Mohr: JTL FYI I have pushed for the DSC tests but I am not certain of its value. Jones et al say it's essential, Millette et al say it's useless. As a journalist I am unqualified to determine the correct answer to this disagreement.
There is no question about the value, this is a procedure set out by the original developers of superthermite and Harrit et al followed it. Also, you cannot replicate Harrit´s paper or evaluate any results without repeating those tests, it is as simple as that.
Another side of that coin is statement by Harrit et al in the paper:
To merit consideration, any assertion that a prosaic sub-
stance such as paint could match the characteristics we have
described would have to be accompanied by empirical dem-
onstration using a sample of the proposed material, including
SEM/XEDS and DSC analyses.
This is why I would like to see a study that has some kind of pre-approved protocol and lab with even one knowledgeable person form this side working WITH Mark Basile. I tried to do that with Kevin Ryan and was strongly rebuffed. My response was to go forward without him and present him with Jim Millette as a fait accompli. I stand behind Millette's integrity but I still want to see a study that is truly done by people on both sides. Can you contact Mark Basile about this and ask if this is possible?
The protocol is already pre-approved, and you have hired Millette to follow it.
If you cannot trust him to do that take your money somewhere else. If you want to contact Basile then do it, but I was under the impression that he has already completed his study. I don´t know why Ryan refused you, but have you considered that your buddies here like to call him and the other authors incompetent morons? It is beyond me why they should want to have anything to do with you or anyone from this forum.
I have no independent opinion on the value of the DSC tests. However, I was able to see that the graphs comparing nanothermite and the chips looked pretyy worthless, either because of the reasons you give or because the chips really are paint. The test doesn't provide a match so for whatever reason I can't see its value.
The "match" in question is about the width of the peak being as narrow as the compared sample, so the tests did provide a match. The ignition temperature and total output are irrelevant. The theory is that paint will show noticeably wider peaks. Millette could perhaps show that the DSC is not a reliable method to prove this theory, by comparing paint in DSC.
Millette tests could also show that Harrit´s results are inconclusive, and so even if he did not debunk Harrit, he would then force Harrit et al to prove their hypothesis with another paper including more data.
I don't know about the hard vs soft chips. All efforts to get chips Jones et al believed were thermitic into Millette's hands were rebuffed, remember.
Unfortunately this has been made quite clear by Jones, so it is obvious that Millette will have to refine his choice of chips. As I noted before, you are not really in a position to scoff at the "different chips" explanation while your buddies base their objections to Harrit on the same kind of explanations.
Don´t you think Millette is qualified to find those chips by himself? If he is not sure about something then he simply has to contact Jones or any one of the authors for clarifications.