WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

I wouldn't go as far as calling MM a disinfo agent, but his posts seem to become more and more aimed at generally discrediting the scientific reputation of the truth movement.
 
I wouldn't go as far as calling MM a disinfo agent, but his posts seem to become more and more aimed at generally discrediting the scientific reputation of the truth movement.
Are you a thermite believer, or a standard poe?

911 truth is a failed movement, where knowledge is banned. You can't discredit something that does not exist; there is no science in 911 truth, 911 truth only has dumbed down delusions, so idiotic only a few fringe believe.

Millette found no thermite. Which was proved many years ago, when no thermite evidence was found on WTC steel. 911 truth will never comprehend reality, but 911 truth is a fleeting distraction to a few people who can learn, and understand. Those intelligent being will leave 911 truth, and have a lesson learned. Those who persist in belief in 911 truth lies, are lost.

What did Millette find? No thermite. What was on WTC steel, no thermite. BINGO
 
Last edited:
where does it say one or two or three did NOT produce microspheres?
What does not produce iron rich micro-spheres?

Millette found no thermite, and 11 years ago there was no thermite damage to WTC steel. Makes your debate, failure.
 
You originally lead us to believe that Dr. Millette would attempt a replication of the most salient tests performed by the Bentham Paper scientists.

And then you pretended to be just as fooled as the rest of us, when days before his research presentation, Dr. Millette made it clear he had absolutely no intention of performing DSC testing.

This is particularly strange Chris when considering your claim of having discussed the ability to do DSC testing with dozens of other labs.

Dr. Millette had the same access to the Bentham Paper as anyone with a decent Internet connection. Just the fact that he did not attempt any Resistivity Testing or Heat testing above 400C on the red layers points to his clear lack of interest in following the Paper.

Dr. Millette did not have to completely destroy the chips. He could have divided chips and only performed destructive testing (heated above 430C) on half, leaving the remaining halves for comparison.

Again, such an approach was obvious, but Dr. Millette risked making a discovery which would not be particularly good for his business relationship with the U.S. Government.

Hoping that Dr. Millette will do the right thing now would seem to be little more than trash talk.

I suspect that given his easy access to WTC dust samples, the ease in which he could isolate chips of interest with Resistivity testing, and the fact that he could easily set his oven to +430C and observe the ignition residue, that he has already done some of this testing and knows what a Pandora's Box it is.

MM
MM if I led you to believe that I asked Millette to follow the Bentham protocol, I am sorry. I have no memory of making such a claim. I clearly remember asking him if he could find the red-grey chips on his own, if hwe would like the chips fromk Kevin Ryan if I could get them, and then I asked the question, "Can you determine if the red-grey chips are thermitic?" My interest in seeing a DSC test comes from YOUR interest in it, and I am not at all convinced that the DSC test would I.D. the chips as thermite. As I have recently said, the readings graphs of energy release from the DSC tests of known thermitic material vs the red-grey chips in the bentham paper shows a tremendous difference, a factor of at least three times more energy release. It shows me nothing even remotely close to a match to nanothermite! JTL has said that this is because of variations in the samples or whatever, and I say, therefore it tells us nothing. The FTIR and other tests DO show us that gthe red-grey chips are NOT thermite. Until Kevin Ryan or Steven Jones release chips they believe are thermitic for testing, I will no longer waste time responding to your claim that Millette found the wrong chips.
 
Carsten: I agree with Oystein: if the "Bentham microspheres" were present already in the unheated chips, it would be a direct and blatant scientific fraud. And since they are still presented/believed to be a "crucial proof" of nanothemite by truthers, including Jones and, they were very probably formed really during heating in DSC.
After all, chips for DSC had to contain gray layers (since they had to be "typical red/gray chips") which dissappeared after heating, and there is no specific reason why to think that e.g. fly-ash microspheres formed during WTC fires should be frequently and firmly sticked just to the WTC paint layers, like we see in Bentham paper. Hence, their origin is probably chips themselves.

As for XEDS of thermite residues, it's perhaps funny, but I've not found any other XEDS than this one in Bentham paper on the net. Of course, Bentham XEDS is hardly representative, since pure aluminothermite should give only Fe, Al and O peaks. Si peak, which is larger than Al peak, remains unexplained and the whole XEDS looks like a typical spectrum of e.g. iron-richer fly ash particles.
I think that this silicon could come at least partially from the substrate, on which this thermite was ignited (some ceramics, glass, brick, concrete... who knows). But I can be wrong...
 
Last edited:
Senenmut, MM, jtl: Please, try to remember, that during any potential replication of heating experiments from Bentham paper, the chips must be heated not to 430 or 450 degrees C, (as you perhaps think?) but to 700 degrees C! (using the same or very similar heating rate indeed)
 
Last edited:
Carsten,

like I said, flyash is one possibility, and to some extent, your image citation proves that flyash is a candidate. And I'd say: Not a bad candidate for Fig. 28 at all!

BUT Fig 26 almost certainly has nothing whatsoever to do with flyash! Remember that these red-gray paint chips atmost might contain some flyash (while most do not), but a spheric blob found after a heating experiment wouldn't be very likely to be an original sphere from the flyash contained in such a specimen.

Instead, the "left-most microsphere" depicted in Fig. 26 seems to have formed on the edge of the chip, where red and gray layers meet. Unfortunately they haven't drawn a rectangle indication the exact spot measured; but I'd suspect that this particular SEM electron beam "saw" both some iron oxide from the gray oxidized steel and calcium aluminates and silica from the reduced red layer.


Again, while spheres with XEDS spectra like some shown in the Harrit paper frequently do occur in flyash, that is not the only place and situation where you find them. Such spheres, with varying proportions of Fe, Al, Si and Ca, form almost always when you burn mixed stuff containing both organic fuel and ordinary minerals.
Coal fits the bill.
Wood fits the bill.
Household waste fits the bill.

Paint fits the bill.
 
"You originally lead us to believe that Dr. Millette would attempt a replication of the most salient tests performed by the Bentham Paper scientists.

And then you pretended to be just as fooled as the rest of us, when days before his research presentation, Dr. Millette made it clear he had absolutely no intention of performing DSC testing.

This is particularly strange Chris when considering your claim of having discussed the ability to do DSC testing with dozens of other labs."
"MM if I led you to believe that I asked Millette to follow the Bentham protocol, I am sorry. I have no memory of making such a claim."

And here I was under the impression that good investigative journalists kept careful records.

And it was not just me you fooled. It was how you presented Dr. Millette's research to everyone!

Let me refresh your memory;

"1.) His [Dr. Millette] intention is to replicate the tests done in the Bentham study... The Bentham paper does not report on having done a normal envirnmental forensic study of the components so Dr. Millette will do that, plus everything they did, plus other tests as needed."
formatting changes are mine

"MM, sigh, I thought Jim Millette was going to do a DSC test and he later decided not to because there was no evidence of thermitic material. He is going to look at the DSC tests already done by the Bentham authors, and I keep asking him about the tests."

"You're right! I don't care what MM thinks. Responding to his accusations is a waste of time. I do believe in responding to technical questions and challenges tho."

"…My interest in seeing a DSC test comes from YOUR interest in it, and I am not at all convinced that the DSC test would I.D. the chips as thermite. As I have recently said, the readings graphs of energy release from the DSC tests of known thermitic material vs the red-grey chips in the bentham paper shows a tremendous difference, a factor of at least three times more energy release. It shows me nothing even remotely close to a match to nanothermite! JTL has said that this is because of variations in the samples or whatever, and I say, therefore it tells us nothing. The FTIR and other tests DO show us that gthe red-grey chips are NOT thermite. Until Kevin Ryan or Steven Jones release chips they believe are thermitic for testing, I will no longer waste time responding to your claim that Millette found the wrong chips."

As you know, it is really not necessary for Kevin Ryan or Dr. Jones, or Dr. Harrit etc etc., to release their WTC dust samples to Dr. Millette.

I am not obsessing about Dr. Millette's need to perform his own DSC testing, especially since I now know it is outside his ability.

But I do not understand why Dr. Millette chose not to perform tests which would have been very easy for his lab?

He could have further separated his larger magnetically isolated chips by taking a quick 'n easy resistance readings.

He could have heated the chips to +430C without involving DSC.

Many chips were removed from the WTC dust with a magnet, and because the majority appeared to be paint or other materials, there is a strong likelihood that the chips Dr. Millette selected from his pile for further testing were not a good match for those described as chips of interest by the Bentham Paper authors.

And if do not think a magnet would have picked up a large number of chips, try drawing a magnet through some ordinary beach sand and observe the results.

MM
 
Last edited:
In a coalfiret heat/powerplant the coal burns about 750- 950 degrees celcius, so when Harrit et al says, that the temp. in the DSC must have raised to over 1400 C., then he is wrong. Flyash is made at very lower temp. And there is many different ones. Rich in iron, alu-silicates, calciumsilicates and more.

From the article page 21:

That thermitic reactions from the red/gray chips have
indeed occurred in the DSC (rising temperature method of
ignition) is confirmed by the combined observation of 1)
highly energetic reactions occurring at approximately
430 ˚C, 2) iron-rich sphere formation so that the product
must have been sufficiently hot to be molten (over 1400 ˚C
for iron and iron oxide), 3) spheres, spheroids and nonspheroidal residues in which the iron content exceeds the
oxygen content. Significant elemental iron is now present as
expected from the thermitic reduction-oxidation reaction of
aluminum and iron oxide.

Of course it burns at 430 C., there is carbon matrix in it.
 
Last edited:
Dr. Millette had the same access to the Bentham Paper as anyone with a decent Internet connection. Just the fact that he did not attempt any Resistivity Testing or Heat testing above 400C on the red layers points to his clear lack of interest in following the Paper.
That is something you're right about. He did not have any interest in following the ATM paper (why do you capitalize it? is it sacred or something?). His interest was in finding out whether there was thermite in the allegedly thermitic chips (which according to the authors, are omnipresent and thus any allegations of not being the same chips Millette tested should be sustained by more than speculation, given the amount of chips that he isolated).

He did so by (in contrast to the ATM paper) competent methods, not by replicating incompetent methods.

And you already know the he found the chips were not thermitic.

The rest of your post is nonsensical rant. The way he would have spoiled his reputation is if he had followed the inane procedures in the ATM paper in order to perform the task at hand, and that's why he didn't do them and he instead chose the proper methodology.
 
In a coalfiret heat/powerplant the coal burns about 750- 950 degrees celcius, so when Harrit et al says, that the temp. in the DSC must have raised to over 1400 C., then he is wrong. Flyash is made at very lower temp. And there is many different ones. Rich in iron, alu-silicates, calciumsilicates and more.

From the article page 21:

That thermitic reactions from the red/gray chips have
indeed occurred in the DSC (rising temperature method of
ignition) is confirmed by the combined observation of 1)
highly energetic reactions occurring at approximately
430 ˚C, 2) iron-rich sphere formation so that the product
must have been sufficiently hot to be molten (over 1400 ˚C
for iron and iron oxide), 3) spheres, spheroids and nonspheroidal residues in which the iron content exceeds the
oxygen content. Significant elemental iron is now present as
expected from the thermitic reduction-oxidation reaction of
aluminum and iron oxide.

Of course it burns at 430 C., there is carbon matrix in it.

Carsten, I don't think that in coal power plants, coal burns at temperatures below 1000 degrees C. Temperatures are usually substantially higher, therefore almost only microspheres (cenospheres, etc.) are formed there as a typical "coal fly-ash". But in other facilities, like in various incinerators, temperatures are frequently lower than 1000 degrees and still some "microspheres" are formed there (I/we have linked some papers/sources in the past).
It follows (from my literature search) that the concentration of microspheres in the fly ash is basically proportional to the highest working temperature of these facilities.

And back to your hypothesis (very probably not the new one;)) that microspheres in Fig. 20 can be fly ash particles present in the paint.

(One remark first: even some perfect match of some XEDS spectrum of Bentham microsphere(s) with microspheres from authentic fly ash does not really prove anything - as well as the comparison with one sphere from thermite residue:rolleyes:, since I have found the whole and broad "spectrum" of various XEDS for spheres from various fly ashes. It's more "cherry picking" of data than any kind of convincing evidence)

Here is "infamous" Fig. 20:
picture.php


I would say that these spheres have diameters roughly about 5 micrometers, which does not seem to be a good for pigment intentionally added to the paint with supposed thickness ca 20 microns. I don't know any example of the paint, which contains fly ash as a pigment (but I can be wrong). And available specification of both Laclede and Tnemec primer does not say anything about fly ash.

Also, look at the upper-right micrograph, more specifically at the lower-left chip. I would say that some remnants of original gray layer are visible there, from which those microspheres probably were created in other chips in the image.

Most importantly, I believe that this observation (microspheres were not present in unheated chips, but were present in heated chips) of Harrit et al is basically accurate/not manipulated or so.
 
Last edited:
Mohr: His [Dr. Millette] intention is to replicate the tests done in the Bentham study... The Bentham paper does not report on having done a normal envirnmental forensic study of the components so Dr. Millette will do that, plus everything they did, plus other tests as needed."

Mohr: MM if I led you to believe that I asked Millette to follow the Bentham protocol, I am sorry. I have no memory of making such a claim.

What is going on here Mohr? You obviously said Millette would replicate Bentham paper.

Another thing, do you have any idea what Millette meant by saying he would do an "environmental forensic study"? It sounds like he was going to identify the sources of the dust in general.

I am not at all convinced that the DSC test would I.D. the chips as thermite.

I asked you before, but could you please tell me why you think Harrit et al try to show that they had iron oxide before ignition and iron after ignition. Do you see any problem with the spheres being iron not iron oxide?

As I have recently said, the readings graphs of energy release from the DSC tests of known thermitic material vs the red-grey chips in the bentham paper shows a tremendous difference, a factor of at least three times more energy release. It shows me nothing even remotely close to a match to nanothermite! JTL has said that this is because of variations in the samples or whatever, and I say, therefore it tells us nothing.

Unless the DSC graphs are proven to be unreliable, it tells us that Harrit´s chips release energy as fast as a known variant of superthermite. It is OK to say that you don´t understand, but then ask questions, don´t ignore. You do realize that one defining feature of superthermites and explosives is how fast they release energy?

The FTIR and other tests DO show us that gthe red-grey chips are NOT thermite. Until Kevin Ryan or Steven Jones release chips they believe are thermitic for testing, I will no longer waste time responding to your claim that Millette found the wrong chips.

Mohr, Basile has said that the dust is full of red paint chips and Jones has made it extra clear recently that a big difference between them and the chips suspected of being thermite is that the paint becomes soft in MEK while the thermite chips remain hard. One very notable thing about Millette´s chips is that they become soft in MEK, and that suggests they belong to which group of chips?

You are being very unreasonable to MM, and given what has been said about your promises of replication, maybe you should be a bit more humble?
 
What is going on here Mohr? You obviously said Millette would replicate Bentham paper.

Chris said he never ASKED Millette to replicate the paper. I looks like Millette told Chris it was his intention to replicate it.

Someone please correct me if I'm wrong, but that's how I see it.
 
...
Do you see any problem with the spheres being iron not iron oxide?
Please, jtl, which sphere in the Bentham paper is iron not iron oxide?

Unless the DSC graphs are proven to be unreliable, it tells us that Harrit´s chips release energy as fast as a known variant of superthermite. It is OK to say that you don´t understand, but then ask questions, don´t ignore. You do realize that one defining feature of superthermites and explosives is how fast they release energy?
How fast did they react? Can you provide a number? Something per second.
Was that "fast" in the case of Fig. 19?

What do the authors of the referenced LLNL study on actual nano-thermite say about DSC and how fast energy is released? They make a specific statement about this!
 
Chris said he never ASKED Millette to replicate the paper. I looks like Millette told Chris it was his intention to replicate it.

Someone please correct me if I'm wrong, but that's how I see it.

The history is a little more complicated.

The original question was, of course: "Harrit e.al. claim there is nano-thermite in red-gray chips - is this claim true or false?"

To answer that claim, you must isolate the same kinds of chips, and the best, and only way, to do that, is to run the same tests on your own specimen that Harrit e.al. used on theirs to isolate and characterize them.

Now, knowing or at least suspecting that there are different kinds of red-gray chips, the question is: Which kind or kinds do we want to look at?

I was among those who urged Chris to ask Millette to focus on chips a-d. There are two reasons for this:
a) We suspected these chips are LaClede primer
b) Those chips are far and out the best characterized in ATM.


Now let's take a look at all specimen's that appear in ATM, and the tests that we know have been done on them, and the test results:


1. Specimens:

  1. Chip a
  2. Chip b
  3. Chip c
  4. Chip d
  5. The MEK-soaked chip (Fig. 12-18)
  6. DSC-chip 1 (MacKinlay 1)
  7. DSC-chip 2 (MacKinlay 2)
  8. DSC chip 3 (Intermont)
  9. DSC chip 4 (White)
  10. A chip that, post DSC, gave rise to Fig. 21
  11. A chip that, after flame test with very hot torch, gave rise to Fig. 23 and 26
  12. A chip that, post-DSC, gave rise to Fig. 25
  13. The multi-layered chip (Fig. 31)
  14. The chip that has a carbon layer (Fig. 32 and 33)


2. Tests done on these chips before DSC or flame test (destructive tests)

2.1 Chips a-d:
  • Magnetic attraction
  • Visual separation for being "red-gray chip"
  • Photomicrograph at 1 µm scale
  • BSE images at 20 µm scale (one of the four chips)
  • BSE image at 10 µm scale
  • XEDS spectrum of bulk gray layer
  • XEDS spectrum of bulk red layer
  • BSE image at 1 µm scale showing sub-micron particles in the matrix
  • SE image at 1 µm scale
  • XEDS map of five elements (chip a)
  • XEDS of selected, identified sub-micron particles

2.2 The MEK-soaked chip:
  • Magnetic attraction
  • Visual separation for being "red-gray chip"
  • Photomicrograph at 100 µm scale (badly out of focus!)
  • SE-image at 100 µm scale
  • XEDS spectrum of bulk red layer
  • XEDS map of five elements (post MEK-soak)
  • XEDS of selected, unidentified sub-micron particles/regions

2.3 The four chips tested in the DSC
  • Magnetic attraction
  • Visual separation for being "red-gray chip"

2.4 The chip from Fig. 21
  • Magnetic attraction
  • Visual separation for being "red-gray chip"

2.5 The chip from Fig. 23 and 26
  • Magnetic attraction
  • Visual separation for being "red-gray chip"

2.6 The chip from Fig. 25
  • Magnetic attraction
  • Visual separation for being "red-gray chip"

2.7 The multi-layered chip
  • Magnetic attraction
  • Visual separation for being "red-gray chip"

2.8 The carbon-layered chip
  • Magnetic attraction
  • Visual separation for being "red-gray chip"
  • XEDS spectrum of bulk gray layer
  • MEK-soaking (though no description of consistency is provided, except that the red layer has expanded and displays "porosity".)


So we see that all chips, except for the first five, have been characterized by magnetic attraction and visual appearance only before being destroyed in fire.

We see that neither DSC nor electric resistance nor anything else has been done to all chips to isolate them from all the other chips that are attracted to a magnet and that are red-gray chips.


As jtl and MM assert that many red-gray chips that are attracted to a magnet are in fact paint, they ought to admit that all these chips might indeed be just paint, or might be different from one another.


How could Millette selöect a chip like the ones that gave rise to Fig. 21, 23, 25, or the four chips that were tested in the DSC, when nothing is known about them except that they are red-gray and magnetic?



So of course Millette went for the four chips on which lots of detailed data is available: chips a-d.

And those have been showm to not contain thermite.

This means that Harrit e.al. must discard chips a-d, or revoke their conclusion that "the" red-gray chips are thermitic.

Once they discard chips a-d, they are out of evidence for anything "nano", as none of the other data shows anything in sub-micron size.
 
...Unless the DSC graphs are proven to be unreliable, it tells us that Harrit´s chips release energy as fast as a known variant of superthermite. It is OK to say that you don´t understand, but then ask questions, don´t ignore. You do realize that one defining feature of superthermites and explosives is how fast they release energy?
...

You are being very unreasonable to MM, and given what has been said about your promises of replication, maybe you should be a bit more humble?
Ironically, no thermite used on 911. Makes discussion a delusion based on fantasy. And you call your friend a nut on 911 issues?

The DSC in the paper prove the dust is not super-thermite. The DSC traces match soil, and burnt-wood better. But you don't seem to understand chemistry, or the purpose of DSC.

Millette found no thermite. A DSC test has a different purpose which you can't understand, or research. Jones/Harrit fooled you.

Thermite used on 911 is nonsense made up by a Jones for some idiotic idea, or he is insane. Why does Jones lie, is he insane? Jones found Harrit, who is insane on 911 issues. Where did the bad guys in Harrit's fantasy, place the 100 tons of thermite? Jones says a valid theory is in the ceiling tiles. Are Jones' claims signs of insanity, some other mental problems? Jones is very polite, and I can't figure out why he lies. I knew this guy who was very polite, and acted as personable, like Jones acts, and he had brain cancer. A mental problem could be why Jones has made up lies, since a physics has the tools to understand the WTC collapse was due to fire and impacts. The fires up to collapse were more energy than 2,500 TONS of thermite, and that is ignoring the initial jet fuel fires with more energy than 630 TONS of thermite. Who can a physicist be as dumb as Jones acts on the physics of 911?

You don't know the purpose of DSC. Did you take any chemistry courses?
Why would anyone do a DSC on unknown material? Do you know how much the equipment cost? Did Jones/Harrit steal time on DSC? Anyone out there with ruined DSC, and you don't know who messed it up?

MM thinks thermite was used on 911. A fantasy dumber than dirt. MM's version of 911 is a fantasy where thermite leaves no evidence, but is found in dust.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom