Yahoo Answers: How some astrohysicists fool people with illogic.

I know this has been done to death with yrreg, but once again from the wikipedia entry on CosmogonyWP:

The most commonly held view is the universe was once a gravitational singularity which then expanded rapidly from this hot and dense state. While this expansion is well-modeled by the Big Bang theory, the origins of the singularity remains one of the unsolved problems in physics.

Inserting God here is no different than inserting God to explain the sun's path across the sky, or a rainbow or lightning, prior to the much better and accurate explanations eventually provided by science. All the people throughout history who inserted God for the sun, rainbows, lighting, earthquakes, etc. were just flat out wrong! It is a terrible explanation!

You spend so much time asking for an example of something that does not have a beginning. Why don't you provide us with an example where the God-explanation has, on closer inspection, turned out to be true?

Lightning... nope.
Rainbows... nope.
Rain... nope.
Earthquakes... nope.
Disease... nope.
The religious have been wrong at every turn.

'We don't know' is a much, much better answer than 'Explain this... if you can't, then God'. I will repeat... virtually everything that we know about nature once had a God explanation attached to it. And that explanation has turned out to be wrong every time.
 
Last edited:
Don't know if you'll answer this yyreg: but if someone agrees with you wholeheartedly on the idea that the universe is evidence for the existence of God, what then ?
 
That is the big obstacle to dialog with atheists on the issue of God or no God, you have got the wrong concept of God, in regard to the Christian God in His fundamental relation to the universe which is
God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​


That is why I say that you are cognitively afraid of the correct concept of God.


Now, tell me what is your concept of God now that I have corrected you.

Thankyou for the "correction" but my concept of god is the same as it has been since I was a child. God does not exist.

Why would anyone be afraid of the concept of god? God doesn't scare me because he/she/it doesn't exist.

Your biggest obstacle to discussing god with atheists is that atheists do nor believe there is a god.
 
"syllogistic Lego toys" is a symonyn for "information damaging to my argument".

Other terms meaning much the same thing include:

"self-mind-truncating dictum"
"sapienti pauca"
"deep self-dungeoned freeze"
"entangled hopelessly with syllogistic reasoning"
"playing a self-dummy game"
"infinite silly ingress"
"useless syllogistic perch"
"toy Lego of carpetbagger syllogisms"
 
Last edited:
"syllogistic Lego toys" is a symonyn for "information damaging to my argument".

Other terms meaning much the same thing include:

"self-mind-truncating dictum"
"sapienti pauca"
"deep self-dungeoned freeze"
"entangled hopelessly with syllogistic reasoning"
"playing a self-dummy game"
"infinite silly ingress"
"useless syllogistic perch"
"toy Lego of carpetbagger syllogisms"

You forgot that golden oldie, "tergiversation".
 
Now, I like to go back to your admission that there is a pre-existing material in the universe, and that you are not any adherent of the school of cosmologists whom I call of the nothingness cosmology school, namely, that you don't advocate that the universe came forth from absolute nothing.



Yrreg

Nope, it is possible and even likely the universe did not come from nothing, that is a strawman of some sort.

We don't know.
 
There are a couple of very good documentaries.


<insert large gap between sentence>


The first is called Everything.



<insert large gap between sentence>



The second one is called Nothing.


<insert large gap between sentence>



They were made by the BBC.


<insert large gap between sentence>


And they explain everything that you want to know yrreg.


<insert large gap between sentence>


In laymens terms.


<insert large gap between sentence>


About our concept of nothing.


<insert large gap between sentence>



And the beginning of the universe.


<insert large gap between sentence>


I'm hoping by using the same arcane formatting that yrreg uses that he will subconsciously take my advice and actually try to watch them.
 
Allow me to remind atheist folks here that when you dialog with Christians you must get the correct concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, otherwise you are being illogical.

yrreg,

I myself am a skeptic, metaphysical naturalist and agnostic atheist. My problem is that as I age I start believing in everything.

Here are some facts:
There's an elephant in that paper bag on the floor. Many claim that though interesting, the study of philosophy seldom, if ever, and perhaps never, provides a concrete and useful "result". If we use partitions in order to define Entropy, then a multiset (a repetition of the same identity) has an entropy that is equivalent to the number of the repetitions that exists within it. But can there be any difficulty in proving, that vice and virtue are not matters of fact, whose existence we can infer by reason? I doubt if it matters whether a newborn is innocent or not, the deciding factor in the heaven part is whether somebody have gotten around to baptise them or not.

The answer needs to be put on hold for a sec to deal with the omnipresent argument that renders the question ineffective; namely, that there is no God. When asked "What is your religion?" 19% said "Spiritual but no religion" and 31% said "None". Jesus answered, "My kingdom is not of this world. If My kingdom were of this world, My servants would fight, so that I should not be delivered to the Jews; but now My kingdom is not from here."

I know that the Bible says that by faith alone can we receive salvation. In all of the discussion over the seperation of church and state, involving so many issues such as creationism vs. real science, abortion, environmental protection, the death penalty, and so on, I think those advocating putting God and Jesus back into government are missing one important point. I don't mean the CHURCH OF Scientology. I mean SCIENTOLOGY, the philosophy/Religion. I believe I have made a thread similar to this one for the existence of Jesus, but is there any evidence outside of the Bible that substantiates any events that supposedly occurred in the Bible? I am currently reading the Bible (I'll put up a post on that sometime soon, although I know there are plenty of posts by previous gluttons for punishment intrepid readers), and I'm still only working my way through Exodus after three days. Religion gives millions (billions!) of people all over the world comfort and hope in a world that seems bleak and uncaring.

Don’t know if this has been brought up before, but I’m wondering what peoples’ take on this is. I've mentioned my past as a Christian missionary before, but never gone into much detail, at least in part because as an atheist today, its quite frankly rather embarrassing. I have been trying to educate my theistic comrade as to what I believe is the correct definition of atheism. I'm switching from atheism back to what I used to believe, which was something like deism, but not exactly. I am honestly wondering how posters on this site feel about agnostics, particularly agnostics with "hope" that there is an intelligent force in the universe. What would make someone stop going to such a loving place as this? I'd be interested to read the arguments of the local theists and deists.

Dave
 
Okay, every good, noted, but not totally and exclusively agreeing to all your implications.

Now as regards universe if you give examples of what everything refers to and at the end say that
"and also everything imaginable and can be the subject of human discourse,"​
that will be fine.

Yrreg

Why should we add 'and also everything imaginable and can be the subject of human discourse'? How is 'everything that exists' inadequate? Doesn't adding anything to 'everything that exists' necessarily involve adding things that don't exist to the universe? Do you think the universe includes things that don't exist?
 
Why should we add 'and also everything imaginable and can be the subject of human discourse'? How is 'everything that exists' inadequate? Doesn't adding anything to 'everything that exists' necessarily involve adding things that don't exist to the universe? Do you think the universe includes things that don't exist?

The greater the number of words used to assert something, the greater its truth value.
 
Don't know if you'll answer this yyreg: but if someone agrees with you wholeheartedly on the idea that the universe is evidence for the existence of God, what then ?

You know, I actually tried that in one of his threads a while back. He never came back with a "what then" because I don't think he even has a "Plan B"

Norm
 
yrreg - You have demonstrated over the years that you do not have the background, inclination, or willingness to work hard enough to learn the math and science necessary to understand any explanations, on any subject, that you might be offered.

Please stop asking questions that you are unwilling/unable to understand or evaluate answers to.
 
Gerry, can you post in your native language and let somebody who actually speaks English translate? Because this just isn't working. Your command of this language is...nonexistent.


I'm pretty sure English is his native language.

He allows us to believe that his first language was other than English so that the flaws won't so obviously be traced to his thinking.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom