WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

Quote:
Originally Posted by Harrit et al
"Given the small size of the red chip, about 0.5 mm x 0.5 mm, we used two probes and obtained a rough value of approximately 10 ohm-m. This is several orders of magnitude less than paint coatings we found tabulated which are typically over 100,000,000,000 ohm-m [31]."



The above quote was taken from post 1618 by MM

Does anyone notice anything unusual about it ?

Looks like the actual reading on the meter must have been .0005 ohms.

(.5mm per ohm/1000 mm)
 
Maybe you should talk to Gamolon?

You do know what a probe is don't you?

MM

Quite unnecessary. Just answer the questions:

MM, which "chips of interest" did they in fact "identify" with those electrical resistivity measurements?
  1. Did they identify chip a with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  2. Did they identify chip b with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  3. Did they identify chip c with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  4. Did they identify chip d with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  5. Did they identify the MEK-soaked chip with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  6. Did they identify the first chip they tested in the DSC (Fig. 19, MacKinlay 1, blue line) with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  7. Did they identify the second chip they tested in the DSC (Fig. 19, MacKinlay 2, red line) with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  8. Did they identify the third chip they tested in the DSC (Fig. 19, Intermont, black line) with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  9. Did they identify the fourth chip they tested in the DSC (Fig. 19, White, green line) with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  10. Did they identify the multilayered chip (Fig. 31) with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  11. Did they identify the chip with the carbon layer (Fig. 32+33) with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
MM, that's 11 separate "chips of interest", 11 separate questions, I expect 11 separate answers. And I expect you to answer all 11 of them with "I don't know".

So much ignorance, MM!

But here is an easy one for you:

On how many chips did they do any electrical resistivity measurements?

So then, of the above-mentioned 11 chips, how many did they NOT select via electrical resistivity measurements?


Final question, MM:


Is "electrical resistivity measurements" the test that helped them to identify the chips of interest, and made it easy to eliminate the many paint chips, MM? Yes, or no?
 
Let's not be too quick to go after MM here, he is quoting Jones and of course MM can't answer every question about what Jones did. Seems to me that Jones is the one who should be challenged, if indeed he tested only two out of 11 chips or whatever. I have been trying to write to Jones, so far with marginal success. MM and Oystein, what would you like to know from Jones about this matter? Two things I want to avoid: asking dozens of questions and being insulting. Jones won't respond to either of these I'm certain.

My questions are here:

Asking Truth scientists: How do you tell energetic and mundane chips apart?

Excerpt:

Abstract

It has been alleged that dust particles from WTC dust that have the two properties "attracted by a magnet" and "are red-gray chips" are also active thermitic material. However, recent remarks made by some of the researchers involved strongly suggest that many chips selected by those criteria may in fact be really just paint.

In order for follow-up researcher to select the "right" chips, an objective method should exist to separate the "right" ("energetic", "thermitic") from "wrong" (perhaps "paint" etc.) chips.

It is also not entirely clear, in my mind, if the researchers like Harrit, Jones, Farrer or Basile who have reported on "energetic" chips were aware of the distinction at the time, and did in fact separate the different kinds of chips prior to any desctructive tests that yielded exotherm reactions and suspicious residues.

I expect that these "thermite"-proponents can declare unequivocally how to distinguish "thermitic" from mundane chips before any destructive experiments are done. I have designed a series of questions to shed light on this.

...

It appears now that some of the authors of ATM [1] acknowledge that indeed some of the red-gray chips they selected were mundane - and believe that Millette looked at the wrong chips! This raises a few questions, that I would like these scientists to answer before any further studies (e.g. Mark Basile, [4]) are undertaken – most prominently:

By what non-destructive method and objective criteria – in addition to selection by magnet and visually seperating red-gray chip – can a researcher who attempts to study the "energetic" red-gray chips, that are alleged to be thermitic, distinguish them from mundane materials such as paint?
​

Please make sure you include the detailed questions. Jones must admit that he did not use electric resistivity, MEK soaking, thermal testing or anything else to actually separate and identify ALL the chips they used in the Bentham paper, and only ASSUME they are all the same material, based ONLY on their being magnetic and red-gray - nothing else.
 
It is always interesting what you choose to leave out.

Or have you forgotten the test that helped them to identify the chips of interest, and made it easy to eliminate the many paint chips?

As you know from your 9/11Blogger exchange with Dr. Jones last September, 2012, that part of the chip isolation process involved Resistivity testing.


Dr. Jones said:
"Also, we checked the electrical resistivity of several paints – consistently orders of magnitude higher than that of the red material. We reported the resistivity of the red material in our paper, page 27 in the Journal. Millette did not report any electrical resistivity measurements. This measurement is rather easy to do so I was surprised when he failed to do this straightforward test. There is a lot of red material of various types in the WTC dust, so one must be careful to make sure it is the same as what we studied, and not some other material."

MM
The quoted fragment does NOT say that they isolated the chips that way. It mentions they tested "several paints" and the "red material".

If they did, which there's no evidence of, why the heck is not that included in section "2. Chip Size, Isolation,[/b ] and Examination"? It goes into quite some details. Why didn't they include the resistivity test there if they used it? The obvious answer is they didn't. They tested one chip and included the result for that chip. That's what the paper says. Anything beyond that is speculation.

What I read in the paragraph you've quoted is that they are playing "dragon in my garage": "Ok, but your chips are not like mine because they have a different resistivity." And when the resistivity is shown to be the same, "Ok, but your chips are not like mine because mine produce iron microspheres." And when the iron microspheres are shown, "Ok, but your chips are not like mine because..."

But letting their chips to be tested? Never! How would they claim they're not the same then? They have THE thermitic chips, those ubiquitous chips in the dust that only the proponents of fringe conspiracies can find.~


Nowhere has Dr. Jones et al indicated that the Resistivity test was only used once.
Nowhere have they indicated that he used it more than once either. And more importantly, nowhere have they indicated that that method was used to separate chips.


Why would he be so interested in how useful it was in sorting-out all the paint chips if he never used it?
Why, to claim they are not the same and keep the ball rolling. That was an easy one.
 
Last edited:
Why don't Harrit et al or Jones or Basile supply Milette with thermite chips to analyse? Surely that way they are guaranteed to have analysed the same sample?

Why haven't they released these thermite chips to the wider scientific community so that they can be studied?
 
OK we may be on a track here. MM and JTL have outlined the Jones objection to the process of finding the chips. Oystein has listed some possible questions to give to Jones. There are so many I could ask, I do want to boil it down to a handful. And thanks Sunstealer, I kind of thought the slavish replication of an existing test was not standard protocol.

My goal here is 1) to get a clear and brief summary of why Steven Jones has claimed the chips Millette used were different, in Jones's own words. 2) to ask Steven Jones exactly what his protocol was for finding the chips 3) to pass his answers on to Millette. I don't think Millette will need the rebuttals to the Jones claims, just a clear exposition of Jones's claims and protocol.

I am still bitter about the fact that Kevin Ryan refused to release samples to me to give to Millette for testing. But this exercise is about summarizing everything Jones has said and done, then passing the information along. Remember my training as a journalist? Watch any good journalist in a challenging interview; they often get quotes or summaries from Person X to read to Person Y for comment. My mission here is to open up both sides so the truth can find its way into the light. So as one example, instead of arguing about exactly what Jones et al actually DID when isolating the chips of interest, I would like to ask him. And of course I will continue to ask him for full disclosure and release of all tests on the chips, which he has promised and has not yet delivered.
 
Last edited:
The above quote was taken from post 1618 by MM

Does anyone notice anything unusual about it ?

I spot one thing myself.

The reference [31] is http://www.emeraldinsight.com/journals.htm?articleid=876638&show=html, Zinc-ferrite pigment for corrosion protection.

These are very specific "paint coatings": it's "zinc-ferrite pigment [...] incorporated in some paint formulations".

Are those the "paint coatings we found tabulated which are typically over 1010 ohm-m [31]"?
 
Harrit first uses DSC test to show that it is energetic because he replicates procedure by people that developed superthermite, so saying this is a useless test is absolute garbage.
Of course it is energetic. Epoxy is energetic. Paper is energetic. Sugar is energetic. All those would show a peak in a DSC under air that would qualify them as energetic.


Harrit then says the energetic exotherm is due to thermite reaction because he compares the residue to the original ingredients, i.e he says he had iron oxide before burn and molten iron after burn, again basically replicating procedure by the developers.
Alas, no aluminium oxide. And visible iron oxide remaining after the process.


Maybe Millette can prove that Harrit results are not conclusive or flawed. He does not compare the DSC results with paint results so he doe not really prove you can´t get similar results with paint, does not prove there is al oxide in the residue etc. But Millette cannot ignore the DSC tests or not do them.
That's reversing the burden of proof. But thanks for admitting the fact that they didn't do a test that would put them closer to having proved they claims. You seem to realize that their claims are not proved.

Since they haven't proved their claims, why don't you push them to do so instead of Millette? Why are you choosing to believe those clumsy amateurs?
 
Actually you forgot to add context to "energetic substance" which is the direct comparison to a known superthermite DSX peak, fig29, so the context is releasing the energy as quickly as one known type of super-thermite.
You don't know what DSC is for; or what?

Fig 29 shows it was not thermite.

111JonesDelusion.jpg

What the purpose of DSC? Why can't you answer? You debunked Jones work, when the topic is Millette. Why does thermite not match the chips, all the chips are not thermite? Why?

Why does Jones DSC, Fig. 29 trace for their chip, match carbon or wood better than super-thermite? Better get some help with chemistry, quick.

The chip DSC is as close to thermite, as it is to soil. What was your point? Did you research any of the real chemistry, or the purpose of DSC? No.

Also, the iron oxide turned into iron is not so easy to dismiss even without confirmed al oxide in the residue because if you burn iron the normal way you end up with oxidized iron,
Making excuses for 911 truth?
Please give the formula for normal burning of iron?

This is pure nonsense.

You say iron oxide turned into iron.
Then you say if you burn iron you end up with iron oxide.

Where is this logic going? You show up as a debunker, and end up being a truther with no practical knowledge of chemistry.

but with these chips it seems the other way around, they start out with Fe to O in a 2 to 3 ratio(iron oxide) but end up with almost pure iron spheres with Fe to O in up to 4 to 1 ratio.

Seriously? Almost pure iron, 4 to 1 ratio? Almost pure.

You understand with thermite the product is iron, not your "almost pure" iron sphere.

This is what you would expect from thermite reaction but if the gray layer is being burned into molten spheres they should be the other way around, turned into iron oxide.
???

Is that friend you have; is he you?

Millette paper found no thermite; you are proving Harrit's paper is nonsense.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by Harrit et al
"Given the small size of the red chip, about 0.5 mm x 0.5 mm, we used two probes and obtained a rough value of approximately 10 ohm-m. This is several orders of magnitude less than paint coatings we found tabulated which are typically over 100,000,000,000 ohm-m [31]."
Re: MM's post 1618. Why has he decided to edit the Harrit post ?

I guess it must be a truther trick. Wow look the large figure at the end, it is so much more than 10 ohm-m

The question is, did MM edit or does he have an already edited truther source ?

A prime example of how the BS spreads. Well done MM Jones will be proud of you.
 
Last edited:
Actually you forgot to add context to "energetic substance" which is the direct comparison to a known superthermite DSX peak, fig29, so the context is releasing the energy as quickly slowly as one known type of superthermite.
Fixed that for you. From the paper: "The DSC tests were conducted with a linear heating rate of 10 °C per minute up to a temperature of 700 °C." That heating rate is the same as in Tillotson and Gash.That means the thermite peak lasted about 6 minutes (from about 490°C to around 540°C), while the blue peak, which is the most similar one, lasted about 3 minutes (from ~425°C to ~455°C). That raises a few questions:

1. In what sense are they similar?
2. What significance does any similarity in peak width have, given that the bulk of the heat comes from different materials (as you have admitted) in each case, and that the peak heights (which are no match for thermite), the temperature (which matches that of most organic substances) and the exothermic behavior are all different?


Also, the iron oxide turned into iron is not so easy to dismiss even without confirmed al oxide in the residue because if you burn iron the normal way you end up with oxidized iron, but with these chips it seems the other way around, they start out with Fe to O in a 2 to 3 ratio(iron oxide) but end up with almost pure iron spheres with Fe to O in up to 4 to 1 ratio.
There is no evidence in the paper that the iron oxide turned into anything (another sign of clumsiness). The red layer keeps being red, which is evidence of major quantities of iron oxide remaining there, and one of the micrographs shows clear iron oxide crystals together with a microsphere.


This is what you would expect from thermite reaction but if the gray layer is being burned into molten spheres they should be the other way around, turned into iron oxide.
I don't understand that logic. There is oxygen in all DSC microspheres, and it is not expected that most of the Fe gets oxidized if it comes from the gray layer; same thing applies if it comes from a thermite reaction in the presence of oxygen. So ask yourself these questions:

1. How can anyone distinguish iron rich microspheres coming from the gray layer, from iron rich microspheres coming from thermite?
2. If it is possible to make such a test, did the authors do it?

If the answer to question (1) is that one can't, then finding iron rich microspheres does not mean anything, and therefore the DSC test proves nothing without showing aluminium oxide, which the authors failed to do, something that speaks for their clumsiness. If the answer to question (2) is they didn't, then they failed to prove their conclusions, which speaks for their clumsiness. Either way:

  • They have not proved their conclusions in any scientifically sound way.
  • That their scientific incompetence is clear stems from the reading of the paper alone, and is obvious to anyone who understands how materials are characterized and the tests they published.
  • The tests they chose NOT to publish, however, does not speak about their scientific incompetence: they raise other questions.
Remember that DSC is not a material characterization experiment; Tillotson and Gash used it on a known substance, and even then, they needed to prove that the reaction resulting from DSC was the thermite reaction by showing presence of aluminium oxide in the residue, in order to validate their DSC curve.

In contrast, Jones et al. did the DSC test because they had a preconceived idea of what the material was, even failing to prove that the thermite reaction happened, and therefore they copied the test without committing to any proper and scientifically sound protocol (identification of the material before the test, separation of red from gray, usage of pure nitrogen instead of air, proper identification of the main products of a thermite reaction), which is clumsy, not to mention that DSC is not a valid material identification test to start with.
 
Re: MM's post 1618. Why has he decided to edit the Harrit post ?

I guess it must be a truther trick. Wow look the large figure at the end, it is so much more than 10 ohm-m

The question is, did MM edit or does he have an already edited truther source ?

A prime example of how the BS spreads. Well done MM Jones will be proud of you.
I saw that but it didn't strike me at the time as it doesn't impress me. But inaccuracy does, and there are 11 zeros in MM's version, meaning he's misquoting. Good job, MM.
 
I'm taking jtl off ignore - the comedic value is just too high to let these gems go unseen.

For example he thinks the gray layer is pure iron and thinks it should turn into molten iron oxide.

Look mummy I'm doing science! lol

He doesn't realise that the gray layer IS iron oxide (and likely to contain haematite, wustite and magnetite) nor does he understand that a reduction of this layer by CO from the carbon in the epoxy is a good explanation as to why we see microspheres.

I'd love to see him write the chemical equations that go with his wrong assumptions.

Bless him. It's soooo cute when truthers try to sound all sciency.
 
...
Lets not forget that your buddy Oystein also indicated that basile has admitted that the red chips are not superthermite when actually he seems really sure they are. This is called dishonesty, and nobody says nothing, including you.
...

Has jtl already corrected this FALSE rendering of what I said about Basile, and apologized? Or can I call this failure dishonesty?
 
Hi, Chris:cool:, as for your question:

"So here is my question and anyone on either side is welcome to answer: when a scientific paper is beinmg published to test the findings of a prior study, is it expected that every aspect of the original protocol be followed to the letter, even if parts of the original study are believed to have been poorly carried out? Or is it more standard to ask the same question and then replicate only the relevant parts, and also filling in the missing parts of the original study (which is what Millette did)?

I don't want just the standard debunker answer, I'd like to know what the tradition is in scientific circles when publishing a paper that follows up on a prior published work."


Personally, I do not remember any scientific paper, which was replicated "verbatim". But, some of its parts are replicated frequently for various reaons.

My job for ca 25 years has been a multistep synthesis of novel complex (conjugated) polymers and their monomers and precursors (I have ca 60 per-reviewed papers in the field). In this regard, my work is kind of "pioneering" one (I do not replicate anybody's whole work), but my new polymers are frequently similar to others, already known, and some precursors are frequently either similar or the same as in published papers.

As any organic/polymer synthetic chemist knows pretty well, replications of published synthetic "recipes" frequently do not work well (low yields, no yields, too complex reaction mixture as a result, etc.), so one is forced to find reasons and solve the problem in some different manner. It can be later described in the paper e.g. like "stuff xy was prepared using this variation of original method" or so. Important is the result, i.e. the well-defined polymer with those and those characterictics and analytical data.

As for analyses, chemists usually know well, what is necessary for proper characterization of the stuff and what can be replaced with what (which means a "non verbatim" characterization in comparison with original paper). E.g., in the case of low molar mass precursors, traditional duo "nuclear magnetic resonance - elemental analysis" can be with advantage replaced with the tandem "mass spectrometry - gas chromatography". Indeed, both such results are accepted by any qualified chemist.

There is some basic set of analytical methods which are typical/necessary for characterization of some "groups of compounds".
E.g., for soluble organic polymers, the necessity is to measure their distribution of molar masses (lengths of polymer chains) using GPC, light scattering etc.
On the other hand, there is e.g. no reason to check if prepared stuff is polymer (or some composite of prevailing polymer and incombustible fillers, like some paint) by burning it at high temperatures, since this is self-evident. Any organic polymer simply burns/is combusted at high temperatures, giving some heat, e.g. at 430 degrees C and similarly high temperatures..

For the replication of any part of any paper, the synthetic chemist must first survive, therefore he has to know the expected behavior of tens of materials and hundreds of common chemicals. Similarly, he has to have some kind of "intuition"/experience like "this product has this property (very typically, thin layer chromatography spot on the expected place), hence it is/it is not perhaps the proper one".
Here, the comparison with some other stuffs is handy, but such comparison should be accompanied with some basic knowledge/common sense. E.g., the comparison of liquid product with some other accidentally chosen and unspecified liquid is an apparent idiocy, since they are millions of various liquid chemicals known to chemists.
To give you another example, the comparison of some sample which can be paint (or something else) with some accidentally chosen (and not specified) paint(s) is the apparent idiocy as well, since they are perhaps even hundreds of thousands of various paints available with different properties. This is anyway the reason, why we do not have only one, two or three paints.
Apparently, such kind comparison used in any paper is worthless and does not need replication. What is even worse, any replication cannot be done, since materials used for comparison are unspecified. But, I have never met any such bad comparison in the per-reviewed papers on polymers.

But, back to your question. I'm an occasional reviewer and some of the papers I have reviewed were really so bad, that I was forced to refute them. As for reading per-reviewed papers, they usually show that these chemists know well what they are talking about and use only proper/relevant methods for the study. Ocassionaly, I've asked: Well, I have repeated everything 30 times without success, isn't some mistake on the side of recipe authors? And occasionally, I'm right;)

(I know well that my answer is little bit "biased" and diverted from your interest, Chris, but the temptation was too strong);)
 
Last edited:
Thanks Ivan,
Both you and Sunstealer have answered the most basic question: is there a tradition of 100% replication of every test performed to validate or invalidate the conclusion of a scientific paper? In the traditional community of chemists, no one would expect you to replicate a DSC test if your job was to ID an unknown chip.
 
1) answer directly everyone's questions and challenges (saying I don't know is OK too) and 2) be sure you quote people accurately (and add the relevant quotes or links when appropriate.

Your request would have more validity if you would request the same from the "debunker" side.
 
is there a tradition of 100% replication of every test performed to validate or invalidate the conclusion of a scientific paper?

If the purpose of your study is to replicate another study to confirm or refute the results, then yes, you do need to replicate the methodology. If you dispute the methodology to begin with, then you should probably state that. And then don't pretend you're replicating the study.

In the traditional community of chemists, no one would expect you to replicate a DSC test if your job was to ID an unknown chip.

If you're looking for energetic materials you need to do some tests of the behaviour of those materials.
 
If the purpose of your study is to replicate another study to confirm or refute the results, then yes, you do need to replicate the methodology. If you dispute the methodology to begin with, then you should probably state that. And then don't pretend you're replicating the study.

If Millette did the DSC tests and got the same results, would you then believe it was paint they found?
 
If Millette did DSC exactly the same as Harrit et al and

1. Microspheres were observed then truthers will shout, "look, look thermite!! Told you look, it's thermite!"

2. Microspheres not observed then truthers will shout, "See, see he didn't have the same chips as Harrit".

It doesn't matter what experiment you do, truthers will ignore them unless the results fit in with their delusional fantasy.

There is no way you can show them otherwise. If 10,000 scientists replicated Harrit et al to the letter and then performed every test known to man and concluded that the chips were paint, truthers still wouldn't accept the answer. That's why they are truthers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom