Originally Posted by yrreg
Whoa, okay tell me does the universe come forth from nothning, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing?
Answer yes or no.
There are three separate assumptions involved in your question, so it is not possible to give a straight yes or no answer. This is because your question is flawed, not because there is anything wrong with the answer.
------------------------
Originally Posted by yrreg
Otherwise you protest too much for nothing but vacuity and vanity, vanity means vacuity.
Firstly, you are being unnecessarily insulting. Given that you have been suspended from here in the past for insulting people, this is not a very wise course for you to take. Secondly, vacuity and vanity are not synonymous. I am neither vacuous nor vain, kindly do not suggest that I am.
-------------------
Originally Posted by yrreg
You say: "If you want an answer, the first thing you need to do is to ask a question in a simple, clear way, without assumptions."
Okay, is this question simple enough for you to answer yes or no?
"Does the universe come forth from nothing, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing, yes or no?"
Did you forget about the bit that said "without assumptions"? You are making an incorrect assumption that there was nothing, and then there was something. This is not what the Big Bang theory says. It is posited that there was energy, compressed into a singularity. Not nothing. Therefore the answer to your question has to be no, that is not how the universe began at t=0; however this does not imply that there is or was any kind of creator.
-------------------
Originally Posted by yrreg
Your answer must be simply yes or no, <snipped redundancy>.
OK,
No. Not nothing and no creator.
--------------------------
Originally Posted by yrreg
Otherwise you will be into a lot of nonsense about my intention to be equivocating whatever: all that nonsense useless paraphernalia like the self-dowry of a lowly bride, from your socalled logic 101 where you learn nothing about productive intelligent thinking, but all about everything that a child can know without all the superfluous and thus useless scaffolding of manipulative logic which is no logic but gimmick.
Insults do not win a debate, rather, they show the paucity of your argument. I will refrain from reporting this post; I will not be as generous should you post any further insults to anyone on this board.
__________________
At the going down of the sun and in the morning, we will remember them.
.