WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

someone said richard gage? :confused: so that would probably mean it got sent to gage via mail then to henryco via mail.
No. No one said gage. Gage was never involved in any of that.
I hope you did not make that up.

it deals with wtc dust. henryco used a magnet and found them. millette used a magnet to seperate dust? it all needs to be looked at.
What a lame and dishonest question is that?!? Of course Millette used a magnet to seperate dust! He followed exactly the protocol described in the Bentham paper! That's why we can be sure that he studied the same materials that Harrit et al did! That's what replication means!

Please read Millette's report carefully before responding any further - you are not fit to participate in this thread if you haven't: http://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/64959841/9119ProgressReport022912_rev1_030112webHiRes.pdf

that was before anyone found the nanothermite.
You are making up excuses.

who knows if they both looked at there mackinlay sample in more detail if basile thinks some are paint chips. we would have to ask them.
What a lame, timid excuse is that?!? Of course Harrit et al "looked at there mackinlay sample in more detail" - or do you suppose they perhaps haven't? If they haven't, wouldn't you think their study is crap and the results dubious?!?
Of course Basile "looked at his mackinlay sample in more detail" - it's the only sample he has!

So why don't YOU ask them what they say about Basile's remark that many of the red-gray chips attracted to a magnet are paint?
Oh, I already asked him:
me said:
Would you [Niels Harrit] today AGREE or DISAGREE with the following statement: "All red-gray chips that you can pull out of WTC dust with a permanent magnet are essentially the same material" (i.e. they are ALL active thermitic material; or they are ALL the same of some non-thermitic material). Reasons?
OR
2b. Would you AGREE or DISAGREE that some of the red-gray chips that you can pull out of WTC dust with a permanent magnet may be paint? Several of your fellow researchers [see FOOTNOTE] have suggested this. (Please note that I ask specifically about red-GRAY chips, not just red-only chips).
...
[FOOTNOTE]
Here are the remarks by several researchers that seem to imply that some of the red-gray chips are paint:

Mark Basile: http://www.911freefall.com/2012/12/mark-basile-and-wtc-dust.html:
In this recent (December 2012) interview, Basile said at 27:26 minutes: "There are a lot of paint chips in the dust! You should make that perfectly clear! Just when you, if anybody in the audience, let's say, would get out there and get a World Trade Center dust sample, and they pull out red chips from this, I'm not telling anybody in the world that every red chip you're gonna pull out of there is one of these nano-thermite chips"
And a little later, at 28:28 minutes: "I think some of the chips that, you know, Jones and all looked at were definitely, you know, primer paint chips, too, so not everything in there was necessarily nanothermite chips."
Guess what who was too afraid to answer that question?

-> Niels Harrit! He didn't even acknowledge what Basile said.
Oh, I also ´presented him statements from Steven Jones, Kevin Ryan and Frank Legge who all also imply that there are different kinds of red-gray chips that you can pull from WTC dust with a magnet.

its not dishonest. its more accurate of a statement than the one you listed.
It's not a statementm, it's a question!


Please answer the question as I ask it:

Are all red-gray chips that you pull from WTC dust (e.g. Janette MacKinley's single sample) with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields two or more different materials?
 
Oystein said:
Actually, that would be you. Harrit et al observed that chips a-d were the same material, and we agree.
are u saying that a-d are the same and millettes are the same as a-d or just a-d are the same?

Can't you read? I am saying: "Harrit et al observed that chips a-d were the same material, and we agree." There is no mention in this quote of Millette.

Do you agree? Are chips a-d the same material? Give reasons - by what objective criteria (be specific!) did you determine that chips a-d are (or are not) all the same material?
 
No. No one said gage. Gage was never involved in any of that.
I hope you did not make that up.

found it. wtcdust said it.
Originally Posted by WTC Dust:
"You all might not be aware of the work of Fredrick Henry-Couannier. He tested the thermite theory using Jones' very same samples given to him by Richard Gage. When he first reported that the thermite reaction did not occur with heating, the response was something like, "Not all of the chips react." When every single chip was tested, and found not to react, Richard Gage stopped communicating with Henry-Couannier. He has a blog. It's in French, but you can do a translate to find out what he says about the chips."
 
<Snip> Fig 21.

Yes, a big signal for iron (Fe), but also significant amounts of oxygen (O) and carbon (C). An analysis ("re-engineering") of this graph shows that it's quite possible that most of the volume of this chip is simply carbon (soot!), while most of the iron is still normal oxide.
Remember that this DSC residue was coated with carbon:

Fig. (21). Spheroid found in post-DSC residue showing iron-rich sphere and the corresponding XEDS spectrum. The carbon peak must be considered indeterminate here since this sample was flashed with a thin carbon layer in order to preclude charging under the electron beam.
Careful in your analysis, it may well look like a large part of the material is soot, but because the carbon peak is ambiguous due to the addition of a carbon layer then there is nothing that can be deduced from that peak.

They say they coated the sample to prevent charging, which is a standard practice by the way, however, I'm surprised by two things:

1. No sputter coating was required when red/gray chips were analysed in the SEM, a simple conductive carbon tape was sufficient. I wonder if that was because of the mainly iron gray layer conducting. I'm going to assume they tried without coating, but had to resort to it because results without were unsatisfactory.

2. With regard to EDX, if a sample needs to be sputtered to prevent charging then carbon is the preferred material because it gives better EDX results than with gold. However, because carbon is a major part of the sample before heating I would have expected them to use gold, because at least then you'd get an idea of the carbon present in the sphere.

It's also interesting that they didn't publish any data on the EDX of other particles present post DSC. My be they did analyse them, maybe they didn't.
 
found it. wtcdust said it.
Originally Posted by WTC Dust:
"You all might not be aware of the work of Fredrick Henry-Couannier. He tested the thermite theory using Jones' very same samples given to him by Richard Gage. When he first reported that the thermite reaction did not occur with heating, the response was something like, "Not all of the chips react." When every single chip was tested, and found not to react, Richard Gage stopped communicating with Henry-Couannier. He has a blog. It's in French, but you can do a translate to find out what he says about the chips."

Henry-Couannier reported to me that Gage gave him the samples, and that Gage stopped talking to H-C after the results came back negative for thermite repeatedly.
 
found it. wtcdust said it.
Originally Posted by WTC Dust:
"You all might not be aware of the work of Fredrick Henry-Couannier. He tested the thermite theory using Jones' very same samples given to him by Richard Gage. When he first reported that the thermite reaction did not occur with heating, the response was something like, "Not all of the chips react." When every single chip was tested, and found not to react, Richard Gage stopped communicating with Henry-Couannier. He has a blog. It's in French, but you can do a translate to find out what he says about the chips."

This is not correct.
See http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4790973#post4790973
and following posts, where Henry-Couannier himself talks about the origin of his samples. Particularly:
T.A.M. said:
So you received multiple samples, from multiple sources, not from Jones?
exactly
T.A.M. said:
Were the samples from the same people who sent Jones his samples?
No
Henry-Couannier suspects that hos samples have been tampered with - OR that Harrit et al are either frauds, or victims of fraud. And anyway, Couannier found only 1 (one!) red-gray chip in all of his samples, and he did not ignite it! So hos sample is irrelevant anyway due to lack of data. A sample size of 1 is just not enough.


Perhaps it's best to just discard Henry-Couannier for the moment being, and concentrate on Harrit et al and Millette. You have some questions yet to answer:


Are all red-gray chips that you pull from WTC dust (e.g. Janette MacKinley's single sample) with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields two or more different materials?
and
Are chips a-d the same material? Give reasons - by what objective criteria (be specific!) did you determine that chips a-d are (or are not) all the same material?
 
Remember that this DSC residue was coated with carbon:

Careful in your analysis, it may well look like a large part of the material is soot, but because the carbon peak is ambiguous due to the addition of a carbon layer then there is nothing that can be deduced from that peak.
...
True, but since...
2. ...However, because carbon is a major part of the sample before heating I would have expected them to use gold, because at least then you'd get an idea of the carbon present in the sphere.
...
...I am still correct to state: "it's quite possible that most of the volume of this chip is simply carbon (soot!)"
When you heat an organic polymer, you are almost guaranteed to end with some carbon-rich char. Harrit et al haven't ruled it out, and so what I explained to kid meatball remains true: It's possible that this particular "ball" got it's shape not from re-solidifying iron but from cooling char and soot. Harrit et al are WRONG if they claim that "only" thermite would explain these spheroids.
 
Henry-Couannier reported to me that Gage gave him the samples, and that Gage stopped talking to H-C after the results came back negative for thermite repeatedly.

Seems like you misremember, or that perhaps H-C has changed his story since 2009. Wouldn't be the first truther to change his facts.
See my previous reply to Senemut. Also, H-C himself, back in June 2009:
But my samples are not from Jones as far as i have understood. Each were sent independently (a different person) from the others. The common denominator is a tract in NY asking people if they have dust to send it for a scientific investigation related to health issues...
Elsewhere in that discussion, he explains how he stopped communicating with Jones and the others because they would not release red-gray chips to H-C from their samples.
 
Seems like you misremember, or that perhaps H-C has changed his story since 2009. Wouldn't be the first truther to change his facts.
See my previous reply to Senemut. Also, H-C himself, back in June 2009:

Elsewhere in that discussion, he explains how he stopped communicating with Jones and the others because they would not release red-gray chips to H-C from their samples.

I am not clairvoyant. I assume that H-C reported the truth to me as best he understood it. From his point of view, as I understand it, is that Gage stopped talking to him when the thermite results came up negative. The most important consequence of this is that Gage would no longer provide samples to H-C and that he didn't have access to any more samples. He had already removed and tested almost all of the chips with a magnet.

H-C and I had our differences. I did not do what he told me to do. He wanted me to give him some of my WTC dust samples, and I did not do this. I didn't give him any samples for two main reasons. First, he was interested in disproving thermite when thermite had already been disproved many times over from many directions. I'm not wasting my samples trying to do something that a) has already been done and b) merely disproving the work of someone else.

I'm interested in the truth, and since thermite has been disproved, we can just crinkle it up into a ball and throw it in the garbage can and move on. Providing my samples to Henry-Co, just so he could repeat his own work? Heck no. Thermite's already dead, I'm not wasting my sample on that.

Henry-Co and I disagreed fundamentally about how to treat the samples. He kept telling me that I should use a magnet to separate out the iron fragments and test those fragments for thermite, as he had done. I wanted him to focus on the dust on a more macroscopic level, but he could not. He did not believe me that some samples were almost 100% iron fragments.

He also did not react as if he understood the implication of my finding that there is more than one type of dust. His entire viewpoint was that there was one type of dust, and that the signature for the dust was fibers and iron fragments.

So, no. I didn't give any samples to Henry-Co. After having made my discovery that there are multiple types of WTC dust, what was I expected to do? Reach in a bag and give him a random sample? Pretend that I hadn't made my discovery? I could give him a sample of each type of dust, but unless he himself understood and agreed that the samples came from different types of WTC dust, it would be a waste. The data would get lost, and I'm not willing to proceed along those lines with my precious dust samples.
 
Last edited:
I am not clairvoyant. I assume that H-C reported the truth to me as best he understood it. From his point of view, as I understand it, is that Gage stopped talking to him when the thermite results came up negative. The most important consequence of this is that Gage would no longer provide samples to H-C and that he didn't have access to any more samples. He had already removed and tested almost all of the chips with a magnet.

I don't understand where and why Gage comes in here. Henryco was very clear back in June of 2009: He has four samples, and those were sent to him from four different sources. They have nothing to do with Jones's samples, and Gage isn't mentioned at all.

Since Henryco's sample either lacks red-gray chips, or he lost all the red-gray chips when he first dragged a magnet through while looking for microspheres only, months before he became aware that such chips are "of interest", there isn't anything useful we can do with henryco's samples anyway, and I suggest we just frop henryco altogether, especially since his study is not the topic of this thread. Millette is, who attempted and succeeded to study the same kinds of chips that Harrit et al did.
 
They say they coated the sample to prevent charging, which is a standard practice by the way, however, I'm surprised by two things:

1. No sputter coating was required when red/gray chips were analysed in the SEM, a simple conductive carbon tape was sufficient. I wonder if that was because of the mainly iron gray layer conducting. I'm going to assume they tried without coating, but had to resort to it because results without were unsatisfactory.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but, wouldn't that imply that the chips had a high resistivity?
 
Henry-Couannier reported to me that Gage gave him the samples, and that Gage stopped talking to H-C after the results came back negative for thermite repeatedly.
Stopped talking?!

They really do not accept a result that contradicts their expectations, huh? Why would that be... :rolleyes:
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, but, wouldn't that imply that the chips had a high resistivity?

A quick reminder:



The image in the middle is an SE image. SE images tend to be white in places where electrons accumulate - which would be areas with high resistivity.

We can see that only the red layer surfaces show this behaviour and thus an indication of high resistivity. whereas the gray areas apparently conduct electrons better.



ETA: To expand on this point: Henryco found the same:
http://www.darksideofgravity.com/marseille_gb.pdf
Page 14
Shows SE-images of his own red-gray chip, and comments: "red layer appears shiny ==> insulating" and "Gray layer appears dark ==> conductive".

And while I am at it: On page 21 he says: "Some chips already carry light gray deposits with spherical metal
particles they can expel when heated
"
So much for the notion that there are never any shiny microspheres present before heating...

And (about red-red chips), page 23: "These chips dont react even when heated up to 900°C: remain red, burn most of their carbon but other elements remain in the same proportion"
Hahaha! Now did they "burn most of their carbon", or "dont react"? For "burn carbon" surely is a reaction! :D
And exactly what we have been saying all along: Of course the red-gray chips react - but it's ONLY the organic matrix that burns, and not the particles it contains! Henryco actually confirms completely what we say!

Now Senemut (an MM?) has a choice to make: Either refer to Henryco - and accept that Henryco's resukt refute Harrit et al and confirm Oystein et al - or reject Henryco's results.
I actually have no problem with either :D
 
Last edited:
A quick reminder:

[qimg]http://i1088.photobucket.com/albums/i328/MikeAlfaromeo/ActiveThermiticMaterial/ActiveThermiticMaterial_Fig03_orig.jpg[/qimg]

The image in the middle is an SE image. SE images tend to be white in places where electrons accumulate - which would be areas with high resistivity.

We can see that only the red layer surfaces show this behaviour and thus an indication of high resistivity. whereas the gray areas apparently conduct electrons better.
So much for the low resistivity of those chips then... :rolleyes:


And (about red-red chips), page 23: "These chips dont react even when heated up to 900°C: remain red, burn most of their carbon but other elements remain in the same proportion"
Hahaha! Now did they "burn most of their carbon", or "dont react"? For "burn carbon" surely is a reaction! :D
I guess that explains that:

1) In the ATM post-DSC micrographs, the chips are still red.
2) In the NIST heating tests, the paint is still red.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom