Robert Oz
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Dec 3, 2007
- Messages
- 1,455
I know this has been done to death with yrreg, but once again from the wikipedia entry on CosmogonyWP:
Inserting God here is no different than inserting God to explain the sun's path across the sky, or a rainbow or lightning, prior to the much better and accurate explanations eventually provided by science. All the people throughout history who inserted God for the sun, rainbows, lighting, earthquakes, etc. were just flat out wrong! It is a terrible explanation!
You spend so much time asking for an example of something that does not have a beginning. Why don't you provide us with an example where the God-explanation has, on closer inspection, turned out to be true?
Lightning... nope.
Rainbows... nope.
Rain... nope.
Earthquakes... nope.
Disease... nope.
The religious have been wrong at every turn.
'We don't know' is a much, much better answer than 'Explain this... if you can't, then God'. I will repeat... virtually everything that we know about nature once had a God explanation attached to it. And that explanation has turned out to be wrong every time.
The most commonly held view is the universe was once a gravitational singularity which then expanded rapidly from this hot and dense state. While this expansion is well-modeled by the Big Bang theory, the origins of the singularity remains one of the unsolved problems in physics.
Inserting God here is no different than inserting God to explain the sun's path across the sky, or a rainbow or lightning, prior to the much better and accurate explanations eventually provided by science. All the people throughout history who inserted God for the sun, rainbows, lighting, earthquakes, etc. were just flat out wrong! It is a terrible explanation!
You spend so much time asking for an example of something that does not have a beginning. Why don't you provide us with an example where the God-explanation has, on closer inspection, turned out to be true?
Lightning... nope.
Rainbows... nope.
Rain... nope.
Earthquakes... nope.
Disease... nope.
The religious have been wrong at every turn.
'We don't know' is a much, much better answer than 'Explain this... if you can't, then God'. I will repeat... virtually everything that we know about nature once had a God explanation attached to it. And that explanation has turned out to be wrong every time.
Last edited:
