up with different conclusions. That's what I was hoping for.

GreNME...what you're basically saying is to do my own research. OK I can do that but whether I actually will is a different story. I'll take the list of books and keep my eyes open for them, but I know the time commitment I'm looking ( months..if not years ) and and I highly doubt that I'd be anywhere up to speed when it comes to this posting on this thread, on this topic.

I guess I'm more looking for the easy way to prove that Zeitgeist is lying to me ( or not )
 
I can give you the web addresses to check for yourself.

Please do.

Are you asking me? Okay...


GreNME...what you're basically saying is to do my own research. OK I can do that but whether I actually will is a different story. I'll take the list of books and keep my eyes open for them, but I know the time commitment I'm looking ( months..if not years ) and and I highly doubt that I'd be anywhere up to speed when it comes to this posting on this thread, on this topic.

Here, I'll give you a list of books, original text websites, and some relevant articles and essays. Hopefully that can help.

[ BOOKS ]



[ WEBSITES WITH ORIGINAL TEXT ]



[ WEBSITES WITH GOOD DISCUSSIONS / ARTICLES (and some quotes I think are useful) ]

  1. Myths of Babylonia and Assyria by Donald A. Mackenzie
    .
  2. The Mystery Cults and Christianity Part One: Introduction and Survey of the Cults by Earl Doherty
    Earl Doherty said:
    But the most important area to be examined centers on the question of the similarities vs. the differences between Christianity and the cults. While the skeptical approach has traditionally been to accentuate (and exaggerate) the former as a means of discrediting the validity of Christianity's claims for itself, more, paradoxically, is to be learned about the nature of the Jesus faith by considering the alleged differences which apologetically oriented scholarship has traditionally appealed to.
    .
  3. The Mystery Cults and Christianity Part Four: A Cult of Parallels: Pagan Myths and the Jesus Story by Earl Doherty
    Earl Doherty said:
    But before we delve deeper into such similarities, we need to step back and consider certain aspects of the situation. It seems to be assumed by some proponents of such parallels that Christianity formulated itself and its Jesus on the basis of this type of precedent in the mystery cult myths and other sources. But this overlooks the fact that in the earliest record of Christianity, as in Paul and other epistle writers, there is no sign of such 'biographical' parallels. In fact, there is no biography at all. The parallels in Paul relate entirely to the principles of salvation theory we have looked at in the earlier articles of this series. Paul gives us no 'myth' of Jesus on earth. His death and resurrection of Christ are soteriological constructs, not historical ones. The vast majority of parallels presented by researchers like Gerald Massey find no echo in the earliest writings of Christians. If we do not read the Gospels into the background of those epistles, Paul cannot be accused of 'borrowing' any of this stuff from the mystery myths, beyond elements like death and rising, unity with the god, a homologic sharing in the god's experiences, baptismal rebirth, and sacred meals commemorating mythical activities of the god. Such ideas can certainly be interpreted as dependent, conscious or otherwise, on the mysteries, but nothing of it is 'biographical'. And since nothing biographical about the early Christian Christ can be found before the Gospels, the biographical elements become the responsibility, as far as we can see, of the evangelists. The Gospels are essentially the adding of an earthly myth to a spiritual one.
    .
  4. Apollos of Alexandria and the Early Christian Apostolate
    Earl Doherty said:
    And not all groups or individuals decoded in the same manner, or arrived at a Savior who had undergone suffering and death. The early Christian record is full of documents which offer a Son without these features: The Epistle of James, the Didache, the Odes of Solomon, the Shepherd of Hermas, many second century apologists. In some cases, such a Son is simply a Revealer. (Q and the Gospel of Thomas also have a Jesus who does not suffer and die, but this is a different case in that it reflects an invented human founder of an (originally) non-cultic nature: see Part Three.)
    .
  5. Old Testament Life and Literature by Gerald A. Larue -- This is an excellent piece to read regarding taking a serious critical thinking look at the Old Testament.
    Chapter 2 - How Do We Read? said:
    THERE was a time when it was believed that the best way to read the Bible was to begin at Genesis and read straight through. Today we know that the Bible was not written in the sequence in which we find it, but developed slowly over hundreds of years. Consequently, passages written centuries apart may now appear side by side. To appreciate the development of Hebrew religious thought, and to understand concepts in terms of the time in which they were recorded, it is essential to read biblical passages in chronological order insofar as we are able to determine that order. During the past one hundred years or so, a methodology, which may be termed "historical-literary," has been developed. This approach seeks to do two things: to determine the specific time in history in which each part of the Bible was written, and to classify various literary genres (such as funeral laments or oracles of doom).
    .
  6. How likely are chance resemblances between languages? by Mark Rosenfelder. This essay examines how comparing two similar things from different cultures, in this case words or language, can be deceiving and not reliable.
    Mark Rosenfelder said:
    What if we're only given a word or two-- say, that cute Japanese gaijin / Hebrew goyim pair? Even with one word, we can estimate phonetic leeway segment by segment:
    • first consonant matches; Japanese has about 14 consonant phonemes, so let's say the chance is 1 in 14
    • first vowel is basically ignored
    • medial consonant is extremely loose-- a dental affricate versus a palatal approximant. To be as fair as possible, let's say the chance is 1 in 3 that we get even this close.
    • second vowel matches; Japanese has 5 vowel phonemes, so the chance here is 1 in 5
    • final consonant is nasal in both cases; but Japanese words can only end in a vowel or n-- so let's assign a chance of 1 in 6.


    That gives us (1/14) * (1/3) * (1/5) * (1/6) or 1 in 1260 (= .00079). This pair doesn't of course come with the size of the comparer's dictionary; but from the probability alone we can say if the lexicon has at least 1260 words, we're likely to find at least one Japanese/Hebrew match that's this close. In a dictionary of 10,000 entries we could expect about 8 such matches.

    Of course it's worse than that, since there's semantic leeway as well. Goyim means 'nations' (from goy 'nation'); though it's metaphorically used for 'non-Jews', it's certainly not an exact semantic match for a word meaning 'foreigner'. (Gaijin is a borrowing from Chinese wairén 'outside-person'.) I can't emphasize enough that inexact matches greatly multiply the chances for finding random resemblances.
    .
  7. Example of a list of similar-looking words in different languages - not that there are some near the bottom where the similar-looking words mean the opposite or something very different from each other.
    .
  8. A BYU study on "wordprinting" in the Book of Mormon (which the LDS claim was written by several authors in a pseudo-Egyptian script)
    D. James Croft said:
    Results based on the next generation of wordprint studies may yet provide the encouraging support sought by faithful Church members. Certainly any research done in the future will be indebted to Larsen, Rencher, and Layton, who called our attention to an interesting and challenging area of Book of Mormon study. At the present time, however, given the tentative nature of "wordprints" and given the data and experimental design problems inherent in the Larsen study, it would be best to reserve judgment concerning whether or not it is possible to prove the existence of multiple authors of the Book of Mormon.
    .
  9. A whole list of various historic Jesus theories - a good resource to bookmark and make not of author names (for buying, not avoiding)
    .
  10. Horus entry in the Encyclopedia Mythica
    Encyclopedia Mythica said:
    The name "Horus" is a general catchall for multiple deities, the most famous of whom is Harseisis (Heru-sa-Aset) or Horus-son-of-Isis (sometimes called Horus the Younger) who was conceived after the death of his father, Osiris, and who later avenged him. In all the Horus deities the traits of kingship, sky and solar symbology, and victory reoccur. As the prototype of the earthly king, there were as many Horus gods as there were rulers of Egypt, if not more.

    The oldest of the Horus gods is appropriately named Horus the Elder (Heru-ur), and was especially venerated in pre-Dynastic Upper Egypt along with Hathor. In this very ancient form, Horus is also a creator god, the falcon who flew up at the beginning of time. The pre-Pharaohnic rulers of Upper Egypt were considered "shemsu-Heru" or "followers of Horus", and the original Horus is himself considered in some myths to be the brother of Seth and Osiris, second-born of the five children of Geb and Nut (Osiris, Horus, Seth, Isis, Nephthys). Horus the Elder's city was Letopolis, and his eyes were thought to be the sun and moon. When these two heavenly bodies are invisible (as on the night of the new moon) he goes blind and takes the name Mekhenty-er-irty, "He who has no eyes". When he recovers them, he becomes Khenty-irty, "He who has eyes". A warrior-god armed with a sword, Horus could be especially dangerous to those around him in his vision-deprived state, and during one battle in particular he managed to not only knock off the heads of his enemies but of the other deities fighting alongside him, thus plunging the world into immediate confusion that was only relieved when his eyes returned.



There. I think that's enough to not only get you started, but probably enough to keep you busy until long past the point where passing interest would fade. :)

I guess I'm more looking for the easy way to prove that Zeitgeist is lying to me ( or not )

Lying? I think you can count on that. They're selling you something. It's an idea, and all it's supposed to cost you right now is that you believe it, but it's a sales pitch.

The problem with it is that it doesn't provide enough of a challenge (this is where I disagree with Nick) to actually encourage people to go look more deeply into the matter themselves and not simply latch on to another paradigm that's been laid out for them, without having to apply any real critical thinking skills. The film is mentally lazy, and expects the viewer to be mentally lazy.

Note: I left out a lot of books, some of which I've mentioned previously in this thread. I think I listed enough books there that it was already getting a bit on the heavy side, because the web links are likely going to be more interesting to most people. Books require an investment that assumes enough interest to not only buy it, but to read it. Go through the web sites first and see if the subject continues to hold much interest for you. If so, try out a book.
 
Usually, I find it's a case of "my link trumps your link because......" style of discussion, with bonus opinions thrown into the mix. Or, better yet, your fact's are really only opinions in disguise, so it's will be very interesting to watch this thread continue to play out.

Haven't any other Egyptologists worked on the exact same material as Massey ( I'm just harping on him, because he seems like the major player ) and come up with different conclusions. That's what I was hoping for.

GreNME...what you're basically saying is to do my own research. OK I can do that but whether I actually will is a different story. I'll take the list of books and keep my eyes open for them, but I know the time commitment I'm looking ( months..if not years ) and and I highly doubt that I'd be anywhere up to speed when it comes to this posting on this thread, on this topic.

I guess I'm more looking for the easy way to prove that Zeitgeist is lying to me ( or not )

I'm pretty sure that what we know of Egyptian belief and mythology is just too incoherent to make the degree of connection that Zeitgeist does. But the Jesus story is a retelling of an age-old spiritual mythos that does connect to all the life/purgation/rebirth Heroes of antiquity.

Trouble is, the proof of the pudding is in the eating, as my mother says. You can't create a scholarly proof here, at least not a real strong one. The validation is in the subjective experience of research.

To the hardened anti-Truther of course this is nonsense.

The movie says at the close of its Sources page....

"That being said, It is my hope that people will not take what is said
in the film as the truth, but find out for themselves, for truth is not told, it is realized."

BTW, Jesus did not die for anyone's sins. The symbolic act of his crucifixion takes one to a level of awareness where the notion of sin becomes invalid.

Nick
 
I am not an Egyptoligist.

The parts of part 1 that I am informed about in the film were accurate. A few which come to mind are:

a) The birth of Moses and the birth of Sargon

b) The precession of equinoxes

c) The 12 tribes of Israel, the 12 signs of the Zodiac and the 12 disciples

d) The epic of Gilgamesh and Noah's ark

Even if the film go it wrong on one point, Horus, there were plenty of other facts regarding Christianity borrowing myths from prior pagan religions.

That's the point. The story of Jesus is mostly myth. He didn't rise from the dead to save us from our sins, his mother wasn't a virgin, and WTC 7 didn't fall from an office fire in the 7th floor window at 4:45 P.M.
You forgot the 12 eggs in the carton from the supermarket, and the 12 donuts that came from Lamar's. That's the definitive proof in my mind.
 
Here's a tidy summary for you:
YES!!!! Finally.

These people who claim that Egyptian Horus mythology is the original template for Christ are making their claims up out of thin air.

Sure...if you interpret the claims to mean that some one sat down and combed through egyptian mythology in order to create a new messiah. I personally don't believe that, although the whole isis, osiris, horus story in it's varied forms does remind me a lot of the whole god, jesus, mary story in many many ways.

No one who has ever attempted to make such a case can cite a single Egyptian text than described things like the virgin birth, the baptism or "Anup the Baptizer", 12 disciples, the death and resurrection of Horus, any usage of the name "Meri" for Isis, and plenty more.

No you sure wouldn't, but that doesn't mean that there aren't other similarities...like the whole horus manger thing among others...zeitgeist does scroll a pretty hefty list, unfortunately it's so fast as to not be readable. One might be able to interpret anup or anubis's enbalming of osiris and john the baptist's annoiting of jesus to be similar....or that isis might have been impregnated by divine power due to osiris not having a functioning pee pee.

The film Zeitgeist ignores Akkad, Sumer, Assyria, and Babylon almost completely. Biblical references to those kingdoms show up in much greater abundance, and there actually exist evidences in those cultures that corroberate the Biblical accounts mentioning those cultures, whereas the Biblical accounts of Egypt are not corroberated by Egyptian historical account. The film Zeitgeist and all of these other "Christ-mythers" or "Jesus-frauds" only barely mention names like Sargon or Nebuchanezzar, even though they played significant roles in Hebrew history from both a Biblical (religious) and academic perspective.

True true. However, here again we are viewing biblical accounts if they have some sort of historical accuracy, and are assuming that the accounts recorded are an accurate portrayal.

The problem with the claims the film makes is that it can't cite a single Egyptian source to support its claim, yet it names all kinds of Egyptian sources. For any honest researcher to hear these claims and actually look at the widely-available texts that exist out there, often for free, they will find absolutely no supporting text in any of the Egyptian sources to back up the claims like those made in Zeitgeist.

And again, why would there be? We are talking about the creation of mythos drawn from many mythos that existed before....not vice versa.

I'm pretty sure that what we know of Egyptian belief and mythology is just too incoherent to make the degree of connection that Zeitgeist does. But the Jesus story is a retelling of an age-old spiritual mythos that does connect to all the life/purgation/rebirth Heroes of antiquity.

Trouble is, the proof of the pudding is in the eating, as my mother says. You can't create a scholarly proof here, at least not a real strong one. The validation is in the subjective experience of research.

Exactly.
 
Hey Syntaxera,

I've now read an assortment of the so-called Zeitgeist Part 1 "debunkings" on the Net and they're all feeble as hell imo. People focus on the Horus-Jesus relationship and the fact that much of what was briefly believed by some writers has now lost credit. No one really looks at the vast number of other mythoi quoted and goes for comparison there.

Part 1 makes 2 principle claims -

1) that Jesus was a retelling of an age old mythological tale, not a real living person
2) that the Romans rehashed it to create religious vehicle for human control

Regarding 1, I'd say this can be pretty well held up, though the way the movie attempts to do so does over simplify things and over-rely on astrology.

Regarding 2, Christianity the religion did emerge at this time, that of Nicaea, and it is inevitably difficult to divine the motivations of those that create it.

Certainly, I've not seen anything that I would remotely consider a "debunking."

Nick
 
I think people talked about Ishtar less than this movie, and it was better than this Zeitgeist crap.

I love it when people make this logical leap (of faith, mind you) "Jesus was a myth, therefore WTC was a CD"
 
Hey Syntaxera,

I've now read an assortment of the so-called Zeitgeist Part 1 "debunkings" on the Net and they're all feeble as hell imo. People focus on the Horus-Jesus relationship and the fact that much of what was briefly believed by some writers has now lost credit. No one really looks at the vast number of other mythoi quoted and goes for comparison there.

Part 1 makes 2 principle claims -

1) that Jesus was a retelling of an age old mythological tale, not a real living person
2) that the Romans rehashed it to create religious vehicle for human control

Regarding 1, I'd say this can be pretty well held up, though the way the movie attempts to do so does over simplify things and over-rely on astrology.

Regarding 2, Christianity the religion did emerge at this time, that of Nicaea, and it is inevitably difficult to divine the motivations of those that create it.

That's not true. Go to the zeitgeist website and you can find a transcript of the film. Do a word search yourself or past the transcript into the word processor of your choice and do a word count. Horus is overwhelmingly the focus of the alleged connection to Jesus. The film attempts to mix in a few other Jesus-myth theories, but focuses primarily on the Jesus-myth claiming he's the new Horus.

Certainly, I've not seen anything that I would remotely consider a "debunking."

Maybe I'll put one together and see what you think. :)
 
Sure...if you interpret the claims to mean that some one sat down and combed through egyptian mythology in order to create a new messiah. I personally don't believe that, although the whole isis, osiris, horus story in it's varied forms does remind me a lot of the whole god, jesus, mary story in many many ways.

No offense, but what you feel and what the movie actually said are two things. As I told Nick, the transcript of the film is available on their site. You can word-count it and see how much focus is placed on Horus. The film focuses primarily on Horus, secondarily on the modern Zodiac, and the rest is a mix of several other Jesus-myth theories of varying validity. My main focus in calling this film crap is in their incorrect focus on those two glaringly incorrect theories nearly at the exemption of those with more validity.


GreNME said:
These people who claim that Egyptian Horus mythology is the original template for Christ are making their claims up out of thin air.
No you sure wouldn't, but that doesn't mean that there aren't other similarities...like the whole horus manger thing among others...zeitgeist does scroll a pretty hefty list, unfortunately it's so fast as to not be readable. One might be able to interpret anup or anubis's enbalming of osiris and john the baptist's annoiting of jesus to be similar....or that isis might have been impregnated by divine power due to osiris not having a functioning pee pee.

Wrong, wrong, and wrong. I've already told you, Anup does not exist. Since Gerald Massey is long since deceased, I challenge anyone who is currently alive to find me a single instance in any Egyptian text naming Anup. I provided links to many original Egyptian texts in translated form in my earlier post on this page. The texts are right there. All you have to do is quote the passage. Horus was not born in a manger, that is yet another falsehood completely from thin air. The story of Isis and Osiris is varied, but the most generalized story is that Isis too Osiris' "essence" into her. While that may sound all kinds of mystical to the uninitiated, "essence" is simply one of the many euphemisms for "manhood" or "sperm" in ancient language (including Egyptian). It is a far easier leap to assume the story describes a much less mystical event taking place.

By the way, that whole list is available on the website for the film as well, and it contains the list I've already pointed out has errors, as well as assumptions made from that smaller list that are equally erroneous. I'm working on a complete listing of them, but it's mostly an attempt to take that list and make it dazzlingly longer for effect. Nick grabbed the right list without the repetetitions.


GreNME said:
The film Zeitgeist ignores Akkad, Sumer, Assyria, and Babylon almost completely. Biblical references to those kingdoms show up in much greater abundance, and there actually exist evidences in those cultures that corroberate the Biblical accounts mentioning those cultures, whereas the Biblical accounts of Egypt are not corroberated by Egyptian historical account. The film Zeitgeist and all of these other "Christ-mythers" or "Jesus-frauds" only barely mention names like Sargon or Nebuchanezzar, even though they played significant roles in Hebrew history from both a Biblical (religious) and academic perspective.
True true. However, here again we are viewing biblical accounts if they have some sort of historical accuracy, and are assuming that the accounts recorded are an accurate portrayal.

I don't think you understand. The biblical accounts are not accurate, they are told from a distinct perspective and with disctinct bias. They are useful as tools of study for history, more the Old Testament than the New, but the facts we know about the level of actual interaction the Hebrews had with the cultures of Mesopotamia come from multiple verified sources, while the stories of the Hebrews and Egyptians prior to the First Diaspora are talked about solely in the Bible, and have no verification outside of it.

Taking biblical accounts as historically accurate without separate verification is one of my main problems with the Jesus-myth preachers: they love cherry-picking from the Bible as if it were accurate, just before they tell everyone the whole thing is complete hogwash.



GreNME said:
The problem with the claims the film makes is that it can't cite a single Egyptian source to support its claim, yet it names all kinds of Egyptian sources. For any honest researcher to hear these claims and actually look at the widely-available texts that exist out there, often for free, they will find absolutely no supporting text in any of the Egyptian sources to back up the claims like those made in Zeitgeist.
And again, why would there be? We are talking about the creation of mythos drawn from many mythos that existed before....not vice versa.

Vice-versa is exactly how Zeitgeist attempts to draw the connection. Looking at the development of the Hebrew and subsequently the Christian religions, the list of possible and probable influences differs greatly from those pushed most heavily by the film. It's dishonest in approach and through omission, and it does so because the producers did not perform any due diligence in backing up the presupposed assumptions that they drew from one or two pre-existing Jesus-myth theories.
 
That's not true. Go to the zeitgeist website and you can find a transcript of the film. Do a word search yourself or past the transcript into the word processor of your choice and do a word count. Horus is overwhelmingly the focus of the alleged connection to Jesus. The film attempts to mix in a few other Jesus-myth theories, but focuses primarily on the Jesus-myth claiming he's the new Horus.

Well, my take is that the film's core assertions are reasonably valid, though the means it chooses to try and demonstrate these assertions are not the best it could have chosen. You can debunk the Horus-Jesus connection, plenty of others have, but only a very superficial individual would feel satisfied with just this. The deeper connections are present, even if they are not so much represented in the film. Allusion to this is made in the film's accompanying material.

If anyone fancies checking through the list of related mythoi I suspect that you will find a lot of resembling symbolism in there too.

GreNME said:
Maybe I'll put one together and see what you think. :)

Yes, do.

Nick
 
Well, my take is that the film's core assertions are reasonably valid, though the means it chooses to try and demonstrate these assertions are not the best it could have chosen. You can debunk the Horus-Jesus connection, plenty of others have, but only a very superficial individual would feel satisfied with just this. The deeper connections are present, even if they are not so much represented in the film. Allusion to this is made in the film's accompanying material.

The film's core assertion is that religion is a lie and a fraud, which implies a deliberate attempt to deceive. That's a ridiculous assertion in which even these various Jesus-myth theories it tries to draw from offer no support. Make no mistake, though, that they focus heavily on the Jesus-Horus thing first, and comparing the modern Zodiac to ancient traditions second.

Still no proof from anyone on Anup the Baptizer, though. :)
 
The film's core assertion is that religion is a lie and a fraud, which implies a deliberate attempt to deceive. That's a ridiculous assertion in which even these various Jesus-myth theories it tries to draw from offer no support. Make no mistake, though, that they focus heavily on the Jesus-Horus thing first, and comparing the modern Zodiac to ancient traditions second.

Still no proof from anyone on Anup the Baptizer, though. :)

Well, the movie's still doing great business. I mean, personally, I don't know why people going on these great "debunking" crusades. I suppose they figure they'll get some kind of reflected glory out of it, or they're just terrified of the ramifications and so stuck in their heads they can't bear to think their compacted little world-view could be shattered.

I see CTs like Encounter Therapy. You put your judgements out! You don't sit around deliberating and rationalising "oh, he shouldn't say that about me. it's not fair because such-and-such..." You just put them out. You create space for all the emotional reactions and then you let people see who they are afterwards. It's healthy.

The Republican Party, World Bank, and Catholic Church are all crying out for some encounter therapy. It's no good to pull punches.

Nick
 
Well, the movie's still doing great business.

So lies and misdirection should go unchallenged? I don't see what your point is.


I mean, personally, I don't know why people going on these great "debunking" crusades. I suppose they figure they'll get some kind of reflected glory out of it, or they're just terrified of the ramifications and so stuck in their heads they can't bear to think their compacted little world-view could be shattered.

I think you're tilting at windmills. There are a few blogs and such out there who have been critical of it. Other sources are entries on websites responding to numerous Jesus-myths out there, not Zeitgeist in general. Some of those sites, by the way, are simply doing Christian apologetics, a tradition that's been around for longer than the popular Jesus-myths around today.


I see CTs like Encounter Therapy. You put your judgements out! You don't sit around deliberating and rationalising "oh, he shouldn't say that about me. it's not fair because such-and-such..." You just put them out. You create space for all the emotional reactions and then you let people see who they are afterwards. It's healthy.

Whereas I see it as often a variation of either false rape accusations or the equivalent of "so-and-so beats their spouse." It's unnecessary for airing potential questions and airing doubts. There are far more healthy and communicative ways to do it.


The Republican Party, World Bank, and Catholic Church are all crying out for some encounter therapy. It's no good to pull punches.

Nick

You don't get a heroin addict to detox by telling everyone he's a compulsive shoplifter.
 
So lies and misdirection should go unchallenged? I don't see what your point is.

No, challenge away, I think it's great. I mean, this thread has certainly raised my awareness.


GreNME said:
I think you're tilting at windmills. There are a few blogs and such out there who have been critical of it. Other sources are entries on websites responding to numerous Jesus-myths out there, not Zeitgeist in general. Some of those sites, by the way, are simply doing Christian apologetics, a tradition that's been around for longer than the popular Jesus-myths around today.

Fair enough.


GreNME said:
Whereas I see it as often a variation of either false rape accusations or the equivalent of "so-and-so beats their spouse." It's unnecessary for airing potential questions and airing doubts. There are far more healthy and communicative ways to do it.

There's enough skeletons in the cupboards of the 3 institutions I mentioned to keep a legion of med students happy for aeons. These are not healthy organisations we're talking about here, doing their best to make the world a better place. Far from it. Let them take some **** and try and scrape it off. It also empowers positive elements within the same orgs to create positive change.

Nick
 
Well, I must say I'm quite proud of myself. 24 posts and I am being labeled as a "troll". All I can say is think what you want ( Just as long as it does not contradict the "official theory" that is!:cool: ) , but calling me names isn't going to make me go away.

Maybe it has something to do with your attitude.

Have you actually done any research on this stuff? Or do you just accept whatever any old Nazi or psychotic off the streets tells you at face value?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom