WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

I'm afraid I don't understand.

What kind of iron has too high resistivity that can be alleviated with a carbon coating?

That's exactly the point, pgimeno!

In section 4 - "Observation of Iron-Rich Sphere Formation Upon Ignition of Chips in a Differential Scanning Calorimeter" of their paper, Harrit et al. write:

In the post-DSC residue, charred-porous material and numerous microspheres and spheroids were observed. Many of these were analyzed, and it was found that some were iron-rich, which appear shiny and silvery in the optical microscope, and some were silicon-rich, which appear transparent
or translucent when viewed with white light; see photographs taken using a Nikon microscope (Fig. 20).

The abundant iron-rich spheres are of particular interest in this study; none were observed in these particular chips prior to DSC-heating. Spheres rich in iron already demonstrate the occurrence of very high temperatures, well above the 700 °C temperature reached in the DSC, in view of the high melting point of iron and iron oxide [5]. Such high temperatures indicate that a chemical reaction occurred.

Using back-scattered electron (BSE) imaging, spheres were selected in the post-DSC residue which appeared to be rich in iron. An example is shown in Fig. (21) along with the corresponding XEDS spectrum for this sphere.

A conventional quantitative analysis routine was used to estimate the elemental contents. In the case of this iron-rich spheroid, the iron content exceeds the oxygen content by approximately a factor of two, so substantial elemental iron must be present.
This result was repeated in other iron-rich
spheroids in the post-DSC sample as well as in spots in the residue which did not form into spheres. Spheroids were observed with Fe:O ratios up to approximately 4:1. Other iron-rich spheres were found in the post-DSC residue which contained iron along with aluminum and oxygen (see Discussion
section).


Fig. 21 relates not to a chip, but to an iron-rich microsphere. Harrit et al. claim that this microsphere contains elemental iron, which is a better conductor than carbon (graphite). So the coating of the material with carbon makes no sense at all. I think that the microsphere doesn't consist of elemental iron, but of a poor conductor like Fe2O3. That's the reason why the microsphere was carbon coated.
 
... That's the reason why the microsphere was carbon coated.

I have no idea about standard practices in a SEM lab, so I am asking: Couldn't it be that they simply carbon-coated all of their samples, perhaps after they found that some had issues with static electricity? Then this particular residue specimen would have been coated before they determined its conductivity.
Or could they have coated it because some other portion of that residue, perhaps some part that is not shown in the image they eventually chose, charged up?

Perhaps this should be asked of the operatore of the SEM (best guess is Farrer, as this is a nice image)
 
I have no idea about standard practices in a SEM lab, so I am asking: Couldn't it be that they simply carbon-coated all of their samples, perhaps after they found that some had issues with static electricity? Then this particular residue specimen would have been coated before they determined its conductivity.
Or could they have coated it because some other portion of that residue, perhaps some part that is not shown in the image they eventually chose, charged up?

Perhaps this should be asked of the operatore of the SEM (best guess is Farrer, as this is a nice image)

In their methods section (2. Chip Size, Isolation, and Examination) Harrit et al. write:

For general surface analysis in the SEM, dust samples were mounted to carbon conductive tabs. The samples were left unwashed and uncoated unless otherwise specified. In order to more closely observe the characteristics of the red and gray layers, and to eliminate the possibility of surface contamination from other dust particles, several red/gray chips from each of the four WTC dust samples were fractured. The clean, cross-section surfaces were then studied by BSE imaging and XEDS.

This happens only once in their paper - Fig. 21!

Fig. (21). Spheroid found in post-DSC residue showing iron-rich sphere and the corresponding XEDS spectrum. The carbon peak must be
considered indeterminate here since this sample was flashed with a thin carbon layer in order to preclude charging under the electron beam.
 
A challenge for the Truther nation…

I would like to see Jonathan Cole use thermite to cut thru a full size mock-up of Building 7 – Column 79. That would be a W14x730 rolled steel section, stiffened with two 4” x 26” steel plates on each size. Then post the whole thing on YouTube.

Maybe Griffin and Gage can chip in some funds for the material required.

Yeah…I know…don’t hold my breath. :rolleyes:
 
Now Senemut (an MM?) has a choice to make: Either refer to Henryco - and accept that Henryco's resukt refute Harrit et al and confirm Oystein et al - or reject Henryco's results.
I actually have no problem with either :D
they did not refute harrit. henryco said they stayed red too. they did not turn pinkish and have the iron and silicon microspheres.

im not sure what you are trying to say for us to accept? I understand that henryco's chips burned there carbon but they did not react and turn pinkish or have the iron and silicon rich microspheres. that's probably why he thought they were manipulated and substituted. of coarse he only found one red gray chip out of the sample (and lost it). I wonder if finding just one red gray chip in X many grams of dust is statistically the same as jones and millettes findings?
 
A challenge for the Truther nation…

I would like to see Jonathan Cole use thermite to cut thru a full size mock-up of Building 7 – Column 79. That would be a W14x730 rolled steel section, stiffened with two 4” x 26” steel plates on each size. Then post the whole thing on YouTube.

Maybe Griffin and Gage can chip in some funds for the material required.

Yeah…I know…don’t hold my breath. :rolleyes:
Hi Mile High, You know, Cole's YouTube is actually pretty good. None of us can claim that thermate can't cut through steel beams. And the fact that thermite was actually used once, in the 1930s. to bring down a structure, means we can't say thermite as a tool of CD is impossible. Maybe it is possible. But did it happen? That's the question. Millette says no. The fact that there wasn't blinding light for almost a minute on 9/11, the paucity of aluminum oxide etc, the complete absence of any triggering devices, the compledgte absence of scalded lungs and burnt bodies from the "pyroclastic dust cloud" tell me thermite was NOT used. I give Cole credit for creating an actual experiment and not just speculating. I organized an actual experiment too, and just look at the praise I receive from MM and Senenmut and others!
 
they did not refute harrit. henryco said they stayed red too. they did not turn pinkish and have the iron and silicon microspheres.

im not sure what you are trying to say for us to accept? I understand that henryco's chips burned there carbon but they did not react and turn pinkish or have the iron and silicon rich microspheres.
Exactly! When he burned red material only then, only the carbon reacted - no iron and silicon rich microspheres! Iron oxide stayed iron oxide! Exactly! THAT refutes Harrit, that refutes you!

OR

Alternatively, you deny that henryco's red-only chips where the same material as Harrit et al's red material in the red-gray chips, then you must discard henryco's ignition tests as irrelevant.

that's probably why he thought they were manipulated and substituted.
You can agree or disagree that they were manipulated and substituted - just make up your mind:
If they were manipulated and substituted, then you must discard henryco altogether
If they were not manipulated and substituted, then you must explain, why henryco didn't get iron and silicon rich microspheres and thus refuted Harrit et al.
Your choice.

of coarse he only found one red gray chip out of the sample (and lost it).
So he did not ignite it.
In your world, that means he did not replicate Hartit et al.
Do you think henryco got results that either confirm or refute Harrit et al? Make up your mind please, but stay consistent!

I wonder if finding just one red gray chip in X many grams of dust is statistically the same as jones and millettes findings?
I wonder if henryco wasn't simpy right when he stated that he probably lost moszt of the red-gray chips when he, months earlier, drew a magnet through his samples and pulled out everything that's magnetic, but then only was inzterested in microspheres and discarded any red-gray chips that may have been there? In other words: He messed up his samples and screwed himself!


Perhaps then it is best for you to discard henryco's samples, and concentrate on Millette and Harrit et al. You are still running away from two simple questions:


Are all red-gray chips that you pull from WTC dust (e.g. Janette MacKinley's single sample) with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields two or more different materials?
and
Are chips a-d the same material? Give reasons - by what objective criteria (be specific!) did you determine that chips a-d are (or are not) all the same material?
 
Hi Mile High, You know, Cole's YouTube is actually pretty good. None of us can claim that thermate can't cut through steel beams. And the fact that thermite was actually used once, in the 1930s. to bring down a structure, means we can't say thermite as a tool of CD is impossible.
I second that.

MHM, you want to prove a negative. That's often not a smart tactic.
Especially since, as Chris points out, the negative has basically already been refuted.

And I will say this very clearly: OF COURSE IT IS POSSIBLE to use thermite to cut thru a full size mock-up of Building 7 – Column 79!!! Of course! There can be absolutely no doubt about it! It is a full, 100% certainty that you can! Just throw in any amount of thermite you can imagine, get a handful of really talented engineers, and you WILL absolutely, definitely cut that damned column. It is utterly stupid to think that it's not possible.

Maybe it is possible. But did it happen? That's the question.
This.
Concentrate on this.

Millette says no.
Does he? :confused:
Millette merely say that certain magnetically attracted paint chips don't contain thermite. That says nothing at al about how and why the towers collapsed. There still could be a zillion tons of thermite around, a zillion tons of thermite residue, and a zillion clues that thermite was used - Millette merely says that those red-gray chips ain't it.

(Unless you refer to private comments he may have made)

The relevance of Millette's refutation of Harrit et al is not so much to disprove that there was thermite (he can't do that!), but to show that a major portion of the 9/11 Truth Movement hung on to "scientific" results that were clearly FALSE, and expose their coollective impotent epistemology. That Gage, Jones, Cole, MM, Senemut, etc etc etc have been totally wrong about this for over 4 years, and weren't able to correct themselves, even after their errors were pointed out repeatedly. It goes to show that they are deafend and blinded by their delusional prejudices. That's all.

...I give Cole credit for creating an actual experiment and not just speculating. ...
Absolutely.
Cole of course also gives us clues about how much thermite might be necessary relative to the steel that need to be cut (plenty!!), and how long it might take (seconds - i.e. to long for anything "controlled"). He shows side effects of burning thermite (e.g. violent ejection of lots of bright sparks) that were NOT observed on 9/11, so I think Cole's experiments can quite helpful in refuting the thermite hypothesis.
 
Of course Oystein is right, Millette never said no thermite anywhere, he just said no thermite in the particular red-gray chips described by Harrit et al. That's science for ya. I try to be careful not to overstate the results of an experiment and appreciate the clarification when I do overstate!
 
Gentlemen...

Again...I disagree...thermite is totally ineffective in the precision cutting of steel frame members, which is required for the controlled demolition of high rise steel frame buildings.

If you try and use thermite to cut a steel member, you have no idea how long it is going to take to cut thru that member. 5 seconds, 30 seconds, 5 minutes, 10 minutes...if at all.

Thermite, who cares...we might as well be talking about peanut butter.
 
Gentlemen...

Again...I disagree...thermite is totally ineffective in the precision cutting of steel frame members, which is required for the controlled demolition of high rise steel frame buildings.

If you try and use thermite to cut a steel member, you have no idea how long it is going to take to cut thru that member. 5 seconds, 30 seconds, 5 minutes, 10 minutes...if at all.

Thermite, who cares...we might as well be talking about peanut butter.
Although true, there was nothing "controlled" about the collapses on 9/11.

I was asked a while back how it could be done. I said, a few gallons of gas and keep the FF efforts away. ;)
 
Of course Oystein is right, Millette never said no thermite anywhere, ...!
Correct. The evidence proves there was no thermite anywhere. Jones made up thermite; I know thermite is only in Jones head, and the disease of woo has spread to a few fringe nuts who can't figure out 911 given 12 years and the answers. An open book test 911 truth believers failed, but can retake, and attempt to join reality.

Millette's study. Like checking for GSR years after a knife fight murder, autopsy proved a knife did it. Fire did it on 911, and Jones made up the Big Lie, and people who can't think for themselves are fooled by woo.

The evidence of no damage to the steel at the WTC makes no thermite anywhere true. Makes Millette's study superfluous, and Jones study, delusional insanity.
 
Last edited:
Gentlemen...

Again...I disagree...thermite is totally ineffective in the precision cutting of steel frame members, which is required for the controlled demolition of high rise steel frame buildings.

If you try and use thermite to cut a steel member, you have no idea how long it is going to take to cut thru that member. 5 seconds, 30 seconds, 5 minutes, 10 minutes...if at all.

Thermite, who cares...we might as well be talking about peanut butter.

True, but no one claimed it was done efficiently (in fact, Harrit has in the past made claims about staggeringly inefficient use of thermite, when he speculated about tens of thousands of tons of thermite!)

And true too: When efficiency and budget pose no constraints on you, then there is zero doubt that clever engineers could have destroyed the towers with peanut butter. Or with midgets operating hand saws. Or with teddy bears made in China. All these ideas being as smart, and as likely, as thermite ;)

So it's of no use asking me to show by experiment that I could cut a #79 kind of column by midgets or with peanut butter. Heck, I might surprise you and actually do it. To which you'd have to retort: "So what?"

:D


So: Same with asking truthers to cut #79 with thermite. Whether they do or don't doesn't make one bit of a difference.
 
Hi Mile High, You know, Cole's YouTube is actually pretty good. None of us can claim that thermate can't cut through steel beams. And the fact that thermite was actually used once, in the 1930s. to bring down a structure, means we can't say thermite as a tool of CD is impossible. Maybe it is possible. But did it happen? That's the question.

Unquestionably, thermite can be used to bring down a building. How controlled that would be is another matter, even if the building is undamaged and not on fire. Controlled while massive fires are burning is an even bigger problem. What kind of controlled initiation system would work reliably inside a burning building? How would you prevent premature ignition from fires?

The truthers brought this on themselves with their endless chanting of the term controlled demolition, which they got from the stunned, spontaneous comments of news reporters describing the collapses of the Twin Towers.

There's no specific physical characteristic of a controlled demolition, and not all demolitions are controlled demolitions. A demolition is controlled if it's done with the intent of reducing the risk of damaging adjacent structures. If it's surrounded by other structures, the demolition team tries to get it to collapse in upon itself. If there are no structures to one side, the building may be toppled, like this one: (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XJHwPNxXhMQ)

OTOH, there are military demolitions, as when a bridge is destroyed to deny its use to opposing forces. In such cases, the structure is massively overloaded with explosives, and any damage to adjoining structures is of little concern.
 
Arguing over how much nanothermite was placed, and where, is pointless.

It ignores the basic fact that ZERO nanothermite should have existed anywhere in the WTC on 9/11, or any other day.

Based on the findings of Dr. Harrit et al, it is fair to deduce that a large volume of nanothermite existed at the WTC on 9/11.

It is 4 years later, and unless another peer-reviewed research paper shows that the findings of the 2009 Bentham paper are not replicable, the findings of the 2009 Bentham paper stand as the explanation for what really caused the level of destruction that occurred on 9/11 at the WTC.

MM
 
Arguing over how much nanothermite was placed, and where, is pointless.
True, because insane fantasies and their authors are unable to explain how, why, by who, etc. Stuck with an insane fantasy of thermite makes how impossible, and pointless. You have to say this, you have a delusion of thermite.

It ignores the basic fact that ZERO nanothermite should have existed anywhere in the WTC on 9/11, or any other day.
And there was zero damage done by thermite, thermite or super nano thermite on 911. Jones and Harrit's insane claims confirm zero thermite existed on 911. The energy in their failed paper does not match thermite and the DSC does not match. Millette can't find thermite in WTC dust, it never existed at the WTC; proved by steel with no thermite damage.

Based on the findings of Dr. Harrit et al, it is fair to deduce that a large volume of nanothermite existed at the WTC on 9/11.
Based on Jones paper, they found dust with energy more or less than thermite; not a match for thermite. Big reason Millette found no thermite.

It is 4 years later, and unless another peer-reviewed research paper shows that the findings of the 2009 Bentham paper are not replicable, the findings of the 2009 Bentham paper stand as the explanation for what really caused the level of destruction that occurred on 9/11 at the WTC.

MM
The Jones paper clearly shows energy in the dust does not match thermite. Four samples not matching the energy of thermite. A big failure only a fringe few miss, due to inability to do chemistry and critical thinking. No damage to steel on 911, makes it impossible to find dust with thermite in it from 911. The fantasy thermite was not there on 911, only in the insane mind of Dr Jones, who thermite work matches his work on Christ walking in the New World. A perfect match, two myths, and 911 truth is exposes as super-macro-gullible.
 
Arguing over how much nanothermite was placed, and where, is pointless.
...

Right.
Rather more to the point:

Are chips a-d the same material? Give reasons - by what objective criteria (be specific!) did you determine that chips a-d are (or are not) all the same material?
 
"Arguing over how much nanothermite was placed, and where, is pointless.

It ignores the basic fact that ZERO nanothermite should have existed anywhere in the WTC on 9/11, or any other day.

Based on the findings of Dr. Harrit et al, it is fair to deduce that a large volume of nanothermite existed at the WTC on 9/11.

It is 4 years later, and unless another peer-reviewed research paper shows that the findings of the 2009 Bentham paper are not replicable, the findings of the 2009 Bentham paper stand as the explanation for what really caused the level of destruction that occurred on 9/11 at the WTC."
"Right.

---

Are chips a-d the same material? Give reasons - by what objective criteria (be specific!) did you determine that chips a-d are (or are not) all the same material?
"

Maybe, if they have a measured electrical resistance of ~10Ω.

Yes, if they produce comparable heat-testing results to the a-d chips identified in the 2009 Bentham paper.

No, if they do not ignite with an exothermic spike around ~430 ̊C and are reduced to an ash residue with no iron-rich micro-spheroids.

9/11 WTC dust sample 1 which produced (a) chip samples was mailed from Jeanette McKinley directly to chemical engineer Mark Basile.

Another 9/11 WTC dust sample was sent in confidence to Mark Basile from a NYC museum.

Mark Basile said:
"And what I can confirm also is that these chips, the red layer is thermitic, it does produce molten iron and I've seen it with a number of chips that Jeanette McKinley supplied to me and I've also seen it in an independent sample which was also supplied to me from a museum in NYC which as asked to remain anonymous at this point in time.

But I have independently seen thermitic activity within two separate independent samples of WTC dust. And I plan to look at more in the next month or so and keep on going."

Mark Basile, as you know Oystein, went on to independently examine and ignite hundreds of the red/gray chips that he discovered in the 9/11 WTC dust samples.

Mark Basile said:
"...I've cut into these chips [pre-ignition test], dozens, if not hundreds of times and I have never found an iron microsphere inside.

I have never found a film of iron inside.

It is not there until the chip reacts. When the chip reacts, it produces molten iron. There is no free iron. There is iron oxide before you ignite it but there is no free iron inside these chips."

You cannot ignore the findings presented in the 2009 Bentham paper simply because Dr. Millette is of the opinion that his red chips represent a substance that would not behave in the manner found by Dr. Harrit et al.

Dr. Millette was clearly in a position to do the necessary testing. He had the time and the equipment.

I understand why he did a non-destructive test and stopped heating at 400 ̊C.

I don't understand his reluctance to allow some of his chip selections to be heated a little higher.

He can then say his chips either did or didn't ignite exothermically at ~430 ̊C.

He can then say he examined the post-ignition residue and it did or didn't contain iron-rich micro-spheroids.

This would have been very easy and of no inconvenience for him and would have strengthened his findings.

Oystein, why do you not want to know the truth about this?

I have been looking for reasonable and believable answers for years, not the constant obfuscation you offer.

MM
 
Last edited:
Maybe, if they have a measured electrical resistance of ~10Ω.

Yes, if they produce comparable heat-testing results to the a-d chips identified in the 2009 Bentham paper.

No, if they do not ignite with an exothermic spike around ~430 ̊C and are reduced to an ash residue with no iron-rich micro-spheroids.
...

Ok, now. The obvious follow-up on YOUR conditions:

1. "if they have a measured electrical resistance of ~10Ω."
MM, did they measure an electrical resistance of ~10Ω for chip a - yes, no, or you don't know?
MM, did they measure an electrical resistance of ~10Ω for chip b - yes, no, or you don't know?
MM, did they measure an electrical resistance of ~10Ω for chip c - yes, no, or you don't know?
MM, did they measure an electrical resistance of ~10Ω for chip d - yes, no, or you don't know?
(Answer in all four cases: "You don't know" or "very probably NOT")

2. "if they produce comparable heat-testing results to the a-d chips identified in the 2009 Bentham paper"
Urrrrr the Bentham paper does NOT identify "heat-testing results to the a-d chips". Do you understand that? The DSC results in Fig 19 are NOT from chips a-d! Could this be the source of your confusion?

3. "if they do not ignite with an exothermic spike around ~430 ̊C and are reduced to an ash residue with no iron-rich micro-spheroids"
Did chip a, b, c or d behave like that? Honest answer, please, MM! Be mindful that the Bentham paper does NOT contain any hint that chips a-d were subjected to any heating at all!


But your logic is obviously flawed:
What if chip a, b, c and d were tested for resistivity, or were subjected to a heating test, and the results came out the same for all four chips - i.e. all had an electrical resistance very differerent from ~10Ω, or/and all ?
Or what if chips a, b, c and d were tested in a DSC, and the results came out the same among them, but none produced microspheres?
Would you then say chips a-d are not the same?


Anyway, after having answered the above questions, please try again, and this time answer without cowardly hiding behind silly conditions:

Are chips a-d the same material?

You have exactly three options:
a) Yes
b) No
c) We can't know, since data is insufficient


We shall now see if you have the courage and honesty to commit to an answer, or if you lack the courage and honesty. No more dodging and dancing around the point, please.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom