WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

That's wrong, too. There was only on chip that showed a low resistivity, while no chip showed a high resistivity.
Actually they don't say that no chip showed a high resistivity. According to Harrit, they chose a random sample of chips for resistivity testing. However they only reported on one. We know nothing about the resistivity of the rest that were tested.
 
Is therm*te the only substance that would produce iron microspheres when heated to 430C?

Your question is rather strange. In fact, no thermite produces iron microspheres when heated to 430C, since it does not ignite at this temperature. The same is valid also for "nanothermites", although perhaps some extremely fine "nano-concoctions" may ignite even at such low temperature. E.g., Tillotson's superthermite referred in Bentham paper ignited above 500 degrees C. Ordinary thermites ignite at even much higher temperatures.

And again, MM wrote "The real issue is what is the substance that permeates all the 9/11 WTC dust and creates molten iron when ignited at ~430C?", which is indeed wrong. In Bentham paper, chips were heated not to 430 degrees C, but to 700 degrees. Sadly, MM is not able to understand this very importance difference, but this is simply his personal problem:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Btw, below my notice about Millette's study in Wikipedia talk about nano-thermite entry, Wildbear added this remark today:

"The James Millette study seems to have pretty well laid the nanothermite hypothesis to rest among those researching 9/11. I haven't seen much talk about it in a long time, although there are still a very small number of stragglers reluctant to let go and accept the Millette findings. Which is okay, in science you can never conduct too much examination of something; although the chances of proving Millette wrong and the chips to be nanothermite appear to be very low at this time."
 
Last edited:
Is therm*te the only substance that would produce iron microspheres when heated to 430C?

Ivan already pointed out that the samples weren't heated to merely 430 °C but to 700 °C (slowly from room temperature), and so you don't know at which temperature the various residues were formed that you find in the ash.

I would like to alert you that none of the microspheres that Harrit et al point to consisted merely of "iron". All also contain other elements such as carbon, oxygen, silicon. The exact nature of the chemical substances in those spheres is unknown. For example, take a look at Figure 21, where Harrit et al present such an "iron-rich spheroid".



I want to point out that the ball in the middle is about 5000 nanometers across. in the top left part of the image, you see a lot of the same rhombic white grains and light gray hexagonal platelets that were already visible in the (unheated) chips a-d, so it appears that they were not changed at all by heating the material to 700 °C. The small white grains are iron oxide - on this all sides agree. It's what makes the red layer red.

So what is this thing in the middle that looks like a snowball?

Look at its elemental composition:



Yes, a big signal for iron (Fe), but also significant amounts of oxygen (O) and carbon (C). An analysis ("re-engineering") of this graph shows that it's quite possible that most of the volume of this chip is simply carbon (soot!), while most of the iron is still normal oxide.



Here is what I think happened:

Remember that the red layer consists of two kinds of particles (iron oxide grains and Al+Si-rich platelets) embedded in an organic matrix. This organic matrix makes up most of the volume of the red layer, and it consists of organic polymers.

When you heat polymers, at some point they start to decompose, that means very large molecules break up into smaller and smaller molecules. This happens, for example, for epoxy, which we know to be the organic matrix in one of the two known WTC primer paints, very near 430 °C! Some of the smaller molecules can and do burn right after beeing freed from the matrix, i.e. they snatch some oxygen from their environment and burn. If the decomopsition of the polymer releases hydrogen (H2) or carbon monoxide (CO), then these would even be able to reduce iron oxide. In fact, that's how iron is typically produced: By reducing iron oxide with CO.

The decomposition and burning of organic polymers is rarely complete - you are usually left with some solid residue called "char". This consists in part of pure carbon, in part of carbon-rich stuff like tar. These chars are sort of liquid while hot, and solidify with a tendency to form spheres just like melted metal would.

And so I think that this snowball in Figure 21 is just a droplet of char which has caught and concentrated iron oxide grains. That iron oxide may have been reduced (been depleted of some of its oxygen) to some degree by the gases released when the organic polymer decomposed.


These kinds of carbon+mineral rich spheroids are indeed very common in all sorts of ashes. You burn wood or household garbage - you will find spheres rich in C, Fe, O, Al and Si. Always.

A standard reference for forensic scientists who study dust is the "McCrone Particle Atlas", published in the early 1970s. It shows several examples of iron-rich microspheres from various combustion processes and even from street dust.

So the RJ Lee report, which truthers like to reference, is entirely correct when it states that iron microspheres are an expected byproduct of office fires.

And Harrit et al are absolutely wrong when they claim such spheres prove temperatures of 1500 °C or more, and even more wrong when they insinuate that only thermite could create such spheres.
 
Last edited:
Oystein: Your hypothesis that iron-richer microspheres may be "balls" of polymer soot with iron oxide "nanograins" is interesting:cool: But it does not explain (I think) how the gray layers can play a role/form microspheres.

After very short googling, it seems to me that the soot is frequently spherical at microscales.

Here is e.g. a paper dealing with a soot from church candles and incense.

And there is e.g. this funny graph how the concentration of soot varies during Easter:;)

picture.php


"Church soot" itself is spherical, but microspheres are smaller than in Bentham paper (left image):

picture.php


It seems to be very marginal matter, but such a soot can be cancerogenic and I vaguely remember that it was a kind of "scandal" some years ago: instead to be healed in the Christian churches, believers/visitors are endangered there by such a soot and other toxic stuffs. In fact, it is much more important matter that e.g. nonsensical hypothesis of controlled demolition of WTC:cool:
 
Last edited:
Oystein: Your hypothesis that iron-richer microspheres may be "balls" of polymer soot with iron oxide "nanograins" is interesting:cool: But it does not explain (I think) how the gray layers can play a role/form microspheres.
Oh, I didn't say it does explain that. I merely replied to kid meatball who asked whether therm*te would be "the only substance that would produce iron microspheres when heated to 430C". Since he obviously talks about such spheres described by Harrit et al, I give him one example of such a microsphere from Harrit et al, as an example, to explain how mundane materials such epoxy-based paint might form such spheres - and what some of those spheres might actually be. And that answers the question whether therm*te is the only substance that does that: No, it isn't. I found at least one other example.

No doubt there are more. But one example to the contrary invalidates a premise that starts with "the only". Harrit et al cannot use the argument "iron-rich microspheres proof therm*te", as their premise is invalid. Iron-rich microspheres may be consistent with therm*te, but to prove therm*te, they need to bring other evidence. They don't. Thermite is Fe2O3+Al, so they'd need to prove both Fe2O3 (that they did, but no quantity) and Al (that they did not; there is only one data point, in Fig 17, that indicates the presence of any elemental Al at all, but Fig 14 shows that the overall amount of Al is far from sufficient to make a significant thermite reaction feasible. For no other chip is there any evidence for elemental Al at all). The thermite reaction produces Fe+Al2O3. They only have very indirect evidence of some elemental Fe, haven't ruled out the presence of elemental Fe before the reaction, and have not shown the presence of Al2O3 at all.
Hence, there is no evidence for the presence of thermite before, or thermite products after any ignition test.
Hence, Harrit et al have failed.

After very short googling, it seems to me that the soot is frequently spherical at microscales.

Here is e.g. a paper dealing with a soot from church candles and incense.

And there is e.g. this funny graph how the concentration of soot varies during Easter:;)

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=1078&pictureid=7886[/qimg]

"Church soot" itself is spherical, but microspheres are smaller than in Bentham paper (left image):

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=1078&pictureid=7885[/qimg]
...

True, but of course the size difference may be due to any number of factors. Chief among them, in my opinion: That paper looked at soot from church walls - so that soot was originally airborne solid residue from some organic combustion, whereas the char and soot that Harrit et al, or Basile, looked at was solid residue that was left in place. I am not surprised at all that the airborne particles tend to be smaller than those that did not get airborne.
 
Last edited:
Oystein: agreed:cool:

But let me remind one thing:
Several times we have repeated here that nobody (including "Bentham authors") knows what kind(s) of chips was heated in DSC device. This is basically right, but on the other hand, chip shown on Fig. 21 contains (very probably) the same pigments as "infamous" chips (a) to (d): small rhomboids of iron oxide and hexagonal platelets of kaolinite. Hence, at least this chip with this spheroid should be of the "kind (a) to (b)"; and consequently, this chip should be a chip of Laclede red primer (or very similar paint).

(And since all heated chips shown in Fig. 20 look very similar, all of them could be Laclede paint as well, but I'm going too far in this respect...)
 
Last edited:
Oystein: agreed:cool:

But let me remind one thing:
Several times we have repeated here that nobody (including "Bentham authors") knows what kind(s) of chips was heated in DSC device. This is basically right, but on the other hand, chip shown on Fig. 21 contains (very probably) the same pigments as "infamous" chips (a) to (d): small rhomboids of iron oxide and hexagonal platelets of kaolinite. Hence, at least this chip with this spheroid should be of the "kind (a) to (b)"; and consequently, this chip should be a chip of Laclede red primer (or very similar paint).
Yes, most likely.

Unfortunately, we have no idea whether this was one of the four specimens whose DSC traces are shown in Figure 21. I'd predict that it would then be the blue or the red trace, as those two have some characteristics of epoxy.

(And since all heated chips shown in Fig. 20 look very similar, all of them could be Laclede paint as well, but I'm going too far in this respect...)
Yes, too far :p

We know from the NIST tests how Tnemec behaves when heated while still attacjed to steel members: It spalls off, but retains cohesion and remains as a red layer. We do not know how LaClede paint behaves when heated, as neither NIST tested any, nor did Harrit et al show us any before/after data of any chip with EDS similar to Fig 7 or SEM images showing hematite and kaolin.
(Of course we have your "LaClede imitation". I don't recall if you got a still-red coherent layer after burning? Or did it fall to ashes?)
 
Ivan, I think one sign for lurkers and other readers that shows that you and I are engaged in real scientific discourse, while Miragememories and Senemut are engaged in aimless trolling, is the fact that we disagree so often on detail, alert each other to weaknesses in our arguments, dig out more facts, and usually eventually reach a consensus - because both of us realize our weaknesses when the other makes a convincing counterargument, and we correct or retract opinions, if that's where the evidence leads us.

In contrast, truthers like MM and SM hardly ever criticize one another, as if only agreement to orthodoxy was allowed.

Progress in scientific discourse comes about by constuctive disagreement.
 
(Of course we have your "LaClede imitation". I don't recall if you got a still-red coherent layer after burning? Or did it fall to ashes?)

I remember that burned layers were still red, but slightly darker than before heating up to 700 degrees. They were "coherent" in sense that they keeped their original shape, but after some crushing with a spatula, they where quite easily destroyed to the coarse powder which was microscoped later.
 
I remember that burned layers were still red, but slightly darker than before heating up to 700 degrees. They were "coherent" in sense that they keeped their original shape, but after some crushing with a spatula, they where quite easily destroyed to the coarse powder which was microscoped later.

Consistent with Fig 20?
 
Ivan Kminek said:
"And again, MM wrote; "The real issue is what is the substance that permeates all the 9/11 WTC dust and creates molten iron when ignited at ~430C?", which is indeed wrong.

In Bentham paper, chips were heated not to 430 degrees C, but to 700 degrees.

Sadly, MM is not able to understand this very importance difference, but this is simply his personal problem:rolleyes:
"

The true story here is that Ivan Kminek, Oystein, Sunstealer etc., simply refuse to acknowledge what the scientists have observed.

"You basically think that microspheres were formed already at the external temperatures around 430 degrees C (because of thermitic reaction). (Note: external temperature means temp. of sample holder.)

We basically think that microspheres were created at considerably higher external temperatures, probably close to final 700 degrees. (We also claim that slow exothermic effects observed at ca 430 degrees were caused by burning of the polymer binder.)

And, since nobody knows at which external temperatures microspheres were formed, the heating up to 700 degrees in any replication is simply a must:cool: Why you refuse to accept this plain fact? What personal problem do you have with the heating up to 700 degrees?
"

Yes Dr. Harrit et al extended their DSC test run to 700C.

But what Ivan Kminek and many others are ignoring is that the scientists monitoring the test observed the exothermic reaction that resulted in the iron-rich results at ~430C.

In denial of what was found by the scientists, Ivan speculates that because the scientists let the DSC test run its full course up to 700C, that some other reaction(s) occurred between ~430C and 700C.

But that is not what Dr. Harrit et al observed.

Dr. Harrit et al said:
"The DSC tests were conducted with a linear heating rate of 10 ̊C per minute up to a temperature of 700 ̊C. ... The plots were generated by acquiring data points at a rate of 20 points per ̊C or 200 points per minute...The plots were set to display positive heat flow out of the sample such that exothermic behavior of the sample would yield a peak and endothermic behavior a trough."

Dr. Harrit et al said:
"That thermitic reactions from the red/gray chips have indeed occurred in the DSC (rising temperature method of ignition) is confirmed by the combined observation of:

1) highly energetic reactions occurring at approximately 430 ̊C"

Dr. Harrit et al said:
"However, the evidence obtained in the DSC analyses is more compelling that a thermitic reaction actually occurs as in that case ignition is observed when the red material is heated to no more than 430 ̊C."

Dr. Harrit et al said:
"As measured using DSC, the material ignites and reacts vigorously at a temperature of approximately 430 ̊C, with a rather narrow exotherm, matching fairly closely an independent observation on a known super-thermite sample."

Mark Basile, a chemical engineer of many years, and an independent researcher into the 9/11 WTC dust, was the original discoverer of the post ignition iron-rich residue.

He claimed to have run the test up to hundreds of times and only heated the chips to the point of ignition. As observed by the scientists monitoring the DSC testing, that temperature was consistently ~430 ̊C..

Mark Basile said:
""So what I did was I set up a little instrument where I could basically control heat these chips.

I basically made up a little apparatus [described above] which I could control heat just to the point where these chips would ignite.

We know what their ignition temperature is based on other scientists work. So I can basically in a controlled manner bring these chips up to the ignition temperature, watch them ignite, with my microscope and camera, and you are about to see one, and then go in and analyze what has happened after the chemical reaction.

...I've cut into these chips [pre-ignition test], dozens, if not hundreds of times and I have never found an iron microsphere inside.

I have never found a film of iron inside.

It is not there until the chip reacts. When the chip reacts, it produces molten iron. There is no free iron. There is iron oxide before you ignite it but there is no free iron inside these chips."

And, even if all these scientists were somehow wrong about the ~430 ̊C ignition point, iron-rich microspheres require a melting temperature of 1538°C.

What other, unobserved, high heat producing reaction, could have occurred in the chip residue between 430 ̊C and 700 ̊C that could possibly explain this?

MM
 
I am late to the discussion so i am not sure if anybody has mentioned this; but if the resistivity test was crucial and necessary in isolating the thermitic chips then why does Mark Basile not mention this in his new proposal for analytic work?

He only states two methods in identifying the thermitic chips which are:

Red/gray chip separation using optical microscopy and magnetic attraction to assist in isolation of particles of interest.

- Optical images of collected particulates as collected at appropriate magnifications to record condition as collected.

(Cant post the link to Basile's website yet)

MM do you feel Mark Basile is wrong in his assessment on how to identify the right chips?
 
The true story here is that Ivan Kminek, Oystein, Sunstealer etc., simply refuse to acknowledge what the scientists have observed.
...

Actually, that would be you. Harrit et al observed that chips a-d were the same material, and we agree.

You don't. Perhaps afraid to admit something that's true.


So please, what's your opinion:

Are chips a-d the same material, yes or no?
Please list ALL the objective criteria that use to make that determination.

Do you have any resistivity data on chip a, b, c, or d?
 
I am late to the discussion so i am not sure if anybody has mentioned this; but if the resistivity test was crucial and necessary in isolating the thermitic chips then why does Mark Basile not mention this in his new proposal for analytic work?

He only states two methods in identifying the thermitic chips which are:

Red/gray chip separation using optical microscopy and magnetic attraction to assist in isolation of particles of interest.

- Optical images of collected particulates as collected at appropriate magnifications to record condition as collected.

(Cant post the link to Basile's website yet)

MM do you feel Mark Basile is wrong in his assessment on how to identify the right chips?

You are of course correct: Mark Basile, who has already colaborated with Jones and Harrit and has studied his own batch of chips from the very same dust sample proposes to follow exactly the separation protocol laid out in the Bentham paper, which does not include any resistivity test:
http://aneta.org/markbasile_org/proposal/index.htm

That's the same Nark Basile who has stated unequivocally that many of the red-gray chips that you pull from WTC dust with a magnet are paint, and that Jones, too, studied paint chips.

The true story here is that Miragememories simply refuses to acknowledge what the scientists have observed.
 
Your question is rather strange.

Thanks for the replies. The reason I ask such a question is more to moot the idea that the microspheres are even important, or as your replies indicate, relevant to the idea that the chips are thermite.

I've learned far too much about what happens when one heats paint by reading this thread.

Um, thanks? :p
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom