WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

An independent lab could still be hired to test the chips by following a pre-agreed-upon protocol, with chips coming from both Millette and the bentham team (if both sides could agree!!!). If the lab thinks other tests are necessary or the DSC is unnecessary, they can do the extra tests needed but also do the DSC or whatever tests they think are unnecessary. OK, less independent maybe, but I would think you can hire someone in a lab to jump up and down on a red-grey chip with green sneakers if you hired them to add such a "test" to the protocol. In their report they could say that they were hired to do such a test and it did not help them identify the chips. So their report would be written independently, even if the protocol were controlled by the customer.

Hi Chris,
This whole thing about new independent lab tests is nothing more than a scam for the truthers to try and gain some form of control for their failing movement.

Jtl is only here to argue round in circles. He has bought nothing new to the table.

As far as I can see the truthers response is, DSC tests are needed, he has the wrong chips and he didn't do any electrical resistance tests. None of these claims have any scientific reference to the work Millette has carried out. It's all just a truther ploy to keep the ball in play.

Millette has yet to finish his work and we are aware of why this is taking some time. When Millette has finished his work, that's when the truthers can start to criticise his work and let's face it, the easy cop out is to say he has the wrong chips :D It's unlikely Jones et al will come out in public to criticise Milettes work unless you call the censorship of 911blogger public.

There is no need to do anything. If truthers want to prove Millette is wrong, they will have to produce evidence and we all know that evidence is not their strong point.
 
Last edited:
@Oystein

"Which kinds of red-gray chips leave iron-rich droplets when ignited in a DSC, and why?". Which is a reasonable question to ask. There are several different possibilies that I can think of:
1. These droplets don't really form as a result of heating and igniting
2. This happens as a result of a thermite reaction
3. This happens as a result of processes other than the thermite reaction
4. In some chips, this happens as a result of thermite, in others for other reasons"

Fig. (21). Spheroid found in post-DSC residue showing iron-rich sphere and the corresponding XEDS spectrum. The carbon peak must be
considered indeterminate here since this sample was flashed with a thin carbon layer in order to preclude charging under the electron beam.

So it was there in the first place. (Before heated)
 
@Oystein
...
Fig. (21). Spheroid found in post-DSC residue showing iron-rich sphere and the corresponding XEDS spectrum. The carbon peak must be
considered indeterminate here since this sample was flashed with a thin carbon layer in order to preclude charging under the electron beam.

So it was there in the first place. (Before heated)

I don't understand - why?
 
Unfortunately you have forgotten about the Direct Reduction method for producing iron from iron oxides. The reason for looking at such a method is the reduction in temperature required to produce iron (sponge iron) in comparison with the blast furnace which produces pig iron.

A reduction in heat required means less money spent on fuel which is why the direct reduction method has been studied.

Incidentally it's the method that has been predominantly used in man's history - research "Bloomery". That process of producing iron does not require the temperatures used in a blast furnace, nor does it require the addition of slag forming additives.

The direct reduction method is only valid, however, if it is thermodynamically possible. The graph I posted gives you the information required to see the thermodynamics associated with the reduction of iron ores via the Boudouard Reaction.

I've coloured the graph so it's easier to see the phases:

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=845&pictureid=7307[/qimg]

You will also note that I've drawn a line representing the lowest temperature that is thermodynamically possible for magnetite to reduce to iron which corresponds to 570°C - well below the 700°C obtained in the DSC. This figure is readily available in the literature.

Having looked at the literature you will also find that H2 can also directly reduce iron oxides to iron below the temperatures experienced in a modern blast furnace process.
i love how the mods deleted my post showing how ridiculous this chart is sunstealer posted. the chart states it would have to be in about 0.25 atmospheres which is like being on top of Mt Everest with a CO% of about 45-50%.
 
Last edited:
Hi Chris,
This whole thing about new independent lab tests is nothing more than a scam for the truthers to try and gain some form of control for their failing movement.

Jtl is only here to argue round in circles. He has bought nothing new to the table.

As far as I can see the truthers response is, DSC tests are needed, he has the wrong chips and he didn't do any electrical resistance tests. None of these claims have any scientific reference to the work Millette has carried out. It's all just a truther ploy to keep the ball in play.

Millette has yet to finish his work and we are aware of why this is taking some time. When Millette has finished his work, that's when the truthers can start to criticise his work and let's face it, the easy cop out is to say he has the wrong chips :D It's unlikely Jones et al will come out in public to criticise Milettes work unless you call the censorship of 911blogger public.

There is no need to do anything. If truthers want to prove Millette is wrong, they will have to produce evidence and we all know that evidence is not their strong point.

Agreed:cool:
 
A few comments: 1) Sunstealer, when you said, "There are hundreds, if not thousands, of labs around the world that can answer the question, "what is this?", by performing independent analysis" ... in reality I found it very difficult to find Jim Millette. I went to some two dozen labs and people either blew me off or clearly were willing to just run the chips through whatever equipment they had on hand for a quick buck. It was a real eye opener. I'd like to know names of at least five independent labs that would actually do this.

2) Several people think yet another test is not worth it. From a scientific point of view I can't agree or disagree. I'm on board this train until at least the Millette study is completed, and would be willing to help any way I reasonably can if the energy for another independent study comes along.

3.) Carsten from Denmark, Just a couple weeks ago Steven Jones wrote to me saying,

" I ask you to address:

1 - the appearance of iron-rich micro-spheres after ignition of the red-gray chips we studied (not present before ignition);
2 - the independent tests of red-gray chips undertaken by Mark Basile."

I don't see where you get that the iron-rich spheres were present prior to heating the chips a-d from anything in the Bentham paper. It is certainly not Steven Jones's position.
 
...
3.) Carsten from Denmark, Just a couple weeks ago Steven Jones wrote to me saying,

" I ask you to address:

1 - the appearance of iron-rich micro-spheres after ignition of the red-gray chips we studied (not present before ignition);
2 - the independent tests of red-gray chips undertaken by Mark Basile."
...

Are you aware if Jones, Harrit or any of his authors have ever addressed Basile's actual data, his methods, his findings?

Basile said, in his recent interview with Bernie Suarez, at 28:28 minutes:
Mark Basile said:
I think some of the chips that, you know, Jones and all looked at were definitely, you know, primer paint chips, too!
Also, Basile's data shows there was less than 2% Al in the red layer of his "lucky chip # 13", yet the very same chips is said to have reacted very "energetically" and appears to have created plenty of those roundish ironish particles in the residue. It is plain impossible to explain either effect as resulting from a thermite reaction involving the tiny over Al content that Basile saw! Has Jones ever addressed that?

You know I have a couple of articles in my blog detailing the techincal specifics, and going through meticulous calculations, on that issue.
 
Mohr: I went to some two dozen labs and people either blew me off or clearly were willing to just run the chips through whatever equipment they had on hand for a quick buck.

What do you mean for a "quick buck"? Did you choose Millette because he was cheaper? For the labs you go to, don´t tell them what this is about and especially not that this is connected to 9/11.

If money is tight and you can´t swing the DSC tests, maybe Millette could at least do some tests with some heating apparatus like Basile, and easily test different kinds of chips without spending some big bucks at independent labs. Jones et al say there are red paint chips in the dust and it seems possible to get samples of confirmed paint chips from the WTC, so if these chips also make those iron spheres when heated to 700 degrees they would not have much of case left. To be fair, the chips would have to have a gray layer to test the gray layer hypothesis by Sunstealer and Kminek.
 
What do you mean for a "quick buck"? Did you choose Millette because he was cheaper?

Your reading comprehension couldn't be worse.
For the labs you go to, don´t tell them what this is about and especially not that this is connected to 9/11.

Why, is this not serious science? You do know by saying this you are questioning the integrity of all scientists. Funny how your bias works.

The DSC is stupid. I asked you before but you did not answer. If Millete does a DSC on the chips in his study and it matches the Harritt et al results will you accept his results? If not, why?
 
Last edited:
What do you mean for a "quick buck"? Did you choose Millette because he was cheaper? For the labs you go to, don´t tell them what this is about and especially not that this is connected to 9/11.

If money is tight and you can´t swing the DSC tests, maybe Millette could at least do some tests with some heating apparatus like Basile, and easily test different kinds of chips without spending some big bucks at independent labs. Jones et al say there are red paint chips in the dust and it seems possible to get samples of confirmed paint chips from the WTC, so if these chips also make those iron spheres when heated to 700 degrees they would not have much of case left. To be fair, the chips would have to have a gray layer to test the gray layer hypothesis by Sunstealer and Kminek.

Millette needs no DSC test, there is no thermite. Jones paper shows no thermite, a few fringe 911 truth idiots believe Jones' fake conclusion. Jones and his fellow failures on 911 issues faked the conclusion. Jones made it up. The conclusion was made up first; we don't need more tests, no rational people believe Jones; he is nuts, or hates war. Why does he lie about 911? That is the only unknown about Jones' failed paper, why does he lie?

Stupid to do a DSC on material you know is not thermite; Big waste. Jones and Harrit expect their audience to be clueless. They weave a story, give partial results which look like thermite to dolts who don't know what they are looking at; claim thermite, 911 truth says it is smoking gun and they take no action. They become big winners in their minds, with no practical knowledge of chemistry, math, and physics. They know they are critical-thinkers, they have the Jones study, published in a vanity journal, and the on-line Jones Journal of Woo. Not a single 911 truther or you can explain what or why a DSC is/need. Wait:"Jones did, Millette needs to do it" ... Ignoring the fact the DSC traces in Jones fraud paper don't match thermite. Or the reality no thermite was used on 911.


DSC tests by Harrit already show it is not super-nano-thermite. It is a wasted test. The traces don't match in the Jones paper. The traces look more like soil (dust stuff), or chard wood. It is nonsense to think DSC is needed.

You don't know what DSC is used for. The biggest crock; iron-rich spheres scam. 911 truthers are so gullible, you can make up the dumbest claims and they eat it up and regurgitate on cue. Jones' dog.
 
If money is tight and you can´t swing the DSC tests,
i have offered chris mohr my own cold hard cash to do a DSC test. the money is still burning a hole in my pocket!!

maybe Millette could at least do some tests with some heating apparatus like Basile, and easily test different kinds of chips without spending some big bucks at independent labs.

millette said he used ASTM standards but i found that when he did the muffle furnace test at 400C, ASTM standard is 450C. i could only find the muffle furnace test in ASTM D 4451-02. i emailed millette and told him i would provide the money for another muffle furnace test at 450C but have had no reply.

i think the guys here on the forum and millette are afraid to go to the 430Cish temp.
 
Last edited:
Wonder who paid for Jones tests? Did Jones and Harrit steal lab time and money from Universities who never knew their DSC equipment was ruined by corrosive tests by some nuts who think 911 was an inside job, 11 years after 911 was solved, in minutes?

Millette did a study, with money put up by donations. Who paid for Jones work? Stolen lab time, or what? 911 truth fails to ask the right questions, because they already have the big answer, "inside job".
 
Why would you want to do that when the claim is that Millette had the wrong chips :confused:
I'm not sure that is the reason. If Millete does a DSC and the results match will he accept that there was no thermite (of any flavor). This is an out for them. If he does this then they will want "conductivity". After that, Millete will have to eat the same breakfast as the Harrit "scientist". It will never end, it can't for their belief.

If the answer is no. Why bother? They don't really want the test.
 
What would this achieve? If Milletes DSC results match exactly will this disprove the Harrit el al paper? A simple yes or no will do.

did they produce iron and silicon rich microsphere's?
 
I don't know? Tell me. what DSC results that Harrit did produce these "spheres?

I'll wait for your data. (clue, the Harrit paper does not have the answer) Where will you get yours?

i guess you need to read the paper again. the answer is in there.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom