Yahoo Answers: How some astrohysicists fool people with illogic.

You see if you are a subscriber to the worldview of materialism then all existence is material.

Of course you have to ask materialistic scientists and philosophers what is a purely material entity.

Now, as you probably know, it is the traditional worldview of mankind that not all things are material things or beings or entities.

There are also non-material things which do not fall in the concept of material things as understood by materialistic scientists and philosophers.

Such as?

So, I have to ask you if you are a subscriber to the worldview of materialism.

Yes.

In my case for being a theist I subscribe to the traditional common worldview of mankind that the universe is more than just composed of material things.

Got anything to back that up?

By the way I thought that you are not of the idea that there is something material pre-existing from which the universe comes forth.

Did you say that you are an adherent to atheist cosmologists and astrophysicists who can convince people that the universe came forth from nothing, not any pre-existing material nor any creator Who is self-existing?

 
You see if you are a subscriber to the worldview of materialism then all existence is material.

A computer program exists, but it is not material. Even from the worldview of materialism, not all existence is necessarily material.

(Of course, computer programs are encoded by means of arrangements of material, but the programs themselves are not the material.)
 
Neither, in my opinion. Yrreg drops in every once in a while and tries to set up what he believes is a clever "sting operation" through which posters replying to his OP will be taken through a "clever" series of yrreg-logic steps to finally admit the existence of God (presumably the Christian God). Generally he quickly gets frustrated when people don't play along, and starts becoming bossy ("answer yes or no"), then insulting. Often his odd use of language further introduces a certain level of confusion, as well as a surreal feel to much of his threads.

Poor Yrreg. He will never get his 'gotcha' moment. We are all far to smart.
 
You see if you are a subscriber to the worldview of materialism then all existence is material.

That is correct.

Of course you have to ask materialistic scientists and philosophers what is a purely material entity.

I don't have to. I already know.

Now, as you probably know, it is the traditional worldview of mankind that not all things are material things or beings or entities.

It was also a traditional world view that the Earth is flat. This does not make it right.

There are also non-material things which do not fall in the concept of material things as understood by materialistic scientists and philosophers.

Not really. There are such things as ideas, various concepts, and math, but all are ultimately bound in the material world, without which they would not only not exist, but they would also not make any sense.

So, I have to ask you if you are a subscriber to the worldview of materialism.

Yes.

In my case for being a theist I subscribe to the traditional common worldview of mankind that the universe is more than just composed of material things.

Yes, we know. You are entitled to your view, but that doesn't make it right.

By the way I thought that you are not of the idea that there is something material pre-existing from which the universe comes forth.

We do not know what was 'before' the universe. In fact, the term 'before' may not make sense, in this context. However, the idea is not that nothing at all led to the universe.

Did you say that you are an adherent to atheist cosmologists and astrophysicists who can convince people that the universe came forth from nothing, not any pre-existing material nor any creator Who is self-existing?

You are now being intentionally obtuse. Cut it out.

Hans
 
Is this what you are saying?

There is a pre-existing material for the coming forth of the universe but it is not a creator who is self-existing.​

Yrreg

It depends what you mean by "pre-existing". With our current knowledge of space and time, it is not meaningful to speak of anything existing "before" the universe. As far as we can tell, there has been a universe as long as there has been time.
 
Did you say that you are an adherent to atheist cosmologists and astrophysicists who can convince people that the universe came forth from nothing, not any pre-existing material nor any creator Who is self-existing?

Yrreg

I don't know of any cosmologist or astrophysicist who claims the universe came forth from nothing.

Why do you assume "nothing" and "creator" are the only two possibilities?
 
God can do exactly what the human mind can imagine god can do.

No it can't. The human mind can only imagine the words that say God can do all that. It can't imagine the actual doing of it. It's totally clueless as to how any of that might actually be done.
 
I've put some thought into this and here are my equations

god + nothing = god + universe

Cancelling on both sides

god + nothing = god + universe

Therefore god is not necessary. Thanks gerry for leading me to this truth
 
Dear Hans, as soon as Agatha has resigned from this thread, please take her place.

Originally Posted by yrreg
You see if you are a subscriber to the worldview of materialism then all existence is material.
​
That is correct.

Quote:
Of course you have to ask materialistic scientists and philosophers what is a purely material entity.
​
I don't have to. I already know.

Quote:
Now, as you probably know, it is the traditional worldview of mankind that not all things are material things or beings or entities.
​
It was also a traditional world view that the Earth is flat. This does not make it right.

Quote:
There are also non-material things which do not fall in the concept of material things as understood by materialistic scientists and philosophers.
​
Not really. There are such things as ideas, various concepts, and math, but all are ultimately bound in the material world, without which they would not only not exist, but they would also not make any sense.

Quote:
So, I have to ask you if you are a subscriber to the worldview of materialism.
​
Yes.

Quote:
In my case for being a theist I subscribe to the traditional common worldview of mankind that the universe is more than just composed of material things.
​
Yes, we know. You are entitled to your view, but that doesn't make it right.

Quote:
By the way I thought that you are not of the idea that there is something material pre-existing from which the universe comes forth.
​
We do not know what was 'before' the universe. In fact, the term 'before' may not make sense, in this context. However, the idea is not that nothing at all led to the universe.

Quote:
Did you say that you are an adherent to atheist cosmologists and astrophysicists who can convince people that the universe came forth from nothing, not any pre-existing material nor any creator Who is self-existing?​
You are now being intentionally obtuse. Cut it out.

Hans



Dear Hans, as soon as Agatha has resigned from this thread, please take her place.


Are you of the worldview what I call that of Hawking, Stenger, and Krauss that the universe came forth from nothing, no pre-existing reality and no creator Who is self-existing?

I call their cosmology the cosmology of nothingness.



Please read the title and the OP of this thread,
How some astrophysicists fool people with illogic.​

About the flat earth idea:
I will just tell you that people thought the earth was flat because at that time they saw the earth with their eyes and it looked flat, so also today if you just look at the earth standing on the earth's surface it will also look flat.

But way way back from the dawn of human conscious reason mankind has already known that the universe is more than just the material universe.


Anyway, wait till Agatha has definitively resigned from this thread, then you can expound on your view of a material exclusively material universe, but then you have to produce what you know to be material the concept of that is.


As regards my intentionally being obtuse, please do not equate ingenuity* with obtuseness, because on that token you are also obtuse in the insistence that you cannot know what comes antecedent to the beginning of the universe.

*Ingenuity: 1. The power of creative imagination (WordWeb free one-click online dictionary)


You see, atheists have chosen to be obtuse when it comes to what is antecedent to the beginning of the universe, but I want to tell you now that for me the universe is the totality of existence, that is bigger than the universe you claim to limit your knowledge to as the only thus prematurely delimited universe accessible to your brain thus self-blindered by yourself.

You notice how you make so much ado about the chronological before, another instant of your self-blindering of your brain; the very enticing thing is how your psychology dictates or you psychologically dictate your worldview and your delimited repertory of concepts.


Lastly, I want you to think of what it is that makes sense to you, since you give so much importance to that word and concept sense.

While you are at it, also think what is meaning and what is meaningless, this word meaningless is also very much used err abused by atheists in their writing, that is their way of saying anathema sit.

But you be different, think of what is sense which you bring in all the time to declare something to not make sense, and also meaning, as to declare something to be meaningless when you prefer not to think about it.




Yrreg
 
Are you of the worldview what I call that of Hawking, Stenger, and Krauss that the universe came forth from nothing, no pre-existing reality and no creator Who is self-existing?


Yrreg

Please provide evidence that any of those people claim that the universe came forth from nothing.
 
Are you of the worldview what I call that of Hawking, Stenger, and Krauss that the universe came forth from nothing, no pre-existing reality and no creator Who is self-existing?

I call their cosmology the cosmology of nothingness.
You can call your mistaken ideas of what those scientist believe whatever you want, your epithets have no bearing on reality.

You are misrepresenting the views of the scientists you mention. It is not the worldview of Hawking, Stenger or Krauss that the universe came from nothing. Rather, it is their view that as far back in time as we can study at our current levels of knowledge, there was an immense amount of something (energy) compressed into a singularity.

It is not the worldview of those scientists that there was no pre-existing material, but not for the reason you seem to be hinting at. Time began at the big bang, so pre-existing in this context is meaningless. There is no time before time, just as there is no south of the south pole.

By the way, pre-existing material is what you originally proposed and it has not gone unnoticed that you have substituted reality into your phrase.

No divine creator has ever been shown to exist, nor is one necessary for science's model of the universe.

By trying to shoehorn your misapprehensions into your question you render it both meaningless and unanswerable, unless it is unpacked into the three separate assumptions and each one addressed separately.

You cannot win a debate with this style of argument; it should have become obvious to you a long time ago that you cannot use sophistry to lead people to agree with a position which they do not hold. Repeating yourself and misrepresenting others does not improve your argument any more than insults do.
 
Last edited:
By the way, Yrreg, if I don't post in a thread for a few hours does not mean I have abandoned it. I am not online 24/7 as I have other responsibilities, and I do not live in the same time zone as you. It is extremely rude of you to suggest that I, or X, MRC_Hans, or indeed any other poster has to post to some timetable of yours or else be accused of resigning from the thread. You are not in charge of who posts to any thread, nor when, nor how often.
 
I've put some thought into this and here are my equations

god + nothing = god + universe

Cancelling on both sides

god + nothing = god + universe

Therefore god is not necessary. Thanks gerry for leading me to this truth

:thumbsup:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom