WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

Perhaps we could expect to see something like this ?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dShGYuU_Wks&feature=youtube

I assume this clip is not fake and as Jtl would say it has other stuff in it.

Read the description with the clip

This mix contains sodium nitrate (NaNO3) - which can be used in gunpowder instead of potassium nitrate. Both nitrates react in gunpowder with carbon by oxidizing the carbon and producing nitrogen gas as a result. I suppose it can react in a similar fashion with some metals, perhaps including iron. No doubt in this video, the explosion (volume work) is in large part due to the sodium nitrate reacting and releasing nitrogen, because otherwise, no gas would be produced there (Cu-oxide + Fe or Ce should result in Cu + Fe/Ce-oxides, which would at most be liquid).
Gunpowder is a low explosive. It can damage things by applying pressure, but can't create a shockwave that would break steel.

So basically you are there looking at something else.

Nano-truthers like Harrit or jtl make themselves believe that the little bit of thermite in the lot of organic matrix would be capable of turning the polymers to gas instantaneously. This expectation is deluded, on several counts:
- The low energy content of the low thermite content is too low compared to the heat capacity and enthalpy of gasification of said polymer
- The process would be greatly slowed by the kinetics of heat transfer between the thermite constituents and the matrix, and render the "explosion", if there is any, too slow and weak to do much damage
 
Last edited:
Thanx, Spanx, for the videos.

I messaged Myles, but will copy my text to another thread, as it really goes off-topic here.
 
Kminek: Try bear in mind that we are "scanning" all truthers' web and other truthers' stuff regularly, so we probably know (almost) everything they published/they think about red/gray chips. By no means we are avoiding to look at these sources!

You say you all don´t avoid those sources but you certainly avoid letting me know about them, even after I specifically asked for them. This just happened with basile and it happened before with Harrit´s essay about Tnemec vs red chips.

You are being very passive about something totally unacceptable. You all basically say that it is a given that the spheres come from the gray layer but you have not done any experiments and you have no actual data. You also somehow forget to mention that a scientist has done experiments and that basile basically rules out the gray layer theory because he has observed that the spheres come from the red layer.

You think you can keep ignoring this without backing up your claims with actual research?

Lets not forget that your buddy Oystein also indicated that basile has admitted that the red chips are not superthermite when actually he seems really sure they are. This is called dishonesty, and nobody says nothing, including you.

This sort of claiming "black is white" happened before when your buddies claimed Millette identifies tnemed when he actually specifically rules it out.

This behavior seems rampant with your buddies here, hiding behind their fake names, and I am fed up with it. Their answer to everything seems to be declaring themselves experts and calling the actual scientists that have done the research and the papers incompetent fools and other names like that.

They seem to think it makes them look cool, but you Kminek should know better and not tolerate this kind of garbage.
 
Lets not forget that your buddy Oystein also indicated that basile has admitted that the red chips are not superthermite when actually he seems really sure they are. This is called dishonesty, and nobody says nothing, including you.
There's a reason why nobody says nothing: You're the only one interpreting Oystein's words that way.

I didn't see him say that Basile admitted the chips are not superthermite.

But maybe I missed the post where he did. Can you repost it, please?
 
...
What is called superthermite ... It can be rocket fuel. ...
I have made "rockets with matches", which might beat your super thermite rocket. Does 911 truth do chemistry? no

Chemistry, and 911 truth. They don't mix. Thermite does not have enough energy to be used as practical rocket fuel; toys, yes, to orbit, maybe not.

What is the energy released per kg of your super thermite? Real rocket fuel has a much greater energy density. Do you know anything about chemistry?

Where did you go?

Question:
Do you understand thermite was not used on 911, including super-thermite?
 
Redwood: You're out of your league.

Wow you guys like to pose as big shots. So impressive.:)

You really should have addressed the rest of my post, which is:

...you seem to be confused about fundamental concepts of physics and chemistry. You really should take my suggestion and enroll in courses in basic physics and chemistry at your local community college before commenting here.

And, even if you never use it professionally, it's good for the soul. :)
 
Yes, this is so obvious that it is beyond me why anyone would stick to those arguments. The nanoscale makes energy release faster but that is only the beginning.

What is called superthermite can be a mixture that is only partially feo-al thermite, and also other stuff not normally found in thermite. The result will obviously not perform like std thermite. Straight hermite does not release gas pressure and is not explosive but superthermite can because it can be mixed with organic components. It can be rocket fuel. Saying that stuff is not a type of thermite because it releases so much pressure would be equally dumb as the 3.9 argument.

Thanks for this.
 
Thanks for this.

After 41 pages of debate I will, for what it's worth, gladly stipulate that the red chips are thermite. Any kind you like. Thermite in the dust.

Now...

would you kindly explain why it matters? Planes crashing into the buildings at over 500 mph thereby causing catastrophic damage to the structure and igniting fires that burned long and hot enough to soften the structural steel which predictably gave way much sooner under a much greater amount of weight (i.e. 2 hit second fell first) and let the upper floors begin falling* onto the structure below, initiating a collapse that, once started, could do nothing but proceed to the ground is...is a hell of a run-on sentence. It's also the common narrative because it squares with everything that was seen--and was not heard.

So again, even if all that red stuff is thermite, so what? Kindly explain what role thermite played in the collapse, oh, I'm sorry!, the destruction of the towers. Where does my narrative fall short and at what point does thermite come in to explain it any better.


*you clearly have no concept of this in terms of scale, but that's largely because you refuse to have one.
 
You say you all don´t avoid those sources but you certainly avoid letting me know about them, even after I specifically asked for them. This just happened with basile and it happened before with Harrit´s essay about Tnemec vs red chips.

You are being very passive about something totally unacceptable. You all basically say that it is a given that the spheres come from the gray layer but you have not done any experiments and you have no actual data. You also somehow forget to mention that a scientist has done experiments and that basile basically rules out the gray layer theory because he has observed that the spheres come from the red layer.

You think you can keep ignoring this without backing up your claims with actual research?

Lets not forget that your buddy Oystein also indicated that basile has admitted that the red chips are not superthermite when actually he seems really sure they are. This is called dishonesty, and nobody says nothing, including you.

This sort of claiming "black is white" happened before when your buddies claimed Millette identifies tnemed when he actually specifically rules it out.

This behavior seems rampant with your buddies here, hiding behind their fake names, and I am fed up with it. Their answer to everything seems to be declaring themselves experts and calling the actual scientists that have done the research and the papers incompetent fools and other names like that.

They seem to think it makes them look cool, but you Kminek should know better and not tolerate this kind of garbage.

Jtl: As for truthers' sources, I don't understand and I'm lazy to look back through this thread. What's your point?

As for what layer could be the "source" of microspheres:
We are internet forum, not scientific commitee or so. I'm just trying to analyze available data, playing with them, having some rather strange fun with all this stuff, and learning some new things in material science, which is indeed good for my own carrier of polymer chemist.
And here, I just gave you two examples of data indicating that spheres should be created from gray layers (Bentham heated chips and "partially" reacted chips).
In the case of Basile's chip I can be wrong (there should be anyway several/many kinds of chips in the dust) and (as Oystein noted) it is even possible (but not very probable) that microspheres have several different origins or so.

On the other hand, I have a full right to have my own view and not to believe Basile;) Why should I believe this guy, who showed us only some messy micrographs and one unconvincing XEDS as alleged proofs of "iron film" formation from the red layer? Why should I blindly believe the guy who is able to claim that stuff containing some 3.5 % of iron oxide and 1.6 % of Al (according to his own XEDS spectra!) is thermite??? And why should I believe the guy who thinks (similarly to Bentham team;)) that a heating the chip with prevailing polymer binder under air is a good way how to prove thermite?

As for your bolded part, here is a quote from Oystein's post 1331 (bolding is mine;):

"Mark Basile, in his recent radio interview with Bernie Suarez, says that "the vast majority of them actually are primer paint, from what I'm finding". "Them" meaning "red chip you're gonna pull out of there" (WTC dust). (Note to MM: See the quotation marks? Yes, these are actual and verbatim quotes from Basile. Find them in my blog, along with a precise source reference.)"

Therefore, I consider your bolded part as not correct (at least). It follows from these sentences that Basile considers now most of the chips as paints, but he still believes that others are thermite.

As for our names and nicks: I'm using my full name here, contrary to you;) And I'm not an administrator, neither I'm responsible for the posts of other posters. But they (I mean debunkers) are basically my fellows or even distant friends (joined by the common idea that "auxiliary" demolition of WTC is just an utter, childish nonsense for countless reasons), so I have always some excuse for them;)
 
Last edited:
Ergo, if you do a google search for nano thermite, you can find out what all that other stuff is. ;)

You won't find that other stuff in Harrits paper :D
Truthers just don't do research. It's interesting to see how they come up with all these exotic materials yet don't realise that there is no evidence for them in Harrit et al. A nano-thermite simply refers to a thermite that has particles with sizes under 100nm. What jtl is actually talking about is a nano-thermite composite. Seeing the quote it's interesting to note that he says superthermite can contain other metals and other metal oxides. but fails to realise that Harrit et al only claim that Fe2O3 and Al are present. It's exactly the same reasoning that other truthers use to claim that Harrit et al found themite (zero Barium and Sulphur), but the thinning of steel beams is proof of thermate (inclusion of Sulphur). Similarly here we have the idea that the epoxy in the paint is somehow engineered to produce gas (which then has to do work) then the "thermite" is ignited. You can plainly see that this is not the case in Basile's heated element experiment.

Millette actually did the work to determine exactly what the carbon matrix material in his samples is. Harrit et al don't. They have no idea what it is. Failing to characterise a major part of the material you are looking at, even when you've performed the perfect experiment (FTIR) to determine the material, but leave that information out of the paper is a huge cock-up. This is a major failing in the paper and would not pass peer review on that single factor alone because the entire point of the paper is a materials characterisation exercise (what is this material?). It's interesting to note that Jones carps on about debunkers needing to do experiments, but fails on two accounts:

1. The experiments he is involved in do not determine what the carbon matrix actually is even though that is the purpose of the exercise.
2. When a debunker pays an independent scientist to actually perform experiments he simply dismisses the results and attacks the person who carried them out.
 
Last edited:
...
1. The experiments he is involved in do not determine what the carbon matrix actually is even though that is the purpose of the exercise.
2. When a debunker pays an independent scientist to actually perform experiments he simply dismisses the results and attacks the person who carried them out.

It's even worse than that: They not only failed to figure out what the dominant substance in the red layer is, they also failed to figure out what the gray layer really is. They kinda realize it's iron oxide, yeah, but it's not just iron oxide, and iron oxide isn't always the same.

They selected particles from the dust with the following properties:

A They are attracted to a magnet
B They are chips (very thin, planar)
C They have a red layer...
D ...and a gray layer that...
E ...are attached to each other

One would expect them to be able to answer after the analysis

A why these particles are attracted to a magnet
B why they are chips
C why one layer is red
D why the other layer is gray
E why the layers are attached to each other

Their hypothesis answers none of these quesions (it hints at B, D and E, but only in speculation, not as a matter of facts they actually found out and realized)

Our theory, paint on spalled steel, answers them all:

A because steel mill contains a good deal of magnetite
B because structural steel has mostly planar surfaces, the top oxide layer tends to spall off as chips, an paint is a film thin
C Because the red layer contains red hematite pigments
D Because the gray layer is a typical mix of various iron oxide phases, including magnetite, hematite, wuestite, that is known to tend to appear gray
E Because the epoxy-based paint is designed and known to adhere to steel
 
Last edited:
"It's even worse than that: They not only failed to figure out what the dominant substance in the red layer is, they also failed to figure out what the gray layer really is. They kinda realize it's iron oxide, yeah, but it's not just iron oxide, and iron oxide isn't always the same.

They selected particles from the dust with the following properties:

A They are attracted to a magnet
B They are chips (very thin, planar)
C They have a red layer...
D ...and a gray layer that...
E ...are attached to each other
"

It is always interesting what you choose to leave out.

Or have you forgotten the test that helped them to identify the chips of interest, and made it easy to eliminate the many paint chips?

As you know from your 9/11Blogger exchange with Dr. Jones last September, 2012, that part of the chip isolation process involved Resistivity testing.

Dr. Jones said:
"Also, we checked the electrical resistivity of several paints – consistently orders of magnitude higher than that of the red material. We reported the resistivity of the red material in our paper, page 27 in the Journal. Millette did not report any electrical resistivity measurements. This measurement is rather easy to do so I was surprised when he failed to do this straightforward test. There is a lot of red material of various types in the WTC dust, so one must be careful to make sure it is the same as what we studied, and not some other material."

Harrit et al said:
"Given the small size of the red chip, about 0.5 mm x 0.5 mm, we used two probes and obtained a rough value of approximately 10 ohm-m. This is several orders of magnitude less than paint coatings we found tabulated which are typically over 100,000,000,000 ohm-m [31]."

MM
 
As the organizer of the Jim Millette study and a person with less scientific knowledge than most posters here, a few thoughts:

1) Oystein's recent post summarizing (with links) the "debunkers'" responses to the Bentham paper, the Basile tests, etc. has been forwarded to Jim Millette

2) I have sent Millette several emails full of feedback from the 9/11 Truth side as well. Millette is not going to slog through all the posts on every internet blog, but when I find something that seems particularly important I pass it along. Over the past year he has received from me Kevin Ryan's accusations of him being a fraud, objections to him not doing the DSC test, questions about the iron-rich microspheres, and more, which I want to be sure he is aware of.

3.) Jim still wants to complete the study and I am hopeful that will happen some time this year.

We've been warned by the JREF administrators not to get too nasty with each other. JTL, while I value your input, it's important to me that you 1) answer directly everyone's questions and challenges (saying I don't know is OK too) and 2) be sure you quote people accurately (and add the relevant quotes or links when appropriate. "Debunkers," it's important to me that you try as much as possible to stick to the facts and try to resist telling JTL he is an idiot or whatever. Calling him on his inaccuracies or failure to respond to your challenges seems like fair game. But when all is said and done, if there is room for improvement in the ongoing Millette study, I want to tell Jim about it. If there is scientific validity to their complaints, that needs to be openly stated (and perhaps corrected in the final paper).

One example: many 9/11 Truth people have told me that Millette should have exactly duplicated the protocol set out by Jones et al in the Bentham paper. Clearly he chose not to do a DSC test (because he considered it useless, not because DSC equipment wasn't in his lab, BTW). Originally, I came to him with a question: can you find samples of the same kind of red-grey chips the Jones et al folks claimed were thermitic and determine if these chips have thermitic materials in them? I did NOT hire him to replicate every element of the Bentham study.

So here is my question and anyone on either side is welcome to answer: when a scientific paper is beinmg published to test the findings of a prior study, is it expected that every aspect of the original protocol be followed to the letter, even if parts of the original study are believed to have been poorly carried out? Or is it more standard to ask the same question and then replicate only the relevant parts, and also filling in the missing parts of the original study (which is what Millette did)?

I don't want just the standard debunker answer, I'd like to know what the tradition is in scientific circles when publishing a paper that follows up on a prior published work.
 
It is always interesting what you choose to leave out.

Or have you forgotten the test that helped them to identify the chips of interest, and made it easy to eliminate the many paint chips?

As you know from your 9/11Blogger exchange with Dr. Jones last September, 2012, that part of the chip isolation process involved Resistivity testing.

Dr. Jones said:
"Also, we checked the electrical resistivity of several paints – consistently orders of magnitude higher than that of the red material. We reported the resistivity of the red material in our paper, page 27 in the Journal. Millette did not report any electrical resistivity measurements. This measurement is rather easy to do so I was surprised when he failed to do this straightforward test. There is a lot of red material of various types in the WTC dust, so one must be careful to make sure it is the same as what we studied, and not some other material."

Harrit et al said:
"Given the small size of the red chip, about 0.5 mm x 0.5 mm, we used two probes and obtained a rough value of approximately 10 ohm-m. This is several orders of magnitude less than paint coatings we found tabulated which are typically over 100,000,000,000 ohm-m [31]."

MM

The test that helped them to identify the chips of interest, eh, MM? :D
Gosh, you're setting yourself up for yet another whooping! :D

So tell, me, MM, which "chips of interest" did they in fact "identify" with those electrical resistivity measurements?
  1. Did they identify chip a with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  2. Did they identify chip b with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  3. Did they identify chip c with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  4. Did they identify chip d with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  5. Did they identify the MEK-soaked chip with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  6. Did they identify the first chip they tested in the DSC (Fig. 19, MacKinlay 1, blue line) with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  7. Did they identify the second chip they tested in the DSC (Fig. 19, MacKinlay 2, red line) with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  8. Did they identify the third chip they tested in the DSC (Fig. 19, Intermont, black line) with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  9. Did they identify the fourth chip they tested in the DSC (Fig. 19, White, green line) with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  10. Did they identify the multilayered chip (Fig. 31) with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  11. Did they identify the chip with the carbon layer (Fig. 32+33) with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
MM, that's 11 separate "chips of interest", 11 separate questions, I expect 11 separate answers. And I expect you to answer all 11 of them with "I don't know".

So much ignorance, MM!

But here is an easy one for you:

On how many chips did they do any electrical resistivity measurements? Here, I'll give you a clue:
Harrit et al said:
"Given the small size of the red chip, about 0.5 mm x 0.5 mm, we used two probes and obtained a rough value of approximately 10 ohm-m. This is several orders of magnitude less than paint coatings we found tabulated which are typically over 100,000,000,000 ohm-m [31]."
I'll give you another clue:

They thusly tested 2 (two) chips!

So then, of the above-mentioned 11 chips, how many did they NOT select via electrical resistivity measurements?

Here is a clue for you:

11-9 = ???




So final question, MM:


Is "electrical resistivity measurements" the test that helped them to identify the chips of interest, and made it easy to eliminate the many paint chips, MM? Yes, or no?


Here is a final clue for you:


No!



Gosh, that was fun :D
 
Given the small size of the red chip, about 0.5 mm x 0.5
mm, we used two probes and obtained a rough value of approximately 10 ohm-m. This is several orders of magnitude
less than paint coatings we found tabulated which are typically over 10
10
ohm-m [31].

They thusly tested 2 (two) chips!

Oystein,

Isn't the "two probes" referring to the two leads from the multimeter that they touched to the chip?

Also, according to the article, they only tested one chip, hence the "Given the small size of the chip" statement, "the chip" being singular.
 
MM did quote Steven Jones and Jones's claim that they did more to separate out the chips than Millette did. Thank for bringing it to my attention MM. Perhaps a summary of Jones's objections to Millette's study would be a good thing for me to have and pass on to Millette, if only as an FYI.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom