WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

Beachnut, Gage sent me to JREF while we were preparing for our debate as a source of information for me and definitely did NOT blow me off. I believe in his sincerity but not in his conclusions. I have a job to complete here and I will carry it through at least to the Millette paper and its aftermath if he follows through on his intention to publish. It's a strange hobby I know...
 
Last edited:
You know, JTL, I just might do this. If I can find someone who would agree to look at the Bentham paper, the Millette preliminary report, and some kind of summary of what Jones, Harrit and other signatories have publicly said in response to Millette (I believe Harrit called Millette's study fraudulent or something if I am not mistaken, does anyone have such a quote?)... I'll be very interested to know what a chemist with no prior experience looking at this issue will say. My honest prediction is that it will be similar to the responses I get when I contacted all the physicists and architects, or for that matter all mainstream scientists like Jonathan Barnett who have been quote-mined to appear to support the 9/11 CD theories (dozens of them, all negative in their opinion of this theory). Maybe a chemistry grad student would do this for a classroom exercise?
If you are going to do this then you can also use a materials engineer/scientist, however, you are not going to get far when 9/11 conspiracy or thermite is mentioned; not many will waste their time with that nonsense. Remember we are familiar with it and some what immune to how crazy this is.

You would be far better off stripping out the data from Harrit et al and presenting that along with just the data from Millette so that there is no bias either way.

You could send all the results and papers and quotes and whatnot to 10,000 scientists and if those 10,000 said, "It's nonsense, the material is paint", that still wouldn't convince jtl, MM, Senenmut and all the other truthers, nothing can.
 
Beachnut, Gage sent me to JREF while we were preparing for our debate as a source of information for me and definitely did NOT blow me off. I believe in his sincerity but not in his conclusions. I have a job to complete here and I will carry it through at least to the Millette paper and its aftermath if he follows through on his intention to publish. It's a strange hobby I know...
Does Gage know he is spreading lies to make money?

Millette's paper will take time to publish, it works that way for real papers. Jones took a short cut, and his peer review is fellow nuts on 911. Millette's paper might not be published, if it does not meet guidelines for the journal, even if the paper is sound.

It is not a strange hobby. Learning about things is not strange.
Learning how to avoid being fooled by fake prophets like Gage is a good thing; how do you help the fooled avoid being fooled, or help them recover from being fooled? The struggle to stop ignorance.
 
Does Gage know he is spreading lies to make money?

Millette's paper will take time to publish, it works that way for real papers. Jones took a short cut, and his peer review is fellow nuts on 911. Millette's paper might not be published, if it does not meet guidelines for the journal, even if the paper is sound.

It is not a strange hobby. Learning about things is not strange.
Learning how to avoid being fooled by fake prophets like Gage is a good thing; how do you help the fooled avoid being fooled, or help them recover from being fooled? The struggle to stop ignorance.
Beachnut you have "Nut" in your name so of course my hobby doesn't seem strange! Most of my friends think it's so idiotic they don't even want to hear about it any more. I've learned a lot, and it is important to me that people don't get sold by Gage's very compelling presentation. Now, if they want to know more after being impressed by Gage's claims, as soon as they look up Gage and controlled demolition they can find my YouTubes, JREF, Gravy, Skeptic, Skeptical Inquirer, etc. So yes we are doing a service in this and many other realms. But no, Gage is not a fraud, I am 100% convinced of his sincerity, and I disagree with him 100% when it comes to his technical claims of CD.
 
If you are going to do this then you can also use a materials engineer/scientist, however, you are not going to get far when 9/11 conspiracy or thermite is mentioned; not many will waste their time with that nonsense. Remember we are familiar with it and some what immune to how crazy this is.

You would be far better off stripping out the data from Harrit et al and presenting that along with just the data from Millette so that there is no bias either way.

You could send all the results and papers and quotes and whatnot to 10,000 scientists and if those 10,000 said, "It's nonsense, the material is paint", that still wouldn't convince jtl, MM, Senenmut and all the other truthers, nothing can.
JTL, what do you think of Sunstealer's strategy, to strip out the WTC and 9/11 stuff from both studies, give it to a chemist or chemistry grad student and ask their opinion? My original idea was to give a chemist 1) the Bentham paper 2) the Millette preliminary study 3) direct public quotes of the critiques in response to the Millette study from Harrit, Jones and other Bentham signatories... with no further comment. Sunstealer's idea would completely strip out the bias in favor of or against any 9/11 theories. JTL if I do this what would you predict the result to be? Do you think Sunstealer is right when he says nothing could convince you?
 
Mohr:I think I am responding to what you are saying. You are ignoring my main point, which is that Jones et al are withholding valuable data and the chips themselves and this is central to the discussion.

You actually ignored almost everything I said, including the part about not repeating accusations from your buddies here about Jones et al hiding "valuable data". You don´t know it, but you are actually accusing them of fraud, and in the end your buddies here could get you in real trouble. Again, you have admitted yourself that you don´t understand the chemistry so the only thing you have to base your accusations on is the hogwash by your very unreliable buddies.

but the fact that massive amounts of aluminum oxide are not found there is no problem. Correct me if I am wrong, but I just see an experiment where Jones et al are trying to fit the data to a preordained theory, .

The no aluminum oxide is just another one of those claims your buddies make, but as I have gone over here before, none of them have ever actually published any of their big claims, and that is because they can´t do it. It is all just hot air my friend, and it is about time you realize it.

As I said before, I actually went to see Harrit lecture and I chatted to a chemist there, who actually had done some work with normal thermite on his own, and you really should try to see what real discussions look like compared to the hogwash seen here. One of the things I learned from this is that the reduced iron spheres are the main thing after ignition, some of them may also have aluminum oxide but some DO NOT.

and there are many ways that there is no fit without resorting to the "supersecret formula" hypothesis

No, It does not matter if the material is 90% secret matrix material and 10% thermite. No matter what the matrix material consists of, be it paint or explosive material, the final product is still called a thermitic material if it goes through the thermite reaction process, which is the iron reduction!
Which means any paper having the hypothesis of "active thermitic material" will have to test to see if the material goes through this reduction after ignition. This means checking for iron oxide before ignition and molten iron after ignition.

I never did find chemists to talk with successfully, I admit.

You also admit not understanding the chemistry but still you make a video dedicated to debunking Harrit et al. You have made a mistake relying on this forum an this is why I am asking you to talk to a chemist that is actually independent, and start with the basics, i.e. the thermite reduction.

For what it's worth, it was Richard Gage who suggested I join JREF.

I suppose he did this because this is the best known or loudest debunking forum, and as such that is fine because he really had to point out what debunkers say about his presentations. I was also told to check out this forum, but I was also given a warning about the content. I thought it would be better than going to some truther forums because they might be biased, and maybe they are, but that does not change the fact that the state of this forum is appalling.

My original idea was to give a chemist 1) the Bentham paper 2) the Millette preliminary study 3) direct public quotes of the critiques in response to the Millette study from Harrit, Jones and other Bentham signatories..

Start by understanding the chemistry of thermite, the reduction, so you can evaluate what Harrit et al say in their paper. Then you expand your goals.

Do you think Sunstealer is right when he says nothing could convince you?

He is one of your buddies that like to say a lot of things, and one of those that has for some reason never published any of his authoritative rants which are supposed to debunk Harrit et al.

Once you have talked to your chemist, you will realize that the only way to refute Harrit et al is to find those chips and repeat the tests. If you think those spheres actually do not contain pure iron or reduced iron or that none of them show aluminum oxide, have someone do the tests and prove it.

This is what would convince me and everyone else. This is how science actually works, not hot air hogwash by the Sunstealers of this world.
 
But if only one or two did not have them, nothing in that statement would be wrong, because it does not say "all", only "numerous microspheres" and "some were iron-rich"

?? what....did you really read the paper?
i really think you are grasping at straws....
 
He is one of your buddies that like to say a lot of things, and one of those that has for some reason never published any of his authoritative rants which are supposed to debunk Harrit et al.
I think I can address this part. There are many reasons why someone qualified to do so would not seek to publish their criticisms of the Harrit et al paper.

First, the most likely format of a response is a letter or discussion note. In a letter, one could lay out the flaws in method and briefly show that the data does not support the conclusion. Unfortunately, this type of response will generally only be published in the same journal as the original paper. In this case that is Bentham Open Chemical Physics Journal. To publish here, one finds:

PUBLICATION FEES:

Letters: The publication fee for each published Letter article submitted is US $600.

Research Articles: The publication fee for each published Research article is US $800.

Mini-Review Articles: The publication fee for each published Mini-Review article is US $600.

Review Articles: The publication fee for each published Review article is US $900.

Book Reviews: The open access fee for a published book review is US $450.

Once the paper is accepted for publication, the author will receive by email an electronic invoice. The fee form is also available on the Web site at www.benthamscience.com/open/feeform

So a letter is certainly not worth the fee, since the original study is only known to some truthers and debunkers. From the debunker perspective, refuting it is mostly a curiosity, a matter of putting the trillionth nail in the coffin of 9/11 truth. "Publishing" on JREF is perfectly adequate for that.

The other option is to carry out a new experiment that may have potential for publication in real journal. This is also expensive, but potentially more interesting because there is room to learn something. If nothing else, one can learn some of what is in the dust.

However, Millette is already doing this. Members in this thread have contributed to the study, if only indirectly, by giving suggestions to Chris Mohr who forwards them to Millette.

So there would be no point in undertaking yet another independent study of this matter at this point.

So there you go. Now you will be able to streamline your posts, since you don't have to reference the lack of publishing every time. You're welcome.
 
JTL said, "You actually ignored almost everything I said, including the part about not repeating accusations from your buddies here about Jones et al hiding "valuable data". You don´t know it, but you are actually accusing them of fraud, and in the end your buddies here could get you in real trouble."

Are you saying I'm in danger of being sued for saying that Jones et al are withholding data? Is this your response to my deep concern that both data and samples of their chips are being withheld? Seriously, thank you for the warning, I won't accuse them of fraud.
 
Mohr: Are you saying I'm in danger of being sued for saying that Jones et al are withholding data? Is this your response to my deep concern that both data and samples of their chips are being withheld? Seriously, thank you for the warning, I won't accuse them of fraud.

"Thank you" accepted. Your "deep concern" is based on a false rumor from your buddies. This will become pretty clear once you start to learn about the thermite reduction process, and this is one of the reasons I am urging you to talk to an independent chemist. Your anonymous buddies like to accuse Harrit et al but they won´t do it using their real names for a reason. It is convenient for them to have your name as a front. I don´t know if Harrit et al would sue you for some comments on this forum, they will never read them here anyway, but things might be different if you were to publish something in say, a newspaper.

Another reason for you not indulge in their rumors is the ethical side, you got very angry with Kevin Ryan, so it would look really bad if you start spreading rumors about Harrit et al. Also, Ryan based his accusation on a documented claim by a named scientist but you do not have that luxury. Be careful, especially considering the kind of buddies you have here.
 
Last edited:
Lol
Listen to jtl !

Anyway, I came across the below clip. Of course it only focuses on Harrit and you can't see any of the information on the screen behind him, which of course is the " Evidence "

This is what jtl has been sucked in by.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9F3xMOoPoYk&feature=youtube

I wonder when jtl will stop hiding behind his initials :D

I wonder what Jones & Co would think of jtl as their representative.
 
Last edited:
"Thank you" accepted. Your "deep concern" is based on a false rumor from your buddies. This will become pretty clear once you start to learn about the thermite reduction process, and this is one of the reasons I am urging you to talk to an independent chemist. Your anonymous buddies like to accuse Harrit et al but they won´t do it using their real names for a reason. It is convenient for them to have your name as a front. I don´t know if Harrit et al would sue you for some comments on this forum, they will never read them here anyway, but things might be different if you were to publish something in say, a newspaper.

Another reason for you not indulge in their rumors is the ethical side, you got very angry with Kevin Ryan, so it would look really bad if you start spreading rumors about Harrit et al. Also, Ryan based his accusation on a documented claim by a named scientist but you do not have that luxury. Be careful, especially considering the kind of buddies you have here.

Harrit lied, he said thermite was used on 911. Tons of it. Nothing was found.
Jones lied, he said thermite was used on 911. He thinks, in the ceiling tiles sounds good.

You can't figure out what a DSC is, and that Jones and Harrit are spreading lies about 911. Thermite in the ceiling tiles? lol

Millette did not find thermite. No steel has thermite damage. Are you a closet thermite Jones drank the kool aid truther? Why be covert? Why hide your claims? Not very honest. Are you being honest? No
 
From the debunker perspective, refuting it is mostly a curiosity, a matter of putting the trillionth nail in the coffin of 9/11 truth. "Publishing" on JREF is perfectly adequate for that.

It doesn't seem to be, since this debate has continued on for over three years, mostly kept alive by bedunkers themselves, with their endless ponderings over paint chips. If bedunkers really felt confident that they've refuted a paper that they also claim has a tiny and insignificant audience, they would surely have tired of this a long time ago. That doesn't seem to be the case.
 
"Thank you" accepted. Your "deep concern" is based on a false rumor from your buddies. This will become pretty clear once you start to learn about the thermite reduction process, and this is one of the reasons I am urging you to talk to an independent chemist. Your anonymous buddies like to accuse Harrit et al but they won´t do it using their real names for a reason. It is convenient for them to have your name as a front. I don´t know if Harrit et al would sue you for some comments on this forum, they will never read them here anyway, but things might be different if you were to publish something in say, a newspaper.

Another reason for you not indulge in their rumors is the ethical side, you got very angry with Kevin Ryan, so it would look really bad if you start spreading rumors about Harrit et al. Also, Ryan based his accusation on a documented claim by a named scientist but you do not have that luxury. Be careful, especially considering the kind of buddies you have here.
OK to both things JTL. And by the way, it's not just my "buddies" here that triggered my deep concern about Jones et al. I truly went on a search for an independent investigation of the WTC chips and found James Millette. This is because I knew all along that I could not independently analyze the validity of the Bentham paper. It was an honest attempt to get someone knowledgeable to weigh in on the question. My search process was met with hostility by Kevin Ryan, and though I could have done better in the process, when I asked Kevin Ryan for the chips he wrote a scathing attack on his blog against both me and Millette. That attack turned out to be untrue; Millette and his lab were actually praised by Cate Jenkins, not complained against. The shroud of suspicion of scientific fraud Ryan tried to put on Millette used another scientist to back him up, all right, except that further research showed that scientist said the opposite of what Ryan implied.

So I have firsthand experience, got my nose bloodied, as it were, no goading from my "buddies" here needed, and still Jones is withholding data and chips. I'd still like to know what you think of Jones's failure to release experimental data he has said he has, and his repeated refusal to share chips he considers thermitic to other experimenters (and not just Millette I might add).

You are right that I am angry at Ryan; he knows how much I admired his intelligence, sincerity and how much I enjoyed our shared love of classical guitar etc. Our respectful disagreement degenerated into what feels like a betrayal to me. So I will be careful not to speak out of anger in anything I say, for the sake of journalistic integrity as well as legal self-protection.

Here's my very elementary understanding of the chemistry of the thermitic reaction: aluminum plus iron oxide, when heated, becomes aluminum oxide plus iron. That generates heat in the 4500 degree F range. I'm saying this off the top of my head to show my current level of understanding or lack thereof; anyone is free to correct me if I am wrong about this.

In the meantime, what do you think of Jones's withholding of data and chips? So far all you have said is that I may get in deep trouble for talking about it. I appreciate the warning, as I have said, but I'd still like to hear a real answer to this question. Also, since I may well go ahead and find a truly independent chemist at one of the local universities, what would you have me ask? Do you like Sunstealer's idea (a version of the Bentham paper and Millette preliminary study stripped of WTC and 9/11 references only), my idea (give them links to the full studies plus a simple summary of Jones's Harrit's and other public feedback from the Bentham signatories), or do you suggest another approach?
 
...
Here's my very elementary understanding of the chemistry of the thermitic reaction: aluminum plus iron oxide, when heated, becomes aluminum oxide plus iron. That generates heat in the 4500 degree F range. I'm saying this off the top of my head to show my current level of understanding or lack thereof; anyone is free to correct me if I am wrong about this.
...
Almost correct, one thing formally wrong.

What you write there, formally, is (I add the numbers before the chemical signs to indicate that you need a stoichiometric mix):

Fe2O3 + 2 Al -> Al2O3 + 2 Fe + 4500 °F​
The green part is correct, the red part is wrong. Correct is:
Fe2O3 + 2 Al -> Al2O3 + 2 Fe - 847.6 kJ/mol[1]​
)
The difference is that an exotherm reaction results in a defined amount of heat - that is: energy that flows out. Heat and eneregy are measured in Joules (J). What's measured in °F or °C or K is temperature. Temperature is an intensive property, whereas heat is an extensive property. In effect, this means that a given amount of thermite, when reacting, releases a defined amount of heat, but does not create a defined temperature due to it interacting with its environment.

If the thermite were a closed system, and all its heat were fed into the reaction products, none escaped, not even as radiation, and if the pressure remained steady, then one could calculate the temperature it reaches. The other day did a rough[2] calculation and found that the mix would reach the boiling point of iron at 5182 °F, and a small part of the iron would vaporize (boil off and turn to gas), while the Al oxide remained liquid.

However, this is mere theory. In practice, heat is immediately lost to radiation and in contact with surrounding material through conduction and convection, and the amount of loss would depend on several factors, including geometry, speed of reaction, properties of surrounding material etc.

If you have pure thermite, not mixed with nothing, and allow it to react very fast and manage to keep the reaction products concentrated, then you'll may see an increase of temperature to the 4,500 °F you cite; I'd say that is as high as the temperature gets - for pure thermite.

BUT! Harrit e.al. claim and speculate that we are dealing with some kind of "superthermite", where thermite only constitutes a minority constituent, and most of the stuff is an organic polymer. So as the thermite reaction releases heat, a significant part of that heat would be sucked up by the organic matrix; first by increasing its temperature; then by decomposing and vaporizing it.
I have shown in my blog post Too little thermite to blow up Mark Basile's chip that <5% thermite in >80% epoxy matrix would result in a temperature increase of less than 400 K (720 °F), and that this little thermite could only vaporize a small portion of the matrix! (This still holds true for 2.4% Al + 7.5% iron oxide + 71.5% epoxy - which is the best estimate for chips a-d).


Another easy way to show how temperature is not fixed:
Supposed you had 1 pound of thermite mixed with 9 pounds of iron and Al2O3, the reaction products of thermite. These 9 pounds would not react any further to anything, they are inert in this scenario. After the heat release of the thermite reaction, which would increase the temperature of the 1 pound of thermite alone y 4,500 °F, the heat actually is distributed over the entire 10 pounds, and consequently, temperature would rise only by (approximately) 1/10th that much, or 450 °F.


Conclusion:
To prove a thermite reaction occurred, measuring temperature directly or indirectly can give you hints at most, it's never conclusive.
The real way is to prove you have Fe2O3 + 2 Al before the reaction (relative quantities are important!), and Al2O3 + 2 Fe after the reaction (and again, relative quantities would be really nice to have!)
Measuring heat flow can give you additional information and help to corroborate whatever you find, but is not strictly necessary.


---------------
Footnotes:
[1] "mol" refers to the amount of metal oxide: 1 mol of iron oxide plus 2 mol of Al result in -847.6 kJ. The negative sign means that energy flows out of the system.
[2] I assumed the heat capacity of the products to be constant with temperature. It isn't; it tends to increase slightly with temperature. It is possible that, with the correct development of heat capacity considered, the mix would not quite reach the boiling point of iron. Also, I disregard that elemental Al has a boiling point of 4,566 °F, so that any scenario where nit all of the Al reacts at the precise same instant, that would further constrain the temperature reached.
 
JTL do you agree with the basic clarification given to me by Oystein? How about the part about the mix of thermite of some kind with organic polymers to create the secret materials Harrit et al claim to have found? What in his explanation do you disagree with?
 
Here is the email I have composed:

If you would be kind enough to answer a couple quick questions, I would be grateful.

1. Were chips labeled “a” through “d” on page 10 of the Bentham paper put through the resistivity test mentioned on page 27 and described under section 7 “Could the Red Chip Material be Ordinary Paint?”
2. After the initial isolation of chips using the criteria described on page 9, under section 2 “Chip Size, Isolation, and Examination”, were those chips that met this criteria further separated into paint chips and thermitic chips based on the resistivity test describe in point 1 above, and then put through further tests?
3. On page 27, under section 7 “Could the Red Chip Material be Ordinary Paint?”, it states the following:

“Given the small size of the red chip, about 0.5 mm x 0.5 mm, we used two probes and obtained a rough value of approximately 10 ohm-m. This is several orders of magnitude less than paint coatings we found tabulated which are typically over 10 10 ohm-m [31].”

Does the first sentence, “Given the small size of the red chip”, indicate that you only tested one chip for resistivity in order to determine if it was some form of paint?

Thank you for your time.

I have sent this email to:

Steven Jones
Niels Harrit
Kevin Ryan

Niels has yet to respond. I just got the following response from Kevin.

For questions on this article, please see the corresponding authors as listed in the paper.

Address correspondence to these authors (NH) Department of Chemistry,
University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, DK-2100, Denmark;
Tel: (+45)35321846; Fax: (+45)35320460; E-mail: [email protected],
(SEJ) at S&J Scientific Co., Provo, UT, 84606, USA; Tel: 801-735-5885;
E-mail: [email protected]

There is also good information within the NIST WTC reports, describing the characteristics of WTC paint.

Good luck, Kevin Ryan

I have gotten a response from Steven, but am trying to get further clarification as he didn't really answer the questions.
 
In the other thread, on the Harrit and Jones paper, I just documented what Harrit said at the Toronto Hearings:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=8979933#post8979933

The interesting points for this thread are:

1. "They" have a large amount (5 gallons?!) of dust from a new donation

2. Harrit confirms that chip isolation has only 2 stepsselected - and of course doesn't mention any step after
i.) magnet
ii.) visual inspection

6. Harrit thinks their DSC curve is narrower than Tillotson's
(This is of course silly - but it goes to counter our trolls' assertion that the curves are essentially of the same width.)

Quite predictably, Ryan and Jones evaded Gamolon's question.
 
The real test for a thermite reaction is verifying iron reduction as I described in previous post, and I suggested you go and talk to a truly independent chemist about this.
That is false.

The real test for a thermite reaction is that both byproducts of the thermite reaction are present.

Tillotson and Gash did that. You know it. They showed that the aluminium was in aluminium oxide form, and that the iron was in elemental form.

That is the real test, not the one you're making up.

To quote again from Tillotson and Gash:

To verify that the reaction observed in Figs. 2 and 3 was indeed the thermite reaction the solid products from the DSC analysis reaction were analyzed using PXRD. The pattern of these products is shown in Fig. 4. The major constituents identified were metallic Fe and Al2O3, which are the expected products if the thermite reaction had occurred.
​
Observe that they don't look for the iron only. They don't look at EDX spectra.

I suggest you go and talk to a truly independent chemist about this.
 
My original idea was to give a chemist 1) the Bentham paper 2) the Millette preliminary study 3) direct public quotes of the critiques in response to the Millette study from Harrit, Jones and other Bentham signatories... with no further comment.
Without a critique of the Bentham paper in the equation, that doesn't seem like a balanced playfield. Some of Sunstealer's posts highlight the problems in the paper in a way that a competent chemist could evaluate without being dragged by rhethoric or by assumptions of competence on the part of the authors.

Just saying in case you finally decide to follow this path.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom