WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

Chris
Any update on Dr. Millette finishing the report and publication?
Oystein and Ivan had some constructive comments re Laclede paint - we'd be interested in knowing if the primer paint(s) can be further identified.
 
Last edited:

It's a video demonstrating rusty iron paint chips are magnetic. Your point?

It's a video of the 1954 removal of the Reichstag dome. Self described as:

Demolition of the dome of the Reichstag building with oxyacetylene cutters and thermite charges. The building had been in ruins since the fire of 1933.

Notice all the workmen, wiring and scaffolding as they first use torches to cut the supports and then the flares and gushing sparks as the thermite slowly melted through the remaining girders?
 
How did Jones & Co separate the rusty iron paint chips from the thermite chips ?

They didn't . There was no primer paint on steel, it was all thermite paint. According to Harrit's thermite estimate I calculated:

"Harrit low 127,832,000 lbs / 12.3 lbs per gal = 10,393,000 gal x 329 SF/gal. = 3,419,297,000 SF of painted steel coverage /14,340,000 SF of steel surface area both towers =
238 times more surface area than the actual total for all of the steel surface areas of the two towers.

Harrit high 630,344,000 lbs / 12.3 lbs per gal = 51,247,000 gal x 329 SF/gal. = 16,860,263,000 SF of painted steel coverage /14,340,000 SF of steel surface area both towers =
1,176 times more surface area than the actual total for all of the steel surface areas of the two towers."

[my bold]
From email correspondence between chemical engineer T. Mark Hightower and Niels Harrit:
On July 27, 2011, Niels Harrit (chief author of the 2009 nanothermite paper) presented a calculation for how much thermitic material would have been necessary to explain the presence of the many tiny iron-rich spheres in the dust (assuming that a thermite reaction was the source of the spheres).
He gave a range of numbers, based on lower and higher concentrations of the thermite formulation. His lowest figure amounted to 29,000 metric tons of thermitic explosive per tower – a value hundreds of times greater than the calculation for conventional explosives. His “conservative” estimate (based on 10% iron-oxide in the thermitic material) was 143,000 metric tons of thermitic material that would have been placed in each tower. http://www.veteranstoday.com/2011/08/27/nanothermite-if-it-doesnt-fit-you-must-acquit/
[note: thermitic material is red layer only per Bentham paper]
Oystein 12,000 tons x 2000 lbs = 24,000,000 lbs. of thermite paint.
From “That infamous ‘6 wt-% of the dust are iron microspheres, says RJ Lee’ “translates to ... 6,000 tons of iron microspheres total, and if these are the product of thermite, this means 12,000 tons of thermite total.”-Oystein.

Harrit low 29,000 metric tonnes x 2204 lbs = 63,916,000 lbs x 2 towers =127,832,000 lbs. of thermite paint.
Harrit high 143,000 metric tonnes x 2204 lbs = 315,172,000 lbs x 2 towers = 630,344,000 lbs. of thermite paint.

We may ignore for the moment the unnoticed transportation, distribution and application difficulties of this amount of thermitic material applied to the steel structure as well as the steel melting or explosive energy deficit of a 100 micron layer, and solely calculate the amount of steel surface area that these amounts of painted thermite would cover.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------

From TNEMEC Series 104-1211 Epoxy red steel primer, similar to that used in the original towers.
http://www.tnemec.com/resources/product/PDS/104.pdf
Total steel surface area of both towers combined= 14,340,000 SF
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8058454&postcount=2109

From Bentham paper - chips thickness; 10-100 microns gray layer, 10-100 microns red layer.
At 100 microns (average width of human hair) dry film paint thickness for the “active” red layer, one gallon of the primer paint covers 329 SF and weighs 14.7 lbs/gallon -2.4 lbs / gal. for evaporative loss of VOCs (volatile organic compounds) and HAPs (hazardous air pollutants) = 12.3 lbs/ gal. net.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Oystein -from 6% iron microspheres 24,000,000 lbs / 12.3 lbs per gal = 1,951,220 gal x 329 SF/gal. = 641,951,380 SF of painted steel coverage /14,340,000 SF of steel surface area both towers =
45 times more surface area than the actual total for all of the steel surface areas of the two towers.

Harrit low 127,832,000 lbs / 12.3 lbs per gal = 10,393,000 gal x 329 SF/gal. = 3,419,297,000 SF of painted steel coverage /14,340,000 SF of steel surface area both towers =
238 times more surface area than the actual total for all of the steel surface areas of the two towers.

Harrit high 630,344,000 lbs / 12.3 lbs per gal = 51,247,000 gal x 329 SF/gal. = 16,860,263,000 SF of painted steel coverage /14,340,000 SF of steel surface area both towers =
1,176 times more surface area than the actual total for all of the steel surface areas of the two towers.

These SF calculations based on the thermite claims show that the amount of iron microspheres found in the dust could not have been produced solely, or even predominantly, by the “thermitic” red layer of the chips.

The cleaning crew must have sprinkled the additional thousands of thermite tons on the carpet before they left.
 
They didn't . There was no primer paint on steel, it was all thermite paint. According to Harrit's thermite estimate I calculated:

"Harrit low 127,832,000 lbs / 12.3 lbs per gal = 10,393,000 gal x 329 SF/gal. = 3,419,297,000 SF of painted steel coverage /14,340,000 SF of steel surface area both towers =
238 times more surface area than the actual total for all of the steel surface areas of the two towers.

Harrit high 630,344,000 lbs / 12.3 lbs per gal = 51,247,000 gal x 329 SF/gal. = 16,860,263,000 SF of painted steel coverage /14,340,000 SF of steel surface area both towers =
1,176 times more surface area than the actual total for all of the steel surface areas of the two towers."

The cleaning crew must have sprinkled the additional thousands of thermite tons on the carpet before they left.

Harrit low 29,000 metric tonnes x 2204 lbs = 63,916,000 lbs x 2 towers =127,832,000 lbs. of thermite paint.

But isn't Harrit's new position that the "nanothermite" was merely a priming charge for a conventional explosive charge? Either nanothermite is the world's most inefficient priming charge, or the total weight of explosives must have been on the order of the weight of the building itself. :jaw-dropp:boggled:

Then there's all that unexploded nanothermite (explosives, too?) that burned and kept the debris piles at thousands of degrees for months -- amazing that the Towers didn't collapse under the sheer weight of all that explosive, no? ;)
 
...Then there's all that unexploded nanothermite (explosives, too?) that burned and kept the debris piles at thousands of degrees for months -- amazing that the Towers didn't collapse under the sheer weight of all that explosive, no? ;)
All of which is why I stay with my "Lazy Aussies" debunking of thermXte viz:
"there was no CD so it matters not if there were 100tonne stockpiles of thermXte at each corner of ground zero. It wasn't used for CD"

Corollary: "Even if there was thermXte in the dust truthers still have to prove CD. And that is the big challenge. So come back to me when you can prove CD and I'll listen whilst you explain where thermXte fitted into the scenario."

Spoils a lot of "debunking fun" and gets me called a few names.... :D
 
It's a video demonstrating rusty iron paint chips are magnetic. Your point?


It's a video of the 1954 removal of the Reichstag dome. Self described as:



Notice all the workmen, wiring and scaffolding as they first use torches to cut the supports and then the flares and gushing sparks as the thermite slowly melted through the remaining girders?

Yah, and they failed the first try on Oct 15 using thermite. The only other time it's been used on a large structure was in 1935 in Chicago (120 lbs dynamite on one Skyride tower, 1500 lbs thermite on the other).

Then apparently a pause of almost 50 years until 2011 without further professional development.

Any rational person with knowledge will quickly conclude that thermite would be a horribly inefficient way to demolish a 110 story tower; nevermind trying to smuggle tons and tons of the stuff and fix it to the perimeter columns...

It defies logic that something like that would happen. Why is it so easy for me to accept that a jet flew into the tower and it burned then collapsed? It doesn't require a stretch of credulity for me.

I guess it's like those cheezy Austin Powers movies where he's about to be killed by an overly-elaborate scheme, which always fails. Reality isn't meant to be entertaining like the movies. It's just brutal and deadly sometimes. And shockingly unexpected.
 
Then apparently a pause of almost 50 years until 2011 without further professional development.

That you can literally count every time thermite was used for building demolitions in the century before 911 tells you everything you need to know about it's practical aplication.
 
Fun with Numbers

But isn't Harrit's new position that the "nanothermite" was merely a priming charge for a conventional explosive charge? Either nanothermite is the world's most inefficient priming charge, or the total weight of explosives must have been on the order of the weight of the building itself. :jaw-dropp:boggled:

Then there's all that unexploded nanothermite (explosives, too?) that burned and kept the debris piles at thousands of degrees for months -- amazing that the Towers didn't collapse under the sheer weight of all that explosive, no? ;)


1) Thermitic explosives.
In that Canadian truther conference in Canada earlier this year (somewhere on youtube), Harrit said that he hadn’t been sure if the thermitic material had been used as an explosive or as an incendiary. He said that after watching Chandler’s convincing “rockets” video at that conference, Harrit was certain the thermitic material was used as an explosive.

2) Weight of the paint per square foot of the TT above grade.
Harrit low of 127,832,000 lbs. of thermitic paint / Square footage of both TT (above grade) 8,600,000=14.86 lb/sf of thermitic paint.
Harrit high of 630,344,000 lbs. of thermitic paint / Square footage of both TT (above grade) 8,600,000=73.30 lb/sf of thermitic paint.
Weight of both TT (dead load only) = 1,000,000 tons x 2,000 lb/ton = 2,000,000,000 lbs / 8,600,000 square feet both TT (above grade) = 233 lbs/ sf (in my experience this is too high) The 500,000 tons weight per Tower is commonly used and likely includes the subbasement levels, skewing the above- grade weight per square footage of the Towers used.
"The total weight of the structure was roughly 500,000 t, but wind load, rather than the gravity load, dominated the design"
"More than 200,000 tons of steel - far more than the amount required for the construction of the Verrazano Narrows Bridge - was used in the World Trade Center's construction."
" The 425,000 cubic yards of concrete used in building the World Trade Center is enough to build a five-foot wide sidewalk from New York City to Washington, DC."
http://hypertextbook.com/facts/2004/EricChen.shtml

SKA12-84_1.png


3)
How many 5 gallon buckets of nano-sol-gel 10% iron oxide (conservative per Harrit) paint did it take to paint the TT?

http://www.veteranstoday.com/2011/08/27/nanothermite-if-it-doesnt-fit-you-must-acquit/
Harrit low 127,832,000 lbs / 12.3 lbs per gal = 10,393,000 gal / 5 gallons = > 2 million 5 gallon buckets.

Harrit high 630,344,000 lbs / 12.3 lbs per gal = 51,247,000 gal / 5 gallons = >10 million 5 gallon buckets.

4) How thick would the thermitic chips have to be to account for Harrit’s numbers and how many coats would have to be applied?
From the Bentham paper - chips thickness; 10-100 microns gray layer, 10-100 microns red layer.
At 100 microns (average width of human hair) dry film paint thickness for the “active” red layer, one gallon of the primer paint covers 329 SF and weighs 14.7 lbs/gallon -2.4 lbs / gal. for evaporative loss of VOCs (volatile organic compounds) and HAPs (hazardous air pollutants) = 12.3 lbs/ gal. net.

Harrit low 127,832,000 lbs / 12.3 lbs per gal = 10,393,000 gal x 329 SF/gal. = 3,419,297,000 SF of painted steel coverage /14,340,000 SF of steel surface area both towers =
238 times more surface area than the actual total for all of the steel surface areas of the two towers.
238 x 100 microns = 23,800 microns = 15/16 inch of thermitic paint over all the surface area of all the steel of the TT. Say you can vertically apply 600 micron ( 1/32 inch)wet coats in one pass, dry, reapply (23,800/600) it would take 40 separate application coats to get 15/16 inch net thickness. ( 238 coats at 100 microns- Benthan chips).

Harrit high 630,344,000 lbs / 12.3 lbs per gal = 51,247,000 gal x 329 SF/gal. = 16,860,263,000 SF of painted steel coverage /14,340,000 SF of steel surface area both towers =
1,176 times more surface area than the actual total for all of the steel surface areas of the two towers.
1,176 x 100 microns = 117,600 microns = 4-5/8 inches of thermitic paint over all the surface area of all the steel of the TT. Say you can vertically apply 600 micron ( 1/32 inch)wet coats in one pass, dry, reapply (117,600/600) it would take 196 separate application coats to get 4-5/8 inches net thickness. ( 1,176 coats at 100 microns- Benthan chips).

5) Practical considerations.
The Towers were completed in 1970-1971 before nano-thermitic-sol-gel technology was invented (~1998-2002), so it must have been applied after the TT had been completed.
All the TT steel was covered with either SFRM fireproofing or sheetrock. All the SFRM perimeter columns had three sides to the exterior and covered in aluminum cladding. This means one had to apply all the nano-coats atop the steel and replace what had been removed without arousing suspicion.

In school, when calculating many numbers, we would first approximate the answer by hand with pencil and paper for say the first few digits– a sanity check to see if the resulting slide rule answer was reasonable.

Where was Harrit’s sanity check?
 
1) Thermitic explosives.
In that Canadian truther conference in Canada earlier this year (somewhere on youtube), Harrit said that he hadn’t been sure if the thermitic material had been used as an explosive or as an incendiary. He said that after watching Chandler’s convincing “rockets” video at that conference, Harrit was certain the thermitic material was used as an explosive.

Mama mia! Harrit doesn't even understand the difference between propellants and explosives! (Paging Ryan Mackey!) You don't use high explosives to propel rockets!

There ARE certain compounds such as PETN that can be either propellants or high explosives, depending on their physical characteristics. And there are certain combinations of chemicals, like nitrocellulose/nitroglycerin, that can do the same, depending on their proportions.

So, if Harrit believes he has both "nanothermite propellant" and "nanothermite high explosive" on 9/11, his beloved dust samples should contain both, and they would be physically or chemically distinguishable. Back to the analytical lab, Niels!


Where was Harrit’s sanity check?

Is this a trick question? ;)

P.S. Chandler's "nanothermite rockets" video is the most idiotic truther YouTube I've ever seen from someone claiming the mantle of science. Judy Wood is more crazy and idiotic, but I've never seen her put together a YouTube video.

 
P.S. Chandler's "nanothermite rockets" video is the most idiotic truther YouTube I've ever seen from someone claiming the mantle of science. Judy Wood is more crazy and idiotic, but I've never seen her put together a YouTube video.

From hereon out, I'm taking the quotes off the phrase Bat#%$^ crazy.
 
Wait, is someone actually claiming there were "nano-thermite" rockets that did, what!? :eek:
 
Wait, is someone actually claiming there were "nano-thermite" rockets that did, what!? :eek:

They supposedly pushed down on the top of the buildings to make them collapse at faster than they should have under a "natural" collapse. I don't get it either, but what do I know? :rolleyes:
 
Wait, is someone actually claiming there were "nano-thermite" rockets that did, what!? :eek:

Well, yeah! How do you think those 10-ton perimeter panels got propelled for hundreds of meters? You can even see the white smoke of the exhaust!


:crazy:
 
They supposedly pushed down on the top of the buildings to make them collapse at faster than they should have under a "natural" collapse. I don't get it either, but what do I know? :rolleyes:
Pushing down on the collapsing building was needed because...?
:confused:
 
speed of deciet

"space beams" ?! funny. Joke is, 'space beams' make more sense than the 'walking' ones of Pinocchio sunders LS-DYNA(secret) creatioNIST agnotology.

Inventing the 'new phenomeNIST' cartoon : 'sequential building collapse due to normal office furnishings fires' (NOFF) of complex steel framed high rises disintegrating at free fall due to 'thermal expansion' by NOFF's already out at the time of critical initiation sure means you gotta 'have the faith'.

Might as well go with the space beams since this forum is already in that game anyway.
 
"space beams" ?! funny. Joke is, 'space beams' make more sense than the 'walking' ones of Pinocchio sunders LS-DYNA(secret) creatioNIST agnotology.
Is this the best Dr Jones has to push the silly thermite lies? When will this get a Pulitzer? never

Inventing the 'new phenomeNIST' cartoon : 'sequential building collapse due to normal office furnishings fires' (NOFF) of complex steel framed high rises disintegrating at free fall due to 'thermal expansion' by NOFF's already out at the time of critical initiation sure means you gotta 'have the faith'.
New? Thermal expansion is the oldest Phenomena in the Universe, it is the origin. Sorry, science wins, thermite and crazy claims lost. 12 years an no evidence from you, or 911 truth; a perfect record of woo.

Might as well go with the space beams since this forum is already in that game anyway.
You are not up to the level of DEW, at least that is science, you only bring attacks on NIST - did they refuse to hire you? What is your degree in?

12 years and thermite claims remains a lie made up by a fired physicist.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom