ZEITGEIST, The Movie

It's been two days, thesyntaxera. Have you found the original source yet? Do you want me to give you the answer, or have you given up?

I haven't even looked at this page for two days.

The problem thesyntaxera is facing here is that he's attempting to argue with someone who's been studying this since before he ever got into middle school (he's in college now, I surmise this because he wouldn't have a JSTOR login unless he borrowed it from a friend).

Or if he worked for a University, I haven't been in college for a while now.

Still no evidence I see. Why not just lay out what you've got for information so we can examine it instead of talking yourself into redundancy.

If you have been researching this for so long then it should be no problem for you to summarize your research into concise points to clearly show how egyptian mythology didn't influence the cultures of the region that would ultimately give rise to christianity. That is the task before you.

Quit wasting everyone's time and get to the point.
 
I haven't even looked at this page for two days.

That's a good excuse. Still no answer to the original source.


Or if he worked for a University, I haven't been in college for a while now.

Another good excuse. Still no original source.

Still no evidence I see. Why not just lay out what you've got for information so we can examine it instead of talking yourself into redundancy.

I've been offering evidence for the past six pages or so. You simply refuse to accept it, and when I challenge you to name a single source for a single point, you are finding it impossible to provide.


If you have been researching this for so long then it should be no problem for you to summarize your research into concise points to clearly show how egyptian mythology didn't influence the cultures of the region that would ultimately give rise to christianity. That is the task before you.

Quit wasting everyone's time and get to the point.

The point is that Gerald Massey's book, which your Google search found for you, is claiming to be a translation of the Book of Ani in the Egyptian Book of the Dead. This attempted translation is old, and more accurately many of the things he claims to have found in the document have not been found in subsequent searches by many other researchers. In fact, while Massey is regarded as a very capable art historian and poetic linguist, his translations have not been matched by subsequent translations of the same texts. So, if you really feel capable of pointing out where the passages Massey cites are located, here is a good place to start that has the translated text for you. No Anup, no baptizer. Here's another one, same original translator but basically broken down easier. Still no anup, still no baptizer.

Since you claim to work at a uni, you should have no problem finding a copy of such resources to verify. This same situation occurs in every instance where I have stated that the people who put together that list fabricated their claim. In other cases, like the usage of "meri" as if it were a name and not Egyptian for "beloved," is also easily verifiable for you. In fact, absolutely nothing I have pointed out should be difficult for you to simply verify by printing these pages and showing them to your history department, if they are so willing.

The reality is that there is no definitive story of Horus, of Isis, of Ra, or of Osiris. Egypt had mostly conflicting relationships with most of Mesopotamia and Canaan, because Mesopotamia was an insular region that had constant infighting and cultures that distrusted outsiders. Information simply did not disseminate in the manner or speed in which it disseminates today, and that includes cultural concepts and religion. Everything that is historically known about the Egyptian dynasties shows more evidence of outside influence on Egyptian culture and religion from outside forces in Nubia, Persia, and the Indus River Valley (these were the Hyksos, meaning "outsider," migrations and dynasties).

I have given explanation after explanation, and all you have done is demand precise evidence from me but expect none from these dubious sources. If you could be bothered to get past your hypocritical emotions regarding my dismissal of what has obviously seemed like a compelling (though not historical as you admitted in at least one past post) argument by those who made these claims. The fact that you haven't been focused on source texts themselves shows that you're more interested in making an argument than finding out if any of these claims have merit to begin with. I can assure you that none of the claims are supported by the Egyptian texts, I can even point you to copies of many of the texts which have translations, but I can't make you read and verify that for you myself. You either have to put in the time to actually read or you have to think about whether you want to defer to people who may have actually shown that they have read these things.

How's that for you? Are you willing yet to believe that "Anup the Baptizer" is a fabrication? Can we now move to the next one?
 
Before we move on to the next talking points, comparisons, and claims from these things I've been calling incorrect or fraudulent, I figured I would check out some of my books to give some context on the things I've been saying. I found, in the preface to the book Development of Religion and Thought in Ancient Egypt by James Breasted, Dr. Breasted states the following:
Dr. James Breasted said:
The great and complicated fabric of life which they [the pyramid texts] reflect to us, the religious and intellectual forces which have left their traces in them, the intrusion of the Osiris faith and the Osirian editiing by the hand of the earliest redactor in literal history-- all these and many other fundemental disclosuresof this earliest body of literature have hitherto been inaccessible to the English reader, and as far as they are new, also to all

The "earliest redactor" he is talking about there, as far as it is reflective of his other observations and much knowledge even today, happens to be Amenhotep (the fourth, known as Akhenaten). This pharaoh was the one who brought a monotheism ('called' Atenism) to Egypt during his rule, and in many cases banished a lot of sacred texts involving the host (list) of gods. This doesn't mean no records were found (there were), but this is one of the easliest examples of an ancient culture performing a mass historical and religious revision. I'm pointing this out because while Amenhotep's (or Akhenaten's) purge was probably most notable in religious terms for Egypt, many pharaohs have been known to blank out sections of history, sometimes that of their predecessor when there were embarrassing moments involved.

I also wanted to point out that, in 1912 (less than a century ago), a lot of these texts were still considered new as far as translations went. Many discoveries of ancient Egyptian texts went for decades before successful translation efforts were able to take place, and even further for some to have definitive translations that the entirety of Egyptology study would find acceptable and with as little bias as possible. Keep this in mind, as this is one of the main reasons I have and continued to point out that the earliest "evidence" that these claims have ever sourced date back to between the times of about 1850 - 1920, when there were many conflicting 'translations' abound.

In this preface, Breasted readily admits that these texts cover such broad and changing amounts of times that attempting to find religious origins is not a practical task. He also writes:
Dr. James Breasted said:
Indeed Re [Ra] and Osiris are so largely anthropomorphic that, in dealing as I have chiefly with the Solar and Osirian faiths, it [origin seeking] was not necessary. In the age discussed these two highest gods were altogether human and highly spiritualized, though the thought of Re [Ra] displays occasional relapses, as it were, in the current allusions to the other falcon [Horus], with which he was so early associated.

Even at this time, it was obvious that many of these gods took many forms, both in relation to humans (mostly pharaohs) at the time and converging with each other. All of these fringe theories linking Judaism and Christianity to Egyptian mythology ignore these things completely or are totally ignorant of these plain facts.

I'll include more later, as I'm off to a Celtic Heritage festival. :)
 
I'll include more later, as I'm off to a Celtic Heritage festival. :)

Ask them about the Celtic Fire festivals - Samhain, Imbolg, Beltane, and Lugnasad. And their significance to Christianity and Gnosticism. (Oh, and, if you're feeling inspired...to Cassini!)

Worked it out yet?

Nick
 
Last edited:
Ask them about the Celtic Fire festivals - Samhain, Imbolg, Beltane, and Lugnasad. And their significance to Christianity and Gnosticism. (Oh, and, if you're feeling inspired...to Cassini!)

Worked it out yet?

Nick

Err...

I wouldn't call it "influence" so much as "absorbtion" in those cases. That's been a steady characteristic of Christianity and a few other religions-- as they spread, they absorb the heroes and hero tales or fables, rewriting them into the narrative. The Celtic areas were one of the few in medieval times who actually had rites performed in the local tongues, which is partly responsible for the early adoption and long history of Celtic saints. Celtic Catholicism is similar to Persian Islam in Iran, in that there exists a lot of symbology in regular use among its practitioners that is not stopped by the church, even though they are obviously not exactly in line with the mainstream and, outside of the culture in which they're practiced. For example, there are Iranian mosques that actually have old paintings of faces and zoroastrian holidays and imagery appear observed enough for an outsider to notice, but not so much to invoke the anger and accusation of heresy by the ruling religious leaders. It's a useful and mostly harmless affectation that gives the practitioners the ability to identify with the main religion while staying connected to their cultural heritage.

All of this isn't necessarily on topic, though. I'm waiting for thesyntaxera to reply as to whether my responses have adequately shown that there is no evidence of existence for Anup the Baptizer, so that we can move on down the list.
 
Err...

I wouldn't call it "influence" so much as "absorbtion" in those cases. That's been a steady characteristic of Christianity and a few other religions-- as they spread, they absorb the heroes and hero tales or fables, rewriting them into the narrative. The Celtic areas were one of the few in medieval times who actually had rites performed in the local tongues, which is partly responsible for the early adoption and long history of Celtic saints. Celtic Catholicism is similar to Persian Islam in Iran, in that there exists a lot of symbology in regular use among its practitioners that is not stopped by the church, even though they are obviously not exactly in line with the mainstream and, outside of the culture in which they're practiced. For example, there are Iranian mosques that actually have old paintings of faces and zoroastrian holidays and imagery appear observed enough for an outsider to notice, but not so much to invoke the anger and accusation of heresy by the ruling religious leaders. It's a useful and mostly harmless affectation that gives the practitioners the ability to identify with the main religion while staying connected to their cultural heritage.

Hi GreNME,

Thanks for your insights and the links you forwarded earlier on to Egyptian beliefs. Though I'm half Iranian I'm so detached from my ancestors that I have little knowledge about their beliefs, so it's nice to learn things.

With regard to the four Celtic Fire Festivals I mentioned, note that these times of major celebration and ritual were held at the peak of each season and fall into the astrological year thus...Samhain - Scorpio; Imbolc - Aquarius; Beltane - Taurus; and Lugnasad - Leo. These are the four stations of the Gnostic Fixed Cross, the symbolic basis for the Christian "crucifixion" legend.

I would personally be happy to accept that Egyptian mythology does not demonstrate a level of coherence to substantiate claims that it is the basis for Christianity, but these elements of Life, Purgation, and Rebirth are found to be central themes in it and many other world mythoi, certainly including Christianity.

Nick

ps - for anyone interested in the Fixed Cross, also note that, astrologically, the Sun, Moon, and 7 planets studied by the ancients only very, very occasionally find themselves solely in the four astrological houses of the Cross. I believe it is supposed to occur only once in the Grand Astrological Year which is about 25,000 years. This did actually happen fairly recently, on August 18 1999, which if you're really a wild CTist with scant regard for coincidence was also the day of the Cassini fly-by. Just to tie in another little bit of this thread!
 
Hi GreNME,

Thanks for your insights and the links you forwarded earlier on to Egyptian beliefs. Though I'm half Iranian I'm so detached from my ancestors that I have little knowledge about their beliefs, so it's nice to learn things.

With regard to the four Celtic Fire Festivals I mentioned, note that these times of major celebration and ritual were held at the peak of each season and fall into the astrological year thus...Samhain - Scorpio; Imbolc - Aquarius; Beltane - Taurus; and Lugnasad - Leo. These are the four stations of the Gnostic Fixed Cross, the symbolic basis for the Christian "crucifixion" legend.

I would personally be happy to accept that Egyptian mythology does not demonstrate a level of coherence to substantiate claims that it is the basis for Christianity, but these elements of Life, Purgation, and Rebirth are found to be central themes in it and many other world mythoi, certainly including Christianity.

Like I said, though, I think "basis" or "origin" or "influence" is all too strong of language to use in accordance to their involvement and absorbtion by Christianity. The reason I mentioned the Iranian observances with relation to Islam is to give an example that doesn't just include Christianity that illustrates how certain cultural aspects are only partially integrated into that main religion in that area, while some practices are culturally specific to people of that area and often exist in a tolerated manner because it provides additional cultural solidarity. There are many practices in many religions that have locally-followed traditions and practices that are not necessarily connected directly to the core beliefs of the overall faith. Celtic Catholic symbology and Persian-Iranian Zoroastrian roots are both very good examples of this that still exist in the modern world. There are similar mixtures of Shinto in Japanese Christianity, but because I'm less well-studied in the language of the culture I would have to research more to give you detailed examples.

For more information on what I was talking about with regard to the Iranian observations in Islam, I suggest checking out In Search of Zarathustra by Paul Kriwaczek. The first couple of chapters are very interesting, and the examinations of Islam in Iran are mostly secondary while much of the book covers Zoroastrian iconography that made its way into Western (Christian) iconography. I think it would be interesting to you, Nick, mostly because of its dips into transfers of symbolism, not necessarily because it is a study on Persian cultural and religious iconography.


ps - for anyone interested in the Fixed Cross, also note that, astrologically, the Sun, Moon, and 7 planets studied by the ancients only very, very occasionally find themselves solely in the four astrological houses of the Cross. I believe it is supposed to occur only once in the Grand Astrological Year which is about 25,000 years. This did actually happen fairly recently, on August 18 1999, which if you're really a wild CTist with scant regard for coincidence was also the day of the Cassini fly-by. Just to tie in another little bit of this thread!

Has anyone made a YouTube video of this yet? Maybe you and I could collaborate on a short production explaining this and put it up there! :D
 
There are similar mixtures of Shinto in Japanese Christianity, but because I'm less well-studied in the language of the culture I would have to research more to give you detailed examples.


A better example would be Korean christianity. Look up Hwanin, as the history of the evolution of this character is relatively well documented.
 
That's a good excuse. Still no answer to the original source.

Good excuse? Sorry, some of us have to maintain some semblance of a real life beyond the semantic circles you would have us run in.

And by the way, your the one who has the "original source"...and have repeatedly avoided revealing it or any other substantive information that could be investigated independently.


I've been offering evidence for the past six pages or so. You simply refuse to accept it, and when I challenge you to name a single source for a single point, you are finding it impossible to provide.

You have been offering BS web pages that in no way have any academic authority nor anything substantial to add to your argument. I am not interested in playing childish ego reinforcing internet mind games with you, if you have information that invalidates the theory that the cultures that christianity sprang from weren't influenced in anyway by the mythologies of the egyptian culture throughout it's long and colored history then cough them up for scrutiny.

The point is...

You can't find a single legitimate reference to back your claim.

Since you claim to work at a uni, you should have no problem finding a copy of such resources to verify. This same situation occurs in every instance where I have stated that the people who put together that list fabricated their claim. In other cases, like the usage of "meri" as if it were a name and not Egyptian for "beloved," is also easily verifiable for you. In fact, absolutely nothing I have pointed out should be difficult for you to simply verify by printing these pages and showing them to your history department, if they are so willing.

Believe me, the tiny shards of "debunking" you have graced this thread with have been very easy to verify. There is not one single academic reference cited to the best of my knowledge, and not one shred of actual evidence to be considered other than your opinion informed opinion.

The reality is that there is no definitive story of Horus, of Isis, of Ra, or of Osiris. Egypt had mostly conflicting relationships with most of Mesopotamia and Canaan, because Mesopotamia was an insular region that had constant infighting and cultures that distrusted outsiders. Information simply did not disseminate in the manner or speed in which it disseminates today, and that includes cultural concepts and religion. Everything that is historically known about the Egyptian dynasties shows more evidence of outside influence on Egyptian culture and religion from outside forces in Nubia, Persia, and the Indus River Valley (these were the Hyksos, meaning "outsider," migrations and dynasties).

Regardless of the speed at which information disseminates, we are talking about thousands upon thousands upon thousands of years during which time the probability of cultural transference of many idea's is very high. It's fine with me if you want to point out how outsiders influenced egypt, but to remind you, what we are talking about here is why you believe egypt did not influence any culture outside of itself, particularly the cultures that ultimately developed christianity.

I have given explanation after explanation, and all you have done is demand precise evidence from me but expect none from these dubious sources.

You have given, rather, nothing that supports your claim that egypt had no influence elswhere. You claim to have precise evidence, so please reveal it.

If you could be bothered to get past your hypocritical emotions regarding my dismissal of what has obviously seemed like a compelling (though not historical as you admitted in at least one past post) argument by those who made these claims. The fact that you haven't been focused on source texts themselves shows that you're more interested in making an argument than finding out if any of these claims have merit to begin with.

My hypocritical emotions? What my dear boy are you talking about? I don't need to focus on the source texts...those aren't going to tell me anything about whether or not egypt influenced cultures in the middle east(something I maintain) or not(something you maintain)...all they are going to do is tell me what the egyptian text says. Some thing you have failed to consider this whole time seems to be that things don't have to be exactly the same to be similar...."correlation doesn't equal causation"...right?... even though you know right and well that when you have a culture living in a region for literally thousands upon thousands of years they are going to rub off on their neighbors a bit. Especially if their neighbors happen to be a culture that is under their hegemony...like the jews...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Jews_in_Egypt
During the Middle Kingdom, especially from the time of Senusret 111, Egypt's suzerainty reached through Palestine as far north as Syria, and in the subsequent troubles of the Thirteenth Dynasty a large influx of nomadic Semites from these areas settled in the more secure and prosperous land of Egypt. Biblical accounts of the time of Abraham onward suggest that considerable numbers of Hebrews, among these groups, also took refuge in Egypt, especially along the eastern frontier of the Delta, called the Land of Goshen. The Egyptian cities mentioned in the Bible all belong to this part of the country.

In the Elephantine papyri, caches of legal documents and letters written in Aramaic amply document the lives of a community of Jewish soldiers stationed in there as part of a frontier garrison in Egypt for the Achaemenid Empire. Established at Elephantine in about 650 BC during Manasseh's reign, these soldiers assisted Pharaoh Psammetichus I in his Nubian campaign. Their religious system shows strong traces of Babylonian polytheism, something which suggests to certain scholars that the community was of mixed Judaeo-Samaritan origins,[6] and they maintained their own temple, being functioning alongside that of the local deity Chnum. The documents cover the period 495 to 399 BC.

I can assure you that none of the claims are supported by the Egyptian texts, I can even point you to copies of many of the texts which have translations, but I can't make you read and verify that for you myself.

Your assurance means nothing if you offer little or nothing to back it up.

You either have to put in the time to actually read or you have to think about whether you want to defer to people who may have actually shown that they have read these things.

So far, you've done little but recycle the same tired phrases and arguments, hence the lack of deferment to you. You may have actually read these things...if so...write up where and how these unnamed scholars discovered in the source texts exactly the reason why egypt didn't influence middle eastern cultures.

A tidy summary will do....
 
Here's a list, btw, of the pre-Christian mythological figures whose lives the movie asserts to have similar attributes to that of Jesus'.

Nick

Attis - Greece - 1200BC
Krishna - India - 900BC
Dionysus - Greece - 500BC
Mithra - Persia - 1200BC

Chrishna of Hindustan
Budha Sakia of India
Salivahana of Bermuda
Zulis, or Zhule, also Osiris and Orus of Egypt
Odin of the Scandinavians
Crite of Chaldea
Zoroaster and Mithra of Persia
Baal and Taut, of Phoenecia
Indra of Tibet
Bali of Afghanistan
Jao of Nepal
Wittoba of the Bilingonese
Thammuz of Syria
Atys of Phrygia
Xamolxis of Thrace
Zoar of the Bonzes
Adad of Assyria
Deva Tat, and Sammonocadam of Siam
Alcides of Thebes
Mikado of the Sintoos
Beddru of Japan
Hesus or Eros, and Bremrillah of the Druids
Thor, son of Odin, of the Gauls
Cadmus of Greece
Hil and Feta of the Mandaites
Gentaut and Quexalcote of Mexico
Universal Monarch of the Sibyls
Ischy of the Island of Formosa
Divine Teacher of Plato
Holy One of Xaca
Fohi and Tien of China
Adonis of Greece
Ixion and Quirinus of Rome
Prometheus of Caucasus
 
Good excuse? Sorry, some of us have to maintain some semblance of a real life beyond the semantic circles you would have us run in.

Ahh, the good old "get a life" variant.


And by the way, your the one who has the "original source"...and have repeatedly avoided revealing it or any other substantive information that could be investigated independently.

The internet has the original texts. You don't need me to give them to you. All you need to do is be serious about looking up sources. Which, so far, you haven't.


You have been offering BS web pages that in no way have any academic authority nor anything substantial to add to your argument. I am not interested in playing childish ego reinforcing internet mind games with you, if you have information that invalidates the theory that the cultures that christianity sprang from weren't influenced in anyway by the mythologies of the egyptian culture throughout it's long and colored history then cough them up for scrutiny.

You're asking for a proof of a negative. Asking to prove a negative is like asking to prove god doesn't exist. I have been repeatedly pointing out that each of the far-fetched claims made about where Christianity "sprang" from have no actual evidence outside of fringe authors who cite no one but themselves as "proof." So far, you've followed suit and self-reference the fringe authors, yet can't point to the original texts they claim they found such information. I actually went as far as to give you the actual Egyptian texts after you failed to provide them, and you're still coming up with no actual evidence from the original cultures that these fringe authors are claiming were the template for Christianity.


You can't find a single legitimate reference to back your claim.

Outside of mainstream academia, Egyptology websites, the ancient text repository on the web, and pretty much every book I've cited, that is.


Believe me, the tiny shards of "debunking" you have graced this thread with have been very easy to verify. There is not one single academic reference cited to the best of my knowledge, and not one shred of actual evidence to be considered other than your opinion informed opinion.

What "debunking" are you talking about? The film makes outrageous claims, and I have said that the evidence they claim exists does not, in fact, exist. There is no Egyptian source describing a virgin birth of Horus. There is no Egyptian source describing twelve disciples of Horus. There is no Egyptian source describing a baptism of Horus, and no evidence of any "Anup the Baptizer" ever existing. Over and over I point this and a multitude of things out, and yet neither you nor any other wannabe-'researcher' who makes these claims can back them up with valid Egyptian text. Just a bunch more of the same late-19th and early-20th fringe scholars who often spent the majority of their later years "debunking" Christianity by claiming it was a fraud.


Regardless of the speed at which information disseminates, we are talking about thousands upon thousands upon thousands of years during which time the probability of cultural transference of many idea's is very high. It's fine with me if you want to point out how outsiders influenced egypt, but to remind you, what we are talking about here is why you believe egypt did not influence any culture outside of itself, particularly the cultures that ultimately developed christianity.

No, what we are talking about is if the film Zeitgeist made claims that are based on fact. Many or most of them are not, and other claims are misdirections by the narration to imply a malicious manipulation. The claims made have no evidence connecting Egyptian mythology to Christianity, and the only "proofs" they cite on their very own website are these fringe authors who have self-referenced themselves for the better part of a decade while displaying no direct translations supporting their claims.


You have given, rather, nothing that supports your claim that egypt had no influence elswhere. You claim to have precise evidence, so please reveal it.

You can't prove a negative. The only thing you can do is prove that the claimed evidence does not exist. If you want, we can go line for line through Egyptian texts, and I will give you and anyone else all of the chance in the world to find for me the sources of these claims made with no evidence.


My hypocritical emotions? What my dear boy are you talking about? I don't need to focus on the source texts...

Right, you just believe whatever these fringe self-referencers claim, even though there is no evidence.

those aren't going to tell me anything about whether or not egypt influenced cultures in the middle east(something I maintain) or not(something you maintain)...all they are going to do is tell me what the egyptian text says.

You need to go check the sources the movie uses, and you need to check what your own link from Gerald Massey's book says. They claim to be using Egyptian texts for their claims. So, to be able to tell whether their claims are based on fact or not, all of their claims should be checked from the originating texts. As it turns out, most of what they claim is in the text happens to not exist.


Some thing you have failed to consider this whole time seems to be that things don't have to be exactly the same to be similar...."correlation doesn't equal causation"...right?... even though you know right and well that when you have a culture living in a region for literally thousands upon thousands of years they are going to rub off on their neighbors a bit.

They aren't even similar, which is what I keep saying. Give me one Egyptian text that describes the virgin birth. Give me one Egyptian text that names 12 disciples. Give me one Egyptian text that describes a baptism by "Anup the Baptizer." You can't, you know you can't, you know that none of these other "souces" can, and you refuse to admit it.

I gave you links to the Book of the Dead. I even told you which scroll (Ani) Massey used. All you have to do is find the actual use of the name "Anup the Baptizer", and yet you continue to fail to do so.


Especially if their neighbors happen to be a culture that is under their hegemony...like the jews...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Jews_in_Egypt

Will you please start to actually read what you link from Wikipedia before you link it? This is getting old having to tell you how your own link shows your ignorance. The only 'evidence' of the Hebrew slavery in ancient Egypt is from the Old Testament. There exists not a single scrap of evidence from Egyptian material from those same periods. The only evidences not of Biblical origin of Hebrews showing up in Egypt happen after the First Diaspora. No Egyptian references to Abraham, no Egyptian references to Noah, no Egyptian references to the 12 Tribes of Jacob (Israel), no Egyptian references to Moses. Not even evidence of Egyptian efforts to hide such details, since there are plenty of references to Rameses in Egyptian records (with whom Moses held court in the Bible).

Interesting, though, that you are so eager to use Biblical record of the Hebrews having been slaves in Egypt, yet refuse to accept the Biblical record that Jews had their religion long before ever coming to Egypt and that Abraham-- who came from the city Ur, very far away from Egypt-- had brought together these tribes that Jacob and eventually Joseph would lead to hide in Egypt. You're willing to cherry-pick which things you want to believe as fact, but only if it suits your predetermined conclusion.


Your assurance means nothing if you offer little or nothing to back it up.

I've backed up everything I have said. I even told you to go ahead and take these last eight or so pages of discussion to your Uni friends and ask them what they think. I've not only given you the opportunity to present your evidences, in the last couple of pages I've given you the source materials to find citations of these things that I am stating do not exist.


So far, you've done little but recycle the same tired phrases and arguments, hence the lack of deferment to you. You may have actually read these things...if so...write up where and how these unnamed scholars discovered in the source texts exactly the reason why egypt didn't influence middle eastern cultures.

A tidy summary will do....

Here's a tidy summary for you:

These people who claim that Egyptian Horus mythology is the original template for Christ are making their claims up out of thin air. No one who has ever attempted to make such a case can cite a single Egyptian text than described things like the virgin birth, the baptism or "Anup the Baptizer", 12 disciples, the death and resurrection of Horus, any usage of the name "Meri" for Isis, and plenty more. The film Zeitgeist ignores Akkad, Sumer, Assyria, and Babylon almost completely. Biblical references to those kingdoms show up in much greater abundance, and there actually exist evidences in those cultures that corroberate the Biblical accounts mentioning those cultures, whereas the Biblical accounts of Egypt are not corroberated by Egyptian historical account. The film Zeitgeist and all of these other "Christ-mythers" or "Jesus-frauds" only barely mention names like Sargon or Nebuchanezzar, even though they played significant roles in Hebrew history from both a Biblical (religious) and academic perspective.

The problem with the claims the film makes is that it can't cite a single Egyptian source to support its claim, yet it names all kinds of Egyptian sources. For any honest researcher to hear these claims and actually look at the widely-available texts that exist out there, often for free, they will find absolutely no supporting text in any of the Egyptian sources to back up the claims like those made in Zeitgeist. Such supporting descriptions for the claims are completely absent, they simply don't exist. The best part of it all is that you don't even have to take my word for it. You can actually check it out for yourself both here and here. These are free online repositories of actual translations to verify if the claims of those in the Zeitgeist film and other lists have factual basis. All that is required is the intellectual honesty to go check for yourself instead of taking the word of some film.
 
Here's a list, btw, of the pre-Christian mythological figures whose lives the movie asserts to have similar attributes to that of Jesus'.

Nick

Attis - Greece - 1200BC
Krishna - India - 900BC
Dionysus - Greece - 500BC
Mithra - Persia - 1200BC

Chrishna of Hindustan
Budha Sakia of India
Salivahana of Bermuda
Zulis, or Zhule, also Osiris and Orus of Egypt
Odin of the Scandinavians
Crite of Chaldea
Zoroaster and Mithra of Persia
Baal and Taut, of Phoenecia
Indra of Tibet
Bali of Afghanistan
Jao of Nepal
Wittoba of the Bilingonese
Thammuz of Syria
Atys of Phrygia
Xamolxis of Thrace
Zoar of the Bonzes
Adad of Assyria
Deva Tat, and Sammonocadam of Siam
Alcides of Thebes
Mikado of the Sintoos
Beddru of Japan
Hesus or Eros, and Bremrillah of the Druids
Thor, son of Odin, of the Gauls
Cadmus of Greece
Hil and Feta of the Mandaites
Gentaut and Quexalcote of Mexico
Universal Monarch of the Sibyls
Ischy of the Island of Formosa
Divine Teacher of Plato
Holy One of Xaca
Fohi and Tien of China
Adonis of Greece
Ixion and Quirinus of Rome
Prometheus of Caucasus

That's one of the "throw spaghetti at a wall and see what sticks" techniques used in the film.
 
That's one of the "throw spaghetti at a wall and see what sticks" techniques used in the film.

Hmmm, well I wouldn't call it so much that. The film makes a lot of use of modern presentation techniques and is, imo, highly convincing to the novice on account of this. Certainly I'd be surprised if the production guy hadn't done the Anthony Robbins course "Mastering Influence" or similar because he or she clearly understands how to construct convincing arguments from limited source material. It's an art in itself.

In the scene where they run down this list on camera the effect is convincing. But of course it would be interesting to hear just how many of these characters really do subscribe to the same general characteristics as the Christ myth.

Nick
 
As I see it, "convincing to the novice" is the problem here. Why just last night I entered into a conversation with a friend of mine who I'd describe as metaphysically oriented and she certainly seemed convinced by her watching of Zeitgeist.

She did seem more focused on the 9/11 portion though and offered little resistance when I tried the 'they just made all that stuff up" approach....so she's not beyond hope.

So where are we with the Egypt?Christianity discussion ? Was Massey the first, or only scholar to draw the parallel ? I accept that his motives may have been biased, however are there any documents out there that deal specifically with flaws in Massey's translation ?

When I research just one author cited in Zeitgeist, John Jackson..strangely enough Amazondotcom also wants to sell me Massey's work along with the works of Kersey Graves, Acharya S and by Tim C. Leedom. Are these authors the one's referred to as self referencing ?
 
Hmmm, well I wouldn't call it so much that. The film makes a lot of use of modern presentation techniques and is, imo, highly convincing to the novice on account of this. Certainly I'd be surprised if the production guy hadn't done the Anthony Robbins course "Mastering Influence" or similar because he or she clearly understands how to construct convincing arguments from limited source material. It's an art in itself.

In the scene where they run down this list on camera the effect is convincing. But of course it would be interesting to hear just how many of these characters really do subscribe to the same general characteristics as the Christ myth.

Nick

Very good point. I actually should have recognized it in a few places. In fact, the entire 9/11 section is practically a textbook example.
 
As I see it, "convincing to the novice" is the problem here. Why just last night I entered into a conversation with a friend of mine who I'd describe as metaphysically oriented and she certainly seemed convinced by her watching of Zeitgeist.

She did seem more focused on the 9/11 portion though and offered little resistance when I tried the 'they just made all that stuff up" approach....so she's not beyond hope.

So where are we with the Egypt?Christianity discussion ? Was Massey the first, or only scholar to draw the parallel ? I accept that his motives may have been biased, however are there any documents out there that deal specifically with flaws in Massey's translation ?

When I research just one author cited in Zeitgeist, John Jackson..strangely enough Amazondotcom also wants to sell me Massey's work along with the works of Kersey Graves, Acharya S and by Tim C. Leedom. Are these authors the one's referred to as self referencing ?

Massey was neither the first or only to make such comparisons. There are usually at least a few in every generation who make these assertations, never provide the actual word-for-word translations from the text (instead translating the "idea" or "message"), and as time goes on they reference each other for citation purposes. The last time I recall this being a somewhat growing subject was in the mid-to-late 1980's when I was in middle and high school.


And please keep in mind that I'm not calling these men uneducated or crazy or possibly lying. Most of the people between the 1850's and the 1930's were honest-to-goodness scholars trying to find their niche in Egyptology. The thing is that the larger body of scholarship in Egyptology kept finding more evidence and more consistent evidence that their 'interpretational' translations were not as accurate as the more conventional translations.
 
Last edited:
Would it be fair to say that these "interpretational" translations were done in good faith and but gradually fell out of favour with the academic crowd as more research and more translations were done ?
 
Would it be fair to say that these "interpretational" translations were done in good faith and but gradually fell out of favour with the academic crowd as more research and more translations were done ?

I would say that they were done in good faith, but were working from a more incomplete understanding and context than what came later, and as such had a great deal of the personal influences or projection of context placed in them inadvertently.

E.A. Wallis Budge, for example, performed some of the most comprehensive translations of ancient Egyptian texts, even compared to many today. Still, while his work is still studied and his books still relevant in terms of translation, corrections have been made by subsequent scholars and Budge's original works (and conclusions) are less definitive today than they were even ten or twenty years ago. His translations-- which are many of the ones found at the links I gave on the ancient and sacred texts websites-- are still fairly good for the lay scholar or someone seeking general translations. There are newer translations, but copyright laws being what they are the authors will probably also be long dead before we find them freely publically accessible.

The point is that even though there are errors in either translations or conclusions of some earlier Egyptologists-- there have even been serious (fringe) Egyptologists who claimed that the pyramids were connected with alien civilizations, for example-- I try not to imply that they were stupid. Many of them were talented and accomplished linguists, art historians, architectural/engineering historians, and/or anthropologists. Some of their claims or conclusions simply haven't been borne out by the evidences they drew from at the time.

Productions like the Zeitgeist film, however, are intellectually sloppy and a better example of how a little bit of knowledge can be dangerous when the understanding of how to apply it is involved. It may very well be that the makers of the film honestly sought to "uncover" something with their sources, but many of the more contemporary sources should know better than to follow such narrow and exclusive schools of thought on subjects that are so broad and in many ways vague to begin with. It tends to often be the case, in my experience over the last decade or so, that people who put things like this out to "explain" the subject in such a decisive manner are proselytizing. Sometimes, they're proselytizing for the specific school of thought. Sometimes they're proselytizing against Christianity. Sometimes they are proselytizing it in supplement to other causes, which is where I think this video stands. It doesn't educate people of anything, it tells them what to believe. The whole first part of the film was put together to make the following indictment on religion as a whole and Christianity in particular:
Zeitgeist said:
Christianity, along with all other theistic belief systems, is the fraud of the age. It served to detach the species from the natural world, and likewise, each other. It supports blind submission to authority. It reduces human responsibility to the effect that "God" controls everything, and in turn awful crimes can be justified in the name of Divine Pursuit. And most importantly, it empowers those who know the truth but use the myth to manipulate and control societies. The religious myth is the most powerful device ever created, and serves as the psychological soil upon which other myths can flourish

Like I said many pages back, it's best to no attribute to malevolence what can better be attributed to ignorance. I think that applies equally to the development of religion (that needed to explain what couldn't be understood) as well as the movie itself.
 
Thanks GreNME
I see..that makes sense then that the knowledge base was expanded upon and clarified over time.

Out of curiosity,,,,how many translations are we talking about here ? I understand the copyright issues but would it be safe to assume that the later translations are available for purchase, should I wish to do so?

There was a time when I gave credence to the idea that aliens from outer space just might have had a hand in building the pyramids. I mean it kinda sorta seemed plausible, what with those huge stones and all. Then it just seemed sort of silly, and then I learned about the big long ramps idea and the aliens idea seemed, well, rather naive and ill reasoned.....but fun nonetheless
 
Last edited:
Thanks GreNME
I see..that makes sense then that the knowledge base was expanded upon and clarified over time.

Out of curiosity,,,,how many translations are we talking about here ? I understand the copyright issues but would it be safe to assume that the later translations are available for purchase, should I wish to do so?

There are a plenty of 'translations' in the interpretational sense out there, and I know of a few translations I find to be less descriptive and more transcriptive. I found some translations that were over $100 USD, but I found this one for the Book of the Dead and this one on the Pyramid texts to be pretty good if you study on a budget (like me). There is also the Ancient Records of Egypt series of five volumes (I'm collecting them myself).


There was a time when I gave credence to the idea that aliens from outer space just might have had a hand in building the pyramids. I mean it kinda sorta seemed plausible, what with those huge stones and all. Then it just seemed sort of silly, and then I learned about the big long ramps idea and the aliens idea seemed, well, rather naive and ill reasoned.....but fun nonetheless

Just so you know, Stargate is one of my favorite movies (despite cheesy acting) and actually comes with fascinating DVD extras on the subject. More fun if you're interested in watching for entertainment. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom