WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

read my above post to oystein.

I previously linked to, and quoted from, an interview with Niels Harrit in the summer of 2009. In the interview, Harrit said that there are also "dead" chips that don't react when heated. Did you hear him say that? Do you remember he said that? There is no mention of these in the Bentham paper, right? But do you accept that there were still chips that did not produce microspheres when heated? Or do you call Niels Harrit a liar?
 
"the data shown if fig 19 demonstrate that the red gray chips from different wtc samples all ignited in the rage of 415-435C."


mm knows that millette needs to replicate to produce or not produce iron and silicon rich microspheres. we agree on that wholeheartedly I believe.

Problem Senenmut.

Bentham paper page 9 said:
For clarification, the dust samples collected and sent to the authors by Ms. Janette MacKinlay will be sample 1; the
sample collected by Mr. Frank Delassio, or the Delassio/Breidenbach sample, will be sample 2; the sample collected by Mr. Jody Intermont will be sample 3; and the sample collected by Mr. Stephen White will be sample 4.

Fig (19) shows data for MacKinlay 1, MacKinlay 2, Intermont, and White.

What happened to the Delassio/Breidenbach sample? According to you:

how many chips did NOT produce iron and silicon rich microspheres from the dsc experiment?

did millette follow the scientific method and replicate experiments to produce iron and silicon rich microspheres so we can say they are the same material?

So did Harrit and his group follow "scientific method" when they DIDN'T perform a DSC test on the Delassio/Breidenbach chips/sample? How did they know that sample 2 (Delassio/Breidenbach) was the "same/correct" material in order to use chips out of it in Fig (2)?
 
Miragememories said:
"The DSC results in Fig. 19 represent test results from red/gray chips taken from locations a-d."

I stand corrected.

Only the results from 4 chips sampled from 3 of the 4 locations were shown in this DSC output.

MM
 
Problem Senenmut.



Fig (19) shows data for MacKinlay 1, MacKinlay 2, Intermont, and White.

What happened to the Delassio/Breidenbach sample? According to you:



So did Harrit and his group follow "scientific method" when they DIDN'T perform a DSC test on the Delassio/Breidenbach chips/sample? How did they know that sample 2 (Delassio/Breidenbach) was the "same/correct" material in order to use chips out of it in Fig (2)?

why don't u ask the authors. I cant speculate why they did that.
 
I previously linked to, and quoted from, an interview with Niels Harrit in the summer of 2009. In the interview, Harrit said that there are also "dead" chips that don't react when heated. Did you hear him say that? Do you remember he said that? There is no mention of these in the Bentham paper, right? But do you accept that there were still chips that did not produce microspheres when heated? Or do you call Niels Harrit a liar?

I guess u need to email him and ask what samples did he analyze. did they come from the original samples that the bentham paper used? did those samples go through the mail? are they the partially reacted thermitic chips? many unanswered questions. maybe they are like millette's chips but.....oh we don't know now do we since he didn't replicate the experiments to produce or not produce iron and silicon microspheres.
 
why don't u ask the authors. I cant speculate why they did that.

Really?

That's all you've got? Let me refresh your memory and how important you thought the DSC test was to making sure that Millette had the same types of chips that Harrit/Jones had.

you gullibly believe millette's chips are the same kind of material studied by jones and crew without him replicating replicating replicating!!

Remember?

Not that you've been shown that Harrit/Jones didn't even follow their own "scientific method" for making sure they had the right chips, you want to clam up and play the "ask them, I don't know" card?

:rolleyes:
 
Problem Senenmut.



Fig (19) shows data for MacKinlay 1, MacKinlay 2, Intermont, and White.

What happened to the Delassio/Breidenbach sample? According to you:



So did Harrit and his group follow "scientific method" when they DIDN'T perform a DSC test on the Delassio/Breidenbach chips/sample? How did they know that sample 2 (Delassio/Breidenbach) was the "same/correct" material in order to use chips out of it in Fig (2)?

you will have to ask them but if they did not do a dsc on the d/b sample, they sure should of.
 
you will have to ask them but if they did not do a dsc on the d/b sample, they sure should of.

They didn't test the D/B sample. It's right there in the paper in black and white.

So much for your "scientific method" garbage eh?
 
This is not a statement. That symbol at the end should give you a clue that this is a question. Do you understand the difference between questions and statements, or do you need to go back to primary school?
the statement I made that is in the form of a question. is that better?

It is not the question I asked. Why are you so afraid of my question?
yours just needs to be tweeked. it does not take into account manipulation and substitution.



Please answer the question that I asked:

Are all red-gray chips that you pull from WTC dust with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields two or more different materials?

it might depend on the sample.:eek:
 
So Senenmut.

Are you not going to accept Harrit's paper like you didn't accept Millette's because THEY didn't follow your beloved "scientific method either? Are you going to chastise their paper, tests, and supposed findings like you did Millette's?
 
They didn't test the D/B sample. It's right there in the paper in black and white.

So much for your "scientific method" garbage eh?

some things they leave in, some things they leave out. we would have to ask the authors.
 
So Senenmut.

Are you not going to accept Harrit's paper like you didn't accept Millette's because THEY didn't follow your beloved "scientific method either? Are you going to chastise their paper, tests, and supposed findings like you did Millette's?

if they didn't run a dsc on the d/b sample, then the paper would have been a lot cooler if they did.:D
 
it might depend on the sample.:eek:

So how does one know if they have the "right sample"? What tests listed in Harrit's paper should be performed on one sample to make sure it's thermite/thermate/super-thermite and not paint or some other substance?

Their paper is a joke as you have just been shown.
 
So how does one know if they have the "right sample"? What tests listed in Harrit's paper should be performed on one sample to make sure it's thermite/thermate/super-thermite and not paint or some other substance?

Their paper is a joke as you have just been shown.

replication of experiments. millette knows what he needs to do. we know what he needs to do.
 
replication of experiments. millette knows what he needs to do. we know what he needs to do.
Millette does not need to do more. Jones and Harrit proved they had no thermite samples, the energy of all four samples did not match thermite. The DSC did not match thermite. Jones and Harrit proved no thermite, simple reading skills, coupled with fall for the fraud, the lie of thermite.

When can some thermite believers explain the electrical resistivity test? Please explain in excruciating detail to this electrical engineer what it means. Are thermite believers going to make resistors with Jones' fantasy thermite?

Case closed; evidence shows no damage to any WTC steel by thermite on 911. oops

No Pulitzer, but 911 truth thermite believers will have eternal failure. Luck you have not been fooled by the lies of thermite, lies dumber than dirt (because there was no damage to WTC steel by thermite), it would hurt your credibility.
 
I stand corrected.
I never thought I'd live to see the day! :eek: ;)

Only the results from 4 chips sampled from 3 of the 4 locations were shown in this DSC output.

MM
So let's go back to the question:

Are chips a-d the same material?
Give reasons - by what objective criteria (be specific!) did you determine that chips a-d are (or are not) all the same material?


Remember that you already conceded that
  • Chips a-d were not the same set of chips that were tested in the DSC for Fig. 19
  • Resistivity is NOT an objective criterion required to identify the "correct" chips
Also:
  • we have ZERO DSC or other heating data on chips a-d, and don't know from experiment if they would produce microsphere
  • we have ZERO resistivity results on chips a-d, and don't know from experiment if they have a low specific resistivity, as we don't know if they were tested at all
Having these FACTS and admissions in mind, and thus KNOWING that neither DSC test nor production of microspheres nor resistivity can be applied as objective criteria to chips a-d to decide whether or not they are the same material, please answer, VERY clearly now:

Are chips a-d the same material?
I must insist that you MUST start your answer very clearly with one of the following three options, that enumerate completely the possibilities, so there is zero wiggle room for you:
  1. Yes.
  2. No.
  3. I, MM, can't know.
Notice all three possible answers ar concluded by a full stop. Make sure you answer like this.

When you have given that answer, please do not forget to also answer this, very specificly and without wiggling:

Give reasons - by what objective criteria (be specific!) did you determine that chips a-d are (or are not) all the same material?
(or - if your first answer was "I, MM, can't know.": Explain why you can't know!)

Thank you.
 
I guess u need to email him and ask what samples did he analyze. did they come from the original samples that the bentham paper used? did those samples go through the mail? are they the partially reacted thermitic chips? many unanswered questions. maybe they are like millette's chips but.....oh we don't know now do we since he didn't replicate the experiments to produce or not produce iron and silicon microspheres.

Maybe maybe maybe.
We don't know, do we?
It's not in the paper, right?
Harrit says there were dead chips - and doesn't say so in the paper, right?
Would you agree that the paper is missing an important bit of information?

How can Millette replicate the paper, if it contains no mention of the fact that there are dead chips, and no objective criteria to identify the live ones? Remember that there HAVE to be such criteria OTHER than actually heating them, as Harrit et al MUST assume that they identified chips a-d correctly as "active", even though they did NOT heat them!
 
Are all red-gray chips that you pull from WTC dust with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields two or more different materials?
it might depend on the sample.:eek:

So you say there are SOME samples where all red-gray chips in those samples are all the same material, AND there or other samples where chips are DIFFERENT materials?

Then you are saying that "there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields two or more different materials".
Thanks for finally answering the question.

The question is then: How do you decide whether a given sample contains different kinds of red-gray chips, or all the same?
How, specifically, did Harrit et al decide whether or not all red-gray chips in the MacKinlay sample are the same material?
Are they all the same material in the MacKinlay sample?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom