No, there is absolutely no obligation to share chips as long as Millette has access to dust, and in fact part of his study is to confirm that the chips are really in the dust. The "major issue" is indeed that Jones has already complained that Millette may not have the same chips, but he also pointed out some procedures from his paper that Millette did not follow, like ignoring the MEK soft vs hard chips. The solution is doing it right next time, not blaming Jones.
I wrote an article a few days ago that covered this specific topic. The reason for the different behaviour of the chips is the different composition of the chips. Millette's aim was to determine, if the chips a - d from the Harrit study contain thermitic material. Therefore Millette used a chip, that had the same EDX signature like the chips a - d. Harrit and Jones used a chip that didn't match these chips. The most probable explanation is that chips a - d consist of Laclede primer paint, while the MEK chip consists of Tnemec primer. Both primers differ in the chemical composition of the pigment and of the filler, so it is very reasonable that these chips show a different behaviour during MEK soaking.
BTW: Millette was not the one, that used the wrong chips, his MEK chip had the same chemical composition than chips a - d from the Harrit paper. Harrit's MEK chip differed in its chemical composition from the chips a -d, so Harrit and Jones were the ones that used the wrong chip!
You don´t want to talk about the iron from the chips no more? Moving goal posts much lately? I am aware of truther claims that there may have been other evidence present, such as molten metal, but I leave that discussion for other people, for now. It´s off topic here anyway.
Harrit made no attempt to exclude the possibility that the microspheres originated in the gray layer.
No, it would be interesting to know the exact composition of the matrix but it is not relevant to the question whether or not thermite is ALSO present within the matrix material.
Millette carried out some experiments (FTIR) that revealed the composition of the matrix - it is epoxy resin.
The hypothesis Harrit has is "active thermitic material" so the question the paper answers is "does it go through thermite reaction"?
No, the paper doesn't answer this question due to lacking experimental data.
It does not matter what the matrix is, paint or explosive material, if there is also thermite present that results in thermite reaction, then the final product is still called "thermitic" material.
There was no (nano)thermite present, Dr. Millette's results prove this without doubt.
All that is required to confirm his hypothesis is to confirm thermite reaction. The composition of the matrix has nothing to do with it, although that would be a very interesting topic for another Harrit paper.
Harrit didn't prove this, he didn't identify elemental aluminum in his chips a - d and he didn't look for aluminumoxide as a product of the thermite reaction.
As I have said before, the paper does say the byproducts are also there.
Please quote the part of Harrit's paper where he "says that aluminum oxide is also there"!
Those that think those spectra do not show iron and aluminum oxide after ignition, should repeat the tests and prove it. As MM pointed out, this is what you said Millette would do, but he does not deliver, and what´s worse you all try to pretend these tests are not important and also tend to treat those that mention them as hostile.
Harrit only recorded EDX spectra from the iron rich microspheres, your claim is obviously wrong!
