Good excuse? Sorry, some of us have to maintain some semblance of a real life beyond the semantic circles you would have us run in.
Ahh, the good old "get a life" variant.
And by the way, your the one who has the "original source"...and have repeatedly avoided revealing it or any other substantive information that could be investigated independently.
The internet has the original texts. You don't need me to give them to you. All you need to do is be serious about looking up sources. Which, so far, you haven't.
You have been offering BS web pages that in no way have any academic authority nor anything substantial to add to your argument. I am not interested in playing childish ego reinforcing internet mind games with you, if you have information that invalidates the theory that the cultures that christianity sprang from weren't influenced in anyway by the mythologies of the egyptian culture throughout it's long and colored history then cough them up for scrutiny.
You're asking for a proof of a negative. Asking to prove a negative is like asking to prove god doesn't exist. I have been repeatedly pointing out that each of the far-fetched claims made about where Christianity "sprang" from have no actual evidence outside of fringe authors who cite no one but themselves as "proof." So far, you've followed suit and self-reference the fringe authors, yet can't point to the original texts they claim they found such information. I actually went as far as to
give you the actual Egyptian texts after you failed to provide them, and you're still coming up with no actual evidence from the original cultures that these fringe authors are claiming were the template for Christianity.
You can't find a single legitimate reference to back your claim.
Outside of mainstream academia, Egyptology websites, the ancient text repository on the web, and pretty much every book I've cited, that is.
Believe me, the tiny shards of "debunking" you have graced this thread with have been very easy to verify. There is not one single academic reference cited to the best of my knowledge, and not one shred of actual evidence to be considered other than your opinion informed opinion.
What "debunking" are you talking about? The film makes outrageous claims, and I have said that the evidence they claim exists does not, in fact, exist. There is
no Egyptian source describing a virgin birth of Horus. There is
no Egyptian source describing twelve disciples of Horus. There is
no Egyptian source describing a baptism of Horus, and no evidence of any "Anup the Baptizer" ever existing. Over and over I point this and a multitude of things out, and yet neither you nor any other wannabe-'researcher' who makes these claims can back them up with valid Egyptian text. Just a bunch more of the same late-19th and early-20th fringe scholars who often spent the majority of their later years "debunking" Christianity by claiming it was a fraud.
Regardless of the speed at which information disseminates, we are talking about thousands upon thousands upon thousands of years during which time the probability of cultural transference of many idea's is very high. It's fine with me if you want to point out how outsiders influenced egypt, but to remind you, what we are talking about here is why you believe egypt did not influence any culture outside of itself, particularly the cultures that ultimately developed christianity.
No, what we are talking about is if the film
Zeitgeist made claims that are based on fact. Many or most of them are not, and other claims are misdirections by the narration to imply a malicious manipulation. The claims made have no evidence connecting Egyptian mythology to Christianity, and the only "proofs" they cite on their very own website are these fringe authors who have self-referenced themselves for the better part of a decade while displaying no direct translations supporting their claims.
You have given, rather, nothing that supports your claim that egypt had no influence elswhere. You claim to have precise evidence, so please reveal it.
You can't prove a negative. The only thing you can do is prove that the claimed evidence does not exist. If you want, we can go
line for line through Egyptian texts, and I will give you and anyone else all of the chance in the world to find for me the sources of these claims made with no evidence.
My hypocritical emotions? What my dear boy are you talking about? I don't need to focus on the source texts...
Right, you just believe whatever these fringe self-referencers claim, even though there is no evidence.
those aren't going to tell me anything about whether or not egypt influenced cultures in the middle east(something I maintain) or not(something you maintain)...all they are going to do is tell me what the egyptian text says.
You need to go check the sources the movie uses, and you need to check what your own link from Gerald Massey's book says. They claim to be using Egyptian texts for their claims. So, to be able to tell whether their claims are based on fact or not, all of their claims should be checked from the originating texts. As it turns out, most of what they claim is in the text happens to not exist.
Some thing you have failed to consider this whole time seems to be that things don't have to be exactly the same to be similar...."correlation doesn't equal causation"...right?... even though you know right and well that when you have a culture living in a region for literally thousands upon thousands of years they are going to rub off on their neighbors a bit.
They aren't even
similar, which is what I keep saying. Give me one Egyptian text that describes the virgin birth. Give me one Egyptian text that names 12 disciples. Give me one Egyptian text that describes a baptism by "Anup the Baptizer."
You can't, you know you can't, you know that none of these other "souces" can, and you refuse to admit it.
I gave you links to the Book of the Dead. I even told you which scroll (Ani) Massey used. All you have to do is
find the actual use of the name "Anup the Baptizer", and yet you continue to fail to do so.
Especially if their neighbors happen to be a culture that is under their hegemony...like the jews...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Jews_in_Egypt
Will you
please start to actually read what you link from Wikipedia before you link it? This is getting old having to tell you how your own link shows your ignorance. The only 'evidence' of the Hebrew slavery in ancient Egypt is from the Old Testament. There exists
not a single scrap of evidence from Egyptian material from those same periods. The only evidences not of Biblical origin of Hebrews showing up in Egypt happen
after the
First Diaspora. No Egyptian references to Abraham, no Egyptian references to Noah, no Egyptian references to the 12 Tribes of Jacob (Israel), no Egyptian references to Moses. Not even evidence of Egyptian efforts to hide such details, since there are plenty of references to Rameses in Egyptian records (with whom Moses held court in the Bible).
Interesting, though, that you are so eager to use Biblical record of the Hebrews having been slaves in Egypt, yet refuse to accept the Biblical record that Jews had their religion long before ever coming to Egypt and that Abraham-- who came from the city Ur, very far away from Egypt-- had brought together these tribes that Jacob and eventually Joseph would lead to hide in Egypt. You're willing to cherry-pick which things you want to believe as fact, but only if it suits your predetermined conclusion.
Your assurance means nothing if you offer little or nothing to back it up.
I've backed up everything I have said. I even told you to go ahead and take these last eight or so pages of discussion to your Uni friends and ask
them what
they think. I've not only given you the opportunity to present your evidences, in the last couple of pages I've
given you the source materials to find citations of these things that I am stating do not exist.
So far, you've done little but recycle the same tired phrases and arguments, hence the lack of deferment to you. You may have actually read these things...if so...write up where and how these unnamed scholars discovered in the source texts exactly the reason why egypt didn't influence middle eastern cultures.
A tidy summary will do....
Here's a tidy summary for you:
These people who claim that Egyptian Horus mythology is the original template for Christ are making their claims up out of thin air. No one who has ever attempted to make such a case can cite a single Egyptian text than described things like the virgin birth, the baptism or "Anup the Baptizer", 12 disciples, the death and resurrection of Horus, any usage of the name "Meri" for Isis, and plenty more. The film
Zeitgeist ignores
Akkad,
Sumer,
Assyria, and
Babylon almost completely. Biblical references to those kingdoms show up in much greater abundance, and there actually exist evidences in those cultures that corroberate the Biblical accounts mentioning those cultures, whereas the Biblical accounts of Egypt are
not corroberated by Egyptian historical account. The film
Zeitgeist and all of these other "Christ-mythers" or "Jesus-frauds" only barely mention names like
Sargon or
Nebuchanezzar, even though they played significant roles in Hebrew history from both a Biblical (religious) and academic perspective.
The problem with the claims the film makes is that it can't cite a single Egyptian source to support its claim, yet it names all kinds of Egyptian sources. For any honest researcher to hear these claims and actually look at the widely-available texts that exist out there, often for free, they will find absolutely no supporting text in any of the Egyptian sources to back up the claims like those made in
Zeitgeist. Such supporting descriptions for the claims are completely absent, they simply don't exist. The best part of it all is that
you don't even have to take my word for it. You can actually
check it out for yourself both
here and
here. These are
free online repositories of actual translations to verify if the claims of those in the
Zeitgeist film and other lists have factual basis. All that is required is the intellectual honesty to go check for yourself instead of taking the word of some film.