WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

Mohr: JTL FYI I have pushed for the DSC tests but I am not certain of its value. Jones et al say it's essential, Millette et al say it's useless. As a journalist I am unqualified to determine the correct answer to this disagreement.

There is no question about the value, this is a procedure set out by the original developers of superthermite and Harrit et al followed it. Also, you cannot replicate Harrit´s paper or evaluate any results without repeating those tests, it is as simple as that.

Another side of that coin is statement by Harrit et al in the paper:
To merit consideration, any assertion that a prosaic sub-
stance such as paint could match the characteristics we have
described would have to be accompanied by empirical dem-
onstration using a sample of the proposed material, including
SEM/XEDS and DSC analyses.


This is why I would like to see a study that has some kind of pre-approved protocol and lab with even one knowledgeable person form this side working WITH Mark Basile. I tried to do that with Kevin Ryan and was strongly rebuffed. My response was to go forward without him and present him with Jim Millette as a fait accompli. I stand behind Millette's integrity but I still want to see a study that is truly done by people on both sides. Can you contact Mark Basile about this and ask if this is possible?

The protocol is already pre-approved, and you have hired Millette to follow it.
If you cannot trust him to do that take your money somewhere else. If you want to contact Basile then do it, but I was under the impression that he has already completed his study. I don´t know why Ryan refused you, but have you considered that your buddies here like to call him and the other authors incompetent morons? It is beyond me why they should want to have anything to do with you or anyone from this forum.

I have no independent opinion on the value of the DSC tests. However, I was able to see that the graphs comparing nanothermite and the chips looked pretyy worthless, either because of the reasons you give or because the chips really are paint. The test doesn't provide a match so for whatever reason I can't see its value.

The "match" in question is about the width of the peak being as narrow as the compared sample, so the tests did provide a match. The ignition temperature and total output are irrelevant. The theory is that paint will show noticeably wider peaks. Millette could perhaps show that the DSC is not a reliable method to prove this theory, by comparing paint in DSC.

Millette tests could also show that Harrit´s results are inconclusive, and so even if he did not debunk Harrit, he would then force Harrit et al to prove their hypothesis with another paper including more data.

I don't know about the hard vs soft chips. All efforts to get chips Jones et al believed were thermitic into Millette's hands were rebuffed, remember.

Unfortunately this has been made quite clear by Jones, so it is obvious that Millette will have to refine his choice of chips. As I noted before, you are not really in a position to scoff at the "different chips" explanation while your buddies base their objections to Harrit on the same kind of explanations.

Don´t you think Millette is qualified to find those chips by himself? If he is not sure about something then he simply has to contact Jones or any one of the authors for clarifications.
 
There is no point answering you Oystein, because any answer goes in one ear and out the other. But I am going to answer this one thing because others might benefit:

The superthermite in that paper(28) is just normal feo/al nanothermite, which means it does not have an energetic organic matrix, and therefore the output is limited(=3.9) to the thermite ingredients. Superthermites with other energetic materials present, such as an energetic organic matrix, are not subject to this limitation. As you know, Harrit does suggest that his chips have this kind of energetic matrix.

They did not find thermite in the dust from the WTC. Make Jones' paper a fake, fraud, a delusion, fantasy, dirt dumb stupid conclusion. Anyway...

Millette found not thermite, Harrit lied and says thermite. Millette study matches the findings of studies by others who never found thermite. Then the big seal the deal, no thermite damage, no thermite evidence found on any WTC steel.

Why did Harrit's thermite chips not have the 3.9? Why is jet fuel 10 times the energy of thermite? Why do we use gasoline instead of thermite to run cars? Fuel oil instead of thermite to heat our houses?

JonesHarritDelusion.jpg

What is amazing, the nuts on 911, Jones and Harrit, have a fantasy conclusion on their chips. They are thermite, tons of thermite not burned on 911. A mixture so super secret it burns faster and has extra stuff, like clay and epoxy, to make it more whatever. They spread a lie about thermite, made up by minds burned out for reality, producing fantasy dumbed down for people who can't think for themselves.

Why present this chart showing two samples can't put out the heat of standard thermite. We Jones and Harrit have is dust, if it has thermite in it, someone planted it and they were fooling with nuts. Shame on anyone who seeded the dust for Jones; it is not nice to fool with old professors with early onset, and advance stages of woo.

http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/JetFuelandWoodBeatThermite.jpg
If you want heat energy on a broad scale, a big office fire beats 2,500 Tons of thermite. Math, chemistry, and physics, not in the tool box of 911 truth.

Harrit's chips with less energy than thermite. Super-less-energy-thermite. wow
 
There is no question about the value, this is a procedure set out by the original developers of superthermite and Harrit et al followed it.

Please document and describe, step by step, that procedure set out by the original developers of superthermite, and then document and describe how Harrit et al followed it, step by step :)


After you have tried that, and discovered that Harrit et al did in fact NOT follow that protocol, please revise the remainder of your post :)
 
...
The protocol is already pre-approved, and you have hired Millette to follow it. ...

Please document and describe, step by step, the protocol (using published documentation available BEFORE Millette published his preliminary report!), and then document and descibed how Millette did, or did not follow that protocol :)

After you have discovered that Millette did in fact follow the protocol, please tell us how you will revise your stance on the matter :)
 
Oystein and JTL,

I did not lay out a protocol for Millette to follow. I hired to him to use his expertise to answer the question, "Is there thermitic material in the reg-grey chips?" I did not tell him how to do his job. I believe he did a very good job, he was confident he found the correct chips even without the help of Ryan/Jones et al. Look around on blogs and you will find 9/11 Truth people saying that the Bentham paper is in real trouble now that Millette has refuted it. Kevin Ryan met me personally and knows me personally. He's a very intelligent, thoughtful, sincere man. He refused to cooperate with me for reasons I am not going to try to guess too much about. But after getting fired from UL and years of withering attacks from his opponents and being ignored by most of his colleagues, it seems that he has fallen into a siege mentality. His response to my request for chips for Millette was an ad hominem attack in advance of Millette's preliminary report, as many people here well know, the details of which are here for JTL's benefit: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=212725&page=86

There is certainly a question about the value of the DSC test; it has been hotly debated here for the past year. And there is obviously no agreement on protocol between Harrit et al and Millette. From what I can see, the original Tilltoson study was not replicated by Harrit et al (in fact, many important tests were supposedly done and never published or released), Mark Basile has admitted that he didn't have the equipment to replicate all the tests done for the Bentham paper, and then Millette did not replicate the protocol set out in the Bentham paper because the DSC test is not part of HIS protocol in determining the presence or absence of thermite. Oystein and JTL, am I wrong here? And Mark Basile and Rick Shaddock are trying to raise money for yet another experiment. How can anyone say there is a protocol agreed upon by all concerned? THERE IS NOT! So before thousands of dollars are spent on another study, how about we put out heads together and agree in advance on a protocol and a means of finding an independent lab?
 
Oystein and JTL,

I did not lay out a protocol for Millette to follow. I hired to him to use his expertise to answer the question, "Is there thermitic material in the reg-grey chips?" I did not tell him how to do his job. I believe he did a very good job, he was confident he found the correct chips even without the help of Ryan/Jones et al. Look around on blogs and you will find 9/11 Truth people saying that the Bentham paper is in real trouble now that Millette has refuted it. Kevin Ryan met me personally and knows me personally. He's a very intelligent, thoughtful, sincere man. He refused to cooperate with me for reasons I am not going to try to guess too much about. But after getting fired from UL and years of withering attacks from his opponents and being ignored by most of his colleagues, it seems that he has fallen into a siege mentality. His response to my request for chips for Millette was an ad hominem attack in advance of Millette's preliminary report, as many people here well know, the details of which are here for JTL's benefit: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=212725&page=86

There is certainly a question about the value of the DSC test; it has been hotly debated here for the past year. And there is obviously no agreement on protocol between Harrit et al and Millette. From what I can see, the original Tilltoson study was not replicated by Harrit et al (in fact, many important tests were supposedly done and never published or released), Mark Basile has admitted that he didn't have the equipment to replicate all the tests done for the Bentham paper, and then Millette did not replicate the protocol set out in the Bentham paper because the DSC test is not part of HIS protocol in determining the presence or absence of thermite. Oystein and JTL, am I wrong here? And Mark Basile and Rick Shaddock are trying to raise money for yet another experiment. How can anyone say there is a protocol agreed upon by all concerned? THERE IS NOT! So before thousands of dollars are spent on another study, how about we put out heads together and agree in advance on a protocol and a means of finding an independent lab?

Not to butt in here as my comment isn't really technically related, but it seems apparent to me that no matter what protocol is followed, it will never satisfy everyone. The DSC is not relative in identifying what the material is, if I understand the information correctly. Before an attack by JTL, I don't read just what's posted here. I take what's posted here, research it, and come to my own conclusion.

As Ozeco said awhile ago, there could have been tons of thermite at the scene, but it makes no difference. There was absolutely no explosives used to take down the WTC. Whether that be super\nano\uber or any other. If we are speaking to thousands of dollars being spent, wouldn't it be a waste no matter what it was spent on? I donated to the first, but at some point I think enough has to be enough. Truthers will always be truthers.
 
Last edited:
Oystein and JTL,

I did not lay out a protocol for Millette to follow. I hired to him to use his expertise to answer the question, "Is there thermitic material in the reg-grey chips?" I did not tell him how to do his job. I believe he did a very good job, he was confident he found the correct chips even without the help of Ryan/Jones et al. ...
Yes.

Very important to point out that you gave Millette an objective, a hypothesis to test, a question to answer - and not some laundry list of nonsense tests to do.

Millette, having decades of pertinant experience, doing exactly this kind of research day in and day out for a living, figured out himself to replicate the Chip Isolation procedure to t, so that he could attend to the objective by studying the correct subject.

And then he chose the competent methods to accomplish the objective.
And he did.

He answered your question "Is there thermitic material in the reg-grey chips?" - the answer is an unambiguous "No!"

Another important fact to point out here is that Jones and Legge, by speculating that Millette studied "wrong" ("non-thermitic") chips, implicitly admit that Millette indeed proved there is no thermite in these chips!

There is certainly a question about the value of the DSC test; it has been hotly debated here for the past year. And there is obviously no agreement on protocol between Harrit et al and Millette. From what I can see, the original Tilltoson study was not replicated by Harrit et al (in fact, many important tests were supposedly done and never published or released), Mark Basile has admitted that he didn't have the equipment to replicate all the tests done for the Bentham paper, and then Millette did not replicate the protocol set out in the Bentham paper because the DSC test is not part of HIS protocol in determining the presence or absence of thermite. Oystein and JTL, am I wrong here?
All correct, spot on, and pertinent, Chris :)

And Mark Basile and Rick Shaddock are trying to raise money for yet another experiment. How can anyone say there is a protocol agreed upon by all concerned? THERE IS NOT! So before thousands of dollars are spent on another study, how about we put out heads together and agree in advance on a protocol and a means of finding an independent lab?
Good idea!

I am not really clear what Basile's objective really is, what hypothesis he wants to have tested, which question answered.

When I talked to him on the phone, he said that he could be convinced that there really is no thermite in any of the chips, if that is what the evidence eventually shows[1] - but that he'd still be puzzled that these iron-rich droplets are found in the residue. So it appears to me that the question he has in mind, although not explicitly stated yet, is: "Which kinds of red-gray chips leave iron-rich droplets when ignited in a DSC, and why?". Which is a reasonable question to ask. There are several different possibilies that I can think of:
1. These droplets don't really form as a result of heating and igniting
2. This happens as a result of a thermite reaction
3. This happens as a result of processes other than the thermite reaction
4. In some chips, this happens as a result of thermite, in others for other reasons

Basile is still unclear about chip isolation.
His proposal starts with:
"Sample Preparation:
- Red/gray chip separation using optical microscopy and magnetic attraction to assist in isolation of particles of interest.
- Optical images of collected particulates as collected at appropriate magnifications to record condition as collected. "​
Which is the Harrit and the Millette protocol.

But then later, when discussiong "Analytical costs", he speaks about "red chips of suspected primer from building dust" and "known thermitic red/gray chips" - but does not explain how to isolate "red chips of suspected primer from building dust" and "known thermitic red/gray chips". How does he "know" that chips are "thermitic"? What makes him "suspect" that one chip is paint, and another is not?



[1] Footnote for jtl: As far as I have seen, you have not yet apologized for LYING when you misrepresented me as claiming that Basile has already said there is no thermite in the chips! I have not forgotten that you told a lie about me!
 
Truthers shouldn't be pushing Millette to do DSC, truthers should be pushing Harrit and Jones to release their FTIR data in (response to Millette).

The Gash report describes FTIR spectra which characterize this energetic material. We have performed these same tests and will report the results elsewhere.
[page]26 The Open Chemical Physics Journal, 2009, Volume 2 [paragraph 4].

Nearly 4 years since publication, but no sign that Harrit or Jones will publish data they already have. What are they afraid of? Don't they want the truth?

Why is Millette castigated for not doing DSC when he did perform FTIR just as Harrit et al did? People are complaining that Millette didn't follow some sort of protocol, but they don't realise that he did perform FTIR just as Harrit et al did.

Surely comparing FTIR traces between Millette and Harrit is the best way forward because anyone can then analyse the data from a definitive materials characterisation technique.
 
I did not lay out a protocol for Millette to follow. I hired to him to use his expertise to answer the question, "Is there thermitic material in the reg-grey chips?" I did not tell him how to do his job.
The question, "Is there thermitic material in the reg-grey chips?", can also be asked in a different way that will also answer the question, namely "what is it?".

Both are a materials characterisation exercise. Obviously, if no thermite is found then there is no thermitic material present. There are numerous methods and techniques that can be used to ascertain the answer to "what is it?". The important thing is to not rely upon one method for the answer, but to use more than one technique to corroborate the data from the previous test.

So for example Millette does what every lab would do once you have the samples you want to look at, which is; look at them under optical magnification and then "stick it in the SEM". The information gained is highly likely to influence the next technique to use for further analysis (if one is required at all). A lot of the time further techniques are not required because a combination of optical microscopy, SEM and EDX are sufficient to get the answer due to past experience. This is where an experienced materials engineer/SEM operator really comes to the fore.

There are hundreds, if not thousands, of labs around the world that can answer the question, "what is this?", by performing independent analysis, but the truthers refuse to release their material or raise sufficient funds to have the work done. I wonder why?
 
Mohr: I did not lay out a protocol for Millette to follow.

You did not have to, it was already there in the Bentham paper, as prescribed by the original developers of superthermite.

I believe he did a very good job, he was confident he found the correct chips even without the help of Ryan/Jones et al. Look around on blogs and you will find 9/11 Truth people saying that the Bentham paper is in real trouble now that Millette has refuted it.

You can believe what you want, and you will continue to do so if you ignore everything that disputes your conclusions. As the Millette paper is right now, Harrit et al could probably refute it with a one-page paper, just by pointing out that his chips have titanium and become soft in MEK, thus showing Millette does not have the same chips.

His response to my request for chips for Millette was an ad hominem attack in advance of Millette's preliminary report, as many people here well know, the details of which are here for JTL's benefit: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=212725&page=86

You should have known that the truthers would be very suspicious of any scientist that had been involved in any of the official investigations, and not telling Ryan about Millette´s past was simply a mistake.
You also represent a forum where Ryan et al are called frauds all the time so why should Ryan not use the opportunity to mention the EPA whistleblower?

Try to see his side of the story.

There is certainly a question about the value of the DSC test; it has been hotly debated here for the past year. And there is obviously no agreement on protocol between Harrit et al and Millette. From what I can see, the original Tilltoson study was not replicated by Harrit et al (in fact, many important tests were supposedly done and never published or released),

Mohr, your buddies on this forum have questioned the value of the DSC, but they say a lot of things that don´t make any sense. There is no one "original" Tillotson study, there are several original superthermite studies referenced, and the basic protocol to determine if the material is energetic by a thermite reaction or reduction is very clear.

Mark Basile has admitted that he didn't have the equipment to replicate all the tests done for the Bentham paper, and then Millette did not replicate the protocol set out in the Bentham paper because the DSC test is not part of HIS protocol in determining the presence or absence of thermite.

Mark Basile replicated the paper and followed the protocol as far as he could. He did not have a DSC but he still replicated the ignition tests with his own equipment and confirmed that the chips ignite and produce iron spheres. He also has not published his paper so there is still a chance it will have ignition tests in DSC.

Millette is making his own protocol and this is why he is testing chips that become soft in MEK even though Harrit et al say their chips remain hard soaked in MEK, and as I said above the result is that Harrit et al will debunk his paper in one page.

how about we put out heads together and agree in advance on a protocol and a means of finding an independent lab?

The protocol was set by the developers and followed by Harrit et al, then Henry and then Basile. Millette is the only one that refuses for some reason.
Finding an independent lab is a very good idea.
 
. As the Millette paper is right now, Harrit et al could probably refute it with a one-page paper, just by pointing out that his chips have titanium and become soft in MEK, thus showing Millette does not have the same chips.

So why won't the truthers supply Millette with the said chips ?

If they are that confident it shouldn't be a problem.
 
You did not have to, it was already there in the Bentham paper, as prescribed by the original developers of superthermite.

I think you're missing the point. The point wasn't to replicate the Bentham paper or use it's processes. The point was to figure out what the red/gray chips consist of, which is what Millette did. Using equipment better designed for that purpose.
 
I think you're missing the point. The point wasn't to replicate the Bentham paper or use it's processes. The point was to figure out what the red/gray chips consist of, which is what Millette did. Using equipment better designed for that purpose.

I don't think jtl will get it.

He likes the idea of finding an independent lab but the tests will have to be carried out the way he says. Not independent really :D
 
I don't think jtl will get it.

He likes the idea of finding an independent lab but the tests will have to be carried out the way he says. Not independent really :D
An independent lab could still be hired to test the chips by following a pre-agreed-upon protocol, with chips coming from both Millette and the bentham team (if both sides could agree!!!). If the lab thinks other tests are necessary or the DSC is unnecessary, they can do the extra tests needed but also do the DSC or whatever tests they think are unnecessary. OK, less independent maybe, but I would think you can hire someone in a lab to jump up and down on a red-grey chip with green sneakers if you hired them to add such a "test" to the protocol. In their report they could say that they were hired to do such a test and it did not help them identify the chips. So their report would be written independently, even if the protocol were controlled by the customer.
 
An independent lab could still be hired to test the chips by following a pre-agreed-upon protocol, with chips coming from both Millette and the bentham team (if both sides could agree!!!). If the lab thinks other tests are necessary or the DSC is unnecessary, they can do the extra tests needed but also do the DSC or whatever tests they think are unnecessary. OK, less independent maybe, but I would think you can hire someone in a lab to jump up and down on a red-grey chip with green sneakers if you hired them to add such a "test" to the protocol. In their report they could say that they were hired to do such a test and it did not help them identify the chips. So their report would be written independently, even if the protocol were controlled by the customer.

I am under the impression that a dust study "a la carte" might be slightly expensive. Millette was able to identify the chips for the cost due to knowing what he would need to do. If you selected an independent lab, and asked for random tests to be done I would think it would be a bit more expensive. Granted I haven't done research to follow that up. Considering that the DSC test alone was quoted at around $1,000 IIRC, it might be out of everyones price range.
 
You did not have to, it was already there in the Bentham paper, as prescribed by the original developers of superthermite.
Could you please give us a citation or reference to "the original developers of superthermite" and their protocol. Thanks.
 
"I think you're missing the point. The point wasn't to replicate the Bentham paper or use it's processes. The point was to figure out what the red/gray chips consist of, which is what Millette did. Using equipment better designed for that purpose."

A lot of red/gray chips were attracted by the magnet.

A lot of those chips were paint.

Many of the chips were red debris containing magnetically-attracted material.

If Dr. Millette has been researching poorly matched chips, he's going to have poorly matched findings.

MM
 
A lot of red/gray chips were attracted by the magnet.

A lot of those chips were paint.

Many of the chips were red debris containing magnetically-attracted material.

If Dr. Millette has been researching poorly matched chips, he's going to have poorly matched findings.

MM

It is impossible to find thermite in the chips because no thermite was used on 911. Millette can't find thermite in the dust when no thermite was used. A wasted study, except to show 911 truth complain when their theories are busted by science.

What do you do after 11 years of supporting the fraud of Jones? Have you produced any steel that thermite was used on at the WTC on 911? No.

Asking questions, giving answers. Why did you support the anti-intellectual movement known as 911 truth? After Millette's study, do you have doubts about your claims, the failed fantasy stuff of 911 truth?
 
Could you please give us a citation or reference to "the original developers of superthermite" and their protocol. Thanks.

Sunstealer: In the Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper, I responded to Jtl:

"Important in our respect is the plain fact that Harrit et al compared their DSC curves with one single "superthermite" curve published in paper 28. And since this curve was measured under pure nitrogen, and Gash explained in detail why in his e-mail, it was a duty of Bentham authors to run their DSC experiments under inert as well. They did not do that, hence they failed to follow original protocol. And all their DSC results are fully compatible with the combustion of polymer binder under air."

Indeed, another evasive response followed, showing again, that he is not able to admit plain facts and he is not able to understand and learn very basics, like that organic polymers burn in air etc.:D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom