Jtl, although I really don't like your "diction", here are another my remarks and answers to some points.
We know very well that even very extensive study could not describe/attribute all kinds of red/gray chips to some specific materials. There is anyway no chance to find details even for some more abundantly present red primers from all WTC buildings
(except WTC1/WTC2 Tnemec and Laclede indeed.) We know very well that there will be always room for truthers to claim “you studied different chips” or so. But we are trying to convince at least some people that
Bentham chips (a) to (d), which were closely studied and declared as
nanothermite, should be
Laclede red primer for WTC floor trusses because of this and this and this. This is basically our goal.
As for MEK chip, we can hardly conclude anything: can be Tnemec
(despite the difference in the height of Zn peaks with authentic Tnemec), but the other possibilities are open. We know it, this is nothing new, but we should be more careful. The issue can be solved only with other XEDS measurements on authentic Tnemec chips
(unwashed, washed, freshly broken).
There is al signature in the molten sphere residue from the ignition tests, and this is also seen in the residue spheres from known thermite. But Harrit did not specify that they made sure this al was al oxide which is a weak point.
It just seems most likely that it is pure al because that melts below 700C while al oxide and kaolin have even higher melting points than iron at over 1800C.
Hehe

) Do you really think that since Al has lower melting point than some of its compounds, the “melting” (whatever) leading to spheres with a such complex composition
(Fe, C, O, Al, Si stuffs, – and some minute Ti) is a sign that metallic Al was originally present? You have probably heard about mixtures called alloys, eutectics etc., behavior of which is very complex and which have or can have distinctly lower melting points than components… or not?
Please, try to bear in mind the fact, which has been already reminded by Sunstealer here, perhaps even several times:
1) We can be sure that chips heated in DSC device, from which these spheres were created, were “typical” bilayered red/gray chips. Really, it does not make sense, that Harrit et al would heat some atypical chips. Do you agree?
2) Hence, these microspheres should be formed mostly from these gray layers, since
gray layers disappeared after heating. Or do you have some better idea what happened with them? And, the contamination of iron oxide spheres with Al, Si, etc. is something fully expectable, when both layers are heated together.
why is that impossible? Your buddies say his main chips(a to d in harrit paper) are laclede which means kaolin, but jones xrd rules out kaolin. Millette and jones ruled out Tnemec for those chips so al oxide from tnemec is not there. What options does that leave besides amorphous al?
I’m not sure if I understand. Jones ruled out kaolin for WHAT kind of chips? Do you know? If his chip for XRD measurements was Tnemec
(or other paint… well, material different from Laclede), no wonder that Jones did not find kaolin(ite). Options are still the same
(materials with kaolinite, and another materials without kaolinite.) No room for amorphous aluminium and other rather mystical stuffs.
You wrote “al oxide from Tnemec”, what you were talking about? There was no aluminum oxide in the Tnemec. And it is just Jones’ problem so far that he was not able to find
“any clear pattern of ANY aluminum-bearing compound in the XRD results“. He should try harder next time. Or, perhaps, this Jones' chip really did not contain any Al stuffs (or Al), who knows? Moreover, we have not seen any of those XRD data, so what? (But, perhaps I misunderstood something here).
Oh please, if you think it will save face for you keep up the act, I will let others read the paper for themselves and see if millette offers other possibilities besides red chips with kaolin.
I attempted to analyze Millette results in
this long post.
My findings were basically inconclusive, except one thing: XEDS spectra taken of freshly cut chips
(Appendix D) corresponded well to Laclede paint
(similarly to freshly cut Bentham chips (a) to (d)). But, namely spectra taken on unwashed chips looked pretty messy and also spectra taken of chips washed with water do not provide any clear picture what can be what. Apparently (to me), chips surface contamination is a very serious issue, and it seems to be an issue even for chips washed with water.
I could only judge that since polymer binder prevailed in these Millette's chips, they should be all
red paints on some
rust flakes