WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

I'm not sure that is the reason. If Millete does a DSC and the results match will he accept that there was no thermite (of any flavor). This is an out for them. If he does this then they will want "conductivity". After that, Millete will have to eat the same breakfast as the Harrit "scientist". It will never end, it can't for their belief.

If the answer is no. Why bother? They don't really want the test.
They will never accept any conclusion except thermite no matter how many tests are performed.

If Millette did a DSC and iron spheres were found they would say that Millette has thermite and discard his FTIR and TEM-SAED results.

If Millette did a DSC and iron spheres were not found then they will claim that Millette has the wrong chips.

There is not a single thing that can be done to make them change their minds regarding thermite. It's a pointless exercise.
 
There is not a single thing that can be done to make them change their minds regarding thermite. It's a pointless exercise.

I agree, they had to invent a special type of super thermite (that they have not specified) to account for the DSC that proves their sample is not thermite.

Thier own paper (data) proves them wrong.
 
I agree, they had to invent a special type of super thermite (that they have not specified) to account for the DSC that proves their sample is not thermite.

Thier own paper (data) proves them wrong.

And they want to do DSC tests on chips that are the wrong chips so they can prove thermite or is it to prove its not thermite ? I lose track with all the BS
 
And they want to do DSC tests on chips that are the wrong chips so they can prove thermite or is it to prove its not thermite ? I lose track with all the BS
It's not hard to do. One problem is, no one really knows what chips produced these "spheres". I think they wanted it that way. ;)
 
They specify what chips produced the "spheres"? Where? Show us (you can't, because they "forgot" to document this, BTW)

quit spinning. they did not say....well you know what, 3 chips formed iron and silicon microspheres but that silly chip #4 did not.

where do you see in the paper that out of the 4 chips that one or two or three did not produce iron and silicon microspheres.
 
They will never accept any conclusion except thermite no matter how many tests are performed.

If Millette did a DSC and iron spheres were found they would say that Millette has thermite and discard his FTIR and TEM-SAED results.
is the FTIR and TEM-SAED results from the same chip that produced the iron and silicon microspheres in the DSC?

If Millette did a DSC and iron spheres were not found then they will claim that Millette has the wrong chips.

what would you conclude from that....
 
is the FTIR and TEM-SAED results from the same chip that produced the iron and silicon microspheres in the DSC?



what would you conclude from that....

Which part of "there was no evidence of thermite found on WTC steel" are you unable to comprehend?

It is silly to conduct a study looking for thermite when it was not used to destroy the WTC on 911. Are you supporting liars who made up the conclusion of thermite based on nothing? The DSC does not match thermite, Jones shows this in their paper. What do you call failure when they publish their own debunking in the same paper?
 
What do you mean for a "quick buck"? Did you choose Millette because he was cheaper? For the labs you go to, don´t tell them what this is about and especially not that this is connected to 9/11.

If money is tight and you can´t swing the DSC tests, maybe Millette could at least do some tests with some heating apparatus like Basile, and easily test different kinds of chips without spending some big bucks at independent labs. Jones et al say there are red paint chips in the dust and it seems possible to get samples of confirmed paint chips from the WTC, so if these chips also make those iron spheres when heated to 700 degrees they would not have much of case left. To be fair, the chips would have to have a gray layer to test the gray layer hypothesis by Sunstealer and Kminek.
JTL, the "quick buck" question wasn't about Millette being cheaper. It was about the fact that they were willing to do tests that even I knew would not help I.D. the chips, based on the Bentham paper (there was no Millette study yet, obviously).
 
i have offered chris mohr my own cold hard cash to do a DSC test. the money is still burning a hole in my pocket!!



millette said he used ASTM standards but i found that when he did the muffle furnace test at 400C, ASTM standard is 450C. i could only find the muffle furnace test in ASTM D 4451-02. i emailed millette and told him i would provide the money for another muffle furnace test at 450C but have had no reply.

i think the guys here on the forum and millette are afraid to go to the 430Cish temp.
I'm not afraid of your generous offer, and I did try to find a lab. So far no success, as you well know. Would someone else like to take this search up? What I would like would be a DSC test AND an independent analysis of the results. What does this test show? If money allows, I suppose we could do the JTL idea, which is not to ask "are these chips thermitic" but rather "what is this stuff?" That's an unusual request and would involve more testing to narrow it down but if some rich person wants to throw more money at this, then let's try to organize a test together and not separately. I am not afraid of the results.
 
mohr: JTL, the "quick buck" question wasn't about Millette being cheaper. It was about the fact that they were willing to do tests that even I knew would not help I.D. the chips, based on the Bentham paper

What tests did they want to do? When you looked for a lab, did you not look for a lab that could replicate the Bentham tests?

but rather "what is this stuff?

It is about replicating tests others have done, and trying to answer Harrit´s question about a proposed "prosaic substance". Also testing Kminek gray layer hypothesis for iron spheres.

Senenmut: i emailed millette and told him i would provide the money for another muffle furnace test at 450C but have had no reply.

It does seem a little strange that he would not do this since he was heating them to nearly ignition temperature anyway.
 
Last edited:
I'm not afraid of your generous offer, and I did try to find a lab. So far no success, as you well know. Would someone else like to take this search up? What I would like would be a DSC test AND an independent analysis of the results. What does this test show? If money allows, I suppose we could do the JTL idea, which is not to ask "are these chips thermitic" but rather "what is this stuff?" That's an unusual request and would involve more testing to narrow it down but if some rich person wants to throw more money at this, then let's try to organize a test together and not separately. I am not afraid of the results.

Why did the labs turn you down? Did you know you can't use some DSC equipment to test unknown junk? You might have to pay for the equipment. DSC is not used to identify squat, it has an entirely different purpose. Millette found no thermite; does Millette think a DSC is required to identify thermite?

This is a simple yes or no type deal. Is DSC required to identify thermite?

Why does the DSC trace in Harrit's paper not match thermite?

It is cool to do test stuff. I have my water tested, to see if it matches the data supplied by the water company.

Why is DSC needed? Because some gullible people who think thermite was used on 911 were fooled by failed nuts who published a fraud paper.

Millette's did not find thermite. Makes further tests nonsense. There is no thermite damage to any WTC steel, until the towers were cleaned up using torches etc to dismantle the WTC debris pile for several months.

1 plus 1 is 2. Jones says 1 plus 1 is thermite. No need to study the nonsense Jones made up in 2005 due to bias, or mental problems.

What did Millette say about DSC test? Did Jones and his nuts ruin some University DSC equipment, steal time/lab to do their fake study? Don't ask Gage for money, he can't have reality mess up his fringe money maker scam - $1,000,000 and still going.
 
quit spinning. they did not say....well you know what, 3 chips formed iron and silicon microspheres but that silly chip #4 did not.

where do you see in the paper that out of the 4 chips that one or two or three did not produce iron and silicon microspheres.
I'm not spinning anything. I asked a simple question. What chips did they put in the DSC and which ones produced "spheres". A simple page number that documents this will do. Yes, I have read the paper, have you?
 
I'm not spinning anything. I asked a simple question. What chips did they put in the DSC and which ones produced "spheres". A simple page number that documents this will do. Yes, I have read the paper, have you?
which ones did not?
 
That's not an answer. What chips did they put in the DSC? You know they had more than one type? Chips a-d and the MEK chips.

yes it is an answer. so how many of those 4 chips did the authors say DID NOT produce iron or silicon microspheres?

from the paper:
"Fig. (2). Photomicrographs of red/gray chips from samples 1-4 of the WTC dust involved in this study, shown in (a)-(d) respectively."


and the MEK chip:
"The chip that was used for this experiment was extracted
from dust sample 2 and is shown in the images below."
 
yes it is an answer. so how many of those 4 chips did the authors say DID NOT produce iron or silicon microspheres?

from the paper:
"Fig. (2). Photomicrographs of red/gray chips from samples 1-4 of the WTC dust involved in this study, shown in (a)-(d) respectively."


and the MEK chip:
"The chip that was used for this experiment was extracted
from dust sample 2 and is shown in the images below."

It's still not an answer, you're asking a question in return.
Which exact chips did they put in the DSC? Which exact chips produced spheres?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom