Mohr: do some research on the Henry-Couannier study. He got sample chips from Jones et al, and determined that the presence of
thermite could not be found. He was a 9/11 Truth person who
apparently then went on to accuse Jones of giving out phony red-grey chips. Some of his original posts re his chips experiment were taken down but were captured by the guy who runs the Screw Loose Change blog if you want to get the unvarnished version.
My YouTube video touches on this a bit as well:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tN9J7aJThwY
Mohr, first of all notice my responses to Sunstealer about his blast furnace and bloomery theories, low temp carbon reduction etc. Also go back to my responses to his assertion that Millette identified Tnemec when Millette actually says the opposite. I want you to realize that if any of you would give such misleading information in a scientific paper you could be in serious trouble, even facing charges of fraud, if the paper actually passed peer review which is unlikely.
That being said, I have gone over Henry´s two papers, and you have to notice carefully that he does not really accuse jones of "giving out phony chips" but does offer some speculation that it is possible that he could do that or that Jones et al were deceived by others. But he also offers another explanation, that is he has red-red chips that already have spheres so they could be previously ignited and as such no longer active. If Jones where to give out "phoney chips" then why would he give chips that do not react?
Do yourself a favor and do not ask people to read screwloosechange. This has the same effect as when truthers ask people to read forums about holographic planes and such hogwash.
And with that in mind I suggest you go back to the drawing board with your video, as it will have the same effect for it quickly makes obvious you have not done any research or that you simply do not understand. Making videos about subjects you do not understand
can make you look really bad, as that rebuttal video does, and it is very likely people will dismiss it as hogwash or disinformation. Just as one example I briefly mention your ideas about the comparison of the DSC curves of Harrit´s chips to one example of a known superthermite. The idea behind those curves is based on the assumption that superthermite incendiaries and explosives release energy faster than paint for example. The total energy release per gram and ignition temperature are NOT the point, as you can so many variations of this stuff that will have varying ignition temperatures, output, and characteristics.
All that said, I think an independent DSC test with an independent analysis of the results, comparing the alleged thermitic chips with known paint chips of different kinds, would be of value if only for the debate itself. While I am inclined to agree with the scientific view of Sunstealer, Ivan and Oystein that the DSC is both unnecessary and incorrect protocol, the argument will never be put to rest until such an experiment is carried out. You and others will always be able to say "They didn't do the DSC! They would have found the proof there!!" However, all THAT said, the chemical analysis of the chips in BOTH the Bentham paper and the Millette study shows they are NOT thermitic, and this is a fact that cannot be ignored.
It is up to you if you make more videos and if you keep reading screwloosehange and continue to believe Oystein, Sunstealer and their authoritative claims. Like I told you earlier, anonymous people on forums can say all kinds of things, but that does not mean these people or those forums are a reliable source of information.
Despite all the noise by Oystein et al, it is still a fact that Harrit et al followed the protocol of the people that developed this new class of materials, and that includes the DSC testing.
Your claims about Bentham paper chemical analysis is not based on fact, it is just an empty claim that rings hollow. Harrit´s chips certainly look thermitic and even Henry confirms that their chemical composition is consistent with that hypothesis, even though he could not confirm it:
Presence of red/dark gray chips and chemical composition of layers
roughly confirmed : Compatible with the nanothermite hypothesis
Henry´s paper has some interesting references including the following that describes a class of superthermites where the skeletal matrix is itself energetic just like Harrit et al suggest in their paper:
The final class of energetic material produced by sol-gel methods is energetic skeletal materials. Basically, the sol-gel chemistry is used to create a skeletal matrix, which is itself energetic.
Of course Harrit could be wrong about his hypothesis, but it is still a fact that his hypothesis of chips made of skeletal energetic matrix embedded with nanothermite is possible.