Starving for Truth
Thinker
- Joined
- Oct 1, 2012
- Messages
- 194
Forget the DSC, MM, we should really move on and get our fine truth movement back on course again. Hi-yo Silver!
Are you a thermite believer, or a standard poe?I wouldn't go as far as calling MM a disinfo agent, but his posts seem to become more and more aimed at generally discrediting the scientific reputation of the truth movement.
That does not say all of them. It is an ambiguous statement.
What does not produce iron rich micro-spheres?where does it say one or two or three did NOT produce microspheres?
MM if I led you to believe that I asked Millette to follow the Bentham protocol, I am sorry. I have no memory of making such a claim. I clearly remember asking him if he could find the red-grey chips on his own, if hwe would like the chips fromk Kevin Ryan if I could get them, and then I asked the question, "Can you determine if the red-grey chips are thermitic?" My interest in seeing a DSC test comes from YOUR interest in it, and I am not at all convinced that the DSC test would I.D. the chips as thermite. As I have recently said, the readings graphs of energy release from the DSC tests of known thermitic material vs the red-grey chips in the bentham paper shows a tremendous difference, a factor of at least three times more energy release. It shows me nothing even remotely close to a match to nanothermite! JTL has said that this is because of variations in the samples or whatever, and I say, therefore it tells us nothing. The FTIR and other tests DO show us that gthe red-grey chips are NOT thermite. Until Kevin Ryan or Steven Jones release chips they believe are thermitic for testing, I will no longer waste time responding to your claim that Millette found the wrong chips.You originally lead us to believe that Dr. Millette would attempt a replication of the most salient tests performed by the Bentham Paper scientists.
And then you pretended to be just as fooled as the rest of us, when days before his research presentation, Dr. Millette made it clear he had absolutely no intention of performing DSC testing.
This is particularly strange Chris when considering your claim of having discussed the ability to do DSC testing with dozens of other labs.
Dr. Millette had the same access to the Bentham Paper as anyone with a decent Internet connection. Just the fact that he did not attempt any Resistivity Testing or Heat testing above 400C on the red layers points to his clear lack of interest in following the Paper.
Dr. Millette did not have to completely destroy the chips. He could have divided chips and only performed destructive testing (heated above 430C) on half, leaving the remaining halves for comparison.
Again, such an approach was obvious, but Dr. Millette risked making a discovery which would not be particularly good for his business relationship with the U.S. Government.
Hoping that Dr. Millette will do the right thing now would seem to be little more than trash talk.
I suspect that given his easy access to WTC dust samples, the ease in which he could isolate chips of interest with Resistivity testing, and the fact that he could easily set his oven to +430C and observe the ignition residue, that he has already done some of this testing and knows what a Pandora's Box it is.
MM
"You originally lead us to believe that Dr. Millette would attempt a replication of the most salient tests performed by the Bentham Paper scientists.
And then you pretended to be just as fooled as the rest of us, when days before his research presentation, Dr. Millette made it clear he had absolutely no intention of performing DSC testing.
This is particularly strange Chris when considering your claim of having discussed the ability to do DSC testing with dozens of other labs."
"MM if I led you to believe that I asked Millette to follow the Bentham protocol, I am sorry. I have no memory of making such a claim."
formatting changes are mine"1.) His [Dr. Millette] intention is to replicate the tests done in the Bentham study... The Bentham paper does not report on having done a normal envirnmental forensic study of the components so Dr. Millette will do that, plus everything they did, plus other tests as needed."
"MM, sigh, I thought Jim Millette was going to do a DSC test and he later decided not to because there was no evidence of thermitic material. He is going to look at the DSC tests already done by the Bentham authors, and I keep asking him about the tests."
"You're right! I don't care what MM thinks. Responding to his accusations is a waste of time. I do believe in responding to technical questions and challenges tho."
"…My interest in seeing a DSC test comes from YOUR interest in it, and I am not at all convinced that the DSC test would I.D. the chips as thermite. As I have recently said, the readings graphs of energy release from the DSC tests of known thermitic material vs the red-grey chips in the bentham paper shows a tremendous difference, a factor of at least three times more energy release. It shows me nothing even remotely close to a match to nanothermite! JTL has said that this is because of variations in the samples or whatever, and I say, therefore it tells us nothing. The FTIR and other tests DO show us that gthe red-grey chips are NOT thermite. Until Kevin Ryan or Steven Jones release chips they believe are thermitic for testing, I will no longer waste time responding to your claim that Millette found the wrong chips."
That is something you're right about. He did not have any interest in following the ATM paper (why do you capitalize it? is it sacred or something?). His interest was in finding out whether there was thermite in the allegedly thermitic chips (which according to the authors, are omnipresent and thus any allegations of not being the same chips Millette tested should be sustained by more than speculation, given the amount of chips that he isolated).Dr. Millette had the same access to the Bentham Paper as anyone with a decent Internet connection. Just the fact that he did not attempt any Resistivity Testing or Heat testing above 400C on the red layers points to his clear lack of interest in following the Paper.
In a coalfiret heat/powerplant the coal burns about 750- 950 degrees celcius, so when Harrit et al says, that the temp. in the DSC must have raised to over 1400 C., then he is wrong. Flyash is made at very lower temp. And there is many different ones. Rich in iron, alu-silicates, calciumsilicates and more.
From the article page 21:
That thermitic reactions from the red/gray chips have
indeed occurred in the DSC (rising temperature method of
ignition) is confirmed by the combined observation of 1)
highly energetic reactions occurring at approximately
430 ˚C, 2) iron-rich sphere formation so that the product
must have been sufficiently hot to be molten (over 1400 ˚C
for iron and iron oxide), 3) spheres, spheroids and nonspheroidal residues in which the iron content exceeds the
oxygen content. Significant elemental iron is now present as
expected from the thermitic reduction-oxidation reaction of
aluminum and iron oxide.
Of course it burns at 430 C., there is carbon matrix in it.
Mohr: His [Dr. Millette] intention is to replicate the tests done in the Bentham study... The Bentham paper does not report on having done a normal envirnmental forensic study of the components so Dr. Millette will do that, plus everything they did, plus other tests as needed."
Mohr: MM if I led you to believe that I asked Millette to follow the Bentham protocol, I am sorry. I have no memory of making such a claim.
I am not at all convinced that the DSC test would I.D. the chips as thermite.
As I have recently said, the readings graphs of energy release from the DSC tests of known thermitic material vs the red-grey chips in the bentham paper shows a tremendous difference, a factor of at least three times more energy release. It shows me nothing even remotely close to a match to nanothermite! JTL has said that this is because of variations in the samples or whatever, and I say, therefore it tells us nothing.
The FTIR and other tests DO show us that gthe red-grey chips are NOT thermite. Until Kevin Ryan or Steven Jones release chips they believe are thermitic for testing, I will no longer waste time responding to your claim that Millette found the wrong chips.
What is going on here Mohr? You obviously said Millette would replicate Bentham paper.
Please, jtl, which sphere in the Bentham paper is iron not iron oxide?...
Do you see any problem with the spheres being iron not iron oxide?
How fast did they react? Can you provide a number? Something per second.Unless the DSC graphs are proven to be unreliable, it tells us that Harrit´s chips release energy as fast as a known variant of superthermite. It is OK to say that you don´t understand, but then ask questions, don´t ignore. You do realize that one defining feature of superthermites and explosives is how fast they release energy?
Chris said he never ASKED Millette to replicate the paper. I looks like Millette told Chris it was his intention to replicate it.
Someone please correct me if I'm wrong, but that's how I see it.
Ironically, no thermite used on 911. Makes discussion a delusion based on fantasy. And you call your friend a nut on 911 issues?...Unless the DSC graphs are proven to be unreliable, it tells us that Harrit´s chips release energy as fast as a known variant of superthermite. It is OK to say that you don´t understand, but then ask questions, don´t ignore. You do realize that one defining feature of superthermites and explosives is how fast they release energy?
...
You are being very unreasonable to MM, and given what has been said about your promises of replication, maybe you should be a bit more humble?