WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

No, there is absolutely no obligation to share chips as long as Millette has access to dust, and in fact part of his study is to confirm that the chips are really in the dust. The "major issue" is indeed that Jones has already complained that Millette may not have the same chips, but he also pointed out some procedures from his paper that Millette did not follow, like ignoring the MEK soft vs hard chips. The solution is doing it right next time, not blaming Jones.

I wrote an article a few days ago that covered this specific topic. The reason for the different behaviour of the chips is the different composition of the chips. Millette's aim was to determine, if the chips a - d from the Harrit study contain thermitic material. Therefore Millette used a chip, that had the same EDX signature like the chips a - d. Harrit and Jones used a chip that didn't match these chips. The most probable explanation is that chips a - d consist of Laclede primer paint, while the MEK chip consists of Tnemec primer. Both primers differ in the chemical composition of the pigment and of the filler, so it is very reasonable that these chips show a different behaviour during MEK soaking.

BTW: Millette was not the one, that used the wrong chips, his MEK chip had the same chemical composition than chips a - d from the Harrit paper. Harrit's MEK chip differed in its chemical composition from the chips a -d, so Harrit and Jones were the ones that used the wrong chip!

You don´t want to talk about the iron from the chips no more? Moving goal posts much lately? I am aware of truther claims that there may have been other evidence present, such as molten metal, but I leave that discussion for other people, for now. It´s off topic here anyway.

Harrit made no attempt to exclude the possibility that the microspheres originated in the gray layer.

No, it would be interesting to know the exact composition of the matrix but it is not relevant to the question whether or not thermite is ALSO present within the matrix material.

Millette carried out some experiments (FTIR) that revealed the composition of the matrix - it is epoxy resin.

The hypothesis Harrit has is "active thermitic material" so the question the paper answers is "does it go through thermite reaction"?

No, the paper doesn't answer this question due to lacking experimental data.

It does not matter what the matrix is, paint or explosive material, if there is also thermite present that results in thermite reaction, then the final product is still called "thermitic" material.

There was no (nano)thermite present, Dr. Millette's results prove this without doubt.

All that is required to confirm his hypothesis is to confirm thermite reaction. The composition of the matrix has nothing to do with it, although that would be a very interesting topic for another Harrit paper.

Harrit didn't prove this, he didn't identify elemental aluminum in his chips a - d and he didn't look for aluminumoxide as a product of the thermite reaction.

As I have said before, the paper does say the byproducts are also there.

Please quote the part of Harrit's paper where he "says that aluminum oxide is also there"!

Those that think those spectra do not show iron and aluminum oxide after ignition, should repeat the tests and prove it. As MM pointed out, this is what you said Millette would do, but he does not deliver, and what´s worse you all try to pretend these tests are not important and also tend to treat those that mention them as hostile.

Harrit only recorded EDX spectra from the iron rich microspheres, your claim is obviously wrong!
 
I am not going to dig through some documents to find out what CJ may have said about Millette personally at perhaps different occasions. Ryan does not call Millette a fraud but he says that this complaint names studies that included Millette.

All I need from you is an answer to this simple question:

Does this fraud complaint from CJ include studies featuring Millette?
JTL,

Unlike you, I did read Cate Jenkins's entire complaint (the one referenced by Kevin Ryan) and at first all I could find was a picture of Jim Millette with no explanation as to why that photo was there and no mention of Millette anywhere near the picture. Other people here found four benign references to Millette in the footnotes. It was a long boring slog and I don't blame you for not reading it all.

Someone else also discovered another similar published complaint against the EPA by Cate Jenkins where she mentions Jim Millette and his MVA company by name in the body of the text, praising him: "“There are 2 credible studies that determined the concentration of concrete in the smallest WTC dust particles, and the concentrations of concrete in the larger particles. Both the Delta Group at the University of California at Davis, and MVA Scientific Consultants, Inc. /company of Jim Millette/ are highly prestigious groups, having received numerous EPA grants for similar studies on fine particulates."

Your "simple question" is a trap: "Does this fraud complaint from CJ include studies featuring Millette?" I would have to slog through every word Jenkins wrote yet again, and her writing is not clear. From what I've read her complaints against the EPA are NEVER "featuring" Millette. He's an insignificant bit player in the studies she complains against. If there is a direct accusation of fraud against Millette by Jenkins I have not found it. All I have found is direct praise. Millette is not the focus of Jenkins's complaint; indeed, elsewhere he is the focus of her praise. Kevin Ryan made a misleading ad hominem attack against Millette without actually calling him a fraud. If you're not even reading the Jenkins complaints, I'm not interested in playing your game any more. There's plenty of info here for you to do your own research, and no direct personal accusation against Millette in these Jenkins complaints that I've been able to find.

Early on, I spent well over an hour and looked for complaints against Millette by the 9/11 Truth community and nothing negative came up in my research.
 
Oh really?

Lie much?

MM
Unworthy of response except to clairfy that the hour I spent looking for comploaints against Millette preceded Kevin Ryan coming out with his accusations. I found NOTHING.

And speaking of being irritated with people, JTL please stop putting words in my mouth such as "You are really saying Ryan lied." No, I am saying Ryan wrote a misleading ad hominem attack against Millette. Also I am not accusing Jones of fraud. Stop putting words in my mouth it is extremely irritating.
 
Does anyone have the first idea what this video re Jim Millette and me is about?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v-43u39y1jo
wow, that is kind of scary when you look at the hundreds of other videos this nut does. Can I call him a nut yet?

Harrit and Jones have inspired a neoNAZI who can't write better than I, to do a video. The video in question is his best effort. The Jews did 911, and it says "If you think Israel stinks well they do. Circle gets square."

Ironically it is tagged education, and it is. This is what idiots do when inspired by Dr Jones, Harrit, and Gage. They accept them as their gods spewing anti-government claptrap about thermite, and you become the enemy.

Here you are stuck in the infinity Gish Gallop of Gage who sent you here so he could study your work, and create more trash to fuel his next Gish Gallop paid for by nuts. Gage did take a pay cut do devote his life to lies, he takes in 300 to 400,000 dollars a year, over 1,000,000 dollars so far.

Jones, Harrit fuel Gage's money making machine spreading woo.

The video is the safe side of inspiration from the fraud of Jones, Harrit, and Gage.

You have found a Charlie Manson of video based on the lies of Jones, Harrit, and the repeater of lies, the marketeer of woo, Gage. Your personable buddies across the isle. Will crazy hate inspired videos remain this nuts only action? I hope the implied bad guys that Jones, Harrit, and Gage say planted tons of thermite in the WTC are not hunted by nuts like this. Who will he pick? He seems to be fixated on your and Millette, who can't find thermite in WTC dust.


A song about a kids game on a slide indirectly inspired a nut. Fake thermite paper and lies about 911 directly inspire this nut. You see, the lies spread by Jones and Harrit, and repeated by Gage, imply to the feeble neoNAZI mind, that someone did 911 other than 19 terrorists. Spreading lies about 911 is bad, Gage has no clue? Means he is insane and needs to be seeing a doctor. Anyway, back to the nut who clearly is inspired by lies of thermite, has taken aim at you as the cover-up guys.

That is how I see it, but I am only a pilot, an engineer, an old LC in the KC retired.

http://digwithin.net/2012/02/17/whe...n-response-to-energetic-materials-at-the-wtc/
A link from the video.
The guy is inspired by Kevin Ryan too, who lies about 911.

I would have them remove the video as hate speech, after looking at all the crazy stuff he has. Most likely the only other action this guy will take will look like this.
Photo to add, but photobucket is so slow since they improved their web page, it might be days...

standup.jpg

wow, took forever to get to the photo

The guy seems to be off a little.
With Kevin Ryan spreading the lie...
Three years ago, an international team of scientists published a scientific paper that established the presence of thermitic residues in the dust from the World Trade Center
You and Millette become the liars to the 911 nuts, pushing NWO propaganda to their delusional minds. You can't win with nuts like Harrit, Jones, Ryan, and Gage. It is like these guys are the cult leaders.
 
Last edited:
Mohr: Your "simple question" is a trap: "Does this fraud complaint from CJ include studies featuring Millette?"

Kevin Ryan: Millette’s name shows up in Jenkins’ report four times because he participated in several EPA-funded studies that Jenkins has charged with fraud.

Mohr: From what I've read her complaints against the EPA are NEVER "featuring" Millette. He's an insignificant bit player in the studies she complains against. If there is a direct accusation of fraud against Millette by Jenkins I have not found it.

Kminek: But who cares that some Jenkins denoted papers 52 and 65 (pH measurements in them) as fraudulent in one sentence?

A trap question Mohr? Really? I simply asked if Ryan is telling the truth that Millette was involved in some of those studies charged with fraud, and Kminek has confirmed that Ryan told the truth. I don´t know what you are thinking, but you can not make this untrue by saying that Millette was only an "insignificant bit player" in those studies.

Mohr: please stop putting words in my mouth such as "You are really saying Ryan lied." No, I am saying Ryan wrote a misleading ad hominem attack against Millette.

There is nothing misleading about Ryan´s claim, he says CJ charged some studies with fraud that included Millette as an author, and this is true. You have no reason to be so angry at Ryan because of this.

He could have been less cynical about the way he presented your effort, but the simple fact is, you made some mistakes that opened the door.
 
A trap question Mohr? Really? I simply asked if Ryan is telling the truth that Millette was involved in some of those studies charged with fraud, and Kminek has confirmed that Ryan told the truth. I don´t know what you are thinking, but you can not make this untrue by saying that Millette was only an "insignificant bit player" in those studies.



There is nothing misleading about Ryan´s claim, he says CJ charged some studies with fraud that included Millette as an author, and this is true. You have no reason to be so angry at Ryan because of this.

He could have been less cynical about the way he presented your effort, but the simple fact is, you made some mistakes that opened the door.

Great post jtl,

Would you care to explain the point of it :confused:

My guess is that you are showing how truthers like to try and make something out of nothing. ;)
 
Chris: Since you are well known as extremely polite, cautious and impartial debater, you can perhaps write some additional note below Ryan's article When Mohr is Less.
Perhaps in a sense: "It happened that I overlooked that the word ´fraudulent´ was really used by CJ in one sentence in her complaint, in respect to two studies in which Jim Millette participated as one of many authors." Or something like that? It's up to you. I can potentially add some technical details, why the word "fraud" or "fraudulent" was inappropriate in that context.


Oystein and others interested: and now from silly accusations and paranoid articles of K. Ryan back to Millette study itself::cool:

In my very long contribution here, I tried to analyze XEDS results with the aim to sort red/gray chips basically into two main groups: Laclede and Tnemec chips.

Although it is impossible to make such sorting unambiguous, there are still some helpful "markers" in the spectra.

As I wrote in that post, one is an "Al/Si marker":
In all Laclede chips, Al and Si XEDS peaks should be of similar height (Al peak slightly lower); and in all Tnemec chips, Si peak should be substantially higher than Al peak (since Si-containing pigments prevailed over Al pigment in this paint).

Looking again at the XEDS spectra of the surfaces of red layers, I would say that there is also potentially another such a marker:
In Laclede chips, carbon peaks should be substantially higher than in Tnemec chips, since XEDS of Tnemec recorded by S. Jones showed carbon and oxygen peaks of the similar height (therefore this primer paint very probably contained less of polymer binder than Laclede primer).
Note: we can consider XEDS of Bentham chips (a) to (d), with their high ratio C/O, as very good spectra of Laclede primer, since they are in perfect agreement with the XEDS spectra of Laclede paint simulated by Almond and Oystein.
Another note: carbon/organic compounds are probably not the frequent surface contaminants of chips of steel red primer not covered with some finishing paint, e.g. Tnemec primer or Laclede one (contrary to calcium stuffs!), therefore carbon peak should be similar for unwashed, washed and freshly cut chips.

I'm fully aware of Almonds' warning that especially C and O peaks cannot be taken quantitatively; still, I think that "C/O" marker may help us, especially "in tandem" with "Al/Si marker"..

Here are screenshots of Millette XEDS spectra taken on red layer surfaces (not on cross-sections of the chips, since in that case, all spectra nicely correspond to Laclede primer):

picture.php


picture.php


picture.php


Look at these images.
I would basically say that wherever the C/O marker is low (C peak roughly equal or lower than O peak), Al/Si marker is also low (Al peak is much lower than Si peak), indicating Tnemec. And, wherever C/O marker is high (C peak much higher than O peak), Al/Si marker is also higher (Al peak roughly equal to Si peak), indicating Laclede.
E.g., all chips in the first figure correspond better to Tnemec, whereas most of the chips in the third figure correspond better to Laclede. The second image shows some mixture of both...

Indeed, I do not consider these findings as anything else than speculation now, and "C/O marker" does not look as reliable one; but I simply like to play with available data:cool:

(Additional remark: provided that all chips with low C/O and Al/Si markers are really Tnemec, then they are perhaps not so rare in the dust samples and their abundance is perhaps similar to that of Laclede chips. In that case, one basic question would arise again: why Millette found only kaolinite and epoxy resin - corresponding to Laclede primer, but not to Tnemec - in all his chips analyzed not by XEDS, but by other methods?)
 
Last edited:
Ivan I took your advice above and submitted an acknowledgement to Kevin Ryan's "When More is Less" Post. I added the fact that Cate Jenkins also spoke highly of Millette and his lab in another complaint she wrote against the EPA. We'll see if it gets posted.
 
A trap question Mohr? Really? I simply asked if Ryan is telling the truth that Millette was involved in some of those studies charged with fraud, and Kminek has confirmed that Ryan told the truth. I don´t know what you are thinking, but you can not make this untrue by saying that Millette was only an "insignificant bit player" in those studies.

Mohr: Your "simple question" is a trap: "Does this fraud complaint from CJ include studies featuring Millette?"

Kevin Ryan: Millette’s name shows up in Jenkins’ report four times because he participated in several EPA-funded studies that Jenkins has charged with fraud.

Mohr: From what I've read her complaints against the EPA are NEVER "featuring" Millette. He's an insignificant bit player in the studies she complains against. If there is a direct accusation of fraud against Millette by Jenkins I have not found it.

Kminek: But who cares that some Jenkins denoted papers 52 and 65 (pH measurements in them) as fraudulent in one sentence?

There is nothing misleading about Ryan´s claim, he says CJ charged some studies with fraud that included Millette as an author, and this is true. You have no reason to be so angry at Ryan because of this.

He could have been less cynical about the way he presented your effort, but the simple fact is, you made some mistakes that opened the door.

Since Jenkins never accused Millette of dishonesty, or even mentioned him, it shows that Ryan himself is completely dishonest. He's telling a half-truth, which is even more dishonest than a lie. Your defense of Ryan shows that either you are easily bamboozled or are also dishonest with yourself and with others.
 
I just asked the following question on two chemistry blogs. We'll see if anyone answers or if I get kicked off for asking:

In 2009 a study was released asserting that thermitic materials were found in the dust of the World Trade Center debris after 9/11: http://www.benthamscience.com/open/...J.htm?TOCPJ/2009/00000002/00000001/7TOCPJ.SGM. A followup study in 2012 said that the WTC dust does not have thermitic materials in it: http://dl.dropbox.com/u/64959841/9119ProgressReport022912_rev1_030112webHiRes.pdf. Did the original or followup study use proper protocol to conclude the presence or absence of thermitic material? Can you offer an objective analysis of these two studies from a purely scientific perspective?
 
Chris: OK. let's wait if your post will be published in Ryan's blog. Contrary to truthers, we have absolutely nothing to hide or to avoid;)

Concerning your question put on two chemistry blogs... why not?
But some relatively quick look at both studies can be hardly comparable to our thorough research on this topic. Remember e.g. that unlike any non-informed chemist (I mean non-informed as for 911 conspiracies), we found very good candidate for the materials of chips (a) to (d) from Bentham paper etc. But it does not mean that opinions of other chemists could not bring some new info or some fresh look on that "matter".

By usual googling, I've found that your question has appeared e.g. on Yahoo Answers . Is that one of the places you considered as "chemistry blog"? As I know, some of the answers there are really good ones, some others are "questionable" or simply bad ones:cool:

Jtl wrote here: "I had an opportunity to see a lecture by Harrit, I did see his university lecture in a hall full of chemists and professors. The paper was taken seriously and you should try some time to see what real scientific discussions are about, instead of the hogwash seen on this forum."
Apparently, even the "hall full of chemists and professors" is not good enough for assessing such a paper in sufficient detail in a short time during and after the lecture; moreover, some crucial facts can be simply overlooked even by Nobel prize winners.
E.g.: I doubt that in the lecture, Harrit accompanied his image of DSC heating by the time scale (given by heating rate), which would clearly show that the burning of these tiny chips was very slow in fact! Remember that even you have been (or you still are:rolleyes:) fooled by the impudent lie that there was some "rapid release of energy". And not all chemists necessarily know that heating rate in DSC device is usually quite low...
(But I can be easily wrong in this regard and perhaps this important topic was discussed after the lecture...)
 
Last edited:
Chris: OK. let's wait if your post will be published in Ryan's blog. Contrary to truthers, we have absolutely nothing to hide or to avoid;)

Concerning your question put on two chemistry blogs... why not?
But some relatively quick look at both studies can be hardly comparable to our thorough research on this topic. Remember e.g. that unlike any non-informed chemist (I mean non-informed as for 911 conspiracies), we found very good candidate for the materials of chips (a) to (d) from Bentham paper etc. But it does not mean that opinions of other chemists could not bring some new info or some fresh look on that "matter".

By usual googling, I've found that your question has appeared e.g. on Yahoo Answers . Is that one of the places you considered as "chemistry blog"? As I know, some of the answers there are really good ones, some others are "questionable" or simply bad ones:cool:

Jtl wrote here: "I had an opportunity to see a lecture by Harrit, I did see his university lecture in a hall full of chemists and professors. The paper was taken seriously and you should try some time to see what real scientific discussions are about, instead of the hogwash seen on this forum."
Apparently, even the "hall full of chemists and professors" is not good enough for assessing such a paper in sufficient detail in a short time during and after the lecture; moreover, some crucial facts can be simply overlooked even by Nobel prize winners.
E.g.: I doubt that in the lecture, Harrit accompanied his image of DSC heating by the time scale (given by heating rate), which would clearly show that the burning of these tiny chips was very slow in fact! Remember that even you have been (or you still are:rolleyes:) fooled by the impudent lie that there was some "rapid release of energy". And not all chemists necessarily know that heating rate in DSC device is usually quite low...
(But I can be easily wrong in this regard and perhaps this important topic was discussed after the lecture...)
Hi Ivan,
Yes yahoo is one of them and I know mediocre or even bad answers can be given to questions there. But if I can find a chemist who generally knows what to look for and how to look for an unknown compound like thermite, he/she may just give a fresh, unbiased opinion on which study was properly conducted in the search for thermitic materials: Harrit et al or Millette? For example, I know music theory well and could tell you quickly which music student did a better job of voicing their musical parts. I may not know all the ins and outs of the two voicing exercises in question but I could quickly identify parallel fifths and other errors in musical grammar if a piece had them. Maybe a chemist can just look at the two studies and say whether a DSC test can identify thermite, for example, or whether the FTIR etc Millette used was a better indicator. No new information from such a person, just a fresh look. In my pre-JREF days, as you know, I talked to 14 physicists and countless other scientists personally and was on various physics chat rooms, and I got consistent responses supporting natural collapse from the ones who answered my questions. Wish I could ask 14 chemists who are not familiar with the 9/11 battles a series of questions about the chemistry of the WTC dust to see if I could get similar perspectives. Hopefully I can get at least two or three from these chat rooms.
 
Mohr: Maybe a chemist can just look at the two studies and say whether a DSC test can identify thermite, for example, or whether the FTIR etc Millette used was a better indicator.

Why don´t you go to a chemist? Asking questions on a forum risks the same ole answers from both sides of the argument, and I suggested you talk to a chemist one to one for your benefit of getting into the nuts and bolts of thermite reaction so you could start to make your own judgements about the tests done in Bentham paper. Again, the DSC is not really used to "identify" the thermite, it is mostly used for ignition tests along with the XEDS to compare the ingredients before and after ignition, to check for iron reduction.
There is no response to Harrit without repeating this test and checking the content of the spheres after ignition.
 
the DSC is not really used to "identify" the thermite.

Thanks.
You are correct.

That's why no competent researcher will repeat it to verify or falsify the presence of thermite.

I am glad you finally got it.
 
jtl: it is mostly used for ignition tests along with the XEDS to compare the ingredients before and after ignition, to check for iron reduction.
Oystein:
That's why no competent researcher will repeat it to verify or falsify the presence of thermite.

I am glad you finally got it.

You miss the details and cannot see the big picture. The DSC alone does not identify thermite, it is used along with XEDS to confirm the thermite reaction aka the iron reduction: This is the actual test to verify presence of thermite, and no competent researcher can ignore it. Maybe you will "get it" one of those days, I doubt it, but I still leave this comment for the benefit of others.

If Millette cannot repeat the igniton tests to check out the composition of the molten spheres, his paper is useless. If he is not going to do this I think Mohr should inform people of that, and maybe start to think about refunding money to those he had told Millette would replicate the Bentham tests.
 
You miss the details and cannot see the big picture. The DSC alone does not identify thermite, it is used along with XEDS to confirm the thermite reaction aka the iron reduction: This is the actual test to verify presence of thermite, and no competent researcher can ignore it.
Wrong, again. And again. And again...

The source of iron is not identified with a XEDS analysis. It may well be the gray layer.

The XEDS analysis does not show whether some of the iron is bound.

Iron reduction does not imply a thermite reaction.

Without a competent test identifying the products before and after the reaction, the DSC is useless. Deal with it.


Maybe you will "get it" one of those days, I doubt it, but I still leave this comment for the benefit of others.
:i:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom