Yahoo Answers: How some astrohysicists fool people with illogic.

Whoa, okay tell me does the universe come forth from nothning, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing?

Answer yes or no.

Otherwise you protest too much for nothing but vacuity and vanity, vanity means vacuity.

You say: "If you want an answer, the first thing you need to do is to ask a question in a simple, clear way, without assumptions."

Okay, is this question simple enough for you to answer yes or no?

"Does the universe come forth from nothing, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing, yes or no?"​

Your answer must be simply yes or no, I mean either yes or no only, meaning one choice: yes, or the other choice: no.

Otherwise you will be into a lot of nonsense about my intention to be equivocating whatever: all that nonsense useless paraphernalia like the self-dowry of a lowly bride, from your socalled logic 101 where you learn nothing about productive intelligent thinking, but all about everything that a child can know without all the superfluous and thus useless scaffolding of manipulative logic which is no logic but gimmick.

Your red scarf matches your eyes.
You closed your cover before striking.
Father has the pipefitter blues.
Loving you has made me bananas.

You burned your finger that evening
While my back was turned.
I asked the waiter for iodine,
But I dined all alone.

ALL TOGETHER NOW:

Your red scarf matches your eyes.
You closed your cover before striking.
Father has the pipefitter blues.
Loving you has made me bananas.

Oh, yeah - and what's an "astrohysicist"?
 
What I got from people who love to answer questions are mockery, parody, and evasions.

What I get from you is the lack of personal debate in the spirited sense. The frequent repeating yourself, tediously rambling opinions and failing to engage people directly. Quite evasive.
 
What I get from you is the lack of personal debate in the spirited sense. The frequent repeating yourself, tediously rambling opinions and failing to engage people directly. Quite evasive.

Kind of sounds like a crazy person doesn't it?
 
What color is the sky? Answer only yes or no. Define "sky" as that which is not earth or spleen, but is beyond and within itself. Explain the strong force in forty words or less; don't use words with an "e" in them. Provide an equation that proves your work, but don't use terms that a 4th grader would not understand. Ha- I knew you couldn't answer my simple question! I laugh at you and notice how clever I myself am.
 
@ annnnoid


Interesting that you should bring this up Mr. Degraves. In another thread not too long ago the reviled Randman presented smackdown evidence that particles are, in fact, informational in nature and that their physical form is, in fact, a derived state…not the fundamental one. The assembled skeptics jumped all over poor Randman...until he revealed that the evidence in question was the result of well documented work done by some of the most highly respected quantum physicists currently working in the field. I'd offer links but doubtless you evidence-starved skeptics already know all about it.

Of course, who knows what in blue blazes this actually means…. except that ‘informational’ is typically associated with information processing…which by the most mind-boggling of coincidences is associated with things that process information…like us. Intelligence it’s called. Intelligence on that kind of scale might reasonably be referred to by applying the most incomprehensible metaphor of all: GOD.

…all nonsense of course…please continue with your endless dismissal of anything remotely resembling evidence of intelligence / sentience in our universe (including you).

OK.. apart from the stupid and baffling ad hominems, you obviously misunderstand the concept of information.


The point that physicists make when they talk about information is that everything can be seen as informational in nature. All matter exists in the form of specific quantities (or quanta) of matter or energy. Energy causes change but information determines the nature of the change.

However, despite your strident insistence, that does not make it sentient.

A rock can be seen as information, each atom in a specific pattern.

Is a rock sentient?

Is God like a rock?

In which case.... what sort of rock?
 
What color is the sky? Answer only yes or no. Define "sky" as that which is not earth or spleen, but is beyond and within itself. Explain the strong force in forty words or less; don't use words with an "e" in them. Provide an equation that proves your work, but don't use terms that a 4th grader would not understand. Ha- I knew you couldn't answer my simple question! I laugh at you and notice how clever I myself am.

You forgot "therefore God!"
 
So,.. God can come from nothing, and God can create the universe from nothing?
Or does God create the universe from God? Or does God create the universe from something that was nothing? Or was there an element to the universe that is eternal? What seems more complicated, an eternal space or an eternal intelligence?
 
Whoa, okay tell me does the universe come forth from nothning, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing?

If your creator can be self-existing, why can't the Universe?
 
"Does the universe come forth from nothing, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing, yes or no?"

Your answer must be simply yes or no, I mean either yes or no only, meaning one choice: yes, or the other choice: no.

Kind of a tall order, since you ask three questions, two of which are partly exclusive, and one having a non-binary answer.


But you know that, I suppose.

Hans
 
Whoa, okay tell me does the universe come forth from nothning, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing?
...



Yrreg

There is no reason to believe that there was ever a state of nothing existing. Either you have something or you don't. Adding a god to the mix doesn't change that one way or the other.

Your self-existing creator would have to exist. Did this creator come from nothing? Is the creator nothing? ( I personally think the creator is nothing :p )
 
yrreg said:
Like for example you are teaching cooking, specifically how to prepare beef stew:

1. Obtain the following ingredients:

---- 3 lbs boneless chuck roast, cut into 2-inch pieces
---- 3 tbsp vegetable oil
---- 2 tsp salt
---- 1 tbsp freshly ground pepper
---- 2 yellow onions, cut into 1-inch chunks
---- 1/4 cup flour
---- 3 cloves garlic, minced
---- 1 cup red wine
---- 3 cups beef broth
---- 1/2 tsp dried rosemary
---- 1 bay leaf
---- 1/2 tsp dried thyme
---- 4 carrots, peeled, cut into 1-inch slices
---- 2 stalks celery, cut into 1-inch slices
---- 3 large russet potatoes, peeled and cut in eighths
---- fresh parsley to garnish (optional)

2. On medium-high heat, add the vegetable oil to a large heavy pot (one that has a tight fitting lid).

3. When it begins to smoke slightly, add the beef and brown very well. Do in batches if necessary. Add the salt and pepper as the beef browns.

4. Once browned, remove the beef with a slotted spoon set aside.

5. Add the onions and sauté for about 5 minutes, until softened.

6. Reduce heat to medium-low, and add the flour and cook for 2 minutes stirring often.

7. Add the garlic and cook for 1 minute.

8. Add wine and deglaze the pan, scraping any brown bits stuck to the bottom of the pan. The flour will start to thicken the wine as it comes to a simmer.

9. Simmer wine for 5 minutes, and then add the broth, bay leaves, thyme, rosemary, and the beef.

10. Bring back to a gentle simmer, cover and cook on very low for about 1 hour.

11. Add potatoes, carrots, and celery, and simmer covered for another 30 minutes or until the meat and vegetables are tender. Taste and adjust seasoning.

12. Turn off heat and let sit for 15 minutes before serving. Garnish with the fresh parsley if desired.

13. Voila, here is your beef stew ready for the dining table.



Yrreg

I wouldn't use dried rosemary. Cook your roast on a charcoal grill and toss a couple of sprigs of fresh rosemary on the coals. Cook to desired doneness and then cut into cubes.

I would also sweat the celery with the onions. Celery takes longer to cook.
 
I wouldn't use dried rosemary. Cook your roast on a charcoal grill and toss a couple of sprigs of fresh rosemary on the coals. Cook to desired doneness and then cut into cubes.

I would also sweat the celery with the onions. Celery takes longer to cook.

Cook the roast til done on the grill? That sort of negates the whole purpose of stew, which is to cook the meat til done, slow, in the wet, so the gelatin dissolves into the stew.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom