Yahoo Answers: How some astrohysicists fool people with illogic.

Whoa, okay tell me does the universe come forth from nothning, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing?

Answer yes or no.
What if the answer is "I don't know"?

Then what?

Because I have no idea where the universe comes from. And so far as I know, no scientist claims to know.

So I don't see why you are demanding an answer that nobody has... or what you think the lack of an answer proves.
 
yrreg needs attention .... once again

I put this question yesterday in Yahoo Answers:




What I got from people who love to answer questions are mockery, parody, and evasions.


Then this morning earlier I introduced this question:




What happened when I submitted the question?

Here:




Well, that is nothing new with Yahoo Answers, they even deleted my questions already out in the web and for some days open to everyone in the web; on other occasions they deleted my questions right away and when I demanded why they in effect beat about the bush.


The earlier question on equation of universe from nothing, it iwll be deleted from Yahoo Answers eventually.




Yrreg

you just asked an improper question in an Internet venue and come here to exploit it and get more attention.

By the way, let the notion of a pre-existent deity aside and tell us, what is the exact mathematical formula that shows you exist?
 
I was asking you to explain your words: "No. Not nothing and no creator."

Dear Agatha:

I was asking you to explain your words: "No. Not nothing and no creator."

Read the line on enlarged bolded font below.


Originally Posted by yrreg
Whoa, okay tell me does the universe come forth from nothning, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing?

Answer yes or no.


There are three separate assumptions involved in your question, so it is not possible to give a straight yes or no answer. This is because your question is flawed, not because there is anything wrong with the answer.

------------------------

Originally Posted by yrreg

Otherwise you protest too much for nothing but vacuity and vanity, vanity means vacuity.


Firstly, you are being unnecessarily insulting. Given that you have been suspended from here in the past for insulting people, this is not a very wise course for you to take. Secondly, vacuity and vanity are not synonymous. I am neither vacuous nor vain, kindly do not suggest that I am.

-------------------

Originally Posted by yrreg

You say: "If you want an answer, the first thing you need to do is to ask a question in a simple, clear way, without assumptions."


Okay, is this question simple enough for you to answer yes or no?

"Does the universe come forth from nothing, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing, yes or no?"


Did you forget about the bit that said "without assumptions"? You are making an incorrect assumption that there was nothing, and then there was something. This is not what the Big Bang theory says. It is posited that there was energy, compressed into a singularity. Not nothing. Therefore the answer to your question has to be no, that is not how the universe began at t=0; however this does not imply that there is or was any kind of creator.

-------------------

Originally Posted by yrreg

Your answer must be simply yes or no, <snipped redundancy>.


OK, No. Not nothing and no creator.

--------------------------

Originally Posted by yrreg

Otherwise you will be into a lot of nonsense about my intention to be equivocating whatever: all that nonsense useless paraphernalia like the self-dowry of a lowly bride, from your socalled logic 101 where you learn nothing about productive intelligent thinking, but all about everything that a child can know without all the superfluous and thus useless scaffolding of manipulative logic which is no logic but gimmick.


Insults do not win a debate, rather, they show the paucity of your argument. I will refrain from reporting this post; I will not be as generous should you post any further insults to anyone on this board.

__________________

At the going down of the sun and in the morning, we will remember them.

.​
.

​
======================
.

​


Agatha said:
No. Not nothing and no creator.


That is your answer to my question:

Yrreg said:
Okay, is this question simple enough for you to answer yes or no?

"Does the universe come forth from nothing, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing, yes or no?"
.​

.

​

I am asking you to explain your answer: "No. Not nothing and no creator."




Yrreg
 
It's pretty simple. There's no evidence the universe came from nothing, and there's no evidence of a creator.
 
Dear Agatha:

I was asking you to explain your words: "No. Not nothing and no creator."



I am asking you to explain your answer: "No. Not nothing and no creator."




Yrreg

Now this is so less tedious and a more personal, direct engagement. Look at how much Bandwidth is saved here Gerry! It's more concise without the redundancy and rudeness. Progress can be made...
 
In what way do you need clarification of my answer?

You asked "Does the universe come forth from nothing, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing, yes or no?"

And I answered with a no. However, I did not feel that the simple one word answer was sufficient to answer your question fully, as the question has three assumptions inherent in it.

So my expanded answer is "no, the universe did not come from nothing, it is not the case that there was no pre-existing material to the best of our knowledge, and no creator is necessary". Do you need any further explanation of this answer?
 
So,.. God can come from nothing, and God can create the universe from nothing?
Or does God create the universe from God? Or does God create the universe from something that was nothing? Or was there an element to the universe that is eternal? What seems more complicated, an eternal space or an eternal intelligence?


God can do exactly what the human mind can imagine god can do.
 
@ annnnoid




OK.. apart from the stupid and baffling ad hominems, you obviously misunderstand the concept of information.


The point that physicists make when they talk about information is that everything can be seen as informational in nature. All matter exists in the form of specific quantities (or quanta) of matter or energy. Energy causes change but information determines the nature of the change.

However, despite your strident insistence, that does not make it sentient.

A rock can be seen as information, each atom in a specific pattern.

Is a rock sentient?

Is God like a rock?

In which case.... what sort of rock?
Personally, I'm thinking a big dense chunk of concrete.
 
Is this what you are saying: Yes pre-exising material but not God?

In what way do you need clarification of my answer?

You asked "Does the universe come forth from nothing, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing, yes or no?"

And I answered with a no. However, I did not feel that the simple one word answer was sufficient to answer your question fully, as the question has three assumptions inherent in it.

So my expanded answer is "no, the universe did not come from nothing, it is not the case that there was no pre-existing material to the best of our knowledge, and no creator is necessary". Do you need any further explanation of this answer?


you say:

1. "no, the universe did not come from nothing,

2. it is not the case that there was no pre-existing material to the best of our knowledge,

3. and no creator is necessary".

​


Is this what you are saying?

There is a pre-existing material for the coming forth of the universe but it is not a creator who is self-existing.​




Yrreg
 
As far as we can determine with our current state of knowledge, yes. I am not a physicist but that is my understanding.
 
Can we agree to change the word material to the word reality?

As far as we can determine with our current state of knowledge, yes. I am not a physicist but that is my understanding.


This is what you are saying:
There is a pre-existing material for the coming forth of the universe but it is not a creator who is self-existing.​


I like to ask you whether we can change the word material to the word reality, because material precludes everything not material, unless you insist that everything is material in the totality of existence which totality is what I understand as the concept of the universe.




Yrreg
 
Your question makes no sense. Material and reality are not synonymous and cannot be used interchangeably in the sentence as you propose.
 
Ok, seriously, is yrreg some kind of Turing test? He doesn't make enough sense to be a Poe but I could believe he's an AI. I'm not joking, this is a real question.
 
Ok, seriously, is yrreg some kind of Turing test? He doesn't make enough sense to be a Poe but I could believe he's an AI. I'm not joking, this is a real question.
Neither, in my opinion. Yrreg drops in every once in a while and tries to set up what he believes is a clever "sting operation" through which posters replying to his OP will be taken through a "clever" series of yrreg-logic steps to finally admit the existence of God (presumably the Christian God). Generally he quickly gets frustrated when people don't play along, and starts becoming bossy ("answer yes or no"), then insulting. Often his odd use of language further introduces a certain level of confusion, as well as a surreal feel to much of his threads.
 
Neither, in my opinion. Yrreg drops in every once in a while and tries to set up what he believes is a clever "sting operation" through which posters replying to his OP will be taken through a "clever" series of yrreg-logic steps to finally admit the existence of God (presumably the Christian God). Generally he quickly gets frustrated when people don't play along, and starts becoming bossy ("answer yes or no"), then insulting. Often his odd use of language further introduces a certain level of confusion, as well as a surreal feel to much of his threads.
That surreal feel is due to what I think is a sort of self induced dissociation on the part of yrreg to where he is fulfilling some kind of role in his own mind of answering "god like" questions. Similar to what a religious person experiences when they walk into a cathedral and describe the "holy" feel of respect and humility, I think yrreg tries to recreate this for himself on some level so that when you discourse with him, he is responding as though he is separate from you in order to tap into these "truths". I'm wondering if there is a term for this that describes it more succinctly then I'm doing here ... it kind of fascinates me a bit, that "I am holy ... respect my oxygen" trait some people project onto themselves and others.
 
Whoa, okay tell me does the universe come forth from nothning, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing?

Answer yes or no.


Otherwise you protest too much for nothing but vacuity and vanity, vanity means vacuity.


You say: "If you want an answer, the first thing you need to do is to ask a question in a simple, clear way, without assumptions."


Okay, is this question simple enough for you to answer yes or no?

"Does the universe come forth from nothing, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing, yes or no?"​


Your answer must be simply yes or no, I mean either yes or no only, meaning one choice: yes, or the other choice: no.

Otherwise you will be into a lot of nonsense about my intention to be equivocating whatever: all that nonsense useless paraphernalia like the self-dowry of a lowly bride, from your socalled logic 101 where you learn nothing about productive intelligent thinking, but all about everything that a child can know without all the superfluous and thus useless scaffolding of manipulative logic which is no logic but gimmick.




Yrreg
yes or no
 
I thought that you are an adherent of atheist cosmologists of the nothingness school?

Your question makes no sense. Material and reality are not synonymous and cannot be used interchangeably in the sentence as you propose.


You see if you are a subscriber to the worldview of materialism then all existence is material.

Of course you have to ask materialistic scientists and philosophers what is a purely material entity.

Now, as you probably know, it is the traditional worldview of mankind that not all things are material things or beings or entities.

There are also non-material things which do not fall in the concept of material things as understood by materialistic scientists and philosophers.



So, I have to ask you if you are a subscriber to the worldview of materialism.

In my case for being a theist I subscribe to the traditional common worldview of mankind that the universe is more than just composed of material things.



By the way I thought that you are not of the idea that there is something material pre-existing from which the universe comes forth.

Did you say that you are an adherent to atheist cosmologists and astrophysicists who can convince people that the universe came forth from nothing, not any pre-existing material nor any creator Who is self-existing?



Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom