WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

That you can literally count every time thermite was used for building demolitions in the century before 911 tells you everything you need to know about it's practical aplication.

Of course, the fact that it was used before takes away the 'never happened before in history' meme.
 
To be fair, the "never before happened in history" claim is about the natural collapse of steel-framed high-rises due to fire, not about the prior use of thermite to bring down a building. The fact that thermite was used twice in the twentieth century eliminates "our" meme that thermite was never used or could never be used for this purpose. It can be done, and was done. I didn't ask Jim Millette these theoretical questions, though. I asked him, can you find thermite in the WTC dust? His answer: no thermite. Simple. It wasn't there, so it's irrelevant whether it CAN be used to bring down a building; it WASN'T THERE so it couldn't have been used to bring down the three tall buildings on 9/11!
 
The fact that thermite was used twice in the twentieth century eliminates "our" meme that thermite was never used or could never be used for this purpose.

If you look hard enough you can find an example of "anything" being used for "anything" else, sensible or not. I've seen armor piercing rocket propelled grenades used to cause snow avalanches. I've seen videos of people driving in nails with pistol shots. Doesn't mean that's what they are used for or what you would use them for in other than silly stunt.

IIRC, there have been a couple recorded instances of karate classes "demolishing" buildings as a publicity stunt. Doesn't mean they are used for demolitions or are capable of bringing down a 110 story skyscraper.
 
To be fair, the "never before happened in history" claim is about the natural collapse of steel-framed high-rises due to fire, not about the prior use of thermite to bring down a building. The fact that thermite was used twice in the twentieth century eliminates "our" meme that thermite was never used or could never be used for this purpose. It can be done, and was done. I didn't ask Jim Millette these theoretical questions, though. I asked him, can you find thermite in the WTC dust? His answer: no thermite. Simple. It wasn't there, so it's irrelevant whether it CAN be used to bring down a building; it WASN'T THERE so it couldn't have been used to bring down the three tall buildings on 9/11!
Not the first time steel failed in fire. Truther say the dumbest things, does that make them idiots? How do you debate fantasy, the contant dumbed down Gish Gallop of cult members and idiots like Gage?
woodsteelfire.jpg


Wood can beat steel.

Fire totals buildings.
onemeridiansag.jpg

Where is this high rise now? In the dump. It did not collapse because the fires were fought, WTC 7, 1, and 2 fires were not fought. "First Time In History"?

Steel frame of Windsor building to high to get water to, collapsed, the concrete core did not.


First time in history 10,000 gallons of jet fuel was used to start fires on multiple floors in seconds.
Why can't 911 truth say something about this first?
 
Last edited:
To be fair, the "never before happened in history" claim is about the natural collapse of steel-framed high-rises due to fire, not about the prior use of thermite to bring down a building. The fact that thermite was used twice in the twentieth century eliminates "our" meme that thermite was never used or could never be used for this purpose. It can be done, and was done. I didn't ask Jim Millette these theoretical questions, though. I asked him, can you find thermite in the WTC dust? His answer: no thermite. Simple. It wasn't there, so it's irrelevant whether it CAN be used to bring down a building; it WASN'T THERE so it couldn't have been used to bring down the three tall buildings on 9/11!

Chris, our 'meme' is correct: a steel frame high rise has never been brought down by either thermite or nanothermite.

btw, is Dr Millette going to get the study published?
 
Speeds of Deciet.

no. your 'meme' is not 'correct' because you do not KNOW that.
That is a 'faith-based' opinion in the new-propaganda-speak of 'meme'.
It would be more accurate to say 'until 911 no steel frame high rise is known to have been brought down by either thermite or nanothermite, but that evidence yet to be contested in a Court of LAW indicates at least 3 of the WTC Towers were demolished using highly engineered thermitic materiel'.
That would be ACCURATE.
In July 1996, Komatsu-Dresser (A director being L.Paul.Bremer whose office in WTC1 was exactly where Flight 11 impacted) patented a thermite demolition device that could demolish a concrete structure at a high efficiency, while preventing a secondary problem due to noise, flying dust and chips, and the like. "Taku Murakami, US Patent 5532449 - Using plasma ARC and thermite to demolish concrete'.(Another Nineteen.pp345.19)
Such technology would easily be applied to steel frames.
 
Last edited:
no. your 'meme' is not 'correct' because you do not KNOW that.
That is a 'faith-based' opinion in the new-propaganda-speak of 'meme'.
It would be more accurate to say 'until 911 no steel frame high rise is known to have been brought down by either thermite or nanothermite, but that evidence yet to be contested in a Court of LAW indicates at least 3 of the WTC Towers were demolished using highly engineered thermitic materiel'.
That would be ACCURATE.
In July 1996, Komatsu-Dresser (A director being L.Paul.Bremer whose office in WTC1 was exactly where Flight 11 impacted) patented a thermite demolition device that could demolish a concrete structure at a high efficiency, while preventing a secondary problem due to noise, flying dust and chips, and the like. "Taku Murakami, US Patent 5532449 - Using plasma ARC and thermite to demolish concrete'.(Another Nineteen.pp345.19)
Such technology would easily be applied to steel frames.

The only place thermite exists doing 911, is in the mind of Dr Jones fired for spreading silly lies about 911. Exactly? lol
 
no. your 'meme' is not 'correct' because you do not KNOW that.
That is a 'faith-based' opinion in the new-propaganda-speak of 'meme'.
It would be more accurate to say 'until 911 no steel frame high rise is known to have been brought down by either thermite or nanothermite, but that evidence yet to be contested in a Court of LAW indicates at least 3 of the WTC Towers were demolished using highly engineered thermitic materiel'.
That would be ACCURATE.
In July 1996, Komatsu-Dresser (A director being L.Paul.Bremer whose office in WTC1 was exactly where Flight 11 impacted) patented a thermite demolition device that could demolish a concrete structure at a high efficiency, while preventing a secondary problem due to noise, flying dust and chips, and the like. "Taku Murakami, US Patent 5532449 - Using plasma ARC and thermite to demolish concrete'.(Another Nineteen.pp345.19)
Such technology would easily be applied to steel frames.

Um, no. Did you even bother to double check the citation or did you simply regurgitate what another Truther told you?

Using plasma ARC and thermite to demolish concreteAccording to the present invention, a concrete demolishing method which melts a surface of a concrete structure comprises: generating a plasma arc from the plasma torch of a plasma arc generator, mixing thermite powder with a supply gas for the plasma torch, passing the mixture of thermite powder and supply gas to the plasma arc, directing the plasma arc at the surface of the concrete structure, and controlling the rate of supply of the thermite powder to the plasma arc in response to the operation of the plasma torch, preferably including initiating and stopping the supply of the thermite powder to the plasma arc in a manner coordinated with the initiation and stoppage of the plasma arc, thereby controlling the heat generated by the thermite reaction and melting at least a portion of the surface of the concrete structure.

Thermite fed through a supply gas into a plasma arc, forming essentially a cutting torch.

A gas fed cutting torch?

Tens of thousands of them in each building, all somehow surviving plane crashes and an of out of control blaze?
 
Um, no. Did you even bother to double check the citation or did you simply regurgitate what another Truther told you?



Thermite fed through a supply gas into a plasma arc, forming essentially a cutting torch.

A gas fed cutting torch?

Tens of thousands of them in each building, all somehow surviving plane crashes and an of out of control blaze?

What, you mean there weren't scores of cutting torches and tanks found in the rubble???!?:confused:
:D
 
Chris, our 'meme' is correct: a steel frame high rise has never been brought down by either thermite or nanothermite.

btw, is Dr Millette going to get the study published?
Alienentity, I just got another email from Jim Millette. His plans for semiretirement never materialized, and he is busier than ever. I gathered from that that our little dust study is on the back burner, so to speak.
 
btw, is Dr Millette going to get the study published?

Is it really worth bothering ?

Jones & Co have given up on the thermite thing long ago. Millette put the final nail in the coffin.

Mark Basile has taken over a year to try and raise $5000 :) all that's left is crack pot truthers.
 
Mark Basile has taken over a year to try and raise $5000 :) all that's left is crack pot truthers.

http://www.markbasile.org/

It looks like they have raised the money :cool:

I'm looking forward to seeing the results.

I wonder how they are going to get their independent lab to get the work peer reviewed ?

Have they got any dust yet ?
 
Last edited:
http://www.markbasile.org/

It looks like they have raised the money :cool:

I'm looking forward to seeing the results.

I wonder how they are going to get their independent lab to get the work peer reviewed ?

Have they got any dust yet ?
The problem is their proposed testing is flawed so they won't get any definitive answer, i.e. a positive identification of the material.

It's just another load of rubbish that truthers can point at and say, "look! look!".
 
The problem is their proposed testing is flawed so they won't get any definitive answer, i.e. a positive identification of the material.

Not from the "truther" point of view. It's designed to get the results they need. They already have definitive answers in their own data but choose to ignore them.

What they should do (If they wanted the truth) is submit the paper to a bunch of universities for independent review. "Truthers" really don't like the independent sort of thing so we know this will never happen. ;)
 
Last edited:
The problem is their proposed testing is flawed so they won't get any definitive answer, i.e. a positive identification of the material.

It's just another load of rubbish that truthers can point at and say, "look! look!".
Sunstealer, if you have the time, can you explain/suggest an addition to their protocol that would help them get a definitive answer? Which tests are they proposing that are NOT materials characterization tests (such as DSC) and which essential tests are not in their protocol? I see they have FTIR but not TEM. I don't know why their suggested protocol would produce junk results as you assert. I would like to take your answer to Mark and others in 9/11 Truth directly to make one last effort to try to develop a protocol that is mutually agreeable before they waste their $5000.
 
Last edited:
Sunstealer, if you have the time, can you explain/suggest an addition to their protocol that would help them get a definitive answer? Which tests are they proposing that are NOT materials characterization tests (such as DSC) and which essential tests are not in their protocol? I see they have FTIR but not TEM. I don't know why their suggested protocol would produce junk results as you assert. I would like to take your answer to Mark and others in 9/11 Truth directly to make one last effort to try to develop a protocol that is mutually agreeable before they waste their $5000.
The problem is there is no criteria for comparing the data they obtain with the data in the Harrit et al paper along with Dr Millette's.

The separation method, i.e. using a magnet and optical microscopy, will produce a sample set with more than one material for both red and gray layers. We know this because the original Harrit et al paper shows us that the red layer of chips a, b, c and d are a different material to the chip soaked in MEK, Fig 14. Similarly, further in the paper, Fig 31, 32 and 33 clearly show that the gray layer is not all the same material.

Dr Millette also obtained chips that have EDX spectra that are a match for chips a-d and Fig 14 (as previously discussed). However, Dr Millette specifies a criteria (data matching chips a, b, c and d) that must be met for chips to be tested using other definitive methods, Basile doesn't.

Basile is going to have a sample of mixed material, which in itself isn't a problem, however, it will become a problem as the additional experiments will produce different data for different chips. Unless there is a criteria for data analysis or the chips have been pre-selected for analysis then there will simply be a mass of data with no coherence. So there won't be an answer one way or the other.

It's not wise to press ahead when there isn't a proper methodology applied to the task.

The first thing to do would be to distinguish between chips using SEM microscopy and EDX of the red layer. So you might have say 3 groups;

Chips that match chips a,b,c and d
Chips that match Fig 17 (MEK soaked sample)
Chips that are none of the above.

This obviously requires accepting that the separation method is going to produce mixed material. Does Basile accept this? Then you decide on what to test and how.

At this stage a test matrix is a good idea so that you plan exactly which samples are going to be subject to which test(s). It might look something like.


---------------------GROUP-------------------TEST----------
------------- a/b/c/d MEK Other ---- ESCA FTIR DSC RESIDUAL
Chip 1 ----------X--------------------X-----X----X-----X----------
Chip 2 ----------------X--------------X-----X----------------------
Chip 3
Chip 4
Chip 5
Chip 6

So whilst it's a good idea to have a look at the chip that matches the MEK soaked one it's not imperative to perform DSC.

You can use a pre-accepted criteria just as you and Dr Millette did so as not to slow the study or introduce additional cost and confusion/changing your mind.

If it was me I'd be looking at chips that match chips a, b, c and d, the same as Millette. Then you have a reasonable comparison across all three studies. We have no idea what the MEK soaked chip looks like under SEM and we have no idea what group of chips was subjected to DSC in Harrit et al.

Once you ascertain that you have chips that match then you can perform the FTIR and more detailed SEM studies. That should be enough to determine what the material is. Then do DSC if you really must. It would simply give a known material a DSC curve.

I suspect what will happen is we'll get a hodgepodge of data with enough ambiguity in it to not be definitive.
 
Last edited:
Thanks I will pass this along. I hope they do the chips a,b,c,d as you suggested. But you, Steven Jones, Kevin Ryan, Oystein, just about everyone agrees there are two different kinds of red-grey chips. They say one is paint and the other thermitic, we say they are different kinds of paint. I would assume they would submit the chips they believe are "thermitic" for testing. Since this is a materials characterization exercise, if any of the chips conclusively show thermitic material it seems this would be the most important thing.
 
Thanks I will pass this along. I hope they do the chips a,b,c,d as you suggested. But you, Steven Jones, Kevin Ryan, Oystein, just about everyone agrees there are two different kinds of red-grey chips. They say one is paint and the other thermitic, we say they are different kinds of paint. I would assume they would submit the chips they believe are "thermitic" for testing. Since this is a materials characterization exercise, if any of the chips conclusively show thermitic material it seems this would be the most important thing.
Magic chips of thermite. Kevin Ryan, Steven Jones are nuts. Both got fired for having delusions about 911. Kevin Ryan, Steven Jones, mocking the murdered of 911 for years with lies and fantasy. What great humans, like Gage, living on lies, funded by stupid people.

Pass that on to the nuts in 911 truth, they are scum, pass that on. Tell to their faces, they are idiots. Pass that on. Can you tell them the truth? Wait, they are mentally ill, they think they are doing right by the murdered they mock with fantasy. They are mentally ill.

Don't be surprised when they find real thermite this time by seeding the dust. Last time they found dust, no data matched thermite, a big disaster. This time maybe they will fake it better. 12 years, time for nuts to make up more lies about 911. How do you debate fantasy?

I never followed the nuts on JFK, it is interesting to see nuts try to back in lies to have a fantasy to support their political biases, and failed logic.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom