Yahoo Answers: How some astrohysicists fool people with illogic.

I kinda like this one [qimg]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/d/d0/Creation_of_the_Sun_and_Moon_face_detail.jpg/220px-Creation_of_the_Sun_and_Moon_face_detail.jpg[/qimg]
Or maybe this one [qimg]http://t0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQMyWpqLij3zaFGAe3yixCOOsWfeVSXq4CA_GmDHxOGpeae0vZH[/qimg]
or even this one [qimg]http://t0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSxkDfIldb5Cj-qqh2TWflMighrsUMedLKsWqYWL9ASZ3dF2XK4ZA[/qimg]

Nah, I think this is the one I like best [qimg]http://t1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQMgOOxmtlQfksAnYSDun9yYTxhAGo6WIVoUMVzpePIZDMVnFlPWw[/qimg]
I think that third one is Charlton Heston as Moses, not God.
 
I think that third one is Charlton Heston as Moses, not God.

I know Chuck played Moses. Just poking fun at the characters he portrayed. ;)
However, the way he portrayed the character suggests God and he had at that time in his career a larger than life persona.
 
The issue now is to determine what is the pre-existing reality antecedent to the material universe.




Yrreg

In this you are right finally correct. Actually the the preceding reality before this universe came into existence was the singularity. However, at this time no one can say what if anything preceded this singularity.

But Yrreg -and his working assortment of fallacies- by the application of a twisted and epistemologically hedonistic version of Occam's Razor -one that has an imaginary notion as a plausible option- have concluded that any deep physics-like rumination is very complicated and that Devil (or God if you like better call it that way) offers the simplest thus right explanation to the origin of this universe.

Besides, by a "mountain moving faith" -no faith has ever moved a mountain but it easily can lead suggestible brains to perceive mountains moved- he is prepared to find weak any logical argumentation: any path offered to him that requires an effort or reveals his limitations or leads him through uncomfortable fields, will be judged by him as wrong, useless or uninteresting -just like little kids do-. The Christian "god", the "creator, provider, yada, yada,..." provides him with the smoke screen that covers his primitive approach to the subject.

Yrreg is very comfortable where he is, so he's not moving one inch because he's maximizing his pleasure, and any braniac, nerd or smart guy trying to make him reasonable only reinforces his hedonistic perception of him being important or having something valuable that others don't.

About argumentation, being the best showing Yrreg's errors is pretty much like being the smartest kid with Down syndrome, and he'll never react to it the same way a Yrreg-like one couldn't convince a fly in his house that the window glass is not air and that is should stop bumping on it and look for an alternative way to get to the closest dung.

What begs the question: It's obvious why the fly bounces but, what is everyone else doing here? Can the umpteenth reply still be fun?
 
Honestly, yes it can be fun. In addition, it sharpens one's thinking and is good practice in making succinct, simple arguments; partly because English is Yrreg's second language, and partly because he appears not to comprehend complex argument or syntax.
 
I ask for our concept in order that I may know it and also to correct it.

No. Not a single concept that you have presented frightens me in the least.



Apparently so you can ignore them. You asked others what there concept of God is. I responded days ago and never got the slightest response from you. All you do is keep telling us what your concept of God is, ad infinitum, as though we may have forgotten after the first hundred times. I get the impression that you have created a dialog in your mind before you even present your first post. Then, like some computer program, you keep repeating the first step in the hope that someone else will provide a response that matches your pre-concieved dialog.


I already gave it to you. I'm sorry if you don't like my response, but repeating, "First, you give your concepts..." over and over and over and over and over isn't going to result in me giving a response that you want. If you really want what you say you want, then acknowledge the response that I gave regarding your query.

.
A more accurate analogy would have you saying, "That will be ten dollars, please", then me holding a ten dollar bill toward you and saying, "here's ten dollars. May I see the dragon now?", only to have you respond, "That will be ten dollars, please".


But you aren't offering us toasters. You are offering us God. But every time we ask you to show us the merchandise you just repeat your first sales-pitch.



Wow! It's like the worst conjuring act ever. It's like you're saying "This is your card" as you show me a plastic flower. You are trying to take my definition of God as a figment of human imagination, no different from Santa Claus or the Easter Bunny, and declare it equal to your definition of God as creator of everything in the universe that is not itself.

Gerry: What would you like to drink.
Foster Zygote: I'll have a glass of The Macallan 12 year, neat.
Gerry: Very good, sir. Here is your Mountain Dew.
FZ: But I wanted a glass of quality malt, not a kid's drink.
Gerry: That is no different essentially from Mountain Dew.


Saying it doesn't make it so.


What about the concept of Santa Claus as held by children?


Wrong. I am not denying the existence of God, I am pointing out that there is no evidence for this entity. This includes your personal definition of God. Quit telling us ad nauseum what your concept of God is and get on with demonstrating that it exists.


No, I don't. This is exactly what I mean when I say that you are determined to force your concepts on us.


No, Gerry, I am not saying that God is an agency. Can you comprehend what I wrote? I am saying that people are attempting to attribute agency where none exists by creating an imaginary entity that dwells only in their minds.


No. I am not afraid of your imaginary friend.



I ask for your concept of God in order that I may know it and also to correct it, if you are misinformed about the fundamental concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe.

I remember you giving me your concept of God and I corrected it.

Do you now have a concept of God in the Christian faith in his fundamental relation to the universe, I want you to tell me now, your corrected concept.


You see, you say that you don't believe in God, but you are not getting the correct God to not believe in, that is why I see you to be essentially illogical but a rich subject for psychology.


That is the big obstacle to dialog with atheists on the issue of God or no God, you have got the wrong concept of God, in regard to the Christian God in His fundamental relation to the universe which is
God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​


That is why I say that you are cognitively afraid of the correct concept of God.


Now, tell me what is your concept of God now that I have corrected you.



Yrreg #142 said:
Yrreg #142

[...]

Here, you give your definition of God:
An anthropomorphic construct of human imagination created to attribute agency to nature in an attempt to anticipate its behavior.
​
That is no different essentially from my concept of God:
Creator of everything in the universe that is not Himself.
​
If you will just bring in the venue of operation of this agent you and I call God.

You say nature, I say the universe understood as the totality of existence.



We are now into working out together for an agreed on concept of God, so that we will not be talking past our heads which is irrational and illogical.


So, what about this concept of God as already established by theists:
Creator of everything in the universe that is not Himself.
​
Remember you are the one denying the existence of the God of theists, so you must be acquainted correctly with their concept of God, and not insist that they agree with your concept of God.


Anyway, you have the same essential idea of God as theists like myself, in God's fundamental relation to the universe of which nature is a part.

You say in effect that God is an agent, and I say God is a creator.



But I must tell you that you are under the spell of fear, fear of the concept of God as propounded by theists like myself, namely:
God is the creator of everything in the universe that is not Himself.
​


Can you and will you comprehend that you are insisting on a wrong concept of God in the Christian faith in his fundamental relation to the universe.


If you will not correct your concept of God, then please do not dialog with Christians because you will be barking up the wrong tree at the wrong God, that is what I am telling you atheist folks all the time.


Go and dialog with folks who believe in your God that is according to your concept of.


------------------------


Allow me to remind atheist folks here that when you dialog with Christians you must get the correct concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, otherwise you are being illogical.




Dear Zygote: I am aware that you are very frustrated, very angry, because you want to insist on your wrong concept of God in order to lambast God and Christians, better to get the correct concept and then dialog according to reason, logic, and facts.




Yrreg
 
You are all into your own concepts but you are not cognizant of the correct...

You are all into your own concepts but you are not cognizant of the correct concept in the Christian faith of God in His fundamental relation to the universe.

You have to get correctly informed about the concept of God in the Christian faith, etc.

I am fully aware that you are all very frustrated and very angry because you want to insist that your concept of God be accepted by me, but it is not the correct concept, can you comprehend that?

But you can get into dialog with folks who have your concept of God.



As regards universe and evidence, I have given my concepts which I know to be what are commonly understood and correctly by people who do have comprehension of language and the world.

Now, you do not agree with my concepts of universe and of evidence.



Suppose you atheist folks here get together and issue your commonly agreed on concept of the universe and also of evidence, so that I will deal with you according to your commonly agreed on concepts, for I do not and cannot be dealing with you all.


Okay, you atheist folk, get together and work to come to your commonly concurred on concepts of the universe as also of evidence.


However, if you can refer me to an online atheist dictionary or glossary or atheists' enclopedia where the words universe and evidence are found, I will appreciate that, and it will save you atheist folks from the laborious task of working out among yourselves your commonly concurring concept of universe as of evidence.




Yrreg
 
Your concept of god is a personal one for you. My concept of your god is a personal one to me. It is unlikely that we will ever agree on this matter, not least because you believe the entity exists and I don't believe that it does.

As you are never likely to persuade an atheist to agree with your concept of god, one has to ask, what is your point in posting here? What do you hope to achieve?

It is clear that you are not attempting to understand the atheist position, as you routinely ignore the posts in which people patiently (and not so patiently) explain their concepts of god, explain that they do not care what you believe and have no wish to change your beliefs, that they do not fear or hate the ideas of gods and have no wish to lambast theists.

Several people have posted their definition of the universe, their definition of evidence, and their concept of the Christian God. Is there any chance at all you will move the discussion forward, bearing in mind that you will not persuade atheists to agree with your concept of God?
 
Further to my reply above, I see I must make one thing clear.

We understand your concept of God. We understand what you believe. We are what you call "correctly informed" about your concept of God. We are not lacking in knowledge, we lack belief.

We understand your faith but we don't share it. No amount of rudeness, misrepresentation or repetition will make us suddenly believe something in which we lack belief.

We are not angry or fearful, we simply hold a different opinion. The only frustration arises from your apparent inability to comprehend why atheists do not believe in the God in which you believe.
 
Suppose you atheist folks here get together and issue your commonly agreed on concept of the universe and also of evidence, so that I will deal with you according to your commonly agreed on concepts, for I do not and cannot be dealing with you all.


Okay, you atheist folk, get together and work to come to your commonly concurred on concepts of the universe as also of evidence.


However, if you can refer me to an online atheist dictionary or glossary or atheists' enclopedia where the words universe and evidence are found, I will appreciate that, and it will save you atheist folks from the laborious task of working out among yourselves your commonly concurring concept of universe as of evidence.
You have already been given these definitions several times.

Universe: Everything that exists

Evidence: The available body of facts or information indicating whether a belief or proposition is true or valid.
 
You are all into your own concepts but you are not cognizant of the correct concept in the Christian faith of God in His fundamental relation to the universe.

You have to get correctly informed about the concept of God in the Christian faith, etc.

I am fully aware that you are all very frustrated and very angry because you want to insist that your concept of God be accepted by me, but it is not the correct concept, can you comprehend that?

But you can get into dialog with folks who have your concept of God.



As regards universe and evidence, I have given my concepts which I know to be what are commonly understood and correctly by people who do have comprehension of language and the world.

Now, you do not agree with my concepts of universe and of evidence.



Suppose you atheist folks here get together and issue your commonly agreed on concept of the universe and also of evidence, so that I will deal with you according to your commonly agreed on concepts, for I do not and cannot be dealing with you all.


Okay, you atheist folk, get together and work to come to your commonly concurred on concepts of the universe as also of evidence.


However, if you can refer me to an online atheist dictionary or glossary or atheists' enclopedia where the words universe and evidence are found, I will appreciate that, and it will save you atheist folks from the laborious task of working out among yourselves your commonly concurring concept of universe as of evidence.




Yrreg

Gerry,
Your frustration and anger is impeding your judgement.

Everything that you have asserted above has been dealt with many times by multiple posters.

Perhaps you should read some of the responses provided to you earlier in this and the previous thread, to save you some time. This may then provide you more time to read your own posts and make them more comprehensible before posting.

I note that you have left the previous thread and continued the argument in this thread. I have therefore asked that the threads be merged, as there's no point in having both threads open.
 
I like to go back to your admission that there is a pre-existing material in the...

You have already been given these definitions several times.

Universe: Everything that exists

Evidence: The available body of facts or information indicating whether a belief or proposition is true or valid.



Okay, every good, noted, but not totally and exclusively agreeing to all your implications.

Now as regards universe if you give examples of what everything refers to and at the end say that
"and also everything imaginable and can be the subject of human discourse,"​
that will be fine.

As regards your concept of evidence, you talk about belief and proposition to be true or valid, why not talk about facts, so that your concept will be like mine, namely,
evidence is a fact known to man leading him to know another fact.​

Are you capable of comprehending the idea that when it comes to evidence we must stick to facts and not bring in belief and proposition.






Now, I like to go back to your admission that there is a pre-existing material in the universe, and that you are not any adherent of the school of cosmologists whom I call of the nothingness cosmology school, namely, that you don't advocate that the universe came forth from absolute nothing.


We were talking about determining what is that pre-existing material, and I was asking you whether I can change that pre-existing material into pre-existing reality, because pre-existing material unless you specify otherwise is indicative of a material universe precluding everything that is not material, that is already a foreclosing of any dialog that involves non-material things, which is of course a pre-blindering of your mind.

And pre-blindering of one's mind is always to be discouraged as it is not to the advancement of learning in a person.




Yrreg
 
God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​


Yrreg

So your god is simply the Big Bang and not the Christian god? Hasn't anyone ever indoctrinated you into the Christian faith with a true concept of the Christian god?

Why are you angry and fearful of The Flying Spaghetti Monster? I told you it couldn't hurt you now that it has created the universe and was destroyed in creating it. You must stop being fearful and angry at The Flying Spaghetti Monster.
 
Okay, every good, noted, but not totally and exclusively agreeing to all your implications.

Now as regards universe if you give examples of what everything refers to and at the end say that
"and also everything imaginable and can be the subject of human discourse,"​
that will be fine.

As regards your concept of evidence, you talk about belief and proposition to be true or valid, why not talk about facts, so that your concept will be like mine, namely,
evidence is a fact known to man leading him to know another fact.​

Are you capable of comprehending the idea that when it comes to evidence we must stick to facts and not bring in belief and proposition.






Now, I like to go back to your admission that there is a pre-existing material in the universe, and that you are not any adherent of the school of cosmologists whom I call of the nothingness cosmology school, namely, that you don't advocate that the universe came forth from absolute nothing.


We were talking about determining what is that pre-existing material, and I was asking you whether I can change that pre-existing material into pre-existing reality, because pre-existing material unless you specify otherwise is indicative of a material universe precluding everything that is not material, that is already a foreclosing of any dialog that involves non-material things, which is of course a pre-blindering of your mind.

And pre-blindering of one's mind is always to be discouraged as it is not to the advancement of learning in a person.




Yrreg

All you have said here is that you want to substitute your own definitions in all cases.

This would not be a problem except that in all cases, your definitions are incorrect or incomplete or both.

This is not agreement, as you have already been told many times. You are being dishonest with us and dishonest with yourself.

Cease the deception.
 
Okay, every good, noted, but not totally and exclusively agreeing to all your implications.

Now as regards universe if you give examples of what everything refers to and at the end say that
"and also everything imaginable and can be the subject of human discourse,"​
that will be fine.
No, because things can be imagined, or talked about, which do not exist. If they do not exist, they are not part of the universe. I am bewildered as to why you want to include imaginary things in the universe. J. K. Rowling imagined a whole world of wizards including Hogwarts School, but it doesn't exist outside of her imagination.

Everything refers to everything. Everything that exists. There really should be no need to expand on it, it's an absolute and does not need to be qualified. If you feel the need to qualify it, then you are not correctly understanding the meaning of the word "everything".

As regards your concept of evidence, you talk about belief and proposition to be true or valid, why not talk about facts, so that your concept will be like mine, namely,
evidence is a fact known to man leading him to know another fact.​
No, because evidence is what we use to determine whether something is a fact (determining the truth of a proposition). Your definition is something which has already been shown to be true, rather than the evidence used to arrive at the conclusion. You are missing the proper meaning of words and you are beginning with the conclusion.
Are you capable of comprehending the idea that when it comes to evidence we must stick to facts and not bring in belief and proposition.
You are not comprehending that we use evidence to turn beliefs or propositions into facts. Evidence is part of the process; facts are what we get at the end.
Now, I like to go back to your admission that there is a pre-existing material in the universe, and that you are not any adherent of the school of cosmologists whom I call of the nothingness cosmology school, namely, that you don't advocate that the universe came forth from absolute nothing.
Kindly do not misrepresent me. I have not admitted that there is a "pre-existing material" in the universe, by which I understand you to mean that there was something before the universe. I refer you to my previous post here (clickable link) in which I explained it is my understanding that time began at the moment the universe began, so it is meaningless to talk about a time "before" time began. What I have said on several occasions is that as far as scientists can determine, at the moment of the beginning of the universe (time=0) there was an immense amount of energy compressed into a singularity, which expanded at that moment which is when time began and the universe began. It is not possible at our current level of knowledge to go further than that.
We were talking about determining what is that pre-existing material, and I was asking you whether I can change that pre-existing material into pre-existing reality, because pre-existing material unless you specify otherwise is indicative of a material universe precluding everything that is not material, that is already a foreclosing of any dialog that involves non-material things, which is of course a pre-blindering of your mind.
Blindering or pre-blindering are not words. As time began at t=0, it is meaningless to discuss anything prior to t=0. It is as meaningless as south of the South Pole or north of the North Pole. There is no time before time.
And pre-blindering of one's mind is always to be discouraged as it is not to the advancement of learning in a person.
Using words which do not exist is always to be discouraged. Starting with the conclusion that there is a god means that you close your mind to the reality of science.
 
Last edited:
Honestly, yes it can be fun. In addition, it sharpens one's thinking and is good practice in making succinct, simple arguments; partly because English is Yrreg's second language, and partly because he appears not to comprehend complex argument or syntax.
...or metaphor, or simile, or analogy, or allegory, or parable, or sarcasm, or irony, or simple humor.
 
I want us to go back to your admission that there is a pre-existing material to...

No, because things can be imagined, or talked about, which do not exist. If they do not exist, they are not part of the universe. I am bewildered as to why you want to include imaginary things in the universe. J. K. Rowling imagined a whole world of wizards including Hogwarts School, but it doesn't exist outside of her imagination.

Everything refers to everything. Everything that exists. There really should be no need to expand on it, it's an absolute and does not need to be qualified. If you feel the need to qualify it, then you are not correctly understanding the meaning of the word "everything".

No, because evidence is what we use to determine whether something is a fact (determining the truth of a proposition). Your definition is something which has already been shown to be true, rather than the evidence used to arrive at the conclusion. You are missing the proper meaning of words and you are beginning with the conclusion.
You are not comprehending that we use evidence to turn beliefs or propositions into facts. Evidence is part of the process; facts are what we get at the end.
Kindly do not misrepresent me. I have not admitted that there is a "pre-existing material" in the universe, by which I understand you to mean that there was something before the universe. I refer you to my previous post here (clickable link) in which I explained it is my understanding that time began at the moment the universe began, so it is meaningless to talk about a time "before" time began. What I have said on several occasions is that as far as scientists can determine, at the moment of the beginning of the universe (time=0) there was an immense amount of energy compressed into a singularity, which expanded at that moment which is when time began and the universe began. It is not possible at our current level of knowledge to go further than that. Blindering or pre-blindering is not a word. As time began at t=0, it is meaningless to discuss anything prior to t=0. It is as meaningless as south of the South Pole or north of the North Pole. There is no time before time. Using words which do not exist is always to be discouraged. Starting with the conclusion that there is a god means that you close your mind to the reality of science.



Well, so as not to waste time interminably I will just proceed from my own concepts of what is universe and what is evidence, and if you dispute me on my thoughts, we will work out our differences as each instant of disputation from you surfaces.

I will just tell you however that you have a blindered mind, and you can say also something about my blindered mind, and I will take that as a basis for self-examination.

As regards the concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, I will also proceed according to my concept on my worldview as a Christian theist, and if you dispute my thoughts we will take up that instant of your disputation and resolve it.



Now, I want us to go back to your admission that there is a pre-existing material to the universe, are you ready for that?



Tell me from your own thoughts and convictions and be ready to give reasons why on facts, not on authorities,
do you or do you not ascribe to the idea that there is a pre-existing material (reality more expansively) to the universe, yes, no?​


Just answer yes or no, then present your reasoning why yes or why no.


Don't start with citing authorities, because who is going to judge the authorities on the the validity of their authority?


Just give from your on rational logical intelligent thinking on the indisputable facts of life and the world.

That means an open mind before anything else.




Yrreg
 
Well, so as not to waste time interminably I will just proceed from my own concepts of what is universe and what is evidence, and if you dispute me on my thoughts, we will work out our differences as each instant of disputation from you surfaces.

I will just tell you however that you have a blindered mind, and you can say also something about my blindered mind, and I will take that as a basis for self-examination.

As regards the concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, I will also proceed according to my concept on my worldview as a Christian theist, and if you dispute my thoughts we will take up that instant of your disputation and resolve it.



Now, I want us to go back to your admission that there is a pre-existing material to the universe, are you ready for that?



Tell me from your own thoughts and convictions and be ready to give reasons why on facts, not on authorities,
do you or do you not ascribe to the idea that there is a pre-existing material (reality more expansively) to the universe, yes, no?​


Just answer yes or no, then present your reasoning why yes or why no.


Don't start with citing authorities, because who is going to judge the authorities on the the validity of their authority?


Just give from your on rational logical intelligent thinking on the indisputable facts of life and the world.

That means an open mind before anything else.




Yrreg

Gerry,
There you go again - you are corrected, and you ignore it and proceed with your own incorrect and incomplete definitions.

What's the point of asking or definitions if you have no intention of using them?
 
I have not admitted that there is "pre-existing material to the universe" and I have already requested that you do not misrepresent my views in that way. You will have seen that request as you quoted it. I will report your posts to the moderators should you continue to tell deliberate untruths about the content of my posts.

Once again, "blindering" is not a word in English other than to refer to steel plates used for a specific purpose (protection from enemy fire). You do not gain credibility by using incorrect words, any more than you do by misrepresenting people. On the contrary, you lose any shred of credibility you had.

I have already said, on more than one occasion, that pre-existing in the context in which you are using it is meaningless. Therefore my answer is no, as it has been throughout both of your threads.

There can be no time before time began. If you are having difficulty grasping this concept, Stephen Hawking's book "A Brief History of Time" may help you, or for an easier read Bill Bryson's "A Short History of Nearly Everything" is an excellent primer.

You can proceed (I wish you would proceed to lay out whatever argument you are trying to present) using your incorrect definitions of the universe and evidence, and your personal definition of the Christian God, but as long as you use incorrect and personal definitions, any conversation will necessarily be halted as people continue to object to your incorrect definitions. It is not a matter of opinion that some imaginary things do not exist and are therefore not part of the universe, it is a matter of fact.

It is now past midnight in my timezone and I am going to bed. I say this so that you are not tempted to accuse me, as you have done in the past, of abandoning the thread.

Your incivility in accusing me and others of having "blindered" minds - perhaps you mean blinkered - is not going unnoticed, and will not go unreported. Try to be civil if you wish to remain a member of this forum.
 
Okay, every good, noted, but not totally and exclusively agreeing to all your implications.

Now as regards universe if you give examples of what everything refers to and at the end say that
"and also everything imaginable and can be the subject of human discourse,"
​
that will be fine.


So Thor, Zeus, and the Flying Spaghetti Monster are imaginable and can be the subject of human discourse, which means they exist.

rAmen!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom