WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

So here is my question and anyone on either side is welcome to answer: when a scientific paper is beinmg published to test the findings of a prior study, is it expected that every aspect of the original protocol be followed to the letter, even if parts of the original study are believed to have been poorly carried out? Or is it more standard to ask the same question and then replicate only the relevant parts, and also filling in the missing parts of the original study (which is what Millette did)?

I don't want just the standard debunker answer, I'd like to know what the tradition is in scientific circles when publishing a paper that follows up on a prior published work.
Chris,

First of all, let me say that I am not a scientist, but I am somewhat familiar with the publication process through several acquaintances.

I doubt that anyone is interested in publishing a replication of a previous study. Publishers typically reject material when it is not sufficiently novel; I've seen it happen several times. For that reason, the only results that would tend to be published at all are negative replications, not positive ones, even if they are performed, written and submitted. Scientists tend to be curious and 'systematically incredulous' people, after all, so I have no doubt that some results are replicated.

However, replication is the tool to use when there is suspicion of fraudulent data, not of flawed methodology: if the method is sound but the conclusions are suspicious based on the data, then by following the same protocols, if your data does not match that of the suspected paper, you have an indication of possible fraud.

But flawed methods are not necessarily fraud, they are just bad science. And this article explains why writing rebuttal papers is a bad idea:

http://dealingwithcreationisminastr.../why-dont-rebuttals-appear-in-scientific.html

The author postulates that it's better for bad science to fall into oblivion because citation raises the relevance of it. That was my concern if Millette's study gets published. Say 0.1 percent of scientists are gullible enough as to fall for the fallacies in Jones et al paper without having any previous preconception on 9/11 conspiracies. That means that If 1000 relevant neutral scientists around the globe have read the paper, 1 has fallen. Now imagine Millette publishes his results in a respectable journal, and it is read by 10,000 people. That means that 10 will fall for it. 10 more supporters for the cause, which facilitates it to gain momentum over time. Frankly, given the reputation of the journal where Jones et al. published, things are quite good as they are without giving the paper any more publicity.

Back to replication, is the ATM paper under suspicion of data fabrication? No, I have not seen anyone here claim any such thing. I personally don't believe that to be the case. But some of their methods and experiments are nonsensical, and their conclusions don't follow from their results, quite the opposite: their results disprove their conclusions. It is just bad science, and the best solution is oblivion. Perhaps that's why so many laboratories shut their doors on you.
 
I saw that but it didn't strike me at the time as it doesn't impress me. But inaccuracy does, and there are 11 zeros in MM's version, meaning he's misquoting. Good job, MM.

I confess to accidentally miscounting and adding a meaningless zero when translating from the Bentham Paper. When I noticed the typo, it was past the time JREF allows for editing posts.

Whether it be my 100 billion ohm-m typo, or the Bentham Paper's actual reading of 10 billion ohm-m, makes no significant difference when applied as a measurement comparison to a 10 ohm-m reference.

But I do regret not being able to correct it.

MM
 
I confess to accidentally miscounting and adding a meaningless zero when translating from the Bentham Paper. When I noticed the typo, it was past the time JREF allows for editing posts.

Whether it be my 100 billion ohm-m typo, or the Bentham Paper's actual reading of 10 billion ohm-m, makes no significant difference when applied as a measurement comparison to a 10 ohm-m reference.

But I do regret not being able to correct it.

MM

Talking about that electric resistivity nonsense:

You claimes earlier that this electric resistivity test is "the test that helped them to identify the chips of interest".

I asked you to back up that bare-assed assertion with fact, by telling us WHICH chips they ACTUALLY identify using that test:

chip a? (Fig. 6-11)
chip b? (Fig. 6-11)
chip c? (Fig. 6-11)
chip d? (Fig. 6-11)
The MEK-chip? (Fig. 12-18)
The chip 1 from the MacKinkley sample that they tested in the DSC? (Fig. 19)
The chip 2 from the MacKinkley sample that they tested in the DSC? (Fig. 19)
The chip from the Intermont sample that they tested in the DSC? (Fig. 19)
The chip from the White sample that they tested in the DSC? (Fig. 19)
The multilayered chip? (Fig 31)
The chip with the carbon layer? (Fig 32+33)

11 chips they presented in some detail in the paper. MM, did they perform "the test that helped them to identify the chips of interest" on all of these 11 chips? Or at least on 1 od these 11 chips?

How many chips did they test with that method, MM?


Why haven't you answered this question, MM?



@ ergo: Can you answer these questions for MM? Do you also believe that electric resistivity is "the test that helped them to identify the chips of interest"?

@ jtl: Can you answer these questions for MM? Do you also believe that electric resistivity is "the test that helped them to identify the chips of interest"?

Can any one of you truthers answer questions honestly?
 
The first WTC red/gray chip so tested was approximately 1mm 1mm. After a few seconds of heating, the high-speed ejection of a hot particle was observed under the hand of the person holding the torch (Fig. 22). The intense light and bright orange color of the particle attest to its high tempera- ture. In this case, the attempt to recover the diminutive end- product of the reaction was unsuccessful. A short video clip of the test (including slow-motion) is available here: http://journalof911studies.com/volume/2008/oxy_redchip_sl ow.mov

The above quote is from the Harrit paper. (no edit ;)) does anyone have a link to the short video clip?

Thanks Oystein for the post below.
 
Last edited:
It's a shame they have video of a sample they did not recover yet they have a sample of which they have no video ;)
 
I confess to accidentally miscounting and adding a meaningless zero when translating from the Bentham Paper. When I noticed the typo, it was past the time JREF allows for editing posts.

Whether it be my 100 billion ohm-m typo, or the Bentham Paper's actual reading of 10 billion ohm-m, makes no significant difference when applied as a measurement comparison to a 10 ohm-m reference.

But I do regret not being able to correct it.

MM

That's ok, MM, Typos happen and I for one understand.

What I don't understand is how significant their measurement is. Are you aware of any Measurement System Analysis they performed to show that their method of measurement of resistivity in a paint chip using a fluke meter is accurate and repeatable?
 
"Whether it be my 100 billion ohm-m typo, or the Bentham Paper's actual reading of 10 billion ohm-m, makes no significant difference when applied as a measurement comparison to a 10 ohm-m reference."
"What I don't understand is how significant their measurement is. Are you aware of any Measurement System Analysis they performed to show that their method of measurement of resistivity in a paint chip using a fluke meter is accurate and repeatable?"

If it was not repeatable, it would never have been suggested as a means for eliminating the large amount of paint and other red material in the dust.

Dr. Jones said:
"Also, we checked the electrical resistivity of several paints – consistently orders of magnitude higher than that of the red material. We reported the resistivity of the red material in our paper, page 27 in the Journal. Millette did not report any electrical resistivity measurements. This measurement is rather easy to do so I was surprised when he failed to do this straightforward test. There is a lot of red material of various types in the WTC dust, so one must be careful to make sure it is the same as what we studied, and not some other material."

MM
 
If it was not repeatable, it would never have been suggested as a means for eliminating the large amount of paint and other red material in the dust.

MM

So, MM, did they, did Jones, IN FACT use that method to eliminate chip a from the large amount of paint? YES or NO, MM?
Did they, did Jones, IN FACT use that method to eliminate chip b from the large amount of paint? YES or NO, MM?
Did they, did Jones, IN FACT use that method to eliminate chip c from the large amount of paint? YES or NO, MM?
Did they, did Jones, IN FACT use that method to eliminate chip d from the large amount of paint? YES or NO, MM?
Did they, did Jones, IN FACT use that method to eliminate the MEK-chip from the large amount of paint? YES or NO, MM?
Did they, did Jones, IN FACT use that method to eliminate the first (MacKinlay 1) DSCed chip from the large amount of paint? YES or NO, MM?
Did they, did Jones, IN FACT use that method to eliminate the second (MacKinley 2) DSCed chip from the large amount of paint? YES or NO, MM?
Did they, did Jones, IN FACT use that method to eliminate the third (Intermont) DSCed chip from the large amount of paint? YES or NO, MM?
Did they, did Jones, IN FACT use that method to eliminate the fourth (White) DSCed chip from the large amount of paint? YES or NO, MM?
Did they, did Jones, IN FACT use that method to eliminate the multylayered chip from the large amount of paint? YES or NO, MM?
Did they, did Jones, IN FACT use that method to eliminate the chip with the carbon layer from the large amount of paint? YES or NO, MM?

Did they, did Jones, IN FACT use that method to eliminate any chip at all from the large amount of paint? YES or NO, MM?


Twelve questions, MM, and if you don't answer all twelve, you are running away like a weasel. If you don't answer "NO" at least eleven times, you are a liar!


Because the obvious truth is:


Jones never every used that method to eliminate any of the supposedly "thermitic" chips, and you, MM, damned well know it, and from this follows that Jones's "suggestion" is a dishonest attempt at serving a red herring - a dishonesty continued by you, who concsiously avoids answering the eleven questions about the eleven chips!
 
Sunstealer: I'm taking jtl off ignore - the comedic value is just too high to let these gems go unseen.

For example he thinks the gray layer is pure iron and thinks it should turn into molten iron oxide.

Look mummy I'm doing science! lol

He doesn't realise that the gray layer IS iron oxide (and likely to contain haematite, wustite and magnetite) nor does he understand that a reduction of this layer by CO from the carbon in the epoxy is a good explanation as to why we see microspheres

Wow his highness speaks again, still with his little mask on and keeping up the act. So cute, go tell you mommy. I never said the gray layer is pure iron, but the whole point of the post was that iron oxide, be it from red or gray layer, does not get reduced into iron when undergoing "oxidation" as in burning.

It is true that iron is reduced from iron oxide in a BLAST FURNACE using C as fuel given very special circumstances, but it takes a very confused scientist(or someone pretending to be a scientist) to think that is in any way similar to a 700 degree DSC. But then sunstealer is very confused, finding it difficult to tell the difference between metals and carbon., and also saying Millette identified Tnemec when he specifically noted he did not.

You have proven again sunstealer that you have not and will never publish any of your "confusions" because you are not capable of facing actual scientists in the real world. But keep up the act, it is so impressive:p
 
Lol, come on then jtl let us in on the secret.

Who are you, what is your qualification and why should we listen to you.
 
If it was not repeatable, it would never have been suggested as a means for eliminating the large amount of paint and other red material in the dust.


MM
Wrong. Nothing is stopping anyone from suggesting it as a means from eliminating the paint and other material. And the existence of the suggestion is therefore not proof that the process is accurate and repeatable.

Only a valid analysis of the measurement system will show whether the measurements are accurate and repeatable. So was that performed, or not?
 
"Talking about that electric resistivity nonsense:

You claimes earlier that this electric resistivity test is "the test that helped them to identify the chips of interest".

I asked you to back up that bare-assed assertion with fact, by telling us WHICH chips they ACTUALLY identify using that test:

chip a? (Fig. 6-11)
chip b? (Fig. 6-11)
chip c? (Fig. 6-11)
chip d? (Fig. 6-11)
The MEK-chip? (Fig. 12-18)
The chip 1 from the MacKinkley sample that they tested in the DSC? (Fig. 19)
The chip 2 from the MacKinkley sample that they tested in the DSC? (Fig. 19)
The chip from the Intermont sample that they tested in the DSC? (Fig. 19)
The chip from the White sample that they tested in the DSC? (Fig. 19)
The multilayered chip? (Fig 31)
The chip with the carbon layer? (Fig 32+33)

11 chips they presented in some detail in the paper. MM, did they perform "the test that helped them to identify the chips of interest" on all of these 11 chips? Or at least on 1 od these 11 chips?

How many chips did they test with that method, MM?


Why haven't you answered this question, MM?



@ ergo: Can you answer these questions for MM? Do you also believe that electric resistivity is "the test that helped them to identify the chips of interest"?

@ jtl: Can you answer these questions for MM? Do you also believe that electric resistivity is "the test that helped them to identify the chips of interest"?

Can any one of you truthers answer questions honestly?
"

I am sorry Oystein. It seemed so clear to me that Dr. Jones was explaining that the Resistivity test was meant as a filtering method.

As you know, Dr. Jones explains that there were so many red chips gathered from the WTC dust, they chose a quick Resistivity test as a means to easily comb out red chips that showed electrical resistances dramatically higher than the chips that were found to be thermitic.

It is reasonable to assume that since Dr. Jones was one of the authors of the Bentham Report, that he used the same methods that were documented in that report.

Therefore, unless you can persuade one of the authors to state otherwise, it can only be concluded that ALL the chips used, were from batches that had passed the Resistivity test.

MM
 
Last edited:
Mohr: In the traditional community of chemists, no one would expect you to replicate a DSC test if your job was to ID an unknown chip.

The DSC tests are not used to "identify" the chips, those tests are used to confirm that the chips release energy quickly like superthermite, and leave molten metal spheres. There is no "traditional community of chemists", there are many different fields of specialization, and the relevant one here is the field dealing with superthermite. Harrit used DSC because he replicated procedures set out by scientists who developed this stuff. You cannot refute the paper without the same tests, so don´t waste your time and money.
 
the dsc tests are not used to "identify" the chips, those tests are used to confirm that the chips release energy quickly like superthermite, and leave molten metal spheres.

lmfao

So WTF does Millette need to replicate DSC tests to identify the chips.
 
Last edited:
LSSBB:Wrong. Nothing is stopping anyone from suggesting it as a means from eliminating the paint and other material. And the existence of the suggestion is therefore not proof that the process is accurate and repeatable.

You are talking about a simple resistivity test which is about as simple and repeatable as they come. And the accuracy part leaves a lot of room for a little variance since we are talking about material x being about 10 billion times more resistive than material Y, so it should not be too complicated to use this test to help rule out certain batches of millette chips.

The same for the MEK test. Given 50 hours of soak all the different paint chips should become soft while one kind of chips stays hard. This seems like another very easy way to help find the right chips.

If you can´t trust Millette to perform these simple tests it is time you replace him with someone who can do.
 
Last edited:
Harrit's paper refutes itself with DSC, no need for Millette to do

The DSC tests are not used to "identify" the chips, those tests are used to confirm that the chips release energy quickly like superthermite, and leave molten metal spheres. There is no "traditional community of chemists", there are many different fields of specialization, and the relevant one here is the field dealing with superthermite. Harrit used DSC because he replicated procedures set out by scientists who developed this stuff. You cannot refute the paper without the same tests, so don´t waste your time and money.
Yes, you can refute the Harrit fraud paper without doing anything but reading the paper. The misuse of DSC proves they are making up nonsense, and proof is they fooled you. This is hilarious.

No need to do DSC, there is no thermite in the dust in the first place. It is ironic Jones fooled people with a DSC which does not match thermite. Your claim you can't refute the paper with doing a useless test is reflective of zero knowledge of chemistry, and shallow research.

You understand the chip release energy like soil, more so than thermite. Why are you so gullible?

You understand the chips match carbon/wood better than thermite? lol

Have you taken chemistry? Do you know how to find DSC traces for soil and carbon/wood?
 
Last edited:
The DSC tests are not used to "identify" the chips, those tests are used to confirm that the chips release energy quickly like superthermite, and leave molten metal spheres.


So, why do you suppose the authors of the paper chose not to document the chips they found to leave these "molten spheres"?
 
You are talking about a simple resistivity test which is about as simple and repeatable as they come. And the accuracy part leaves a lot of room for a little variance since we are talking about material x being about 10 billion times more resistive than material Y, so it should not be too complicated to use this test to help rule out certain batches of millette chips.

The same for the MEK test. Given 50 hours of soak all the different paint chips should become soft while one kind of chips stays hard. This seems like another very easy way to help find the right chips.

If you can´t trust Millette to perform these simple tests it is time you replace him with someone who can do.

Your answer is a lot of handwaving. I know what a reistivity test is. I have done several myself. I also have my own fluke meter. I also now well how to verify a measurement system. If you cannot certify a measurement system is accurate and repeatible you cannot defend the measurement made with it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom