WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

... Red color is my emphasis. Molten iron spheres would be the very surprising first recorded case for paint, and for superthermite study they would be the important result, so there is no way to avoid replicating the DSC tests, as they are the central feature in Harrit´s paper.

The DSC done in Jones paper is closer to soil or carbon/wood than thermite. You don't understand what DSC is for.

Millette found no thermite. No need to do a DSC. There was no thermite used on 911, no need to do any papers. Jones tried to back in thermite, it only fooled a few idiots; mainly themselves.
 
Jones XRD says no kaolin in std form so if there is also no amorphous form of it in chips a - d then there is no kaolin in them at all, meaning no LaClede paint. No Zn in them means they are not Tnemec so this would mean they are not any form of known WTC primer paint.

The XRD is just another indicator that Millette and Harrit do not have the same chips, along with Millette´s titanium chips that become soft in MEK. Leave it up to Kminek to answer technical questions.

1. And you can provide Jones' data?

2. You are wrong and you are not able to backup your claims with actual data. Millette and Harrit investigated identical chips. Jones only makes claims without publishing sufficient data. Millette has published his data, it is available online.

Red color is my emphasis. Molten iron spheres would be the very surprising first recorded case for paint, and for superthermite study they would be the important result, so there is no way to avoid replicating the DSC tests, as they are the central feature in Harrit´s paper.

No, the DSC test is irrelevant as Millette has figured out that the chips contain no elemental aluminum and therefore cannot be any sort of thermite. Even if the DSC test produces iron rich microspheres, these microspheres cannot derive from thermite as no elemental aluminum was present. The presence of elemental aluminum is the criterion for exclusion for the presence of thermite. No elemental aluminum, no thermite - even if iron rich microspheres are produced in a DSC test!

And just one remark to the replication of the DSC test. The french scientist Frederic Henry-Couannier tried to reproduce this test with red chips that had the same composition as the red layer of Harrit's chips. He was not able to generate iron rich microspheres although he applied higher temperatures than Harrit (up to 900°C). Another proof that the layer contains no thermite.
 
Stop the act, it became transparent long ago.

You cant even tell the difference between air temperature and metal temperature, and you evidently do not understand the "special conditions" under which this reduction occurs in stages going up to about 1200 degrees(C) metal temp:

This reduction requires refined carbon fuel and limestone together, the latter being missing from the DSC.

It also involves a turbocharger pressuring air into the furnace, and this air is pre-heated to over 1000 degrees(C). The actual final maximum air temperature of the blast furnace is about 2000 degrees(C). The DSC does not have these things, having to do manage with one atmosphere and 700(C).

The blast furnace process also takes several hours, and the result is carbon infused pig iron not elemental iron.

Unfortunately you have forgotten about the Direct Reduction method for producing iron from iron oxides. The reason for looking at such a method is the reduction in temperature required to produce iron (sponge iron) in comparison with the blast furnace which produces pig iron.

A reduction in heat required means less money spent on fuel which is why the direct reduction method has been studied.

Incidentally it's the method that has been predominantly used in man's history - research "Bloomery". That process of producing iron does not require the temperatures used in a blast furnace, nor does it require the addition of slag forming additives.

The direct reduction method is only valid, however, if it is thermodynamically possible. The graph I posted gives you the information required to see the thermodynamics associated with the reduction of iron ores via the Boudouard Reaction.

I've coloured the graph so it's easier to see the phases:

picture.php


You will also note that I've drawn a line representing the lowest temperature that is thermodynamically possible for magnetite to reduce to iron which corresponds to 570°C - well below the 700°C obtained in the DSC. This figure is readily available in the literature.

Having looked at the literature you will also find that H2 can also directly reduce iron oxides to iron below the temperatures experienced in a modern blast furnace process.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
1. And you can provide Jones' data?

2. You are wrong and you are not able to backup your claims with actual data. Millette and Harrit investigated identical chips. Jones only makes claims without publishing sufficient data. Millette has published his data, it is available online.



No, the DSC test is irrelevant as Millette has figured out that the chips contain no elemental aluminum and therefore cannot be any sort of thermite. Even if the DSC test produces iron rich microspheres, these microspheres cannot derive from thermite as no elemental aluminum was present. The presence of elemental aluminum is the criterion for exclusion for the presence of thermite. No elemental aluminum, no thermite - even if iron rich microspheres are produced in a DSC test!

And just one remark to the replication of the DSC test. The french scientist Frederic Henry-Couannier tried to reproduce this test with red chips that had the same composition as the red layer of Harrit's chips. He was not able to generate iron rich microspheres although he applied higher temperatures than Harrit (up to 900°C). Another proof that the layer contains no thermite.

JTL: do some research on the Henry-Couannier study. He got sample chips from Jones et al, and determined that the presence of thermite could not be found. He was a 9/11 Truth person who apparently then went on to accuse Jones of giving out phony red-grey chips. Some of his original posts re his chips experiment were taken down but were captured by the guy who runs the Screw Loose Change blog if you want to get the unvarnished version.

My YouTube video touches on this a bit as well: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tN9J7aJThwY

All that said, I think an independent DSC test with an independent analysis of the results, comparing the alleged thermitic chips with known paint chips of different kinds, would be of value if only for the debate itself. While I am inclined to agree with the scientific view of Sunstealer, Ivan and Oystein that the DSC is both unnecessary and incorrect protocol, the argument will never be put to rest until such an experiment is carried out. You and others will always be able to say "They didn't do the DSC! They would have found the proof there!!" However, all THAT said, the chemical analysis of the chips in BOTH the Bentham paper and the Millette study shows they are NOT thermitic, and this is a fact that cannot be ignored.
 
Last edited:
While I am inclined to agree with the scientific view of Sunstealer, Ivan and Oystein that the DSC is both unnecessary and incorrect protocol, the argument will never be put to rest until such an experiment is carried out. You and others will always be able to say "They didn't do the DSC! They would have found the proof there!!"

Do you believe that if Millette did a DSC on his chips (that match perfectly) and he gets the same results "truthers" will then believe there was no thermite?

They believe the DSC results in the Harret et al paper proves "thermite". It doesn't, why would they believe Millete if he tells them so? It's pointless.
 
JTL: do some research on the Henry-Couannier study. He got sample chips from Jones et al, and determined that the presence of thermite could not be found. He was a 9/11 Truth person who apparently then went on to accuse Jones of giving out phony red-grey chips. Some of his original posts re his chips experiment were taken down but were captured by the guy who runs the Screw Loose Change blog if you want to get the unvarnished version.

My YouTube video touches on this a bit as well: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tN9J7aJThwY

All that said, I think an independent DSC test with an independent analysis of the results, comparing the alleged thermitic chips with known paint chips of different kinds, would be of value if only for the debate itself. While I am inclined to agree with the scientific view of Sunstealer, Ivan and Oystein that the DSC is both unnecessary and incorrect protocol, the argument will never be put to rest until such an experiment is carried out. You and others will always be able to say "They didn't do the DSC! They would have found the proof there!!" However, all THAT said, the chemical analysis of the chips in BOTH the Bentham paper and the Millette study shows they are NOT thermitic, and this is a fact that cannot be ignored.

Dr. Millette did not report doing Resistivity Testing. To omit such a valuable, time saving, cheap and easy test, suggests the Bentham Paper was never completely read.

Dr. Millette stopped heating selected chips at 400C which prevented a residue comparison with that obtained from the DSC, or an oven set to +430C.

From a pile of isolated chips, it is up to the researcher to decide which, and how many, chips they are interested in examining.

In Dr. Millette's pile of magnetically isolated WTC dust chips, if the number of non-thermitic chips (e.g. paint) was quite high compared to the number of thermitic chips, the probability was also quite high that Dr. Millette never selected any chips that were a match for the thermitic chips reported in the Bentham Paper.

I have little doubt that Dr. Millette found and identified real substances that existed in the WTC dust. But I can also see how easy it is to find hay when you aren't looking very hard for the needles.

MM
 
Dr. Millette did not report doing Resistivity Testing. To omit such a valuable, time saving, cheap and easy test, suggests the Bentham Paper was never completely read.

Time saving/valuable to what end? What were they actually testing for? Please show data. Did they run a base on the gray layer?

Any bets he can't answer any of these simple questions?
 
Last edited:
Dr. Millette did not report doing Resistivity Testing. To omit such a valuable, time saving, cheap and easy test, suggests the Bentham Paper was never completely read.
MM - were chips a-d in Harrit et al separated (from other chips) via the resistivity test?
 
In Dr. Millette's pile of magnetically isolated WTC dust chips, if the number of non-thermitic chips (e.g. paint) was quite high compared to the number of thermitic chips, the probability was also quite high that Dr. Millette never selected any chips that were a match for the thermitic chips reported in the Bentham Paper.
Err, except he did. He matched the specific EDX spectrum from Fig 7 in Harrit et al with a number of chips he extracted via magnetic separation.

Can you please post Fig 7 from Harrit et al and then post all of the corresponding red layer EDX spectra from Millette that are;

a) identical

or

b) not identical.

Thanks.
 
Mohr: do some research on the Henry-Couannier study. He got sample chips from Jones et al, and determined that the presence of thermite could not be found. He was a 9/11 Truth person who apparently then went on to accuse Jones of giving out phony red-grey chips. Some of his original posts re his chips experiment were taken down but were captured by the guy who runs the Screw Loose Change blog if you want to get the unvarnished version.
My YouTube video touches on this a bit as well: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tN9J7aJThwY

Mohr, first of all notice my responses to Sunstealer about his blast furnace and bloomery theories, low temp carbon reduction etc. Also go back to my responses to his assertion that Millette identified Tnemec when Millette actually says the opposite. I want you to realize that if any of you would give such misleading information in a scientific paper you could be in serious trouble, even facing charges of fraud, if the paper actually passed peer review which is unlikely.

That being said, I have gone over Henry´s two papers, and you have to notice carefully that he does not really accuse jones of "giving out phony chips" but does offer some speculation that it is possible that he could do that or that Jones et al were deceived by others. But he also offers another explanation, that is he has red-red chips that already have spheres so they could be previously ignited and as such no longer active. If Jones where to give out "phoney chips" then why would he give chips that do not react?

Do yourself a favor and do not ask people to read screwloosechange. This has the same effect as when truthers ask people to read forums about holographic planes and such hogwash.

And with that in mind I suggest you go back to the drawing board with your video, as it will have the same effect for it quickly makes obvious you have not done any research or that you simply do not understand. Making videos about subjects you do not understand can make you look really bad, as that rebuttal video does, and it is very likely people will dismiss it as hogwash or disinformation. Just as one example I briefly mention your ideas about the comparison of the DSC curves of Harrit´s chips to one example of a known superthermite. The idea behind those curves is based on the assumption that superthermite incendiaries and explosives release energy faster than paint for example. The total energy release per gram and ignition temperature are NOT the point, as you can so many variations of this stuff that will have varying ignition temperatures, output, and characteristics.

All that said, I think an independent DSC test with an independent analysis of the results, comparing the alleged thermitic chips with known paint chips of different kinds, would be of value if only for the debate itself. While I am inclined to agree with the scientific view of Sunstealer, Ivan and Oystein that the DSC is both unnecessary and incorrect protocol, the argument will never be put to rest until such an experiment is carried out. You and others will always be able to say "They didn't do the DSC! They would have found the proof there!!" However, all THAT said, the chemical analysis of the chips in BOTH the Bentham paper and the Millette study shows they are NOT thermitic, and this is a fact that cannot be ignored.

It is up to you if you make more videos and if you keep reading screwloosehange and continue to believe Oystein, Sunstealer and their authoritative claims. Like I told you earlier, anonymous people on forums can say all kinds of things, but that does not mean these people or those forums are a reliable source of information.

Despite all the noise by Oystein et al, it is still a fact that Harrit et al followed the protocol of the people that developed this new class of materials, and that includes the DSC testing.

Your claims about Bentham paper chemical analysis is not based on fact, it is just an empty claim that rings hollow. Harrit´s chips certainly look thermitic and even Henry confirms that their chemical composition is consistent with that hypothesis, even though he could not confirm it:
Presence of red/dark gray chips and chemical composition of layers
roughly confirmed : Compatible with the nanothermite hypothesis

Henry´s paper has some interesting references including the following that describes a class of superthermites where the skeletal matrix is itself energetic just like Harrit et al suggest in their paper:
The final class of energetic material produced by sol-gel methods is energetic skeletal materials. Basically, the sol-gel chemistry is used to create a skeletal matrix, which is itself energetic.

Of course Harrit could be wrong about his hypothesis, but it is still a fact that his hypothesis of chips made of skeletal energetic matrix embedded with nanothermite is possible.
 
Last edited:
Of course Harrit could be wrong about his hypothesis, but it is still a fact that his hypothesis of chips made of skeletal energetic matrix embedded with nanothermite is possible.

So is Bigfoot. Do you believe he/she exists considering the same level of proof? (yes it is comparable)
 
...
Despite all the noise by Oystein et al, it is still a fact that Harrit et al followed the protocol of the people that developed this new class of materials, and that includes the DSC testing.
...

Without any noise: You claim a fact - can you please substantiate it with evidende? Quite briefly:

  • Please describe, item by item, the protocol of the people that developed this new class of materials (bullets will do - just include citations)!
  • Please show how Harrit et al followed that protocol, item by item (again, bulleted citations will do for the moment)

Thank! :)
 
Last edited:
DGM: So is Bigfoot. Do you believe he/she exists considering the same level of proof? (yes it is comparable)

You saying this in response to my post where I confirm that there are known examples of nanothermite embedded in a skeletal energetic matrix, means if you stick to your claim, that you believe that there are in fact Bigfoot skeletons and Bigfoot DNA stored in some labs somewhere.

In other words, NO this is not at all comparable, and I hope you realize how silly you have made yourself look.
 
Last edited:
You saying this in response to my post where I confirm that there are known examples of nanothermite embedded in a skeletal energetic matrix, means if you stick to your claim, that you believe that there are in fact Bigfoot skeletons and Bigfoot DNA stored in some labs somewhere.

In other words, NO this is not at all comparable, and I hope you realize how silly you have made yourself look.
I would only look "silly" if he did prove his hypothesis. Got a timeline on that?

(BTW, you assume he can prove his hypothesis by saying you know what I believe).
 
Last edited:
All that said, I think an independent DSC test with an independent analysis of the results, comparing the alleged thermitic chips with known paint chips of different kinds, would be of value if only for the debate itself. While I am inclined to agree with the scientific view of Sunstealer, Ivan and Oystein that the DSC is both unnecessary and incorrect protocol, the argument will never be put to rest until such an experiment is carried out. You and others will always be able to say "They didn't do the DSC! They would have found the proof there!!" However, all THAT said, the chemical analysis of the chips in BOTH the Bentham paper and the Millette study shows they are NOT thermitic, and this is a fact that cannot be ignored.

A DSC test is not necessary to prove or disprove thermite (this has been already done by the FTIR tests), but if carried out properly, this test could help strengthen the "gray layer hypothesis". I think, it would be a good idea, to take photographs of both sides of the chip before and after the DSC test, thus proving the presence or absence of the gray layer after heating, although I think, that Jones and Co. would handwave this result, too.

MM,

your article is a good proof, that the disinformation of Harrit and Jones works.

Dr. Millette did not report doing Resistivity Testing. To omit such a valuable, time saving, cheap and easy test, suggests the Bentham Paper was never completely read.

The resistivity test is irrelevant, as Millette proved that the chips were not thermitic due to the absence of elemental aluminum.

Dr. Millette stopped heating selected chips at 400C which prevented a residue comparison with that obtained from the DSC, or an oven set to +430C.

This sentence indicates, that you do not unterstand the purpose of this test. Millette wanted to remove the organic layer in order to examine the mineralic particles.

From a pile of isolated chips, it is up to the researcher to decide which, and how many, chips they are interested in examining.

Millette gave the exact criteria for the selection of the chips at the beginning of his progress report.

In Dr. Millette's pile of magnetically isolated WTC dust chips, if the number of non-thermitic chips (e.g. paint) was quite high compared to the number of thermitic chips, the probability was also quite high that Dr. Millette never selected any chips that were a match for the thermitic chips reported in the Bentham Paper.

This claim is unsubstantiated, vide supra.

Despite all the noise by Oystein et al, it is still a fact that Harrit et al followed the protocol of the people that developed this new class of materials, and that includes the DSC testing.

No, they didn't! Tillotson tested the products after DSC by means of X-Ray Diffraction and was able to prove the presence of iron and aluminum oxide. Harrit didn't carry out this test. Ergo: Harrit didn't follow the protocol of Tillotson et al. .

qed
 
Last edited:
... Of course Harrit could be wrong about his hypothesis, but it is still a fact that his hypothesis of chips made of skeletal energetic matrix embedded with nanothermite is possible.
Since there was no thermite used on 911, Harrit's conclusion is fictional claptrap.

Your Harrit claptrap is off topic, find a better thread. Use some of that super-nano-research to find the right thread.

Harrit uses the same evidence Bigfoot believers have for his claim thermite was used on 911. Harrit says 100 TONS of thermite. What a loon.
 
Last edited:
Did MM seriously just compare finding thermite in the chips from the wtc dust to finding a needle in a haystack?

I was under the impression that MM believed that thermite was ubiquitous in the wtc dust. Supposedly thermite laden dust falling into the underground areas of the debris pile allowed for the months long existence of molten steel.
 
Last edited:
Not going to clutter this thread up more than necessary, I just want to point to another reason why it is best to assume that Harrit, Jones, Farrer did NOT separate paint chips from "thermitic" chips by any method at all: They did a full tally and count of red-gray chips in two sub-samples of their dust, and did not indicate that they separated thermitic chips from paint chips before or after the count.

Details in thought 1 here
 
JTL,

Henry's original comments about the Jones chips were indeed very harsh and accusatory. He withdrew those comments from whatever blog it first appeared on, but his original accusations were in fact picked up by the screwloosechange people.

I collect information about 9/11 from every source on both sides (except the NeoNazis, who make me puke). When I mentioned Henry in my YouTube and another place, I got lambasted by a 9/11 Truth writer who said Henri was a paranoid conspiracy theorist and his comments should be ignored by anyone seriously researching the WTC thermitic dust issue. Now you are quoting him and saying I have misquoted him. In truth, I would say I probably quoted only his conclusion which went something like "the presence of nanothermite could not be confirmed." I left out the anti-Jones accusations from the YouTube video.

You, in the meantime, linked us to the infamous "Pearls Before Swine" video of David Chandler as evidence of my ignorance (the "make you look bad" underline). Do you think it appropriate for Chandler to use such a quote in reference to me? And much more importantly, he DID catch some mistakes in my YouTube video #18 about Building 7, the corrected version of which which you can see here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2MER5PhIDt0. So the link on David Chandler's "Pearls Before Swine" video has been dead for a year and a half with no link to the corrected video.

I am aware that Millette did not assert that these chips were of any particular paint he could positively identify, and he has been on a nationwide search for known samples of LaClede primer for the past 10 months. I am also aware that he has stated unequivocally that the chips are not thermitic but consistent with some kind of paint. And as you well know, some 9/11 Truth researchers have said that Millette did indeed find the right chips, in spite of Kevin Ryan's refusal to share any of the chips he believed were thermitic.

My claims about the chemical analysis of the Bentham paper may "ring hollow" in your mind, and I don't blame you, I'm no chemist. But I have enough professional training as a journalist to know that the many tests Jones says were done (but never shared) could give us much more information about the chemical composition of these chips. Jones's failure to release this data is enough to tell this journalist that Jones's claims ring very very hollow. As I said in my revised video 18, I know this stuff fairly well, my occasional inevitable mistakes notwithstanding, and I try hard to be fairminded about this --- to the point where I am completely willing to be proven wrong.

Oh and I use my real name. You don't. No problem there but isn't it hypocritical for you to complain about anonymous internet posters?
 
Mohr: I collect information about 9/11 from every source on both sides (except the NeoNazis, who make me puke). When I mentioned Henry in my YouTube and another place, I got lambasted by a 9/11 Truth writer who said Henri was a paranoid conspiracy theorist and his comments should be ignored by anyone seriously researching the WTC thermitic dust issue. Now you are quoting him and saying I have misquoted him. In truth, I would say I probably quoted only his conclusion which went something like "the presence of nanothermite could not be confirmed." I left out the anti-Jones accusations from the YouTube video.

Yes it seems he is avoided because he has his own agenda which is some exotic and hard to define future weapons like Judy Wood´s "energy beams" or whatever she calls it. These people are naturally excluded just like the "no-planers" and "mini-nukes" and all that garbage.

You asked me to check out his work so I did, and you did misquote him.

Your "training as a journalist" should have told you narrow down your pool of sources to the ones that best represent your subject, and this is easy with ae911 and the journal run by Steven Jones and friends.

And Mark Basile was an obvious choice, not Henry.

You, in the meantime, linked us to the infamous "Pearls Before Swine" video of David Chandler as evidence of my ignorance (the "make you look bad" underline). Do you think it appropriate for Chandler to use such a quote in reference to me? And much more importantly, he DID catch some mistakes in my YouTube video #18 about Building 7, the corrected version of which which you can see here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2MER5PhIDt0. So the link on David Chandler's "Pearls Before Swine" video has been dead for a year and a half with no link to the corrected video.

That video was staring me in the face when I watched your video, so I checked it out and linked to it. You say you have made corrections for that video but you did not catch my point about your video on the chips. The point being that it has the same effect on knowledgeable viewers as the other video did, before you corrected it. Like I said, you should consider going back to the drawing board on that one, and maybe ask yourself if you really understand the topic well enough to try to debunk Harrit?

I am aware that Millette did not assert that these chips were of any particular paint he could positively identify, and he has been on a nationwide search for known samples of LaClede primer for the past 10 months. I am also aware that he has stated unequivocally that the chips are not thermitic but consistent with some kind of paint. And as you well know, some 9/11 Truth researchers have said that Millette did indeed find the right chips, in spite of Kevin Ryan's refusal to share any of the chips he believed were thermitic.

You say some truthers agree the chips are the same without references, and what does it matter when at least one of the authors has already doubted it in public and provided some reasons? This same author has pointed out that there are also red paint chips in the dust, so what value has Millette´s claim that he has found paint chips?

My claims about the chemical analysis of the Bentham paper may "ring hollow" in your mind, and I don't blame you, I'm no chemist. But I have enough professional training as a journalist to know that the many tests Jones says were done (but never shared) could give us much more information about the chemical composition of these chips. Jones's failure to release this data is enough to tell this journalist that Jones's claims ring very very hollow. As I said in my revised video 18, I know this stuff fairly well, my occasional inevitable mistakes notwithstanding, and I try hard to be fairminded about this --- to the point where I am completely willing to be proven wrong.

There are plenty of references in Harrit´s paper to suggest that the general composition of the chips is consistent with thermitic matrix material, and again the reference I pointed out from Henry´s paper is pretty clear about this, and even Henry admitted that. You ignore a lot of things with your statements.
There is plenty of data in Harrit´s paper to go on, but it can still be proven wrong, and that is done by repeating the experiments.
The details of the composition of the matrix material are not really that important while there is no challenge to the assertion that the chips reduce iron oxide and perform like an incendiary or explosive. According to your buddies on this forum, it should be very easy to demonstrate that this assertion is not true.

Oh and I use my real name. You don't. No problem there but isn't it hypocritical for you to complain about anonymous internet posters?

You don´t know my name so you can only accuse me of using my partial name, or initials.

My complaint about your buddies here is not that they are anonymous, it is that they use their masks to spread nasty rumors about Harrit et al and dismiss everything they do, while they pretend to be big time experts themselves. And I gave you some examples of their mistakes that could get a real scientist in serious trouble. I remind you of Dr.Greening and ask you to consider what he ended up saying about this forum.

If you really want to debunk the truthers you have to be able to listen to and accept criticism to be able to upgrade your material.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom