WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

There are plenty of references in Harrit´s paper to suggest that the general composition of the chips is consistent with thermitic matrix material, ...

I'm so excited, I can't wait for you to provide only one of these references and to explain why the

general composition of the chips is consistent with thermitic matrix material

.
 
Yes it seems he is avoided because he has his own agenda which is some exotic and hard to define future weapons like Judy Wood´s "energy beams" or whatever she calls it. These people are naturally excluded just like the "no-planers" and "mini-nukes" and all that garbage.

This is an interesting comment. How does his search differ from the undefined "military grade super nano-thermite" Harritt et al claims they found but, can't exactly classify and no one else has found?
 
You don´t know my name so you can only accuse me of using my partial name, or initials.

My complaint about your buddies here is not that they are anonymous, it is that they use their masks to spread nasty rumors about Harrit et al and dismiss everything they do, while they pretend to be big time experts themselves. And I gave you some examples of their mistakes that could get a real scientist in serious trouble. I remind you of Dr.Greening and ask you to consider what he ended up saying about this forum.
.

Lol this is funny.

There is a guy who posts on 911blogger called JTL, of course he is another face less person spreading nasty rumours about 911. Of course this is ok because 911 blogger is sensored :D yet jref isn't sensored and the proof is here to see because jtl,s posts are here for all to see.

Of course jtl is pretending to be a big time expert, but that is ok because he is hiding behind his initials :D

The big question is, why doesn't jtl ask jones to defend his claims in public ? I am sure it could be arranged to have a discussion with selected people with out people like me and senenmut piping in.

My initials are GFS, so I guess I am no longer anonymous :D I guess I must be an expert now :D.
 
Yes it seems he is avoided because he has his own agenda which is some exotic and hard to define future weapons like Judy Wood´s "energy beams" or whatever she calls it. These people are naturally excluded just like the "no-planers" and "mini-nukes" and all that garbage.

You asked me to check out his work so I did, and you did misquote him.

Your "training as a journalist" should have told you narrow down your pool of sources to the ones that best represent your subject, and this is easy with ae911 and the journal run by Steven Jones and friends.

And Mark Basile was an obvious choice, not Henry.


That video was staring me in the face when I watched your video, so I checked it out and linked to it. You say you have made corrections for that video but you did not catch my point about your video on the chips. The point being that it has the same effect on knowledgeable viewers as the other video did, before you corrected it. Like I said, you should consider going back to the drawing board on that one, and maybe ask yourself if you really understand the topic well enough to try to debunk Harrit? ...



You say some truthers agree the chips are the same without references, and what does it matter when at least one of the authors has already doubted it in public and provided some reasons? This same author has pointed out that there are also red paint chips in the dust, so what value has Millette´s claim that he has found paint chips? ...


You don´t know my name so you can only accuse me of using my partial name, or initials....


If you really want to debunk the truthers you have to be able to listen to and accept criticism to be able to upgrade your material.


OK JTL, here we go...

When I researched the history of followup studies of the Bentham paper, Henry's attempts (and strange accusations) came up. That was a failure to produce proof of thermitic materials. Mark Basile's YouTube video also came up. Mark impresses me as an honest person, but he did not have the equipment available to him that the author of the Bentham study had, so he was unable to move his study forward. The Bentham paper was better. I would love to talk to Mark personally about his efforts to create a new study, better funded.

I don't like to use the word "debunker" to describe myself. As an example, knowing that I am not a chemist, and knowing that I could not on my own respond knowledgeably to the claims made by the bentham paper, I did a national search and organized a dust study done by Jim Millette. My efforts to work with Kevin Ryan on this were responded to with hostility and noncooperation. I would still like to see a study done where the protocol etc are agreed upon in advance by at least some people on both sides of the argument.

I have so far been unimpressed with arguments that Millette found the wrong chips, and I am especially unhappy with those arguments in light of the fact that Kevin Ryan refused to release HIS chips, which Millette would have studied, and instead launched a false ad hominem attack against Millette.

You mentioned obvious mistakes you think exist in my discussion of the bentham paper. For example, the graph comparing the energy release of one of the alleged thermitic chips to known nanothermite. Well those two curves are so different, by a factor of over 100 degrees for ignition points and by a factor of three for energy release, that I can't imagine how such a comparison can show evidence of nanothermite. And I said so. If I am wrong about this or if I am not understanding something here, please explain. And I will correct it, as I have corrected inaccurate details in many of my YouTube videos. Please note the corrections and clarifications throughout these videos, both in the videos themselves and in the written Description section of these videos. So for you or Sunstealer or anyone else, feel free to go to http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tN9J7aJThwY any time (Finlarg's version combines parts a and b for convenience) and let me know of any factual errors I need to correct. I don't want to "debunk the truthers" I want the truth and I welcome corrections from people on both sides of the argument.

Not only did I not accuse you of not using your name, I said it was fine.

More importantly, let me know about my mistakes and I will correct them.
 
"Dr. Millette did not report doing Resistivity Testing. To omit such a valuable, time saving, cheap and easy test, suggests the Bentham Paper was never completely read."
MM - were chips a-d in Harrit et al separated (from other chips) via the resistivity test?

Based on what was published in the Bentham Report in 2009 and what one of its authors, Dr. Jones said last September, I would have to say yes.

Given that Dr. Jones received the MacKinlay sample in November of 2006, and that the findings as reported in the Dr. Harrit et al Bentham Paper, were not released until 2009, allowed a great deal of time for their WTC dust research.

Once researchers discovered that chips with a resistivity value of 10 ohm-m matched the chips of interest, they had a significant time saving tool.

And given how easy a test this is to perform, I would imagine its dramatic results would have been one of earliest discoveries made during the analysis of the first red/gray chips isolated by magnetism.

Even easily affordable consumer Multi-Meters have Resistance ranges that can quickly show if a material is conductive (very low resistance) or non-conductive (very high resistance). They had lots of chips to confirm or not confirm the Resistivity findings they presented in the Bentham Paper.

The scientists must have realized with all the research ahead, there would be a continual need for good chip candidates. Only an idiot, or someone doing paint or generic research, would continue picking through the original isolation pile and ignore such an extremely useful discovery.

But I believe your opinion holds to a belief that the Bentham Paper scientists never followed a disciplined methodology protocol.

MM
 
...
Once researchers discovered that chips with a resistivity value of 10 ohm-m matched the chips of interest, they had a significant time saving tool.
...
Even easily affordable consumer Multi-Meters have Resistance ranges that can quickly show if a material is conductive (very low resistance) or non-conductive (very high resistance). They had lots of chips to confirm or not confirm the Resistivity findings they presented in the Bentham Paper.
...

I am not well learned in electricity, that was really the field in physics I struggled most with in my high school physics classes.

Could you tell me if that resistivity value of 10 ohm-m indicates a conductive (very low resistance) or non-conductive (very high resistance) material? Thanks!


ETA:
Oh, and for extra credit, MM (answer this ONLY of you already anserwed the the first question!!)
Only an idiot, or someone doing paint or generic research, would continue picking through the original isolation pile and ignore such an extremely useful discovery.
After you learn that Jones and collaborators did NOT use that resistivity test on chips a-d, and did NOT use it on the MEK-soaked chip, and did NOT use it on the four chips wasted in the DSC test, will you then declare here, publicly, that Steven E. Jones is an idiot, that Jeff Farrer is an idiot, and that Niels Harrit is an idiot for not using such an extremely useful discovery? :p
 
Last edited:
.

But I believe your opinion holds to a belief that the Bentham Paper scientists never followed a disciplined methodology protocol.

MM

Wouldn't that include proper documentation of their results and methods? Do you feel they have done this? If yes, can you show us where?

Anyone want to bet he ignores this?
 
Based on what was published in the Bentham Report in 2009 and what one of its authors, Dr. Jones said last September, I would have to say yes.

Given that Dr. Jones received the MacKinlay sample in November of 2006, and that the findings as reported in the Dr. Harrit et al Bentham Paper, were not released until 2009, allowed a great deal of time for their WTC dust research.

Once researchers discovered that chips with a resistivity value of 10 ohm-m matched the chips of interest, they had a significant time saving tool.

And given how easy a test this is to perform, I would imagine its dramatic results would have been one of earliest discoveries made during the analysis of the first red/gray chips isolated by magnetism.

Even easily affordable consumer Multi-Meters have Resistance ranges that can quickly show if a material is conductive (very low resistance) or non-conductive (very high resistance). They had lots of chips to confirm or not confirm the Resistivity findings they presented in the Bentham Paper.

The scientists must have realized with all the research ahead, there would be a continual need for good chip candidates. Only an idiot, or someone doing paint or generic research, would continue picking through the original isolation pile and ignore such an extremely useful discovery.

But I believe your opinion holds to a belief that the Bentham Paper scientists never followed a disciplined methodology protocol.

MM

No MM, this is what is said in the Bentham paper.

We measured the resistivity of the red material (with very little gray adhering to one side) using a Fluke 8842A mul- timeter in order to compare with ordinary paints, using the formula:
Specific resistivity = RA / L
where R = resistance (ohms); A = cross-sectional area (m2); L
= thickness (m).
Given the small size of the red chip, about 0.5 mm x 0.5 mm, we used two probes and obtained a rough value of ap- proximately 10 ohm-m. This is several orders of magnitude less than paint coatings we found tabulated which are typi- cally over 1010 ohm-m [31].

Next you will be telling us it says that Harrit takes no milk and one sugar in his coffee and jones only drinks mineral water :rolleyes:
 
Based on what was published in the Bentham Report in 2009 and what one of its authors, Dr. Jones said last September, I would have to say yes.

Given that Dr. Jones received the MacKinlay sample in November of 2006, and that the findings as reported in the Dr. Harrit et al Bentham Paper, were not released until 2009, allowed a great deal of time for their WTC dust research.

Once researchers discovered that chips with a resistivity value of 10 ohm-m matched the chips of interest, they had a significant time saving tool.

And given how easy a test this is to perform, I would imagine its dramatic results would have been one of earliest discoveries made during the analysis of the first red/gray chips isolated by magnetism.

Even easily affordable consumer Multi-Meters have Resistance ranges that can quickly show if a material is conductive (very low resistance) or non-conductive (very high resistance). They had lots of chips to confirm or not confirm the Resistivity findings they presented in the Bentham Paper.

The scientists must have realized with all the research ahead, there would be a continual need for good chip candidates. Only an idiot, or someone doing paint or generic research, would continue picking through the original isolation pile and ignore such an extremely useful discovery.

But I believe your opinion holds to a belief that the Bentham Paper scientists never followed a disciplined methodology protocol.

MM
Could you please ask Jones or Harrit to confirm what you are claiming. They didn't put any such information in the paper. It would be impossible for another researcher to follow a method that isn't documented. If they do confirm your claims could you then please ask them why they failed to document such a vital procedure.

Until you get confirmation then all you are doing is speculating.

Now if you claim that chips a-d are separated by resistivity from a pile of chips that were magnetically isolated from the dust then why do you have a problem with Millette, when Millette's entire criteria for isolating chips is solely based on the properties of chips a-d?

For example.

Millette's chips have the same EDX spectra as chips a-d for;

The red layer, the gray layer, the small whitish particles, the platelet particles.

Millette's chips have exactly the same rhombohedral (iron oxide) particles as chips a-d.

Millette's chips have exactly the same hexagonal shaped (kaolin) particles as chips a-d.

Millette's chips have exactly the same morphology of carbon based matrix (epoxy) particles as chips a-d.

By that criteria he has already separated chips indirectly via resistivity testing.
 
No MM, this is what is said in the Bentham paper.



Next you will be telling us it says that Harrit takes no milk and one sugar in his coffee and jones only drinks mineral water :rolleyes:
Until he has confirmation from the authors MM is just making stuff up. The word "resistivity" appears twice in the paper. Why would the authors leave out such a vital technique for further separating out isolated chips? (that's an oxymoronic statement by definition of the word isolated). Why don't they tell us what else they found but discarded?

None of what MM is saying makes any sense.
 
Last edited:
Until he has confirmation from the authors MM is just making stuff up. The word "resistivity" appears twice in the paper. Why would the authors leave out such a vital technique for further separating out isolated chips? (that's an oxymoronic statement by definition of the word isolated). Why don't they tell us what else they found but discarded?

None of what MM is saying makes any sense.

It makes sense if Harrit et al are dishonest and only trying to avoid criticism. If I wanted to preclude falsification, I might use undocumented methods, only to be revealed piecemeal as others debunk me. Next we will learn that they further separated the chips by sprinkling them on salad and sorting into salty versus sweet, and then that they put them in a sack and hit each other in the face, sorting into sharp stinging pain versus dull throbbing pain. Each time, a new undocumented test Millette absolutely must do or his results are worthless.

Or maybe resistivity was never used to separate chips.
 
Mohr: When I researched the history of followup studies of the Bentham paper, Henry's attempts (and strange accusations) came up. That was a failure to produce proof of thermitic materials.

Henry did after all agree that the composition of the chips is consistent with Harrit´s hypothesis of thermitic chips, but he failed to ignite redgray chips, for some odd reason he only tried red-red chips which may have been ignited already. But there may be a lot of odd things about Henry.

It is interesting to note that you call his study a failure because his ignition tests were not successful, so after all you do know that those tests are important. You must realize that it seems you would also not accept Millette conclusion of thermitic chips without successful ignition tests, and if you don´t push for those tests it can look like you don´t want him to come to that conclusion.

I would still like to see a study done where the protocol etc are agreed upon in advance by at least some people on both sides of the argument.

Good.

I have so far been unimpressed with arguments that Millette found the wrong chips, and I am especially unhappy with those arguments in light of the fact that Kevin Ryan refused to release HIS chips, which Millette would have studied, and instead launched a false ad hominem attack against Millette.

Have you not noticed that the basic argument your buddies have against Harrit paper is that the MEK chip and the ignited chips were somehow the wrong chips, and not the same as chips a to d?

Did you notice the part where Harrit et al say their chips remain hard in MEK while paint chips become soft, and that Millette´s chips become soft?

There is no reason for Harrit et al to release their chips while Millette has access to the dust. I do not know about any attacks against Millette, but have you not noticed how all your buddies like to use ad hominem attacks on Harrit and Jones? What goes around comes around.

Well those two curves are so different, by a factor of over 100 degrees for ignition points and by a factor of three for energy release, that I can't imagine how such a comparison can show evidence of nanothermite. And I said so. If I am wrong about this or if I am not understanding something here, please explain

I already went over this, the point was showing fast energy release comparable to a known superthermite. The ignition temperature and total energy output are not important as they will vary for different ratios of components and different compositions(different superthermites!). Even with all the same ingredients in the same ratios, just changing the size of the particles will change ignition temp.

And if you read the paper where that compared superthermite peak comes from, you realize that the authors explain that it did not release as much energy as expected because of some faults with the sample, so that small 1.5 energy release is certainly not typical.
 
... There is no reason for Harrit et al to release their chips while Millette has access to the dust. I do not know about any attacks against Millette, but have you not noticed how all your buddies like to use ad hominem attacks on Harrit and Jones? What goes around comes around. ...
There is no attack on Jones. He spreads lies about thermite being used on 911. It was not used on 911. His better published work is Christ in the New World.
Harrit says ton of thermite was used, 100 tons of thermite. Why is there no damage from thermite on any WTC steel? There is no need to attack Harrit with regards to 911 issues. Harrit is a loon when it comes to 911. He spreads the big lie for idiots who believe 911 was an inside thermite job. Who would support the nonsense Jones and Harrit publish? No rational people do.

Hard to attack Millette on 911 issues, he has not lied about 911. No thermite was found in the dust after 911 by real studies. Makes Jones and Harrit's claims of thermite a fraud.
 
Last edited:
It makes me wonder how people fell for the Jones crap. Fire fighters dipping their hands in molten metal :D

And we know truthers are liars! Just like jtl coming on to jref pretending to be some sort of debunker.

LMFAO keep up the good work jtl.
 
Last edited:
...
Have you not noticed that the basic argument your buddies have against Harrit paper is that the MEK chip and the ignited chips were somehow the wrong chips, and not the same as chips a to d?

Did you notice the part where Harrit et al say their chips remain hard in MEK while paint chips become soft, and that Millette´s chips become soft?
Did they test any of chips a-d with MEK? What was the result?
Which of the chips they did test with MEK had the same elemental composition, as per XEDS, as chips a-d?
Which of the chips they did test with MEK was observed to contain those peculiar hexagonal platelets?
Citation and data, please.
Thanks.

After you fail to provide these citations an data, please comment on the evidence that exists that the MEK-chip (Fig. 12-18) is the same material as chips a-d (Fig 5-11). Also, comment on the evidence that exists that they were different.
Thanks.

I already went over this, the point was showing fast energy release comparable to a known superthermite.
How fast was the energy release?
Was it "fast"?
Did they, or did the not, compare their DSC results with that of Tillotson and Gash (Reference [28])?
What do Tillotson and Gash (Reference [28]) say about DSC and its ability to measure how "fast energy release" is of nano-thermite? They make an explicit statement on this!

The ignition temperature and total energy output are not important as they will vary for different ratios of components and different compositions(different superthermites!). Even with all the same ingredients in the same ratios, just changing the size of the particles will change ignition temp.
Why then did they show the shape of one of their DSC curves along with that of Tillotson and Gash (Reference [28])? When you answer this, keep in mind that the draft of their paper originally had many more Figures, but that they eliminated many on advide of the peer-reviewer, so they would have kept only important Figures, or not?
Why then do they keep stressing the ignition temperature, if it's "not important"?
Why does the paper even mention the total energy output, if it's "not important"?
Would you say that they drew no conclusion from the energy output?

And if you read the paper where that compared superthermite peak comes from, you realize that the authors explain that it did not release as much energy as expected because of some faults with the sample, so that small 1.5 energy release is certainly not typical.
How much did they expect, and what is the basis for that expectation? There must be some base numbers, and calculations, that one can do to come up with such an expectation, right?
Applying the same method to Harrit's chips, what should they expect in terms of energy release?
 
Henry did after all agree that the composition of the chips is consistent with Harrit´s hypothesis of thermitic chips, but he failed to ignite redgray chips, for some odd reason he only tried red-red chips which may have been ignited already. But there may be a lot of odd things about Henry.

It is interesting to note that you call his study a failure because his ignition tests were not successful, so after all you do know that those tests are important. You must realize that it seems you would also not accept Millette conclusion of thermitic chips without successful ignition tests, and if you don't push for those tests it can look like you don´t want him to come to that conclusion.


Have you not noticed that the basic argument your buddies have against Harrit paper is that the MEK chip and the ignited chips were somehow the wrong chips, and not the same as chips a to d?

Did you notice the part where Harrit et al say their chips remain hard in MEK while paint chips become soft, and that Millette´s chips become soft?

There is no reason for Harrit et al to release their chips while Millette has access to the dust. I do not know about any attacks against Millette, but have you not noticed how all your buddies like to use ad hominem attacks on Harrit and Jones? What goes around comes around.



I already went over this, the point was showing fast energy release comparable to a known superthermite. The ignition temperature and total energy output are not important as they will vary for different ratios of components and different compositions(different superthermites!). Even with all the same ingredients in the same ratios, just changing the size of the particles will change ignition temp.

And if you read the paper where that compared superthermite peak comes from, you realize that the authors explain that it did not release as much energy as expected because of some faults with the sample, so that small 1.5 energy release is certainly not typical.

JTL FYI I have pushed for the DSC tests but I am not certain of its value. Jones et al say it's essential, Millette et al say it's useless. As a journalist I am unqualified to determine the correct answer to this disagreement. This is why I would like to see a study that has some kind of pre-approved protocol and lab with even one knowledgeable person form this side working WITH Mark Basile. I tried to do that with Kevin Ryan and was strongly rebuffed. My response was to go forward without him and present him with Jim Millette as a fait accompli. I stand behind Millette's integrity but I still want to see a study that is truly done by people on both sides. Can you contact Mark Basile about this and ask if this is possible?

I have no independent opinion on the value of the DSC tests. However, I was able to see that the graphs comparing nanothermite and the chips looked pretyy worthless, either because of the reasons you give or because the chips really are paint. The test doesn't provide a match so for whatever reason I can't see its value.

I don't know about the hard vs soft chips. All efforts to get chips Jones et al believed were thermitic into Millette's hands were rebuffed, remember.

I try to be respectful at all times and believe that I am entitled to respect in return. I don't speak for others or defend ad hominem attacks on either side.
 
Sunstealer post 1703 on this thread:
Unfortunately you have forgotten about the Direct Reduction method for producing iron from iron oxides. The reason for looking at such a method is the reduction in temperature required to produce iron (sponge iron) in comparison with the blast furnace which produces pig iron.

A reduction in heat required means less money spent on fuel which is why the direct reduction method has been studied.

Incidentally it's the method that has been predominantly used in man's history - research "Bloomery".

Once more, this has been answered here, but answer was moved

Once more, if someone gets a request to move this answer, please then also move Sunstealer´s post. Since this kind of thing is getting really old, please try to make this a rule. If the answer to a certain post is off topic, then that post has to be off topic as well, and then BOTH should get moved.
 
Once more, this has been answered here, but answer was moved

Once more, if someone gets a request to move this answer, please then also move Sunstealer´s post. Since this kind of thing is getting really old, please try to make this a rule. If the answer to a certain post is off topic, then that post has to be off topic as well, and then BOTH should get moved.
You are now off-topic (bold part). This will likely be moved because the correct forum for this would be forum management.

Why don't you try actually reading the MA you agreed too.
 
Oystein: How much did they expect, and what is the basis for that expectation? There must be some base numbers, and calculations, that one can do to come up with such an expectation, right?
Applying the same method to Harrit's chips, what should they expect in terms of energy release?

There is no point answering you Oystein, because any answer goes in one ear and out the other. But I am going to answer this one thing because others might benefit:

The superthermite in that paper(28) is just normal feo/al nanothermite, which means it does not have an energetic organic matrix, and therefore the output is limited(=3.9) to the thermite ingredients. Superthermites with other energetic materials present, such as an energetic organic matrix, are not subject to this limitation. As you know, Harrit does suggest that his chips have this kind of energetic matrix.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom