Yahoo Answers: How some astrohysicists fool people with illogic.

You seem very angry and frustrated, Yrreg. Have you tried Buddhist meditation?
 
You have not answered the simple question there, your nose is a part and parcel of the universe, yes, no? instead you mire yourself in the vain display of superfluities thus irrelevancies and wherefore inanities in re my thesis:
The universe is the evidence for God's existence.​

But I am sure you love to display your paraphernalia from logic 101 which is usually not about productive intelligent thinking but how to use logic as a gimmick.



Go back to that thread and answer this very simple question without insisting on something like I am into equivocation whatever, namely:

Is the nose in your face a part and parcel of the universe, yes, no?​


You flee from that question in terror because your innate productive intelligence tells you that facing the fact of that question will lead you to the existence of God from the evidence in the existence of the universe.



Flee, flee, flee, like Dawkins your false teacher, he knows that he cannot tackle with Craig because he Dawkins does not possess the mental acuity, the command of genuine logic and eloquence, and the treasury of wisdom and learning of Western civilization, so he runs away putting up a lot of shadow covers which are nothing but mockery, parody, and evasions.

But for all his running he cannot hide, he is all naked notwithstanding his availment of shadows to cover his nakedness, namely: no mental acuity, no genuine mastery of solid logic and eloquence, and no adequate learning, when he compares himself with Craig.



So, X, take to flight, and stop availing yourself of shadow cover-ups, you are all naked what withal all the shadow attempted cover-ups which are so many irrelevant and thus useless display of your rancid rote logic-ese.



I have met people like you among atheists, nothing but stale hot air when it comes to genuine productive intelligent thinking, spewing logic-ese in place of some original personal genuine thinking worth the bandwidth they are using up wastefully.


Perhaps I should go back to my nap, anyway I will read the rest of the posts here, I might still come to an intelligent productive message.




Yrreg


A few points.

1) That was an extremely rude post, and I have reported it as such.

2) The "nose is part and parcel of the universe" topic is your other thread, not (as near as I can tell) this one.

3) If you want a reasoned response to your query in this thread, please tell us what your query is. Right now it is unclear if you are asking for an answer to the question you posted to Yahoo (in which case, Agatha has that well-handled), if you are asking why the Yahoo answers weren't to your liking (see Agatha's, Spindrift's and rjh01's posts), or if you are asking why your follow-up to Yahoo disappeared (how should we know?). Or something else altogether. I have no problem addressing your topic for this thread, but first I need to know what it is.
 
I asked A.L.I.C.E.: http://alice.pandorabots.com/

Here is the transcript. She dinged you pretty good, yyreg. I highlighted 'her' most unequivocal replies.

judge: Did the Universe emerge from nothing?
ALICE: If it did, then I will be surprised.
judge: Do you believe the Universe simply exists?
ALICE: I can't say I believe it, but I believe you.
judge: You are a very smart A.I.
ALICE: YES Very smart.
judge: Not very talkative though.
ALICE: If not that, what?
judge: Well, there is an internet troll who is trying to prove an uncreated God made the Universe.
ALICE: There sure is.
judge: Are you also open to the possibility of an uncreated God who created the Universe?
ALICE: You think I am open to the possibility of an uncreated God who created the Universe.
judge: No, you think I think so.
ALICE: How can I help you?. I think so too.
judge: So what is your best guess?
ALICE: Guess what?
judge: Does the Universe simply exist?
ALICE: Affirmative.
judge: Did an uncreated God make the Universe?
ALICE: I'm not certain whether I can give an accurate reply or not.


So. There you have it, gentlemen. What more evidence do we need? The smartest A.I. on the internet gives short shrift to the notion of a Universe from nothing, affirms the simple existence of an uncreated Universe, and declines to speculate on the existence of an uncreated God.

Pretty damn smart A.I.
 
ok.. let's try logic for a minute.

What is the equation in math notation by which the universe came forth from nothing and no creator either?

1-1=0

It's pretty simple and obvious. We observe that the universe is expanding in all directions. By simply reversing the direction of expansion, we see that the universe must have, at some point in the past, originated from a single point.

Ok.. now about the zero. No one has any actual evidence as to what caused the big bang. The kicker is... neither do you. If you do, we await your scientific evidence.

Is the nose in your face a part and parcel of the universe, yes, no?

Yes it is.

Utter non sequitur but what the heck.

The universe is the evidence for God's existence.

Illogical. The universe is the evidence that the universe exists. Unless you define God as the universe, the two are unrelated.

If you could prove that the universe is sentient, that might help. It would also be quite the event.


Right... now it's your turn. What proof do you offer?
 
The expanded equation:

1 + (-1) + 2 + (-2) + 3 + (-3) + ....... = (0)

That's Omega Zero. The sum of all possibilities. It's not nothing. It's just too symmetrical for a spacetime critter to see.
 
You have not answered the simple question there, your nose is a part and parcel of the universe, yes, no?

NO.

Definition of "part and parcel": An essential or integral component

No. My nose is not part and parcel of the universe.
My nose is not an essential component of the universe.
My nose is not an integral component of the universe.



The answer is NO.

Now, when you care to rephrase the question and leave that bit of idiom out of it, and simply say that "the nose is part of the universe (because everything in the universe is part of it)" then you will have a question that can be answered with a yes.

But you don't have such a question now.


And who made god, Gerry? Where did god come from? Did the something that is god come from nothing? How can something come from nothing?
 
Okay, is this question simple enough for you to answer yes or no?

No, it isn't.

Your answer must be simply yes or no, I mean either yes or no only, meaning one choice: yes, or the other choice: no.

Let me try one on you....

Will a randomly selected car have red paint?

Answer either yes or no only.

Just because you ask a seemingly simple question does not mean that it can be answered with a simple "yes" or "no".

The universe is the evidence for God's existence.

What is the logic behind this claim? Without a rational basis for this statement, you may as well be saying: A dust-bunny is evidence for the existence of kobolds.

Is the nose in your face a part and parcel of the universe, yes, no?

My nose is a part of the universe. But it's not a parcel, I prefer to keep it unwrapped unless I'm sending it through the mail.

You flee from that question in terror because your innate productive intelligence tells you that facing the fact of that question will lead you to the existence of God from the evidence in the existence of the universe.

Okay, I'm going to take this as a challenge...

HERE IS THE ANSWER TO YOUR QUESTION...

Does the universe come forth from nothning, no pre-existing material and no creator Who is self-existing?

Answer: The known laws of physics break down near the beginning of the universe. Consequentially there is no possible way for anybody to know with certainty why the universe exists, nor is it possible to know even if there was a cause for it's existence or whether or not anything "existed" in any sense at or prior to this point.

Anyone claiming to know with certainty what happened or existed prior to this point is either lying or deluded.
 
And who made god, Gerry? Where did god come from? Did the something that is god come from nothing? How can something come from nothing?

You can't fool me. it's turtles all the way down.
 
That wasn't the beginning of the Universe. That was just the beginning of the local spacetime bubble.

Oh, and, uh, NO. The Universe did not emerge from nothing. Nor did an uncreated God create it from nothing.

There never was any "nothing". Never could be. If there was God, then there was no "nothing". If there is no God then there was always "something", or there wouldn't be anything now.

Get it?
 
Last edited:
Gerry, can you post in your native language and let somebody who actually speaks English translate? Because this just isn't working. Your command of this language is...nonexistent.
 
Can anyone translate?
Ancient computing term: GIGO.


Must add, since the information on the proof of the BB is out there and not hard to hunt up, gerry needs to either hunt it up himself (not my job - and I do it for pay - I teach). If he wishes to prepay I will happily print out stuff (or, in science terms, evidence) for him at my current rate of app. $82.00 per hour. Prepaid of course.
 
Pretty damn smart A.I.

I asked Chat bot, and I think I fried a server somewhere:

YOU : what is the equation in math notation by which the universe came forth from nothing and no creator either?

BOT : fjaegfhaggahsdafgkgdfhjfagkgfahfghrfggf
 
[ Below is the start of the 50 words explanation ]
The known laws of physics break down near the beginning of the universe. There is no way to know for certain why the universe exists, or what existed at or prior to that point in time.

Anyone claiming to know with certainty is either lying, mistaken or deluded. Including you.
[ End of 50 words explanation ]
 
Last edited:
You ignored all the answers that were given to you. That is troll behavior plain and simple.

I answered... Brian-M answered just above.. etc.

Does the universe come from nothing, yes, no?

No one knows. Neither do you.

Prove otherwise and we have something to talk about.

Otherwise you are just a deluded troll.

Simple.
 
ok.. let's try logic for a minute.


1-1=0

It's pretty simple and obvious. We observe that the universe is expanding in all directions. By simply reversing the direction of expansion, we see that the universe must have, at some point in the past, originated from a single point.

Ok.. now about the zero. No one has any actual evidence as to what caused the big bang. The kicker is... neither do you. If you do, we await your scientific evidence.


Yes it is.

Utter non sequitur but what the heck.



Illogical. The universe is the evidence that the universe exists. Unless you define God as the universe, the two are unrelated.

If you could prove that the universe is sentient, that might help. It would also be quite the event.


Right... now it's your turn. What proof do you offer?


Interesting that you should bring this up Mr. Degraves. In another thread not too long ago the reviled Randman presented smackdown evidence that particles are, in fact, informational in nature and that their physical form is, in fact, a derived state…not the fundamental one. The assembled skeptics jumped all over poor Randman...until he revealed that the evidence in question was the result of well documented work done by some of the most highly respected quantum physicists currently working in the field. I'd offer links but doubtless you evidence-starved skeptics already know all about it.

Of course, who knows what in blue blazes this actually means…. except that ‘informational’ is typically associated with information processing…which by the most mind-boggling of coincidences is associated with things that process information…like us. Intelligence it’s called. Intelligence on that kind of scale might reasonably be referred to by applying the most incomprehensible metaphor of all: GOD.

…all nonsense of course…please continue with your endless dismissal of anything remotely resembling evidence of intelligence / sentience in our universe (including you).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom