The history is a little more complicated.
The original question was, of course: "Harrit e.al. claim there is nano-thermite in red-gray chips - is this claim true or false?"
To answer that claim, you must isolate the same kinds of chips, and the best, and only way, to do that, is to run the same tests on your own specimen that Harrit e.al. used on theirs to isolate and characterize them.
Now, knowing or at least suspecting that there are different kinds of red-gray chips, the question is: Which kind or kinds do we want to look at?
I was among those who urged Chris to ask Millette to focus on chips a-d. There are two reasons for this:
a) We suspected these chips are LaClede primer
b) Those chips are far and out the best characterized in ATM.
Now let's take a look at all specimen's that appear in ATM, and the tests that we know have been done on them, and the test results:
1. Specimens:
- Chip a
- Chip b
- Chip c
- Chip d
- The MEK-soaked chip (Fig. 12-18)
- DSC-chip 1 (MacKinlay 1)
- DSC-chip 2 (MacKinlay 2)
- DSC chip 3 (Intermont)
- DSC chip 4 (White)
- A chip that, post DSC, gave rise to Fig. 21
- A chip that, after flame test with very hot torch, gave rise to Fig. 23 and 26
- A chip that, post-DSC, gave rise to Fig. 25
- The multi-layered chip (Fig. 31)
- The chip that has a carbon layer (Fig. 32 and 33)
2. Tests done on these chips before DSC or flame test (destructive tests)
2.1 Chips a-d:
- Magnetic attraction
- Visual separation for being "red-gray chip"
- Photomicrograph at 1 µm scale
- BSE images at 20 µm scale (one of the four chips)
- BSE image at 10 µm scale
- XEDS spectrum of bulk gray layer
- XEDS spectrum of bulk red layer
- BSE image at 1 µm scale showing sub-micron particles in the matrix
- SE image at 1 µm scale
- XEDS map of five elements (chip a)
- XEDS of selected, identified sub-micron particles
2.2 The MEK-soaked chip:
- Magnetic attraction
- Visual separation for being "red-gray chip"
- Photomicrograph at 100 µm scale (badly out of focus!)
- SE-image at 100 µm scale
- XEDS spectrum of bulk red layer
- XEDS map of five elements (post MEK-soak)
- XEDS of selected, unidentified sub-micron particles/regions
2.3 The four chips tested in the DSC
- Magnetic attraction
- Visual separation for being "red-gray chip"
2.4 The chip from Fig. 21
- Magnetic attraction
- Visual separation for being "red-gray chip"
2.5 The chip from Fig. 23 and 26
- Magnetic attraction
- Visual separation for being "red-gray chip"
2.6 The chip from Fig. 25
- Magnetic attraction
- Visual separation for being "red-gray chip"
2.7 The multi-layered chip
- Magnetic attraction
- Visual separation for being "red-gray chip"
2.8 The carbon-layered chip
- Magnetic attraction
- Visual separation for being "red-gray chip"
- XEDS spectrum of bulk gray layer
- MEK-soaking (though no description of consistency is provided, except that the red layer has expanded and displays "porosity".)
So we see that all chips, except for the first five, have been characterized by magnetic attraction and visual appearance only before being destroyed in fire.
We see that neither DSC nor electric resistance nor anything else has been done to all chips to isolate them from all the other chips that are attracted to a magnet and that are red-gray chips.
As jtl and MM assert that many red-gray chips that are attracted to a magnet are in fact paint, they ought to admit that all these chips might indeed be just paint, or might be different from one another.
How could Millette selöect a chip like the ones that gave rise to Fig. 21, 23, 25, or the four chips that were tested in the DSC, when nothing is known about them except that they are red-gray and magnetic?
So of course Millette went for the four chips on which lots of detailed data is available: chips a-d.
And those have been showm to not contain thermite.
This means that Harrit e.al. must discard chips a-d, or revoke their conclusion that "the" red-gray chips are thermitic.
Once they discard chips a-d, they are out of evidence for anything "nano", as none of the other data shows anything in sub-micron size.