WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

Paints will either dissolve or become soft in MEK. Harrit´s chips remain hard even after over 50 hours of soaking in this paint solvent, that is they do not even become soft. This is no proof they are thermitic, but it is evidence that they are not paint, and also a definite test to sort out the different chips in the dust. Just take the time to answer this question you ignored before:

jtl,

At which stage did they use MEK to sort out chips from the dust? Was it after the initial isolation of the chips from the original dust samples in which they used a magnet and the visual characteristic of red/gray layers?

According to your understanding, what types of chips were they sorted into using MEK?
 
Mohr, Basile has said that the dust is full of red paint chips and Jones has made it extra clear recently that a big difference between them and the chips suspected of being thermite is that the paint becomes soft in MEK while the thermite chips remain hard.

What paint chips did they test jtl? The ones supposedly from the dust pile or OTHER paint chips from other sources?
 
...You Mohr, will remain confused if you keep trusting this forum.

There was not thermite used on 911. Only a few fringe nuts believe thermite was used on 911 and they have to ignore the evidence of no thermite damage to any WTC steel.

Trust, the study of WTC by Jones is was an attempt to back in thermite. Jones had the fantasy in September 2005 when he figured out he was anti-war or some anti-government or some other bias he has. He was fired because he essentially went nuts on 911 issues, irrational albeit in a very personable way. Then Jones found an idiot on 911 issues, as insane as himself on thermite; Harrit. They did tests on dust, which might be from 911, or not. The tests show the dust does not match thermite, but since there is Fe and Al in the dust, they pronounce they have found super-thermite.

Millette studied dust, and could not find thermite. RJ Lee studied the dust, and did not find thermite. USGS studied dust and did not find thermite.

Then some nuts from 911 truth think DSC is used to figure out if you have thermite, they have no clue what DSC is, but since Jones used DSC, their God of Gods on thermite, DSC is required by 911 truth dolts.

DSC purpose is not known to you, and there is no need to debunk Jones' fantasy paper. It is a waste of money to chase the fantasy gish-gallop of Jones on thermite.

Feel free to show any steel that had evidence of thermite, or the tons of thermite products left after Harrits tons of thermite were used on 911. Where are they?
Yes, they are in Harrit's paranoid conspiracy mind, and in Jones fantasy thermite insanity.

There is not need for Mohr to trust anyone, there is no thermite damage to any WTC steel. This is all that Mohr needs.

When is the ETIC for understanding DSC? Never? Millette study is not needed. Catering to 911 truth is a waste of time. 911 truth is a purgatory for a few; they believe the cool anti-government, anti-NWO claims for a while. Those who have critical thinking skills use knowledge to climb out of the pit of 911 truth and leave the fantasy and lies behind; those who refuse to think for themselves, remain in ignorance, unable to drop the fantasy that defines their biases.

Trust JREF? You can't define what DSC is used for. Is he to trust Harrit, or Jones. What happen to your cousin? Is he a twoofie? Is that a nice name? Are you a twoofie too?
To be fair, some twoofies are serious academics, including Harrit and some ae911 truthers. My annoying ginger cousin is a rather serious academic, and serious about this stuff although I don´t know if he is registered with any group. He is very smart but also crazy.
...
Millette found no thermite.
I was hoping this study would end the debate, ...?
No thermite damage to WTC steel ended the debate long ago. But 911 truth does not do reality based evidence, they use experts who are nuts on 911 as their source of woo.

Your 911 truth based lies have failed. They were lies in the first place, and can't be resurrected by Jones, even though he has evidence for Christ walking in the New World, or Harrit because he has delusions of tons of thermite used to destroy the WTC. And we have people who see DSC traces of chips and thermite, can't see they don't match.

Willful ignorance, and fantasy. 911 truth can't loose as long as people don't think for themselves, as you guys cycle through your believe anything phase, or not.

Anyone who takes thermite destroying the WTC on 911 serious, has mental problems. Do you know anyone that intellectually bankrupt? Is your cousin?
Millette found no thermite; the paper was not needed to confirm thermite was not used on 911.
 
"…We say the curves are "broad" because they represent an ongoing exotherm reaction over the course of many minutes. This is not at all like the sparky bust seen in Fig. 22 which was powered by a torch, or the vigorous burn in a matter of seconds that Basile showed."

No. Not even close.

The truth, for those not in heavy denial, is that Mark Basile's test shows an exothermic reaction lasting no more than 1/15 to 2/15 of a second.

If you can produce similar results with your LaClede paint chip, or any paint chip of similar sample size, you might have the start of an argument.

"... By claiming his MEK-soak results are worth anything at all, he implies that all chips he studied were the same material.
They weren't.
And of course you are right, different paints will behave differently in MEK. Also, different superthermite compositions might behave differently in MEK, too!
It's a useless crap test.
"

Well you certainly provided the expected useless crap response.

The fact Millette's MEK-soaked chips went soft and that even after a 50 hour MEK-soak the Bentham Paper chip remained hard, clearly shows there is no match.

MM
 
Mohr questions:

1.) Even if the post-ignition spheres in the Bentham paper are not pure iron, is there relatively more pure iron in these spheres than there was pre-ignition?

There is no pure iron before ignition but for some reason your buddies haven´t made that clear for you. The spheres after ignition have pure iron in them but they are not 100% pure iron, you also have a bit of other elements present, just like the compared spheres from a known thermite.

The iron before ignition is 2 parts iron married to 3 parts oxygen, like common red rust. The iron after ignition is up to 4 parts iron with 1 part oxygen, or mostly pure iron. This is called reduction, aka thermite reaction.

Instead of asking your buddies here, I suggest you go to an independent chemist and ask him about this. By the way, again your buddies try to muddy the water by suggesting that just "looking at the peaks" is not reliable way to get the ratios, but of course this was not the case, the authors did calculations.

2.) I also realize that a piece of paper catching on fire might create a "steep curve" while a gasoline explosion would create a curve that looks more like a sheer cliff. My response to JTL though was that the graph comparing the nanothermite and the red-grey chips looks different in 3 ways: ignition temperature, energy release AND speed of ignition. The first two are obvious; the third I'm checking in with you on.

What is being discussed is the width of the peaks, Harrit´s samples all have peaks that are as narrow or even narrower than that superthermite example, which means that they burn as fast or even faster than that sample of superthermite in DSC.

You cannot compare the controlled combustion in DSC to other methods like torching or Basile´s heating. Again your buddies know this but they choose not to make this clear for you this time, for some reason. Kminek did explain this earlier on this thread
But, this comparison is not really correct, since typical extremely rapid thermitic reaction must be triggered by some thermal/energetic shock, like in the linked video, which is not the case of slow DSC heating indeed


3.) Most importantly, is this true: THE BEST WAY TO DETERMINE WHETHER THERE I THERMITE IN THE CHIPS IS TO ANALYZE THE CHEMISTRY OF THE CHIPS. Things like iron spheres and DSC tests are at best secondary tools which might show supportive evidence, but it's the very tests Jones et al are withholding that would offer the strongest evidence.

This is not true because the superhermite Harrit et al propose is not at all a simple feO-al thermite, the main part being the proposed energetic matrix. And as we have discussed before, you yourself have admitted that you do not accept a conclusion of thermitic material based on the conclusion that the chemical composition is consistent with thermitic material. As you must remember this is what Henry did, but still you called that paper a failure to confirm thermitic material because his ignition tests failed.

And going back to your first question, and the answer to that, the way to determine if a proposed exotic mixture of "superthermite" is actually thermitic, you have to check for reduction after ignition.

The only way to refute Harrit´s conclusion is to repeat the tests, see if you have non spherical iron oxide before ignition, and if some of the molten spheres after ignition have reduced iron. The results can confirm Harrit, refute him or make his result inconclusive, which would still force his team to respond with more data.
 
Last edited:
Paints will either dissolve or become soft in MEK. Harrit´s chips remain hard even after over 50 hours of soaking in this paint solvent, that is they do not even become soft. This is no proof they are thermitic, but it is evidence that they are not paint, and also a definite test to sort out the different chips in the dust.

1. Of course Millette's chip shows a different behaviour in the MEK test than Harrit's chip, because both chips are different! Millette investigated chips that match the criteria Harrit's chips a - d and these chips differ in their chemical composition from the MEK chip. Just take a look at the EDX spectrum of "Millette's MEK chip" on p. 28 of Millette's progress report (3rd spectrum of the left column) and compare it to the EDX spectrum of Harrit's MEK chip.

2. Could you give the composition of the paint, that Harrit used for his comparison?
 
Last edited:
You need something like XRD to determine if pure iron is present in the spheres. EDX simply can't determine that even with a semi-quantitative analysis. EDX does not measure the atomic spacings or crystal structure of the material, etc, which is what is required to determine if pure iron is present.
 
If one or two did not, would the statement be wrong?

yeah. it would say that one chip did not react when the other three did. remember that henryco heated his chips up to 900C and nothing!!!

its not that hard to comprehend:
from the thermitic paper:
"In the post-DSC residue, charred-porous material and
numerous microspheres and spheroids were observed.
Many
of these were analyzed, and it was found that some were
iron-rich, which appear shiny and silvery in the optical microscope,
and some were silicon-rich, which appear transparent
or translucent when viewed with white light; see photographs
taken using a Nikon microscope (Fig. 20).
The abundant iron-rich spheres are of particular interest
in this study; none were observed in these particular chips
prior to DSC-heating.
"

which means they all produced microspheres. see, it did NOT say that one chip was observed not to have produced microspheres.
 
Last edited:
JTL,

I am not confused about the most important things... The simplest way for Jones et al to prove that Millette tested the wrong chips is for him to release his own chips for further experimentation. The simplest way for Jones to prove thermite is to release all the results of all the tests he did and then held back. Those tests could add to his body of evidence. He is doing neither. Until he does this, his complaints about hard vs soft chips and DSC are meaningless to me. I don't understand chemistry, but I do understand when someone is withholding information. I am not ignoring the question of hard vs soft chips, I don't understand its import and am asking about it. But that is not going to derail me from my central concern as a journalist, that Steven Jones is withholding information. You have consistently ignored my repeated insistence on the importance of this fact. Nothing else is important, don't you agree? Why do you ignore this?
 
Mohr: I am not confused about the most important things... The simplest way for Jones et al to prove that Millette tested the wrong chips is for him to release his own chips for further experimentation. The simplest way for Jones to prove thermite is to release all the results of all the tests he did and then held back. Those tests could add to his body of evidence. He is doing neither. Until he does this, his complaints about hard vs soft chips and DSC are meaningless to me. I don't understand chemistry, but I do understand when someone is withholding information. I am not ignoring the question of hard vs soft chips, I don't understand its import and am asking about it. But that is not going to derail me from my central concern as a journalist, that Steven Jones is withholding information. You have consistently ignored my repeated insistence on the importance of this fact. Nothing else is important, don't you agree? Why do you ignore this?

Oh calm down Mohr, I was not ignoring anything, I was responding to things you asked about, so there is no sense in getting all dramatic when you get the answers. It also makes no sense to say you are not ignoring hard vs soft chips while you also say the issue is meaningless. You brought up these issues so I think it is only fair to ask you to discuss your questions.

As indicated in previous posts your buddies are not very reliable sources of information, but you keep relying on them for your opinions. The real test for a thermite reaction is verifying iron reduction as I described in previous post, and I suggested you go and talk to a truly independent chemist about this.

This is what you should do as a journalist, instead of relying on a scientist with a possible conflict of interest, and a forum of "debunkers" with a very bad reputation. Before you make any more loud declarations about Jones hiding important tests I suggest you remember what I have said here and what Dr. Greening also said about this forum and the authoritative statements by the resident "debunkers".

Do you think these are unfair requests?
 
No Thermite damage on WTC steel, DSC not understood by 911 truth

... Dr. Greening also said about this forum and the authoritative statements by the resident "debunkers". ... ?
A weak attack on JREF posters, using what you can't say Dr. Greening said? Does he support the insane claims of Jones and Harrit, tons of thermite were used to destroy the WTC? lol, you don't know what DSC is used for and think it is necessary?

When you can't explain why DSC is use. You can't explain why the DSC traces for the chips don't match thermite and look more like soil, or burnt wood. You make the weakest attack on JREF in history.

Who cares if 911 truth does not believe the Millette paper results because he did not do an unnecessary test. It is self-critiquing and exposes those 911 truthers can't think for themselves or figure out what a DSC is for. It means they are bigger failures. They not only were fooled by the fake results of Jones, they can't see the traces don't match, and don't have the research skills to look up what the traces look like. And then it does not matter, a DSC does not identify what it was.

The bottom line; No steel shows any signs thermite was use on 911. Millette found no thermite, and Jones lied. Dr. Greening? lol, he was joking. Do you know him?
 
Jtl:
Hehe;)
Since you are still repeating the same illiterate nonsenses like "Paints will either dissolve or become soft in MEK," you again showed me that you are not able to learn anything new (as well as Harrit who apparently has zero knowledge about paints and polymers).

(Anyway, my definitely last attempt: the degree of polymer swelling e.g. in MEK is dependent on the degree of cross-linking: heavily cross-linked polymers do not swell at all (remain "hard", which is of course a vague term for real science, the hardness should be measured by some objective method!), less heavily cross-linked polymers would swell more, lightly cross-linked polymers would swell to considerable extent, leading to considerable "softening", and can be even partially soluble, linear (non-crosslinked) polymers would dissolve completely. Therefore, paint with those binders have the same behavior: some of them would not swell at all (remain hard), some swell to some extent/are "softened", etc. We can expect all these kinds of paints in WTC, as well as in any other large/complex buildings)

As for reduction of iron oxide: we do not deny that there was some (probably partial) reduction. Quite possible. But it was not conclusively proven by Harrit et al.

(I'm going to take some rest now, since things are going to be repetitive and rather boring... basically nothing new has been brought by truthers during last several days, just the old pretty worn stuff)
 
Last edited:
yeah. it would say that one chip did not react when the other three did. remember that henryco heated his chips up to 900C and nothing!!!

its not that hard to comprehend:
from the thermitic paper:
"In the post-DSC residue, charred-porous material and
numerous microspheres and spheroids were observed.
Many
of these were analyzed, and it was found that some were
iron-rich, which appear shiny and silvery in the optical microscope,
and some were silicon-rich, which appear transparent
or translucent when viewed with white light; see photographs
taken using a Nikon microscope (Fig. 20).
The abundant iron-rich spheres are of particular interest
in this study; none were observed in these particular chips
prior to DSC-heating.
"

which means they all produced microspheres. see, it did NOT say that one chip was observed not to have produced microspheres.

But if only one or two did not have them, nothing in that statement would be wrong, because it does not say "all", only "numerous microspheres" and "some were iron-rich"
 
Jtl:
Hehe;)
Since you are still repeating the same illiterate nonsenses like "Paints will either dissolve or become soft in MEK," you again showed me that you are not able to learn anything new (as well as Harrit who apparently has zero knowledge about paints and polymers).

(Anyway, my definitely last attempt: the degree of polymer swelling e.g. in MEK is dependent on the degree of cross-linking: heavily cross-linked polymers do not swell at all (remain "hard", which is of course a vague term for real science, the hardness should be measured by some objective method!), less heavily cross-linked polymers would swell more, lightly cross-linked polymers would swell to considerable extent, leading to considerable "softening", and can be even partially soluble, linear (non-crosslinked) polymers would dissolve completely. Therefore, paint with those binders have the same behavior: some of them would not swell at all (remain hard), some swell to some extent/are "softened", etc. We can expect all these kinds of paints in WTC, as well as in any other large/complex buildings)

As for reduction of iron oxide: we do not deny that there was some (probably partial) reduction. Quite possible. But it was not conclusively proven by Harrit et al.

(I'm going to take some rest now, since things are going to be repetitive and rather boring... basically nothing new has been brought by truthers during last several days, just the old pretty worn stuff)




There is the basic truth to truthers. Their object is not to reach a solution but to keep the balls in the air by focusing on meaningless minutiae, going off on tangents and just ignoring any inconvenient information. This approach drives most engineering types bonkers since they are detail and problem solving orientated. I've seen many leave in disgust and not a few get banned when their frustration level gets to high.

I usually post one liners since any more will be ignored.:)


(of course nothing in this post is new):D
 
Hi JTL,

OK I'll respond to your latest posts. Here's the logic that concerns me: soft vs. hard chips after an MEK soak therefore Millette tested the wrong chips. Chemical analysis of the chips is not reliable because the materials being tested are not standard nanothermite but some other chemical compound. The width of the peaks on the DSC graphs are the same for nanothermite and the a-d chips (though in post 1858 they look different to me) therefore the DSC test has made a valid comparison (even though the ignition temperatures and the energy releases are drastically different). A better way to test for thermitic material than chemical analysis is to look at the post-ignition residue, but the fact that massive amounts of aluminum oxide are not found there is no problem. Correct me if I am wrong, but I just see an experiment where Jones et al are trying to fit the data to a preordained theory, and there are many ways that there is no fit without resorting to the "supersecret formula" hypothesis.

For what it's worth, it was Richard Gage who suggested I join JREF. For two years before that, the only people I approached for information were scientists with no connection to the 9/11 debate and 9/1 Truth activits. I talked with 14 physicists one on one and joined a physics chat room, for example. I talked with a wide range of engineers. One aeronautical engineer agreed with one aspect of Gage's claims about the physics of the collapse, all the others were in complete disagreement with him on every major point. I tried to talk with many other scientists, most of whom rebuffed my attempts to even bring it up. I also talked with architects and others with expertise. I never did find chemists to talk with successfully, I admit. What these "debunkers" have said is largely in alignment with what the many physicists, architects and others I have talked to outside of this debate have said.

I think I am responding to what you are saying. You are ignoring my main point, which is that Jones et al are withholding valuable data and the chips themselves and this is central to the discussion.
 
Hi JTL,

OK I'll respond to your latest posts. Here's the logic that concerns me: soft vs. hard chips after an MEK soak therefore Millette tested the wrong chips. Chemical analysis of the chips is not reliable because the materials being tested are not standard nanothermite but some other chemical compound. The width of the peaks on the DSC graphs are the same for nanothermite and the a-d chips (though in post 1858 they look different to me) therefore the DSC test has made a valid comparison (even though the ignition temperatures and the energy releases are drastically different). A better way to test for thermitic material than chemical analysis is to look at the post-ignition residue, but the fact that massive amounts of aluminum oxide are not found there is no problem. Correct me if I am wrong, but I just see an experiment where Jones et al are trying to fit the data to a preordained theory, and there are many ways that there is no fit without resorting to the "supersecret formula" hypothesis.

For what it's worth, it was Richard Gage who suggested I join JREF. For two years before that, the only people I approached for information were scientists with no connection to the 9/11 debate and 9/1 Truth activity's. I talked with 14 physicists one on one and joined a physics chat room, for example. I talked with a wide range of engineers. One aeronautical engineer agreed with one aspect of Gage's claims about the physics of the collapse, all the others were in complete disagreement with him on every major point. I tried to talk with many other scientists, most of whom rebuffed my attempts to even bring it up. I also talked with architects and others with expertise. I never did find chemists to talk with successfully, I admit. What these "debunkers" have said is largely in alignment with what the many physicists, architects and others I have talked to outside of this debate have said.

I think I am responding to what you are saying. You are ignoring my main point, which is that Jones et al are withholding valuable data and the chips themselves and this is central to the discussion.

Gage sent you to JREF? Were you bothering his taking money from the dumb scam? The Gage scam, taking money from the nuts who believe fantasy so dumbed down, only a select few idiots are fooled.

Jones and Harrit are fraud. A fringe few idiots are fooled by their vanity journal paper. Jones has thermite in the ceiling tiles, and Harrit is unable to get past the 100 tons of thermite. Two nuts. The old, ends justify the means. How nice of them to fool dumb people.

Gage wants you to stop bothering him, so he sent you to JREF. lol. You know the paper is nuts, there is no need to debunk it, it shows the chips are not thermite. Don't you like the gish gallop with the iron sphere, oh, "iron rich". Rich.

Don't sink more time and money whacking the mole Jones, Gage and Harrit. Intelligent truther will mature and discover the fraud, the insane will return to the middle ages with Gage, taking no action, acting dumb. Can't believe people have sent Gage over a million dollars, at 300 to 400k/yr.

Have you exposed Gage as a fraud? Where is the smack down published? Why did Gage fail to fund Millette's study with his thousands? Is Gage not looking for the truth? $$$
 
Last edited:
go and talk to a truly independent chemist about this.

You know, JTL, I just might do this. If I can find someone who would agree to look at the Bentham paper, the Millette preliminary report, and some kind of summary of what Jones, Harrit and other signatories have publicly said in response to Millette (I believe Harrit called Millette's study fraudulent or something if I am not mistaken, does anyone have such a quote?)... I'll be very interested to know what a chemist with no prior experience looking at this issue will say. My honest prediction is that it will be similar to the responses I get when I contacted all the physicists and architects, or for that matter all mainstream scientists like Jonathan Barnett who have been quote-mined to appear to support the 9/11 CD theories (dozens of them, all negative in their opinion of this theory). Maybe a chemistry grad student would do this for a classroom exercise?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom