The 2009 Bentham paper identifies the red chip material as having a measured electrical resistance of ~10Ω. It is logical to assume that the red chip measured was representative of the type of red chip that the scientists based their findings.
No.
The expression "the red chip material" assumes already that there is only
one "red chip material" - i.o.w. that all red-gray chips pulled from WTC dust with a magnet are the same material.
Is that what you are saying?
Then you are assuming, as your premise, the conclusion. I asked you:
Are chips a-d the same material?
And if you assume that "the red chip material" - singular! - pertains to any red-gray chip that can be found in the four dust samples, then you would have, without recourse to any conditions ("...if...") answered my question as YES, chips a-d are the same material.
You didn't. Hence there is something wrong with your reasoning. You are assuming the conclusion. See your mistake?
It would make no sense for the scientists to measure only a single red chip from the hundreds or thousands they tested and then extrapolate that finding to grossly claim that this one chip was representative of all the other thermitic red chips.
Hahaha

Yes, exactly: "It would make no sense for the scientists to measure only a single red chip"
So: According to the Bentham paper, how many red chips did they measure for resistivity?
Answer: ONE!
It doesn't make sense, right? You just said so!
Hahaha again!

What?!?! "The hundreds or thousands they tested"??
Hahahahaha!

"Hundreds" (plural) means: At least 200.
Page 23 of the Bentham paper:
"In the sample provided by collector J. MacKinlay the fraction of red/gray chips was roughly estimated. Fifteen small chips having a total mass of 1.74 mg were extracted from a 1.6 g sample of dust from which readily identifiable glass and concrete fragments had been removed by hand. Thus the fraction of red/gray chips was approximately 0.1% by weight in the separated dust Another sampling showed 69 small red/gray chips in a 4.9 g sample of separated dust."
So there is talk of 84 individual chips from 2 samples. That were counted. There is no mention that they all have been analysed.
Hundreds, MM? What place where the sun don't shine did you pull that crap from?

Do you think you can fool us? Do you think you can make up lies and get away with them?
Please retract explicitly!
From the familiarity gained from many months of microscopic observations, it is unlikely that the scientists required the resistivity test to aid them in finding red/gray chips of interest.
Good. SO I take note for future reference:
According to you, MM, resistivity is NOT an objective criterion required to identify the "correct" chips.
Reason: Harrit et al don't require it.
Very good.
So, MM, what do you think?
Did Harrit et al measure the resistivity of chip a?
Did Harrit et al measure the resistivity of chip b?
Did Harrit et al measure the resistivity of chip c?
Did Harrit et al measure the resistivity of chip d?
Yes? No? Don't know?
If they didn't do it, why would a replication be required to do it?
You make something of the "familiarity gained from many months of microscopic observations". What does this "familiarity" mean, in a science lab, and as far as scientists trying to replicate the study are concerned?
Did it bestow Harrit et al with karma?
Did it cause the Gods to lead them magically to the right chips and keep them safe from the wrong ones?
Or did they identify any objective criteria by which to determine whether two chips are the right one - criteria that, as you just admitted,
do not include resistivity?
If you decide for the latter:
Please list, in full, the objective scientific criteria that would enable Harrit et al after months of getting familiar with the chips
to determine if chips a-d are the same material or not!
Based on their inclusion of the resistivity test and its results in their paper, it is my conclusion that the scientists after consistently finding that the red/gray chips had an electrical resistivity of ~10Ω, determined that they could publish this as a finding.
What, exactly, do you mean by "the red/gray chips"?
All red-gray chips in the world?
All red-gray chips that one can pull from WTC dust with a magnet?
All red-gray chips that one can pull from Harrit et al's four dust samples with a magnet - but that not from any other dust samples?
Or all red-gray chips that holy karma or the grace of Gods puts in the hands of Harrit et al (and no other scientists)?
Or do you have any objective criteria to determine those red/gray chips with a resistivity of 10 ohm-m, short of measuring their resistivity?
Please be specific, we need to know what hiffen constraints you place on the term "the red/gray chips"
Also, since they did show lots and lots and lots of data from chips a-d on pages 10-16 (7 full pages with detailed data), AND included resistivity testing on ONE (otherwise unidentified) chip on page 27, wouldn't a smart team of internetional researchers have thrown in just one line either on page 27 or on page 16, just mentioning that they measured 10 ohm-m for chip a, for chip b, chip c and chip d - if they had done that? So doesn't it stand to reason that, with utmost certainty, they did NOT measure the resistivity of chips a-d?
And now you are beginning to appear intoxicated?
Just because you don't understand the Bentham paper? No.
No I do not agree with your translation.
Quibbling over synonyms is childish.
The DSC 'testing' used 'heat'.
I am not quibbling. Not sure what you even mean. Probably something irrelevant.
a-d chips are red/gary chips extracted from 9/11 WTC dust taken from locations a-d.
You have to understand something here, which you so far don't:
The letters a-d denote for specimens, four individual chips. For example, chip a, which is a small thing, a particle, that you can hold in your palm (which is not a location; which is not a dust sample), is shown in a microphotograph in Fig. 2a. A part of exact same particle, chip a, is shown as BSE image in Fig 5a. Still the very same specimen, the very same thing, chip a, has its gray-layer EDS presented in Figure 6a, its red-layer EDS in Fig. 7a. A higher resolution BSE image of the very same chip a is seen in Fig. 8a.
Likewise, there is another particle, an individual chip, named bhip b, and the very same, identical particle is presented in Figures 2b, 5b, 6b, 7b and 8b.
Etc.
So to repeat: "a" denotes a single, particular chip. It does not denote a dust sample. It does not denote a location.
Chip a was extracted, using a magnet and the visual clue of being a "red-gray chip", from a dust sample, specifically Sample 1. Sample 1 is identified in Fig. 1 as the the dust sample from, Janette MacKinley, collected in her apartment on Liberty street.
So "Sample 1" is the name, or label, of a collection (several grams) of
dust.
Likewise, "Sample 2" is the name, or label, of a collection (several grams perhaps) of
dust collected from a handrail of the Brooklyn Bridge and made available to Jones by two gentlemen named Delessio and Breidenbach. Chip b was extracted from this Dust sample, so indeed chip b can be traced to a handrail of the Brooklyn Bridge.
Likewise, "Sample 3" is the name, or label, of a collection (several grams perhaps) of
dust collected from 16 Hudson St and made available to Jones by Jody Intermont. Chip c comes from that sample 3.
Likewise, "Sample 4" is the name, or label, of a collection (several grams perhaps) of
dust collected from 1 Hudson St and made available to Jones by Stephen White. Chip d comes from that sample 4.
Here, a table, for your convenience:
Chip|Sample #|Collector|Location
a|1|MacKinley|Liberty St
b|2|Delessio/Breidenbach|Brooklyn Bridge
c|3|Intermont|16 Hudson St
d|4|White|1 Hudson St
Each
dust sample consists of probably millions of dust particles, and the dust particles represent a vast number of different materials. For example: Several phases of crushed concrete; gypsum; ashes; skin flakes; mineral fibers; organic fibers; pollen; blue paint flakes; white paint flakes; red paint flakes; etc etc etc.
So when you have two particles from, say, Sample 1, this of course does not mean that both are the same material. One could be a skin flake, one a blue paint chip. Clearly, those are different materials. Even when you have two particles of the same kind, say two blue paint chips, they could easily be two different blue colours: One perhaps epoxy based with mineral pigments from a steel cabinet, another oil based with natural pigments from a painting. So it would be possible to find two red chips in the same sample, or even two red-gray chips, and they could be two different materials, right?
I am saying this to alert you to the simple fact that, because two particles, or two magnetic red-gray particles, aren't the same because they come from the same dust sample, or location, nor do you know they are different materials if they come from two different locations.
So knowing the location doesn't really help in determining whether two chips are the same, or two different, materials, right?
The DSC results in Fig. 19 represent test results from red/gray chips taken from locations a-d.
The confused person is you.
No. The confused person is YOU.
The DSC results in Fig 19 represent test results from THREE locations, not four. The four curves, representing four chips, have the colors blue, red, black and green. Let me call the chips (the individual particles!) therefore "blue", "red", "black" and "green". In the top left corner of Fig. 19, find the description of the origin of these four specimens:
Chip|Identification in Fig. 19|Location|Sample
blue|MacKinley 1|Liberty St|1
red|MacKinley 2|Liberty St|1
black|Intermont|16 Hudson St|3
green|White|1 Hudson St|4
You meant to say that the four specimen wasted in the DSC for Fig 19 came from Samples 1, 2, 3 and 4 - just like chips a-d did.
But that is not true!
They came from Samples 1, 3 and 4 only!
This tells you that the two sets of four chips, a-d and blue|red|black|green, are not the same sets.
In fact, it is exceedingly likely that the sets are totally disjoint: Chip a <> blue, chip a <> red, chip b from Sample 2 definitely can't be one of the DSC chips as none from Sample 2 appears there; chip c <> black; and chip d <> green.
Really?
Again. The DSC results in Fig. 19 represent test results from red/gray chips taken from locations a-d.
As you just saw, you are simply confused and mistaken.
Those are different chips - and it doesn't matter at all which locations the DSC chips came from, as any two chips from the same location can very well be different materials.
So you can't use the DSC results in Fig 19 to argue whether or not chips a-d are or aren't the same material.
Until you learn how to write more coherently, further response is a waste of my time.
Since you now know that you can't use the DSC data to answer questions about the identity of chips a-d, and you already admitted that Harrit et al would not need to use resistivity to determine if chips a-d are the same material, I am afraid that you still haven't given a coherent and useful (useful = provides any interested scientist with objective information to replicate the study) answer to my question - please try again:
Are chips a-d the same material?
Give reasons - by what objective criteria (be specific!) did you determine that chips a-d are (or are not) all the same material?