ZEITGEIST, The Movie

It doesn't seem interested in actually answering the science, only the faith of the person looking for it in the text. Whether it does so successfully, in my opinion, depends entirely on the reader and is a personal matter that is between the individual and their faith.
This is absolutely why I find religion to be so completely outrageous. I don't understand how I can be expected to have faith in something when the proof isn't actually present, I'm just supposed to have that thing called faith. For years I've been taught to stop using my head and to use my heart, but to me that is only an excuse for the fact that there is just no factual support for particular claims. It's like they're covering up the lack of evidence with a big spirited AMEN. It turns me soooo utterly off and I am just sickened by all the people who so readily accept claims that they themselves have done little or no research on. I just see faith as something to make people feel more safe and sheltered, which I guess really, that isn't such a bad thing. Unless you want actual answers. But thankyou for your post, I appreciate it.:)

And then the third part started, and I hadn't done much research into the Federal Reserve, and I'll be! The movie started to grab me. Well, it would have if I hadn't just suffered through the first two parts. I watched it all the way through, and then did a couple of Google searches. And that was the end of that.
Ha, it's just so amazing at how little people are willing to question as long as something is convincing. I've been on a few sites that evoke overwhelming support for this film, and anyone who disagrees(which there are very few) are simply not wanting to hear the truth.:rolleyes:

But yes, it's very easy to get sucked in, and if I hadn't done research, obviously there would be no reason for me to doubt this movie; or anything.

Research is power.
 
Last edited:
Research is power.

I love that quote, mind if I steal it ?

I haven't done any serious research on pt.1 of Zeitgeist, mainly because it sure looks like GreNME knows what he's talking about, but I have read every link posted on this thread as well as doing some googling on my own. I even found references to a book on this topic written in 1863.

As GreNME states, the relationship between Egypt and Christianity pops up every now and then, gets tossed around a bit, and is eventually kicked to the curb by scholars who know what they're talking about. GreNME also nailed it when he stated that these authors prefer to reference each other when making their case for this argument .

One thing I am curious about is, Why do people seem to want the alleged relationship between Egypt and Christianity to be true ? I personally don't care because as an atheist, I'm not really fussed whether one belief system "ripped off" or borrowed from another, but I am interested in whether a "documentary" like Zeitgeist is lying to me.

When I look back on all the time I've spent reading this thread, I realise that I'd actually forgotten that there were two other parts to this movie, so maybe the passion with which some people defend this relationship stems from their belief that if parts 1 and 2 are true, then, logically, part 1 must be also.
 
I love that quote, mind if I steal it ?

I haven't done any serious research on pt.1 of Zeitgeist, mainly because it sure looks like GreNME knows what he's talking about, but I have read every link posted on this thread as well as doing some googling on my own. I even found references to a book on this topic written in 1863.

As GreNME states, the relationship between Egypt and Christianity pops up every now and then, gets tossed around a bit, and is eventually kicked to the curb by scholars who know what they're talking about. GreNME also nailed it when he stated that these authors prefer to reference each other when making their case for this argument .

One thing I am curious about is, Why do people seem to want the alleged relationship between Egypt and Christianity to be true ? I personally don't care because as an atheist, I'm not really fussed whether one belief system "ripped off" or borrowed from another, but I am interested in whether a "documentary" like Zeitgeist is lying to me.

When I look back on all the time I've spent reading this thread, I realise that I'd actually forgotten that there were two other parts to this movie, so maybe the passion with which some people defend this relationship stems from their belief that if parts 1 and 2 are true, then, logically, part 1 must be also.

As a general answer to the last day's posts....

With regard to the links between Egypt and Chrisitianity - it's seems to me rather the case that those who write appear not to know, and those that know do not tell.

There's heavy linkage, throughout the mainstream of Western Esoteric thought. Kabbalists, Rosicrucians, and Freemasons all acknowlege their principle early source as Egypt. They are all also Christian schools. It's absolutely common knowledge in these traditions and there are still thousands upon thousands of adherents here in the West. I've not been so involved in Gnosticism but I'd be surprised if it were much different. The thing is...these guys are all behind walls, and still sitting on vows of silence. Their material is not really up on the Net, and mostly you still have to at least sign up for a postal course if you want to study.

Tom Harpur's "Pagan Christ"... I searched around a bit and it does look pretty weak in terms of accurate referencing. I can understand his frustration, if that's what it was that drew him to create a book from so limited a number of sources. It is frustrating knowing something to be essentially true but also being unable to use the evidence at hand to demonstrate.

Nick
 
Nick, are you suggesting that there may be a "secret" body of knowledge out there that links Christianity to Egypt that is not being made available to scholars for peer review ?
 
I'd disagree that there was sufficient evidence of that. I would say instead that Christianity, like many religions, has evidence of being utilized as a tool for manipulating social control throughout history. The difference is the actual role religion played in the act of others asserting control: instead of religion being created for the purpose of control, individuals saw a common thread of religious observance and sought to take advantage of that thread. It may seem like a minor distinction, but it takes religion as a thing and places it outside of the realm of malicious intent, which I think is key at this point (see my constant references to Hanlon).

Yes, I think this is fair enough. I doubt we will ever know. With regard to Hanlon, I think if one is going to take viewpoints on this basis it is also worthwhile assessing what the likely outcome of the belief is. That people come to believe that they have been "conspired against" could, in some circumstances, be the fastest route to positive change.


GreNME said:
I've been over this already. The fish symbol had many meanings, even at the time of the first Christians. There are no conclusive evidences to show which of those meanings it can be attributed to-- though it's likely that usage as a symbolism for the penis (glans) or the vulva were not mitigating factors. The areas written about in the books discussing the ministry of Jesus were all described as fishing towns. In Rome, the fish symbol had so many contradictory meanings it would have been innocuous-- after all, upper-class Romans often had stone phalluses hanging from walls in their homes, so seeing simple fish symbols on walls wouldn't have been out of place in the least. The end of the Jesus ministry and the first recorded uses of the fish symbol by his followers are nearly a century later, near the end of the first century CE. There is no evidence of even linear correlation, let alone any real causation.

Well, the fish symbol that survives on Christian's car boot doors does usually appear to be drawn from the vesica pisces. There are other ways to draw fish.

You see this vesica a lot on old churches too. It's invariably upright, frequently above the door, and with a seated figure of Christ inside it. Often the only part of his body that extends from the vesica is his right hand which he holds slightly aloft and with the two first fingers extended, an esoteric symbol that is used to intimate "there is something here which is not immediately obvious." See an example at http://nick2211.yage.net/pics/vesica.jpg (note the "four living creatures" of the Gnostic fixed cross also in evidence on this one)

In addition, the fish is associated in Christian Qabalah as something hidden in the deep, frequently to be drawn up through meditation.


GreNME said:
Honestly, this type of view is an example of the gross misunderstanding of the importance of history that has led to large groups of people-- civilizations, even-- repeating the same tired mistakes due to inability to see the relevance of and learn from their history. To personalize it: when a child touches something that is hot and it burns them, the logical and expected response is, at some point, for the child to not put their hand there again. I'm not of the "those who refuse to learn history are doomed to repeat it" or the "history repeats itself" school of thought, but I do believe that social and cultural trends through history can echo through up to present day, and certainly have relevance for choosing a response to things that inevitably occur (unrest, war, political maneuvering) inside a culture, government, and governmental relation to one another. We actually need to look no further than the Middle East today for an example of how this is true: all sides to the conflicts over there have historical claims that they feel lend authority to their position over the opposition.

History is relevant because it permeates the core of our relationship to different cultures in our own nations, and with the cultures in other nations.

History's relevant. It's just that people don't get lost in the past, that's what I was saying.

Nick
 
Nick, are you suggesting that there may be a "secret" body of knowledge out there that links Christianity to Egypt that is not being made available to scholars for peer review ?

For sure. Except for scholars who are also Kabbalists, Rosicrucians, or Masons. There's a slight caveat though (always is, huh!) and that is that, whilst there are documented references, a lot is understood through the use of symbology. This takes time and a considerable degree of practice and finally often doesn't reveal so much to someone who hasn't done the same. You can read the Fama Fraternitatis (1607) back to front, upside and down, whatever you want. If you don't know the symbology it's not going to make much sense.

Like I say, there are also direct references. I mean all of these guys above would strongly cite, say, "The Emerald Tablet of Hermes."

Nick
 
Hi guys, first post here... good topic...

After watching this movie i started studying some statements made in the first chapter, the religious part.

i did find the 'gods' mentioned in the movie, i couldnt find any documentation on Horus being born on dec 25th though, but the christian religion compared to egyptian is quite similar... And this, i only see people in old times, writing these as myths, but a story, so well written, enough to belive, and finding the answer to the biggest all time philosophical question, 'why are we here'. ... well just an opinion, there are so many religions and so many beliefs, its hard to belive that any god exists anywhere.

one part ive yet to study on are some of the writers mentioned in the movie that lived shortly after Jesus was said to have lived. The movie states these writers have documented nothing of jesus's being. except the Roman statements shortly made, referring to the 'christ'. Has anyone looked into this?

The translation from the Bible to Astrological mappings was very interesting though..
anyone know where i can find some good information on this?
 
Hi guys, first post here... good topic...

After watching this movie i started studying some statements made in the first chapter, the religious part.

i did find the 'gods' mentioned in the movie, i couldnt find any documentation on Horus being born on dec 25th though, but the christian religion compared to egyptian is quite similar... And this, i only see people in old times, writing these as myths, but a story, so well written, enough to belive, and finding the answer to the biggest all time philosophical question, 'why are we here'. ... well just an opinion, there are so many religions and so many beliefs, its hard to belive that any god exists anywhere.

one part ive yet to study on are some of the writers mentioned in the movie that lived shortly after Jesus was said to have lived. The movie states these writers have documented nothing of jesus's being. except the Roman statements shortly made, referring to the 'christ'. Has anyone looked into this?

The translation from the Bible to Astrological mappings was very interesting though..
anyone know where i can find some good information on this?

You need to be more specific. What do you want information on? If you want to look for information on the Christian-Egyptian connections, the only information you are going to find are going to be more of the same self-referencing information.

I suggest, if you really are interested to see if there are connections, to learn about how the different mythologies actually manifested during ancient times, especially regarding how they changed throughout the centuries. You will find that there is no consistent story of Horus, that most Egyptian gods traded parts of their identity, role in the universe, and in a few cases even names over the course of ancient Egypt. You're not going to find a consistent comparative publication on Horus and Jesus because it would all depend on which Horus you're talking about (which dynasty, what aspects, whether it's Horus alone or the mixtures of Horus and Ra, etc.).
 
With regard to the links between Egypt and Chrisitianity - it's seems to me rather the case that those who write appear not to know, and those that know do not tell.

There's heavy linkage, throughout the mainstream of Western Esoteric thought. Kabbalists, Rosicrucians, and Freemasons all acknowlege their principle early source as Egypt.

Precisely the point. I am wondering, as far as historical connection goes, how much influence Kabbalists, Rosicrucians, and Freemasons had on developing christianity. I also wonder what influence the mystical traditions that existed in the mediterranean region had on the development of the christian gnostic sects...as well I wonder what influence non-christian gnostic sects had on the development of christian gnostic sects.

Nick? GrenME? Anyone?
 
Precisely the point. I am wondering, as far as historical connection goes, how much influence Kabbalists, Rosicrucians, and Freemasons had on developing christianity. I also wonder what influence the mystical traditions that existed in the mediterranean region had on the development of the christian gnostic sects...as well I wonder what influence non-christian gnostic sects had on the development of christian gnostic sects.

Nick? GrenME? Anyone?

How could Kabbalism, the Rosecroix, or Freemasonry have had an influence on developing Christianity when each of them have their earliest recorded appearances well after Christianity began?

This is precisely what I mean about the whole problem with allowing the wildest of assertations to be considered valid. Of the three listed, the Kabballah has the oldest know records and the earliest references to it only go back to the 11th century CE. This is a millenia after the alleged ministry of Jesus and is many centuries after the Nicene Council. On top of that, each of these three organizations have splinters in their own basic frameworks, whether through splinter groups or differing schools of thought. At even the very best, such wild speculation is off by 1000 years of recorded history.
 
Last edited:
How could Kabbalism, the Rosecroix, or Freemasonry have had an influence on developing Christianity when each of them have their earliest recorded appearances well after Christianity began?

On a physical level this is pretty much unquestionably the case, though it's worth noting that the body of knowledge referred to by these names is largely the same and predates Christianity. Of course, it is an absolutely fundamental belief of all of these doctrines, certainly including Gnosticism too, that our "world" or, perhaps better, our "prevailing state of consciousness" is descended from a higher plane, one aspect of which is atemporality - freedom from the bondage of time (I am the Alpha & Omega).

Precisely the point. I am wondering, as far as historical connection goes, how much influence Kabbalists, Rosicrucians, and Freemasons had on developing christianity. I also wonder what influence the mystical traditions that existed in the mediterranean region had on the development of the christian gnostic sects...as well I wonder what influence non-christian gnostic sects had on the development of christian gnostic sects.

Nick? GrenME? Anyone?

Good luck with your wondering, dude! I don't envy you your task.

Well, the Pentateuch (1st five books of the Bible) is a core Kabbalistic document, the very nature of which clearly indicates prior knowledge of the principles involved. It's mystical interpretation, the Zohar, is dated between the 3rd and 14th century AD, depending on who you listen to. Thus, though they might not have called themselves "kabbalists," those who created it certainly understood that which would become Kabbalah. Don't know that this helps so much. We're probably drifting a bit OT now, btw.

Nick
 
How could Kabbalism, the Rosecroix, or Freemasonry have had an influence on developing Christianity when each of them have their earliest recorded appearances well after Christianity began?

This is precisely what I mean about the whole problem with allowing the wildest of assertations to be considered valid. Of the three listed, the Kabballah has the oldest know records and the earliest references to it only go back to the 11th century CE. This is a millenia after the alleged ministry of Jesus and is many centuries after the Nicene Council. On top of that, each of these three organizations have splinters in their own basic frameworks, whether through splinter groups or differing schools of thought. At even the very best, such wild speculation is off by 1000 years of recorded history.

To answer the first question see Nick's response. I never said they existed before christianity. What I asked was what influence they had in developing christianity?

You never answered my second question:
"I also wonder what influence the mystical traditions that existed in the mediterranean region had on the development of the christian gnostic sects...as well I wonder what influence non-christian gnostic sects had on the development of christian gnostic sects."

I think that might have some bearing on this discussion.

Good luck with your wondering, dude! I don't envy you your task.

haha...yeah it has been a blast....
 
Last edited:
On a physical level this is pretty much unquestionably the case, though it's worth noting that the body of knowledge referred to by these names is largely the same and predates Christianity.

Yes, they all claim to have timeless knowledge of some sort of another. However, none of them ever actually offer proof, only platitudes. I've been approached by or checked into local Rosecroix and Mason lodges before, and each time there is only so far my curiosity went until it became obvious that the key to these fraternities is membership and social networking, not secrets to a long gone past. Since the two I mention don't identify as religious orders, I don't see how that is anything to find fault with as a group. They're no different than the local moose lodge or VFW.

Using old names does not make the claim of these groups more authentically ancient. Unless some proof that is able to be examined and verified is produced, it is just another self-referencing claim.


----


To answer the first question see Nick's response. I never said they existed before christianity. What I asked was what influence they had in developing christianity?

Your question is too vague. I would simply respond with: which 'Christianity' are you asking about? The Catholic Church? The Anglican Church? Lutherans? Seventh-Day Adventists? Mormons? Baptists? Unitarians? There was more than one 'Christianity' by the time these groups formed, and there are plenty more today. Can you narrow down your question a little?

What are you looking for? Direct influence? If that's the case, then little to none. Possible cross-associated members throughout history? likely a reasonable number, especially with the Masons and slightly less so with the Rosecroix. Kabballah has pretty much never been closely associated with any Christian group that I'm aware of, and only nominally associated to Judaism.

You never answered my second question:
"I also wonder what influence the mystical traditions that existed in the mediterranean region had on the development of the christian gnostic sects...as well I wonder what influence non-christian gnostic sects had on the development of christian gnostic sects."

I think that might have some bearing on this discussion.

Once again, you're going to need to be way more specific in your question. There have been whole books-- and if you are interested, Elaine Pagels has one or two good ones on the gnostics-- on the subject you're asking about, so I need to know more of what you want to know before I could begin to give you a direct answer.
 
Yes, they all claim to have timeless knowledge of some sort of another. However, none of them ever actually offer proof, only platitudes. I've been approached by or checked into local Rosecroix and Mason lodges before, and each time there is only so far my curiosity went until it became obvious that the key to these fraternities is membership and social networking, not secrets to a long gone past. Since the two I mention don't identify as religious orders, I don't see how that is anything to find fault with as a group. They're no different than the local moose lodge or VFW.

Using old names does not make the claim of these groups more authentically ancient. Unless some proof that is able to be examined and verified is produced, it is just another self-referencing claim.

I would agree. However, these groups are not, I submit, seeking to verify their claims. There is an open door, you can travel through it and see for yourself, or you can pass it by. It's up to you. It's also the case that, particularly in the case of the Masons, the possibility to enhance your social status and create "better" connections attracts a lot of people. However, this is by no means the sum total of what's being offered. There's a lot of variety between the multitude of groups now descended from the original strands of this perennial philosophy, and a lot of different approaches. But finally they're all, trying to point you back to a more causal layer of consciousness.

As I mentioned in the reply to Stout yesterday, this is not hard science. It is rather the awareness from which hard science descends. It's not really about the surface layer of objective awareness we become concerned with through egoic identification with thought.

Nick
 
There's heavy linkage, throughout the mainstream of Western Esoteric thought. Kabbalists, Rosicrucians, and Freemasons all acknowlege their principle early source as Egypt.
A correction, if I may...

While they SAY it's their early source, in fact they're making up the connection to lend authenticity and cachet to the claim that their school/organization/etc has ties to the (in their view) oldest civilization and therefore is party to ancient secrets that nobody else has.

If you look at these "ancient secrets" you will find that (gosh) the ancient Egyptians (although polytheistic and viewing the pharaoh as God Incarnate) somehow happened to pass along scret knowledge that was Just Like Judaeo-Christianity. This should make you suspicious from the get-go.

The thing is...these guys are all behind walls, and still sitting on vows of silence. Their material is not really up on the Net, and mostly you still have to at least sign up for a postal course if you want to study.
It's available -- but you have to look offline. During the early 1900's, these groups were publishing their own material for their memberships, and "old books that granddad had" are still very much around. You can (if you like) find some available by interlibrary loan.

Tom Harpur's "Pagan Christ"... I searched around a bit and it does look pretty weak in terms of accurate referencing.
And one of his books was written BEFORE the Rosetta Stone was well translated, meaning that a lot of the derived knowledge was "Oh look at the pictures! And here's an eye! And over here's a bird! This MUST mean that..."

We still get that kind of reasoning today, I'm afraid. Folks aren't aware that panels and funky hieroglyphs were related (a type of "cartoon" where there's captions for each scene that detail what's gong on.) You can learn to read them (I have, though rather badly.)

The case for the Pagan Christ is even weaker if you look at the early Church writings. In some of the apocrypha you see legends being made and material being added, but although the sources appear to be local folk and hero tales they don't substantially change the nature of the message of Jesus (as they would if this was a combination and evolving figure.)

An example of a changing deity is Bast, who begins as a desert cat goddess, evolves to the "Right Eye of Re And Bringer Of Justice" deity. whose savage aspect gets taken over by Sekhmet (who also took over Hathor's savage aspect), becomes associated with housecat types about 1,000 years after her worshp started.
http://www.per-bast.org/bast/essay5.html

She turned into the Fluffy Goddess Of Happiness And Sex after the rise of the Greek pharaohs (Ptolomies), who for political reasons wanted their gods merged with the Greek and later Roman pantheons.
http://www.per-bast.org/bast/essay10.html
 
Yes, they all claim to have timeless knowledge of some sort of another. However, none of them ever actually offer proof, only platitudes.

Actually, those "proofs" are pretty easily overturned if you study history and anthropology. For example, the "builder of Solomon's temple" was "Hiram Abiff."

That comes from a time when people didn't have last names. Abiff is not a Hebrew last name (If he had the equivalent of one, it would be "Hiram of Bethlehem" or "Hiram of Aramathea" or "Hiram, son of Dan." It's the details that reveal the fiction.
 
A correction, if I may...

While they SAY it's their early source, in fact they're making up the connection to lend authenticity and cachet to the claim that their school/organization/etc has ties to the (in their view) oldest civilization and therefore is party to ancient secrets that nobody else has.

You may! Though I must say that my personal experience is that few of these organisations are much concerned with establishing their roots in antiquity. What they claim is that they are directly linked to the "Inner School" - the proposed extra-dimensional source of the teachings. Certainly this is true of the Rosicrucian groups and Kabbalah groups I know. They're not so much bothered with history.


Pyrts said:
If you look at these "ancient secrets" you will find that (gosh) the ancient Egyptians (although polytheistic and viewing the pharaoh as God Incarnate) somehow happened to pass along scret knowledge that was Just Like Judaeo-Christianity. This should make you suspicious from the get-go.

I'm not aware of any meaningful esoteric knowledge that can be passed on through written language. Not saying it doesn't exist, but I've not heard of it.

Nick
 
Actually, those "proofs" are pretty easily overturned if you study history and anthropology. For example, the "builder of Solomon's temple" was "Hiram Abiff."

That comes from a time when people didn't have last names. Abiff is not a Hebrew last name (If he had the equivalent of one, it would be "Hiram of Bethlehem" or "Hiram of Aramathea" or "Hiram, son of Dan." It's the details that reveal the fiction.

Hiram Abiff (ChVRM ABIV) = 273 = the stone the builders rejected(ABN MASV HBVNIM) = hidden light AVR GNVZ.

"The stone the builders rejected becomes the capstone." The capstone of the Pyramid, the hidden eye whose full flowering reveals the glory of the world.

What can it all mean?!

Nick
 
I wouldn't necessarily call their doors "open," so to speak. With the Rosecrucians there are fees for attending or joining, and with the Masons there are contributions that are made. Granted, neither of them are strictly social networks-- they both engage in some charity work or donation, for example-- but what I'm talking about is the main thrust of the membership nowadays.

As a matter of fact, one of the most common complaints I hear against them is their tendency to be considered clandestine and working behind the scenes. To someone who has investigated and at least considered joining one of them, I couldn't find any evidence of such. The Rosecrucians even have a lot of scheduled 'meetings' (more like speaking engagements on certain topics) listed online, if you find a location near you. Still, these groups have a mystique of being a 'secret society' and that mystique has served them well in the past. It's also served to build up a lot of distrust and animosity toward them. Some openly distrust them (look at all the CTs involving Masons), while others mimic them (I won't get into naming names, because it involves one or two religious groups and they take it very personally). To most people, though, they barely register.

Interestingly, much like the government, groups like the Rosecroix and Masons have the dual honor of being overestimated and underestimated nearly simultaneously when it comes to issues either applying to or sharing similarities with conspiracy theories.
 
Hiram Abiff (ChVRM ABIV) = 273 = the stone the builders rejected(ABN MASV HBVNIM) = hidden light AVR GNVZ.

"The stone the builders rejected becomes the capstone." The capstone of the Pyramid, the hidden eye whose full flowering reveals the glory of the world.

What can it all mean?!

It means that sometimes spaghetti can stick to walls.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom