Another very interesting thing he has to say is that
he is sure the red layer produces the spheres, not the gray layer, because he can look into the chips after burning them and see the trail they leave behind in the red layer, what sounds like a kind of tunnels with a thin iron film.
See basile above. Like I said so many times before i want to see actual tests on paint-metal chips to confirm this gray layer hypothesis. I mentioned some time before that you all should give links to what truthers say about your arguments, and this basile comment is a very good example.
He clearly says the spheres are from the red layer and you can´t just ignore stuff like that.
Jtl, I fully agree with you that some real experiments would be great. Are you (hypothetically) willing to contribute to their financing?
And now, let's see what Basile actually shows us in his
lecture (since radio interview cannot prove anything).
This stuff has been indeed already discussed here, jtl, but I have one (perhaps) new image from the lecture. And sorry for perhaps too many images.
Here is a shot of red/gray chip „Lucky 13“ before heating. Just a typical bi-layered chip:
Here is a sequence of shots from filming this chip when heated on a heating element:
Because of a high heating current (ca 6 A), the element of this size/thickness should be heated pretty quickly. We see some flame/burning lasting for some second or so. We also see that after burning, the gray layer is somehow changed, but
remains there.
Basile is correct in this, but since the burning was short and we have no idea what was the temperature of heating element during burning of the chip
(and the temperature of burning chip), no comparison with DSC experiments in Bentham paper is possible.
And here is the chip after burning:
It is very apparent that the burning of polymer binder was incomplete, perhaps because of too short burning (see my posts about thermal behavior of polymers) and a lot of black soot/char remained.
Here is some micrograph (unknown method) after burning:
This image is pretty messy, but Basile shows us blueish objects, which are “iron droplets” according to him. Rounded shapes of these droplets are probably connected not only with their real shapes, but also with the fact, that they are surrounded/”immersed” in black char/soot.
And, here is one such droplet with corresponding XDES analysis:
Elements content is almost not readable, but here are per cents for more abundant elements: C 8.2,
O 21.3, Al 5.2, Si 7.9,
Fe 53.
According to these data, it is questionable to consider this object as “iron droplet” (iron oxide is perhaps a better guess), but anyway, these droplets still can still originate from the gray layer, more specifically from the “contact area” between red and gray layer, where some reduction of iron oxide by graphitic soot/char can occur. Who knows. But, this set of data itself does not exclude droplet formation from red layers.
What is really important, I repeat, is that we do not know the temperatures and other parameters, so no direct comparison with the thermal behavior of Bentham chips is possible.
Jtl: Try bear in mind that we are "scanning" all truthers' web and other truthers' stuff regularly, so we probably know (almost) everything they published/they think about red/gray chips. By no means we are avoiding to look at these sources!