WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

cjnewson88: I have just 3 questions I would like you to answer.

1. Oystein is wrong as explained in my post 1515.

2. Oystein is wrong, he does not offer any evidence to support his conclusions, no links to the authors admitting the extra data does not support their paper, and that they have found no more evidence. Until then his story is just that, a story.

3. You are right, a=b=c=d. As far as I know.
 
I think I speak for a lot of members and lurkers here when I state the appreciation of the very informative posts made by the likes of Sunstealer, Oystein, and Ivan. I personally think that Sunstealer is mainly responsible for thinning out the thermite crowd with his analysis of the Harrit et.al paper. Millete has basically confirmed his findings he made a few years ago, forcing most truthers to back off their position or go back to conventional explosions. As you can see, there are only few hangers-on left, desperately trying to find a way to make thermite work.

My question is since this is the preliminary report, is there anything possible that Truthers could legitimately hang their hat on in the final report? Or does the preliminary report completely rule out thermite? Are they stuck with the false hopes of the lame DSC argument?*

*ETA: These questions are actually being asked by a cousin acquaintance of mine, Lennay. Here she is in this video. She's the one on the right...or left...you decide:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qQTqKcojrVY :D
​
 
Last edited:
"…I think, personally, after having talked to him on the phone, that Basile is an honest man, and somewhat open towards admitting that the stuff really isn't thermite after all. But he has stopped communication with me, and I don't know why. So I hesitate..."

I quite believe that Mark Basile is an honest and sincere man and that he is quite willing to admit he is wrong if shown to be wrong.

But if you wish to imply that you and he were so chummy on the phone that he confided doubts about the red chips being thermitic, I suggest you provide some proof.

MM
 
I quite believe that Mark Basile is an honest and sincere man and that he is quite willing to admit he is wrong if shown to be wrong.

But if you wish to imply that you and he were so chummy on the phone that he confided doubts about the red chips being thermitic, I suggest you provide some proof.

MM
Mark thinks corrosion is due to thermite. Rules him out as a rational person. He thinks steel exposed to 1,000 C and less, were ravaged by thermite. It is pathetic nonsense. Mark has nothing.
 
Millette repeats (perhaps copies) the mistake Harrit made about the composition of Tnemec:
http://ae911truth.org/downloads/documents/primer_paint_Niels_Harrit.pdf

In that letter, Figure 3, Harrit quotes the Tnemec formula found in the NIST report. It states: "Zinc yellow 20.3%"
These 20% do NOT actually refer to the paint but to the total pigment! All pigments add up to 100%, all vehicle ingredients likewise add up to 100%.
But you mix vehicle and pigments in a certain proportion. In the case of LaClede paint that proportion is 71.5% : 28.5% organics (non-volatile!) : pigment. Assuming that Tnemec would have a similar proportion, the actual Zinc Yellow (ZnCrO4) content of the dry paint would be 20.3% * 28.5% = 5.8%. Of this, Zn makes up 36% by weight, Cr 29% and O the balance. In the paint, Zn would be thus expected to be 2.1% and Cr 1.7% of the mass.

2.1% Zn is actually nicely compatible with the Zn-signal in Fig. 14!
Cr is a bit too low, but quantification of XEDS spectra is an imprecise thing anyway, so we are at least in the right ball park.
Remember why the zinc chromate is included in the paint formulation. It's for corrosion protection. The mechanism by which it does this is the zinc chromate will slightly dissolve due to moist air penetrating the paint. The dissolved zinc chromate will then react with the steel's surface to form a passive layer (of zinc) which protects the steel. Over time the zinc chromate is removed from the paint via this degradation and can lead to problems of corrosion. I would imagine that there is a concentration gradient for zinc across the paint thickness due to this process, I'll have to see if that's the case.

I suspect that the same is true of zinc phosphate.
 
Last edited:
You guys are so lame. First you deny that Millette ruled out Tnemec and now it comes down to Millette must have made a mistake, which you blame on Harrit.
Do you at least see the mistake that Harrit made?

Millette's data doesn't rule out Tnemec.

You also ignore that you have referred directly to an actual graph of known Tnemec paint and it is obvious from that graph that is has much more Zn in it than both the Millette chips and Harrit fig14, so you this latest explanation of failed math is a dead end.
It is not obvious.
Eyeballing peak heights is not sufficient to make that determination.

Do you understand that? You can't just look at two XEDS spectra and declare that one shows more Zn than the other.

Can you explain how you would compare two XEDS spectra quantitatively? Thanks.

Millette does not refer to Harrit about the Tnemec paint, he went to the producer, so maybe the producer made mistakes?
No. The producer most assuredly did not make a mistake.

The 20% Zinc yellow value is taken from Table 1, which is taken from Reference 16, which is the same Tnemec formulation documented by NIST that Harrit's letter referred to.

Since I informed Millette of the Harrit letter, and in it the composition of Tnemec as specified in 1967 for the WTC perimeter columns, it is very well possible that Millette copied Harrit's error; or he may have made the same mistake using the same reference.

As for the reference to 177 Tnemec formulations from the producer's website: These are current formulations. Formulations produced, sold and used by Tnemec Corp. in the late 60s and early 70s may very well not be listed on today's product information!

Besides lack of Zn, millette adds:
and diatomaceous silica along with some other proprietary (Tnemec ) pigments. No diatoms were found during the analysis of the red/gray chips.

You think Millette also made a mistake here? Face the facts.
This could actually be a good point.
Almost.
However, I think a fuller quote clears this up:
Millette said:
At the time of this progress report, the identity of the product from which the red/gray chips were generated has not been determined. The composition of the red/gray chips found in this study (epoxy resin with iron oxide and kaolin pigments) does not match the formula for the primer paint used on iron column members in the World Trade Center towers (Table 1).16 Although both the red/gray chips and the primer paint contain iron oxide pigment particles, the primer is an alkyd-based resin with zinc yellow (zinc chromate) and diatomaceous silica along with some other proprietary (Tnemec ) pigments. No diatoms were found during the analysis of the red/gray chips. Some small EDS peaks of zinc and chromium were detected in some samples but the amount detected was inconsistent with the 20% level of zinc chromate in the primer formula.
It is not entirely clear, but reading in context, I think that he found no diatoms in the chips characterised by "epoxy resin with iron oxide and kaolin pigments". In other words: Those chips that match Harrit's chips a-d. This is expected then: Chips a-d are not Tnemec, we know that; and Tnemec contains no kaolin (Al-silicate).
The context is slightly ambiguous, and it is possible that he looked for, but didn't find, diatoms in other chips as well, including those that resemble Tnemec / the MEK chip.

I could ask Millette (via Chris Mohr). Shall I?
 
Must be, unless there are also other new papers on the way?
Jones spoke in September about an unnamed scientist, a geologist, who wants to study chips. He said he would blog more about this, but I haven't seen any details since.

I found a recent interview with Basile on a radio show that I will listen to, and check how it compares to your story. With your meltdowns in mind and some of your posts here I do wonder a bit if he did not get fed up with you, and that you are bending the truth a bit?
This:
http://www.911freefall.com/2012/12/mark-basile-and-wtc-dust.html

I have a good portion (maybe half) of the actual interview already transcribed. I could dump a PDF, if you like?
 
1. Oystein is wrong as explained in my post 1515.
You didn't even start to address my argument in post 1515

2. Oystein is wrong, he does not offer any evidence to support his conclusions, no links to the authors admitting the extra data does not support their paper, and that they have found no more evidence. Until then his story is just that, a story.
I think you hadn't yet seen my links and quotes that show that Farrer and Jones admit to finding nothing to prove thermite with XRD and TEM.

3. You are right, a=b=c=d. As far as I know.
cjnewson asked you to explain your answer. Why do you think that a=b=c=d?
 
Oystein: Without evidence for elemental Al, you haven't proven thermite.
TEM and XRD can provide evidence for elemental Al.
They just didn't.
As Farrer and Jones publicly admitted.

Oystein you have a tendency to misrepresent what people say. I will have to go over those 911blogger arguments later as there is a lot of material, but I quickly note a couple of things. Jones actually says new tests rule out al bearing compounds so no kaolin, no laclede. There does not seem to be any ruling out of aluminum.

Jones: Do debunkers ever do experiments? I say, do the experiment and let us know what you find! Experiments are much more convincing in science than hand-waving arguments.

Having tried to talk to you and Sunstealer, it is not hard to imagine that the arguments you presented may have been a bit less convincing than you think. It is easy to agree with Jones on hand-waving arguments, as you and sunstealer are prone to that.
 
Last edited:
...
My question is since this is the preliminary report, is there anything possible that Truthers could legitimately hang their hat on in the final report? Or does the preliminary report completely rule out thermite? Are they stuck with the false hopes of the lame DSC argument?*
...

We haven't seen the final report yet, and I don't know yet what Millette will have done above and beyond the prelim report. And my crystal ball is jammed. So no, I don't know how much hope it will leave truthers to hang on to.

One fundamental problem is that there are several different kinds of red-gray chip - no one knows how many - which always leaves the possibility for truthers to claim Millette didn't look at the "right" chips. He'd have to tally all the different kinds, and go into great detail with them, to close most of that door.

And also he will hardly be able to definitely ID each kind of chip as this or that particular paint (or whatever else some chips may be). We haven't found any LaClede samples yet for comparison, for example.
 
Jones: Do debunkers ever do experiments? I say, do the experiment and let us know what you find! Experiments are much more convincing in science than hand-waving arguments.

It would be good to see some of jone's experiments since the Bentham paper.

Perhaps jtl can link me to some ?
 
Remember why the zinc chromate is included in the paint formulation. It's for corrosion protection. The mechanism by which it does this is the zinc chromate will slightly dissolve due to moist air penetrating the paint. The dissolved zinc chromate will then react with the steel's surface to form a passive layer (of zinc) which protects the steel. Over time the zinc chromate is removed from the paint via this degradation and can lead to problems of corrosion. I would imagine that there is a concentration gradient for zinc across the paint thickness due to this process, I'll have to see if that's the case.
Where would the chrome go in the process?

I suspect that the same is true of zinc phosphate.
Why phosphate? :confused:
 
Oystein you have a tendency to misrepresent what people say. I will have to go over those 911blogger arguments later as there is a lot of material, but I quickly note a couple of things. Jones actually says new tests rule out al bearing compounds so no kaolin, no laclede. There does not seem to be any ruling out of aluminum.
No, he doesn't say that.
Or actually, he at first did say it:
Jones: "We found that the Al and Si are in fact NOT in equal amounts; the Al:Si ratio came out to approximately 0.92 (based on atomic wt %, TEM focused on a platelet.) How could this be the mineral kaolinite as you suggest, for which the Al:Si ratio is exactly 1.0? Formula: Al2Si2O5(OH)4 "
But then he had correct himself, after Farrer told him he was wrong:
Jones, paraphrasing Farrer: "With regard to the 0.92 ratio, Jeff notes that he did not use standards for the TEM/XEDS analysis so this ratio could be consistent with unity."

Having tried to talk to you and Sunstealer, it is not hard to imagine that the arguments you presented may have been a bit less convincing than you think. It is easy to agree with Jones on hand-waving arguments, as you and sunstealer are prone to that.
Blablabla.
You are out of your depth, and it shows.
 
Originally Posted by jtl:
Having tried to talk to you and Sunstealer, it is not hard to imagine that the arguments you presented may have been a bit less convincing than you think. It is easy to agree with Jones on hand-waving arguments, as you and sunstealer are prone to that. Oystein: Blablabla.You are out of your depth, and it shows.


Oystein: No, he doesn't say that.
Or actually, he at first did say it:
Jones: "We found that the Al and Si are in fact NOT in equal amounts; the Al:Si ratio came out to approximately 0.92 (based on atomic wt %, TEM focused on a platelet.) How could this be the mineral kaolinite as you suggest, for which the Al:Si ratio is exactly 1.0? Formula: Al2Si2O5(OH)4 "
But then he had correct himself, after Farrer told him he was wrong:
Jones, paraphrasing Farrer: "With regard to the 0.92 ratio, Jeff notes that he did not use standards for the TEM/XEDS analysis so this ratio could be consistent with unity."

Once again you resort to hand waving argument, suddenly the XRD disappears and you talk like there is only TEM but the following quote which you posted here clearly had the XRD. The TEM may be inconclusive about no kaolin but the XRD is not:
Jones: "I will say that after our paper was published, we went to another lab trying to get XRD patterns that would definitively resolve the question of whether elemental aluminum was present. But like Dr Farrer's TEM results, there was no clear pattern of ANY aluminum-bearing compound in the XRD results. These results have surprised me, not satisfied me. So we go to further experiments."

Maybe you should keep up the bla bla bla and go back to ranting about jelly.
Don´t have another meltdown, but you should realize that if you try to go outside this JREF forum with this kind of endless hand waving people will notice even though your buddies here don´t. Just note that you cant play mr.surprised when actual scientists like jones and basile give up on talking to you.

It is not entirely clear, but reading in context, I think that he found no diatoms in the chips characterised by "epoxy resin with iron oxide and kaolin pigments".

No it is quite clear, millette says the chips in his study do not match tnemec. Stop your hand waving non sense.
 
Last edited:
I have not infracted anyone in this thread, because I would have had to infract everyone. From this post forward, however, any bickering or incivility will be considered disregarding a moderator directive and will be dealt with harshly. DO NOT personalize your arguments, and remain civil and polite. Thank you for your anticipated cooperation.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jhunter1163
 
Once again you resort to hand waving argument, suddenly the XRD disappears and you talk like there is only TEM but the following quote which you posted here clearly had the XRD. The TEM may be inconclusive about no kaolin but the XRD is not:
XRD is capable of detecting elemental Al.
What Jones writes includes elemental Al: He did not find any proof for it.

Maybe you should keep up the bla bla bla and go back to ranting about jelly.
Don´t have another meltdown, but you should realize that if you try to go outside this JREF forum with this kind of endless hand waving people will notice even though your buddies here don´t. Just note that you cant play mr.surprised when actual scientists like jones and basile give up on talking to you.
You place too much trust in authorities.

No it is quite clear, millette says the chips in his study do not match tnemec. Stop your hand waving non sense.
Quite clear? Yes. The opposite of what you imply. See, Millette didn't write just "the chips in this study" - he wrote, as I quoted fully: "red/gray chips found in this study (epoxy resin with iron oxide and kaolin pigments)"
Why did you quote only half that phrase? Inconvenient fact contained inside the parentheses?

Bye bye.
 
Last edited:
... It is easy to agree with Jones on hand-waving arguments, as you and sunstealer are prone to that.

Jones?

Jones first letter of having delusions about 911, Sept 2005, Jones had an idiotic episode and declared, thermite. Then his fellow paranoid conspiracy theorists, faked a paper. Or did someone tease them with fake dust? That would be funny.

Jones first indications we was nuts on 911...
5. I conducted simple experiments on the "pancaking" theory, by dropping cement blocks from approximately 12 feet onto other cement blocks. (The floors in the WTC buildings were about 12 feet apart.) We are supposed to believe, from the pancaking theory, that a concrete floor dropping 12 feet onto another concrete floor will result in PULVERIZED concrete observed during the Towers' collapses! Nonsense! My own experiments, and I welcome you to try this yourself, is that only chips/large chunks of cement flaked off the blocks -- no mass pulverization to approx. 100-micron powder as observed. Explosives, however, can indeed convert concrete to dust --mostly, along with some large chunks-- as observed in the destruction of the Twin Towers on 9-11-01.


12 feet are to 1300 feet as insanity is to reality. Wave hands, make up thermite. Jones.

Jones...
6. The observations of molten metal (I did not say molten steel!) in the basements of all three buildings, WTC 1, 2 and 7 is consistent with the use of the extremely high-temperature thermite reaction: iron oxide + aluminum powder --> Al2O3 + molten iron. Falling buildings are not observed to generate melting of large quantities of molten metal -- this requires a concentrated heat source such as explosives. Even the government reports admit that the fires were insufficient to melt steel beams (they argue for heating and warping then failure of these beams) -- but these reports do not mention the observed molten metal in the basements of WTC1, 2 and 7. Again we have a glaring omission of critical data in the FEMA, NIST and 9-11 Commission reports.
No melted steel, but molten metal means? FIRE, Dr Jones, not thermite, not the nonsense you have.

Jones wins the hand-waving nonsense, as he declares thermite with no evidence. 2005... 9.16.05 The reason Jones was fired.

I love the experiment with the cement block - he essentially ignores E=mgh released and jumps to woo - super hand-waving winner... Jones, and you now with no clue what DSC is for.

It is easy to see why Millette's paper found not thermite in WTC dust. No thermite was used on 911 except in a few failed minds, like Jones.

Not sure how Jones goes from thermite, to full blown nuts.
Jones says...
Essentially none of these science-based considerations is mentioned in the Popular Mechanics article on this subject, authored by B. Chertoff (a cousin of M. Chertoff who heads the Homeland Security Dept.) (Squibs are mentioned briefly, but the brief PM analysis does not fit the observed facts.)
Paranoid, Jones makes up thermite, then the make up a fake paper. Why? You can't make up this stuff. Why put nonsense in his letter?

Why can't Gage fund a study with his over a million dollars take from nuts who believe in thermite anyway? Because his believers don't care.

If 911 truth funded a study years ago, there would be no reason for 911 truth to exist. But then we have JFK, Bigfoot, and UFO, oh my.
How to improve Millette's study? Understand there was no thermite used on 911. No thermite products found fused to steel, no thermite product found.
 
Last edited:
.

Does Jones address and answer the challenges in his next, and final, response? Nooooo!
He entirely dodges all questions, all challenges!
Instead, argues ad homininem, incessantly!
Some examples:
"this anonymous Oystein fellow"
"Does payment motivate your efforts to defend the “official story” of 9/11?"

Conspiracists typically stoop to accusing the other side of being paid agents for the Vast Conspiracy. Seriously, that thread is a summum malum of pseudoscience! The ghost of William of Ockham let out a wail that shook my windows when Prof. Jones tried to account for the lack of elemental Al showing up in XRD by pulling "amorphous aluminum alloys" out of his nether regions! :boggled:

The thread even includes a post by a Holocaust Denier. Ominous that he got more votes than the fellow who argued that they shouldn't let their site be contaminated by such sorts.
 
Question: The al in the residue spheres kind of has to be pure al? Al oxide and kaolin have very high melting temps while al melts below 700. How can we get al from kaolin of al oxide from laclede or tnemec in those dsc tests?

Bless your heart, laddie, but nobody, not even Harrit or Jones, is claiming that elemental aluminum is in the residue. Real thermite contains aluminum, and its biggest reaction product (by volume) is aluminum oxide. Jones and Harrit have yet to account for its absence from WTC dust, if they wish to make a thermite claim.

Aluminum silicate is a common ingredient in paint, and it is readily identifiable in the electron microscope photos of the chips. It's the thin platelets. It's quite stable chemically, but it may change crystal structure from heating.
 
Redwood: No, laddie, the yield for ferric oxide thermite is fixed by the immutable Laws of Thermodynamics, and there is nothing that anyone can do to raise it.

You mean nothing besides adding extra chemicals to it like the organic matrix. This can also make nonexplosive thermite explosive.

No. Putting thermite into an organic matrix will not increase the energy yield of the thermite. The combustion of the organic matrix, in air, will dwarf the energy yield from the thermite. (That's what makes Jones' & Harrit's DSC tests extra-ridiculous. They did them in air.) But most of that energy will be carried away as hot CO2. If a very stupid person ever tried to use an organic matrix thermite to melt the steel columns in a building that was on fire like the WTCs, the energy generated by burning the matrix, compared to the energy of the building fires, would be like a grain of salt tossed into the ocean. Far better to simply pack ordinary, 1890s-type thermite about the columns in a melt-proof container.

This was actually done in 1937 in the demolition of one tower of the Chicago Exposition's "Century of Progress" skyride , but it required at least 700 kg. to bring down two legs of the tower, and the cupolas that held the thermite were enormous. Good luck on building anything such in the WTCs without anyone noticing!

As to the explosive potential of the conversion of the solid matrix to gas by heating: I watched Kevin Ryan's backyard-brewed thermite, and it had less explosive quality than a kielbasa I once heated in a microwave without poking vent holes with a fork.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom