Yahoo Answers: How some astrohysicists fool people with illogic.

You are all into your own concepts but you are not cognizant of the correct concept in the Christian faith of God in His fundamental relation to the universe.

Neither are you.

You have to get correctly informed about the concept of God in the Christian faith, etc.

Then get busy and go find us someone who knows what it could possibly be.

I am fully aware that you are all very frustrated and very angry because you want to insist that your concept of God be accepted by me, but it is not the correct concept, can you comprehend that?

I am fully aware that you are very frustrated and very angry because you want to insist that your concept of god be accepted by all of us, but yours is not the correct concept, can you comprehend that?

But you can get into dialog with folks who have your concept of God.

You could, too. Instead, you come here.



Now, you do not agree with my concepts of universe and of evidence.

Not for a second.


However, if you can refer me to an online atheist dictionary or glossary or atheists' enclopedia where the words universe and evidence are found, I will appreciate that, and it will save you atheist folks from the laborious task of working out among yourselves your commonly concurring concept of universe as of evidence.

I suppose this will have to do: http://www.skepdic.com/gods.html
 
What begs the question: It's obvious why the fly bounces but, what is everyone else doing here? Can the umpteenth reply still be fun?

I can't speak for anyone else, but I'm posting in this thread when I have nothing better to do. Trying to explain things to yrreg in a way he can understand is a mildly diverting, albeit futile exercise.
 
I ask for your concept of God in order that I may know it and also to correct it, if you are misinformed about the fundamental concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe.

I am fully aware that you are all very frustrated and very angry because you want to insist that your concept of God be accepted by me, but it is not the correct concept, can you comprehend that?

I'm neither angry nor frustrated, merely annoyed that I keep taking the time and effort to respond intelligently to your posts, yet you consistently fail to even acknowledge that I've even responded.

I'm not sure if you're just inconsiderate, or if for some reason you have me on your ignore list.

But if want to correct my concept of God, I'd like to hear your critique. Here it is again...

A powerful incorporeal supernatural intelligent agency presumed to be responsible for human existence.​

Is there anything wrong with this definition to your mind?

Could someone else please quote this post, so if he does have me on ignore, he can see it and possibly let me know that he can't see my posts?
 
There are two amazing things about Yrreg's threads:

1. Although he repeatedly prompts people for their definitions, opinions, viewpoints, etc., he is absolutely and totally uninterested in their response. After receiving multiple replies, he will discard them all as incorrect, and proceed to go ahead with his own. It's the Socratic method as performed by someone with a blindfold and earplugs.

2. He never gets anywhere. All his threads stall out at his very first step: define God. Nonetheless, after some delay, he returns to try the same thing again, but with a slightly different OP. It's like watching a stage magician flubbing the same trick over and over again.

At least this time we got a recipe.
 
I'm neither angry nor frustrated, merely annoyed that I keep taking the time and effort to respond intelligently to your posts, yet you consistently fail to even acknowledge that I've even responded.

I'm not sure if you're just inconsiderate, or if for some reason you have me on your ignore list.

But if want to correct my concept of God, I'd like to hear your critique. Here it is again...

A powerful incorporeal supernatural intelligent agency presumed to be responsible for human existence.​

Is there anything wrong with this definition to your mind?

Could someone else please quote this post, so if he does have me on ignore, he can see it and possibly let me know that he can't see my posts?

Done.
 
1. Although he repeatedly prompts people for their definitions, opinions, viewpoints, etc., he is absolutely and totally uninterested in their response. After receiving multiple replies, he will discard them all as incorrect, and proceed to go ahead with his own. It's the Socratic method as performed by someone with a blindfold and earplugs.

It's more like the interrogation scenes in 1984 or that ST:TNG episode where Picard is being tortured by the Cardassians.

Yrreg: What is your concept of 2 + 2?
Rest of Forum: Four.
Yrreg: Your concept is erroneous. 2 + 2 is five.
<Yrreg proceeds to do horrible things to logic and the English language*. Rof howls in protest>
Yrreg: Now what is your concept of 2 + 2?
RoF: It's still four.

Or, more succinctly:

<Picard>
THERE. ARE. FOUR. LIGHTS!!!!
</Picard>



*-- Yes, I'm aware that yrreg is presumably not a native English speaker. Normally I would never criticize such a person's syntax and grammar, but given yrreg's insistence on using ten dollar words that he doesn't understand and idioms that he's been told repeatedly are being misapplied, it's fair game.
 
I want you to tell me now, your corrected concept.
God: An anthropomorphic construct of human imagination created to attribute agency to nature in an attempt to anticipate its behavior.

You see, you say that you don't believe in God, but you are not getting the correct God to not believe in, that is why I see you to be essentially illogical but a rich subject for psychology.
You have done absolutely nothing to demonstrate that yours is the correct concept of God.

That is the big obstacle to dialog with atheists on the issue of God or no God, you have got the wrong concept of God, in regard to the Christian God in His fundamental relation to the universe which is God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.
So the big obstacle in debating with people who do not believe in gods is that they won't just accept your assertion that your god exists because you tell them to?

That is why I say that you are cognitively afraid of the correct concept of God.
Actually, I suspect that you say this because you are frustrated by your inability to control the debate by forcing others to adopt your definitions.

Now, tell me what is your concept of God now that I have corrected you.
God: An anthropomorphic construct of human imagination created to attribute agency to nature in an attempt to anticipate its behavior.

(Do you ever read through your compositions prior to posting them and say to yourself, "I've already stated that. I can delete it because it is redundant"?)

Can you and will you comprehend that you are insisting on a wrong concept of God in the Christian faith in his fundamental relation to the universe.
Why is it wrong, because you say so? That's not how it works, Gerry. You have to provide actual evidence that your definition is logically superior to mine. But all you ever seem to do is attempt to force others to adopt your definition so that you can finally move on to whatever the next step is in your preconceived narrative aimed at the big "Gotcha!" victory that will only ever exist in your mind.

If you will not correct your concept of God, then please do not dialog with Christians because you will be barking up the wrong tree at the wrong God, that is what I am telling you atheist folks all the time.
Gerry, my having a different concept of your god than you do does not mean that I do not understand your concept. I reject your concept because of the lack of evidence proffered in support of it.

Go and dialog with folks who believe in your God that is according to your concept of.
There's that control issue again.

Allow me to remind atheist folks here that when you dialog with Christians you must get the correct concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, otherwise you are being illogical.
This is silly, Gerry. Did you accept Buddhist definition regarding Buddhist concepts before you debated others regarding them? All you are doing is telling us, "You can't talk to me about this until you agree that I am right". I'm sorry, but debate doesn't work that way.

Dear Zygote: I am aware that you are very frustrated, very angry, because you want to insist on your wrong concept of God in order to lambast God and Christians, better to get the correct concept and then dialog according to reason, logic, and facts.
You are aware of nothing. You are attempting to personalize the argument out of your own seeming frustration regarding your inability to control my responses.
 
You are all into your own concepts but you are not cognizant of the correct concept in the Christian faith of God in His fundamental relation to the universe.

We are cognizant. We just don't believe it and conclude that you are deluding yourself.
 
Further to my reply above, I see I must make one thing clear.

We understand your concept of God. We understand what you believe. We are what you call "correctly informed" about your concept of God. We are not lacking in knowledge, we lack belief.

We understand your faith but we don't share it. No amount of rudeness, misrepresentation or repetition will make us suddenly believe something in which we lack belief.

We are not angry or fearful, we simply hold a different opinion. The only frustration arises from your apparent inability to comprehend why atheists do not believe in the God in which you believe.

Gerry, please carefully read the above post.
 
There are two amazing things about Yrreg's threads:

1. Although he repeatedly prompts people for their definitions, opinions, viewpoints, etc., he is absolutely and totally uninterested in their response. After receiving multiple replies, he will discard them all as incorrect, and proceed to go ahead with his own. It's the Socratic method as performed by someone with a blindfold and earplugs.

2. He never gets anywhere. All his threads stall out at his very first step: define God. Nonetheless, after some delay, he returns to try the same thing again, but with a slightly different OP. It's like watching a stage magician flubbing the same trick over and over again.

At least this time we got a recipe.

He's created the whole exposition of dialog in his head long ago. The problem is that we aren't following through with the "proper" responses, so he keeps repeating the lines in the hope that someone will indulge him, so he ends up sounding like he has an extra GOTO10 line.
 
Okay, clearly now you do not admit any pre-existing material, now what?

I have not admitted that there is "pre-existing material to the universe" and I have already requested that you do not misrepresent my views in that way. You will have seen that request as you quoted it. I will report your posts to the moderators should you continue to tell deliberate untruths about the content of my posts.

Once again, "blindering" is not a word in English other than to refer to steel plates used for a specific purpose (protection from enemy fire). You do not gain credibility by using incorrect words, any more than you do by misrepresenting people. On the contrary, you lose any shred of credibility you had.

I have already said, on more than one occasion, that pre-existing in the context in which you are using it is meaningless. Therefore my answer is no, as it has been throughout both of your threads.

There can be no time before time began. If you are having difficulty grasping this concept, Stephen Hawking's book "A Brief History of Time" may help you, or for an easier read Bill Bryson's "A Short History of Nearly Everything" is an excellent primer.

You can proceed (I wish you would proceed to lay out whatever argument you are trying to present) using your incorrect definitions of the universe and evidence, and your personal definition of the Christian God, but as long as you use incorrect and personal definitions, any conversation will necessarily be halted as people continue to object to your incorrect definitions. It is not a matter of opinion that some imaginary things do not exist and are therefore not part of the universe, it is a matter of fact.

It is now past midnight in my timezone and I am going to bed. I say this so that you are not tempted to accuse me, as you have done in the past, of abandoning the thread.

Your incivility in accusing me and others of having "blindered" minds - perhaps you mean blinkered - is not going unnoticed, and will not go unreported. Try to be civil if you wish to remain a member of this forum.


Okay, I get you very clearly now:
I [you] have not admitted that there is "pre-existing material to the universe.
​


Now, what, do you admit or you don't admit but deny that there is a creator which is self-existent.


And don't bring in Hawking, I am asking you to do your own thinking from your own reasoning resources, your knowledge of logic, your intelligence, and on the facts as you are acquainted with the facts of life and the world.


And don't get dungeoned with syllogistic Lego toys, intelligent thinking is much more than any manipulative syllogistic Lego toys.


I have to be harsh with you because I see you to be wishy-washy.



Okay, that is now clear from you, you don't accept any pre-existing material to the universe.




Now, to be clear, also tell me categorically and no bringing in Hawking, do you or do you not admit the existence of a creator Who is self-existing?

Answer, No, I don't admit or accept etc., or Yes, I admit or accept etc, and don't bring in Hawking or any cosmology whatever, just answer from your reasoning resources, your knowledge of logic, your intelligence, working on the facts which you are acquainted with, the facts of life and the world.




Yrreg
 
Okay, I get you very clearly now:
I [you] have not admitted that there is "pre-existing material to the universe.
​
If you had read my posts, you would have grasped this several pages ago.

Now, what, do you admit or you don't admit but deny that there is a creator which is self-existent.
Your poor grasp of English makes this a little difficult to parse, but if you asking if I deny that there is a creator (self-existent is a meaningless phrase) then yes, I do deny that. I don't believe there is a creator of the universe, but I cannot prove this and neither can you. All either of us can do is study the available resources, such as the books I mentioned, and educate ourselves as to the facts.
And don't bring in Hawking, I am asking you to do your own thinking from your own reasoning resources, your knowledge of logic, your intelligence, and on the facts as you are acquainted with the facts of life and the world.
You are clearly mistaken as to the reason I mentioned Professor Hawking. He is an expert in cosmology, he has the best and most thorough understanding of the universe and he knows more about the subject than you or I could ever hope to know. If you wilfully refuse to acquaint yourself with Professor Hawking's expertise, you are blinding yourself to science. If you find "A Brief History of Time" too complicated, then the Bill Bryson book I mentioned does a very good job of putting things into layman's language. The thing about science and cosmology is that much of it cannot be understood by using what is generally called common sense, because some of it appears counter-intuitive unless you have sufficient understanding of complex concepts.

And don't get dungeoned with syllogistic Lego toys, intelligent thinking is much more than any manipulative syllogistic Lego toys.
What on earth does "syllogistic Lego toys" mean? Lego toys are small plastic blocks of various colours and shapes used for construction; syllogism pertains to logical arguments. The two things have no relationship. Dungeon is not a verb, so a person cannot be "dungeoned". Please use English correctly, it is a beautiful, powerful and expressive language but not the way you are using it. I understand it is not your first language so I am trying to help you improve your communication which is rather poor at the moment. I am sure you feel you are communicating clearly but unfortunately you are not. Try to avoid metaphor and idiom unless you are certain of the meaning.

I have to be harsh with you because I see you to be wishy-washy.
I see no reason for you to be insulting, unless you are hoping for yet another enforced holiday from this forum.
Okay, that is now clear from you, you don't accept any pre-existing material to the universe.
You said that above; repetition does not change my answer. I do not accept it.

Now, to be clear, also tell me categorically and no bringing in Hawking, do you or do you not admit the existence of a creator Who is self-existing?
You said this above too, and repetition still won't change my answer.
Answer, No, I don't admit or accept etc., or Yes, I admit or accept etc, and don't bring in Hawking or any cosmology whatever, just answer from your reasoning resources, your knowledge of logic, your intelligence, working on the facts which you are acquainted with, the facts of life and the world.
Bossiness and insults in the same post, you must be desperate for a suspension.

No, I don't admit or accept the existence of a creator. If you claim there is or was a creator, the burden of proof is on you to bring evidence (not unevidenced assertions) to support your claim. As a reminder, evidence is what is used to support a claim, or to determine the truth or falsity of an assertion. This means that if you want to support your claim of a creator, you have to bring evidence which must be repeatable and testable. If you do not understand why evidence must be repeatable and testable, then you have not yet grasped what evidence is.

Finally, to make my position clear, I am aware that you believe in the Christian God and I have no wish to change your mind. I am not angry at your God, I do not hate your God, I simply do not believe it exists.
 
And don't bring in Hawking, I am asking you to do your own thinking from your own reasoning resources, your knowledge of logic, your intelligence, and on the facts as you are acquainted with the facts of life and the world.

Says the guy who keeps telling us to believe in a god because Anthony Flew (kinda, sorta) decided to.
 
Okay, I get you very clearly now:
I [you] have not admitted that there is "pre-existing material to the universe.
​
No, you don't. As has been explained numerous time, the term "pre-existing" is as meaningless as "north of the North Pole" when discussing the universe as we currently understand it.

Now, what, do you admit or you don't admit but deny that there is a creator which is self-existent.
I do not deny that there is a creator, I simply have no belief in one because of the complete lack of evidence for such an agency.

And don't get dungeoned with syllogistic Lego toys, intelligent thinking is much more than any manipulative syllogistic Lego toys.
And it is also much, much more than simply using a thesaurus.
 
It's more like the interrogation scenes in 1984 or that ST:TNG episode where Picard is being tortured by the Cardassians.

Yrreg: What is your concept of 2 + 2?
Rest of Forum: Four.
Yrreg: Your concept is erroneous. 2 + 2 is five.
<Yrreg proceeds to do horrible things to logic and the English language*. Rof howls in protest>
Yrreg: Now what is your concept of 2 + 2?
RoF: It's still four.

Yes, you're right! A much better analogy. In 1984 Winston eventually truly sees five fingers when O'Brien holds up 4. The pain machine helped, of course. A few more Yrreg posts, and I may genuinely begin to accept his logic; but I've never been able to handle pain very well...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom