Yahoo Answers: How some astrohysicists fool people with illogic.

The task now is to concur on a concept of the universe.

For my part:
The universe is the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.
​


Since your supposed god is the subject of your imagination, then you must consider it also a part of the Universe as you describe it.
 
As regards your concept of God, you are barking up the wrong tree at the wrong god.

Please leave Zygote out of your posts, he can speak for himself, and don't seek support by bringing in the name of Zygote.

Speak for yourself alone.

Yrreg

I see we've already moved heavily into the bossy phase of Yrreg's approach to threads, with just the beginning hints of the insulting, condescending phase that will become more evident if we don't say exactly what Yrreg wants us to say.

Hey guys- get with the program! Yrreg will never be able to spring his big trap on you if you don't help.
 
Read here how a wannabee astrophysicist can be incoherently inconsistent.

Abandon all hope of logical thinking, all ye who enter the gate of the cosmology of nothingness.


Read my post in the other thread on “God's existence, and man-made concepts and words.”

Click on that link.


And enjoy!




Yrreg
 
You are under the spell of fear, fear of concepts.
No. Not a single concept that you have presented frightens me in the least.


If I am forcing my concepts on you, why am I here asking you for your concepts?
Apparently so you can ignore them. You asked others what there concept of God is. I responded days ago and never got the slightest response from you. All you do is keep telling us what your concept of God is, ad infinitum, as though we may have forgotten after the first hundred times. I get the impression that you have created a dialog in your mind before you even present your first post. Then, like some computer program, you keep repeating the first step in the hope that someone else will provide a response that matches your pre-concieved dialog.

First, you give your concepts and we will work out an agreed on concept of God, by which concept we will set forth to look for evidence, but don't forget to also have a concept of evidence which we will all agree on.
I already gave it to you. I'm sorry if you don't like my response, but repeating, "First, you give your concepts..." over and over and over and over and over isn't going to result in me giving a response that you want. If you really want what you say you want, then acknowledge the response that I gave regarding your query.

I hate to give this illustration: I am a shop-keeper and you are to all appearances a prospective buyer; I ask you if you have money, you say that I am forcing my concept of money on you, so I show you some dollar bills and ask you if you have some; then you get angry and say that I am looking down on you
.
A more accurate analogy would have you saying, "That will be ten dollars, please", then me holding a ten dollar bill toward you and saying, "here's ten dollars. May I see the dragon now?", only to have you respond, "That will be ten dollars, please".

So, I say, sir, please leave for I have a busy day ahead; otherwise show me your money and I will bring down things for you to examine but not everything and only the kind you want to buy, for example, bread toasters.
But you aren't offering us toasters. You are offering us God. But every time we ask you to show us the merchandise you just repeat your first sales-pitch.


Here, you give your definition of God:
An anthropomorphic construct of human imagination created to attribute agency to nature in an attempt to anticipate its behavior.
​


That is no different essentially from my concept of God:
Creator of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​

If you will just bring in the venue of operation of this agent you and I call God.

You say nature, I say the universe understood as the totality of existence.
Wow! It's like the worst conjuring act ever. It's like you're saying "This is your card" as you show me a plastic flower. You are trying to take my definition of God as a figment of human imagination, no different from Santa Claus or the Easter Bunny, and declare it equal to your definition of God as creator of everything in the universe that is not itself.

Gerry: What would you like to drink.
Foster Zygote: I'll have a glass of The Macallan 12 year, neat.
Gerry: Very good, sir. Here is your Mountain Dew.
FZ: But I wanted a glass of quality malt, not a kid's drink.
Gerry: That is no different essentially from Mountain Dew.

We are now into working out together for an agreed on concept of God, so that we will not be talking past our heads which is irrational and illogical.
Saying it doesn't make it so.

So, what about this concept of God as already established by theists: Creator of everything in the universe that is not Himself.
What about the concept of Santa Claus as held by children?

Remember you are the one denying the existence of the God of theists, so you must be acquainted correctly with their concept of God, and not insist that they agree with your concept of God.
Wrong. I am not denying the existence of God, I am pointing out that there is no evidence for this entity. This includes your personal definition of God. Quit telling us ad nauseum what your concept of God is and get on with demonstrating that it exists.

Anyway, you have the same essential idea of God as theists like myself, in God's fundamental relation to the universe of which nature is a part.
No, I don't. This is exactly what I mean when I say that you are determined to force your concepts on us.

You say in effect that God is an agent, and I say God is a creator.
No, Gerry, I am not saying that God is an agency. Can you comprehend what I wrote? I am saying that people are attempting to attribute agency where none exists by creating an imaginary entity that dwells only in their minds.

But I must tell you that you are under the spell of fear, fear of the concept of God as propounded by theists lke myself, namely:
God is the creator of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​
No. I am not afraid of your imaginary friend.
 
Here again is my concept of evidence:
A fact known to man leading him to know another fact.
​

You say:
Evidence in its broadest sense includes everything that is used to determine or demonstrate the truth of an assertion.
​


Now, tell me how is your concept of evidence contrary to mine?



Yrreg

Excellent! As you agree with my definition of evidence we can use that going forward.

Great news everybody: Gerry has agreed to a definition of evidence and has assumed the burden of proof for his assertion.

Just in case you missed it, here's the definition again:

"Evidence in its broadest sense includes everything that is used to determine or demonstrate the truth of an assertion. Giving or procuring evidence is the process of using those things that are either (a) presumed to be true, or (b) were themselves proven via evidence, to demonstrate an assertion's truth. Evidence is the currency by which one fulfills the burden of proof."

We might be getting somewhere at last!!
 
Here, you give your definition of God:
An anthropomorphic construct of human imagination created to attribute agency to nature in an attempt to anticipate its behavior.
​


That is no different essentially from my concept of God:
Creator of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​

:eek:

Definition 1: Created by humans, no effect on the universe.
Definition 2: Not created by humans, created the universe.

How are these two definitions essentially the same thing?

As regards concept of universe and concept of evidence, I do invite heartily atheists to work with me together to come to mutually agreed on concepts.

Okay, I'll bite...

Now, here is my concept of God, which I want atheists to be properly informed about, otherwise they are barking up the wrong tree at the wrong god

God: In His fundamental relation to the universe, the creator (I used maker before but it's okay if you want to revert to maker) of everything in the universe that is not Himself.
​

That definition doesn't seem particularly coherent to me. Here's another definition of "God" for you to consider.

A powerful incorporeal supernatural intelligent agency presumed to be responsible for human existence.​

Would this be an acceptable definition to you?

Where is the concept? In the mind of man.

Where is man? In the universe which is the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.

This only means that the concepts, imagination and discourse are part of the universe, not that the subject of these things are part of the universe.

The task now is to concur on a concept of the universe.

For my part:
The universe is the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.
​

Once again, the coherency of your definition is somewhat questionable.

How about...
Universe: All matter, energy and space.​
 
Last edited:
Universe: The totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.

Evidence: A fact known to man leading him to know another fact.

God: In His fundamental relation to the universe, the creator (I used maker before but it's okay if you want to revert to maker) of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Unpacking your concepts:

Universe: The totality of existence (you can stop your definition here if you want, the succeeding words don't add any clarity, in fact they confuse things)

where man lives in and is part (this is redundant, you've already defined the universe as the totality of existence so it includes the earth)

and parcel of, (this is flat out wrong, as has been explained several times)

as also everything else that exists (this is redundant, you already have defined the universe as the totality of existence so there is nothing else that exists)

or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse (here's where you make an error, things which can be imagined don't necessarily exist)

Evidence: A fact known to man (okay)

leading him to know (not really. Leading him to know is not the correct phrase here. Determining the truth or falsity would be better)

another fact (no, you should say an assertion here. Evidence isn't a chain of facts, evidence is what you use to determine whether something is true or not.)

God: In His fundamental relation to the universe, the creator of everything in the universe that is not Himself. (this is your concept and as such, has as much validity as anyone else's concept. Your concept isn't better or more true than anyone else's; you need to use evidence to determine the assertions inherent in your concept)

As you can see, your definition of universe and your definition of evidence aren't really quite right, and your concept of god is personal to you.

Now what?
 
Last edited:
Yrreg,

Since you seem to think that your definitions and ours are essentially the same, would you agree to using our wording from here on, for the sake of moving the discussion forward?
 
I know for a certainty that you want to convince me that God does not exist, and you know for a certainty that I am trying to show you that the universe is the evidence for God's existence.
Yrreg

1. If P, then Q.
2. Q.
3. Therefore, P.

1. If God, then the Universe.
2. The Universe.
3. Therefore, God.

1. If Harry Potter, then London.
2. London.
3. Therefore, Harry Potter.

The mistake you're making is called the fallacy of affirming the consequent, it is inherently invalid. That is, if it is true, it is not because the argument affirms it, but rather, it is true despite the argument, it is true for some other reason.

This, on the other hand, is valid:

1. If P, then Q.
2. P.
3. Therefore, Q.

Also, I am certain that your certainty that Agatha is trying to convince you that God does not exist is misplaced, and probably has more to do with your tendency to take things personally. No skin off our noses what you believe, speaking for myself, I'm pretty much just interested in analyzing your arguments as light mental exercise.
 

One astrophysicist does not a consensus make, and given he or she is unnamed...

And when named what does their biography say

"Keith Mayes has been a dedicated amateur astronomer for the past 45 years "

so hardly someone who is an astrophysicist
 
Last edited:
Neither, in my opinion. Yrreg drops in every once in a while and tries to set up what he believes is a clever "sting operation" through which posters replying to his OP will be taken through a "clever" series of yrreg-logic steps to finally admit the existence of God (presumably the Christian God). Generally he quickly gets frustrated when people don't play along, and starts becoming bossy ("answer yes or no"), then insulting. Often his odd use of language further introduces a certain level of confusion, as well as a surreal feel to much of his threads.

An accurate analysis. I wish I'd said this. There are several other members that try the same tactic, but always fail.
 
For some reason, you've convinced yourself that the origin of the universe can be described by one equation: UNorigin = (lots of symbols). Such a subject is extremely complex and requires more than one equation to describe all the matter transformations involved. You are ready to conclude that the absence of your unrealistic assumption gives automatically God the green light to enter the works.

Science works differently than religion; it's like climbing a mountain: science must anchor itself very often, coz if something goes wrong, it falls only a few feet just to find another, safer way up. That makes it a very slow climb. Religion moves much faster, but when something goes wrong, it tumbles all the way down. (See the climbing of Mt. Creation.) In other words, if science is not sure, it won't move ahead to call a speculation a theory.
http://science.howstuffworks.com/dictionary/astronomy-terms/before-big-bang.htm

You are free to believe that God created the universe, but you'll never find out how apart from the Bible account. See, there is a rational speculation called "the big crunch." According to this scenario, there was a universe before ours which began collapsing due to gravitational influences to a certain stage and then, like a supernova, it expanded again (the big bang). But in this stage of our mental development, it's impossible for the cosmologists to roll the film back that far and form a theory of that hypothetical process. That "pre-universe" wasn't like this one though. According to Hawking's number crunching, this universe will not collapse on itself - the opposite will take place and it slowly "evaporates" out of its existence. But you never know, coz "God's mind works the mysterious ways . . ."

Holy cow ! I'm impressed.
 
The issue now is to determine what is the pre-existing reality antecedent to the material universe.




Yrreg

In this you are right finally correct. Actually the the preceding reality before this universe came into existence was the singularity. However, at this time no one can say what if anything preceded this singularity.
 
Who created God?


First, we have to work together on what is our mutually agreed on concept of God.


I have said time and again that my concept of God in His fundamental relation to the universe is that
God is the creator of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​
I love to hear from you what is your concept of God.




Yrreg

I kinda like this one
220px-Creation_of_the_Sun_and_Moon_face_detail.jpg

Or maybe this one
images

or even this one
images


Nah, I think this is the one I like best
images
 
Okay, let us work out our concepts for concurrence.

On your concept of universe as everything that exists, I ask you how it is if at all contrary to my concept of the universe?
The totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.
​
As regards your concept of God, you are barking up the wrong tree at the wrong god.

Please leave Zygote out of your posts, he can speak for himself, and don't seek support by bringing in the name of Zygote.

Speak for yourself alone.



Now, where is your concept of evidence?




Yrreg

You are aware I hope that minds much more perspicacious than yours have tried with very elaborate arguments to prove the existence of God.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom