Yahoo Answers: How some astrohysicists fool people with illogic.

I put this question yesterday in Yahoo Answers:
...Now, is there anywhere in the internet their equations in math notation by which on the left side before the = sign there is the notation of un or whatever for universe, and on the right side after the = sign there are all kinds of symbols and digits and letters and signs whatever showing that with that equation: there is the mathematical demonstration with mathematical certainty that the universe where we live in and are part and parcel of came forth from nothing, i.e. no antecedent material of composition and no creator whatsoever who is self-existing.

For some reason, you've convinced yourself that the origin of the universe can be described by one equation: UNorigin = (lots of symbols). Such a subject is extremely complex and requires more than one equation to describe all the matter transformations involved. You are ready to conclude that the absence of your unrealistic assumption gives automatically God the green light to enter the works.

Science works differently than religion; it's like climbing a mountain: science must anchor itself very often, coz if something goes wrong, it falls only a few feet just to find another, safer way up. That makes it a very slow climb. Religion moves much faster, but when something goes wrong, it tumbles all the way down. (See the climbing of Mt. Creation.) In other words, if science is not sure, it won't move ahead to call a speculation a theory.
http://science.howstuffworks.com/dictionary/astronomy-terms/before-big-bang.htm

You are free to believe that God created the universe, but you'll never find out how apart from the Bible account. See, there is a rational speculation called "the big crunch." According to this scenario, there was a universe before ours which began collapsing due to gravitational influences to a certain stage and then, like a supernova, it expanded again (the big bang). But in this stage of our mental development, it's impossible for the cosmologists to roll the film back that far and form a theory of that hypothetical process. That "pre-universe" wasn't like this one though. According to Hawking's number crunching, this universe will not collapse on itself - the opposite will take place and it slowly "evaporates" out of its existence. But you never know, coz "God's mind works the mysterious ways . . ."
 
By the way, Yrreg, if I don't post in a thread for a few hours does not mean I have abandoned it. I am not online 24/7 as I have other responsibilities, and I do not live in the same time zone as you. It is extremely rude of you to suggest that I, or X, MRC_Hans, or indeed any other poster has to post to some timetable of yours or else be accused of resigning from the thread. You are not in charge of who posts to any thread, nor when, nor how often.


Yes.
Patrick_1000 tried that in his Apollo-hoax thread. After asking him not to (multiple times), I did leave. Not because of his arguments (they are laughable), but because of his attitude.
 
Science works differently than religion; it's like climbing a mountain: science must anchor itself very often, coz if something goes wrong, it falls only a few feet just to find another, safer way up. That makes it a very slow climb. Religion moves much faster, but when something goes wrong, it tumbles all the way down. (See the climbing of Mt. Creation.) In other words, if science is not sure, it won't move ahead to call a speculation a theory.
Good analogy imo.
 
The beauty of it is that Yrreg's argument is so retarded epix is actually trying to show him he's wrong... :D
:popcorn1 And Epix actually sounds sensible (for a few words) in comparison. Digging this thread. I enjoy surrealism.
 
I see yrreg is still on his quest to prove the existence of the Dunning-Krueger effect over and over again.
 
Pre-existing material is the term I used, but I have to change it...

You can call your mistaken ideas of what those scientist believe whatever you want, your epithets have no bearing on reality.

You are misrepresenting the views of the scientists you mention. It is not the worldview of Hawking, Stenger or Krauss that the universe came from nothing. Rather, it is their view that as far back in time as we can study at our current levels of knowledge, there was an immense amount of something (energy) compressed into a singularity.

It is not the worldview of those scientists that there was no pre-existing material, but not for the reason you seem to be hinting at. Time began at the big bang, so pre-existing in this context is meaningless. There is no time before time, just as there is no south of the south pole.

By the way, pre-existing material is what you originally proposed and it has not gone unnoticed that you have substituted reality into your phrase.

No divine creator has ever been shown to exist, nor is one necessary for science's model of the universe.

By trying to shoehorn your misapprehensions into your question you render it both meaningless and unanswerable, unless it is unpacked into the three separate assumptions and each one addressed separately.

You cannot win a debate with this style of argument; it should have become obvious to you a long time ago that you cannot use sophistry to lead people to agree with a position which they do not hold. Repeating yourself and misrepresenting others does not improve your argument any more than insults do.



Pre-existing material is the term I used, but I have to change it in order that we have a more precise term for our discussion, and I submit reality is the more precise term because reality means any existing thing whatsoever, but material thing means only what is material to atheist scientists and cosmologists.


About Hawking, Stenger, and Krauss, they really do not explicitly say that the universe comes forth from absolute nothing, but that is their intention and that is how they are represented in the media, and that is what they affirm in the media, and they do that in order to deny the existence of God -- if they really want to say that there is an existing material or I prefer a reality antecedent to the material universe, they could have come out openly in the media to make the correction that the media is misrepresenting them: they do not say that the universe comes forth from absolute nothing, but that there is a reality or for them a material that is pre-existing.


Do not any more occupy your time with my use of pre-existing material and now I want to change it to reality, because that is not the important issue, the important issue now is to determine what is this antecedent thing to the material universe of the atheist scientists.


Now that you admit the pre-existing material or for me now reality, tell me what you know of this pre-existing reality?


Can we now just use the term reality instead of material to signify anything at all that exists in anyway at anytime or anywhere or even outside of time and space?

If you insist on using the word material then you have already preclude the existence of things which are not material but still they do exist; however, you can specify exactly what is your concept of material.

Can you understand what I am trying to tell you that reality is a broader concept than material.

If you insist on using the word material then you must give your concept of what is material, then perhaps I will accept it if you understand by material anything at all that exists in any manner at any time and in any space and also most importantly even outside time and space.


That is what I seem to be seeing in you, your stubbornness in nitpick details, in order to suppress the thought of the totality of existence which I also understand to be the universe.

Can you see now how important it is to first come to agreement on concepts, for on the concepts used by a speaker readers will see right away what kind of delimitations they already put into their world or universe or the totality of existence.

Of course you can say the same thing about me, but we will see whether we can come to mutually accepted concepts.




Yrreg
 
For some reason, you've convinced yourself that the origin of the universe can be described by one equation: UNorigin = (lots of symbols). Such a subject is extremely complex and requires more than one equation to describe all the matter transformations involved. You are ready to conclude that the absence of your unrealistic assumption gives automatically God the green light to enter the works.

Science works differently than religion; it's like climbing a mountain: science must anchor itself very often, coz if something goes wrong, it falls only a few feet just to find another, safer way up. That makes it a very slow climb. Religion moves much faster, but when something goes wrong, it tumbles all the way down. (See the climbing of Mt. Creation.) In other words, if science is not sure, it won't move ahead to call a speculation a theory.
http://science.howstuffworks.com/dictionary/astronomy-terms/before-big-bang.htm

You are free to believe that God created the universe, but you'll never find out how apart from the Bible account. See, there is a rational speculation called "the big crunch." According to this scenario, there was a universe before ours which began collapsing due to gravitational influences to a certain stage and then, like a supernova, it expanded again (the big bang). But in this stage of our mental development, it's impossible for the cosmologists to roll the film back that far and form a theory of that hypothetical process. That "pre-universe" wasn't like this one though. According to Hawking's number crunching, this universe will not collapse on itself - the opposite will take place and it slowly "evaporates" out of its existence. But you never know, coz "God's mind works the mysterious ways . . ."



The issue now is to determine what is the pre-existing reality antecedent to the material universe.




Yrreg
 
Pre-existing material is the term I used, but I have to change it in order that we have a more precise term for our discussion, and I submit reality is the more precise term because reality means any existing thing whatsoever, but material thing means only what is material to atheist scientists and cosmologists.


About Hawking, Stenger, and Krauss, they really do not explicitly say that the universe comes forth from absolute nothing, but that is their intention and that is how they are represented in the media, and that is what they affirm in the media, and they do that in order to deny the existence of God -- if they really want to say that there is an existing material or I prefer a reality antecedent to the material universe, they could have come out openly in the media to make the correction that the media is misrepresenting them: they do not say that the universe comes forth from absolute nothing, but that there is a reality or for them a material that is pre-existing.


Do not any more occupy your time with my use of pre-existing material and now I want to change it to reality, because that is not the important issue, the important issue now is to determine what is this antecedent thing to the material universe of the atheist scientists.


Now that you admit the pre-existing material or for me now reality, tell me what you know of this pre-existing reality?


Can we now just use the term reality instead of material to signify anything at all that exists in anyway at anytime or anywhere or even outside of time and space?

If you insist on using the word material then you have already preclude the existence of things which are not material but still they do exist; however, you can specify exactly what is your concept of material.

Can you understand what I am trying to tell you that reality is a broader concept than material.

If you insist on using the word material then you must give your concept of what is material, then perhaps I will accept it if you understand by material anything at all that exists in any manner at any time and in any space and also most importantly even outside time and space.


That is what I seem to be seeing in you, your stubbornness in nitpick details, in order to suppress the thought of the totality of existence which I also understand to be the universe.

Can you see now how important it is to first come to agreement on concepts, for on the concepts used by a speaker readers will see right away what kind of delimitations they already put into their world or universe or the totality of existence.

Of course you can say the same thing about me, but we will see whether we can come to mutually accepted concepts.




Yrreg

Let's agree on whether everything needs to begin.
 
The fact is that there are things that began to exist and will cease to exist.

Let's agree on whether everything needs to begin.


The fact is that there are things that began to exist and will cease to exist.


I for one am convinced that not everything has to begin to exist, only those things which we do know to have begun to exist, and from these things we have in them the evidence that there is God the creator of everything that has a beginning and an ending to their existence.




Yrreg
 
The fact is that there are things that began to exist and will cease to exist.


I for one am convinced that not everything has to begin to exist,
Ah good, then the universe doesn't need to begin to exist.

only those things which we do know to have begun to exist, and from these things we have in them the evidence that there is God the creator of everything that has a beginning and an ending to their existence.




Yrreg

No, you've made an unfounded leap there. That's why I would prefer that you use logical arguments rather than just making up crap like that.

If you're positing a god, what created that god?
 
I love to hear from you what is your concept of God.

Ah good, then the universe doesn't need to begin to exist.



No, you've made an unfounded leap there. That's why I would prefer that you use logical arguments rather than just making up crap like that.

If you're positing a god, what created that god?



Who created God?


First, we have to work together on what is our mutually agreed on concept of God.


I have said time and again that my concept of God in His fundamental relation to the universe is that
God is the creator of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​


I love to hear from you what is your concept of God.




Yrreg
 
Who created God?

First, we have to work together on what is our mutually agreed on concept of God.

I have said time and again that my concept of God in His fundamental relation to the universe is that
God is the creator of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​

I love to hear from you what is your concept of God.

So, if no one first agrees with your concept of God, then you'll never answer the question of who/what created your God. I got that right?
 
So, if no one first agrees with your concept of God, then you'll never answer the question of who/what created your God. I got that right?

Basically, we have this situation:

Red Corner....
God
Yahweh
FSM
Giant Turtle
Mice
Zeus
Odin
Cthulhu

Blue Corner....
The Universe

So far, Gerry has not shown a way for any or all of the Red Corner to find their way to the Blue Corner.
 
Well, that is correct, first we have to agree on concepts otherwise how can we at...

So, if no one first agrees with your concept of God, then you'll never answer the question of who/what created your God. I got that right?



Well, that is correct, first we have to agree on concepts otherwise how can we at all communicate viably?


You will say that agreeing on concept is already admitting the reality of the thing represented by the concept.


That is not correct.

We can agree on the concept of an extra terrestrial intelligent being but that is not admitting that such a being exists outside of the concept in our mind.


But with the concept already agreed on we can both set forth to seek the reality outside our concept but corresponding to the concept to look for e.g. a being in outer space not from earth that is also intelligent as we know what is intelligence with us humans.


Can you see now, or you are already afraid of the concept of God?

In which case your fear of the concept itself is irrational, illogical, and not at all to your credit as a being possessed of a reasoning mind.




Yrreg
 
First, we have to work together on what is our mutually agreed on concept of God.

I get the feeling that what you really mean is that you want to force your definition on us.

I have said time and again that my concept of God in His fundamental relation to the universe is that
God is the creator of everything in the universe that is not Himself.
In your other thread I gave my definition of God as: An anthropomorphic construct of human imagination created to attribute agency to nature in an attempt to anticipate its behavior. So, how do we come to an agreement as to the definition of God?

I love to hear from you what is your concept of God.
I would love to believe you, but history causes me to conclude that you have no interest in other people's definitions of God.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom