OK,
Jlt, you can be right in some aspects, you are probably wrong in some others. I will check it later. Before I will (perhaps) go to more “important” matters, one single older example of your hand-waving of rational arguments.
You: "Why should the layer have been so thin? Maybe it´s just a fragment of a thick piece?"
Me: This possibility (chips can be fragments of thick piece) had been torn apart into tiny pieces long ago here. There is simply no even closely reasonable truthers explanation, why active thermite layers should be diluted by inactive iron oxide (rust) layers, which can "serve" only as heat sinks and can only stop/preclude any thermitic reaction. (For me, there are also some other strong contra-arguments available, e.g.: alleged "thick piece" consisting of many multilayers in a fashion "red-gray-red-gray-red-gray-etc. layer) cannot be "delaminated" only to bilayers "red-gray", which we see in Bentham paper as well as in Millette's report. In such a case, also some other objects with more than two layers should be always and frequently found in WTC dust. At least I think so.)
You: It is just my opinion that these sort of arguments are weak. If there had been larger pieces then it does not seem impossible that explosive force could leave behind tiny fragments of the material and whatever it was attached to. Arguing about this kind of stuff gets us nowhere because it looks like avoiding Harrit. Much better to just falsify his hypothesis.
You see? You asked, I answered and you immediately hand-waved my answer without any thinking; and you added the remark that this kind of stuff gets us nowhere. So, why did you ask?
(Similarly, you boldly proposed some my additional experiments with Laclede paint imitation, and when I showed you my real TGA experiments with such an imitation, you basically hand-waved them, as expected.)
But back to „nanothermite multilayers“: you perhaps just did not understand my explanation.
Once again: let us have a “thick piece” of such multilayered stuff “red-gray-red-gray-red-gray…etc. layers. Explosive force (or any other destructive force) cannot leave behind
only bilayers (or sometimes perhaps monolayers with some pieces of the second layer or so) , which we see in Bentham paper and in Millette’s report. It is apparent
(at least to me
) that any such explosion would yield
(besides expected and probably strongly prevailing monolayers) also some 3-layered, 4-layered, 5-layered etc pieces/chips etc.
Well, we have this strange object in Fig. 31 in Bentham paper, which looks like a piece of some polymer "wrapped" by red-gray bilayers, but it is explicitly written that there is a lot of a lead in this “chip”, therefore it should not be thermite, multilayered or not. At least, it should not be any material shown before in Bentham paper. Otherwise, no single chip shows any presence even of the third layer
(either the same one or different from other two layers) anywhere.
Hence, the occurrence of
solely bilayers (and some monolayers) tells me that this material was bi-layered from the start. Such a material should be… e.g. the paint layer on rust layer
This matter is indeed marginal anyway. Later this day, I will try to read the fresh contributions here in detail and will (perhaps) try to respond…