You guys are so lame. First you deny that Millette ruled out Tnemec and now it comes down to Millette must have made a mistake, which you blame on Harrit.
Do you at least see the mistake that Harrit made?
Millette's data doesn't rule out Tnemec.
You also ignore that you have referred directly to an actual graph of known Tnemec paint and it is obvious from that graph that is has much more Zn in it than both the Millette chips and Harrit fig14, so you this latest explanation of failed math is a dead end.
It is not obvious.
Eyeballing peak heights is not sufficient to make that determination.
Do you understand that? You can't just look at two XEDS spectra and declare that one shows more Zn than the other.
Can you explain how you would compare two XEDS spectra quantitatively? Thanks.
Millette does not refer to Harrit about the Tnemec paint, he went to the producer, so maybe the producer made mistakes?
No. The producer most assuredly did not make a mistake.
The 20% Zinc yellow value is taken from Table 1, which is taken from Reference 16, which is the same Tnemec formulation documented by NIST that Harrit's letter referred to.
Since I informed Millette of the Harrit letter, and in it the composition of Tnemec as specified in 1967 for the WTC perimeter columns, it is very well possible that Millette copied Harrit's error; or he may have made the same mistake using the same reference.
As for the reference to 177 Tnemec formulations from the producer's website: These are current formulations. Formulations produced, sold and used by Tnemec Corp. in the late 60s and early 70s may very well not be listed on today's product information!
Besides lack of Zn, millette adds:
and diatomaceous silica along with some other proprietary (Tnemec ) pigments. No diatoms were found during the analysis of the red/gray chips.
You think Millette also made a mistake here? Face the facts.
This could actually be a good point.
Almost.
However, I think a fuller quote clears this up:
Millette said:
At the time of this progress report, the identity of the product from which the red/gray chips were generated has not been determined. The composition of the red/gray chips found in this study (epoxy resin with iron oxide and kaolin pigments) does not match the formula for the primer paint used on iron column members in the World Trade Center towers (Table 1).16 Although both the red/gray chips and the primer paint contain iron oxide pigment particles, the primer is an alkyd-based resin with zinc yellow (zinc chromate) and diatomaceous silica along with some other proprietary (Tnemec ) pigments. No diatoms were found during the analysis of the red/gray chips. Some small EDS peaks of zinc and chromium were detected in some samples but the amount detected was inconsistent with the 20% level of zinc chromate in the primer formula.
It is not entirely clear, but reading in context, I think that he found no diatoms in the chips characterised by "
epoxy resin with iron oxide and kaolin pigments". In other words: Those chips that match Harrit's chips a-d. This is expected then: Chips a-d are not Tnemec, we know that; and Tnemec contains no kaolin (Al-silicate).
The context is slightly ambiguous, and it is possible that he looked for, but didn't find, diatoms in other chips as well, including those that resemble Tnemec / the MEK chip.
I could ask Millette (via Chris Mohr). Shall I?