WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

Redwood: Bless your heart, laddie, but nobody, not even Harrit or Jones, is claiming that elemental aluminum is in the residue. Real thermite contains aluminum, and its biggest reaction product (by volume) is aluminum oxide. Jones and Harrit have yet to account for its absence from WTC dust, if they wish to make a thermite claim
.

There is al signature in the molten sphere residue from the ignition tests, and this is also seen in the residue spheres from known thermite. But Harrit did not specify that they made sure this al was al oxide which is a weak point.

It just seems most likely that it is pure al because that melts below 700C while al oxide and kaolin have even higher melting points than iron at over 1800C.

Jones tried to account for the lack of elemental Al showing up in XRD by pulling "amorphous aluminum alloys"

why is that impossible? Your buddies say his main chips(a to d in harrit paper) are laclede which means kaolin, but jones xrd rules out kaolin. Millette and jones ruled out Tnemec for those chips so al oxide from tnemec is not there. What options does that leave besides amorphous al?

No. Putting thermite into an organic matrix will not increase the energy yield of the thermite.

Give it a rest, you are entering Ron Mossad territory. I won´t spend any more time on answering this sort of stuff.

Seriously, that thread is a summum malum of pseudoscience!

I don´t think you should make any big statements about other threads considering the state of this one
 
Last edited:
.

There is al signature in the molten sphere residue from the ignition tests, and this is also seen in the residue spheres from known thermite. But Harrit did not specify that they made sure this al was al oxide which is a weak point.

It just seems most likely that it is pure al because that melts below 700C while al oxide and kaolin have even higher melting points than iron at over 1800C.

why is that impossible? Your buddies say his main chips(a to d in harrit paper) are laclede which means kaolin, but jones xrd rules out kaolin. Millette and jones ruled out Tnemec for those chips so al oxide from tnemec is not there. What options does that leave besides amorphous al?

I don´t think you should make any big statements about other threads considering the state of this one

No melted steel, no thermite on 911. Makes Harrit paper a fraud; Millette's paper verifies the fraud.

Jones drops cement blocks 12 feet to simulate 911, and made up thermite due to some problem he has. Woo in action.

DSC is used for what?
 
Last edited:
Oystein: XRD is capable of detecting elemental Al.
What Jones writes includes elemental Al: He did not find any proof for it.

Oystein, the xrd rules out kaolin and the std form of elemental al, but there is a possibility for non conventional elemental amorphous al. You do not seem to realize that this result of no kaolin rules out laclede as an option for chips a to d.

Oystein: Quite clear? Yes. The opposite of what you imply. See, Millette didn't write just "the chips in this study" - he wrote, as I quoted fully: "red/gray chips found in this study (epoxy resin with iron oxide and kaolin pigments)"

Oh please, if you think it will save face for you keep up the act, I will let others read the paper for themselves and see if millette offers other possibilities besides red chips with kaolin. Funny how there is only ftir for kaolin chips? He says some of them have Zn but none have enough to be tnemec:

Millette:
At the time of this progress report, the identity of the product from which the red/gray chips were generated has not been determined. The composition of the red/gray chips found in this study (epoxy resin with iron oxide and kaolin pigments) does not match the formula for the primer paint used on iron column members in the World Trade Center towers (Table 1).16 Although both the red/gray chips and the primer paint contain iron oxide pigment particles, the primer is an alkyd-based resin with zinc yellow (zinc chromate) and diatomaceous silica along with some other proprietary (Tnemec ) pigments. No diatoms were found during the analysis of the red/gray chips. Some small EDS peaks of zinc and chromium were detected in some samples but the amount detected was inconsistent with the 20% level of zinc chromate in the primer formula.
 
The mechanism by which it does this is the zinc chromate will slightly dissolve due to moist air penetrating the paint. The dissolved zinc chromate will then react with the steel's surface to form a passive layer (of zinc) which protects the steel. Over time the zinc chromate is removed from the paint via this degradation and can lead to problems of corrosion. I would imagine that there is a concentration gradient for zinc across the paint thickness due to this process, I'll have to see if that's the case.

I suspect that the same is true of zinc phosphate.

The trouble with this explanation is that we have and actual example of known tnemed from the wtc and its spectra, as pointed out in my post 1515

This sample would also have lessened amount of Zn if this explanation was valid, but in fact it has massive Zn peak compared to harrit fig14 and millette chips. (besides the fact that Harrit claims the Zn disappeared after wash)

If fig14 and millette chips are also wtc tnemec they should have same amount of Zn as the known wtc tnemec, even if they ALL lost Zn over the years.

So this explanation is a bit weak.
 
Last edited:
Oystein, the xrd rules out kaolin and the std form of elemental al, but there is a possibility for non conventional elemental amorphous al. You do not seem to realize that this result of no kaolin rules out laclede as an option for chips a to d.



Oh please, if you think it will save face for you keep up the act, I will let others read the paper for themselves and see if millette offers other possibilities besides red chips with kaolin. Funny how there is only ftir for kaolin chips? He says some of them have Zn but none have enough to be tnemec:

http://dl.dropbox.com/u/64959841/9119ProgressReport022912_rev1_030112webHiRes.pdf

oops

After looking at Harriet's failed paper (when if first came out), I thought the evidence looked like clay. It is used for coatings. No wonder Harrit fooled the non-science people like your cousin. Does your cousin think the fantasy of CD with thermite is true?
 
Last edited:
.

Real thermite contains aluminum, and its biggest reaction product (by volume) is aluminum oxide. Jones and Harrit have yet to account for its absence from WTC dust, if they wish to make a thermite claim.

There is al signature in the molten sphere residue from the ignition tests, and this is also seen in the residue spheres from known thermite. But Harrit did not specify that they made sure this al was al oxide which is a weak point.

It just seems most likely that it is pure al because that melts below 700C while al oxide and kaolin have even higher melting points than iron at over 1800C.

So we can't find elemental aluminum in the putative thermite, but it shows up in its reaction products? :eye-poppi Does this thermite come from an alternate universe that runs in the opposite direction of ours?

Jones tried to account for the lack of elemental Al showing up in XRD by pulling "amorphous aluminum alloys"


why is that impossible? Your buddies say his main chips(a to d in harrit paper) are laclede which means kaolin, but jones xrd rules out kaolin. Millette and jones ruled out Tnemec for those chips so al oxide from tnemec is not there. What options does that leave besides amorphous al?

Wrong. Jones' XRD rules out elemental aluminum, the sine qua non of thermite. He tries to excuse this by appealing to an XRD-invisible aluminum alloy, a violation of William of Ockham's razor. The ghost of Carl Sagan was in a better mood tonight than William, and he let out a guffaw. He suggests you read about the invisible dragon in his garage: http://www.godlessgeeks.com/LINKS/Dragon.htm

No. Putting thermite into an organic matrix will not increase the energy yield of the thermite.

Give it a rest, you are entering Ron Mossad territory. I won´t spend any more time on answering this sort of stuff.

I think you've come up with a new type of "non-responsive response", the "argumentum ad hominem by proxy".

Seriously, that thread is a summum malum of pseudoscience!

I don´t think you should make any big statements about other threads considering the state of this one

There is a lot of pseudo-science on this thread, but it seems to be coming mainly from one person, who originally claimed to be only JAQing off!:rolleyes: And as for the other thread, I recommend you ask the opinion of any chemistry professor at your school, if you are in school, and if you're not, take it to a chem professor at your local community college. You might consider enrolling in class. You'd learn something!
 
Redwood said:
]No. Putting thermite into an organic matrix will not increase the energy yield of the thermite.
Give it a rest, you are entering Ron Mossad territory. I won´t spend any more time on answering this sort of stuff.

I'm interested in this point, which I've raised before, about the limits on the energy yield of thermite: the popular literature on nanoenergetics suggests that nanoengineering greatly increases the power (vs. energy) density of a composite. Your debate opponents here cannot seem to acknowledge that we are talking about a nanoengineered product (likely because they have little knowledge of nanoenergetics) which means that we are talking about a different power potential entirely. Do you agree?
 
Last edited:
I'm interested in this point, which I've raised before, about the limits on the energy yield of thermite: the popular literature on nanoenergetics suggests that nanoengineering greatly increases the power (vs. energy) density of a composite. Your debate opponents here cannot seem to acknowledge that we are talking about a nanoengineered product (likely because they have little knowledge of nanoenergetics) which means that we are talking about a different power potential entirely. Do you agree?

It is chemistry, not opinion.

Who are they?

You can't change the amount of energy in thermite. Your post is nonsense, unless you can explain.

Are you saying you can get more joules out of super-nano-thermite than "standard" thermite?

Why can't you understand that the heat energy of the office fires is equal more than 2,500 Tons of thermite, and even though it is not efficient, a play on your energy/power play, it did cause the collapse?
 
Last edited:
Why can't you understand that the heat energy of the office fires is equal more than 2,500 Tons of thermite

That is really just the point. Truthers spend so much time arguing over nonsense, when at the end of the day, thermite was not needed to bring down those towers. There was plenty of heat being supplied by the 8 stories of uncontrolled, enormous fires. It really doesn't get more to the point than that.
 
Last edited:
You can't change the amount of energy in thermite.
Yes, that's your argument. And it's irrelevant.

Are you saying you can get more joules out of super-nano-thermite than "standard" thermite?
My understanding is that energy density is measured in joules, power density in watts.
 
Yes, that's your argument. And it's irrelevant.
You agree you can't change the energy in thermite.

Millette's paper found no thermite. Why are you off topic? There is no thermite in this thread. Did you miss the paper?

My understanding is that energy density is measured in joules, power density in watts.
So? Did you google that?

And?

Why can't office fires with the heat energy of 2,500 tons of thermite start the WTC collapse? You can't offer how much thermite it took, can you? Oops, there is no evidence of thermite. darn

Millette's paper says no thermite. The WTC steel has no damage from thermite. USGS found not themite. RJ Lee, found no thermite.

Do you still have a fantasy of thermite?
 
Last edited:
Your understanding is incorrect. Energy is measured in Joules, and power is measured in Watts.

Yes, ok.

J/kg (energy density)
W/m2 (power density)

What is the point you are trying to make with respect to the power density of nanoengineered materials?
 
.


I won´t spend any more time on answering this sort of stuff.

Now there is a suprise !

You don't want to talk about your DSC Al making machine.

Please call me a troll, I love it when you talk dirty :)
 
Yes, that's your argument. And it's irrelevant.


My understanding is that energy density is measured in joules, power density in watts.

Well, that's wrong, but never mind.
Has anyone measure the power, or power density, of anything, what was the result, was the result compared to anything, and what was concluded from it?

That is all off-topic, but your tap-dancing should be fun :)

ETA: Oh:
Yes, ok.

J/kg (energy density)
W/m2 (power density)
What is the point you are trying to make with respect to the power density of nanoengineered materials?
Yes, fun indeed :D
 
Last edited:
OK, Jlt, you can be right in some aspects, you are probably wrong in some others. I will check it later. Before I will (perhaps) go to more “important” matters, one single older example of your hand-waving of rational arguments.

You: "Why should the layer have been so thin? Maybe it´s just a fragment of a thick piece?"

Me: This possibility (chips can be fragments of thick piece) had been torn apart into tiny pieces long ago here. There is simply no even closely reasonable truthers explanation, why active thermite layers should be diluted by inactive iron oxide (rust) layers, which can "serve" only as heat sinks and can only stop/preclude any thermitic reaction. (For me, there are also some other strong contra-arguments available, e.g.: alleged "thick piece" consisting of many multilayers in a fashion "red-gray-red-gray-red-gray-etc. layer) cannot be "delaminated" only to bilayers "red-gray", which we see in Bentham paper as well as in Millette's report. In such a case, also some other objects with more than two layers should be always and frequently found in WTC dust. At least I think so.)

You: It is just my opinion that these sort of arguments are weak. If there had been larger pieces then it does not seem impossible that explosive force could leave behind tiny fragments of the material and whatever it was attached to. Arguing about this kind of stuff gets us nowhere because it looks like avoiding Harrit. Much better to just falsify his hypothesis.

You see? You asked, I answered and you immediately hand-waved my answer without any thinking; and you added the remark that this kind of stuff gets us nowhere. So, why did you ask? ;)

(Similarly, you boldly proposed some my additional experiments with Laclede paint imitation, and when I showed you my real TGA experiments with such an imitation, you basically hand-waved them, as expected.):cool:

But back to „nanothermite multilayers“: you perhaps just did not understand my explanation.
Once again: let us have a “thick piece” of such multilayered stuff “red-gray-red-gray-red-gray…etc. layers. Explosive force (or any other destructive force) cannot leave behind only bilayers (or sometimes perhaps monolayers with some pieces of the second layer or so) , which we see in Bentham paper and in Millette’s report. It is apparent (at least to me:cool:) that any such explosion would yield (besides expected and probably strongly prevailing monolayers) also some 3-layered, 4-layered, 5-layered etc pieces/chips etc.

Well, we have this strange object in Fig. 31 in Bentham paper, which looks like a piece of some polymer "wrapped" by red-gray bilayers, but it is explicitly written that there is a lot of a lead in this “chip”, therefore it should not be thermite, multilayered or not. At least, it should not be any material shown before in Bentham paper. Otherwise, no single chip shows any presence even of the third layer (either the same one or different from other two layers) anywhere.

Hence, the occurrence of solely bilayers (and some monolayers) tells me that this material was bi-layered from the start. Such a material should be… e.g. the paint layer on rust layer:cool:

This matter is indeed marginal anyway. Later this day, I will try to read the fresh contributions here in detail and will (perhaps) try to respond…
 
Last edited:
Hey Ivan, sorry for waiting a day and more than 40 posts before replying to this.

;)

Owing to quite a large amount of info in all these paint (and microspheres) threads, I'm not really sure: have we discussed this old good NIST image of Tnemec primer heated to more than 650 degrees C?

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=993&pictureid=7286[/qimg]

This burned paint layer with some rust scales is basically quite similar to "infamous" Bentham chips:

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=993&pictureid=7287[/qimg]

This is no surprise, since any such red primer paint "after exposure greater than 650 degrees" should be basically similar to unheated paint (visually). But what is probably interesting that we do not see any microspheres created from the scales here. Scales still look like scales (although the image quality is probably not good enough).

From this point of view (which is not conclusive) , Bentham chips heated in DSC device should be different kind of paint chips, since microsphere formation (mostly from gray rust scales) was very apparent there, at similar temperatures:cool:

I don't think I am following you there. I think you can't really compare that NIST photograph of heated Tnemec on solid, thick steel with images of another paint (I am pretty sure the photomicrographs are of chips a-d, they are LaClede) that has (probably) not been heated.
For starters, the magnification is different, and not indicated in the NIST image. I doubt we would even be able to see any microspheres if they were present.
Next, it might make a difference if the oxidized steel surface is still attached to the bulk of steel, or already spalled to a thin layer of just tens of microns.

So I am not sure what you are validly comparing :confused:
 
Hey Ivan, sorry for waiting a day and more than 40 posts before replying to this.



I don't think I am following you there. I think you can't really compare that NIST photograph of heated Tnemec on solid, thick steel with images of another paint (I am pretty sure the photomicrographs are of chips a-d, they are LaClede) that has (probably) not been heated.
For starters, the magnification is different, and not indicated in the NIST image. I doubt we would even be able to see any microspheres if they were present.
Next, it might make a difference if the oxidized steel surface is still attached to the bulk of steel, or already spalled to a thin layer of just tens of microns.

So I am not sure what you are validly comparing :confused:

Oystein: Visual comparison of heated Tnemec paint with "Bentham chips" is not important, I just referred to some loose resemblance of these two "materials".

I know that scale in NIST image is missing, but judging from the structures of gray layers, I would guess that the scales of both images are not so drastically different - perhaps NIST image has a scale 5-10 times higher (?). Therefore, microspheres might be perhaps observable.
I was interested basically only in these gray scales attached to the twisted red layer, since such scales could be subjected to similar condition like in DSC apparatus, at least from the time of red layer deformation/delamination from the steel.

But, indeed, this my post did not prove anything, it was just a reminder that micrographs of one authentic WTC paint with rust scales heated to similar temperatures like in Bentham paper are available;)

And (even before reading the new Jtl stuff), it seems that new XEDS spectra of authentic Tnemec primer chips (which should be obtained quite easily by Jim Millette) would be really very helpful.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom