...
Here's my very elementary understanding of the chemistry of the thermitic reaction: aluminum plus iron oxide, when heated, becomes aluminum oxide plus iron. That generates heat in the 4500 degree F range. I'm saying this off the top of my head to show my current level of understanding or lack thereof; anyone is free to correct me if I am wrong about this.
...
Almost correct, one thing formally wrong.
What you write there, formally, is (I add the numbers before the chemical signs to indicate that you need a stoichiometric mix):
Fe2O3 + 2 Al -> Al2O3 + 2 Fe + 4500 °F
The green part is correct, the red part is wrong. Correct is:
Fe2O3 + 2 Al -> Al2O3 + 2 Fe - 847.6 kJ/mol[1]
)
The difference is that an exotherm reaction results in a defined amount of
heat - that is: energy that flows out. Heat and eneregy are measured in Joules (J). What's measured in °F or °C or K is
temperature. Temperature is an
intensive property, whereas heat is an extensive property. In effect, this means that a given amount of thermite, when reacting, releases a defined amount of heat, but does not create a defined temperature due to it interacting with its environment.
If the thermite were a closed system, and all its heat were fed into the reaction products, none escaped, not even as radiation, and if the pressure remained steady, then one could calculate the temperature it reaches. The other day did a rough
[2] calculation and found that the mix would reach the boiling point of iron at 5182 °F, and a small part of the iron would vaporize (boil off and turn to gas), while the Al oxide remained liquid.
However, this is mere theory. In practice, heat is immediately lost to radiation and in contact with surrounding material through conduction and convection, and the amount of loss would depend on several factors, including geometry, speed of reaction, properties of surrounding material etc.
If you have pure thermite, not mixed with nothing, and allow it to react very fast and manage to keep the reaction products concentrated, then you'll may see an increase of temperature to the 4,500 °F you cite; I'd say that is as high as the temperature gets - for pure thermite.
BUT! Harrit e.al. claim and speculate that we are dealing with some kind of "superthermite", where thermite only constitutes a minority constituent, and most of the stuff is an organic polymer. So as the thermite reaction releases heat, a significant part of that heat would be sucked up by the organic matrix; first by increasing its temperature; then by decomposing and vaporizing it.
I have shown in my blog post
Too little thermite to blow up Mark Basile's chip that <5% thermite in >80% epoxy matrix would result in a temperature increase of less than 400 K (720 °F), and that this little thermite could only vaporize a small portion of the matrix! (This still holds true for 2.4% Al + 7.5% iron oxide + 71.5% epoxy - which is the best estimate for chips a-d).
Another easy way to show how temperature is not fixed:
Supposed you had 1 pound of thermite mixed with 9 pounds of iron and Al2O3, the reaction products of thermite. These 9 pounds would not react any further to anything, they are inert in this scenario. After the heat release of the thermite reaction, which would increase the temperature of the 1 pound of thermite alone y 4,500 °F, the heat actually is distributed over the entire 10 pounds, and consequently, temperature would rise only by (approximately) 1/10th that much, or 450 °F.
Conclusion:
To prove a thermite reaction occurred, measuring temperature directly or indirectly can give you hints at most, it's never conclusive.
The real way is to prove you have Fe
2O
3 + 2 Al
before the reaction (relative quantities are important!), and Al
2O
3 + 2 Fe
after the reaction (and again, relative quantities would be really nice to have!)
Measuring heat flow can give you additional information and help to corroborate whatever you find, but is not strictly necessary.
---------------
Footnotes:
[1] "mol" refers to the amount of metal oxide: 1 mol of iron oxide plus 2 mol of Al result in -847.6 kJ. The negative sign means that energy flows out of the system.
[2] I assumed the
heat capacity of the products to be constant with temperature. It isn't; it tends to increase slightly with temperature. It is possible that, with the correct development of heat capacity considered, the mix would not quite reach the boiling point of iron. Also, I disregard that elemental Al has a boiling point of 4,566 °F, so that any scenario where nit all of the Al reacts at the precise same instant, that would further constrain the temperature reached.