WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

@ Senemut:

I had asked you: Are chips a-d the same material? Give reasons - by what objective criteria (be specific!) did you determine that chips a-d are (or are not) all the same material?

I asked the same question of Miragememories, and here is his answer:

Oystein said:
Are chips a-d the same material? Give reasons - by what objective criteria (be specific!) did you determine that chips a-d are (or are not) all the same material?"
Maybe, if they have a measured electrical resistance of ~10Ω.

Yes, if they produce comparable heat-testing results to the a-d chips identified in the 2009 Bentham paper.

No, if they do not ignite with an exothermic spike around ~430 ̊C and are reduced to an ash residue with no iron-rich micro-spheroids.
...

So MM says: maybe, or no, or yes... depending on certain conditions whose truth value is unknown to MM.

Senemut: Do you agree or disagree with MM, that the answer to the question whether a-d are the same material is "could be, could be not"?

If you disagree, then I see you two are in disagreement about an important aspect of the Bentham paper. I wonder then which of the two other alternatives you consider as true:
  1. Chips a-d are all the same material - you know this to be true, even though there are no results of any ignition or resistivity test done on chips a-d
  2. Chips a-d are two or more different materials - and you know this to be true, even though there are no results of any ignition or resistivity test done on chips a-d
In either case, I'd like you to tell us by which objective criteria you made your decision!
Note though: If you can't commit on 1. or 2., then you fall back to MM's "I don't know", which gets us to the remaining bit of logic:


If you agree with MM that chips a-d could be different materials, then you should finally be able to anser the other question:
Are all red-gray chips that you pull from WTC dust with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields two or more different materials?​
because you would then already have conceded that four specific red-gray chips pulled from WTC dust by Harrit et al are possibly two or more different materials.
 
Last edited:
@ Senemut:
...
If you agree with MM that chips a-d could be different materials, then you should finally be able to anser the other question:
Are all red-gray chips that you pull from WTC dust (e.g. Janette MacKinley's single sample) with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields two or more different materials?​
because you would then already have conceded that four specific red-gray chips pulled from WTC dust by Harrit et al are possibly two or more different materials.

@ Miragememories:

The same question goes to you, too, except that you are, of course, forced to agree with yourself, as you have already conceded that four specific red-gray chips pulled from WTC dust by Harrit et al are possibly two or more different materials. So the question to you is:

Since you concede that chips a-d could be different materials, then you should finally be able to anser the other question:
Are all red-gray chips that you pull from WTC dust with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields two or more different materials?​
 
Last edited:
"Maybe, if they have a measured electrical resistance of ~10Ω.

Yes, if they produce comparable heat-testing results to the a-d chips identified in the 2009 Bentham paper.

No, if they do not ignite with an exothermic spike around ~430 ̊C and are reduced to an ash residue with no iron-rich micro-spheroids..."
"Ok, now. The obvious follow-up on YOUR conditions:

"if they have a measured electrical resistance of ~10Ω."(Answer in all four cases: "You don't know" or "very probably NOT")
"

The 2009 Bentham paper identifies the red chip material as having a measured electrical resistance of ~10Ω. It is logical to assume that the red chip measured was representative of the type of red chip that the scientists based their findings.

It would make no sense for the scientists to measure only a single red chip from the hundreds or thousands they tested and then extrapolate that finding to grossly claim that this one chip was representative of all the other thermitic red chips.

From the familiarity gained from many months of microscopic observations, it is unlikely that the scientists required the resistivity test to aid them in finding red/gray chips of interest.

Based on their inclusion of the resistivity test and its results in their paper, it is my conclusion that the scientists after consistently finding that the red/gray chips had an electrical resistivity of ~10Ω, determined that they could publish this as a finding.

Dr. Jones said:
"Also, we checked the electrical resistivity of several paints – consistently orders of magnitude higher than that of the red material. We reported the resistivity of the red material in our paper, page 27 in the Journal. Millette did not report any electrical resistivity measurements. This measurement is rather easy to do so I was surprised when he failed to do this straightforward test. There is a lot of red material of various types in the WTC dust, so one must be careful to make sure it is the same as what we studied, and not some other material."

And now you are beginning to appear intoxicated?

""if they produce comparable heat-testing results to the a-d chips identified in the 2009 Bentham paper"
Urrrrr the Bentham paper does NOT identify "heat-testing results to the a-d chips". Do you understand that? The DSC results in Fig 19 are NOT from chips a-d! Could this be the source of your confusion?
"

No I do not agree with your translation.

Quibbling over synonyms is childish.

The DSC 'testing' used 'heat'.

a-d chips are red/gary chips extracted from 9/11 WTC dust taken from locations a-d.

The DSC results in Fig. 19 represent test results from red/gray chips taken from locations a-d.

The confused person is you.

"if they do not ignite with an exothermic spike around ~430 ̊C and are reduced to an ash residue with no iron-rich micro-spheroids"
Did chip a, b, c or d behave like that? Honest answer, please, MM! Be mindful that the Bentham paper does NOT contain any hint that chips a-d were subjected to any heating at all!
"

Really?

Again. The DSC results in Fig. 19 represent test results from red/gray chips taken from locations a-d.

2009 Bentham paper said:
"Red/gray chips were subjected to heating using a differential scanning calorimeter (DSC). The data shown in Fig. (19) demonstrate that the red/gray chips from different WTC samples all ignited in the range 415-435 ̊C."

2009 Bentham paper said:
"Some samples were also tested in a differential scanning calorimeter [DSC] (Netzsch DSC 404C) to measure heat flow into or out of the red/gray chips. The DSC tests were conducted with a linear heating rate of 10 ̊C per minute up to a temperature of 700 ̊C. During heating, the samples were contained in alumina pans and air was allowed to flow at 55 milliliters per minute during the heating. The plots were generated by acquiring data points at a rate of 20 points per ̊C or 200 points per minute. The equipment was calibrated to display the data in watts per gram. The plots were set to display positive heat flow out of the sample such that exothermic behaviour of the sample would yield a peak and endothermic behaviour a trough."

Until you learn how to write more coherently, further response is a waste of my time.

MM
 
Last edited:
MM:

Do you agree or disagree with the authors of the paper that chips a-d are the same material? It's not a trick or trap question.

I agree with them (see how easy that is).
 
MM - It's a very simple question but you are avoiding it like the plague.

Here is Fig 5 - it is a picture of 4 different chips. These chips are labelled chip a, chip b, chip c and chip d. You will notice there is a letter in each of the 4 pictures that corresponds to these chips a-d. The is also a caption below fig 5 which tells you that these are 4 different chips from 4 different locations.

Now look at fig 5 and answer the question,

picture.php


Are the red layers in chips a, b, c and d the same material? What is the reasoning behind your answer?

Remember that everyone except you and Senenmut agrees with Harrit et al that chips a-d are the same material.

Now look at this fig which is and EDX of the red layer for the same chips a-d.

picture.php


Are the red layers in chips a, b, c and d the same material? What is the reasoning behind your answer?

Remember that everyone except you and Senenmut agrees with Harrit et al that chips a-d are the same material.


Here is Fig 8 which shows in detail the red layers of the chips a-d. You will notice that it is labelled in exactly the same way as the other Figs with 4 individual chips labelled a, b, c and d.

picture.php


Are the red layers in chips a, b, c and d the same material? What is the reasoning behind your answer?

Remember that everyone except you and Senenmut agrees with Harrit et al that chips a-d are the same material.


A simple yes or no is all that is required. All you have to say is something like, "yes, they are the same, all the particles in chips a-d are identical as is the matrix and the EDX spectra are all the same so from that one can conclude that chips a-d are the same material".

How hard can it be? Why do you steadfastly refuse to agree with the authors of the paper, whom you support, that individual chips labelled a-d are the same material when Oystein, Millette, me and everyone else actually agree with Harrit et al?

How can you support Harrit et al when you refuse to acknowledge their simple conclusion?

What are you afraid of?
 
Last edited:
It would make no sense for the scientists to measure only a single red chip from the hundreds or thousands they tested and then extrapolate that finding to grossly claim that this one chip was representative of all the other thermitic red chips.

It would make perfect sense if those scientists believed that the red/gray chips that were extracted by a magnet were all the same.

What you fail to realize is that they had two criteria for extracting their chips.

1. Must contain a red/gray layer
2. Must be attracted to a magnet

Based on what the paper says every single chip that is extracted with the two criteria above will be thermitic.

I posted this before:

If Harrit wasn't sure of the conclusion above, please explain why he, in the video below, talks about a large jar of dust he just received, from which he takes a small sample and puts it into a plastic bag in order to give to the audience to separate with a magnet.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I51fDKsuJ_I

Listen closely at starting at 10:00 (he'll talk about iron spheres and the chips).

What does Harrit say about the red/gray chips starting at 10:21?

With a little bit of luck, you may also get a chance to see.. I don't know about this sample, I just got it yesterday morning, I don't know how much is in it, but these red, we call them chips, is what we're gonna talk about for the next 20 minutes or half hour.

So if he hasn't look or tested the sample in the video, how is he so sure that if anyone gets red/gray chips to attract to the magnet, those chips will be the same as the ones in his paper? No mention of a resisitivity test. No mention that SOME of the red/gray chips could be paint or another substance.

All of them, Harrit and his cronies, believe that any red/gray chip extracted with a magnet from ANY WTC dust, will be thermitic as proven in the video above.

That's why Harrit/Jones were very cryptic in their email answer to me and why they won't answer any more. Jones stuck his foot in his mouth with his "resisitivty test" and "more than one type of red chip" statement. It contradicts the paper's conclusion and what Harrit believes.

Your mincing words while trying to defend that farce of a paper is pathetic.
 
The 2009 Bentham paper identifies the red chip material as having a measured electrical resistance of ~10Ω. It is logical to assume that the red chip measured was representative of the type of red chip that the scientists based their findings.

1. Just a brief information: Harrit et al. didn't measure an electrical resistance of 10Ω, they measured an electrical resistivity of 10Ωm!

2. Your conclusion that the measured electrical resistivity is representative of the red/gray chips is not valid. This would only be true, if the chips are of the same chemical composition.

3. Harrit et al. only confirmed that the measured electrical resistivity doesn't match the resistivity of some selected paints, they did not confirm that their result matches the resistivity of nanothermite. As a chemist Harrit should know that a positiv match (and proper methods!) is necessary to confirm the composition of a compound/composite.

It would make no sense for the scientists to measure only a single red chip from the hundreds or thousands they tested and then extrapolate that finding to grossly claim that this one chip was representative of all the other thermitic red chips.

But Harrit et al. did so! It is really nice that you found a serious drawback of Harrit's method on your own! :D

The DSC results in Fig. 19 represent test results from red/gray chips taken from locations a-d.

That's wrong, the DSC results represent samples from three of the four locations as two samples from Ms. MacKinlay and none of Delessio/Breidenbach were used. Get your facts straight!
 
The 2009 Bentham paper identifies the red chip material as having a measured electrical resistance of ~10Ω. It is logical to assume that the red chip measured was representative of the type of red chip that the scientists based their findings.

It would make no sense for the scientists to measure only a single red chip from the hundreds or thousands they tested and then extrapolate that finding to grossly claim that this one chip was representative of all the other thermitic red chips.

From the familiarity gained from many months of microscopic observations, it is unlikely that the scientists required the resistivity test to aid them in finding red/gray chips of interest.

Based on their inclusion of the resistivity test and its results in their paper, it is my conclusion that the scientists after consistently finding that the red/gray chips had an electrical resistivity of ~10Ω, determined that they could publish this as a finding.
The above is just a story based on complete conjecture. The paper only lists one chip measurement. That measurement can't be extrapolated, it is a single data point. I can make up a story too: they left out anything in the paper that contradicts their foregone conclusion. It fits just as well as the one above.
 
The 2009 Bentham paper identifies the red chip material as having a measured electrical resistance of ~10Ω. It is logical to assume that the red chip measured was representative of the type of red chip that the scientists based their findings.

It would make no sense for the scientists to measure only a single red chip from the hundreds or thousands they tested and then extrapolate that finding to grossly claim that this one chip was representative of all the other thermitic red chips.

From the familiarity gained from many months of microscopic observations, it is unlikely that the scientists required the resistivity test to aid them in finding red/gray chips of interest.

Based on their inclusion of the resistivity test and its results in their paper, it is my conclusion that the scientists after consistently finding that the red/gray chips had an electrical resistivity of ~10Ω, determined that they could publish this as a finding.



And now you are beginning to appear intoxicated?

Can you show me one instance in the Bentham paper where they say that they found ANY red/gray chips that they tested to be anything other than thermtic? You keep saying that there were more than one type of red/gray chip according to statements made by the authors AFTER the paper was published or that the needed to do the resistivity test to make sure they HAD the right chips.

Complete idiocy.

The contents of the paper CLEARLY try to conclude:

ANY RED/GRAY LAYERED CHIP EXTRACTED FROM A PILE OF WTC DUST WITH A MAGNET IS THERMITIC.

Excerpts from the Bentham paper:

1.
page 7 said:
Abstract: We have discovered distinctive red/gray chips in all the samples we have studied of the dust produced by the
destruction of the World Trade Center. Examination of four of these samples, collected from separate sites, is reported in this paper. These red/gray chips show marked similarities in all four samples.
No mention, implied or otherwise, of "different types of red/gray chips".

2.
page 8 said:
It was learned that a number of people had saved samples
of the copious, dense dust, which spread and settled across Manhattan. Several of these people sent portions of their samples to members of this research group. This paper discusses four separate dust samples collected on or shortly after 9/11/2001. Each sample was found to contain red/gray chips.
No mention, implied or otherwise, of "different types of red/gray chips".

3.
page 9 said:
For clarification, the dust samples collected and sent to
the authors by Ms. Janette MacKinlay will be sample 1; the sample collected by Mr. Frank Delassio, or the Delassio/Breidenbach sample, will be sample 2; the sample collected by Mr. Jody Intermont will be sample 3; and the sample collected by Mr. Stephen White will be sample 4. The red/gray chips are attracted by a magnet, which facilitates collection and separation of the chips from the bulk of the dust. A small permanent magnet in its own plastic bag was used to attract and collect the chips from dust samples. The chips are typically small but readily discernible by eye due to their distinctive color. They are of variable size with major dimensions of roughly 0.2 to 3 mm. Thicknesses vary from roughly 10 to 100 microns for each layer (red and gray). Samples of WTC dust from these and other collectors have been sent directly from collectors to various scientists (including some not on this research team) who have also found such red/gray chips in the dust from the World Trade Center destruction.
No mention, implied or otherwise of a resitivity test OR "different types of red/gray chips".

4.
page 10 said:
Some samples were also tested in a differential scanning
calorimeter (Netzsch DSC 404C) to measure heat flow into
or out of the red/gray chips.
No mention, implied or otherwise, of "different types of red/gray chips".

5.
page 10 said:
Red/gray chips were found in all of the dust samples collected. An analysis of the chips was performed to assess the similarity of the chips and to determine the chemistry and materials that make up the chips.
No mention, implied or otherwise, of "different types of red/gray chips".

6.
page 11 said:
These four cross sections are representative of all the red/gray chips studied from the dust samples. The BSE images illustrate the finding that all of the red layers studied contained small bright particles or grains characterized by a high average atomic number.
No mention, implied or otherwise, of "different types of red/gray chips".

7.
page 19 said:
Red/gray chips were subjected to heating using a differential scanning calorimeter (DSC).
No mention, implied or otherwise, of "different types of red/gray chips".

8.
page 22 said:
Several paint samples were also tested and in each case, the paint sample was immediately reduced to fragile ashes by the hot flame. This was not the case, however, with any of the red/gray chips from the World Trade Center dust.
No mention, implied or otherwise, of "different types of red/gray chips". Not to mention NONE of their extracted chips acted like paint.

9.
page 25 said:
In addition to the red/gray chips, many small spheres
have been found by our group in the WTC dust.
No mention, implied or otherwise, of "different types of red/gray chips".

10.
page 27 said:
We suggest that the organic material in evidence in the red/gray chips is also highly energetic, most likely producing gas to provide explosive pressure.
No mention, implied or otherwise, of "different types of red/gray chips".

11.
page 29 said:
Based on these observations, we conclude that the red
layer of the red/gray chips we have discovered in the WTC dust
is active, unreacted thermitic material, incorporating nanotechnology, and is a highly energetic pyrotechnic or explosive material.
No mention, implied or otherwise, of "different types of red/gray chips".

These are just a few instances in the paper MM. The reference to "red/gray" chips and which ones they are in directly related to the extraction method which used "a visible red/gray layer" and "attraction to a magnet". Any discussion stating that they meant otherwise is ridiculous. As I posted above, even Harrit, who hadn't tested the sample just received that was mentioned in the video, gives his audience a small plastic bag of dust and a magnet and askes them to play with it to extract the chips that they will be discussing.

Sounds like a man sure of his findings.

So I challenge you or anyone else who defends that paper to find ONE SINGLE sentence within it that shows they believe/believed that any red/gray chip attracted to a magnet was anything BUT thermitic.
 
The 2009 Bentham paper identifies the red chip material as having a measured electrical resistance of ~10Ω. It is logical to assume that the red chip measured was representative of the type of red chip that the scientists based their findings.

...
MM
LOL, is it a resistor they found crushed? Do you realize this is proof you have no clue what you are doing? As it stands, you have posted proof Jones and Harrit are nut cases doing silly work which fools gullible people. And you can't tell me why your post is pure hogwash as it stands.

You want Millette to do tests not needed to identify what he found? His finding are clear, Jones and Harrit's purpose was support their fantasy they made unjustified claims. They fooled you because you want a fantasy for 911, not the truth, not reality. Carry on, the resistance stuff is comedy.
 
The 2009 Bentham paper identifies the red chip material as having a measured electrical resistance of ~10Ω. It is logical to assume that the red chip measured was representative of the type of red chip that the scientists based their findings.
No.
The expression "the red chip material" assumes already that there is only one "red chip material" - i.o.w. that all red-gray chips pulled from WTC dust with a magnet are the same material.
Is that what you are saying?
Then you are assuming, as your premise, the conclusion. I asked you:
Are chips a-d the same material?
And if you assume that "the red chip material" - singular! - pertains to any red-gray chip that can be found in the four dust samples, then you would have, without recourse to any conditions ("...if...") answered my question as YES, chips a-d are the same material.

You didn't. Hence there is something wrong with your reasoning. You are assuming the conclusion. See your mistake?

It would make no sense for the scientists to measure only a single red chip from the hundreds or thousands they tested and then extrapolate that finding to grossly claim that this one chip was representative of all the other thermitic red chips.
Hahaha :D
Yes, exactly: "It would make no sense for the scientists to measure only a single red chip"
So: According to the Bentham paper, how many red chips did they measure for resistivity?
Answer: ONE!
It doesn't make sense, right? You just said so! :D

Hahaha again! :D
What?!?! "The hundreds or thousands they tested"??
Hahahahaha! :D :D
"Hundreds" (plural) means: At least 200.
Page 23 of the Bentham paper:
"In the sample provided by collector J. MacKinlay the fraction of red/gray chips was roughly estimated. Fifteen small chips having a total mass of 1.74 mg were extracted from a 1.6 g sample of dust from which readily identifiable glass and concrete fragments had been removed by hand. Thus the fraction of red/gray chips was approximately 0.1% by weight in the separated dust Another sampling showed 69 small red/gray chips in a 4.9 g sample of separated dust."​
So there is talk of 84 individual chips from 2 samples. That were counted. There is no mention that they all have been analysed.

Hundreds, MM? What place where the sun don't shine did you pull that crap from? :D Do you think you can fool us? Do you think you can make up lies and get away with them?

Please retract explicitly!

From the familiarity gained from many months of microscopic observations, it is unlikely that the scientists required the resistivity test to aid them in finding red/gray chips of interest.
Good. SO I take note for future reference:
According to you, MM, resistivity is NOT an objective criterion required to identify the "correct" chips.
Reason: Harrit et al don't require it.
Very good.
So, MM, what do you think?
Did Harrit et al measure the resistivity of chip a?
Did Harrit et al measure the resistivity of chip b?
Did Harrit et al measure the resistivity of chip c?
Did Harrit et al measure the resistivity of chip d?
Yes? No? Don't know?
If they didn't do it, why would a replication be required to do it?

You make something of the "familiarity gained from many months of microscopic observations". What does this "familiarity" mean, in a science lab, and as far as scientists trying to replicate the study are concerned?
Did it bestow Harrit et al with karma?
Did it cause the Gods to lead them magically to the right chips and keep them safe from the wrong ones?
Or did they identify any objective criteria by which to determine whether two chips are the right one - criteria that, as you just admitted, do not include resistivity?
If you decide for the latter: Please list, in full, the objective scientific criteria that would enable Harrit et al after months of getting familiar with the chips to determine if chips a-d are the same material or not!

Based on their inclusion of the resistivity test and its results in their paper, it is my conclusion that the scientists after consistently finding that the red/gray chips had an electrical resistivity of ~10Ω, determined that they could publish this as a finding.
What, exactly, do you mean by "the red/gray chips"?
All red-gray chips in the world?
All red-gray chips that one can pull from WTC dust with a magnet?
All red-gray chips that one can pull from Harrit et al's four dust samples with a magnet - but that not from any other dust samples?
Or all red-gray chips that holy karma or the grace of Gods puts in the hands of Harrit et al (and no other scientists)?
Or do you have any objective criteria to determine those red/gray chips with a resistivity of 10 ohm-m, short of measuring their resistivity?
Please be specific, we need to know what hiffen constraints you place on the term "the red/gray chips"

Also, since they did show lots and lots and lots of data from chips a-d on pages 10-16 (7 full pages with detailed data), AND included resistivity testing on ONE (otherwise unidentified) chip on page 27, wouldn't a smart team of internetional researchers have thrown in just one line either on page 27 or on page 16, just mentioning that they measured 10 ohm-m for chip a, for chip b, chip c and chip d - if they had done that? So doesn't it stand to reason that, with utmost certainty, they did NOT measure the resistivity of chips a-d?

And now you are beginning to appear intoxicated?
Just because you don't understand the Bentham paper? No.

No I do not agree with your translation.

Quibbling over synonyms is childish.

The DSC 'testing' used 'heat'.
I am not quibbling. Not sure what you even mean. Probably something irrelevant.

a-d chips are red/gary chips extracted from 9/11 WTC dust taken from locations a-d.
You have to understand something here, which you so far don't:
The letters a-d denote for specimens, four individual chips. For example, chip a, which is a small thing, a particle, that you can hold in your palm (which is not a location; which is not a dust sample), is shown in a microphotograph in Fig. 2a. A part of exact same particle, chip a, is shown as BSE image in Fig 5a. Still the very same specimen, the very same thing, chip a, has its gray-layer EDS presented in Figure 6a, its red-layer EDS in Fig. 7a. A higher resolution BSE image of the very same chip a is seen in Fig. 8a.
Likewise, there is another particle, an individual chip, named bhip b, and the very same, identical particle is presented in Figures 2b, 5b, 6b, 7b and 8b.
Etc.

So to repeat: "a" denotes a single, particular chip. It does not denote a dust sample. It does not denote a location.

Chip a was extracted, using a magnet and the visual clue of being a "red-gray chip", from a dust sample, specifically Sample 1. Sample 1 is identified in Fig. 1 as the the dust sample from, Janette MacKinley, collected in her apartment on Liberty street.
So "Sample 1" is the name, or label, of a collection (several grams) of dust.
Likewise, "Sample 2" is the name, or label, of a collection (several grams perhaps) of dust collected from a handrail of the Brooklyn Bridge and made available to Jones by two gentlemen named Delessio and Breidenbach. Chip b was extracted from this Dust sample, so indeed chip b can be traced to a handrail of the Brooklyn Bridge.
Likewise, "Sample 3" is the name, or label, of a collection (several grams perhaps) of dust collected from 16 Hudson St and made available to Jones by Jody Intermont. Chip c comes from that sample 3.
Likewise, "Sample 4" is the name, or label, of a collection (several grams perhaps) of dust collected from 1 Hudson St and made available to Jones by Stephen White. Chip d comes from that sample 4.

Here, a table, for your convenience:
Chip|Sample #|Collector|Location
a|1|MacKinley|Liberty St
b|2|Delessio/Breidenbach|Brooklyn Bridge
c|3|Intermont|16 Hudson St
d|4|White|1 Hudson St
Each dust sample consists of probably millions of dust particles, and the dust particles represent a vast number of different materials. For example: Several phases of crushed concrete; gypsum; ashes; skin flakes; mineral fibers; organic fibers; pollen; blue paint flakes; white paint flakes; red paint flakes; etc etc etc.

So when you have two particles from, say, Sample 1, this of course does not mean that both are the same material. One could be a skin flake, one a blue paint chip. Clearly, those are different materials. Even when you have two particles of the same kind, say two blue paint chips, they could easily be two different blue colours: One perhaps epoxy based with mineral pigments from a steel cabinet, another oil based with natural pigments from a painting. So it would be possible to find two red chips in the same sample, or even two red-gray chips, and they could be two different materials, right?

I am saying this to alert you to the simple fact that, because two particles, or two magnetic red-gray particles, aren't the same because they come from the same dust sample, or location, nor do you know they are different materials if they come from two different locations.

So knowing the location doesn't really help in determining whether two chips are the same, or two different, materials, right?

The DSC results in Fig. 19 represent test results from red/gray chips taken from locations a-d.

The confused person is you.
No. The confused person is YOU.

The DSC results in Fig 19 represent test results from THREE locations, not four. The four curves, representing four chips, have the colors blue, red, black and green. Let me call the chips (the individual particles!) therefore "blue", "red", "black" and "green". In the top left corner of Fig. 19, find the description of the origin of these four specimens:
Chip|Identification in Fig. 19|Location|Sample
blue|MacKinley 1|Liberty St|1
red|MacKinley 2|Liberty St|1
black|Intermont|16 Hudson St|3
green|White|1 Hudson St|4

You meant to say that the four specimen wasted in the DSC for Fig 19 came from Samples 1, 2, 3 and 4 - just like chips a-d did.
But that is not true!
They came from Samples 1, 3 and 4 only!

This tells you that the two sets of four chips, a-d and blue|red|black|green, are not the same sets.

In fact, it is exceedingly likely that the sets are totally disjoint: Chip a <> blue, chip a <> red, chip b from Sample 2 definitely can't be one of the DSC chips as none from Sample 2 appears there; chip c <> black; and chip d <> green.

Really?

Again. The DSC results in Fig. 19 represent test results from red/gray chips taken from locations a-d.
As you just saw, you are simply confused and mistaken.
Those are different chips - and it doesn't matter at all which locations the DSC chips came from, as any two chips from the same location can very well be different materials.

So you can't use the DSC results in Fig 19 to argue whether or not chips a-d are or aren't the same material.

Until you learn how to write more coherently, further response is a waste of my time.

Since you now know that you can't use the DSC data to answer questions about the identity of chips a-d, and you already admitted that Harrit et al would not need to use resistivity to determine if chips a-d are the same material, I am afraid that you still haven't given a coherent and useful (useful = provides any interested scientist with objective information to replicate the study) answer to my question - please try again:


Are chips a-d the same material?
Give reasons - by what objective criteria (be specific!) did you determine that chips a-d are (or are not) all the same material?
 
From the familiarity gained from many months of microscopic observations, it is unlikely that the scientists required the resistivity test to aid them in finding red/gray chips of interest.

:eye-poppi

WOW! Are you backpedaling or what?!

Therefore, unless you can persuade one of the authors to state otherwise, it can only be concluded that ALL the chips used, were from batches that had passed the Resistivity test.

Once it was discovered how low the electrical resistance was in the red layers of chips that later ignited in the DSC, it made no sense for the researchers to abandon this useful knowledge and continue selecting magnetically-isolated chips using a 'hit or miss' method.

It also helps emphasize the fact that after being isolated with a magnet, there are so many red/gray chips that using a resistivity test becomes a valuable time saver.


Something that caught my eye MM.

The reported Resistivity Test values between thermitic red-layered chips, and the paint red-layered chips, were 10 to 10,000,000,000.

Is the above a deliberate lie? Can you show me in the paper where they tested "THE paint red-layered chips"? Because all I see is that they tested "OTHER" paint/paint chips outside their dust pile samples.
 
The above is just a story based on complete conjecture. The paper only lists one chip measurement. That measurement can't be extrapolated, it is a single data point. I can make up a story too: they left out anything in the paper that contradicts their foregone conclusion. It fits just as well as the one above.
Actually that one counts with some supporting evidence. Harrit said they tested several chips at random, yet they report only on one and they don't specify whether it's representative. And the SE images show a material of high resistivity, not low, so it's thinkable that many chips had a high resistivity that wasn't reported.
 
Last edited:
Whoops!

The Truther Guide now requires MM to either:

1. Drop all this detailed discussion and just say "This is why we need a new investigation"

or

2. Disappear for 3 months then return spouting the exact same nonsense, as if nothing had happened.
 
the paper is not incorrect. they showed what the dsc produced. not one mention of any chips not reacting to produce iron and silicon rich microspheres.



let millette prove them wrong then. either him or another serious researcher can follow the scientific method and replicate the experiemnts. if millettes do not produce iron and silicon rich microspheres, then by george, you got your answer!

I'll post this here so as to not be off topic in the other thread.

how many chips did NOT produce iron and silicon rich microspheres from the dsc experiment?

did millette follow the scientific method and replicate experiments to produce iron and silicon rich microspheres so we can say they are the same material?

Did Harrit and his group produce iron and silicon rich microspheres from every single chip tested in the Bentham paper to make sure they had the same material?
 
@ Senemut:

I had asked you: Are chips a-d the same material? Give reasons - by what objective criteria (be specific!) did you determine that chips a-d are (or are not) all the same material?

Senemut: Do you agree or disagree with MM, that the answer to the question whether a-d are the same material is "could be, could be not"?

I think they are and they lay out their case in the paper. they did not once say that one or two or three chips did not react in the dsc to procuce iron and silicon rich microspheres.

If you disagree, then I see you two are in disagreement about an important aspect of the Bentham paper. I wonder then which of the two other alternatives you consider as true:
  1. Chips a-d are all the same material - you know this to be true, even though there are no results of any ignition or resistivity test done on chips a-d

  1. from the thermite paper:
    "the data shown if fig 19 demonstrate that the red gray chips from different wtc samples all ignited in the rage of 415-435C."

    If you agree with MM that chips a-d could be different materials, then you should finally be able to anser the other question:
    Are all red-gray chips that you pull from WTC dust with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields two or more different materials?​
    because you would then already have conceded that four specific red-gray chips pulled from WTC dust by Harrit et al are possibly two or more different materials.
    mm knows that millette needs to replicate to produce or not produce iron and silicon rich microspheres. we agree on that wholeheartedly I believe.

    I agree with my statement:
    Are all red-gray chips from each sample that you pull from WTC dust with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields the same material in some samples, altogether different material in some samples, or two or more different materials in some samples?
 
Oystein said:
Are chips a-d the same material? Give reasons - by what objective criteria (be specific!) did you determine that chips a-d are (or are not) all the same material?
I think they are and they lay out their case in the paper. they did not once say that one or two or three chips did not react in the dsc to procuce iron and silicon rich microspheres.
Fine, so you, finally, answer the first part of the question:
Question: Are chips a-d the same material?
Answer Senemut: Yes
(And with this, you DISAGREE with MM)

But you don't really answer the second part:
Question: Give reasons - by what objective criteria (be specific!) did you determine that chips a-d are (or are not) all the same material?
You talk about DSC, but we don't know that chips a-d were at all tested in the DSC - or do we? No, we don't.

Please answer the question:
By what objective criteria (be specific!) did you determine that chips a-d are all the same material?

from the thermite paper:
"the data shown if fig 19 demonstrate that the red gray chips from different wtc samples all ignited in the rage of 415-435C."
But Fig 19 does NOT show results for chips a-d!
I was talking about chips a-d. So please answer the question that I asked about chips a-d, and please avoid talking about chips that are not chips a-d. So do NOT talk about the chips from the DSC in Fig. 19:

Are you saying that chips a-d are all the same material - you know this to be true, even though there are no results of any ignition or resistivity test done on chips a-d?

Note the part that I put in italics, and please acknowledge in your own words that you understand the part in marked in italic font - that's two facts:
1. We don't know if chips a-d were put in the DSC, and have NO results of any ignition (e.g. DSC) test for chips a-d
2. We don't know of chips a-d were tested for resistivity and have NO results of reistivity measurements for chips a-d

mm knows that millette needs to replicate to produce or not produce iron and silicon rich microspheres. we agree on that wholeheartedly I believe.
I wasn't talking about this.

MM is of the opinion that we can't decide if chips a-d are the same material.
You disagree: You think chips a-d are the same material.
So you disagree with MM on the topic that we are discussing here. Period.

I agree with my statement:
Are all red-gray chips from each sample that you pull from WTC dust with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields the same material in some samples, altogether different material in some samples, or two or more different materials in some samples?
This is not a statement. That symbol at the end should give you a clue that this is a question. Do you understand the difference between questions and statements, or do you need to go back to primary school?

It is not the question I asked. Why are you so afraid of my question?


Please answer the question that I asked:

Are all red-gray chips that you pull from WTC dust with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields two or more different materials?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom