WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

Yes, this is so obvious that it is beyond me why anyone would stick to those arguments. The nanoscale makes energy release faster but that is only the beginning.

What is called superthermite can be a mixture that is only partially feo-al thermite, and also other stuff not normally found in thermite. The result will obviously not perform like std thermite. Straight hermite does not release gas pressure and is not explosive but superthermite can because it can be mixed with organic components. It can be rocket fuel. Saying that stuff is not a type of thermite because it releases so much pressure would be equally dumb as the 3.9 argument.
Another thing is that Harrit tested chips in air so that will obviously increase output because of the organic part. We don´t know if the chips will go over 3.9 in nitrogen.

Thermite releases pressure? :eye-poppi Bless your heart, but you seem to be confused about fundamental concepts of physics and chemistry. You really should take my suggestion and enroll in courses in basic physics and chemistry at your local community college before commenting here. You're out of your league.
 
...
Ad hominem attack on Jones.

by the way, you should not bring up the former contributor to the official story, and former member of JREF Dr Greening.
Quoting what he actually said about you lot is enough to get booted of this forum
Jones is self-debunking.

Greening would clean up the thread with your lack of understanding in chemistry.

What does you nonsense have to do with Millette's paper not finding thermite? No thermite, means your crazy friend is debunked by Millette.

Do you understand no thermite was used to destroy the WTC on 911? Why can't you answer a simple question?
 
Lol jtl keeps asking for links for truther responses to Milletes work.

I bumped a thread for him and with all his knowledge of everything he has no idea that there are none, apart from, he didn't do DSC and he had the wrong chips :D

Yep jtl that's as good as it gets. It's sad isn't it ! Oh yeah someone on 911 blogger tried to insinuated that Millette was bought off for 1000 bucks LMFAO
 
Last edited:
and also other stuff not normally found in thermite
Yes, this is so obvious that it is beyond me why anyone would stick to those arguments. The nanoscale makes energy release faster but that is only the beginning.

What is called superthermite can be a mixture that is only partially feo-al thermite, and also other stuff not normally found in thermite. The result will obviously not perform like std thermite. Straight hermite does not release gas pressure and is not explosive but superthermite can because it can be mixed with organic components. It can be rocket fuel. Saying that stuff is not a type of thermite because it releases so much pressure would be equally dumb as the 3.9 argument.

Another thing is that Harrit tested chips in air so that will obviously increase output because of the organic part. We don´t know if the chips will go over 3.9 in nitrogen.

Very technical post this one.
 
Another very interesting thing he has to say is that he is sure the red layer produces the spheres, not the gray layer, because he can look into the chips after burning them and see the trail they leave behind in the red layer, what sounds like a kind of tunnels with a thin iron film.

See basile above. Like I said so many times before i want to see actual tests on paint-metal chips to confirm this gray layer hypothesis. I mentioned some time before that you all should give links to what truthers say about your arguments, and this basile comment is a very good example. He clearly says the spheres are from the red layer and you can´t just ignore stuff like that.:mad:


Jtl, I fully agree with you that some real experiments would be great. Are you (hypothetically) willing to contribute to their financing?

And now, let's see what Basile actually shows us in his lecture (since radio interview cannot prove anything). This stuff has been indeed already discussed here, jtl, but I have one (perhaps) new image from the lecture. And sorry for perhaps too many images.

Here is a shot of red/gray chip „Lucky 13“ before heating. Just a typical bi-layered chip:

picture.php


Here is a sequence of shots from filming this chip when heated on a heating element:

picture.php


Because of a high heating current (ca 6 A), the element of this size/thickness should be heated pretty quickly. We see some flame/burning lasting for some second or so. We also see that after burning, the gray layer is somehow changed, but remains there.
Basile is correct in this, but since the burning was short and we have no idea what was the temperature of heating element during burning of the chip (and the temperature of burning chip), no comparison with DSC experiments in Bentham paper is possible.
And here is the chip after burning:

picture.php


It is very apparent that the burning of polymer binder was incomplete, perhaps because of too short burning (see my posts about thermal behavior of polymers) and a lot of black soot/char remained.

Here is some micrograph (unknown method) after burning:

picture.php


This image is pretty messy, but Basile shows us blueish objects, which are “iron droplets” according to him. Rounded shapes of these droplets are probably connected not only with their real shapes, but also with the fact, that they are surrounded/”immersed” in black char/soot.


And, here is one such droplet with corresponding XDES analysis:

picture.php


Elements content is almost not readable, but here are per cents for more abundant elements: C 8.2, O 21.3, Al 5.2, Si 7.9, Fe 53.

According to these data, it is questionable to consider this object as “iron droplet” (iron oxide is perhaps a better guess), but anyway, these droplets still can still originate from the gray layer, more specifically from the “contact area” between red and gray layer, where some reduction of iron oxide by graphitic soot/char can occur. Who knows. But, this set of data itself does not exclude droplet formation from red layers.

What is really important, I repeat, is that we do not know the temperatures and other parameters, so no direct comparison with the thermal behavior of Bentham chips is possible.

Jtl: Try bear in mind that we are "scanning" all truthers' web and other truthers' stuff regularly, so we probably know (almost) everything they published/they think about red/gray chips. By no means we are avoiding to look at these sources!
 
Last edited:
Yes, this is so obvious that it is beyond me why anyone would stick to those arguments. The nanoscale makes energy release faster but that is only the beginning.

What is called superthermite can be a mixture that is only partially feo-al thermite, and also other stuff not normally found in thermite. The result will obviously not perform like std thermite. Straight hermite does not release gas pressure and is not explosive but superthermite can because it can be mixed with organic components. It can be rocket fuel. Saying that stuff is not a type of thermite because it releases so much pressure would be equally dumb as the 3.9 argument.

Another thing is that Harrit tested chips in air so that will obviously increase output because of the organic part. We don´t know if the chips will go over 3.9 in nitrogen.

With the super fast nano-scale thermite reacting so fast, why did some escape the super fast reaction? Oh, right, the use of super-nano-thermite on 911 only exists in the delusional minds of 911 truth believers.

The best part of the fake paper. Is how super-nano-thermite has less energy than standard thermite.

JonesHarritDelusion.jpg

Good old super-nano-thermite claims. Why do they have less energy? Why does paper have more energy than thermite? Poor chip 1 and 2, must be not-so-super-nano-thermite.

When I did experiments in chemistry in college, things turned out a lot better than the Jones paper. Jones had a conclusion before he did the study.

Millette found no thermite. USGS found no thermite. RJ Lee found no thermite. 911 truth has the fantasy of thermite. 11 years, 911 truth can push this delusion on the fresh, gullible patsies, unable to think for themselves, googling their way to ultimate knowledge.

How will your super thermite stuff help Millette's paper? Millette found no thermite, and no thermite was used on 911. It is normal procedure for those who can't think for themselves, 911 truth followers, to ignore reality, new studies, and anything that will vaporize their fantasy.

Who was the first nut to make up the thermite claim?
 
Oystein:

There are actually two detailed images of "iron droplets" in Basile's lecture:

picture.php


and

picture.php


Looking at the scales, both droplets are larger than 100 micrometers, so they are considerably larger than thicknesses of both layers together (should be around 50 microns).

What they actually are? Probably some objects separated from the chip itself after burning?

Main object on the second, color image looks basically as a piece of gray layer partially melted (?) together with the red piece, difficult to say...

All these images from Mark Basile are rather messy/unexplained...
 
Last edited:
A few pages on, page 189-192, they show red-gray chips that already have spheres attached, and call those "partially reacted".

Haha! So much for the claim "there are no microspheres prior to igniting them" :D

Well, such microspheres in unheated WTC chips (I mean unheated in some scientific apparatus) could be quite rare in fact and we can reasonably expect that they are really "partially reacted chips", as declared by truthers; more specifically, burned perhaps in the fire zones of WTC1/2. But who knows... Millette did not show us anything like this in his set of chips.

Anyway, here are two images available:

picture.php


picture.php


Jtl: Isn't the second image a kind of some evidence that those microspheres should be created from the gray layers? Inconclusive, but...
 
Last edited:
Well, such microspheres in unheated WTC chips (I mean unheated in some scientific apparatus) could be quite rare in fact and we can reasonably expect that they are really "partially reacted chips", as declared by truthers; more specifically, burned perhaps in the fire zones of WTC1/2. But who knows... Millette did not show us anything like this in his set of chips.

Anyway, here are two images available:

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=996&pictureid=7293[/qimg]

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=996&pictureid=7292[/qimg]

Jtl: Isn't the second image a kind of some evidence that those microspheres should be created from the gray layers? Inconclusive, but...

True, all true...

But if chips react only partially, what good is this "superthermite" then? What stopped the chips from burning up completely - and do so extremely rapdily, at the speed of explosives? Isn't that how they are designed?

It seems you need to heat them continually on a crucible or hot steel strip to make them burn completely, not?
 
True, all true...

But if chips react only partially, what good is this "superthermite" then? What stopped the chips from burning up completely - and do so extremely rapdily, at the speed of explosives? Isn't that how they are designed?

It seems you need to heat them continually on a crucible or hot steel strip to make them burn completely, not?

Would you not also expect to see a bright flash and some form of spheres exploding ? Not to mention melting the strip it is sitting on ?
 
Spanx: If the Basile's heating strip was substantially thicker than heated chip "Lucky 13", even superthermite should not substantially damage it. Perhaps, we could observe some "hot corrosion" on the strip. But, this is just my guess. Otherwise, you are of course right, when a real superthermite is ignited, it should show some bright and very short flash:cool:

Oystein: Hehe;) But, do not forget that also in the video of Kevin Ryan, who ignited his home-made superthermite, not all red material completely burned, they are still some red areas visible in the thermitic residue. When superthermite is ignited in sol-gel form like in Ryan's video, some material is probably just blown away by hot air without complete burning.

Anyway, this image of partially burned chip above looks strange. We can reasonably expect that the whole this tiny paint chip was exposed to the same high temperature, therefore why the sphere was formed only in some area close to the chip edge? Perhaps the microsphere formation requires some "seed", in which it starts, and then it is/can be spread further (?).
Supposed that some experiments on heating of other red/gray chips are really arranged anywhere, it would be great to record the whole heating process with some microcamera (with a substantially better resolution than that of Basile's microscope):cool:
 
Last edited:
Perhaps we could expect to see something like this ?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dShGYuU_Wks&feature=youtube

I assume this clip is not fake and as Jtl would say it has other stuff in it.

Read the description with the clip

Exactly, a good example how the superthermite should burn;) Months ago I calculated what should be the "burning time" of such a chip measuring ca 1 mm. Since the burning velocities (? I'm not sure with the terminology) should be roughly 1000 m/s, the chip should be burned in 1/1 000 000 s, which is one microsecond.
Quite a difference from the Basile's chip which burned about one second, not speaking to Bentham chips, which released heat during several minutes;)

(But, this comparison is not really correct, since typical extremely rapid thermitic reaction must be triggered by some thermal/energetic shock, like in the linked video, which is not the case of slow DSC heating indeed)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom