WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

Dr.Millette has not presented any paper formally responding to Harrit/Jones findings. He has done his tests and said what he has found which is nothing more than an expert opinion satisfying some very limited needs. Peer review demands the formal presentation of evidence for further contest. Ongoing.
Dr. Millette also has a conflict of interest in that he has represented government in other 911 dust studies previous, finding no evidence of thermitic reaction, so it hardly surprising he finds none in response to Niels Harrit.
However, observed building behaviour argues against Millettes opinion anyway. The pile ran molten steel " like we were in a foundry, like lava from a volcano" for 13 weeks. Temperatures evaporated steel. Were hot enough to create molybdenum m/spheres.That required added energy. The Szamboti paper confirms that in tower 1. Also, " collapse " is a misnomer. The wrong word entirely. initiations were sudden and eruptive and complete, assisted and at speed, pulverising to ppm 10+floors per second of complex steel framed high rise at actual free fall, in the case of WTC7., unheard of in 'never-seen-before-nor-since' building behaviour WITHOUT demolition sequencing. A 'new phenomenon' fuelled by office furnishings and secret computer algorithms invented by NIST. The buildings were designed to withstand the events, and they did. The 'normal' office furnishings fires Identified by NIST resulting from plane-strike suddenly creating sequential collapse, is an hypothesis -a theory advanced by NIST with a 'low probability of occurring'(FEMA). ANY PROPER INVESTIGATION would have established all of that 10 years ago. Advances in incendiary/explosive techniques developed by Military/industrial complex must be factored into this argument.

Millette is scientist, unbiased by definition. If he was biased it would show in his work as it does in Harrit's, Tony's, and the rest of the 9/11 TM's disingenuous arguments from authority.

The buildings weren't designed to withstand anything other than wind. The design was shown to be resistant to collapse from an aircraft impact after it was designed. No one ever ran complex fire simulations back then cause you couldn't.

It's not our fault you can't comprehend that fire is one of the most damaging/dangerous phenomena there is. Add gravity and a **** ton of potential energy and you get the WTC collapses. It's really not that hard of an idea to understand... unless you have your biases firmly planted. :D
 
Dr.Millette has not presented any paper formally responding to Harrit/Jones findings. He has done his tests and said what he has found which is nothing more than an expert opinion satisfying some very limited needs. Peer review demands the formal presentation of evidence for further contest. Ongoing.
Dr. Millette also has a conflict of interest in that he has represented government in other 911 dust studies previous, finding no evidence of thermitic reaction, so it hardly surprising he finds none in response to Niels Harrit.
However, observed building behaviour argues against Millettes opinion anyway. The pile ran molten steel " like we were in a foundry, like lava from a volcano" for 13 weeks. Temperatures evaporated steel. Were hot enough to create molybdenum m/spheres.That required added energy. The Szamboti paper confirms that in tower 1. Also, " collapse " is a misnomer. The wrong word entirely. initiations were sudden and eruptive and complete, assisted and at speed, pulverising to ppm 10+floors per second of complex steel framed high rise at actual free fall, in the case of WTC7., unheard of in 'never-seen-before-nor-since' building behaviour WITHOUT demolition sequencing. A 'new phenomenon' fuelled by office furnishings and secret computer algorithms invented by NIST. The buildings were designed to withstand the events, and they did. The 'normal' office furnishings fires Identified by NIST resulting from plane-strike suddenly creating sequential collapse, is an hypothesis -a theory advanced by NIST with a 'low probability of occurring'(FEMA). ANY PROPER INVESTIGATION would have established all of that 10 years ago. Advances in incendiary/explosive techniques developed by Military/industrial complex must be factored into this argument.

So, I take it you have scientific metallurgical analysis of that so called molten steel so Millete and other researchers can properly take it into account?
 
Dr.Millette has not presented any paper formally responding to Harrit/Jones findings. He has done his tests and said what he has found which is nothing more than an expert opinion satisfying some very limited needs. Peer review remo demands the formal presentation of evidence for further contest. Ongoing.

FIFY. "Peer review" isn't making any demands. Various people in the research community may have various opinions -- but I haven't noticed anyone other than 9/11 Truthers clamoring for Millette to make a more "formal presentation."

Dr. Millette also has a conflict of interest in that he has represented government in other 911 dust studies previous, finding no evidence of thermitic reaction, so it hardly surprising he finds none in response to Niels Harrit.

This makes no sense. Finding no evidence of X in one study doesn't create an incentive to find no evidence of X in a completely different study; it doesn't disqualify a researcher from any further investigation of X. Saying that Millette "has represented government" in previous studies is simply poisoning the well.

Millette is scientist, unbiased by definition. If he was biased it would show in his work as it does in Harrit's, Tony's, and the rest of the 9/11 TM's disingenuous arguments from authority.

Nobody is "unbiased by definition." But I agree that Millette's work looks careful and honest, whereas, say, the Harrit et al. paper has obvious serious problems.
 
Remo you are flat out wrong about Millette. I know the man well and I know he is a man of integrity. Remember the public declaration that the air was safe to breathe around Ground Zero days after 9/11? What a screaming obvious falsehood that was! And who did a study revealing a witch's bew of deadly toxins in the dust? Millette! He completely contradicted the government's false claims. And who did a study that showed dangerously high pH levels in the dust? Millette! His calculations were even used by Cate Jenkins as an honest contrast to the EPA figures which she accused the EPA of fudging in her complaint! No wonder she said Millette and his company were "highly presitigious" in her complaint against the EPA! And you have the NERVE to parrot the falsehoods being spread about him! Do your fact checking. Millette is the real McCoy, and his results were honest. I personlly challenged him repeatedly on the matter of what he would do if he found thermite, and he passed every test with flying colors. I'm fed up with you and others who try to paint Millette as anything less than the honest scientist that he is.
 
Some 911 truth followers are fooled by Jones and Harrit, they don't seem to comprehend the Jones paper conclusion is nonsense. There were no pools of melted steel. Spreading lies after 12 years of failure, the only thing 911 truth can do. The melted steel is one of the failed claims.

Jones and Harrit fool a few who can't do chemistry, and can't read a report to understand the thermite conclusion is a fantasy.

USGS found no thermite; RJ Lee found no thermite; Millette found no thermite. Thousands against Jones and Harrit, two nuts who make up lies about 911 to fool those who can't think for themselves - aka 911 truth followers.

How do you explain to kids who find 911 lies on Youtube and the Internet, Jones and Harrit are nuts on 911 issues. How do you tell them, don't be fooled by the lies of 911 truth. With 12 years of pathetic failure, the lies have become stale.
 
Last edited:
Does anyone know if Kevin Ryan has ever fully released all of his FTIR data from the 2008-2009 thermitic experiments? I am almost certain he has not. He talks about it in this latest post, but where's the full set of data from this important materials characterization test? Please correct me if I am wrong about this, anyone.
 
FTIR in isolation means nothing without an identification of the specimens throughout the analysis. They need to clearly identify what they are making a FTIR of, and more specifically how the photomicrographs match the specimens in figs. 2 and 3, the BSE in fig. 4, and the XEDS spectra in fig. 6.

Without that, we have no proof that they're really analyzing the same kind of chips and the FTIR results over unknown kinds of chips are utterly irrelevant.

In particular, this FTIR:

http://ultruth.files.wordpress.com/2013/12/ftir911.jpg

comes from chips whose description doesn't remotely match that of chips a-d in the Bentham paper:
Sample JM-12 is a 2mm multi-colored, interconnected network. It has dark bands and a light white coating.​

That's just another proof that they're showing results of completely unrelated specimens. They need to actually document what they analyze from the beginning to the end if they want to be taken seriously. There's enough proof in the data from the Bentham paper alone that they're analyzing a completely heterogeneous set of chips and taking the results as if they belonged to the same thing, which obviously they don't.

Sunstealer already documented this undeniable fact in great detail.
 
Last edited:
LOL, more comments.

If I remember correctly Niells Harrit has a large Jar of dust :D

LMFAO they are such an organised bunch ;)

IIRC, Harrit stated at the "Toronto Hearings" that they had ~5 gallons (20 liters) of dust. I watched this once, and I'm not masochistic enough to watch it twice. But anyone else....

 
Does anyone know if Kevin Ryan has ever fully released all of his FTIR data from the 2008-2009 thermitic experiments? I am almost certain he has not. He talks about it in this latest post, but where's the full set of data from this important materials characterization test? Please correct me if I am wrong about this, anyone.

Chris...do you know a Jeremy R. Hammond? He called you "demonstrably ignorant and dishonest" in his latest post.

http://www.foreignpolicyjournal.com/2013/12/09/how-to-debunk-wtc-thermite/2/
 
Chris...do you know a Jeremy R. Hammond? He called you "demonstrably ignorant and dishonest" in his latest post.

http://www.foreignpolicyjournal.com/2013/12/09/how-to-debunk-wtc-thermite/2/


Poor Hammond is nuts.
Explosions were heard around WTC 7 all morning, and two blasts can be heard just before it collapsed at free-fall acceleration, which means that all its potential energy was converted into kinetic energy, which means that there was no energy available to do the work of buckling columns as required by NIST's fire-induced collapse hypothesis.
Free-fall.

Remember, 911 truth knows
Nanothermite is, needless to say, much more energetic.
How much more? More joules, or what?
Did they put oil in their thermite, or change the properties of elements?
The office fires of the WTC would take 2,700 tons of thermite to equal the heat output. Hammond can't do math, or physics. Another failed 911 truth disciple talks woo.

Lies about chemistry and physics fool the self proclaimed "political analyst and award-winning journalist". Guess the award-winning refers to woo.

Jeremy R. Hammond the independent political analyst and award-winning journalist can't get 911 right, is all his work the same level of ignorance and fantasy? Does his other work offer the same level of stupidity as his work on 911? Why do "award-winning journalist" fall for the lies of thermite? Did they skip chemistry? Was science too hard for Jeremy? Making up lies, cutting and pasting lies is much easier than doing real work; Jeremy does the easy stuff because that is all he can do.
 
Last edited:
Jeremy and I had a falling out over his personal attacks against me, which he considers simply statements of fact. I wished him well in his research and said goodbye.
 
Jeremy and I had a falling out over his personal attacks against me, which he considers simply statements of fact. I wished him well in his research and said goodbye.
Checking his work on 911, his journalistic super stuff. He copies from other sources and cites them properly, but does no real digging. He take stuff from people who quote people, and make general statements, non-experts, people not identified.
I was thinking about doing a thread on his exploits as the award winning journalist for 911 truth, and how he is a perfect match for the movement of woo - but taking the grandkids to school won - raking leaves won, redoing the storage of junk won, etc.

Jeremy R. Hammond is not a top gun journalist when it comes to 911. Bet he can't figure out chemistry, as he copies, pastes and adds references for the woo he publishes. Sad to think if he has good stuff to present his 911 stand is tainted BS.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom