Sunstealer, if you have the time, can you explain/suggest an addition to their protocol that would help them get a definitive answer? Which tests are they proposing that are NOT materials characterization tests (such as DSC) and which essential tests are not in their protocol? I see they have FTIR but not TEM. I don't know why their suggested protocol would produce junk results as you assert. I would like to take your answer to Mark and others in 9/11 Truth directly to make one last effort to try to develop a protocol that is mutually agreeable before they waste their $5000.
The problem is there is no criteria for comparing the data they obtain with the data in the Harrit et al paper along with Dr Millette's.
The separation method, i.e. using a magnet and optical microscopy, will produce a sample set with more than one material for both red and gray layers. We know this because the original Harrit et al paper shows us that the red layer of chips a, b, c and d are a different material to the chip soaked in MEK, Fig 14. Similarly, further in the paper, Fig 31, 32 and 33 clearly show that the gray layer is not all the same material.
Dr Millette also obtained chips that have EDX spectra that are a match for chips a-d and Fig 14 (as previously discussed). However, Dr Millette specifies a criteria (data matching chips a, b, c and d) that must be met for chips to be tested using other definitive methods, Basile doesn't.
Basile is going to have a sample of mixed material, which in itself isn't a problem, however, it will become a problem as the additional experiments will produce different data for different chips. Unless there is a criteria for data analysis or the chips have been pre-selected for analysis then there will simply be a mass of data with no coherence. So there won't be an answer one way or the other.
It's not wise to press ahead when there isn't a proper methodology applied to the task.
The first thing to do would be to distinguish between chips using SEM microscopy and EDX of the red layer. So you might have say 3 groups;
Chips that match chips a,b,c and d
Chips that match Fig 17 (MEK soaked sample)
Chips that are none of the above.
This obviously requires accepting that the separation method is going to produce mixed material. Does Basile accept this? Then you decide on what to test and how.
At this stage a test matrix is a good idea so that you plan exactly which samples are going to be subject to which test(s). It might look something like.
---------------------GROUP-------------------TEST----------
------------- a/b/c/d MEK Other ---- ESCA FTIR DSC RESIDUAL
Chip 1 ----------X--------------------X-----X----X-----X----------
Chip 2 ----------------X--------------X-----X----------------------
Chip 3
Chip 4
Chip 5
Chip 6
So whilst it's a good idea to have a look at the chip that matches the MEK soaked one it's not imperative to perform DSC.
You can use a pre-accepted criteria just as you and Dr Millette did so as not to slow the study or introduce additional cost and confusion/changing your mind.
If it was me I'd be looking at chips that match chips a, b, c and d, the same as Millette. Then you have a reasonable comparison across all three studies. We have no idea what the MEK soaked chip looks like under SEM and we have no idea what group of chips was subjected to DSC in Harrit et al.
Once you ascertain that you have chips that match then you can perform the FTIR and more detailed SEM studies. That should be enough to determine what the material is. Then do DSC if you really must. It would simply give a known material a DSC curve.
I suspect what will happen is we'll get a hodgepodge of data with enough ambiguity in it to not be definitive.