WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

Mohr: In the meantime, what do you think of Jones's withholding of data and chips? So far all you have said is that I may get in deep trouble for talking about it. I appreciate the warning, as I have said, but I'd still like to hear a real answer to this question.

I did not warn you about "talking about" missing data or chips. Jones giving out chips is a non issue until someone has published a paper and there is disagreement about the chips.

I warned you about parroting the suggestion from your friends that Jones cherry picked useless data to fit his conclusion and that he hid the "real data" that would prove him wrong. Talking about the "missing data" in this way is actually accusing him of fraud. This is what your anonymous buddies are doing and they have managed to get you to use your name for it.

So if you are actually so angry at Ryan maybe you should start to think about your relationship with your buddies here and this forum in general.

Also, since I may well go ahead and find a truly independent chemist at one of the local universities, what would you have me ask?

Pretty much what I discussed in previous posts here, learn about the reduction process aka the thermite reaction, i.e. the iron oxide before ignition and the molten iron after igntion. Your goal is to understand Harrit´s presentation of the data and if it makes sense.

Do you like Sunstealer's idea (a version of the Bentham paper and Millette preliminary study stripped of WTC and 9/11 references only), my idea (give them links to the full studies plus a simple summary of Jones's Harrit's and other public feedback from the Bentham signatories), or do you suggest another approach?

It is a good idea to present papers stripped of 9/11 and WTC references, but do this in a few steps. Start with the Bentham paper pages 14 to 21, and add figures 23 to 27. This would be plenty of material for your first meeting with that chemist. The rest of the Bentham paper, Millette´s paper and comments from truthers and Jones et al should follow in other meetings.

JTL do you agree with the basic clarification given to me by Oystein? How about the part about the mix of thermite of some kind with organic polymers to create the secret materials Harrit et al claim to have found? What in his explanation do you disagree with?

His basic explanation for basic thermite is mostly correct, but in reality the proportions of al and iron oxide do not always follow the textbook ratio. And as i mentioned before, even though aluminum oxide is an expected product of ignition along with iron, the al is not always found in the iron spheres, and certainly not in some set proportion. If you look at the figures in the paper, you will see that aluminum was sometimes present in Harrit´s iron spheres.

The part about the matrix is incorrect, it assumes that it is some inert material that would swallow up all the energy from the thermite embedded in it, but in reality the authors suggest the matrix is also energetic and that it does the opposite, adding energy and explosive power to those ingredients.

It is not really accurate to call this energetic matrix design a "secret material", since the basic design comes from US government labs. The problem Harrit et al have is that there is no one single energetic matrix material, there could be hundreds of different variants, and fully identifying the composition may not be as easy as some think.
 
Does anyone else find it interesting that jtl's posts suggest that everyone should take his advice. Yet he has not listened to a word anyone has said.

Who could be hiding behind the initials jtl ?

Could it be jolly truther lover ?
 
Spanx: according to his short profile on 911Blogger,
jtl is from West Virginia and he is an "Old Right Conservative, Constitutionalist, States' Rightist, 911 Truth Activist".

No need to take him seriously, since this guy is able to claim e.g.:
"No matter what the matrix material consists of, be it paint or explosive material, the final product is still called a thermitic material if it goes through the thermite reaction process, which is the iron reduction! "

Hehe:D This guy basically claims that any reduction of iron oxide must thermitic!!! He probably has not acknowledged yet that e.g. iron oxide reduction by organic stuffs has been employed for the production of iron for many thousands years by mankind;)
 
Last edited:
Pretty much what I discussed in previous posts here, learn about the reduction process aka the thermite reaction, i.e. the iron oxide before ignition and the molten iron after igntion. Your goal is to understand Harrit´s presentation of the data and if it makes sense.

All the world's irony meters just exploded.

His basic explanation for basic thermite is mostly correct, but in reality the proportions of al and iron oxide do not always follow the textbook ratio.

Correct! Since nanometer-sized aluminum loses a considerable proportion of its mass to oxidation even when in the volumetrically efficient shape of a sphere, producing surface alumina, additional aluminum must be added to maximize iron production.

This means that the energy density of "nano" thermite will be less than that of standard thermite. Also, that more alumina should be in the reaction product. So where is it?

Platelets are about the worst shape possible for aluminum, if one wishes to minimize oxidation loss. But Harrit and Jones claim to have found aluminum metal platelets. But this would mean that even more aluminum would have to be added, lowering energy density yet more, and meaning that even more alumina would be found as product. So where is it?

And as i mentioned before, even though aluminum oxide is an expected product of ignition along with iron, the al is not always found in the iron spheres, and certainly not in some set proportion.

No, alumina is not an "expected" product, it is a necessary product. No alumina in the product means no thermite, just as no metallic aluminum in the reactant means no thermite. Alumina is produced in a set proportion to iron, 48 parts by mass alumina to 52 parts by mass iron. Since alumina is about half the density or iron, alumina will be about twice the amount by volume.

You'd know these things if you had an understanding of basic chemistry. Really, son, you should take my advice and enroll in freshman chemistry at a community college. Maybe you'll go on to a degree, and look back at what a simpleton you once were. Don't worry, four years from now trutherism will still be here, and still be going nowhere. It's undergoing an asymptotic decline but hasn't hit minimum yet. It's minimum will be somewhere below JFK conspiracism but above hollow earth notions (probably on the same level as birtherism), though it really deserves much lower.

It's late. I'll let someone else deal with the rest of your nonsense.
 
Last edited:
... It is not really accurate to call this energetic matrix design a "secret material", since the basic design comes from US government labs. ...

LOL, thermite was used on 911 from US government labs? lol

Fantasy arrives out of gullibility.

Millette found no thermite in WTC. With the fact no thermite damage was found on WTC. And Harrit said 100 tons were used, but never found. There were no products of thermite found on 911.
 
Spanx: according to his short profile on 911Blogger,
jtl is from West Virginia and he is an "Old Right Conservative, Constitutionalist, States' Rightist, 911 Truth Activist".

No need to take him seriously, since this guy is able to claim e.g.:
"No matter what the matrix material consists of, be it paint or explosive material, the final product is still called a thermitic material if it goes through the thermite reaction process, which is the iron reduction! "

Hehe:D This guy basically claims that any reduction of iron oxide must thermitic!!! He probably has not acknowledged yet that e.g. iron oxide reduction by organic stuffs has been employed for the production of iron for many thousands years by mankind;)
Roflmao. He doesn't realise that the thermite reaction is actually a redox reaction, that is one reactant is oxidised and one reactant is reduced. To simply concentrate on iron reduction and forget about aluminium oxidation is stupid.

Tillitson et al show in their paper that a thermite reaction has occurred by using a proper technique to characterise the reaction products, namely iron and alumina. It's interesting to note that truthers scream at Millette for not doing DSC but keep very quite about Harrit not confirming reaction products like Tillitson. Double standards.

According to him any method of iron oxide reduction is a thermitic process which is laughable. This is why it's best to put such ignorant people on ignore. Even children aged 14 who are taught chemistry are taught about redox reactions. What we effectively dealing with is someone who has no education in any scientific subject, no wonder he falls for the Harrit thermite nonsense.

He lied about being a truther in his first post, but he didn't fool anyone.
 
...Jones giving out chips is a non issue until someone has published a paper and there is disagreement about the chips.

I am going to respond to you directly and off the top of my head JTL with no help from my "buddies" to see where I can learn from any mistakes I may be making in my understanding. But this statement above is absurd. Jones refusing to share chips and then publicly complaining that Millette got the wrong chips is a VERY major issue. There is already disagreement between Jones et al and Millette. His preliminary report has plenty of data to analyze.

...learn about the reduction process aka the thermite reaction, i.e. the iron oxide before ignition and the molten iron after igntion. Your goal is to understand Harrit´s presentation of the data and if it makes sense.

I think I know the very basics, which includes my understanding that a real-world scenario of tons of thermite being used on the WTC buildings would have left behind massive blobs of melted iron (by the ton), which were not found.

...It is a good idea to present papers stripped of 9/11 and WTC references, but do this in a few steps. Start with the Bentham paper pages 14 to 21, and add figures 23 to 27. This would be plenty of material for your first meeting with that chemist. The rest of the Bentham paper, Millette´s paper and comments from truthers and Jones et al should follow in other meetings.

I'll check this out.

...His basic explanation for basic thermite is mostly correct, but in reality the proportions of al and iron oxide do not always follow the textbook ratio. And as i mentioned before, even though aluminum oxide is an expected product of ignition along with iron, the al is not always found in the iron spheres, and certainly not in some set proportion. If you look at the figures in the paper, you will see that aluminum was sometimes present in Harrit´s iron spheres.

At my present level of knowledge I cannot respond.

The part about the matrix is incorrect, it assumes that it is some inert material that would swallow up all the energy from the thermite embedded in it, but in reality the authors suggest the matrix is also energetic and that it does the opposite, adding energy and explosive power to those ingredients.

At my present level of knowledge I cannot respond.

It is not really accurate to call this energetic matrix design a "secret material", since the basic design comes from US government labs. The problem Harrit et al have is that there is no one single energetic matrix material, there could be hundreds of different variants, and fully identifying the composition may not be as easy as some think.

It may not be easy, but the burden of proof still rests with them. And they use the word thermite to describe something that does not produce large amounts of melted iron and aluminum oxide as a byproduct. This makes no sense to me.
 
Last edited:
No need to take him seriously, since this guy is able to claim e.g.:
"No matter what the matrix material consists of, be it paint or explosive material, the final product is still called a thermitic material if it goes through the thermite reaction process, which is the iron reduction! "

Hehe:D This guy basically claims that any reduction of iron oxide must thermitic!!! He probably has not acknowledged yet that e.g. iron oxide reduction by organic stuffs has been employed for the production of iron for many thousands years by mankind;)

The thermite reaction doesn't produce that much energy, really - a mere 1 Kcal/g. For its main use, welding, this is inconsequential. Thermite can be used to melt metal not because it generates so much energy overall, but because it doesn't lose its energy to the atmosphere like simple organic combustion, and heat transfer via liquid is much greater than via gas.

Fe2O3 is a poor oxidizing agent. Iron thermite gets its "power" from aluminum being an excellent reducing agent. Other metal oxides such as molybdenum trioxide (MoO3) are much better oxidizers, so a molybdenum trioxide/aluminum thermite has much greater energy density. Harrit, in the Toronto talk referred to by Oystein pointed this out in passing, but never pursued the idea - why didn't the omnicompetent idiot conspirators use molybdenum thermite?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
...
why didn't the omnicompetent idiot conspirators use molybdenum thermite?

That might have an obvious answer:

Finding 2-6 wt% iron in the dust around GZ is far less suspicios than finding that much Mo in the same ;)
 
Originally Posted by Redwood
...
why didn't the omnicompetent idiot conspirators use molybdenum thermite?


That might have an obvious answer:

Finding 2-6 wt% iron in the dust around GZ is far less suspicios than finding that much Mo in the same ;)

With "hundreds of tons" of thermite, there should have been large masses of iron resembling iron-nickle meteorites all about the WTC site. I wonder why Harrit hasn't addressed their absence. :rolleyes:
 
Without a critique of the Bentham paper in the equation, that doesn't seem like a balanced playfield. Some of Sunstealer's posts highlight the problems in the paper in a way that a competent chemist could evaluate without being dragged by rhethoric or by assumptions of competence on the part of the authors.

Just saying in case you finally decide to follow this path.
true. i will keep this in mind.
 
Been thinking about the idea about stripping away all things WTC and 9/11 from the Bentham paper and the Millette preliminary report. I want anyone who is willing to be of help not be fooled into helping me with this without full disclosure of the content of this issue. It's more honest that way. Perhaps a simple way would be to just offer up links to the two papers with no further comment and ask them for an independent opinion based solely on those two papers at first. If they want to go the next step, we can give them a Sunstealer/Oystein critique of Bentham and a Jones/Harrit critique of Millette to look at as the next stage of this.
 
Mohr: That attack turned out to be untrue; Millette and his lab were actually praised by Cate Jenkins, not complained against. The shroud of suspicion of scientific fraud Ryan tried to put on Millette used another scientist to back him up, all right, except that further research showed that scientist said the opposite of what Ryan implied.

You are really saying Ryan lied about this:
Millette’s name shows up in Jenkins’ report four times because he participated in several EPA-funded studies that Jenkins has charged with fraud.

Are you sure you can back up your claim that Ryan is lying? If he is lying don´t you think Millette would sue his ass? Ryan´s claim does not look like he is making up some dirt, he simply mentions that there is an official document out there that charges some studies with fraud, and that Millette was involved.

I looked at the document he refers to but I am too lazy to dig through more than 100 pages to make sure Ryan is telling the truth about Millette being involved in some of those studies. But this document is basically a list of studies that are charged with fraud and if Millette was involved in some then Ryan is quite simply telling the truth.

But if Millette was not involved then you are right about charging Ryan with fraudulent claims. Again with your video in mind and some of the claims you have made about Jones and his data, I suspect you are being a bit careless with your claims.

Again, it seems like a bit of a double standard to get so angry at Ryan for mentioning this charge of fraud when you buddies here can hardly write a post about Jones et al without calling them frauds. And as I said they have gotten you involved in this game of theirs:

I warned you about parroting the suggestion from your friends that Jones cherry picked useless data to fit his conclusion and that he hid the "real data" that would prove him wrong. Talking about the "missing data" in this way is actually accusing him of fraud. This is what your anonymous buddies are doing and they have managed to get you to use your name for it.

So if you are actually so angry at Ryan maybe you should start to think about your relationship with your buddies here and this forum in general.
 
Mohr: But this statement above is absurd. Jones refusing to share chips and then publicly complaining that Millette got the wrong chips is a VERY major issue. There is already disagreement between Jones et al and Millette. His preliminary report has plenty of data to analyze.

No, there is absolutely no obligation to share chips as long as Millette has access to dust, and in fact part of his study is to confirm that the chips are really in the dust. The "major issue" is indeed that Jones has already complained that Millette may not have the same chips, but he also pointed out some procedures from his paper that Millette did not follow, like ignoring the MEK soft vs hard chips. The solution is doing it right next time, not blaming Jones.

I think I know the very basics, which includes my understanding that a real-world scenario of tons of thermite being used on the WTC buildings would have left behind massive blobs of melted iron (by the ton), which were not found.

You don´t want to talk about the iron from the chips no more? Moving goal posts much lately? I am aware of truther claims that there may have been other evidence present, such as molten metal, but I leave that discussion for other people, for now. It´s off topic here anyway.

jtl: there is no one single energetic matrix material, there could be hundreds of different variants, and fully identifying the composition may not be as easy as some think.

Mohr: It may not be easy, but the burden of proof still rests with them. And they use the word thermite to describe something that does not produce large amounts of melted iron and aluminum oxide as a byproduct. This makes no sense to me.

No, it would be interesting to know the exact composition of the matrix but it is not relevant to the question whether or not thermite is ALSO present within the matrix material.

The hypothesis Harrit has is "active thermitic material" so the question the paper answers is "does it go through thermite reaction"?

It does not matter what the matrix is, paint or explosive material, if there is also thermite present that results in thermite reaction, then the final product is still called "thermitic" material.

All that is required to confirm his hypothesis is to confirm thermite reaction. The composition of the matrix has nothing to do with it, although that would be a very interesting topic for another Harrit paper.

As I have said before, the paper does say the byproducts are also there. Those that think those spectra do not show iron and aluminum oxide after ignition, should repeat the tests and prove it. As MM pointed out, this is what you said Millette would do, but he does not deliver, and what´s worse you all try to pretend these tests are not important and also tend to treat those that mention them as hostile.
 
JTL, find out what Cate Jenkins actually said about Millette personally. Her charges of fraud against the EPA notwithstanding, when she specifically mentions Millette or his company MVA Consultants by name, her mentions are either benign or praising of Millette. I am not saying Ryan or Jones are lying or are frauds, and thank you for your reminder not to do so in light of Niels Harrit's recent lawsuit against a journalist. You will find many many posts going back over the past year where I defend the sincerity of belief of Gage, Harrit, Ryan, Jones, etc.
 
Mohr: JTL, find out what Cate Jenkins actually said about Millette personally.

I am not going to dig through some documents to find out what CJ may have said about Millette personally at perhaps different occasions. Ryan does not call Millette a fraud but he says that this complaint names studies that included Millette.

All I need from you is an answer to this simple question:

Does this fraud complaint from CJ include studies featuring Millette?
 
I am not going to dig through some documents to find out what CJ may have said about Millette personally at perhaps different occasions. Ryan does not call Millette a fraud but he says that this complaint names studies that included Millette.

All I need from you is an answer to this simple question:

Does this fraud complaint from CJ include studies featuring Millette?

So what your saying is, your not going to do any research to back up any claims that may or may not have been made and you want Chris to make a public statement.

Isn't it about time you submitted your full name?

You really are a fruitless wonder who has nothing better to do than argue about nothing.

If you have a claim about Millette then produce your evidence.

Oh wait a minute you are a truther and truther = NO EVIDENCE :D

All this talk about sueing. It will certainly bring a platform to start sueing truthers.
 
Jtl, for your convencience, here is a repost of my contribution from another thread:

"Chris: Just for your question "Is Siggi correct in asserting that Cate Jenkins accuses Millette of fraud directly?"

Siggi cited in his e-mails this single sentence from Jenkins complaint on p. 16: "Even this reported pH range of 8.88 to 10 may be erroneous or falsified, due to the probable use of the same fraudulent pre-neutralization analytical techniques employed in the EPA-funded Rutgers team studies, described earlier." (EPA-funded Rutgers team studies are those papers 52 and 65, where Millette participated.)
This is only place in the complaint in which Jenkins directly used the word fraud or fraudulent in some connection with Millette.

But who cares that some Jenkins denoted papers 52 and 65 (pH measurements in them) as fraudulent in one sentence? It's just her problem. She did not bring any proof that some fraud was committed. Once again: the methodology of pH measurements is basically described in the papers (although perhaps not in sufficient detail, and method used is different from EPA Method 9045D), so any fraud is out of question."

If you would like to know more, check also previous posts in this thread (Siggi is one of the truthers who wrote this article)

(Note: Chris quoted several times these sentences from Jenkins petition: “There are 2 credible studies that determined the concentration of concrete in the smallest WTC dust particles, and the concentrations of concrete in the larger particles. Both the Delta Group at the University of California at Davis, and MVA Scientific Consultants, Inc. /company of Jim Millette/ are highly prestigious groups, having received numerous EPA grants for similar studies on fine particulates." So, Jenkins appraised Jim Millette and his company in this quote.)

Now, it is up to you if Kevin Ryan was honest when accusing Chris Mohr to cooperate with Jim Millette as basically "government shill" and fraudster...
 
Last edited:
Are you sure you can back up your claim that Ryan is lying?
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8900481&postcount=488

If he is lying don´t you think Millette would sue his ass?
The real world doesn't work that way. Millette would have to prove actual economical damage if he were to sue Ryan. I might be wrong here, I'm no lawyer. But Ryan has his freedom of speech too and is entitled to airing his opinion as long as he doesn't trespass certain limits.

Ryan´s claim does not look like he is making up some dirt, he simply mentions that there is an official document out there that charges some studies with fraud, and that Millette was involved.
Millette was involved in studies that Jenkins used to reveal the fraud in other studies. Given the timing of Jenkins' references, they actually don't prove any fraud for the one instance where she accuses a study where Millette was involved (which she uses later to reveal possible fraud in others). See link above.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom