Senenmut
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Nov 7, 2008
- Messages
- 1,372
Yeah, you never did that!![]()
Yeah, you never did that!![]()
Here is the email exchange that ended with me finding out about Ivan's death (way too young, I'm about to turn 60 myself so this really gets me where I live). You can see it involves an older email exchange where I give Steven Jones one of Ivan's posts. Unfortunately, when I copied the post, Ivan's links were stripped out. I was asking Ivan about his old post and where I might find it. If anyone knows, I'd be grateful. As you can also see, Jones now knows about Ivan's and Dave's discovery or iron-rich spheres from burning paint at regular fire temperatures:
Hi Ivan,
This is an old email exchange with Steven Jones, which I have revived to let him know about you and Dave Thomas and your discovery of iron-rich spheres in the burning of regular primer paint on steel. I looked at the old email, which quotes one of your old posts extensively. Unfortunately, the links in this post no longer work. Can you connect me to the original of this?
Thanks
Chris
On Tuesday, October 8, 2013 7:43 AM, Chris Mohr wrote:
Hello again Steven,
Last spring you asked me to address the iron-rich micropheres post-ignition, and I managed to goad two scientists into buring primer paint on steel in a regular fire. Here is one result: *URL removed*. Iron-rich spheres were created, as you can see. Here is another chemist from the Czech Republic who also burned primer paint on steel and photographed spheres that look very much like the ones you showed in your thermitic paper: *URL removed*
I hope this addresses your first question.
As for one of my questions: will you please release your TEM and FTIR data from your 2009 thermitic paper? I have discussed this with Ken Jenkins. I am still hoping for the public release of this important data.
Thank you for your consideration,
Chris Mohr
From: Steven Jones
To: Chris Mohr
Cc: Jeffrey Farrer
Sent: Tuesday, January 15, 2013 7:39 AM
Subject: Re: Info on the red-grey chips and Jim Millette
Chris,
I ask you to address:
1 - the appearance of iron-rich micro-spheres after ignition of the red-gray chips we studied (not present before ignition);
2 - the independent tests of red-gray chips undertaken by Mark Basile.
Thank you,
Steven J
On Tue, Jan 15, 2013 at 8:42 AM, Chris Mohr wrote:
Hi Jeff and Steven,
I just wanted to keep you up on some things I've read re the red-grey chips. First, an email I got from Jim Millette last year; then some postings on JREF. Jim Millette is still hoping to finish his study of the chips and publish his conclusions some time this year.
Chris Mohr
I asked Jim Millette last year why he didn't do a DSC test, here is the email he sent back, verbatim and unedited:
Chris,
My assessment of the situation is that researchers performed DSC on some WTC chips and found what they thought was an exothermic reaction. They then formed a hypothesis that this might be caused by thermite materials in the dust. As is required in scientific inquires their hypothesis was testable. They set out to confirm their hypothesis by testing the chips. Their microscopical analysis showed some results that they concluded were consistent with thermite or nano-thermite. I was asked to analyze the materials to see if I could confirm or not confirm their conclusion. My initial tests showed similar findings in terms of the characteristics of the chips. However, additional testing following analytical forensic methods showed that the chips were not thermite or nano-thermite. We repeated the tests on 4 different samples from different locations and found the same result – not thermite. It seems to me that the ball is now in their court. The DSC testing can suggest a type of material based on thermal properties but cannot be used to prove the existence of thermite. If they believe that the DSC results clearly show an exothermic reaction they need to come up with another testable hypothesis as to what the chips are as they are not thermite.
Jim
From Ivan at JREF:
- About one year ago we predicted that all red-gray chips analyzed by Jim Millette will be compatible with paints (on rust flakes). This really happened, all chips contained only kaolinite instead of aluminum. Such composite cannot be thermite.
- Because of these finding we can easily predict that these red/gray chips would behave like paints in DSC device under air, i.e. they will show similar curves as in Fig. 19 in Bentham paper.
E.g., here are calorimetry curves for cured pure epoxy resin Epon 862 (left) and its mixture with 5 % of silica (right). (HRR means heat release reate):
And here is a Fig. 19 from Bentham paper:
As you can see, curves in Fig. 19 are compatible with the combustion of epoxy resin just shown. Hence, all these results, including Fig. 19, are compatible with epoxy paints
(Note: HRR for epoxy are much higher than in Fig. 19, and I don't know the reasons at the moment; one factor is anyway clear: all red-gray chips burned in Bentham paper contained gray incombustible layer of iron oxides, which substantially lowered heat released from one gram of sample.)
I've been pointed out several times here that DSC is not a good/common method for determining the heat release during thermal-oxidative degradation/combustion of polymers since, among others, the mass of sample is dramatically changing during measurements and combustible vapors/gases are(can be) blown out with the stream of air, hence they can "escape" from the measured "space" prior their ignition/combustion). This is why it is so difficult to find papers showing e.g. DSC curves of thermally decomposed epoxy resins.
Howeve r, other, more suitable methods are available.
In the paper I've just cited above, a quite new device/method was employed for examining heat release rate (and overal released heat).
A device called Microscale Combustion Calorimeter, MCC was employed for the combustion of epoxy resin composites.
A quote from here: "A very small quantity of sample (1–4 mg) is pyrolyzed under nitrogen flow at a constant heating rate (typically 1 K/s) and the released gases are sent to an oven and burnt in presence of oxygen at 900 °C. These conditions allow complete combustion. The heat release is calculated according to the Huggett’s relation (1 kg of consumpted oxygen corresponds to 13.1 MJ of released energy)."
Here are some more curves obtained using MCC: < /span>
A typical "MCC curve" for polymers (caption: Fig. 1. Typical HRR curve using MCC apparatus (example: Polyamide 6)):
Some more MCC curves for epoxy resins/their composites:
We can see that "MCC curves" can be/are similar for various polymers and they basically indicate: at temperatures around 400 degrees C, polymers are massively degraded under inert and their combustible/vaporized degradation products are then burned in air/oxygen.
Question is why DSC curves in Fig. 19 (Bentham paper) are so similar to all these MCC curves. It seems to me that just accidentally (?), the most/substantial part of flammable vapors/gases formed by the rmal-oxidative degradation of polymer binder in these red-gray chips was really combusted closely to the chips; therefore the thermal effect of these processes was recorded by DSC device, at least partially.
(Note: quite clearly, MCC device is much more suitable for measurements of thermal effects during heating of red-gray chips than DSC. This method allows in principle - among others - to determine if the thermal effect belongs to thermitic reaction, since no flammable gaseous products, which can be then ignited in air, are formed during burning of (pure) thermites. Hence, "MCC curve" for pure thermites should be basically flat.
err...tell me something I don't know.I've been a truther for some years now.
I've been a truther for some years now.
I'm signed up on ae11truth.org, but I have not followed so closely of late, so I only found out about Dr. Millette's study a couple of days ago.
It's maddening that NIST could not have done this in the first place!
It is actually much sillier than that statement makes explicit....If there's a suggestion here that an investigating organisation should thoroughly investigate every obscure theory raised by CTists then they'll never get any actual work done...

It's the Gish Gallop in action. Truthers invent new theories faster than scientific research can debunk them. Then they cite this as "evidence" of the CT.It is actually much sillier than that statement makes explicit.
To satisfy what Clive's claim implies requires NIST to predict all future claims and do the research BEFORE the CTists have even invented them.
And that goes circular in a rush.
Because as soon as NIST publishes all predicted locations of plausible and foreseeable future goal post relocations....the goal post shifters have the map of where to next move the goal posts.
A direct feed back loop heading towards infinity as fast as the "CT's can type" >>> "NIST can respond" system can cycle.
![]()
It's the Gish Gallop in action. Truthers invent new theories faster than scientific research can debunk them. Then they cite this as "evidence" of the CT.
I've been a truther for some years now.
I'm signed up on ae11truth.org, but I have not followed so closely of late, so I only found out about Dr. Millette's study a couple of days ago.
It's maddening that NIST could not have done this in the first place!
Hi CliveHill, and welcome.
One question - why would NIST investigate GZ debris for thermite or its residues? The thermite idea was invention of Prof Jones, iirc, and I seriously doubt it was on NIST's mind at the time.
If there's a suggestion here that an investigating organisation should thoroughly investigate every obscure theory raised by CTists then they'll never get any actual work done.
Space beams?
Mini-nukes?
Plasma weapons?
Conventional explosives planted during construction?
2,000,000 explosive ceiling tiles planted during renovation work?
HAARP?
Well, it is actually standard procedure!
Both in terms of NY code, to look for incendiary residues after a fire
I've been a truther for some years now.
I'm signed up on ae11truth.org, but I have not followed so closely of late, so I only found out about Dr. Millette's study a couple of days ago.
It's maddening that NIST could not have done this in the first place!
NIST said:14. Is it possible that thermite or thermate contributed to the collapse of WTC 7?
NIST has looked at the application and use of thermite and has determined that it was highly unlikely that it could have been used to sever columns in WTC 7 on Sept. 11, 2001.
CliveHill said:Harrit found elemental Aluminium, he said, and Millette just didn't... why.
911, 19 terrorists came in four planes. They did 911 with planes, not thermite.Well, it is actually standard procedure! ...
What a silly line from 911 truth. Pick up the silly lines and repeat them, don't look at the evidence, just say they did not look for themite; oops, did not look for nukes, oops, no looking for beam weapons; explosives, etc - the endless loops of woo from 911 truth. A movement which refuses to use critical thinking skills to see their claims are lies.Both in terms of NY code, to look for incendiary residues after a fire ...
Cool if 911 truth would used and understood science. 911 truth uses nonsense to fool people who can't think for themselves. People who miss the cause, the aircraft loaded with jet fuel starting the biggest office fires in history, in seconds; leading to office fires with more heat energy than 2,700 TONS of thermite. 2,700 TONS?and it terms of scientific investigation, ...
911 truth does not use evidence to support the insane thermite theory, they let a few nuts like Jones and Harrit do their thinking for them with a paper where four samples don't match the heat output of thermite. 4 failed attempts, and the conclusion is, thermite? Fraud is the scam put on by Jones and Harrit. If they believe their fraud they are crazy on 911.to look to see what is there and follow the evidence, ...
Jones made up thermite out of thin air because some stuff was red hot dripping from the WTC where all the Flight 175 had pushed office contents and aircraft parts to one corner. UPS, oxygen generators, paper, jet fuel started first cause a fire fall at the corner of them building. Four years after 911, Jones wakes up, hates war, and invents a lie to fight back. Make up a lie, put down by Millette, USGS, and RJ Lee, and the evidence.rather than attempt to prove only your own pet theory. ...
Jones ceiling tiles with thermite was an insane claim, needs no study.And no, obviously, you don't have to answer to every mad idea that a CTist puts out, ...
911 truth ignores all the evidence. All the theories are nonsense from 911 truth.but equally you don't ignore every other theory either just by tarring it with a CT brush. ...
This is where 911 truth has big problems with the concept of zero. Zero evidence is seen as "overwhelming".The thermite theory had enough evidence ...
Look at all the steel. No damage from thermite. No thermite product found. Did you look at the USGS? noand credibility to warrant a proper look. ...
Thermite is an easy one to debunk, the evidence for thermite is fake, like fantasy evidence no one in 911 truth can produce. All 911 truth theories are nonsense. Overwhelming nonsense.I've seen a lot of other theories too that don't. ...
Now you know Jones and Harrit's conclusion were fantasy.All I really wanted to say was that it was good to see an independent investigation actually happen.
Well, it is actually standard procedure!
Both in terms of NY code, to look for incendiary residues after a fire
and it terms of scientific investigation, to look to see what is there and follow the evidence, rather than attempt to prove only your own pet theory.
And no, obviously, you don't have to answer to every mad idea that a CTist puts out, but eqully you don't ignore every other theory either just by tarring it with a CT brush.
The thermite theory had enough evidence and credibility to warrant a proper look. I've seen a lot of other theories too that don't.
All I really wanted to say was that it was good to see an independent investigation actually happen.