WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

Using an independent lab that has no idea that the dust is from wtc or 911

So we can expect to see what other materials are in Dust, or will they tell them to focus on the red chips ?

Will they be putting dust through the DSC ? Oh hang on will it be independent if they start telling them what to do ?
 
Thanks I will pass this along. I hope they do the chips a,b,c,d as you suggested. But you, Steven Jones, Kevin Ryan, Oystein, just about everyone agrees there are two different kinds of red-grey chips. They say one is paint and the other thermitic, we say they are different kinds of paint. I would assume they would submit the chips they believe are "thermitic" for testing. Since this is a materials characterization exercise, if any of the chips conclusively show thermitic material it seems this would be the most important thing.
bolding is mine

That is it in a nut shell.

Sunstealer's response is pure obfuscation.

The revelation of any nano-thermitic material in 9/11 WTC dust chips is what is really significant.

It absolutely should not be there!

MM
 
no. your 'meme' is not 'correct' because you do not KNOW that.
That is a 'faith-based' opinion in the new-propaganda-speak of 'meme'.
It would be more accurate to say 'until 911 no steel frame high rise is known to have been brought down by either thermite or nanothermite, but that evidence yet to be contested in a Court of LAW indicates at least 3 of the WTC Towers were demolished using highly engineered thermitic materiel'.
That would be ACCURATE.
In July 1996, Komatsu-Dresser (A director being L.Paul.Bremer whose office in WTC1 was exactly where Flight 11 impacted) patented a thermite demolition device that could demolish a concrete structure at a high efficiency, while preventing a secondary problem due to noise, flying dust and chips, and the like. "Taku Murakami, US Patent 5532449 - Using plasma ARC and thermite to demolish concrete'.(Another Nineteen.pp345.19)
Such technology would easily be applied to steel frames.

I'm not sure you're using the word "Accurate" accurately.
 
bolding is mine

That is it in a nut shell.

Sunstealer's response is pure obfuscation.

The revelation of any nano-thermitic material in 9/11 WTC dust chips is what is really significant.

It absolutely should not be there!

MM
Nope, not obfuscation as you will see.

Care to give the criteria for what you or any other truther considers to be nano-thermite?

For example, what percentage by weight of (free) Aluminium would you expect to be present in thermite when analysed by SEM EDX? 0.001% 0.5% 1.0% 10% 20% 50%?

If say Mark Basile's study shows that 2% of the red material is pure Al then is the material thermite? Given that the material contains 2% Al what is the temperature this material can heat the steel up to given a complete chemical reaction and no loss in heat transfer?

You see Basile already claims that this material:

picture.php


is thermite. Yet that material contains a tiny amount of Al. Even if this were thermite it would have zero effect.

Look at Fig 7 in Harrit et al

picture.php


Do you agree that these red layers in Fig 7 are the same material that Mark Basile has in #13? Explain your answer - what criteria are you using to determine that they are the same?

I bet you won't give answers


Now go and look at Millette's data. Post the EDX spectra of the red layers that most closely match chips a,b, c and d using the same criteria that you have used to judge that Mark Basile's #13 chip's red layer is the same as the red layer in chips a-d.

You won't post any of Millette's data


You claim that Millette has the wrong chips. What criteria are you using to determine that Millette has the wrong chips?

You won't say - you can't even post Millette's data that matches the red layer of chips a-d


How will you be able to tell, using the same type of data, namely, SEM microscopy data and SEM EDX whether Mark Basile has the right chips in his new study? What criteria are you using?

Are you using the criteria that tells you that Mark Basile's #13 chip is the same as chips a-d in Harrit et al?

Or are you using the criteria that tells you that Dr Millette's data is different to chips a-d in Harrit et al?

Therefore the criteria by which you ascertain that you do indeed have the same chips as a, b, c, d in the Harrit et al paper is paramount.

Which is the point I made in responding to Chris Mohr and which went over your head.
 
"Nope, not obfuscation as you will see.

Care to give the criteria for what you or any other truther considers to be nano-thermite?.........................."

You hate to keep it simple.

Overwhelm the audience with useless facts and figures while ignoring the pertinent data.

That is what lawyers do.

Until you can provide a reasonable explanation that explains the observations made by Dr. Harrit et al, your smokescreen remains nothing but a load of horse pucky.

Mark Basile's upcoming study will shed even more light on the nano-thermite finding and no doubt you will do your best to cloud the issue with more irrelevant bs.

If Mark discovers that he was wrong about nano-thermite, I will rejoice.

I am only interested in the truth.

The NSA et al are only interested in suppressing the truth.

MM
 
... If Mark discovers that he was wrong about nano-thermite, I will rejoice.

I am only interested in the truth.

The NSA et al are only interested in suppressing the truth.

MM
No thermite was used on 911. Rejoice.

Does NSA have some thermite? What does the NSA have to do with thermite?
 
No thermite was used on 911....
The more fundamental fact is that there was no CD on 9/11.

It wouldn't matter if there had been 100 tonne stockpiles at each corner of three buildings. No CD therefore thermXte is irrelevant other than:
1) As an issue of scientific research interest. (If so why not test dust from LA or 'Frisco?); OR
2) A red herring used by truthers or trolls. And I cannot remember seeing any interest from a truther.

Sure I contributed to the study....I respect ChrisM and what he tries to do even tho' I'm dubious about the value of the process of engagement.

The issue identified at the outset being "How will you draw the line in the sand and stop chasing the purveyors of dishonest nonsense..." (And that is the PC self censored version :D )
 
Kevin Ryan's been stamping his foot and trying to get some limelight.

"How to Debunk WTC Thermite"

Steven Jones comments with a paranoid claim about being "warned" not to talk about thermite. :newlol

His family? Steven Jones family most likely wants him to appear more sane. Kevin Ryan is upset he got fired for being stupid; no lie is too stupid to fight back, and prove Kevin Ryan is dumber than a box of rocks.
 
"The more fundamental fact is that there was no CD on 9/11.

It wouldn't matter if there had been 100 tonne stockpiles [nano-thermite] at each corner of three buildings...."

The most appropriate response to that idiocy comes from Abraham Lincoln:

"It is better to remain silent and be thought a fool, than to open your mouth and remove all doubts."

MM
 
The most appropriate response to that idiocy comes from Abraham Lincoln:

"It is better to remain silent and be thought a fool, than to open your mouth and remove all doubts."

MM
Or:

"Present false science to layman and hope they believe and never question".

DGM. :D

You really never question why the scientific community pays no attention to you? :boggled:
 
You hate to keep it simple.


Mark Basile's upcoming study will shed even more light on the nano-thermite finding and no doubt you will do your best to cloud the issue with more irrelevant bs.

The NSA et al are only interested in suppressing the truth.

MM

I just hope he hand delivers those chips if ya know what I mean! maybe even photographs them beforehand to make sure the ones studied are actually his.
 
I just hope he hand delivers those chips if ya know what I mean! maybe even photographs them beforehand to make sure the ones studied are actually his.
If the study shows him wrong they will find another excuse. They already have an out in that there's no way to connect them to the original paper (harrit et al).

This new "study" has no use.
 
If the study shows him wrong they will find another excuse. They already have an out in that there's no way to connect them to the original paper (harrit et al).

This new "study" has no use.

I predict failing to discover evidence of any thermite whatsoever, they will invent an new fantabulous "nana-bananna thermite" which is undetectable to the naked eye as well as being silent yet explosive.
 
I predict failing to discover evidence of any thermite whatsoever, they will invent an new fantabulous "nana-bananna thermite" which is undetectable to the naked eye as well as being silent yet explosive.

They are either dishonest or lacking in reasoning skill.

The only 9/11 legitimate reason they are down this derail track is because they are trying to use arse about logic to prove CD.

As I said recently thermXte proves nothing - until they prove CD. Even if they prove thermXte present they are only at the starting line for proving CD.

And most of them know it.

ThermXte was only a marketing ploy when Jones was losing "brand recognition" to Gage. He lost and thermXte has not put him back as top truther.
 
I just hope he hand delivers those chips if ya know what I mean! maybe even photographs them beforehand to make sure the ones studied are actually his.

Good thinking batman.

I expect all labs around the world have been informed the money has been raised and they are on high alert looking out for red gray chips :cool:

If the photos don't match we will know for sure it was an inside job.
 
Last edited:
I predict failing to discover evidence of any thermite whatsoever, they will invent an new fantabulous "nana-bananna thermite" which is undetectable to the naked eye as well as being silent yet explosive.
I have to wonder who this study is directed to. No one paid any attention to the Harrit et al.(outside of the AE truth hobbyists)

Surely it's not the scientific community.
 
I have to wonder who this study is directed to. No one paid any attention to the Harrit et al.(outside of the AE truth hobbyists)

Surely it's not the scientific community.

Hardly.

It would not interest the scientific community as a pro-CD 9/11 related matter because there was no CD.

As a matter of pure research it could be published but at this stage the methodology is flawed as per Sunstealer's comments. So it would get roundly criticised if it got to publication with those flaws still in place. (IMO There is near zero probability that Sunstealer is wrong.)

If the flaws are corrected and it is published it would have the rare distinction of being a bit of legitimate research conducted by people motivated by CT.

Two subsets:
a) If it legitimately found "no thermXte' then it would be forgotten in the professional scene and subject to reframing/goalpost shifting in the 9/11 conspiracy discussion venues. So back here and back to square one.
b) If it legitimately found thermXte then the truth movement would claim victory - ignoring that they have not even started to address the real challenge to "prove CD". So back here we would need to lift our game a full grade. (Or two ;) )

And it would have scarcely scratched the default position - there was no CD (AKA no prima facie hypothesis ever put forward.)
 
Last edited:
Hardly.

It would not interest the scientific community as a pro-CD 9/11 related matter because there was no CD.

As a matter of pure research it could be published but at this stage the methodology is flawed as per Sunstealer's comments. So it would get roundly criticised if it got to publication with those flaws still in place. (IMO There is near zero probability that Sunstealer is wrong.)

If the flaws are corrected and it is published it would have the rare distinction of being a bit of legitimate research conducted by people motivated by CT.

Two subsets:
a) If it legitimately found "no thermXte' then it would be forgotten in the professional scene and subject to reframing/goalpost shifting in the 9/11 conspiracy discussion venues. So back here and back to square one.
b) If it legitimately found thermXte then the truth movement would claim victory - ignoring that they have not even started to address the real challenge to "prove CD". So back here we would need to lift our game a full grade. (Or two ;) )

And it would have scarcely scratched the default position - there was no CD (AKA no prima facie hypothesis ever put forward.)
So it's for a "truther" hope they might find something they still can't tie into their no hypothesis.


Good plan. :cool:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom