WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

I am sorry Oystein. It seemed so clear to me that Dr. Jones was explaining that the Resistivity test was meant as a filtering method.

As you know, Dr. Jones explains that there were so many red chips gathered from the WTC dust, they chose a quick Resistivity test as a means to easily comb out red chips that showed electrical resistances dramatically higher than the chips that were found to be thermitic.

It is reasonable to assume that since Dr. Jones was one of the authors of the Bentham Report, that he used the same methods that were documented in that report.

Therefore, unless you can persuade one of the authors to state otherwise, it can only be concluded that ALL the chips used, were from batches that had passed the Resistivity test.

MM

OMG, you are worse than I thought.

You have been shown several times already the entire description of that test in the Bentham paper. here it is again:
Harrit e.al. said:
7. Could the Red Chip Material be Ordinary Paint?

We measured the resistivity of the red material (with very little gray adhering to one side) using a Fluke 8842A multimeter in order to compare with ordinary paints, using the formula:
Specific resistivity = RA / L​
where R = resistance (ohms); A = cross-sectional area (m2); L = thickness (m).

Given the small size of the red chip, about 0.5 mm x 0.5 mm, we used two probes and obtained a rough value of approximately 10 ohm-m. This is several orders of magnitude less than paint coatings we found tabulated which are typically over 1010 ohm-m [31].

It is clear that they performed the test, and got the result of 10 ohm-m, on precisely one (1) chip - "chip", not chips - a chips characterized by having "very little gray adhering to one side" and being "about 0.5 mm x 0.5 mm" in size.

The reason Professor Jones is "suggesting" someone else do this test is that he is a dishonest distractor, hel-bent on throwing a red herring down your throat.

Of course you know that perfectly well - you are as dishonest as he is, and this now plainer to see than ever. Or you trust in him irrationally and uncritically, which would makes you a gullible fool. Either way:

Bye bye.
 
You are talking about a simple resistivity test which is about as simple and repeatable as they come. And the accuracy part leaves a lot of room for a little variance since we are talking about material x being about 10 billion times more resistive than material Y, so it should not be too complicated to use this test to help rule out certain batches of millette chips.
Did Jones himself, or his team, use that test to "help rule out certain batches of chips", jtl?
Did they use that test to rule out that chips a-d are paint?
Did they use that test to rule out that chip the MEK-chip is paint?
Did they use that test to rule out that the four chips burnded in the DSC are paint?
Did they use that test to rule out that chip the multi-layered chip is paint?
Did they use that test to rule out that chip the chip with the carbon layer is paint?

Of course they did NOT, and you know it, too: They did that test on just one chip, and have NOT determined at all that all alleged "thermitic" chips share this low resistivity, and all paint chips do not!

The same for the MEK test. Given 50 hours of soak all the different paint chips should become soft while one kind of chips stays hard. This seems like another very easy way to help find the right chips.
No, this is wrong. Why do you think that all paints become soft in MEK? Different paints have different matrix materials that react differently to MEK-soaking. What makes you think that all the different supposed "thermitic" chips don't? Jones has documented that on uncharacterized chips, and the chip shown in figures 12-18. This chip clearly is different from chips a-d, clearly is different from the multi-layered chip, and you cannot know of it is the same, or a different, material as the four chip documented in the DSC.

If you can´t trust Millette to perform these simple tests it is time you replace him with someone who can do.
Millette shows his competence by staying away from inconclusive, incompetence tests the results of which are meaningless.

If you can't trust Jones to perform competent tests, and do so systematically, then you should never have believed their stupid conclusions in the first place.
 
Guys,
as for the measurements of electrical resistance of the chips/paints, I'd like to note once again that my job are conjugated, hence semiconductive or even conductive polymers. But they can be even insulators, depends on the case. The measurements of their electrical properties are indeed pretty important.

Therefore I know well that electrical resistance of polymer films (or films of other materials) should be measured not by primitive two-probe arrangement (like in Bentham paper), but by so called "four probe method". As you can read e.g. in the Wiki entry Four-terminal sensing , "The key advantage of four-terminal sensing is that the separation of current and voltage electrodes eliminates the impedance contribution of the wiring and contact resistances."

Hence, electrical resistivity measurements in Bentham paper are rather "naive" and the results can be wrong for numerous reasons.
(Not speaking to the fact, that the comparison of resistivity of red/graychips with unspecified paints is just another clear sign of utter incompetence of Harrit et al;))

(Addendum: I read now the quote of Bentham paper pasted by Oystein: "Given the small size of the red chip, about 0.5 mm x 0.5 mm, we used two probes". It follows from this that someone from Bentham team even knows that four probe method is the method of choice, but unusable here because of too little samples. But this does not change the fact that two probe method is not reliable and can give very wrong results.)
 
Last edited:
(Not speaking to the fact, that the comparison of resistivity of red/graychips with unspecified paints is just another clear sign of utter incompetence of Harrit et al;))
Not unspecified, just unavailable for free. From the paper

[...] paint coatings we found tabulated which are typically over 1010 ohm-m [31].
​
And reference [31] tells us what they compared it to:
[31] Abu Ayana YM, El-Sawy SM, Salah SH. Zinc-ferrite pigment for corrosion protection. Anti-Corros Methods Mater 1997; 44(6): 381-8.
Available from: http://www.emeraldinsight.com/Insight/ViewContentServlet?Filename=Published/EmeraldFullTextArticle/Articles/1280440604.html
​
It costs $25 to download, which I didn't do. But the abstract mentions it refers to a zinc-ferrite pigment and:

The prepared pigment was incorporated in some paint formulations. Physical, chemical and mechanical properties of the formulated paint films were studied and also tested for corrosion resistance.
​

Alas, in order to know the details of what they compared the resistivity to, one needs to purchase the article. I, for one, am curious, but not $25-curious.
 
pgimeno: You are right and I was wrong in this respect. Thanks:cool:

Tomorrow at work, I will check if this paper is available for me.
 
Last edited:
You are talking about a simple resistivity test which is about as simple and repeatable as they come. And the accuracy part leaves a lot of room for a little variance since we are talking about material x being about 10 billion times more resistive than material Y, so it should not be too complicated to use this test to help rule out certain batches of millette chips.

The same for the MEK test. Given 50 hours of soak all the different paint chips should become soft while one kind of chips stays hard. This seems like another very easy way to help find the right chips.

If you can´t trust Millette to perform these simple tests it is time you replace him with someone who can do.

Never saw an ohmmeter with a "billion" scale on it.
 
Millette actually did the work to determine exactly what the carbon matrix material in his samples is. Harrit et al don't.

This seems to be quite optimistic to me, Sunstealer. I think that Harrit and Co. had a very good knowledge about the composition of the red layer. I further think, that it is no coincidence that they incorporated the DSC test and the resistivity test. My opinion is, that this is a clear case of deliberate disinformation.

http://undsci.berkeley.edu/article/0_0_0/howscienceworks_16

Re : Peer review, the above link may be of interest to some ?

A very interesting link, but the following page is even more interesting:

http://undsci.berkeley.edu/article/0_0_0/howscienceworks_17

This article deals with the replication of scientific studies and I think, that jtl and MM as well as Jones should read this carefully, especially the following paragraph:

Does this mean that scientists are constantly repeating what others before them have already done? No, of course not — or we would never get anywhere at all. The process of science doesn't require that every experiment and every study be repeated, but many are, especially those that produce surprising or particularly important results. In some fields, it is standard procedure for a scientist to replicate his or her own results before publication in order to ensure that the findings were not due to some fluke or factors outside the experimental design.

Bolding is mine.
 
Last edited:
Guys,
as for the measurements of electrical resistance of the chips/paints, I'd like to note once again that my job are conjugated, hence semiconductive or even conductive polymers. But they can be even insulators, depends on the case. The measurements of their electrical properties are indeed pretty important.

Therefore I know well that electrical resistance of polymer films (or films of other materials) should be measured not by primitive two-probe arrangement (like in Bentham paper), but by so called "four probe method". As you can read e.g. in the Wiki entry Four-terminal sensing , "The key advantage of four-terminal sensing is that the separation of current and voltage electrodes eliminates the impedance contribution of the wiring and contact resistances."

Hence, electrical resistivity measurements in Bentham paper are rather "naive" and the results can be wrong for numerous reasons.
(Not speaking to the fact, that the comparison of resistivity of red/graychips with unspecified paints is just another clear sign of utter incompetence of Harrit et al;))

(Addendum: I read now the quote of Bentham paper pasted by Oystein: "Given the small size of the red chip, about 0.5 mm x 0.5 mm, we used two probes". It follows from this that someone from Bentham team even knows that four probe method is the method of choice, but unusable here because of too little samples. But this does not change the fact that two probe method is not reliable and can give very wrong results.)

At the level they're dealing with the probe-to-chip resistance could cause considerable error.
 
"OMG, you are worse than I thought.

You have been shown several times already the entire description of that test in the Bentham paper. here it is again:

It is clear that they performed the test, and got the result of 10 ohm-m, on precisely one (1) chip - "chip", not chips - a chips characterized by having "very little gray adhering to one side" and being "about 0.5 mm x 0.5 mm" in size.

The reason Professor Jones is "suggesting" someone else do this test is that he is a dishonest distractor, hel-bent on throwing a red herring down your throat.

Of course you know that perfectly well - you are as dishonest as he is, and this now plainer to see than ever. Or you trust in him irrationally and uncritically, which would makes you a gullible fool. Either way:

Bye bye."

What is so useful about the Resistivity test, is that it is quick and easy, and it does not depend on precision.

It is the dramatic differences in easily obtained resistivity values that make it easy to eliminate red chip materials with high electrical resistance (paint) from red materials with dramatically lower electrical resistance.

Dr. Jones has publicly stated that there were a lot of red/gray chips collected, many of which were paint, and that their elimination by Resistivity testing significantly reduced the number of chips to be examined prior to further testing.

MM
 
What is so useful about the Resistivity test, is that it is quick and easy, and it does not depend on precision.

If it is so quick and easy,
why did Jones fail to do it on chip a?
why did Jones fail to do it on chip b?
why did Jones fail to do it on chip c?
why did Jones fail to do it on chip d?
why did Jones fail to do it on the MEK-soaiked chip?
why did Jones fail to do it on the first DSCed chip (MacKinlay 1)?
why did Jones fail to do it on the second DSCed chip (MacKinlay 2)?
why did Jones fail to do it on the third DSCed chip (Intermont)?
why did Jones fail to do it on the fourth DSCed chip (White)?
why did Jones fail to do it on the multilayered chip?
why did Jones fail to do it on the chip with the carbon layer?

Why did they not say in the article, in the segment that describes chip isolation, that this is their method to isolate chips?

-> Because it isn't!

They don't know if chip a has this high resistivity.
They don't know if chip b has this high resistivity.
They don't know if chip c has this high resistivity.
They don't know if chip d has this high resistivity.
They don't know if the MEK-chip has this high resistivity.
They don't know if any of the four DSCed chips has this high resistivity.
They don't know if the multi-layered chip has this high resistivity.
They don't know if the chip with the carbon layer has this high resistivity.

So MM, is this a useful, reliabale feature, givenm that they measured it on precisely one (1) chip, and given that they already knew they were dealing with several different kinds of chips?



You know the answer. You can't be that stupid.
You are propagating Jones's dishonesty and make it your own.


You heap shame upon you with every dishonest post.
 
At the level they're dealing with the probe-to-chip resistance could cause considerable error.

Well, anyway my sentence "Not speaking to the fact, that the comparison of resistivity of red/graychips with unspecified paints is just another clear sign of utter incompetence of Harrit et al" was not clever.
I even owe the apology to Harrit et al, since in this case paint(s) were specified at least by some link with some table. I was incompetent in this sentence.

It's probably hard to predict or estimate the eletrical resistivity of paint with ca 50 % of nanosized hematite in pigments, where pigments represent some 30 % of paint (e.g. Laclede).

It would be much better to see tables with real values.

But I can anyway measure at least the resistivity of my Laclede paint imitation next week:o)
 
Last edited:
What is so useful about the Resistivity test, is that it is quick and easy, and it does not depend on precision.

It is the dramatic differences in easily obtained resistivity values that make it easy to eliminate red chip materials with high electrical resistance (paint) from red materials with dramatically lower electrical resistance.

Dr. Jones has publicly stated that there were a lot of red/gray chips collected, many of which were paint, and that their elimination by Resistivity testing significantly reduced the number of chips to be examined prior to further testing.

MM
But none of this is mentioned in the paper under 2. Chip Size, Isolation, and Examination.

How do you expect anyone doing a follow up to this paper to know that you need to perform a resistivity test on every chip attracted by a magnet in order to separate the correct chips out when that is not specified anywhere in the paper?

If it is specified then explicitly state where. BTW, don't quote page 27 because that doesn't state that every chip needs to have an electrical test performed on it. It only states that they tested a chip with little gray layer acknowledging the fact that the gray layer may cause problems with such a test.

How come Millette's chips show exactly the same EDX for the red and gray layer as chips a-d even though he didn't perform the resistivity test?

How come Millette's chips show exactly the hexagonal platelets and rhomboid particles in the red layer as chips a-d even though he didn't perform the resistivity test?

How come Millette's chips show exactly the same EDX spectra for those hexagonal and rhomboidal particles in the red as chips a-d even though he didn't perform the resistivity test?

How come Millette's chips show exactly the same carbon matrix in the red layer as chips a-d even though he didn't perform the resistivity test?

Why do Millette's chips exactly match all the characteristics of chips a-d in Harrit et al, but truthers ignore these facts, and instead concentrate on a test that is meaningless and not required to do the science?
 
Wow his highness speaks again, still with his little mask on and keeping up the act. So cute, go tell you mommy. I never said the gray layer is pure iron, but the whole point of the post was that iron oxide, be it from red or gray layer, does not get reduced into iron when undergoing "oxidation" as in burning.

It is true that iron is reduced from iron oxide in a BLAST FURNACE using C as fuel given very special circumstances, but it takes a very confused scientist(or someone pretending to be a scientist) to think that is in any way similar to a 700 degree DSC. But then sunstealer is very confused, finding it difficult to tell the difference between metals and carbon., and also saying Millette identified Tnemec when he specifically noted he did not.

You have proven again sunstealer that you have not and will never publish any of your "confusions" because you are not capable of facing actual scientists in the real world. But keep up the act, it is so impressive:p
If you knew what you were talking about and had managed to complete a degree in Metallurgy and Materials Engineering like me, then you'd realise how wrong you are, here's the diagram that proves you wrong,

picture.php


So jtl - what is the temperature below which it is thermodynamically impossible for magnetite to reduce to iron? The diagram tells you by the way. Show how you arrive at your answer using the diagram.
 
Sunstealer: If you knew what you were talking about and had managed to complete a degree in Metallurgy and Materials Engineering like me, then you'd realise how wrong you are, here's the diagram that proves you wrong,

Stop the act, it became transparent long ago.

You cant even tell the difference between air temperature and metal temperature, and you evidently do not understand the "special conditions" under which this reduction occurs in stages going up to about 1200 degrees(C) metal temp:

This reduction requires refined carbon fuel and limestone together, the latter being missing from the DSC.

It also involves a turbocharger pressuring air into the furnace, and this air is pre-heated to over 1000 degrees(C). The actual final maximum air temperature of the blast furnace is about 2000 degrees(C). The DSC does not have these things, having to do manage with one atmosphere and 700(C).

The blast furnace process also takes several hours, and the result is carbon infused pig iron not elemental iron.

Edited by LashL: 
Edited to remove breach of Rule 0 and Rule 12.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Edited by LashL: 
Edited to remove quote of moderated content and response to same.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Ivan Kminek, please check out post 1649 which includes a link to my response to you that was moved, saying among other things:
You as a scientist must appreciate the difference between theories and test results. Basile has done tests to back up his red layer hypothesis, while you have nothing to back up your gray layer hypothesis. Going back to "my point" above, you now need tests if you want to refute Basile, talk won´t do it anymore.

Also, I would like you to respond to this comment from 1649:

jtl: Also, the iron oxide turned into iron is not so easy to dismiss even without confirmed al oxide in the residue because if you burn iron the normal way you end up with oxidized iron, but with these chips it seems the other way around, they start out with Fe to O in a 2 to 3 ratio(iron oxide) but end up with almost pure iron spheres with Fe to O in up to 4 to 1 ratio.

This is what you would expect from thermite reaction but if the gray layer is being burned into molten spheres they should be the other way around, turned into iron oxide.

Also, do you have any thoughts regarding XRD tests and vague results? Is it possible that those chips have a unusual or amorphous form of kaolin in case they are LaClede? What about Tnemec aluminum oxide, could it be an amorphous form? Could it have some sort of Si based coating, and could it be in the form of platelets? Can you think of anything to refute Jones´s idea of amorphous aluminum?
 
Is it possible that those chips have a unusual or amorphous form of kaolin in case they are LaClede? What about Tnemec aluminum oxide, could it be an amorphous form? Could it have some sort of Si based coating, and could it be in the form of platelets? Can you think of anything to refute Jones´s idea of amorphous aluminum?

jtl, we know from both Harrit's and Millette's study that the red layer contains hexagonal platelats, which are of the typical size of kaolin platelets (ca. 0.001 mm). We know from both studies, that these platelets contain aluminum and silicon and that the amount of both elements is equal. And we know from Millette's study that the platelets are kaolin as he recorded the IR spectra of different chips. So the answer is clear: No, the chips a - d of the Harrit study didn't contain kaolin in an amorphous form.

ETA: It is not necessary to refute the amorphous aluminum hypothesis as long as it isn't backed up by proper data. If Jones doesn't present the data, this hypothesis will be marked as an unsubstantiated claim.
 
Last edited:
Africanus: So the answer is clear: No, the chips a - d of the Harrit study didn't contain kaolin in an amorphous form.

Jones XRD says no kaolin in std form so if there is also no amorphous form of it in chips a - d then there is no kaolin in them at all, meaning no LaClede paint. No Zn in them means they are not Tnemec so this would mean they are not any form of known WTC primer paint.

The XRD is just another indicator that Millette and Harrit do not have the same chips, along with Millette´s titanium chips that become soft in MEK. Leave it up to Kminek to answer technical questions.

The process of science doesn't require that every experiment and every study be repeated, but many are, especially those that produce surprising or particularly important results. In some fields, it is standard procedure for a scientist to replicate his or her own results before publication in order to ensure that the findings were not due to some fluke or factors outside the experimental design.
Africanus: Bolding is mine.

Red color is my emphasis. Molten iron spheres would be the very surprising first recorded case for paint, and for superthermite study they would be the important result, so there is no way to avoid replicating the DSC tests, as they are the central feature in Harrit´s paper.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom